Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleted line(s) 1,7 (click to see context) :
[floatboxright:
Series: Series/StargateSG1\\
Episode: Season 1, Episode 3\\
Title: "Emancipation"\\
Previous: "The Enemy Within"\\
Next: "The Broca Divide"\\
Recapper: @/ShadowPenguin]
Series: Series/StargateSG1\\
Episode: Season 1, Episode 3\\
Title: "Emancipation"\\
Previous: "The Enemy Within"\\
Next: "The Broca Divide"\\
Recapper: @/ShadowPenguin]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 31 (click to see context) from:
* IdiotBall: A lot of problems could have been averted if Carter, upon Daniel suggesting that they stay, said "uh, screw you. You're not the one who was just threatened with the death penalty for the crime of talking. How about you three guys stay and I go home?" Its not even as if there was some pressing need for her to stay as her two main skills (pilot and scientist) were of little use in a society that has neither aircraft nor modern science. Of course, that doesn't excuse O'Neill either for not putting the safety of Carter ahead of the mission.
to:
* IdiotBall: A lot of problems could have been averted if Carter, upon Daniel suggesting that they stay, said "uh, said, "Uh, screw you. You're not the one who was just threatened with the death penalty for the crime of talking. How about you three guys stay and I go home?" Its It's not even as if there was some pressing need for her to stay stay, as her two main skills (pilot and scientist) were of little use in dealing with a society that has neither aircraft nor modern science. Of course, that doesn't excuse O'Neill either for not putting the safety of Carter ahead of the mission.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* IdiotBall: A lot of problems could have been averted if Carter, upon Daniel suggesting that they stay, said "uh, screw you. You're not the one who was just threatened with the death penalty for the crime of talking. How about you three guys stay and I go home?" Its not even as if there was some pressing need for her to stay as her two main skills (pilot and scientist) were of little use in a society that has neither aircraft nor modern science. Of course, that doesn't excuse O'Neill either for not putting the safety of Carter ahead of the mission.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 21 (click to see context) from:
* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The actual Mongols and other Eurasian steppe tribes didn't practice gender-segregation to anywhere near the degree portrayed in this episode, because it wasn't practical. And while steppe women didn't accompany the men on raids, they were in fact trained to ride and fight, because it was their job to guard the camps when the men were off on a tear. The episode implies that the Shavadai practice is probably a legacy of Goa'uld raids for hosts.
to:
* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The actual Mongols and other Eurasian steppe tribes didn't practice gender-segregation to anywhere near the degree portrayed in this episode, because it wasn't practical. And while steppe women didn't accompany the men on raids, they were in fact trained to ride and fight, because it was their job to guard the camps when the men were off on a tear. The episode implies that the Shavadai practice is probably a legacy of Goa'uld raids for hosts.hosts - which is probably just a convenient excuse given the fact that the Goa'uld could just remove the masks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 43 (click to see context) from:
* PragmaticHero: During the duel it looks for a brief moment like Carter is losing. Jack's hand is clearly shown inching towards the fire selector on his [=MP5=], indicating he's planning to shoot their way out if she actually loses.
to:
* PragmaticHero: During the duel it looks for a brief moment like Carter is losing. Jack's hand is clearly shown inching towards the fire selector on his [=MP5=], indicating he's planning to shoot their way out if she actually loses.loses, local traditions be damned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 34 (click to see context) from:
* NeverBringAKnifeToAFistfight: Carter and O'Neill clearly expect the fight with Turghan to be purely hand-to-hand, and react appropriately when he unsheathes a lethal-looking scythe. Carter takes out her own (comparatively tiny) field knife in response.
to:
* NeverBringAKnifeToAFistfight: Carter and O'Neill clearly expect the fight with Turghan to be purely hand-to-hand, and react appropriately when he unsheathes a lethal-looking scythe.tulwar-like sword. Carter takes out her own (comparatively tiny) field knife in response.
Added DiffLines:
* PragmaticHero: During the duel it looks for a brief moment like Carter is losing. Jack's hand is clearly shown inching towards the fire selector on his [=MP5=], indicating he's planning to shoot their way out if she actually loses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The actual Mongols and other Eurasian steppe tribes didn't practice gender-segregation to anywhere near the degree portrayed in this episode, because it wasn't practical. And while steppe women didn't accompany the men on raids, they were in fact trained to ride and fight, because it was their job to guard the camps when the men were off on a tear. The episode implies that the Shavadai practice is probably a legacy of Goa'uld raids for hosts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* RightMakesMight: Moughal's excuse for challenging Turghan. In their ancient tradition, the spirits strengthen the hand of the just.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It's YMMV now
Changed line(s) 34 (click to see context) from:
* NoodleIncident: According to Jack, on a previous off-world mission Sam drank something that made her take off her ... and then Sam nervously cuts him off before he can embarrass her in front of Moughal. This brief exchange has proven to be a FanFicMagnet, especially for Jack/Sam shippers.
to:
* NoodleIncident: According to Jack, on a previous off-world mission Sam drank something that made her take off her ... and then Sam nervously cuts him off before he can embarrass her in front of Moughal. This brief exchange has proven to be a FanFicMagnet, especially for Jack/Sam shippers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* WhatIsThisThingYouCallLove: The Shavadai 'do' know what love is. However, the idea that a man can have feelings for a woman beyond being property is treated as though they were mad. Moughal is believed to have this affliction because he is in love with his wife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 15,16 (click to see context) from:
SG-1 goes to free Carter and find that the boy's father is considering changing the customs since he loves his wife. They find Carter and to avoid war, they make a trade to get her back. Jack trades the chieftain a gun and they run off before he finds out it is useless once the bullets run out. However, he laters finds that his daughter has escaped to meet with the boy. They decide a duel will settle the dispute and avoid war, so Carter challenges the chieftain. She kicks his butt, no war occurs, the women are freed, and everything is changed.
to:
SG-1 goes to free Carter and find that the boy's father is considering changing the customs since he loves his wife. They find Carter and to avoid war, they make a trade to get her back. Jack trades the chieftain a gun and they run off before he finds out it is useless once the bullets run out. However, he laters the chieftain later finds that his daughter has escaped to meet with the boy. boy, and she is recaptured and sentenced to be stoned to death. This, of course, SG-1 and their new friends cannot let happen. They decide a duel will settle the dispute and avoid war, so Carter challenges the chieftain. She kicks his butt, no war occurs, the women are freed, and everything is changed.
Changed line(s) 34 (click to see context) from:
* NoodleIncident: According to Jack, on a previous offworld mission Sam drank something that made her take off her ... and then Sam nervously cuts him off before he can embarrass her in front of Moughal. This brief exchange has proven to be a FanFicMagnet, especially for Jack/Sam shippers.
to:
* NoodleIncident: According to Jack, on a previous offworld off-world mission Sam drank something that made her take off her ... and then Sam nervously cuts him off before he can embarrass her in front of Moughal. This brief exchange has proven to be a FanFicMagnet, especially for Jack/Sam shippers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 45,47 (click to see context) from:
* StarCrossedLovers: Abu and Nya
* ThisIsMyBoomstick: Jack twice uses his pistol to impress the locals
* TrueBlueFemininity: The traditional Mongol dress which Carter is forced to wear
* ThisIsMyBoomstick: Jack twice uses his pistol to impress the locals
* TrueBlueFemininity: The traditional Mongol dress which Carter is forced to wear
to:
* StarCrossedLovers: Abu and Nya
Nya.
* ThisIsMyBoomstick: Jack twice uses his pistol to impress thelocals
locals.
* TrueBlueFemininity: The traditional Mongol dress which Carter is forced towearwear.
* ThisIsMyBoomstick: Jack twice uses his pistol to impress the
* TrueBlueFemininity: The traditional Mongol dress which Carter is forced to
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 34 (click to see context) from:
* NoodleIncident: According to Jack, on a previous offworld mission Sam drank something that made her take off her ... and then Sam nervously cuts him off before he can embarrass her in front of Moughal. This brief exchange has proved to be a FanFicMagnet, especially for Jack/Sam shippers.
to:
* NoodleIncident: According to Jack, on a previous offworld mission Sam drank something that made her take off her ... and then Sam nervously cuts him off before he can embarrass her in front of Moughal. This brief exchange has proved proven to be a FanFicMagnet, especially for Jack/Sam shippers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* InternalReformist: Moughal tries to be as non-sexist as he can within the bounds of his culture
Deleted line(s) 43 (click to see context) :
* RuleAbidingRebel: Moughal tries to be as non-sexist as he can within the bounds of his culture
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 17 (click to see context) from:
The writer of this episode was Katharyn Powers, who previously co-wrote the ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'' episode "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS1E3CodeOfHonor Code of Honor]]", which essentially had ''[[AuthorAppeal exactly the same plot]]''. Just replace Mongols with Africans and Sam Carter with the also blonde, short-haired Tasha Yar. Both were even the third episode of their respective shows' first season. However, the ''Stargate'' version [[WriterOnBoard manages to be even preachier]].
to:
The writer of this episode was Katharyn Powers, who previously co-wrote the ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'' episode "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS1E3CodeOfHonor Code of Honor]]", which essentially had ''[[AuthorAppeal exactly the same plot]]''. Just replace Mongols with Africans and Sam Carter with the also blonde, short-haired Tasha Yar. Both were even the third episode of their respective shows' first season. However, the ''Stargate'' version [[WriterOnBoard manages to be even preachier]].preachier]] (but also, it must be said, less racist).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* RuleAbidingRebel: Moughal tries to be as non-sexist as he can within the bounds of his culture
Changed line(s) 45 (click to see context) from:
* ThisIsMyBoomstick: Jack twice uses his pistol to impress the Shavadai
to:
* ThisIsMyBoomstick: Jack twice uses his pistol to impress the Shavadailocals
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* ThisIsMyBoomstick: Jack twice uses his pistol to impress the Shavadai
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* CultureJustifiesAnything: Subverted. The argument that the Shavadai's sexism should be tolerated because it's part of their culture is brought up several times, but is ultimately rejected by the end of the episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* TrueBlueFemininity: The traditional Mongol dress which Carter is forced to wear
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 32 (click to see context) from:
* NoodleIncident: According to Jack, on a previous offworld mission Sam drank something that made her take off her ... and then Sam nervously cuts him off before he can embarrass her in front of Moughal. This exchange has proved to be a FanFicMagnet, especially for Jack/Sam shippers.
to:
* NoodleIncident: According to Jack, on a previous offworld mission Sam drank something that made her take off her ... and then Sam nervously cuts him off before he can embarrass her in front of Moughal. This brief exchange has proved to be a FanFicMagnet, especially for Jack/Sam shippers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 32 (click to see context) from:
* NoodleIncident: According to Jack, on a previous offworld mission Sam drank something that made her take off her ... and then Sam nervously cuts him off before he can embarrass her in front of Moughal.
to:
* NoodleIncident: According to Jack, on a previous offworld mission Sam drank something that made her take off her ... and then Sam nervously cuts him off before he can embarrass her in front of Moughal. This exchange has proved to be a FanFicMagnet, especially for Jack/Sam shippers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 13,14 (click to see context) from:
Turns out the tribe is a Mongul type tribe with very strict rules on women. Covering their faces, acting submissive, speaking only when spoken to, and generally being the property of the men. Carter is upset, but gets talked into following the customs while they are there. She gets kidnapped in the middle of the night by the teenager, who decides she's the perfect woman to trade to a rival tribe in order to get what he wants, the hand of his love, the daughter of the chieftain. The chieftain rejects his offer and gives him gold for Carter instead.
to:
Turns out the tribe is a Mongul Mongol type tribe with very strict rules on women. Covering their faces, acting submissive, speaking only when spoken to, and generally being the property of the men. Carter is upset, but gets talked into following the customs while they are there. She gets kidnapped in the middle of the night by the teenager, who decides she's the perfect woman to trade to a rival tribe in order to get what he wants, the hand of his love, the daughter of the chieftain. The chieftain rejects his offer and gives him gold for Carter instead.
* FemaleMisogynist: Nya says her father is a good man who protects and provides for his women and children.
* FeminineWomenCanCook: "I'm a lousy cook, and I couldn't spin, weave, or dye if my life depended on it. You made yourself a bad deal."
* FeminineWomenCanCook: "I'm a lousy cook, and I couldn't spin, weave, or dye if my life depended on it. You made yourself a bad deal."
* PetTheDog: Before ordering her stoned, Turghan whispers to Nya that he personally forgives her.
* PlanetOfHats: The Shavadai's entire culture seems to be built around treating women like crap. In a slight subversion of this trope, however, it's suggested that other cultures on the planet might be different.
* PlanetOfHats: The Shavadai's entire culture seems to be built around treating women like crap. In a slight subversion of this trope, however, it's suggested that other cultures on the planet might be different.
Changed line(s) 37,38 (click to see context) from:
* SheCleansUpNicely: O'Neill and Daniel are momentarily lost for words on first sight of Carter in the traditional Mongol dress.
* WeNeedADistraction: Carter sets fire to one of the tents in Turghan's camp in order to create a distraction for Nia to escape.
* WeNeedADistraction: Carter sets fire to one of the tents in Turghan's camp in order to create a distraction for Nia to escape.
to:
* RippedFromTheHeadlines: The episode is sometimes understood as a commentary on the Taliban, who had just recently come to power in Afghanistan at the time the episode was produced. However, this may be a coincidence, considering the same writer wrote a similar episode for ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration''.
* SheCleansUpNicely: Much to her chagrin, O'Neill and Daniel are momentarily lost for words on first sight of Carter in the traditional Mongol dress.
* StarCrossedLovers: Abu and Nya
* WeNeedADistraction: Carter sets fire to one of the tents in Turghan's camp in order to create a distraction forNia Nya to escape.escape.
* WhereDaWhiteWomenAt: It's mentioned that "foreign women" are especially prized and Turghan comments approvingly on Carter's fair skin.
* SheCleansUpNicely: Much to her chagrin, O'Neill and Daniel are momentarily lost for words on first sight of Carter in the traditional Mongol dress.
* StarCrossedLovers: Abu and Nya
* WeNeedADistraction: Carter sets fire to one of the tents in Turghan's camp in order to create a distraction for
* WhereDaWhiteWomenAt: It's mentioned that "foreign women" are especially prized and Turghan comments approvingly on Carter's fair skin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 17 (click to see context) from:
The writer of this episode was Katharyn Powers, who previously co-wrote the ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'' episode "Code of Honor", which essentially had ''[[AuthorAppeal exactly the same plot]]''. Just replace Mongols with Africans and Sam Carter with the also blonde, short-haired Tasha Yar. Both were even the third episode of their respective shows' first season. However, the ''Stargate'' version [[WriterOnBoard manages to be even preachier]].
to:
The writer of this episode was Katharyn Powers, who previously co-wrote the ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'' episode "Code "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS1E3CodeOfHonor Code of Honor", Honor]]", which essentially had ''[[AuthorAppeal exactly the same plot]]''. Just replace Mongols with Africans and Sam Carter with the also blonde, short-haired Tasha Yar. Both were even the third episode of their respective shows' first season. However, the ''Stargate'' version [[WriterOnBoard manages to be even preachier]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 25 (click to see context) from:
* FantasyCultureCounterpart: This culture for the Mongols.
to:
* FantasyCultureCounterpart: FantasyCounterpartCulture: This culture for the Mongols.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* BoundAndGagged: Carter when she is kidnapped.
Added DiffLines:
* FantasyCultureCounterpart: This culture for the Mongols.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* KarmaHoudini: The teenager kidnapping Carter to give her to Turghan for the hand of his daughter is forgiven by Carter because he was acting on true love and tradition.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* BadassInDistress: Carter manages to hold her own inside Turghan's camp until the others come to her rescue, and even comes close to escaping at one point.
* DuelToTheDeath: The fight between Carter and Turghan is intended to be this, though she allows him to live once he admits defeat.
* ForcefulKiss: Turghan forces one on Carter as punishment for her disobedience.
* IWillPunishYourFriendForYourFailure: Turghan intends to beat one of the other women as punishment for Carter's escape attempt; Carter intervenes, but it isn't made clear whether she actually succeeds in stopping him.
* NeverBringAKnifeToAFistfight: Carter and O'Neill clearly expect the fight with Turghan to be purely hand-to-hand, and react appropriately when he unsheathes a lethal-looking scythe. Carter takes out her own (comparatively tiny) field knife in response.
* ForcefulKiss: Turghan forces one on Carter as punishment for her disobedience.
* IWillPunishYourFriendForYourFailure: Turghan intends to beat one of the other women as punishment for Carter's escape attempt; Carter intervenes, but it isn't made clear whether she actually succeeds in stopping him.
* NeverBringAKnifeToAFistfight: Carter and O'Neill clearly expect the fight with Turghan to be purely hand-to-hand, and react appropriately when he unsheathes a lethal-looking scythe. Carter takes out her own (comparatively tiny) field knife in response.
Changed line(s) 27 (click to see context) from:
'''Teal'c:''' What is an Oprah?
to:
'''Teal'c:''' What is an Oprah?Oprah?
* ReverseGrip: Carter wields her knife this way during the duel.
* SheCleansUpNicely: O'Neill and Daniel are momentarily lost for words on first sight of Carter in the traditional Mongol dress.
* WeNeedADistraction: Carter sets fire to one of the tents in Turghan's camp in order to create a distraction for Nia to escape.
* ReverseGrip: Carter wields her knife this way during the duel.
* SheCleansUpNicely: O'Neill and Daniel are momentarily lost for words on first sight of Carter in the traditional Mongol dress.
* WeNeedADistraction: Carter sets fire to one of the tents in Turghan's camp in order to create a distraction for Nia to escape.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 8 (click to see context) from:
to:
-> ''"Daniel, find me an anthropologist that dresses like this and I will eat this headdress."''
--> -- '''Sam''' commenting on the native clothes she gets roped into wearing
--> -- '''Sam''' commenting on the native clothes she gets roped into wearing
Changed line(s) 16 (click to see context) from:
----
to:
!!"Emancipation" provides examples of the following tropes:
* ActionGirl: Sam gets her first real opportunity to show it off when she uses her "level three, advanced" training in hand-to-hand combat to take down Turghan.
* ChekhovsGun: Literally. Jack fires his Beretta M9 into the air to startle Moughal's tribesmen. He later fires it again to impress Turghan, then trades it to him to get Sam back.
* NoodleIncident: According to Jack, on a previous offworld mission Sam drank something that made her take off her ... and then Sam nervously cuts him off before he can embarrass her in front of Moughal.
* PopCulturalOsmosisFailure: Teal'c, providing TheStinger. [[JustifiedTrope At this point he hasn't been on Earth very long.]]
--> '''Carter:''' Sir do you think this new anesthesia will be a miracle drug on Earth?\\
'''Jackson:''' Well if it is, I bet somebody else will get the credit. We can never say where it came from.\\
'''O'Neill:''' Damn... guess I'm going to have to cancel that Oprah interview.\\
'''Teal'c:''' What is an Oprah?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[floatboxright:
Series: Series/StargateSG1\\
Episode: Season 1, Episode 3\\
Title: "Emancipation"\\
Previous: "The Enemy Within"\\
Next: "The Broca Divide"\\
Recapper: @/ShadowPenguin]
SG-1 arrives on a forested world and come across a teenager being chased by dogs. They scare off the dogs and save him. Men on horseback appear, and seem offended by Carter, and prepare to kill her. The boy stops them, and his father comes riding up. Carter asks what she did and he is about to attack her for speaking without being spoken to. The boy stops him again, and they decide she lives since she helped save the boy.
Turns out the tribe is a Mongul type tribe with very strict rules on women. Covering their faces, acting submissive, speaking only when spoken to, and generally being the property of the men. Carter is upset, but gets talked into following the customs while they are there. She gets kidnapped in the middle of the night by the teenager, who decides she's the perfect woman to trade to a rival tribe in order to get what he wants, the hand of his love, the daughter of the chieftain. The chieftain rejects his offer and gives him gold for Carter instead.
SG-1 goes to free Carter and find that the boy's father is considering changing the customs since he loves his wife. They find Carter and to avoid war, they make a trade to get her back. Jack trades the chieftain a gun and they run off before he finds out it is useless once the bullets run out. However, he laters finds that his daughter has escaped to meet with the boy. They decide a duel will settle the dispute and avoid war, so Carter challenges the chieftain. She kicks his butt, no war occurs, the women are freed, and everything is changed.
The writer of this episode was Katharyn Powers, who previously co-wrote the ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'' episode "Code of Honor", which essentially had ''[[AuthorAppeal exactly the same plot]]''. Just replace Mongols with Africans and Sam Carter with the also blonde, short-haired Tasha Yar. Both were even the third episode of their respective shows' first season. However, the ''Stargate'' version [[WriterOnBoard manages to be even preachier]].
----
Series: Series/StargateSG1\\
Episode: Season 1, Episode 3\\
Title: "Emancipation"\\
Previous: "The Enemy Within"\\
Next: "The Broca Divide"\\
Recapper: @/ShadowPenguin]
SG-1 arrives on a forested world and come across a teenager being chased by dogs. They scare off the dogs and save him. Men on horseback appear, and seem offended by Carter, and prepare to kill her. The boy stops them, and his father comes riding up. Carter asks what she did and he is about to attack her for speaking without being spoken to. The boy stops him again, and they decide she lives since she helped save the boy.
Turns out the tribe is a Mongul type tribe with very strict rules on women. Covering their faces, acting submissive, speaking only when spoken to, and generally being the property of the men. Carter is upset, but gets talked into following the customs while they are there. She gets kidnapped in the middle of the night by the teenager, who decides she's the perfect woman to trade to a rival tribe in order to get what he wants, the hand of his love, the daughter of the chieftain. The chieftain rejects his offer and gives him gold for Carter instead.
SG-1 goes to free Carter and find that the boy's father is considering changing the customs since he loves his wife. They find Carter and to avoid war, they make a trade to get her back. Jack trades the chieftain a gun and they run off before he finds out it is useless once the bullets run out. However, he laters finds that his daughter has escaped to meet with the boy. They decide a duel will settle the dispute and avoid war, so Carter challenges the chieftain. She kicks his butt, no war occurs, the women are freed, and everything is changed.
The writer of this episode was Katharyn Powers, who previously co-wrote the ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'' episode "Code of Honor", which essentially had ''[[AuthorAppeal exactly the same plot]]''. Just replace Mongols with Africans and Sam Carter with the also blonde, short-haired Tasha Yar. Both were even the third episode of their respective shows' first season. However, the ''Stargate'' version [[WriterOnBoard manages to be even preachier]].
----
