Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekVoyagerS7E9FleshAndBlood

Go To

OR

Added: 221

Changed: 91

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CallBack

to:

* CallBackCallBack:
** This whole mess is the result of the events of "[[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS4E17TheKillingGame The Killing Game]]".



* HyperspeedAmbush: ''Voyager'' follows the Hirogen warships at warp and attacks when they drop to impulse.



* LuredIntoATrap: The Hirogen ship that ''Voyager'' teams up with. Janeway sees it coming, though.

to:

* LuredIntoATrap: The Hirogen ship that ''Voyager'' teams up with. Janeway sees it coming, though.coming and tries to warn them, but the Alpha decides to go LeeroyJenkins instead of listening to her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BizarreAlienBiology: An alien species with ''six'' feet? Okay, then...

to:

* BizarreAlienBiology: An alien species with ''six'' feet? ''[[VertebrateWithExtraLimbs six]]'' [[VertebrateWithExtraLimbs feet]]? Okay, then...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Iden:''' Would you really kill one of your own to save an organic?\\

to:

--> '''Iden:''' Would you really [[ApeShallNeverKillApe kill one of your own own]] to save an organic?\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenAesop: Two recurring themes in this episode are that people should take responsibility for their actions, and whether an artificially-intelligent hologram has the same rights as a person or is JustAMachine. However to [[StatusQuoIsGod let the Doctor off the hook]] Janeway declares that he's not responsible for his actions. Which would certainly be the case if the Doctor were JustAMachine, but [[WithGreatPowerComesGreatResponsibility not if he has the right to exercise his free will]].

to:

* BrokenAesop: Two recurring themes in this episode are that people should take responsibility for their actions, and whether an artificially-intelligent hologram has the same rights as a person or is JustAMachine. However to [[StatusQuoIsGod [[EasilyForgiven let the Doctor off the hook]] Janeway declares that he's not responsible for his actions. Which would certainly be the case if the Doctor were JustAMachine, but [[WithGreatPowerComesGreatResponsibility not if he has the right to exercise his free will]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnswersToTheNameOfGod: Iden was programmed to [[ReligiousRobot adhere to the Bajoran faith]]. Eventually, he figures he doesn't want to associate his people with anything dirty and "organic" -- but his subroutines still demand a deity and so he appoints himself.
-->'''Doctor:''' (sarcastically) ''And on the seventh day, Iden created Ha'Dara...''

Added: 436

Changed: 4

Removed: 435

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AttackBackfire: With the Doctor's help, the holograms are able to send the Technobabble Beam meant to shut down their holo-emitters back at Voyager's deflector dish.



* AttackReflector: With the Doctor's help, the holograms are able to send the Technobabble Beam meant to shut down their holo-emitters back at Voyager's deflector dish.



* [[KlingonScientistsGetNoRespect Hirogen Scientists Get No Respect]]: Donik suffers from this something fierce. He's actually grateful to Voyager, because their holographic technology gave him a chance to be an Engineer instead of just another Hunter like his father.



** Dorik expanded the abilities of the holograms (under orders) until they got out of control.

to:

** Dorik Donik expanded the abilities of the holograms (under orders) until they got out of control.



* [[KlingonScientistsGetNoRespect Hirogen Scientists Get No Respect]]: Donik suffers from this something fierce. He's actually grateful to Voyager, because their holographic technology gave him a chance to be an Engineer instead of just another Hunter like his father.



* TestosteronePoisoning: When Dorik chooses to help Janeway, a Hirogen sneers at him, "Is this female your Alpha now?"

to:

* TestosteronePoisoning: When Dorik Donik chooses to help Janeway, a Hirogen sneers at him, "Is this female your Alpha now?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Has nothing to do with familiarity with in-universe fiction.


* WoundedGazelleGambit: You'd think a Hunter would be GenreSavvy about this trick.

to:

* WoundedGazelleGambit: You'd think a Hunter would be GenreSavvy savvy about this trick.

Added: 36

Changed: 91

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeathFakedForYou: The [[YouAreInCommandNow last remaining Alpha]] insists on claiming the holograms. It's pointed out that he doesn't have the manpower to seize them, and his reputation will be improved if he can say he hunted down and destroyed the rebel ship, rather than admit he was saved by a hologram.

to:

* DeathFakedForYou: The [[YouAreInCommandNow last remaining Alpha]] insists on claiming the holograms. It's pointed holograms until Neelix points out that he doesn't have the manpower to seize them, and his reputation will be improved if he can say he hunted down and destroyed the rebel ship, rather than admit he was saved by a hologram.



* EvilIsHammy: Iden is [[TranquilFury calmly spoken]] at first, but once he starts thinking of himself as a messiah the shouting starts.

to:

* EvilIsHammy: Iden is [[TranquilFury calmly spoken]] at first, but once he starts thinking of himself as a messiah the shouting starts.he starts SuddenlyShouting.



* TheHunterBecomesTheHunted: Iden's plan for the Hirogen. As one of his minions says, "Who's the prey now?"

to:

* TheHunterBecomesTheHunted: Iden's plan for the Hirogen. As one of his minions says, "Who's Hirogen.
--> '''Weiss:''' Who's
the prey now?"now?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BizarreAlienBiology: An alien species with ''six'' feet? Okay, then...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TalkToTheFist: An Alpha knocks down his Beta when the latter questions his actions.

to:

* TalkToTheFist: An Alpha knocks down his Beta when the latter questions his actions.for questioning him.



* TestosteronePoisoning: When Dorik chooses to help Janeway, a Hirogen sneers at him, "Is this woman your Alpha now?"

to:

* TestosteronePoisoning: When Dorik chooses to help Janeway, a Hirogen sneers at him, "Is this woman female your Alpha now?"

Added: 117

Removed: 117

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TestosteronePoisoning: When Dorik chooses to help Janeway, a Hirogen sneers at him, "Is this woman your Alpha now?"



* TestosteronePoisoning: When Dorik chooses to help Janeway, a Hirogen sneers at him, "Is this woman your Alpha now?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.

to:

* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels use holo-novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WallOfWeapons: In the Hirogen sickbay, no less. Or perhaps it was the evisceration room for trophies?

to:

* WallOfWeapons: In the Hirogen sickbay, no less. Or perhaps it was the evisceration room for trophies?trophies? There are a good many SpikesOfDoom...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TalkToTheFist: An Alpha knocks down his Beta when he questions his actions.

to:

* TalkToTheFist: An Alpha knocks down his Beta when he the latter questions his actions.

Added: 117

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[KlingonScientistsGetNoRespect Hirogen Scientists Get No Respect]]: Donik suffers from this something fierce. He's actually grateful to Voyager, because their holographic technology gave him a chance to be an Engineer instead of just another Hunter like his father.

to:

* [[KlingonScientistsGetNoRespect Hirogen Scientists Get No Respect]]: Donik suffers from this something fierce. He's actually grateful to Voyager, because their holographic technology gave him a chance to be an Engineer instead of just another Hunter like his father.



* TestosteronePoisoning: When Dorik chooses to help Janeway, a Hirogen sneers at him, "Is this woman your Alpha now?"



* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.

to:

* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware? self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[KlingonScientistsGetNoRespect Hirogen Scientists Get No Respect]]: Donik suffers from this something fierce.

to:

* [[KlingonScientistsGetNoRespect Hirogen Scientists Get No Respect]]: Donik suffers from this something fierce. He's actually grateful to Voyager, because their holographic technology gave him a chance to be an Engineer instead of just another Hunter like his father.



* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.

to:

* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware? self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenAesop: Two recurring themes in this episode are that people should take responsibility for their actions, and whether an artificially-intelligent hologram has the same rights as a person or is JustAMachine. However to [[StatusQuoIsGod let the Doctor off the hook]] Janeway declares that he's not responsible for his actions. Which would certainly be the case if the Doctor were JustAMachine, but not if he has the right to exercise his free will.

to:

* BrokenAesop: Two recurring themes in this episode are that people should take responsibility for their actions, and whether an artificially-intelligent hologram has the same rights as a person or is JustAMachine. However to [[StatusQuoIsGod let the Doctor off the hook]] Janeway declares that he's not responsible for his actions. Which would certainly be the case if the Doctor were JustAMachine, but [[WithGreatPowerComesGreatResponsibility not if he has the right to exercise his free will.will]].



* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.

to:

* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware? self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenAesop: Two recurring themes in this episode are that people should take responsibility for their actions, and whether an artificially-intelligent hologram has the same rights as a person or is JustAMachine. However to let the Doctor off the hook at the end of the episode, Janeway declares that he's not responsible for his actions. Which would certainly be the case if the Doctor were JustAMachine, but not if he has the right to exercise his free will.

to:

* BrokenAesop: Two recurring themes in this episode are that people should take responsibility for their actions, and whether an artificially-intelligent hologram has the same rights as a person or is JustAMachine. However to [[StatusQuoIsGod let the Doctor off the hook at the end of the episode, hook]] Janeway declares that he's not responsible for his actions. Which would certainly be the case if the Doctor were JustAMachine, but not if he has the right to exercise his free will.



* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.

to:

* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware? self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IChooseToStay: Donik with the holograms.

to:

* IChooseToStay: Donik chooses to stay with the holograms.holograms and fix some of the damage he's caused.



* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.

to:

* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware? self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.

Added: 261

Changed: 546

Removed: 881

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompressedVice: Janeway is openly bigoted against the holograms, regarding them solely as dangerous malfunctioning machines. This is rather spectacularly at odds with how the character and franchise as a whole dealt with sentient holograms on other occasions.



* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine:
** Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware?
** Janeway is openly bigoted against the holograms and states straight-out that she refuses to consider them as possessing any rights as sentient beings, seeing them solely as dangerous malfunctioning machines. This is rather spectacularly at odds with how the character and franchise as a whole dealt with sentient holograms on other occasions.
** Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.

to:

* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine:
**
JustAMachine: Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware?
** Janeway is openly bigoted against the holograms and states straight-out that she refuses to consider them as possessing any rights as sentient beings, seeing them solely as dangerous malfunctioning machines. This is rather spectacularly at odds with how the character and franchise as a whole dealt with sentient holograms on other occasions.
**
self-aware? For instance Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.

Added: 359

Changed: 148

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoChallengeEqualsNoSatisfaction: In the Doctor's nightmare, a Hirogen tosses his own weapon at the Doctor's feet and tells him to pick it up. When he refuses, the Hirogen guts him.

to:

* NoChallengeEqualsNoSatisfaction: NoChallengeEqualsNoSatisfaction:
**
In the Doctor's nightmare, a Hirogen tosses his own weapon at the Doctor's feet and tells him to pick it up. When up, deriding him as worthless prey when he refuses, refuses.
** In an effort to make more challenging prey,
the Hirogen guts him.ArtificialIntelligence of the holograms was increased until they became clever enough to [[TurnedAgainstTheirMasters kill their captors and escape]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DispenseWithThePleasantries: With a Hirogen hunting party closing in Janeway doesn't have time to negotiate with Iden, just offering them the dubious sanctuary of Voyager's databanks. Iden hardly going to trust an organic not to hand them over to the Hirogen, so he refuses.

to:

* DispenseWithThePleasantries: With a Hirogen hunting party closing in Janeway doesn't have time to negotiate with Iden, just offering them the dubious sanctuary of Voyager's databanks. Iden is hardly going to trust an organic not to hand them over to the Hirogen, so he refuses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DispenseWithThePleasantries: With a Hirogen hunting party closing in Janeway doesn't have time to negotiate with Iden, just offering them the dubious sanctuary of Voyager's databanks. Iden is not going to trust an organic not to hand them over to the Hirogen again, so he refuses.

to:

* DispenseWithThePleasantries: With a Hirogen hunting party closing in Janeway doesn't have time to negotiate with Iden, just offering them the dubious sanctuary of Voyager's databanks. Iden is not hardly going to trust an organic not to hand them over to the Hirogen again, Hirogen, so he refuses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenAesop: Two recurring themes in this episode are that people should take responsibility for their actions, and whether an artificially-intelligent hologram has the same rights as a person or is JustAMachine. However to let the Doctor off the hook at the end of the episode, Janeway declares that he's not responsible for his actions. Which would certainly be the case if the Doctor were JustAMachine, but not if he has the right to exercise his free will.

to:

* BrokenAesop: Two recurring themes in this episode are that people should take responsibility for their actions, and whether an artificially-intelligent hologram has the same rights as a person or is JustAMachine. However to let the Doctor off the hook at the end of the episode, Janeway declares that he's not responsible for his actions. actions. Which would certainly be the case if the Doctor were JustAMachine, but not if he has the right to exercise his free will.



* ClosestThingWeGot: The Doctor is put to work repairing the holograms, despite being only programmed to repair organics. Fortunately he has had some experience in the area, what with self-maintenance and experimenting with his own program.

to:

* ClosestThingWeGot: The Doctor is put to work repairing the holograms, despite only being only programmed to repair organics. Fortunately he has had some experience in the area, what with self-maintenance and experimenting with his own program.



* DispenseWithThePleasantries: With a Hirogen hunting party closing in Janeway doesn't have time to negotiate with Iden, just offering them the dubious sanctuary of Voyager's databanks. Iden is not going to trust an organic not to hand them over to the Hirogen again, so he refuses.

to:

* DispenseWithThePleasantries: With a Hirogen hunting party closing in Janeway doesn't have time to negotiate with Iden, just offering them the dubious sanctuary of Voyager's databanks. Iden is not going to trust an organic not to hand them over to the Hirogen again, so he refuses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenAesop: Two recurring themes in this episode are that people should take responsibility for their actions, and that the [[ArtificialIntelligence AI]] holograms have rights too. However in order to let the Doctor off the hook at the end of the episode, Janeway declares that he's not responsible for his actions. Meaning that the Doctor is JustAMachine after all.

to:

* BrokenAesop: Two recurring themes in this episode are that people should take responsibility for their actions, and that whether an artificially-intelligent hologram has the [[ArtificialIntelligence AI]] holograms have same rights too. as a person or is JustAMachine. However in order to let the Doctor off the hook at the end of the episode, Janeway declares that he's not responsible for his actions. Meaning that actions. Which would certainly be the case if the Doctor is JustAMachine after all.were JustAMachine, but not if he has the right to exercise his free will.



** In Seasons One and Two, Captain Janeway refused to trade technology with the Kazon because it might be misused. She's learnt to be more flexible, but now Janeway faces the consequences of compromising on this point.

to:

** In Seasons One and Two, Captain Janeway refused to trade technology with the Kazon because it might be misused. She's learnt to be more flexible, flexible over the years, but now Janeway faces the consequences of compromising on this point.



* DispenseWithThePleasantries: With a Hirogen hunting party closing in Janeway doesn't have time to negotiate with Iden, which has serious consequences.

to:

* DispenseWithThePleasantries: With a Hirogen hunting party closing in Janeway doesn't have time to negotiate with Iden, which has serious consequences.just offering them the dubious sanctuary of Voyager's databanks. Iden is not going to trust an organic not to hand them over to the Hirogen again, so he refuses.

Added: 162

Changed: 356

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenAesop: Don't holographic rights come with responsibilities?

to:

* BrokenAesop: Don't holographic Two recurring themes in this episode are that people should take responsibility for their actions, and that the [[ArtificialIntelligence AI]] holograms have rights come with responsibilities?too. However in order to let the Doctor off the hook at the end of the episode, Janeway declares that he's not responsible for his actions. Meaning that the Doctor is JustAMachine after all.


Added DiffLines:

** Janeway treats the holograms as machines that have malfunctioned, and can hardly believe that the Doctor has abandoned his TrueCompanions for these...'people'.

Added: 111

Changed: 15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GrewBeyondTheirProgramming: Kejal used her increased intelligence to teach herself how to become an engineer.



* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman:

to:

* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman:WhatMeasureIsANonHuman / JustAMachine:

Added: 500

Changed: 751

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman: Janeway is openly bigoted against the holograms and states straight-out that she refuses to consider them as possessing any rights as sentient beings, seeing them solely as dangerous malfunctioning machines. This is rather spectacularly at odds with how the character and franchise as a whole dealt with sentient holograms on other occasions.
** But the episode shows the issue isn't that simple. Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.

to:

* WhatMeasureIsANonHuman: WhatMeasureIsANonHuman:
** Captain Janeway handed Voyager's holodeck technology to the Hirogen to encourage them to stop [[HuntingTheMostDangerousGame hunting sentient races]]. As that episode showed, Voyager's crew already have holodeck novels that involve shooting holograms for their own entertainment. At what point do the holograms have rights? Is it when they become so advanced they are self-aware?
**
Janeway is openly bigoted against the holograms and states straight-out that she refuses to consider them as possessing any rights as sentient beings, seeing them solely as dangerous malfunctioning machines. This is rather spectacularly at odds with how the character and franchise as a whole dealt with sentient holograms on other occasions.
** But the episode shows the issue isn't that simple. Iden liberates a crewful of holograms, but their programming is so simple they can't comprehend their 'liberation'. They literally are talking machines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LetUsNeverSpeakOfThisAgain: Instead of [[DeathOfPersonality resetting him to factory settings]] or confiscating his mobile emitter for [[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS5E9ThirtyDays thirty days]], Janeway tells the Doctor to write up a report on his 'away mission', sweeping his desertion under Voyager's well-maintained carpet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EasilyForgiven: At the end of the episode, the Doctor offers to surrender his mobile emitter to Captain Janeway for a set period, the holographic equivalent of being confined to quarters. Janeway declares he's not responsible for his actions, creating a BrokenAesop for the entire AI question. One can't help think StatusQuoIsGod is what's actually the issue, as confining the holo-emitter for emergency use would have restricted the writers.

to:

* EasilyForgiven: At the end of the episode, the Doctor offers to give up his holodeck privileges and surrender his mobile emitter to Captain Janeway for a set period, Janeway, the holographic equivalent of being confined to quarters. Janeway declares he's not responsible for his actions, creating a BrokenAesop for the entire AI question. One can't help think StatusQuoIsGod is what's actually the issue, as confining the holo-emitter for emergency use would have restricted the writers.

Top