Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekTheNextGenerationS5E5Disaster

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseMedicine: Hoo boy. The "advice" Crusher gives LaForge just before he decompresses the cargo bay, is not only wrong, it's *dangerously* wrong...if he had followed her advice to "resist the urge to exhale" he would've died. The proper way to handle even a very brief decompression is to completely empty your lungs so they don't pop from overpressure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MajorGeneralSong: Crusher wants Geordi to sing this as part of some upcoming performance. He gets out the first two lines before deciding that he can't sing, especially in front of others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Has nothing to do with familiarity with in-universe fiction.


* GenreSavvy: Upon arriving in engineering, Riker sees the power is a mess, but that the viewscreens are all on. He realizes that someone on the bridge is trying to alert them to what problem needs fixing.

Added: 159

Changed: 248

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GrewASpine: Marissa, enough to refuse Picard's order to abandon him.



* ThatsAnOrder: Marissa gets to use the line when telling the other two kids to be quiet.



* TookALevelInBadass: [[DownplayedTrope Downplayed]]. Marissa [[GrewASpine grows enough of a spine]] to refuse to abandon Picard.

to:

* TookALevelInBadass: [[DownplayedTrope Downplayed]]. Marissa [[GrewASpine grows enough of a spine]] UncomfortableElevatorMoment: Picard is clearly ill at ease while in the turbolift with three kids--and that's ''before'' [[ElevatorFailure things go to refuse to abandon Picard.hell]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Clean Pretty Childbirth - Apparently there are two versions of this episode.

Added DiffLines:

** Averted in the DVD (and Netflix streaming) version, where Molly is shown crying, naked, covered in placenta, and with a strategically placed umbilical cord still attached.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FourLinesAllWaiting: There are five situations going on simultaneously in the aftermath of the collision with the filament: Troi, Ro, O'Brien and a few extras on the bridge, Picard and the kids in the turbolift, LaForge and Crusher with the fire in the cargo bay, Riker and Data getting to engineering, and Worf and his adventures in midwifing Keiko's labor.

to:

* FourLinesAllWaiting: There are five situations going on simultaneously in the aftermath of the collision with the filament: Troi, Ro, O'Brien and a few extras on the bridge, Picard and the kids in the turbolift, LaForge [=LaForge=] and Crusher with the fire in the cargo bay, Riker and Data getting to engineering, and Worf and his adventures in midwifing Keiko's labor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FourLinesAllWaiting: There are four situations going on simultaneously.

to:

* FourLinesAllWaiting: There are four five situations going on simultaneously.simultaneously in the aftermath of the collision with the filament: Troi, Ro, O'Brien and a few extras on the bridge, Picard and the kids in the turbolift, LaForge and Crusher with the fire in the cargo bay, Riker and Data getting to engineering, and Worf and his adventures in midwifing Keiko's labor.

Added: 74

Removed: 76

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InLaymansTerms: O'Brien translates some of Ro's {{technobabble}} for Troi.


Added DiffLines:

* LaymansTerms: O'Brien translates some of Ro's {{technobabble}} for Troi.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InLaymansTerms: O'Brien translates some of Ro's {{technobabble}} for Troi.

Changed: 530

Removed: 529

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DramaPreservingHandicap: Troi's empathic abilities abruptly become functionally useless, preventing her from determining how many people are alive or dead, or where they are on the ship. She knows that there ''are'' people elsewhere who are alive, but not where they are on the ship.
The main purpose of this power outage is to preserve the tension over the question of whether or not to separate the saucer section, since if Troi were aware that Picard, Riker and [=LaForge=] were all still alive and working on various parts of the problem she would have just been able to tell Ro to shut up and let the rest of the command staff save the day. (It should be noted that Troi has been able to sense emotions of people on the planet while the ship is ''in orbit'', in another example of her plot-dependent powers.)

to:

* DramaPreservingHandicap: Troi's empathic abilities abruptly become functionally useless, preventing her from determining how many people are alive or dead, or where they are on the ship. She knows that there ''are'' people elsewhere who are alive, but not where they are on the ship.
ship. The main purpose of this power outage is to preserve the tension over the question of whether or not to separate the saucer section, since if Troi were aware that Picard, Riker and [=LaForge=] were all still alive and working on various parts of the problem she would have just been able to tell Ro to shut up and let the rest of the command staff save the day. (It should be noted that Troi has been able to sense emotions of people on the planet while the ship is ''in orbit'', in another example of her plot-dependent powers.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheEeyore: Jay Gordon, one of the science kids, continually says that they're all going to die.


Added DiffLines:

* SignificantWardrobeShift: A mild example, but Marissa is dressed in a much brighter red outfit at the end of the episode, after her confidence boost.

Added: 528

Changed: 1290

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor: In the first scene, Keiko says she wishes her pregnancy was over already.



* DramaPreservingHandicap: Troi's empathic abilities abruptly become functionally useless, preventing her from determining how many people are alive or dead, or where they are on the ship. The best excuse is that everyone is freaked out. But this neglects the fact that the ''Enterprise'' has been in deadly danger before and Troi's powers were never white-noised (except when dramatically necessary). The main purpose of this power outage is to preserve the tension over the question of whether or not to separate the saucer section, since if Troi were aware that Picard, Riker and [=LaForge=] were all still alive and working on various parts of the problem she would have just been able to tell Ro to shut up and let the rest of the command staff save the day.
** Troi's empathic abilities tell her that there are people elsewhere who are alive and hurt, but she cannot tell for certain whether any of the living people she senses are in the stardrive section or not. Her empathic abilities are there, but are not fine-tuned enough to resolve the dilemma on their own.

to:

* DramaPreservingHandicap: Troi's empathic abilities abruptly become functionally useless, preventing her from determining how many people are alive or dead, or where they are on the ship. The best excuse is She knows that everyone is freaked out. But this neglects there ''are'' people elsewhere who are alive, but not where they are on the fact that the ''Enterprise'' has been in deadly danger before and Troi's powers were never white-noised (except when dramatically necessary). ship.
The main purpose of this power outage is to preserve the tension over the question of whether or not to separate the saucer section, since if Troi were aware that Picard, Riker and [=LaForge=] were all still alive and working on various parts of the problem she would have just been able to tell Ro to shut up and let the rest of the command staff save the day.
** Troi's empathic abilities tell her
day. (It should be noted that there are Troi has been able to sense emotions of people elsewhere who are alive and hurt, but she cannot tell for certain whether any of on the living people she senses are in planet while the stardrive section or not. Her empathic abilities are there, but are not fine-tuned enough to resolve the dilemma on their own.ship is ''in orbit'', in another example of her plot-dependent powers.)



* FourLinesAllWaiting

to:

* FourLinesAllWaitingFourLinesAllWaiting: There are four situations going on simultaneously.



* IWillOnlySlowYouDown: Picard to the children.

to:

* IWillOnlySlowYouDown: Picard to the children.children when he breaks his ankle.


Added DiffLines:

* MadeOfExplodium: The poratum in the cargo bay where Geordi and Crusher are trapped is normally stable, but not in the presence of radioactive plasma fires.


Added DiffLines:

* NoOSHACompliance:
** No normal human adult would be able to reach the emergency hatch on the turbolift.
** In-universe, O'Brien protests the way Ro transfers power from phasers to the engineering station because that's way too much power to put into a computer terminal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/tng_disaster_hd_357.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:Troi takes command of the ''Enterprise'' (however hesitantly).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Foreshadowing}}: The events here play a large role in Troi taking the promotion exam in[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E15ThineOwnSelf "Thine Own Self"]]).

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: The events here play a large role in Troi taking the promotion exam in[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E15ThineOwnSelf in [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E15ThineOwnSelf "Thine Own Self"]]).Self"]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrazyEnoughToWork: Geordi's idea to decompress the cargo bay, both putting out the plasma fire and dumping the explosive stuff. Not only does it work, it also averts ExplosiveDecompression. ([[SpaceDoesNotWorkThatWay Crusher does, however, screw up by telling Geordi not to exhale;]] [[RealityIsUnrealistic in reality, holding your breath in a vacuum could rupture your lungs.]]
* DeliveryGuy: Worf plays this part to a tee.)

to:

* CrazyEnoughToWork: Geordi's idea to decompress the cargo bay, both putting out the plasma fire and dumping the explosive stuff. Not only does it work, it also averts ExplosiveDecompression. ([[SpaceDoesNotWorkThatWay Crusher does, however, screw up by telling Geordi not to exhale;]] [[RealityIsUnrealistic in reality, holding your breath in a vacuum could rupture your lungs.]]
]])
* DeliveryGuy: Worf plays this part to a tee.)

Added: 1530

Changed: 1574

Removed: 45

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrazyEnoughToWork: Geordi's idea to decompress the cargo bay, both putting out the plasma fire and dumping the explosive stuff. Not only does it work, it also averts ExplosiveDecompression.
** [[SpaceDoesNotWorkThatWay Crusher does, however, screw up by telling Geordi not to exhale;]] [[RealityIsUnrealistic in reality, holding your breath in a vacuum could rupture your lungs.]]
* DeliveryGuy: Worf plays this part to a tee.

to:

* CrazyEnoughToWork: Geordi's idea to decompress the cargo bay, both putting out the plasma fire and dumping the explosive stuff. Not only does it work, it also averts ExplosiveDecompression.
** [[SpaceDoesNotWorkThatWay
ExplosiveDecompression. ([[SpaceDoesNotWorkThatWay Crusher does, however, screw up by telling Geordi not to exhale;]] [[RealityIsUnrealistic in reality, holding your breath in a vacuum could rupture your lungs.]]
* DeliveryGuy: Worf plays this part to a tee.)



* {{Foreshadowing}}: The events here play a large role in Troi taking the promotion exam in[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E15ThineOwnSelf "Thine Own Self"]]).



* MoreExpendableThanYou: Data offers to use himself to absorb an electric current, allowing Riker to pass, which will cripple him, but should leave him repairable later on. Riker points out to regardless if whether or not he'd be willing to sacrifice Data, and he isn't, it would be pointless. Riker wouldn't be able to fix the Warp Core without him as he's not an engineer. Instead they disconnect Data's head and toss his headless body into the current, diverting it, but allowing Riker to take Data's head along so he can talk him through what repairs need to be done.

to:

* MoreExpendableThanYou: Two examples:
**
Data offers to use himself to absorb an electric current, allowing Riker to pass, which will cripple him, but should leave him repairable later on. Riker points out to regardless if whether or not he'd be willing to sacrifice Data, and he isn't, it would be pointless. Riker wouldn't be able to fix the Warp Core without him as he's not an engineer. Instead they disconnect Data's head and toss his headless body into the current, diverting it, but allowing Riker to take Data's head along so he can talk him through what repairs need to be done.done.
** Second, Picard tells the children to leave him behind, as he'd only slow them down; they refuse.



* NoOneGetsLeftBehind: The children to Picard.

to:

* NoOneGetsLeftBehind: NoOneGetsLeftBehind:
**
The children to Picard. Picard; they refuse to abandon him, despite his "orders" to do so.



* YouAreInCommandNow: [[DeconstructedTrope Deconstructed]] with Troi, who is forced into command on the bridge after Lt. Monroe is killed. Despite her rank as Lieutenant Commander, she has no idea what she's doing. Neither does she seem to understand the basics of how the ship works. It really doesn't make sense that, as part of the Medical structure and not Command, she would take command of the bridge just by being ranked higher, but it makes for some good CharacterDevelopment (for example, the events of this episode is the main reason she takes the bridge officer's exam in [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E15ThineOwnSelf "Thine Own Self"]]).

to:

* YouAreInCommandNow: YouAreInCommandNow:
**
[[DeconstructedTrope Deconstructed]] with Troi, who is forced into command on the bridge after Lt. Monroe is killed. Despite her rank as Lieutenant Commander, she has no idea what she's doing. Neither does she seem to understand the basics of how the ship works. It really doesn't make sense that, as part of the Medical structure and not Command, she would take command of the bridge just by being ranked higher, but it makes for some good CharacterDevelopment (for example, the events of this episode is the main reason she takes the bridge officer's exam in [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E15ThineOwnSelf "Thine Own Self"]]).

Added: 154

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LosingYourHead: Fortunately, Data can still talk and instruct Riker while his head is separate from his body; doesn't make it any less creepy, however.



* MoreExpendableThanYou: Data offers to use himself to absorb an electric current, allowing Riker to pass, which will cripple him, but should leave him repairable later on. Riker points out to regardless if whether or not he'd be willing to sacrifice Data, and he isn't, it would be pointless. Riker wouldn't be able to fix the Warp Core without him as he's not an engineer. Instead they disconnect Data's head and toss his headless body into the current, diverting it, but allowing Riker to take Data' head along so he can talk him through what repairs need to be done.

to:

* MoreExpendableThanYou: Data offers to use himself to absorb an electric current, allowing Riker to pass, which will cripple him, but should leave him repairable later on. Riker points out to regardless if whether or not he'd be willing to sacrifice Data, and he isn't, it would be pointless. Riker wouldn't be able to fix the Warp Core without him as he's not an engineer. Instead they disconnect Data's head and toss his headless body into the current, diverting it, but allowing Riker to take Data' Data's head along so he can talk him through what repairs need to be done.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheComplainerIsAlwaysWrong: Ro for wanting to separate the ship. The writers admitted they sort of shortchanged her by having her in this position in what was her second appearance.


Added DiffLines:

* GenreSavvy: Upon arriving in engineering, Riker sees the power is a mess, but that the viewscreens are all on. He realizes that someone on the bridge is trying to alert them to what problem needs fixing.


Added DiffLines:

* PoorlyDisguisedPilot: Slightly. Producers were developing ''[=DS9=]'' at the time and had pegged O'Brien and Ro to be part of the cast. Their interactions here were to see how the two characters would play off of each other. Producers were satisfied, though Michelle Forbes ended up turning down being on the spinoff.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: In RealLife, a therapist like Troi would not be in command of a warship. Ensign Ro, the highest-ranking line officer, should be the one in charge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MoreExpendableThanYou: Data offers to use himself to absorb an electric current, allowing Riker to pass, which will cripple him, but should leave him repairable later on. Riker points out to regardless if whether or not he'd be willing to sacrifice Data, and he isn't, it would be pointless. Riker wouldn't be able to fix the Warp Core without him as he's not an engineer. Instead they disconnect Data's head and toss his headless body into the current, diverting it, but allowing Riker to take Data' head along so he can talk him through what repairs need to be done.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CharacterDevelopment: A subtle example. Picard has some trouble interacting with his three young charges, but he's also come a long way from the first episode (where he thought he was wholly incapable of dealing with children).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShrinkingViolet: Marissa, before her CharacterDevelopment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Troi's empathic abilities tell her that there are people elsewhere who are alive and hurt, but she cannot tell for certain whether any of the living people she senses are in the stardrive section or not. Her empathic abilities are there, but are not fine-tuned enough to resolve the dilemma on their own.


Added DiffLines:

**Troi's taking command is the automatic result of an emergency protocol, after the redshirt in command was suddenly killed. While Troi did not have the necessary preparation to command a starship under normal circumstances, she sought input from other officers with the expertise she needed. Troi also realized the need to exert her authority and be confident in her decisions, despite Ro relentlessly undermining her. That realization is probably why Troi chose to pursue further training in command, instead of running fast and far from the bridge once the crisis passed. Like [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS6E13FaceOfTheEnemy "Face of the Enemy"]], this episode is one where we begin to see Troi's potential as a Starfleet officer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheDanza: None of the kids' last names are spoken onscreen. The plaque they make for Picard gives them the last names of their actors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Typo


* YouAreInCommandNow: [[DeconstructedTrope Deconstructed]] with Troi, who is forced into command on the brdige after Lt. Monroe is killed. Despite her rank as Lieutenant Commander, she has no idea what she's doing. Neither does she seem to understand the basics of how the ship works. It really doesn't make sense that, as part of the Medical structure and not Command, she would take command of the bridge just by being ranked higher, but it makes for some good CharacterDevelopment (for example, the events of this episode is the main reason she takes the bridge officer's exam in [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E15ThineOwnSelf "Thine Own Self"]]).

to:

* YouAreInCommandNow: [[DeconstructedTrope Deconstructed]] with Troi, who is forced into command on the brdige bridge after Lt. Monroe is killed. Despite her rank as Lieutenant Commander, she has no idea what she's doing. Neither does she seem to understand the basics of how the ship works. It really doesn't make sense that, as part of the Medical structure and not Command, she would take command of the bridge just by being ranked higher, but it makes for some good CharacterDevelopment (for example, the events of this episode is the main reason she takes the bridge officer's exam in [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E15ThineOwnSelf "Thine Own Self"]]).

Changed: 619

Removed: 641

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YouAreInCommandNow: Troi, being the highest-ranking officer on the bridge, is forced into command after Lt. Monroe is killed.
** [[DeconstructedTrope Deconstructed]]: Despite her rank, she has no idea what she's doing. Neither does she seem to understand the basics of how the ship works. It really doesn't make sense that, as part of the Medical structure and not Command, she would take command of the bridge just by being ranked higher (just like Picard doesn't take command of counseling or sickbay despite outranking Troi and Crusher), but it makes for some good CharacterDevelopment (for example, the events of this episode is one of the main reasons she takes the bridge officer's exam in [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E15ThineOwnSelf "Thine Own Self"]]).

to:

* YouAreInCommandNow: [[DeconstructedTrope Deconstructed]] with Troi, being the highest-ranking officer on the bridge, who is forced into command on the brdige after Lt. Monroe is killed.
** [[DeconstructedTrope Deconstructed]]:
killed. Despite her rank, rank as Lieutenant Commander, she has no idea what she's doing. Neither does she seem to understand the basics of how the ship works. It really doesn't make sense that, as part of the Medical structure and not Command, she would take command of the bridge just by being ranked higher (just like Picard doesn't take command of counseling or sickbay despite outranking Troi and Crusher), higher, but it makes for some good CharacterDevelopment (for example, the events of this episode is one of the main reasons reason she takes the bridge officer's exam in [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E15ThineOwnSelf "Thine Own Self"]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Formatting.


* NegativeSpaceWedgie: A "quantum filament," whatever the hell that is,[[note]] It's ''definitely'' [[CallBack nothing like]] a [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS4E10TheLoss cosmic string]]]][[/note]] upending and disabling the ''Enterprise'' like a rogue tidal wave.

to:

* NegativeSpaceWedgie: A "quantum filament," whatever the hell that is,[[note]] It's ''definitely'' [[CallBack nothing like]] a [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS4E10TheLoss cosmic string]]]][[/note]] string]][[/note]] upending and disabling the ''Enterprise'' like a rogue tidal wave.

Added: 125

Changed: 96

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoAntagonist: The conflicts of the episode are caused by a technical catastrophe, not by any antagonistic character.

to:

* NoAntagonist: The conflicts of the episode are caused by a technical catastrophe, collision with a NegativeSpaceWedgie, not by any antagonistic character.



** Also Troi to the rest of the ship - she won't separate the ship without proof there are no survivors in the drive section.



* YouAreInCommandNow: Troi, being the highest-ranking officer on the bridge.

to:

* YouAreInCommandNow: Troi, being the highest-ranking officer on the bridge.bridge, is forced into command after Lt. Monroe is killed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NegativeSpaceWedgie: A "quantum filament," whatever the hell that is, upending and disabling the ''Enterprise'' like a rogue tidal wave.

to:

* NegativeSpaceWedgie: A "quantum filament," whatever the hell that is, is,[[note]] It's ''definitely'' [[CallBack nothing like]] a [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS4E10TheLoss cosmic string]]]][[/note]] upending and disabling the ''Enterprise'' like a rogue tidal wave.



* ThreeMonthOldNewborn

to:

* ThreeMonthOldNewbornThreeMonthOldNewborn: Molly starts her {{SORAS}} right out of the gate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ExplosiveInstrumentation: Scratch one RedShirt.

Top