Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekS3E2TheEnterpriseIncident

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Perhaps this could be a different troupe instead. It is possible in dialogue that the cloaking device has just been invented, but maybe it is a new one, as opposed to the old one. Dialogue early in the episode has Spock stating it appears the Romulans have a cloaking device that their sensors can’t detect, this could mean they could detect the old one


* SeriesContinuityError: The Enterprise encountered Romulans using cloaking devices back in "[[Recap/StarTrekS1E14BalanceOfTerror Balance Of Terror]]". Here, the Enterprise crew have never heard of the technology and it's implied to have recently been invented.

Added: 94

Changed: 1

Removed: 94

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonDiscontinuity: In a 1991 interview Tim Lynch, [[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration TNG]] research consultant, Richard Arnold talked about the crew forgetting that Romulans had cloaking devices and said to consider the third season canon until it contradicts something.

to:

* CanonDiscontinuity: In a 1991 interview Tim Lynch, [[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration TNG]] research consultant, Richard Richard Arnold talked about the crew forgetting that Romulans had cloaking devices and said to consider the third season canon until it contradicts something.



* ForcefieldDoor: Kirk gets injured throwing himself at it, causing Dr [=McCoy=] to beam over.



* ForcefieldDoor: Kirk gets injured throwing himself at it, causing Dr [=McCoy=] to beam over.

Added: 896

Changed: 6

Removed: 622

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonDiscontinuity: In a 1991 interview Tim Lynch, [[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration TNG]] research consultant, Richard Arnold talked about the crew forgetting that Romulans had cloaking devices and said to consider the third season canon until it contradicts something.



--> "Execution of state criminals is both painful...and unpleasant."

to:

--> "Execution of state criminals is both painful...and unpleasant."unpleasant".



* FakingTheDead: Kirk. Even his own crew isn't in on it. [=Dr. McCoy=] [[LampshadeHanging lampshades]] a real danger with this kind of trick that most people don't think of, "You're lucky they didn't do an autopsy on you."

to:

* FakingTheDead: Kirk. Even his own crew isn't in on it. [=Dr. McCoy=] [[LampshadeHanging lampshades]] a real danger with this kind of trick that most people don't think of, "You're lucky they didn't do an autopsy on you."you".



* OnlyMostlyDead: Kirk, thanks to the "Vulcan Death Grip."

to:

* OnlyMostlyDead: Kirk, thanks to the "Vulcan Death Grip."Grip".



* TakeAThirdOption: The Romulan Commander accurately points out that as a hybrid, Spock is constantly torn between the emotionless logic of his Vulcan side and the emotions of his human side. She tempts him that if he joined Team Romulan, he wouldn't ''have'' to choose, because the Romulans are an offshoot of the Vulcans who did not reject their emotions and passions, thus making them a nice middle-path where he would actually fit in pretty well. At the end of the episode Spock reveals that this middle path was more tempting to him than he ever let on, and it took his strong sense of duty to Starfleet to reject it.



* TakeAThirdOption: The Romulan Commander accurately points out that as a hybrid, Spock is constantly torn between the emotionless logic of his Vulcan side and the emotions of his human side. She tempts him that if he joined Team Romulan, he wouldn't ''have'' to choose, because the Romulans are an offshoot of the Vulcans who did not reject their emotions and passions, thus making them a nice middle-path where he would actually fit in pretty well. At the end of the episode Spock reveals that this middle path was more tempting to him than he ever let on, and it took his strong sense of duty to Starfleet to reject it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SeriesContinuityError: The Enterprise encountered Romulans using cloaking devices back in "[[Recap/StarTrekS1E14BalanceOfTerror Balance Of Terror]]". Here, the Enterprise crew have never heard of the technology and it's implied to have recently been invented.

Added: 297

Removed: 297

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScottyTime: Kirk gives Scotty fifteen minutes to rig up the cloak. Spock meanwhile gives a 20 minute formal statement justifying his crimes, which is almost up by the time Scotty is finished. Unfortunately Scotty's first attempt doesn't work and a HyperspeedEscape is needed to gain enough time.



* ScottyTime: Kirk gives Scotty fifteen minutes to rig up the cloak. Spock meanwhile gives a 20 minute formal statement justifying his crimes, which is almost up by the time Scotty is finished. Unfortunately Scotty's first attempt doesn't work and a HyperspeedEscape is needed to gain enough time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CaptainObvious: When Spock states "I carried out my duty" while invoking his Right of Statement, the Romulan Commander objects (probably suspecting that he is [[HoldingTheFloor stalling for time]]) that he is stating the obvious. Spock simply points out that there are [[LoopholeAbuse no regulations regarding the content of his statement]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TakeAThirdOption: The Romulan Commander accurately points out that as a hybrid, Spock is constantly torn between the emotionless logic of his Vulcan side and the emotions of his human side. She tempts him that if he joined Team Romulan, he wouldn't ''have'' to choose, because the Romulans are an offshoot of the Vulcans who did not reject their emotions and passions, thus making them a nice middle-path where he would actually fit in pretty well. At the end of the episode Spock reveals that this middle path was more tempting to him than he ever let on, and it took his strong sense of duty to Starfleet to reject it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LensmanArmsRace: Starfleet has to steal the cloaking device to keep the BalanceOfPower with the Romulans. The new model is even better at hiding cloaked ships from sensors than old models — demonstrated when ''Enterprise'' is caught completely by the Romulan armada, whereas in "Balance of Terror" the cloak was imperfect enough ''Enterprise'' could catch an echo of the cloaked ship. Starfleet wants a copy so they can study it and build countermeasures.

to:

* LensmanArmsRace: Starfleet has to steal the cloaking device to keep the BalanceOfPower with the Romulans. The new model is even better at hiding cloaked ships from sensors than old models — demonstrated when ''Enterprise'' is caught completely by the Romulan armada, whereas in "Balance of Terror" the cloak was imperfect enough ''Enterprise'' could catch an echo of the cloaked ship. Starfleet wants a copy so they can study it and build countermeasures. Capping off the episode, at the end after both the new cloaking device and the Romulan Commander have been captured, she chides Spock that any advances they make in scanning technology from studying it will only be transient, as before too long the Romulans will ''simply build a better one''. Spock himself freely admits that military "secrets" are perhaps the most fleeting of all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* GenderMisdirection: The audience doesn't get a gender reveal until the ChairReveal.

to:

* GenderMisdirection: GenderConcealingWriting: The audience doesn't get a gender reveal until the ChairReveal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Superdickery}}: In the first half of the episode, we see Kirk behaving irrationally, culminating with him ordering the ''Enterprise'' to fly unprovoked into Romulan space. And then, we see Spock betray the ''Enterprise'' to the Romulans, even killing Kirk. Of course, it all turns out to be a ruse that Kirk and Spock planned ahead of time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SealedOrders: Kirk receives them from Starfleet, explaining his erratic behavior.

to:

* SealedOrders: Kirk [[TheCaptain Captain Kirk]] receives them from Starfleet, explaining his erratic behavior.secret orders to steal a Romulan [[InvisibilityCloak cloaking device]]. As part of ThePlan, he acts like a {{Jerkass}} as a form of ObfuscatingInsanity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It's another day on the ''Enterprise'', and Kirk's acting like he had an extra helping of bitch flakes for breakfast. This becomes especially evident when he orders the ship to fly straight into Romulan space, a direct violation of the peace treaty. Of course, they soon find themselves surrounded by Romulan ships demanding their surrender. Kirk tries to B.S. the (female) Romulan commander by saying it was all a big mistake due to equipment failure. Spock rats him out, saying it was deliberate, resulting in Kirk doing a passable impression of [[Creator/JeffDunham Achmed the Dead Terrorist.]] Bones comes aboard just in time to see Kirk attempt to carry out his threat, only to be thwarted by the Vulcan Death Grip (tm). "You're dead, Jim!"

to:

It's another day on the ''Enterprise'', and Kirk's acting like he had an extra helping of bitch flakes for breakfast. This becomes especially evident when he orders the ship to fly straight into Romulan space, a direct violation of the peace treaty. Of course, they soon find themselves surrounded by Romulan ships demanding their surrender. Kirk tries to B.S. the (female) Romulan commander (Creator/JoanneLinville) by saying it was all a big mistake due to equipment failure. Spock rats him out, saying it was deliberate, resulting in Kirk doing a passable impression of [[Creator/JeffDunham Achmed the Dead Terrorist.]] Bones comes aboard just in time to see Kirk attempt to carry out his threat, only to be thwarted by the Vulcan Death Grip (tm). "You're dead, Jim!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
add vid link


* ElevatorConference: Spock and the Romulan Commander get one. Naturally, the ride (from the Bridge to Deck 2, just beneath) lasts ''just long enough'' for their lengthy conversation.

to:

* ElevatorConference: Spock and the Romulan Commander get one. Naturally, the ride (from the Bridge to Deck 2, just beneath) lasts ''just long enough'' for their lengthy conversation. [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8v181BxVxBk Watch]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Corpsing}}: Kirk breathes awful deeply for a dead man. Then again, he's not yet dead....
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlugAndPlayTechnology: The Romulan cloaking device is compatible with a Federation ship? Maybe Scotty has an adapter in his bag of tricks. {{Downplayed}}; Scotty notes that it's a slapdash job, likely to overload and blow out the cloak or cause any other number of problems. His wince when he "throws the switch" per Kirk's orders indicates that at least one of those potential problems was a fatally large boom.

to:

* PlugAndPlayTechnology: PlugNPlayTechnology: The Romulan cloaking device is compatible with a Federation ship? Maybe Scotty has an adapter in his bag of tricks. {{Downplayed}}; Scotty notes that it's a slapdash job, likely to overload and blow out the cloak or cause any other number of problems. His wince when he "throws the switch" per Kirk's orders indicates that at least one of those potential problems was a fatally large boom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChairReveal: My God, the Romulan warbird is piloted by...a [[SamusIsAGirl beautiful woman!]]

to:

* ChairReveal: My God, the Romulan warbird is piloted commanded by...a [[SamusIsAGirl beautiful woman!]]

Added: 4

Changed: 4

Removed: 326




to:

----



* PantyShot: The Romulan Commander's uniform may be ''the'' shortest skirt in the entire ''Original Series''; there's hardly a scene that ''doesn't'' flash a shot of her underwear. It makes her SlipIntoSomethingMoreComfortable almost comical because her slinky evening gown is in many ways ''less'' revealing than her uniform.



* YoureInsane: The Romulan Commander says "You must be mad!" to Spock after he betrays her. He denies it.

to:

* YoureInsane: The Romulan Commander says "You must be mad!" to Spock after he betrays her. He denies it.it.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Accidentally made a grammatical error


* PantyShot: The Romulan Commander's uniform may be ''the'' most short skirt in the entire ''Original Series''; there's hardly a scene that ''doesn't'' flash a shot of her underwear. It makes her SlipIntoSomethingMoreComfortable almost comical because her slinky evening gown is in many ways ''less'' revealing than her uniform.

to:

* PantyShot: The Romulan Commander's uniform may be ''the'' most short shortest skirt in the entire ''Original Series''; there's hardly a scene that ''doesn't'' flash a shot of her underwear. It makes her SlipIntoSomethingMoreComfortable almost comical because her slinky evening gown is in many ways ''less'' revealing than her uniform.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* CustomUniformOfSexy: The Romulan uniform doesn't involve much fanservice, except for the female commander's DangerouslyShortSkirt.

to:

* CustomUniformOfSexy: The Romulan uniform doesn't involve much fanservice, except for the female commander's DangerouslyShortSkirt.short skirt.



* PantyShot: The Romulan Commander's uniform may be ''the'' most DangerouslyShortSkirt in the entire ''Original Series''; there's hardly a scene that ''doesn't'' flash a shot of her underwear. It makes her SlipIntoSomethingMoreComfortable almost comical because her slinky evening gown is in many ways ''less'' revealing than her uniform.

to:

* PantyShot: The Romulan Commander's uniform may be ''the'' most DangerouslyShortSkirt short skirt in the entire ''Original Series''; there's hardly a scene that ''doesn't'' flash a shot of her underwear. It makes her SlipIntoSomethingMoreComfortable almost comical because her slinky evening gown is in many ways ''less'' revealing than her uniform.



* SlipIntoSomethingMoreComfortable: The commander leaves Spock to change from her uniform to a more feminine dress, giving Spock a chance to send a signal to Kirk about the location of the cloaking device. Ironically, given the DangerouslyShortSkirt of her uniform, the "Something More Comfortable" is in many ways ''less'' revealing.

to:

* SlipIntoSomethingMoreComfortable: The commander leaves Spock to change from her uniform to a more feminine dress, giving Spock a chance to send a signal to Kirk about the location of the cloaking device. Ironically, given the DangerouslyShortSkirt short skirt of her uniform, the "Something More Comfortable" is in many ways ''less'' revealing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RealLifeWritesThePlot: The Romulans are suddenly using Klingon battlecruisers because the original Romulan Warbird model was not available. The reasons are unclear: some say it was lost and eventually passed to a private collector, others say it was damaged or destroyed, either in a mishap while filming for "[[Recap/StarTrekS1E13BalanceOfTerror Balance of Terror]]" or by the modelmaker himself (who was not in the prop-makers union and so was uncredited and unpaid for his work, and smashed it in anger when it was returned to him without payment).

to:

* RealLifeWritesThePlot: The Romulans are suddenly using Klingon battlecruisers because the original Romulan Warbird model was not available. The reasons are unclear: some say it was lost and eventually passed to a private collector, others say it was damaged or destroyed, either in a mishap while filming for "[[Recap/StarTrekS1E13BalanceOfTerror "[[Recap/StarTrekS1E14BalanceOfTerror Balance of Terror]]" or by the modelmaker himself (who was not in the prop-makers union and so was uncredited and unpaid for his work, and smashed it in anger when it was returned to him without payment).

Top