Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 15 (click to see context) from:
* {{Irony}}: In this episode, we see Saru being one of the boldest and most inquisitive Kelpiens among his society. Even so, years later as a senior officer during the first season of ''Discovery'', he is still one of the most cautious Starfleet officers portrayed in ''Star Trek''.
to:
* {{Irony}}: In this episode, we see Saru being one of the boldest and most inquisitive Kelpiens among his society. Even so, years over a decade later as a senior officer during the first season of ''Discovery'', he is still one of the most cautious Starfleet officers portrayed in ''Star Trek''.
Changed line(s) 19 (click to see context) from:
* RankUp: Inverted. Since this episode is set years or even decades before the first season of ''Discovery'', Philippa Georgiou is still a lieutenant, while Saru is a young civilian who has yet to enter Starfleet Academy.
to:
* RankUp: Inverted. Since this episode is set years or even decades over a decade before the first season of ''Discovery'', Philippa Georgiou is still a lieutenant, while Saru is a young civilian who has yet to enter Starfleet Academy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 4,5 (click to see context) from:
We learn the story of how Saru first came into contact with Starfleet. The son of a village priest, Saru is uneasy with the arrangement his people have with the Ba'ul, namely that in return for the Ba'ul not hunting the Kelpiens, regular offerings of Kelpiens are made as sacrifice. Saru wonders if there might be someone out there other than the Ba'ul, and when a piece of advanced technology falls from a visiting Ba'ul ship, he tries to reach anyone he can by building a transmitter.
to:
We learn the story of how Saru first came into contact with Starfleet. The son of a village priest, Saru is uneasy with the arrangement that his people have with the Ba'ul, namely that in return for the Ba'ul not hunting the Kelpiens, regular offerings of Kelpiens are made as sacrifice. Saru wonders if there might be someone out there other than the Ba'ul, and when a piece of advanced technology falls from a visiting Ba'ul ship, he tries to reach anyone that he can by building a transmitter.
Changed line(s) 10 (click to see context) from:
* ForegoneConclusion: We already knew from the first season of ''Discovery'' that Saru left his homeworld to join Starfleet. What we didn't know is ''why'', or that he's not allowed to ever return home or communicate with his people again thanks to the Prime Directive.
to:
* ForegoneConclusion: We already knew from the first season of ''Discovery'' that Saru left his homeworld to join Starfleet. What we didn't know is ''why'', or that he's not allowed to ever return home or communicate with his people again again, thanks to the Prime Directive.
Changed line(s) 15 (click to see context) from:
* {{Irony}}: In this episode, we see Saru being one of the boldest and most inquisitive Kelpiens among his society. Even so, by the time he is a senior officer during the first season of ''Discovery'', he is still one of the most cautious Starfleet officers portrayed in ''Star Trek''.
to:
* {{Irony}}: In this episode, we see Saru being one of the boldest and most inquisitive Kelpiens among his society. Even so, by the time he is years later as a senior officer during the first season of ''Discovery'', he is still one of the most cautious Starfleet officers portrayed in ''Star Trek''.
Changed line(s) 18 (click to see context) from:
* MissingMom: Saru, his father (Aradar) and his sister (Siranna) appear in the episode, but no mention or appearance is made of Saru's mother. Given the nature of the Kelpiens' arrangement with the Ba'ul, she may well have been sacrificed some time before when the episode is set.
to:
* MissingMom: Saru, his father (Aradar) (Aradar), and his sister (Siranna) appear in the episode, but no mention or appearance is made of Saru's mother. Given the nature of the Kelpiens' arrangement with the Ba'ul, she may well have been sacrificed some time before when the episode is set.
Changed line(s) 20,21 (click to see context) from:
* TheReveal: The person Saru has been communicating with is Lieutenant Philippa Georgiou, Saru's future captain aboard the U.S.S. ''Shenzhou''.
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Played with; Georgiou mentions how hard she had to lobby for an exception to be made in the PrimeDirective for Saru (and Saru alone) to be contacted and allowed to leave Kaminar.
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Played with; Georgiou mentions how hard she had to lobby for an exception to be made in the PrimeDirective for Saru (and Saru alone) to be contacted and allowed to leave Kaminar.
to:
* TheReveal: The person that Saru has been communicating with is Lieutenant Philippa Georgiou, Saru's future captain aboard the U.S.S. ''Shenzhou''.
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Played with; Georgiou mentions how hard she had to lobby for an exception to be madein to the PrimeDirective for Saru (and Saru alone) to be contacted and allowed to leave Kaminar.
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Played with; Georgiou mentions how hard she had to lobby for an exception to be made
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/saru_on_kaminar.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:Saru looking up at the night sky.]]
[[caption-width-right:350:Saru looking up at the night sky.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 21 (click to see context) from:
** Georgiou never directly mentions what ship she serves on at the time. "The Sounds of Thunder" establishes that she was serving aboard the ''Archimedes'' at the time.
to:
** Georgiou never directly mentions what ship she serves on at the time.on. "The Sounds of Thunder" establishes that she was serving aboard the ''Archimedes'' at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 21 (click to see context) from:
** Georgiou never directly mentions what ship she serves on at the time, but given that the shuttle she arrives and departs in is designated "SHN 03", it's likely that she is already part of the crew of the U.S.S. ''Shenzhou''.
to:
** Georgiou never directly mentions what ship she serves on at the time, but given that the shuttle she arrives and departs in is designated "SHN 03", it's likely time. "The Sounds of Thunder" establishes that she is already part of was serving aboard the crew of ''Archimedes'' at the U.S.S. ''Shenzhou''.time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 24 (click to see context) from:
* YouCantGoHomeAgain: Georgiou offers to take Saru away from his homeworld, but if he accepts, he can never come back again due to the dictates of the PrimeDirective.
to:
* YouCantGoHomeAgain: Georgiou offers to take Saru away from his homeworld, but if he accepts, he can never come back again due to the dictates of the PrimeDirective.PrimeDirective.
----
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5,7 (click to see context) from:
* AlienNonInterferenceClause: As Lieutenant Georgiou explains, the PrimeDirective prevents Starfleet from interfering with a pre-warp society. As a rule, such cultures are not typically successful at initiating FirstContact.
* TheEngineer[=/=]GadgeteerGenius: Saru proves to be quite clever, studying the lost bit of Ba'ul technology to create a communications beacon, which he uses to make FirstContact with the Federation.
* ForegoneConclusion: We already knew from the first season of ''Discovery'' that Saru left his homeworld to join Starfleet. What we didn't know is ''why'', or that he's not allowed to ever return home or communicate with his people again thanks to the PrimeDirective.
* TheEngineer[=/=]GadgeteerGenius: Saru proves to be quite clever, studying the lost bit of Ba'ul technology to create a communications beacon, which he uses to make FirstContact with the Federation.
* ForegoneConclusion: We already knew from the first season of ''Discovery'' that Saru left his homeworld to join Starfleet. What we didn't know is ''why'', or that he's not allowed to ever return home or communicate with his people again thanks to the PrimeDirective.
to:
* AlienNonInterferenceClause: As Lieutenant Georgiou explains, the PrimeDirective Prime Directive prevents Starfleet from interfering with a pre-warp society. As a rule, such cultures are not typically successful at initiating FirstContact.
*TheEngineer[=/=]GadgeteerGenius: TheEngineer: Saru proves to be quite clever, studying the lost bit of Ba'ul technology to create a communications beacon, which he uses to make FirstContact with the Federation.
* ForegoneConclusion: We already knew from the first season of ''Discovery'' that Saru left his homeworld to join Starfleet. What we didn't know is ''why'', or that he's not allowed to ever return home or communicate with his people again thanks to thePrimeDirective.Prime Directive.
*
* ForegoneConclusion: We already knew from the first season of ''Discovery'' that Saru left his homeworld to join Starfleet. What we didn't know is ''why'', or that he's not allowed to ever return home or communicate with his people again thanks to the
* GadgeteerGenius: Saru manages to at least partially disassemble the piece of Ba'ul technology and get it working as an interstellar transmitter[[note]](even though it seems to already ''be'' a transmitter to begin with)[[/note]].
Changed line(s) 12 (click to see context) from:
* MeaningfulName: The Kelpiens spend much of their time on Kaminar harvesting kelp.
to:
* MeaningfulName: The Kelpiens (or at least those we see) spend much of their time on Kaminar harvesting kelp.
Changed line(s) 14 (click to see context) from:
* MissingMom: Saru, his father and his sister appear in the episode, but no mention or appearance is made of Saru's mother. Given the nature of the Kelpiens' arrangement with the Ba'ul, she may well have been sacrificed some time before when the episode is set.
to:
* MissingMom: Saru, his father (Aradar) and his sister (Siranna) appear in the episode, but no mention or appearance is made of Saru's mother. Given the nature of the Kelpiens' arrangement with the Ba'ul, she may well have been sacrificed some time before when the episode is set.
Changed line(s) 16 (click to see context) from:
* TheReveal: The person Saru has been communicating with is Lieutenant Philippa Georgiou, Saru's future captain aboard the ''Shenzhou''.
to:
* TheReveal: The person Saru has been communicating with is Lieutenant Philippa Georgiou, Saru's future captain aboard the U.S.S. ''Shenzhou''.
Changed line(s) 18 (click to see context) from:
* StrictParentsMakeSneakyKids: Saru's father is one of the village priests, so naturally Saru manages to conceal his beacon inside their home.
to:
* StrictParentsMakeSneakyKids: Saru's father is one of the village priests, so naturally naturally, Saru manages to conceal his beacon inside their home.
Changed line(s) 20 (click to see context) from:
** Georgiou never makes any mention of what ship she serves on at the time.
to:
** Georgiou never makes any mention of directly mentions what ship she serves on at the time.time, but given that the shuttle she arrives and departs in is designated "SHN 03", it's likely that she is already part of the crew of the U.S.S. ''Shenzhou''.
Changed line(s) 22 (click to see context) from:
** The Ba'ul never appear in person, nor is it ever explained why or exactly how they take Kelpiens from Kaminar (or for what purpose).
to:
** The Ba'ul [[TheGhost never appear in person, person]], nor is it ever truly explained or confirmed why or exactly how they take the Kelpiens from Kaminar (or away, or for what purpose).purpose. We only have Saru's word that the Kelpiens are a "prey species".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* {{Irony}}: In this episode, we see Saru being one of the boldest and most inquisitive Kelpiens among his society. Even so, by the time he is a senior officer during the first season of ''Discovery'', he is still one of the most cautious Starfleet officers portrayed in ''Star Trek''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
** The Ba'ul never appear in person, nor is it ever explained why or exactly how they take Kelpiens from Kaminar (or for what purpose).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No spoiler-tagging in recap pages, as per Spoilers Off.
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
We learn the story of how Saru first came into contact with Starfleet. The son of a village priest, Saru is uneasy with the arrangement his people have with the Ba'ul, namely that in return for the Ba'ul not hunting the Kelpians, an offering of Kelpians is made as sacrifice. Saru wonders if there might be someone out there other than the Ba'ul that he can try to reach when a piece of advanced technology falls from a Ba'ul ship during one of their visits.
to:
We learn the story of how Saru first came into contact with Starfleet. The son of a village priest, Saru is uneasy with the arrangement his people have with the Ba'ul, namely that in return for the Ba'ul not hunting the Kelpians, an offering Kelpiens, regular offerings of Kelpians is Kelpiens are made as sacrifice. Saru wonders if there might be someone out there other than the Ba'ul that he can try to reach Ba'ul, and when a piece of advanced technology falls from a visiting Ba'ul ship during one of their visits.ship, he tries to reach anyone he can by building a transmitter.
Changed line(s) 5,9 (click to see context) from:
* AlienNonInterferenceClause: As [[spoiler: Lieutenant Georgiou]] explains, the Prime Directive prevents Starfleet from interfering with a pre-warp society. As a rule, such cultures are not typically successful at initiating FirstContact.
* TheEngineer: Saru proves to be quite clever, studying the lost bit of Ba'ul technology to create a communications beacon, which he uses to make FirstContact with the Federation.
* ForegoneConclusion: We already know Saru will leave his homeworld and join Starfleet. What we don't know is the details [[spoiler: or that he's not allowed to ever return home or communicate with his people again.]]
* FirstContact: Saru manages to initiate this with the Federation, despite being from a world without warp travel. [[spoiler: The latter detail causes complications for Starfleet when they have to decide what to do about it.]]
* HumanResources: The Kelpian villages are PeopleFarms for the Ba'ul. They live freely enough, but from time to time a selection of them are volunteered as tribute as part of some agreement.
* TheEngineer: Saru proves to be quite clever, studying the lost bit of Ba'ul technology to create a communications beacon, which he uses to make FirstContact with the Federation.
* ForegoneConclusion: We already know Saru will leave his homeworld and join Starfleet. What we don't know is the details [[spoiler: or that he's not allowed to ever return home or communicate with his people again.]]
* FirstContact: Saru manages to initiate this with the Federation, despite being from a world without warp travel. [[spoiler: The latter detail causes complications for Starfleet when they have to decide what to do about it.]]
* HumanResources: The Kelpian villages are PeopleFarms for the Ba'ul. They live freely enough, but from time to time a selection of them are volunteered as tribute as part of some agreement.
to:
* AlienNonInterferenceClause: As [[spoiler: Lieutenant Georgiou]] Georgiou explains, the Prime Directive PrimeDirective prevents Starfleet from interfering with a pre-warp society. As a rule, such cultures are not typically successful at initiating FirstContact.
*TheEngineer: TheEngineer[=/=]GadgeteerGenius: Saru proves to be quite clever, studying the lost bit of Ba'ul technology to create a communications beacon, which he uses to make FirstContact with the Federation.
* ForegoneConclusion: We alreadyknow knew from the first season of ''Discovery'' that Saru will leave left his homeworld and to join Starfleet. What we don't didn't know is the details [[spoiler: ''why'', or that he's not allowed to ever return home or communicate with his people again.]]
again thanks to the PrimeDirective.
* FirstContact: Saru manages to initiate this with the Federation, despite being from a world without warp travel.[[spoiler: The latter detail causes complications for Starfleet when they have to decide what to do about it.]]
it.
* HumanResources: TheKelpian Kelpien villages on Kaminar are PeopleFarms for the Ba'ul. They The Kelpiens live freely enough, but from time to time a selection of them are volunteered as tribute as part of some agreement.
*
* ForegoneConclusion: We already
* FirstContact: Saru manages to initiate this with the Federation, despite being from a world without warp travel.
* HumanResources: The
Changed line(s) 11 (click to see context) from:
* TheReveal: The person Saru has been communicating with is [[spoiler: Lieutenant Philippa Georgiou, Saru's future captain.]]
to:
* MeaningfulName: The Kelpiens spend much of their time on Kaminar harvesting kelp.
* TheMentor: This episode shows how Georgiou first met Saru.
* MissingMom: Saru, his father and his sister appear in the episode, but no mention or appearance is made of Saru's mother. Given the nature of the Kelpiens' arrangement with the Ba'ul, she may well have been sacrificed some time before when the episode is set.
* RankUp: Inverted. Since this episode is set years or even decades before the first season of ''Discovery'', Philippa Georgiou is still a lieutenant, while Saru is a young civilian who has yet to enter Starfleet Academy.
* TheReveal: The person Saru has been communicating with is[[spoiler: Lieutenant Philippa Georgiou, Saru's future captain.]]captain aboard the ''Shenzhou''.
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Played with; Georgiou mentions how hard she had to lobby for an exception to be made in the PrimeDirective for Saru (and Saru alone) to be contacted and allowed to leave Kaminar.
* TheMentor: This episode shows how Georgiou first met Saru.
* MissingMom: Saru, his father and his sister appear in the episode, but no mention or appearance is made of Saru's mother. Given the nature of the Kelpiens' arrangement with the Ba'ul, she may well have been sacrificed some time before when the episode is set.
* RankUp: Inverted. Since this episode is set years or even decades before the first season of ''Discovery'', Philippa Georgiou is still a lieutenant, while Saru is a young civilian who has yet to enter Starfleet Academy.
* TheReveal: The person Saru has been communicating with is
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Played with; Georgiou mentions how hard she had to lobby for an exception to be made in the PrimeDirective for Saru (and Saru alone) to be contacted and allowed to leave Kaminar.
Changed line(s) 13 (click to see context) from:
* YouCantGoHomeAgain: [[spoiler: Georgiou]] offers to take Saru off of his homeworld, but he can never come back again if he does.
to:
* TheUnreveal:
** Georgiou never makes any mention of what ship she serves on at the time.
** [[MissingMom Saru's mother]] never appears or is mentioned, but given the ongoing arrangement with the Ba'ul, it's likely that she was among a past group who were sacrificed.
* YouCantGoHomeAgain:[[spoiler: Georgiou]] Georgiou offers to take Saru off of away from his homeworld, but if he accepts, he can never come back again if he does.due to the dictates of the PrimeDirective.
** Georgiou never makes any mention of what ship she serves on at the time.
** [[MissingMom Saru's mother]] never appears or is mentioned, but given the ongoing arrangement with the Ba'ul, it's likely that she was among a past group who were sacrificed.
* YouCantGoHomeAgain:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 6,7 (click to see context) :
* ImportedAlienPhlebotinum: Saru's father collects a piece of something that falls from the Ba'ul ship during an offering, and orders Saru to dispose of it. Naturally, Saru does nothing of the sort.
* StrictParentsMakeSneakyKids: Saru's father is one of the village priests, so naturally Saru manages to conceal his beacon inside their home.
* StrictParentsMakeSneakyKids: Saru's father is one of the village priests, so naturally Saru manages to conceal his beacon inside their home.
Added DiffLines:
* ImportedAlienPhlebotinum: Saru's father collects a piece of something that falls from the Ba'ul ship during an offering, and orders Saru to dispose of it. Naturally, Saru does nothing of the sort.
Added DiffLines:
* StrictParentsMakeSneakyKids: Saru's father is one of the village priests, so naturally Saru manages to conceal his beacon inside their home.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 10 (click to see context) from:
* FirstContact: Saru manages to initiate this with the Federation, despite being from a world without warp travel. This causes complications for Starfleet when they have to decide what to do about it.
to:
* FirstContact: Saru manages to initiate this with the Federation, despite being from a world without warp travel. This [[spoiler: The latter detail causes complications for Starfleet when they have to decide what to do about it.]]
* HumanResources: The Kelpian villages are PeopleFarms for the Ba'ul. They live freely enough, but from time to time a selection of them are volunteered as tribute as part of some agreement.
* HumanResources: The Kelpian villages are PeopleFarms for the Ba'ul. They live freely enough, but from time to time a selection of them are volunteered as tribute as part of some agreement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
* ImportedAlienPhlebotinum: Saru's father collects a piece of something that falls from the Ba'ul ship during an offering, and orders Saru to dispose of it. Naturally, Saru does nothing of the sort.
to:
* AlienNonInterferenceClause: As [[spoiler: Lieutenant Georgiou]] explains, the Prime Directive prevents Starfleet from interfering with a pre-warp society. As a rule, such cultures are not typically successful at initiating FirstContact.
* ImportedAlienPhlebotinum: Saru's father collects a piece of something that falls from the Ba'ul ship during an offering, and orders Saru to dispose of it. Naturally, Saru does nothing of thesort.sort.
* StrictParentsMakeSneakyKids: Saru's father is one of the village priests, so naturally Saru manages to conceal his beacon inside their home.
* TheEngineer: Saru proves to be quite clever, studying the lost bit of Ba'ul technology to create a communications beacon, which he uses to make FirstContact with the Federation.
* ForegoneConclusion: We already know Saru will leave his homeworld and join Starfleet. What we don't know is the details [[spoiler: or that he's not allowed to ever return home or communicate with his people again.]]
* FirstContact: Saru manages to initiate this with the Federation, despite being from a world without warp travel. This causes complications for Starfleet when they have to decide what to do about it.
* TheReveal: The person Saru has been communicating with is [[spoiler: Lieutenant Philippa Georgiou, Saru's future captain.]]
* YouCantGoHomeAgain: [[spoiler: Georgiou]] offers to take Saru off of his homeworld, but he can never come back again if he does.
* ImportedAlienPhlebotinum: Saru's father collects a piece of something that falls from the Ba'ul ship during an offering, and orders Saru to dispose of it. Naturally, Saru does nothing of the
* StrictParentsMakeSneakyKids: Saru's father is one of the village priests, so naturally Saru manages to conceal his beacon inside their home.
* TheEngineer: Saru proves to be quite clever, studying the lost bit of Ba'ul technology to create a communications beacon, which he uses to make FirstContact with the Federation.
* ForegoneConclusion: We already know Saru will leave his homeworld and join Starfleet. What we don't know is the details [[spoiler: or that he's not allowed to ever return home or communicate with his people again.]]
* FirstContact: Saru manages to initiate this with the Federation, despite being from a world without warp travel. This causes complications for Starfleet when they have to decide what to do about it.
* TheReveal: The person Saru has been communicating with is [[spoiler: Lieutenant Philippa Georgiou, Saru's future captain.]]
* YouCantGoHomeAgain: [[spoiler: Georgiou]] offers to take Saru off of his homeworld, but he can never come back again if he does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
We learn the story of how Saru first came into contact with Starfleet. The son of a village priest, Saru is uneasy with the arrangement his people have with the Ba'ul, namely that in return for the Ba'ul not hunting the Kelpians, an offering of Kelpians is made as sacrifice. Saru wonders if there might be someone out there other than the Ba'ul that he can try to reach when a piece of advanced technology falls from a Ba'ul ship during one of their visits.
!!Tropes
* ImportedAlienPhlebotinum: Saru's father collects a piece of something that falls from the Ba'ul ship during an offering, and orders Saru to dispose of it. Naturally, Saru does nothing of the sort.
!!Tropes
* ImportedAlienPhlebotinum: Saru's father collects a piece of something that falls from the Ba'ul ship during an offering, and orders Saru to dispose of it. Naturally, Saru does nothing of the sort.