Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS02E24TheCollaborator

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BaitAndSwitchComment: Kira says that if she had known Vedek Winn was on the station she would have told Odo to increase security. When Winn assures her she feels perfectly safe, Kira says she wasn't referring to her, and makes an unsubtle reference to Winn's attempt to have Bariel assassinated by a fanatical follower.
* CallBack: When meeting Winn, both Kira and Sisko makes a pointed reference to the events of [[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS01E20InTheHandsOfTheProphets "In The Hands Of The Prophets"]].

to:

* BaitAndSwitchComment: Kira says that if she had known Vedek Winn was on the station she would have told Odo to increase security. When Winn assures her she feels perfectly safe, Kira says she wasn't referring to her, and makes an unsubtle reference to Winn's attempt to have a not-so-subtle mention of the attempted assassination of Bariel assassinated by a fanatical follower.
follower of Winn.
* CallBack: When meeting Winn, both Kira and Sisko makes a make pointed reference to the events of [[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS01E20InTheHandsOfTheProphets "In The Hands Of The Prophets"]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BaitAndSwitchComment: Kira says that if she had known Vedek Winn was on the station she would have told Odo to increase security. When Winn assures her she feels perfectly safe, Kira makes a pointed reference to Winn's attempt to have Bariel assassinated by a fanatical follower.

to:

* BaitAndSwitchComment: Kira says that if she had known Vedek Winn was on the station she would have told Odo to increase security. When Winn assures her she feels perfectly safe, Kira says she wasn't referring to her, and makes a pointed an unsubtle reference to Winn's attempt to have Bariel assassinated by a fanatical follower.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BaitAndSwitchComment: Kira says that if she had known Vedek Winn was on the station she would have told Odo to increase security. When Winn assures her she feels perfectly safe, Kira makes a pointed reference to Winn's attempt to have Bariel assassinated by a fanatical follower.
* CallBack: When meeting Winn, both Kira and Sisko makes a pointed reference to the events of [[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS01E20InTheHandsOfTheProphets "In The Hands Of The Prophets"]].


Added DiffLines:

* ManipulativeBitch: Winn wins again. She gets Kubus to return to Bajor by offering [[SeekingSanctuary sanctuary]], gets his allegations investigated by people who have no connection to her, then forces Bariel to pull out of the race, achieving the same goal she wanted at the end of Season One without even having to kill him.

Added: 418

Changed: 269

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Foreshadowing}}: When Kira expresses her feelings for Bareil to Odo, his body language betrays his shock, although he quickly covers himself by claiming he already knew. This is the first time we've gotten any indication that Odo's own feelings toward her aren't strictly professional.

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: {{Foreshadowing}}:
**
When Kira expresses her feelings for Bareil to Odo, his body language betrays his shock, although he quickly covers himself by claiming he already knew. This is the first time we've gotten any indication that Odo's own feelings toward her aren't strictly professional.professional.
** Odo observes to Kira that, in extreme situations, even the best of humanoids are capable of terrible things. Boy, is he proven right by the end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HiddenDisdainReveal: When Odo sardonically notes that Gul Dukat called Kubus "his favorite Bajoran," Kubas snaps "I never could stand that arrogant tyrant."

to:

* HiddenDisdainReveal: When Odo sardonically notes that Gul Dukat called Kubus "his favorite Bajoran," Kubas Kubus snaps "I never could stand that arrogant tyrant."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DownerEnding: Bariel thinks preserving the good memory of Kai Opaka is worth letting the blackhearted SmugSnake Winn become her successor, but Kira clearly disagrees, but still has to suck it up, smile at that treacherous backstabber and pay her respects.

to:

* DownerEnding: Bariel thinks preserving the good memory of Kai Opaka is worth letting the blackhearted SmugSnake Winn become her successor, but successor. Kira clearly disagrees, but still has to suck it up, smile at that treacherous backstabber SmugSnake and pay her respects.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BackhandedCompliment: Winn has a biting one when Bareil offers a different viewpoint on whether the Prophets' love is conditional or not. She thanks him in her usual saccharine way for reminding everyone how easy it is to misinterpret prophecy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ThePowerOfLegacy: Bareil believes that it is more important that the Bajoran people's belief Kai Opaka remain unshakable and unblemished by a scandal than to prevent a politically-motivated rival from becoming her SuckSessor.

to:

* ThePowerOfLegacy: Bareil believes that it is more important that the Bajoran people's belief Kai Opaka remain unshakable and unblemished by a scandal than to prevent a politically-motivated rival from becoming her SuckSessor.



* RebuiltPedestal: Once she realizes why Bareil did it, she admires his willingness to sacrifice his own good name for the greater good.

to:

* RebuiltPedestal: Once she realizes why Bareil did it, she Kira admires his willingness to sacrifice his own good name for the greater good.

Added: 687

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAlibi: Comes out too late, but Bareil had an ironclad alibi - transit logs show he was secluded in a monastery for ''weeks'' before the massacre, and the only communication log from that monastery during that time was ''after'' the massacre occurred. Bareil either forgot to erase them, or did not have access to them.



* DownerEnding: Bariel thinks preserving the good memory of Kai Opaka is worth letting the blackhearted SmugSnake Winn become her successor, but Kira clearly disagrees, but still has to suck it up to, smile at that treacherous backstabber and pay her respects.

to:

* DownerEnding: Bariel thinks preserving the good memory of Kai Opaka is worth letting the blackhearted SmugSnake Winn become her successor, but Kira clearly disagrees, but still has to suck it up to, up, smile at that treacherous backstabber and pay her respects.


Added DiffLines:

* ThePowerOfLegacy: Bareil believes that it is more important that the Bajoran people's belief Kai Opaka remain unshakable and unblemished by a scandal than to prevent a politically-motivated rival from becoming her SuckSessor.


Added DiffLines:

* RebuiltPedestal: Once she realizes why Bareil did it, she admires his willingness to sacrifice his own good name for the greater good.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DownerEnding: Bariel thinks preserving the good memory of Kai Opaka is worth letting the blackhearted SmugSnake Winn become her successor, but Kira clearly disagrees, but still has to suck it up to, smile at that treacherous backstabber and pay her respects.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: When Kira expresses her feelings for Bareil to Odo, his body language betrays his shock, although he quickly covers himself by claiming he already knew. This is the first time we've gotten any indication that Odo's own feelings toward her aren't strictly professional.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HonorBeforeReason: Bareil's actions provide a rare example of someone not upholding his own honor; instead, he protects Opaka's by TakingTheHeat for the massacre, even if that ensures that Winn becomes Kai.

Added: 295

Changed: 157

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheNeedsOfTheMany: Between 43 resistance members and ''1200'' innocent villagers, Kai Opaka made the hard choice—''especially'' hard, given that one of the former was her son.

to:

* TheNeedsOfTheMany: TheNeedsOfTheMany:
**
Between 43 resistance members and ''1200'' innocent villagers, Kai Opaka made the hard choice—''especially'' choice -- ''especially'' hard, given that one of the former was her son.son.
** This also applies to Bareil TakingTheHeat for Opaka, as he decides that her legacy is more important to Bajor than his reputation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PersonaNonGrata: Under the law following the Cardassian withdrawl, any Bajoran who collaborated with the Cardassians is exiled from the homeworld.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Between accusations and not so veiled contempt between her and Kira, an old Bajoran enters the stations, harmlessly bumping into another. He waves it off for a moment, but then notices the man. He's not just any Bajoran. He's Kubus Oak, former Cardassian collaborator during the occupation.

to:

Between accusations and not so veiled contempt between her and Kira, an old Bajoran enters the stations, station, harmlessly bumping into another. He waves it off for a moment, but then notices the man. He's not just any Bajoran. He's Kubus Oak, former Cardassian collaborator during the occupation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PassiveAggressiveKombat: The first meeting between Winn and Bariel is absolutely covered in this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HiddenDisdainReveal: When Odo sardonically notes that Gul Dukat called Kubus "his favorite Bajoran," Kubas snaps "I never could stand that arrogant tyrant."
-->'''Odo''': You hid your feelings well.
-->'''Kubus''': It kept me alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* AsYouKnow: Kira describes the Kendra Valley Massacre to Odo, ending with "You were here, you must have read [the suicide note]."

Added: 195

Removed: 195

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LesCollaborateurs: Several Bajorans worked for the Cardassian government during the occupation. Their punishment for this is permanent exile from Bajor. Kira thinks that's ''way'' too generous.



* LesCollaborateurs: Several Bajorans worked for the Cardassian government during the occupation. Their punishment for this is permanent exile from Bajor. Kira thinks that's ''way'' too generous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TooDumbToLive: Kai Opaka knew the location of the resistance base because her son was a member. The logical conclusion is that her son told her of his whereabouts, which is a huge no-no when fighting a guerrilla war.

to:

* TooDumbToLive: Kai Opaka knew the location of the resistance base because her son was a member. The logical conclusion is that her son told her of his whereabouts, which is a huge no-no when fighting a guerrilla war.war.
* UndyingLoyalty: Bareil to Opaka, so much that he takes the fall to preserve her legacy.

Added: 218

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Rule of Acquisition #258.

to:

* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Rule of Acquisition #258.#285.



* TakingTheHeat: Prylar Bek and Vedek Bareil both do this to protect Kai Opaka - Bek because he was already a collaborator, and Bareil to preserve Opaka's memory as unblemished.

to:

* TakingTheHeat: Prylar Bek and Vedek Bareil both do this to protect Kai Opaka - Bek because he was already a collaborator, and Bareil to preserve Opaka's memory as unblemished.unblemished.
* TooDumbToLive: Kai Opaka knew the location of the resistance base because her son was a member. The logical conclusion is that her son told her of his whereabouts, which is a huge no-no when fighting a guerrilla war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheQuisling: Subverted, ironically enough. Everyone involved in collaboration either claimed or actually were trying to save Bajoran lives.

to:

* TheQuisling: Subverted, ironically enough. Everyone involved in collaboration either claimed claim to be or actually were trying to save Bajoran lives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheNeedsOfTheMany: Between 43 resistance members and ''1200'' innocent villagers, Kai Opaka made the hard choice - especially hard given that one of them was her son.

to:

* TheNeedsOfTheMany: Between 43 resistance members and ''1200'' innocent villagers, Kai Opaka made the hard choice - especially hard choice—''especially'' hard, given that one of them the former was her son.

Added: 449

Changed: 122

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* IDidWhatIHadToDo: How Kubus lives with his actions working for the Cardassians.

to:

* TheExile: Many Bajorans who collaborated with the Cardassians fled with them to Cardassia Prime.
* IDidWhatIHadToDo: How Kubus lives with his actions working for the Cardassians. Notably, he clearly is just hanging onto this rationalization.


Added DiffLines:

* TheQuisling: Subverted, ironically enough. Everyone involved in collaboration either claimed or actually were trying to save Bajoran lives.
** Kubus is, arguably, a {{Downplayed}} example of this as he's clearly grief stricken and remorseful about his actions. None of this matters to Major Kira, though.

Added: 177

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheNeedsOfTheMany: Between 43 resistance members and ''1200'' innocent villains, Kai Opaka made the hard choice - especially hard given that one of them was her son.
* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Rule of Acquisition #258.

to:

* TheNeedsOfTheMany: Between 43 resistance members and ''1200'' innocent villains, villagers, Kai Opaka made the hard choice - especially hard given that one of them was her son.
* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Rule of Acquisition #258.#258.
* TakingTheHeat: Prylar Bek and Vedek Bareil both do this to protect Kai Opaka - Bek because he was already a collaborator, and Bareil to preserve Opaka's memory as unblemished.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheNeedsOfTheMany: Between 43 resistance members and ''1200'' innocent villains, Kai Opaka made the hard choice.

to:

* TheNeedsOfTheMany: Between 43 resistance members and ''1200'' innocent villains, Kai Opaka made the hard choice.choice - especially hard given that one of them was her son.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


She's not done causing people misery just yet. As Kira finds out when Kobus Oak tries leaving on a ship for Bajor. Turns out Winn has granted the traitorous Bajoran sanctuary. Heading for Odo's office, she finds out Winn spent ten minutes talking with Kobus before accessing something on Odo's console.

That something was information on the Kendra Valley Massacre, the death of 42 Bajoran resistance members when a collaborator named Prylar Bek sold them out. Winn saunters into the office again, asking to speak to Kira alone.

Kira is of course pissed about her offering a collaborator sanctuary. Well, the shifty Vedek has her reasons. Kobus has given her the name of the collaborator who caused the Kendra Valley Massacre. Turns out it wasn't Prylar Bek after all. The traitor is none other than ''Vedek Bareil''.

Kira naturally doesn't buy a word of this. Between a traitor like Kobus and a snake like Winn, she has little reason to. The two strike a tentative deal. Kira will investigate these claims, and she'll report her findings to Winn.

to:

She's not done causing people misery just yet. As Kira finds out when Kobus Kubus Oak tries leaving on a ship for Bajor. Turns out Winn has granted the traitorous Bajoran sanctuary. Heading for Odo's office, she finds out Winn spent ten minutes talking with Kobus Kubus before accessing something on Odo's console.

That something was information on the Kendra Valley Massacre, the death of 42 43 Bajoran resistance members members, including the son of Kai Opaka, when a collaborator named Prylar Bek sold them out. Winn saunters into the office again, asking to speak to Kira alone.

Kira is of course pissed about her offering a collaborator sanctuary. Well, the shifty Vedek has her reasons. Kobus Kubus has given her the name of the collaborator who caused the Kendra Valley Massacre. Turns out it wasn't Prylar Bek after all. The traitor is none other than ''Vedek Bareil''.

Kira naturally doesn't buy a word of this. Between a traitor like Kobus Kubus and a snake like Winn, she has little reason to. The two strike a tentative deal. Kira will investigate these claims, and she'll report her findings to Winn.



It's time to confront Bareil over this. With as much reluctance as can be expected, he reveals why he sold the resistance out. It was either sacrifice 42 resistance members, or let 1200 civilians perish.

to:

It's time to confront Bareil over this. With as much reluctance as can be expected, he reveals why he sold the resistance out. It was either sacrifice 42 43 resistance members, or let 1200 civilians perish.



* TheNeedsOfTheMany: Between 42 resistance members and ''1200'' innocent villains, Kai Opaka made the hard choice.

to:

* TheNeedsOfTheMany: Between 42 43 resistance members and ''1200'' innocent villains, Kai Opaka made the hard choice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LesCollaborateurs: Several Bajorans worked for the Cardassian government during the occupation. Their punishment for this is permanent exile from Bajor. Kira thinks that's ''way'' to generous.

to:

* LesCollaborateurs: Several Bajorans worked for the Cardassian government during the occupation. Their punishment for this is permanent exile from Bajor. Kira thinks that's ''way'' to too generous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixed redlink


And since Bareil is on DS9, that means a certain slimy Bajoran is hot on his heels as usual. Yes, Vedek Winn is back again. And no one around the station is thrilled about it.

to:

And since Bareil is on DS9, [=DS9=], that means a certain slimy Bajoran is hot on his heels as usual. Yes, Vedek Winn is back again. And no one around the station is thrilled about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

The elections for Kai are just around the corner. And Kira and Vedek Bareil have been spending the time as expected: Banging each others brains out.

And since Bareil is on DS9, that means a certain slimy Bajoran is hot on his heels as usual. Yes, Vedek Winn is back again. And no one around the station is thrilled about it.

Between accusations and not so veiled contempt between her and Kira, an old Bajoran enters the stations, harmlessly bumping into another. He waves it off for a moment, but then notices the man. He's not just any Bajoran. He's Kubus Oak, former Cardassian collaborator during the occupation.

A burgeoning lynch mob of Bajorans surrounds the man before Odo steps in. And instantly places him under arrest. As he's dragged off, he catches the eye of a nearby Vedek Winn.

Locked inside a cell, Kubus tries defending his actions as a traitor. Claiming the situation on Bajor would have been even worse without the collaborators. He also tries using his age, claiming there's no harm in letting an old man live his final years on his home world.

That's when Kira comes in. Slapping down every excuse he tries. His name is number ''four'' on the banishment order named the Ilvian Proclamation. She also reminds him of his clerical work. Effectively signing death warrants when he sent Bajorans to die in the ore processing mines.

Vedek Winn meanwhile is doing her usual thing. Namely trying to get Sisko to speak with her at the Vedek Assembly. Sisko is smarter than that, knowing this is just a ploy to try and sway votes in the coming election.

She's not done causing people misery just yet. As Kira finds out when Kobus Oak tries leaving on a ship for Bajor. Turns out Winn has granted the traitorous Bajoran sanctuary. Heading for Odo's office, she finds out Winn spent ten minutes talking with Kobus before accessing something on Odo's console.

That something was information on the Kendra Valley Massacre, the death of 42 Bajoran resistance members when a collaborator named Prylar Bek sold them out. Winn saunters into the office again, asking to speak to Kira alone.

Kira is of course pissed about her offering a collaborator sanctuary. Well, the shifty Vedek has her reasons. Kobus has given her the name of the collaborator who caused the Kendra Valley Massacre. Turns out it wasn't Prylar Bek after all. The traitor is none other than ''Vedek Bareil''.

Kira naturally doesn't buy a word of this. Between a traitor like Kobus and a snake like Winn, she has little reason to. The two strike a tentative deal. Kira will investigate these claims, and she'll report her findings to Winn.

Questioning Kubus in the cargo bay, he claims Bek was just a simple messenger between the Cardassians and the Vedek Assembly. In the time leading up the massacre, Bek became panicked and erratic. Along with being in constant communication with a then-unknown source within the Assembly.

The day after the massacre, however, Vedek Bareil visited Bek for several hours, during which time Kubus could hear shouting coming from Bek's quarters. Bek hanged himself on the Promenade shortly thereafter. Based on this, Kubus believes that Bek wanted to confess his betrayal but Bareil forbid him to do so which led to his suicide, a theory Kira regards as incredible.

Kira insists there could be any number of explanations for this. And Winn informs her it's her job to find out.

Kira contacts Bareil, who admits coming to the station to meet with Bek on the day in question. While he denies any involvement in the massacre and seems sure Winn will not be able to prove anything, Bareil cannot reveal what he and Bek talked about due to confidentiality between monks and their Vedeks.

She tries going for Cardassian logs next, but the communications between them and the Bajorans were wiped during the withdrawal. Odo accesses the Bajoran Central Archives for any more info. And info he finds. Specifically, the records between Prylar Bek and the Assembly for the week prior to the Kendra Valley Massacre have been sealed.

And the security seal placed on them could only come from a Vedek. And when there's possible illegal data to obtain, there's only one person to go to: Quark.

Quark rather reluctantly assists the two of them. But there's not much to show for it. The file has been blanked. With some assistance from O'Brien next, Kira searches for any shred of data leftover. He's got one thing: Tidbits of residual data from a retinal scan.

This is pay-dirt. Piecing it together, the eraser of the logs is revealed: Vedek Bareil.

It's time to confront Bareil over this. With as much reluctance as can be expected, he reveals why he sold the resistance out. It was either sacrifice 42 resistance members, or let 1200 civilians perish.

Kira relays this information to Winn. But she knows already, due to Bareil withdrawing from the choosing. But something about the situation is still irking Kira.

With Bareil out of the running, the expected happens. Vedek Winn becomes ''Kai'' Winn. After some hollow platitude from Winn, Kira confronts Bareil with new evidence. Namely, the transit files he forgot to erase. He was stowed away in a monastery in the weeks leading up to the massacre. And there's only one transmission log. Made a week ''after'' the incident.

Bareil took the fall for the real collaborator. The one person who he cares for more than Kira. The true collaborator in the massacre was none other than ''Kai Opaka''.

Her faith in Bareil renewed, the two of them walk away together to go pay their respects to the new Kai.
----
* TheBadGuyWins: Treacherous, backstabbing and manipulative Vedek Winn becomes the new Kai.
* IDidWhatIHadToDo: How Kubus lives with his actions working for the Cardassians.
* LesCollaborateurs: Several Bajorans worked for the Cardassian government during the occupation. Their punishment for this is permanent exile from Bajor. Kira thinks that's ''way'' to generous.
* TheNeedsOfTheMany: Between 42 resistance members and ''1200'' innocent villains, Kai Opaka made the hard choice.
* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Rule of Acquisition #258.

Top