Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ReasonableAuthorityFigure / LiveActionFilms

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/WereNoAngels'' (1989): In contrast to the warden, the sheriff is a competent but compassionate lawman. He takes the hunt for the escaped convicts seriously, but he's reluctant to harass the townspeople during the search and [[spoiler:allows a wounded Bobby to see a priest.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** See the Comic Books folder for another example.

to:

*** See the Comic Books folder for another example.more examples.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** See the Comic Books folder for another example.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Fillm/RapTheWildWind'':

to:

* ''Fillm/RapTheWildWind'': ''Fillm/ReapTheWildWind'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fillm/RapTheWildWind'':
** Judge Marvin runs a tough but fair courtroom. He is considerate of people's feelings, but values truth and justice more. He also will only allow delays and continuances under reasonable circumstances, but is unhappy when a lack of reasonable circumstances threaten to let Cutler and [[spoiler:Jack]] escape justice.
** Downplayed with Commodore Devereaux and his board members (save Steve, who plays it straighter). They wrongly blame Jack for the loss of the ''Jubilee''. When Steve makes a strong argument that Jack is innocent, they agree to promote Jack if his innocence is proven, although they also refuse to tell Jack that they're giving him a second chance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/RedRockWest:'' Deputy Matt Greytack recognizes Michael has no reason to kill Kurt ''and'' try to save his life. He quickly discovers the sheriff's embezzlement scam and catches onto Lyle's WeNeedADistraction scheme just as fast. Unfortunately, he's just not fast enough to catch anyone until the chaos has already settled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/{{Traffic}}'': Wakefield's processor on the anti-drugs task force, General Landry. He's done a lot of good work, but is open about believing that his actions have had no lasting impact. He's willing to give some advice to his successor, while offering himself up as a {{Scapegoat}} in the event that's necessary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Lord Humungus from ''Film/MadMax2TheRoadWarrior'' is a villainous example. Unlike every other villain up to that point, he is only after the oil rig and is perfectly willing to let the tribe leave peacefully instead of massacring them.
** He tells his underling "The gasoline will be ours. Then, you shall have your revenge." implying that he plans on betraying and massacring the tribe the second they leave their defenses.

to:

* Lord Humungus from ''Film/MadMax2TheRoadWarrior'' is (possibly) a villainous example. Unlike every other villain up to that point, he is only after the oil rig and says he is perfectly willing to let the Papagallo's tribe leave peacefully instead of massacring them.
if they let him have the refinery.
** He tells does tell his underling [[TheDragon leading henchman]] Wez "The gasoline will be ours. Then, you shall have your revenge." ", implying that he plans on betraying and massacring the tribe the second they leave their defenses.defenses, but it is not clear whether he means it or is just trying to calm his AxCrazy underling.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/TheSapphires'': The leader of the soldiers escorting the band says that if it was his call, he would stay with them all the way through the tour rather than have them journey alone at times. He also gives them his sidearm for protection after they part ways.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added unknown

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Film/Unknown2011'', Herr Strauss and some of the senior cops. When Martin is trying to persuade them that he really is Martin, and that the other Martin is an imposter, they give him every chance to prove his claim, and try to verify what they can. They review CCTV, check immigration records, and his university website. They're remarkably sympathetic and reasonable to what appear to be crazy and outlandish claims:
--> '''Martin:''' He [the other Martin] must be forcing her [his wife not to recognise him]
--> '''Herr Strauss:''' But why? Help me, why?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/GuiltByAssociation'': Judge Markam openly disagrees with the law that he has to give Susan twenty years under. He later resigned over being forced to. Other judges are mentioned as even refusing to hear such cases at all so they won't have to pass such sentences. President Clinton too commutes the sentences of some prisoners serving time under these laws, which includes Susan.

Added: 99

Changed: 31

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%%
%%
%% This page has been alphabetized. Please add new examples in the correct order. Thanks!
%%
%%%



* The detective in ''Film/BunnyLakeIsMissing'' embodies this trope. Despite the fact that every piece of evidence suggests that Ann Lake never really had a daughter, he continues to investigate zealously because after all, if she's not crazy then a four-year-old girl is missing. And thanks to this behavior [[spoiler: he gets possibly the most understated, British BigDamnHeroes moment in cinematic history]].

to:

* The detective in ''Film/BunnyLakeIsMissing'' embodies this trope. Despite the fact that every piece of evidence suggests that Ann Lake never really had a daughter, he continues to investigate zealously because after all, if she's not crazy then a four-year-old 4-year-old girl is missing. And thanks to this behavior [[spoiler: he gets possibly the most understated, British BigDamnHeroes moment in cinematic history]].



-->President Camacho. Former pro wrestler turned porn star turned president. He dresses in American flag pants, he addresses the nation by dancing, singing, and firing a gun into the air and rallying them with his aggressively patriotic (if completely empty) rhetoric. He's energetic, likable, and absolutely captivating... it's not just President Camacho's patriotism that makes him a great leader. Eventually, Joe is brought to the attention of President Camacho. This weird-talking time traveler with his fancy ideas made it all the way to the White House, because an IQ test claimed he was the smartest man alive. And when that happened, President Camacho did a remarkable thing. He recognized that Joe was smarter, and he bowed to his wisdom. Everyone — everyone — in the world of ''Idiocracy'' resented Joe, because he talked differently and because his ideas, to them, sounded crazy. They turned against him out of their fear, their pride, and their inability to understand him. Everyone else, when faced with Joe's unconventional ideas, immediately went on the defensive and resented Joe. He didn't fit in with their weird hive mind of delusion and idiocy. Yet for all of his pomposity and ridiculousness, Camacho had the clarity of mind to look beyond all that. What he saw was a man who was smarter than himself, and he had no problem humbling himself and saying "Let's trust the smart guy."

to:

-->President Camacho. Former pro wrestler turned porn star turned president. He dresses in American flag pants, he addresses the nation by dancing, singing, and firing a gun into the air and rallying them with his aggressively patriotic (if completely empty) rhetoric. He's energetic, likable, and absolutely captivating... it's not just President Camacho's patriotism that makes him a great leader. Eventually, Joe is brought to the attention of President Camacho. This weird-talking time traveler with his fancy ideas made it all the way to the White House, because an IQ test claimed he was the smartest man alive. And when that happened, President Camacho did a remarkable thing. He recognized that Joe was smarter, and he bowed to his wisdom. Everyone -- everyone -- in the world of ''Idiocracy'' resented Joe, because he talked differently and because his ideas, to them, sounded crazy. They turned against him out of their fear, their pride, and their inability to understand him. Everyone else, when faced with Joe's unconventional ideas, immediately went on the defensive and resented Joe. He didn't fit in with their weird hive mind of delusion and idiocy. Yet for all of his pomposity and ridiculousness, Camacho had the clarity of mind to look beyond all that. What he saw was a man who was smarter than himself, and he had no problem humbling himself and saying "Let's trust the smart guy."



** Also Elmont, the captain of the Guardians. He'll put a good scare in Jack for not kneeling when he's supposed to--but when the Princess goes missing, Elmont remembers that Jack was the peasant who'd stand up to bullies to protect a strange girl whom he didn't even ''know'' was the princess. He vouches for Jack with the King when it counts.

to:

** Also Elmont, the captain of the Guardians. He'll put a good scare in Jack for not kneeling when he's supposed to--but to -- but when the Princess goes missing, Elmont remembers that Jack was the peasant who'd stand up to bullies to protect a strange girl whom he didn't even ''know'' was the princess. He vouches for Jack with the King when it counts.



* Every authority figure in ''Film/NightOfTheLepus'' accepts that monsters are rampaging without question, and all immediately spring into action. Which is rather unreasonable in and of itself - not a single person ever stops and says "Giant Man Eating Rabbits? You can't be serious!?"

to:

* Every authority figure in ''Film/NightOfTheLepus'' accepts that monsters are rampaging without question, and all immediately spring into action. Which is rather unreasonable in and of itself - -- not a single person ever stops and says "Giant Man Eating Rabbits? You can't be serious!?"



* ''Film/RebelWithoutACause'' - the police officer played by Ed Platt. He lets Jim know that he's there to talk to when things are driving him crazy (and things ''are'' driving him crazy).
* ''Film/ReformSchoolGirls'': Psychologist Dr. Norton seems to be the only authority figure at the school who is not a megalomaniac or a sadist. When she gets proof of what is going on at the school, she goes straight to the board to expose it. At the end of the film — after Edna has been killed and Sutter removed — she is shown as the new warden.

to:

* ''Film/RebelWithoutACause'' - -- the police officer played by Ed Platt. He lets Jim know that he's there to talk to when things are driving him crazy (and things ''are'' driving him crazy).
* ''Film/ReformSchoolGirls'': Psychologist Dr. Norton seems to be the only authority figure at the school who is not a megalomaniac or a sadist. When she gets proof of what is going on at the school, she goes straight to the board to expose it. At the end of the film -- after Edna has been killed and Sutter removed -- she is shown as the new warden.



* In ''Film/SilverLode'', all the local authority figures--Sheriff Wooley, Judge Cranston, and Reverend Field--are helpful and willing to listen to reason. Wooley and Field go the extra mile in protecting Ballard from extrajudicial killing by respectively swearing in a {{posse}} and granting him [[SeekingSanctuary refuge in the church]]. It's the townspeople and [=McCarty=] and his men who cause trouble for Ballard.

to:

* In ''Film/SilverLode'', all the local authority figures--Sheriff figures -- Sheriff Wooley, Judge Cranston, and Reverend Field--are Field -- are helpful and willing to listen to reason. Wooley and Field go the extra mile in protecting Ballard from extrajudicial killing by respectively swearing in a {{posse}} and granting him [[SeekingSanctuary refuge in the church]]. It's the townspeople and [=McCarty=] and his men who cause trouble for Ballard.



* In ''Film/TheTerminator'', Lieutenant Ed Traxler and Detective Vukovich take the situation seriously, and do their best to save Sarah Connor when they realize she's the "Phone Book Killer's" most likely next target. Face-to-face with our protagonists, they're not so apt to believe Kyle Reese's wild descriptions of a "Terminator" in human flesh sent back to their time from AfterTheEnd, but — more than the unfortunately sneering condescension of Dr. Silberman — recognize a situation bad enough to rattle anyone and make a very respectable go at DoingInTheWizard, [[WrongGenreSavvy except, unfortunately, they live in a world where their wild-eyed hobo with a shotgun is]] ''[[WrongGenreSavvy right]].'' In a deleted scene, [[spoiler:the mortally-wounded]] Traxler even gives Reese a gun after the Terminator attacks the police station.

to:

* In ''Film/TheTerminator'', Lieutenant Ed Traxler and Detective Vukovich take the situation seriously, and do their best to save Sarah Connor when they realize she's the "Phone Book Killer's" most likely next target. Face-to-face with our protagonists, they're not so apt to believe Kyle Reese's wild descriptions of a "Terminator" in human flesh sent back to their time from AfterTheEnd, but -- more than the unfortunately sneering condescension of Dr. Silberman -- recognize a situation bad enough to rattle anyone and make a very respectable go at DoingInTheWizard, [[WrongGenreSavvy except, unfortunately, they live in a world where their wild-eyed hobo with a shotgun is]] ''[[WrongGenreSavvy right]].'' In a deleted scene, [[spoiler:the mortally-wounded]] Traxler even gives Reese a gun after the Terminator attacks the police station.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/IndianaJonesAndTheKingdomOfTheCrystalSkull'':
** Dean Stanforth defends Indy against accusations that he's a communist and is willing to sacrifice his own career to protect Indy's.
** General Ross shows up when the [=FBI=] are accusing Indy of being a Communist spy to talk about how he's a trustworthy war hero and dedicated archeologist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheMcKenzieBreak:'' Colonel Perry doesn't get along well with Captain O'Connor and he makes some bad decision, but he's able to logically explain why he makes those decisions and does help O'Connor at times. Furthermore, in the film but not the book, Perry is absolutely right when it comes to his biggest argument with O'Connor (whether or not to stop the prisoners before they escape, regardless of the intelligence loss), and O'Connor eventually admits it.

to:

* ''Film/TheMcKenzieBreak:'' Colonel Perry doesn't get along well with Captain O'Connor Connor and he makes some bad decision, but he's able to logically explain why he makes those decisions and does help O'Connor Connor at times. Furthermore, in the film but not the book, Perry is absolutely right when it comes to his biggest argument with O'Connor Connor (whether or not to stop the prisoners before they escape, regardless of the intelligence loss), and O'Connor eventually admits it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/TheTerminator'', Lieutenant Ed Traxler and Detective Vukovich take the situation seriously, and do their best to save Sarah Connor when they realize she's the "Phone Book Killer's" most likely next target. Face-to-face with our protagonists, they're not so apt to believe Kyle Reese's wild descriptions of a "Terminator" in human flesh sent back to their time from AfterTheEnd, but — more than the unfortunately sneering condescension of Dr. Silberman — recognize a situation bad enough to rattle anyone and make a very respectable go at DoingInTheWizard, except, unfortunately, they live in a world where their wild-eyed hobo with a shotgun is ''right.'' In a deleted scene, Vulkovich even gives Reese a gun when the Terminator comes back.

to:

* In ''Film/TheTerminator'', Lieutenant Ed Traxler and Detective Vukovich take the situation seriously, and do their best to save Sarah Connor when they realize she's the "Phone Book Killer's" most likely next target. Face-to-face with our protagonists, they're not so apt to believe Kyle Reese's wild descriptions of a "Terminator" in human flesh sent back to their time from AfterTheEnd, but — more than the unfortunately sneering condescension of Dr. Silberman — recognize a situation bad enough to rattle anyone and make a very respectable go at DoingInTheWizard, [[WrongGenreSavvy except, unfortunately, they live in a world where their wild-eyed hobo with a shotgun is ''right.is]] ''[[WrongGenreSavvy right]].'' In a deleted scene, Vulkovich [[spoiler:the mortally-wounded]] Traxler even gives Reese a gun when after the Terminator comes back.attacks the police station.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/TheMcKenzieBreak:'' Colonel Perry doesn't get along well with Captain O'Connor and he makes some bad decision, but he's able to logically explain why he makes those decisions and does help O'Connor at times. Furthermore, in the film but not the book, Perry is absolutely right when it comes to his biggest argument with O'Connor (whether or not to stop the prisoners before they escape, regardless of the intelligence loss), and O'Connor eventually admits it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The proof in question


* Dr. Paul Dreyfus in ''Film/DantesPeak''. He's skeptical of Dr. Dalton's claims that the volcano is going to erupt, not because he's a SuitWithVestedInterests or because he thinks there's a MillionToOneChance, but because he wants absolute proof as a scientist and he's seen how premature warnings can cause unnecessary panic and cause people to disregard real warnings. But as soon as Dr. Dalton has real proof, he agrees to issue a warning and helps plan an evacuation. Of course [[spoiler: he still ends up being a DoomedContrarian.]]

to:

* Dr. Paul Dreyfus in ''Film/DantesPeak''. He's skeptical of Dr. Dalton's claims that the volcano is going to erupt, not because he's a SuitWithVestedInterests or because he thinks there's a MillionToOneChance, but because he wants absolute proof as a scientist and he's seen how premature warnings can cause unnecessary panic and cause people to disregard real warnings. But as soon as Dr. Dalton has real proof, proof (contaminated water), he agrees to issue a warning and helps plan an evacuation. Of course [[spoiler: he still ends up being a DoomedContrarian.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/ALeagueOfTheirOwn:'' League official Ira Lowenstein lectures Jimmy for his poor behavior, tries to accommodate Dottie when she feels being on the same team as Kit is hurting their relationship (although his methods aren't perfect), and really goes to bat to keep the league going on multiple occasions when it looks doomed, feeling that the women deserve to keep pursuing their dream.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/{{Solarbabies}}:'' The warden doesn't discipline the orphans under his care unless he's forced to by his bosses and lets them go outside the facility's walls on occasion. When disciplining the Solarbabies for going outside without permission to play a game, he says that he would have allowed them to play at the prison if they'd asked. He also pleads with Strictor not to kill Jason and the others after they escape.
--> '''The Warden:''' This orphanage is dedicated to producing useful members of the E-Protectorate. I will not run it as a prison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/ToBeOrNotToBe:'' The military intelligence leaders who Stanislav tells his suspicions about the professor immediately believe him once he reveals that the professor told the Polish pilots about his supposedly top secret mission and then [[TheVillainKnowsWhereYouLive got a list of the names and addresses all of their families back in Poland.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mayor Wells from ''Film/TheLastShow'', like [[Film/{{Jaws}} Mayor Vaughn]], refuses to close the beaches in response to the shark attacks. Unlike Vaughn, Wells ''does'' take precautions, such as installing safety barriers and hiring patrol boats. Hell, [[spoiler: he even tries to take on the shark himself in the climax!]]

to:

* Mayor Wells from ''Film/TheLastShow'', ''Film/TheLastShark'', like [[Film/{{Jaws}} Mayor Vaughn]], refuses to close the beaches in response to the shark attacks. Unlike Vaughn, Wells ''does'' take precautions, such as installing safety barriers and hiring patrol boats. Hell, [[spoiler: he even tries to take on the shark himself in the climax!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Mayor Wells from ''Film/TheLastShow'', like [[Film/{{Jaws}} Mayor Vaughn]], refuses to close the beaches in response to the shark attacks. Unlike Vaughn, Wells ''does'' take precautions, such as installing safety barriers and hiring patrol boats. Hell, [[spoiler: he even tries to take on the shark himself in the climax!]]

Added: 498

Changed: 136

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/EscapeFromThePlanetOfTheApes:'' General Winthrop is quick to recognize that the apes have some kind of humanlike intelligence and treats them respectfully as a result.

to:

* ''Film/EscapeFromThePlanetOfTheApes:'' ''Film/EscapeFromThePlanetOfTheApes:''
** The President extends a great deal of courtesy to the apes. He opposes a motion to abort Zira's pregnancy and then sterilize her, only going along with it when he's forced to by the democratic process. When the apes go on the run after accidentally killing a civilian, he also orders that they be taken alive and allowed to tell their side of what happened.
**
General Winthrop is quick to recognize that the apes have some kind of humanlike intelligence and treats them respectfully as a result.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/EscapeFromThePlanetOfTheApes:'' General Winthrop is quick to recognize that the apes have some kind of humanlike intelligence and treats them respectfully as a result.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/ShootToKill:''
** Stantin's boss at the FBI doesn't criticize him over the failed hostage negotiations at the beginning and tells him to get some rest so he can be at his best when he resumes work.
** Sheriff Arnett in Washington and Superintendent Hsu in Vancouver are both meticulous law enforcement professionals who are unfailingly accommodating to the heroes. Hsu even aids in Stantin and Knox's CowboyCop antics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/SafetyPatrol:''
** Three of Scout's teachers are forgiving of his screw-ups and support his desire to be on the safety patrol while telling Tromp that the rules favor letting Scout fulfill his dream.
** Security Chief Penn is TheKlutz, but he treats the amount of stealing at the school with appropriate seriousness and publicly recognizes Scout's heroism at the end of the movie.

Changed: 4

Removed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling, formatting.


**



* ''Film/{Paycheck}}'': The two FBI agents are quick to decide that Jennings doesn't show signs of guilt. They are equally quick to accept that Jennings' actions indicate he has knowledge of the future, and they are ProperlyParanoid about how their own government might abuse that technology.

to:

* ''Film/{Paycheck}}'': ''Film/{{Paycheck}}'': The two FBI agents are quick to decide that Jennings doesn't show signs of guilt. They are equally quick to accept that Jennings' actions indicate he has knowledge of the future, and they are ProperlyParanoid about how their own government might abuse that technology.



* Evenlyn Salt's superior Ted Winter in ''Film/{{Salt}}'' was at least trying to understand why Salt was acting the way she was and acted more calmly, in contrast to the more rash, frantic Peabody. [[spoiler: Winter was in fact a Russian spy, so he took Salt's side because he wanted her succeed. And in the end, when Salt was arrested, Peabody, after receiving certain information to get him to trust Salt, he lets her escape.]]

to:

* Evenlyn Evelyn Salt's superior Ted Winter in ''Film/{{Salt}}'' was at least trying to understand why Salt was acting the way she was and acted more calmly, in contrast to the more rash, frantic Peabody. [[spoiler: Winter was in fact a Russian spy, so he took Salt's side because he wanted her succeed. And in the end, when Salt was arrested, Peabody, after receiving certain information to get him to trust Salt, he lets her escape.]]



* Mejor Fedotov in ''Film/WhiteTiger'' pays close attention to what Naydenov (a {{Cloudcuckoolander}} who believes tanks talk to him) says, unlike everyone else who dismisses him as insane.

to:

* Mejor Major Fedotov in ''Film/WhiteTiger'' pays close attention to what Naydenov (a {{Cloudcuckoolander}} who believes tanks talk to him) says, unlike everyone else who dismisses him as insane.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/{Paycheck}}'': The two FBI agents are quick to decide that Jennings doesn't show signs of guilt. They are equally quick to accept that Jennings' actions indicate he has knowledge of the future, and they are ProperlyParanoid about how their own government might abuse that technology.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the ''Franchise/BackToTheFuture'' series, while Principal Strickland shows some jerkass tendencies (mocks Marty for his musical ambitions, castigates George for being a victim of bullies), his grandfather in the Old West, Marshall Strickland, appears to be a fair-minded lawman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/RelativeFear'': Adam's pre-school teacher is quick to race up and show concern when other kids bully him by smearing paint on his face, informs his parents about what happened, and discusses the merits of private tutoring with them.

Top