Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / TokenEnemyMinority

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Updating Link


* ''Sgt. Fury's ComicBook/HowlingCommandos'':

to:

* ''Sgt. Fury's ComicBook/HowlingCommandos'':''ComicBook/SgtFuryAndHisHowlingCommandos'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In [[ComicBook/RainbowRowellsRunaways the 2017 series]], Gib is the only Gibborim willing to abandon his people's obsession with reclaiming the Earth.

to:

** In [[ComicBook/RainbowRowellsRunaways [[ComicBook/RunawaysRainbowRowell the 2017 series]], Gib is the only Gibborim willing to abandon his people's obsession with reclaiming the Earth.



* ''{{Series/Charmed 1998}}'' had an arc involving the demon Cole falling in love with Phoebe and pulling a HeelFaceTurn for a while.

to:

* ''{{Series/Charmed 1998}}'' ''Series/Charmed1998'' had an arc involving the demon Cole falling in love with Phoebe and pulling a HeelFaceTurn for a while.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Most of Literature/{{Alatriste}}'s enemies are aristocrats, but he is also friends with an aristocrat, the Count of Guadalmedina. In ''Corsairs of the Levant'', Alatriste joins the Spanish galleys fighting the Muslims in the Mediterranean and is accompanied by Gurriato, a Muslim auxilliary from Wahran (now in Algeria, part of the Spanish Empire at the time of the novels).

to:

* Most of Literature/{{Alatriste}}'s enemies are aristocrats, but he is also friends with an aristocrat, the Count of Guadalmedina. In ''Corsairs of the Levant'', Alatriste joins the Spanish galleys fighting the Muslims in the Mediterranean and is accompanied by Gurriato, a Muslim auxilliary auxiliary from Wahran (now in Algeria, part of the Spanish Empire at the time of the novels).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheWordForWorldIsForest'' was published in 1972 and includes Vietnamese characters, Creator/UrsulaKLeGuin having written it as a response to UsefulNotes/TheVietnamWar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Golden Girl in ''ComicBook/TheInvadersMarvel'' (Japanese during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII -- note that she's a {{Retcon}} hero; real World War II comic books didn't do this).

to:

* Golden Girl in ''ComicBook/TheInvadersMarvel'' ''ComicBook/{{The Invaders|MarvelComics}}'' (Japanese during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII -- note that she's a {{Retcon}} hero; real World War II comic books didn't do this).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** One episode (''Future Imperfect'') has Riker wake up sixteen years into the future, a time where he is now captain of the ''Enterprise''. He is startled to see a Ferengi Ensign on the bridge and remarks on the unlikeliness of this, his first clue as to what is really going on. Despite this, ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine''featured a Ferengi joining Starfleet only seven years after this episode of TNG was broadcast.

to:

*** One episode (''Future Imperfect'') has Riker wake up sixteen years into the future, a time where he is now captain of the ''Enterprise''. He is startled to see a Ferengi Ensign on the bridge and remarks on the unlikeliness of this, his first clue as to what is really going on. Despite this, ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine''featured ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'' featured a Ferengi joining Starfleet only seven years after this episode of TNG was broadcast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** One episode (''Future Imperfect'') has Riker wake up sixteen years into the future, a time where he is now captain of the ''Enterprise''. He is startled to see a Ferengi Ensign on the bridge and remarks on the unlikeliness of this, his first clue as to what is really going on. Despite this, ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine''featured a Ferengi joining Starfleet only seven years after this episode of TNG was broadcast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheUntouchables'' is about prohibition agents fighting Italian mobsters run by Al Capone. One of the agents, George Stone (birth name Giuseppe Petri), is also Italian. This leads to bigotry from Irish-American cop Jim Malone (Sean Connery) who calls him a "thieving wop" upon discovering that he is Italian. Interestingly enough, Stone is played by Andy Garcia who is actually Cuban, not Italian, but is famous for playing Italian characters.

to:

* ''Film/TheUntouchables'' ''Film/TheUntouchables1987'' is about prohibition agents fighting Italian mobsters run by Al Capone.UsefulNotes/AlCapone. One of the agents, George Stone (birth name Giuseppe Petri), is also Italian. This leads to bigotry from Irish-American cop Jim Malone (Sean Connery) (Creator/SeanConnery) who calls him a "thieving wop" upon discovering that he is Italian. Interestingly enough, Stone is played by Andy Garcia Creator/AndyGarcia who is actually Cuban, not Italian, but is famous for playing Italian characters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
no linking to the same page


* In ''VideoGame/FireEmblemFates'', you choose which of the two warring countries to side with, and so, who the TokenEnemyMinority is depends on which version you're playing. Hoshidan Ninja Kaze and Nohrian Cavalier Silas will join the Avatar character no matter which side you choose (though under different circumstances in different routes). If you choose Nohr, Kaze is the TokenEnemyMinority, due to overhearing how the Avatar wishes to end the conflict by reforming Nohr from within [[spoiler:and his latent guilt for not preventing their kidnapping in the first place]]. If you choose Hoshido, it will be Silas and the Avatar's servants, Jakob and Felicia, whose personal loyalty to the Avatar trumps their nationalism. Silas in particular has to deal with a lot of anti-Nohrian suspicion in his interactions with his Hoshidan comrades, while Kaze's easygoing charm spares him the worst of it. Both are considered extremely trustworthy and likable by both sides.

to:

* In ''VideoGame/FireEmblemFates'', you choose which of the two warring countries to side with, and so, who the TokenEnemyMinority Token Enemy Minority is depends on which version you're playing. Hoshidan Ninja Kaze and Nohrian Cavalier Silas will join the Avatar character no matter which side you choose (though under different circumstances in different routes). If you choose Nohr, Kaze is the TokenEnemyMinority, Token Enemy Minority, due to overhearing how the Avatar wishes to end the conflict by reforming Nohr from within [[spoiler:and his latent guilt for not preventing their kidnapping in the first place]]. If you choose Hoshido, it will be Silas and the Avatar's servants, Jakob and Felicia, whose personal loyalty to the Avatar trumps their nationalism. Silas in particular has to deal with a lot of anti-Nohrian suspicion in his interactions with his Hoshidan comrades, while Kaze's easygoing charm spares him the worst of it. Both are considered extremely trustworthy and likable by both sides.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Golden Girl in ''ComicBook/TheInvadersComicBook'' (Japanese during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII -- note that she's a {{Retcon}} hero; real World War II comic books didn't do this).

to:

* Golden Girl in ''ComicBook/TheInvadersComicBook'' ''ComicBook/TheInvadersMarvel'' (Japanese during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII -- note that she's a {{Retcon}} hero; real World War II comic books didn't do this).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Rampart in Creator/ChrisClaremont's ''ComicBook/Gen13'' (Arab Muslim during the War on Terror). Noble gesture, but unfortunately a bit CaptainEthnic; the guy said "Oh Allah!" so many times you'd think it was his CatchPhrase.
* Golden Girl in ''ComicBook/TheInvaders'' (Japanese during World War II -- note that she's a {{Retcon}} hero; real World War II comic books didn't do this).

to:

* Rampart in Creator/ChrisClaremont's ''ComicBook/Gen13'' (Arab Muslim during the War on Terror).UsefulNotes/TheWarOnTerror). Noble gesture, but unfortunately a bit CaptainEthnic; the guy said "Oh Allah!" so many times you'd think it was his CatchPhrase.
* Golden Girl in ''ComicBook/TheInvaders'' ''ComicBook/TheInvadersComicBook'' (Japanese during World War II UsefulNotes/WorldWarII -- note that she's a {{Retcon}} hero; real World War II comic books didn't do this).

Added: 254

Changed: 296

Removed: 95

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''[[ComicBook/StarTrekDCComics Star Trek]]'' [[ComicBook/StarTrekDCComics comics from DC]] featured the Klingon defector Konom serving under Captain Kirk, pre-dating the creation of Worf on [[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration TNG]] by several years.



** Worf in ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'' is a fantastic variant of the same, as a member of what was the main BigBad alien race in the original ''Series/{{Star Trek|the Original Series}}'', though by the time of the new series relations are tense, but no longer hostile, and they improve over the course of the franchise due in no small part to Worf himself.
** Before TNG, the Star Trek comics had Konom, a Klingon defector serving on Kirk's Enterprise.

to:

** Worf in ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'' is a fantastic variant of the same, an in-universe example as a member of what was the main BigBad alien race in the original ''Series/{{Star Trek|the Original Series}}'', though by the time of the new series showing that relations with them are tense, but no longer hostile, hostile. This gets more complex as the show goes on and they improve over the course state of the franchise due in no small part to Worf himself.
** Before TNG, the Star Trek comics had Konom, a
Klingon defector serving on Kirk's Enterprise.Empire becomes an ongoing subplot.



* Sayid Jarrah from ''Series/{{Lost}}''. He served in the Gulf War. In the Iraqi Republican Guard. Dude.

to:

* Sayid Jarrah from ''Series/{{Lost}}''. He ''Series/{{Lost}}'', an Iraqi who served in the Gulf War. In the Iraqi Republican Guard. Dude.Guard during the Gulf War.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The remake of ''Film/RedDawn2012'', in which the North Koreans are the enemy, had an Asian-American Marine played by Kenneth Choi (himself of Korean ancestry) working with Colonel Tanner.

to:

* The remake of ''Film/RedDawn2012'', in which the North Koreans are the enemy, had an Asian-American Marine played by Kenneth Choi Creator/KennethChoi (himself of Korean ancestry) working with Colonel Tanner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''VideoGame/FarCryPrimal'', Takkar of the [[ProudWarriorRace Wenja tribe]] captures Dah and Roshani, two commanders from enemy tribes the [[AllCavemenWereNeanderthals Udam]] and the [[KillItWithFire Izila]], respectively. He brings them back to the Wenja village alive so he can learn from them how to create [[PoisonedWeapons rot bane bombs]] and fire bombs. After that, he decides to just keep them alive among the villagers because [[spoiler:he feels sympathetic towards Dah upon learning that most of the Udam are dying of the "skull fire" disease]] and Roshani's too cowardly to try returning to the Izila. Slightly deconstructed by the fact that the rest of the villagers are less welcoming to Dah, [[spoiler:and they try to drown him behind Takkar's back]]. [[spoiler:By the end of the game, Takkar adds a third enemy minority by adopting Ull the Udam warchief's children into the tribe. They end up replacing Dah as the token Udam minority after Dah asks Takkar to MercyKill him so that he doesn't die a CruelAndUnusualDeath by "skull fire".]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The character often remains stereotypical in ways other than being an enemy. In cases where this overlaps with TokenNonHuman, this results in TokenHeroicOrc.

to:

The character often remains stereotypical in ways other than being an enemy. In cases where If this overlaps is done with TokenNonHuman, this results in TokenHeroicOrc.
in-universe conflicts instead of real life ones, that's TokenHeroicOrc.



* Creator/RobertAHeinlein's story ''Literature/SixthColumn'' was a reworking of a Creator/JohnWCampbell story where the YellowPeril invades America. Heinlein wrote that he had to remove racist elements from the original story, and the final story has a Japanese-American as one of the good guys. Assuming this was an addition by Heinlein (which seems likely), it may be unique as an example of the trope used during World War II.

to:

* Creator/RobertAHeinlein's story ''Literature/SixthColumn'' was a reworking of a Creator/JohnWCampbell story where the YellowPeril invades America. Heinlein wrote that he had to remove racist elements from the original story, and the final story has a Japanese-American as one of the good guys. Assuming this was an addition by Heinlein (which seems likely), it may be unique as an example of the trope used for a Japanese character during World War II.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Fischer is an officer in the Heer who is working as a ReverseMole for the British SOE, and is Rousseau's contact in Paris. It's heavily implied that, while he is loyal to Germany, he hates the way the Nazis are running things.

to:

** Fischer is an officer in the Heer who is working as a ReverseMole TheMole for the British SOE, and is Rousseau's contact in Paris. It's heavily implied that, while he is loyal to Germany, he hates the way the Nazis are running things.

Added: 442

Removed: 442

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/CodenameKidsNextDoor'':
** One episode involves a BadFuture where the world has become a LadyLand ruled by {{Straw Feminist}}s. The one girl who is not a villain is Sally, who turns out to be Numbuh 3's granddaughter.
** Teenagers are prominent antagonists, as Kids Next Door operatives are decommissioned as soon as they turn 13. [[spoiler: Both Maurice and Chad turn out to be {{Fake Defector}}s who were GoodAllAlong.]]



* ''WesternAnimation/CodenameKidsNextDoor'':
** One episode involves a BadFuture where the world has become a LadyLand ruled by {{Straw Feminist}}s. The one girl who is not a villain is Sally, who turns out to be Numbuh 3's granddaughter.
** Teenagers are prominent antagonists, as Kids Next Door operatives are decommissioned as soon as they turn 13. [[spoiler: Both Maurice and Chad turn out to be {{Fake Defector}}s who were GoodAllAlong.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Leonard on ''Series/{{Community}}'' is this trope played for laughs: despite appearing in every way to be an elderly American American male and Korean War veteran, it is later revealed that he fought on the North Korean side.

to:

* Leonard on ''Series/{{Community}}'' is this trope played for laughs: despite appearing in every way to be an elderly American American male and Korean War veteran, it is later revealed that he fought on the North Korean side.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Hillman's ''Air Fighters Comics'' (1941-48) featured two, reformed villainess Valkyrie (Liselotte von Schellendorf) and her Air Maidens in the ''Airboy'' feature (she would reappear in later incarnations of that franchise) and The Heap, a proto-Swamp Thing in ''Skywolf''. The Heap was World War 1 German flying ace, Baron Emmelmann, merged with swamp vegetation.

to:

* Hillman's ''Air Fighters Comics'' (1941-48) featured two, reformed villainess Valkyrie (Liselotte von Schellendorf) and her Air Maidens in the ''Airboy'' feature (she would reappear in later incarnations of that franchise) and The Heap, ComicBook/TheHeap, a proto-Swamp Thing in ''Skywolf''. The Heap was World War 1 German flying ace, Baron Emmelmann, merged with swamp vegetation.
K

Added: 799

Changed: 44

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Considering that the Fire Nation are the main antagonists of the series, then [[spoiler:Zuko]] will fulfill this role after he joins Team Avatar in ''WesternAnimation/AvatarTheLastAirbender''.
** An earlier example is Aang's past life, Avatar Roku. Roku was a Fire Nation Avatar who explicitly opposed the war and is the second Fire Nation citizen Aang meets who does. (The first is Shyu, who helps Aang contact Roku's spirit.) Roku serves as Aang's SpiritAdvisor and the lesson Aang takes from learning his life story is that people from the Fire Nation aren't born evil.

to:

* Considering that the Fire Nation are the main antagonists of the series, then [[spoiler:Zuko]] Prince Zuko will fulfill this role after he joins Team Avatar in ''WesternAnimation/AvatarTheLastAirbender''.
** An earlier example is Aang's past life, life and Zuko's great-grandfather, Avatar Roku. Roku was a Fire Nation Avatar who explicitly opposed the war and is the second Fire Nation citizen Aang meets who does. (The first is Shyu, who helps Aang contact Roku's spirit.) Roku serves as Aang's SpiritAdvisor and the lesson Aang takes from learning his life story is that people from the Fire Nation aren't born evil.
** Other Fire Nation citizens that aid Aang and his friends to reinforce the idea that they're not all evil include Jeong Jeong, the deserter who abandoned the war; his disciple Chey, who led Aang to him; Zuko's uncle Iroh, who's initial priority is aiding Zuko but also tries to encourage his better instincts until that means openly opposing the Fire Nation; and the swordmaster Piandao, who tells Sokka point-blank that he figured out he was a Water Tribesman almost immediately and advises him to choose a fake name that blends in better than his real one. Iroh, Piandao and Jeong Jeong all turn out to be members of the Order of the White Lotus, a secret society that promotes the beauty of all nations. Of the five named characters who are members of the Order, three are from the Fire Nation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/SpecialOperations'': Max from the second book, who is a German (albeit a Jewish one).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/AdvanceToTheRear'': Sergeant Beauregard Davis is the only southerner among the Union forces.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The 1932 film ''Film/ShanghaiExpress'' is about Chinese revolutionaries holding a bunch of expats and tourists hostage on board a train. The main villain is a Chinese man who was posing as a passenger, but there is a supporting character called Hui Fei - who is Chinese and not one of the revolutionaries. [[spoiler: She also gets to be the one to kill the villain and save the day]].
* ''Film/TheWindThatShakesTheBarley'' has a token 'good Brit' in contrast to the barbaric Black & Tans. The character is Welsh rather than English however.


Added DiffLines:

* ''{{Series/Charmed 1998}}'' had an arc involving the demon Cole falling in love with Phoebe and pulling a HeelFaceTurn for a while.


Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/CodenameKidsNextDoor'':
** One episode involves a BadFuture where the world has become a LadyLand ruled by {{Straw Feminist}}s. The one girl who is not a villain is Sally, who turns out to be Numbuh 3's granddaughter.
** Teenagers are prominent antagonists, as Kids Next Door operatives are decommissioned as soon as they turn 13. [[spoiler: Both Maurice and Chad turn out to be {{Fake Defector}}s who were GoodAllAlong.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Interestingly he is actually based on a real person, Ali Soufan, who was one of the greatest FBI interrogators during the War on Terror. He also left the FBI for a similar reason, that he was unable to do his job when the CIA tried to torture people instead of letting him work.

Added: 446

Changed: 187

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Fanfic/CodeGeassPaladinsOfVoltron'': Twofold - he leads the Black Knights and is a Britannian Prince, [[spoiler: and is the leader of the Paladins of Voltron despite being one-quarter Galra (though he doesn't know it yet).]]

to:

* ''Fanfic/CodeGeassPaladinsOfVoltron'': ''Fanfic/CodeGeassPaladinsOfVoltron'':
**
Twofold - he leads the Black Knights and is a Britannian Prince, [[spoiler: and is the leader of the Paladins of Voltron despite being one-quarter Galra (though he doesn't know it yet).]]]]
** Rai's a Britannian Prince just like Lelouch (though no one on Team Voltron knows this yet) and a member of the Paladins. How long this will be the case is still up in the air, though, since Lelouch is working on getting Britannian on the Paladins' side.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Fan Works]]
* ''Fanfic/CodeGeassPaladinsOfVoltron'': Twofold - he leads the Black Knights and is a Britannian Prince, [[spoiler: and is the leader of the Paladins of Voltron despite being one-quarter Galra (though he doesn't know it yet).]]
* ''Fanfic/MyMirrorSwordAndShield'': Suzaku is the only minority and first person from a conquered Area to be in the Britannian high command while Cornelia is the only Britannian in the mostly Japanese Black Knights.
[[/folder]]
K

Added: 380

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** An earlier example is Aang's past life, Avatar Roku. Roku was a Fire Nation Avatar who explicitly opposed the war and is the second Fire Nation citizen Aang meets who does. (The first is Shyu, who helps Aang contact Roku's spirit.) Roku serves as Aang's SpiritAdvisor and the lesson Aang takes from learning his life story is that people from the Fire Nation aren't born evil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''VideoGame/ShuyanSaga'', Master Shan tells Shuyan that if she transcends her anger, she'll see that despite the damage done by the Guer in the name of the Red Dragon, "the Guer are victims of the Red Dragon" too. It turns out that one of Shuyan's fellow students is Guer, and wants to free them from the rule of Ganbaatar. This doesn't equate to being nice, however -- or to choosing the right methods.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:Isaac]] becomes this in ''Series/TheOrville'' after his people starts a war against the Union. [[spoiler:He remains part of The Orville's crew after he has a change of heart during the ship's occupation by the hostile Kailon extermination force traveling to Earth.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:Isaac]] becomes this in ''Series/TheOrville'' after his people starts start a war against the Union. [[spoiler:He remains part of The Orville's the ''Orville'''s crew after he has a change of heart during the ship's occupation by the hostile Kailon Kaylon extermination force traveling to Earth.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A similar case of Fencer is Tyger in the animated series ''WesternAnimation/FievelsAmericanTails'', series base in Creator/DonBluth's movie ''WesternAnimation/AnAmericanTail'', Tyger is Fievel's friend and the only good cat in a town full of villain cats.

to:

* A similar case of Fencer is Tyger Tiger in the animated series ''WesternAnimation/FievelsAmericanTails'', series base in based on Creator/DonBluth's movie ''WesternAnimation/AnAmericanTail'', Tyger Tiger is Fievel's friend and the only good cat in a town full of villain villainous cats.



* Slimer in ''WesternAnimation/TheRealGhostBusters'', yes the series shows that not every ghost is evil and some ghosts can be very cooperative with the Ghostbusters, but that doesn't change the fact that Slimer is a ghost helping the [=GHOSTbusters=]. He was call a traitor for several spirits, like Samhain. Naturally he has a similar role in the successor series ''WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters''.
* Garahl nar Hhallas in ''WesternAnimation/WingCommanderAcademy'', the animated series based in the game of the same name. Hhallas acomplishes more or less the same role of Hobbes in the aforementioned game.

to:

* Slimer in ''WesternAnimation/TheRealGhostBusters'', yes the series shows that not every ghost is evil and some ghosts can be very cooperative with the Ghostbusters, but that doesn't change the fact that Slimer is a ghost helping the [=GHOSTbusters=]. He was call called a traitor for by several spirits, like Samhain. Naturally he has a similar role in the successor series ''WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters''.
* Garahl nar Hhallas in ''WesternAnimation/WingCommanderAcademy'', the animated series based in on the game of the same name. Hhallas acomplishes accomplishes more or less the same role of Hobbes in the aforementioned game.

Top