Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / TheWindowOrTheStairs

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 6187

Changed: 681

Removed: 971

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


This is often invoked by other characters as a SecretTestOfCharacter. The "window" option can sometimes take the form of someone deciding to ScrewThisImOuttaHere. When the situation is serious enough, choosing the "stairs" may set up a CheatersNeverProsper, MuggingTheMonster, or RewardedAsATraitorDeserves scenario. If the "window" option would have gone badly anyway (although probably not as bad), the choice may overlap with a MortonsFork.



* ''Film/ImGonnaGitYouSucka'', as described above. The trope is subverted at the end of the film when the protagonist says "There's two ways outta here..." at which point Wayans screams and jumps out the window. This prompts one of the heroes to say, "Didn't he know about the elevator?"
* Subverted and then completely lampshaded in ''Film/GalaxyQuest''. Captain Taggert sees the path between himself and the Berylium Sphere he needed for his ship is clear. [[GenreSavvy Suspecting this trope is in play]], he begins taking the 'window' by dodging from boulder to boulder and [[UnnecessaryCombatRoll rolling behind cover]]. Meanwhile the other characters simply stroll unmolested up the path. Gwen [=DeMarco=] looks over at him as they do and comments, "Does the rolling help, actually?" Capt. Taggerty stands up and dusts himself off. Unwilling to admit defeat, he says, "Uh huh. It helps." Then she points out that during his somersaults he actually dropped his raygun.



* Subverted and then completely lampshaded in ''Film/GalaxyQuest''. Captain Taggert sees the path between himself and the Berylium Sphere he needed for his ship is clear. [[GenreSavvy Suspecting this trope is in play]], he begins taking the 'window' by dodging from boulder to boulder and [[UnnecessaryCombatRoll rolling behind cover]]. Meanwhile the other characters simply stroll unmolested up the path. Gwen [=DeMarco=] looks over at him as they do and comments, "Does the rolling help, actually?" Capt. Taggerty stands up and dusts himself off. Unwilling to admit defeat, he says, "Uh huh. It helps." Then she points out that during his somersaults he actually dropped his raygun.
* ''Film/Halloween4TheReturnOfMichaelMyers'': The vigilante mob that arrives looking for Michael in the final act is offered a choice between escorting his attempted victims Rachel and Jamie to safety and letting the arriving police take care of Michael, or charging inside to risk getting picked off by the NighInvulnerable StealthExpert killer. They choose to drive Rachel and Jamie away, unaware that Michael is hitching an UndersideRide and quickly starts going through them to get at the girls.
* ''Film/ImGonnaGitYouSucka'', as described above. The trope is subverted at the end of the film when the protagonist says "There's two ways outta here..." at which point Wayans screams and jumps out the window. This prompts one of the heroes to say, "Didn't he know about the elevator?"
* ''Film/TheImaginariumOfDoctorParnassus'': People experiencing imagination fantasies are often offered choices like climbing a steep staircase to sobriety, stopping for a nice drink at the bar, or joining the police force to beat people up or running home to their mothers. Taking the easy option tends to result in death by explosion.
* ''Film/JoyRide3Roadkill'': When the homicidal Rusty orders Jordon, Alisa, and Mickey to meet him and their kidnapped friend at an abandoned location, Mickey leaves to go get the cops instead, while urging the others not to go to the obvious trap. Mickey is ambushed and brutally killed immediately after they part ways, while Jordon and Alisa both survive the movie.
* ''Film/TheToweringInferno'': Several characters are offered a chance to evacuate the burning build down a sheltered elevator rather than a dangerous zipline and accept the offer. However, the elevator is put in jeopardy by an explosion and one of its passengers falls to her death.



* One ''[[Literature/TheBerenstainBears Berenstain Bears]]'' book had the kids go camping à la [[ScoutOut cub scouts]]. At one point their map tells them to take a long and winding mountain path around a deadly culvert, while their leader insists on taking the shortcut right over said culvert (ignoring the blank spot on the map). He takes the shortcut and promptly falls into the culvert because the bridge was out.
* In the ''Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer'' prequel short story "Blood and Brine," a pirate mutiny leads to the crew splitting up and taking separate ships, being faced with the choice between siding with their captain to sail a skeleton-crewed ship that has recently been subjected to monster attacks or taking a ship that is seemingly free of whatever is attracting the monster and has a much bigger crew (and will get to take a bigger share of the crew's treasure). Unfortunately for the men who side with the mutineers, the monster is being [[DeathByMaterialism drawn to the treasure they take, not any individual ship.]]



* One ''[[Literature/TheBerenstainBears Berenstain Bears]]'' book had the kids go camping à la [[ScoutOut cub scouts]]. At one point their map tells them to take a long and winding mountain path around a deadly culvert, while their leader insists on taking the shortcut right over said culvert (ignoring the blank spot on the map). He takes the shortcut and promptly falls into the culvert because the bridge was out.

to:

* One ''[[Literature/TheBerenstainBears Berenstain Bears]]'' book had ''Literature/RepublicCommando'': During Order 66, Etain is trying to escape offworld before being executed as a former Jedi, but when Bardan Jusik offers to pick her up in his speeder to take her to the kids go camping à la [[ScoutOut cub scouts]]. At one point their map tells spaceport, she decides it would attract too much attention and she can just blend in with a crowd while walking there, as she isn't carrying anything which would identify her as a Jedi. Unfortunately, several other Jedi who have the same idea are caught with lightsabers while she is nearby [[spoiler:and she dies trying to break up the fight.]]
* ''Literature/SergeStorms'': Sometimes, SerialKiller Serge will trick his victims into picking something that will kill them over something harmless. For instance, in ''Tiger Shrimp Tango,'' he makes a man choose between being hurt with various weapons (such as a pistol) or three cigars. The man picks the cigars, but rather than having him smoke them, Serge converts the nicotine in
them to take a long liquid form and winding mountain path around uses them as a deadly culvert, (highly toxic) spray to kill the guy while their leader insists on taking the shortcut right over said culvert (ignoring the blank spot on the map). He takes the shortcut and promptly falls into the culvert because the bridge was out.revolver is unloaded.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/ColdCase'':
** In "The Badlands," after one GangBanger suspect, [=JT=], fingers another one, Joe, as someone who bragged about committing the murders, the cops ask where Joe lives. [=JT=] is reluctant to risk snitching on Joe, but the cops threaten to arrest him for the murders if they think he isn't cooperating, whereas if Joe is the killer, then they'll take him off the streets and he won't bother [=JT=]. Joe isn't the killer though (he just implied he was to [=JT-=] to build VillainCred and keep the gangs from seeing him as easy prey, leading to his StartOfDarkness), so the cops let him go, but he's mad enough about [=JT=] talking to have him killed.
** In "Kensington," recently unemployed mill worker Monty has the option between taking a risk starting a cab business with his friends (with no guarantee about the fares they will get) or withdrawing his contribution to the business (making it tank) to take a lower paying but guaranteed job at his uncle's shoe store. The shoe store goes bankrupt a few months later.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/{{Jeremiah}}'': The end of season 2 reveals that the Army of Daniel came into being when the Founders had a clear choice between leading by example as {{Hope Bringer}}s to become a clear counterpart to the sinister Valhalla Sector or using authoritarian force to consolidate their territory. They choose dictatorship and end up BurningTheShips and being committed to their new government's ideals of contest and autocracy even after the Valhalla Sector falls, when if they'd gone the other way, the Valhalla Sector would have probably still been destroyed without ever having a chance to turn its might against them and they would have had an easy time dealing with Thunder Mountain and its allies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''WesternAnimation/{{Wish|2023}}'' Everyone in Rosa is led to believe Magnifico method may be the easier way to grant their wish, even though no one has any idea whose wish Magnifico will grant or when, with Sabino waiting for decades. Meanwhile, the Star methods are harder as while Star does help you, you still have to put the work into it, but ultimately the wish does get granted.

to:

* In ''WesternAnimation/{{Wish|2023}}'' ''WesternAnimation/{{Wish|2023}}'', Everyone in Rosa is led to believe Magnifico Magnifico's method may be the easier way to grant their wish, even though no one has any idea whose wish Magnifico will grant or when, with Sabino waiting for decades. Meanwhile, the Star methods are harder as while Star does help you, you still have to put the work into it, but ultimately the wish does get granted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''WesternAnimation//{{Wish|2023}}'' Everyone in Rosa is led to believe Magnifico method may be the easier way to grant their wish, even though no one has any idea whose wish Magnifico will grant or when, with Sabino waiting for decades. Meanwhile, the Star methods are harder as while Star does help you, you still have to put the work into it, but ultimately the wish does get granted.

to:

* In ''WesternAnimation//{{Wish|2023}}'' ''WesternAnimation/{{Wish|2023}}'' Everyone in Rosa is led to believe Magnifico method may be the easier way to grant their wish, even though no one has any idea whose wish Magnifico will grant or when, with Sabino waiting for decades. Meanwhile, the Star methods are harder as while Star does help you, you still have to put the work into it, but ultimately the wish does get granted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''WesternAnimation//{{Wish|2023}}'' Everyone in Rosa is led to believe Magnifico method may be the easier way to grant their wish, even though no one has any idea whose wish Magnifico will grant or when, with Sabino waiting for decades. Meanwhile, the Star methods are harder as while Star does help you, you still have to put the work into it, but ultimately the wish does get granted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not sure what that is but it's not a subversion of this trope. If anything it's closer to this trope being played straight, but it's not even that, it's just some weird third thing.


* This trope is subverted in the ''WesternAnimation/AdventureTime'' episode [[Recap/AdventureTimeS3E23AnotherWay "Another Way"]]. Throughout the episode, Finn keeps being presented with situations that seem to only have one (or two equally bad) options; he insists on finding another way each time, generally resulting in much more distress than necessary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That's not this trope, that's just an unbalanced case of Boring But Practical where the practical advantage is minimal and the boredom is immense. Nothing bad happens to you if you take the stealth route (just a bunch of tedium), whereas you do get attacked if you storm the base.


* A borderline-literal example happens in ''VideoGame/FinalFantasyVII'' where Cloud is asked if he wants to [[BigDamnHeroes storm into the heavily-guarded Shinra HQ]], or sneak in. Storming the building involves a handful of easy battles, a couple of floors to climb and a lot of fun things to see and do on the way, including a car advert FMV. Sneaking in involves climbing up 60 stories of identical staircases, [[LeaveTheCameraRunning in real time]] (there's some amusing party banter, though).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That's not this trope. You're just given a choice between standing and fighting or fleeing. If you take the option to flee, it's because your primary objective is to save yourself rather than your brother, so having the brother die if you run away should not be a surprise.


* ''VideoGame/DeusEx'' has a very literal example of this trope, though which also reverses the conditions. At one point, TheMenInBlack storm your brother's apartment building to apprehend him, and you'll be faced with a choice. You can either take the safer option, which in this case will be to escape through the window, evading the attackers completely, or you can stay behind and fight them, clearing all of them out of the front door and in the downstairs lobby. Doing the former will result in your brother dying, but doing the more dangerous latter will save him.

Changed: 49

Removed: 1166

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
edited for spoilers


* In ''Literature/TheWorstWitch'', the hapless trainee witch Mildred Hubble tends to make unfortunate journeys through windows, usually on a broomstick, instead of the much simpler ways of using the stairs.



* In the Series/SaturdayNightLive game show parody "What Have You Become?", each of the contestants realize that they had taken the fun, easy way throughout their lives (depicted as something that everyone does from time to time and then their horror exaggerated for comedic effect) and in doing so had sabotaged their chances to become so much more (in contrast to their oldest living relatives, who had instead become war heroes or known Eleanor Roosevelt).



* Episode 3 of ''VideoGame/TheWalkingDead: Season Two'' ends with your group wandering through a horde of zombies, using the classic zombie disguise. However, some zombies see through it, and one woman in your group gets bitten on the hand. You then have two choices; kill the zombie with your hatchet, or chop the woman's arm off. Over 80% of players chopped it off, because they had recently found out that chopping off the infected area just after someone is bitten can stop the infection spreading. Unfortunately, doing so results in said woman [[spoiler:letting out a scream that attracts several zombies which kill her immediately.]]
* A very minor example happens in ''VideoGame/{{Undertale}}'': When Sans implies that crosswords are tough, his brother Papyrus immediately says that Junior Jumble is much harder, and asks the player to settle the argument. As Sans is more likable (and crosswords do tend to be tougher), players have a tendency to agree with him. However, Sans is a laid back guy. The only thing he cares about is his brother, so he is actually grateful if you agree with Papyrus, because he likes it when he's happy.

to:

* Episode ''VideoGame/TheWalkingDeadSeasonTwo: [[spoiler:Episode 3 of ''VideoGame/TheWalkingDead: Season Two'' ends with your group wandering through a horde of zombies, using the classic zombie disguise. However, some zombies see through it, and one woman in your group gets bitten on the hand. You then have two choices; kill the zombie with your hatchet, or chop the woman's arm off. Over 80% of players chopped it off, because they had recently found out that chopping off the infected area just after someone is bitten can stop the infection spreading. Unfortunately, doing so results in said woman [[spoiler:letting letting out a scream that attracts several zombies which kill her immediately.]]
* A very minor example happens in ''VideoGame/{{Undertale}}'': When Sans implies that crosswords are tough, his brother Papyrus immediately says that Junior Jumble is much harder, and asks the player to settle the argument. As Sans is more likable (and crosswords do tend to be tougher), players have a tendency to agree with him. However, Sans is a laid back guy. The only thing he cares about is his brother, so he is actually grateful if you agree with Papyrus, because he likes it when he's happy.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/TheWorstWitch'', the hapless trainee witch Mildred Hubble tends to make unfortunate journeys through windows, usually on a broomstick, instead of the much simpler ways of using the stairs.


Added DiffLines:

* In the Series/SaturdayNightLive game show parody "What Have You Become?", each of the contestants realize that they had taken the fun, easy way throughout their lives (depicted as something that everyone does from time to time and then their horror exaggerated for comedic effect) and in doing so had sabotaged their chances to become so much more (in contrast to their oldest living relatives, who had instead become war heroes or known Eleanor Roosevelt).


Added DiffLines:

* A very minor example happens in ''VideoGame/{{Undertale}}'': When Sans implies that crosswords are tough, his brother Papyrus immediately says that Junior Jumble is much harder, and asks the player to settle the argument. As Sans is more likable (and crosswords do tend to be tougher), players have a tendency to agree with him. However, Sans is a laid back guy. The only thing he cares about is his brother, so he is actually grateful if you agree with Papyrus, because he likes it when he's happy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That's not this, that's once again morton's fork. or. well. a positive version of morton's fork. either way, morton's fork


* A very minor example happens in ''VideoGame/{{Undertale}}'': When Sans implies that crosswords are tough, his brother Papyrus immediately says that Junior Jumble is much harder, and asks the player to settle the argument. As Sans is more likable (and crosswords do tend to be tougher), players have a tendency to agree with him. However, Sans is a laid back guy. The only thing he cares about is his brother, so he is actually grateful if you agree with Papyrus, because he likes it when he's happy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I mean... I guess you could make a case that that's this trope but for one thing, the characters are never presented with the choice, it happened long in their past, and second, it's a *big* stretch. I'm staying up at 2 am editing this page instead of doing something productive, does that mean I'm participating in this trope? No.


* In the Series/SaturdayNightLive game show parody "What Have You Become?", each of the contestants realize that they had taken the fun, easy way throughout their lives (depicted as something that everyone does from time to time and then their horror exaggerated for comedic effect) and in doing so had sabotaged their chances to become so much more (in contrast to their oldest living relatives, who had instead become war heroes or known Eleanor Roosevelt).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Haven't read the books so maybe I'm missing something but... like... unless there's additional context that is not remotely this trope, that's just either a character taking the Awesome But Impractical option or a character being needlessly paranoid.


* In ''Literature/TheWorstWitch'', the hapless trainee witch Mildred Hubble tends to make unfortunate journeys through windows, usually on a broomstick, instead of the much simpler ways of using the stairs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
There's a bit of window or stairs going on there but mostly it's just Morton's Fork since both options are the same thing, just that one ends in death. And the fact that the option was *advertised* as death makes this a sadistic choice. either way, it's not window or stairs


* There is a famous joke where three men have been caught by a tribe of natives and get to choose their sentences. The two options are "Death" and "Nugoba"[[note]]or whatever word AsLongAsItSoundsForeign, other popular choices include "Tchi-Tchi", "Poontah", "Unga-Bunga", and "[[WesternAnimation/{{Futurama}} Snu-snu]]"[[/note]]. The first man says "Nugoba", thinking that whatever it is has to be better than death. He is immediately raped by all of the men in the village, then released. The second man chooses the same fate, knowing he will at least live after it is over. The third man, too proud to subject himself to such treatment, chooses death. The chief then says "Death... [[OutWithABang by Nugoba!]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That's not the window or the stairs, that's morton's fork because the good looking option is the exact same bad option as the bad option.


* Subverted in ''ComicBook/TheTransformersMegaseries''. Optimus Prime and Ironhide were reminiscing about old battles in one issue, remembering one in which there were two ways to advance. One route turned out to be a minefield, so Ironhide had suggested going the other way. Optimus sensed that something was up and [[TakeAThirdOption instead ordered a retreat]]. Ironhide started to argue when suddenly [[HumongousMecha Trypticon]] revealed himself on the un-mined route.

Top