Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / TheRevolutionWillNotBeCivilized

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/WolfWarrior2'': The country is in a civil war between the government and revolutionaries. The revolutionaries are depicted much less sympathetically, with their modus operandi being [[WithUsOrAgainstUs "kill anybody who is not on our side",]] be it either native or foreign civilians.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The success of the Revolutionary Army's ideals being spread around the world? Mostly owed to good old-fashioned warfare. [[TheRevolutionWillNotBeVilified Then again, against the corrupt World Government, not exactly a hard choice.]]

to:

** The success of the Revolutionary Army's ideals being spread around the world? Mostly owed to good old-fashioned warfare. [[TheRevolutionWillNotBeVilified Then again, against the corrupt World Government, not exactly a hard choice.]] It's a choice made by necessity, as well: [[spoiler:Their leader, Monkey D. Dragon, was a former Marine who defected because he found no justice there and was initially opposing the Government by non-violent means; but after the genocide of Ohara, in which his friend Clover was among the victims, Dragon realized the Government would never see reason, and so he, Kuma and Ivankov formed the Revolutionaries.]]

Added: 1514

Changed: 568

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Webcomic/{{Unsounded}}'': The Aldish rebels in Avelpit target and blow up a medical cart, then later sacrifice their child soldier mages, without said children understanding that what they were doing would lead to CruelAndUnusualDeath when the khert reacted, in order to set the khert on fire long enough for their cursed leader to talk to an ally without their curse killing them. Their leader was also going to give war prisoners to Shaensigin dooming them to a slow death and use as food provisions, though he grabbed the child with them out of the group to be sacrificed to the salt lizard.

to:

* ''Webcomic/{{Unsounded}}'': ''Webcomic/{{Unsounded}}'':
**
The Aldish rebels in Avelpit target and blow up a medical cart, then later sacrifice their child soldier mages, without said children understanding that what they were doing would lead to CruelAndUnusualDeath when the khert reacted, in order to set the khert on fire long enough for their cursed leader to talk to an ally without their curse killing them. Their leader was also going to give war prisoners to Shaensigin dooming them to a slow death and use as food provisions, though he grabbed the child with them out of the group to be sacrificed to the salt lizard.lizard.
** The Inak Rebellion in Cresce takes place in response to decades of slavery and discrimination, which has culminated in the Inak being scapegoated for the murder of the queen's sister and [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything sent to labour camps]]. However, what we see of the rebellion shows us that it consists in large part of brutally murdering Crescian civilians who happen to be in their way as they march towards the nobles responsible for their oppression. Their leader is also [[spoiler:Delicieu/Prakhuta/Cutter]], an utter psychopath who rants about drinking the blood and bile of Crescians and [[spoiler:plans to unleash the horrific First Silver, which he created by [[WouldHurtAChild experimenting on and killing children]], against Cresce. Ultimately the entire rebellion turns out to be a front for Prakhuta to use the despair produced by the war to power the First Silver enough to [[OmnicidalManiac annihilate the entire world.]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/AllForLuz'': As he plans on raising a rebellion to overthrow Emperor Belos before the [[FinalSolution Day of Unity]], intent on having [[AntiHero Toshiko Shigaraki ]]help him kill the tyrant, [[RebelLeader Perry Porter]] remarks to himself that no revolution in history was ever truly peaceful, and they all started and ended in violence but believes it will be WorthIt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There are a few hints that the Party itself is a result of this trope, as it is (nominally) socialist, and Winston's childhood memories indicate it came to power violently.

Changed: 560

Removed: 379

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Updating links


* This is a major issue in ''ComicBook/BeastWarsUprising''; the Resistance has noble motives for rebelling against the Builders, but Lio Convoy’s “[[ShootTheDog no matter the cost]]” attitude quickly leads to them becoming a bunch of ultra-ruthless psychos that are hardly any better than the Builders and drive out all the sane members for [[SarcasmMode the hideous crime]] of not playing jump rope with the MoralEventHorizon. By the end, [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone Lio comes to deeply regret everything about the Resistance]] and [[spoiler:the [[EarnYourHappyEnding happy ending]] only comes about, in part, because most of the radicals die [[HeelRealization or learn their lessons]] in the Vehicon Apocalypse.]]

to:

* ''ComicBook/BeastWarsUprising'': This is a major issue in ''ComicBook/BeastWarsUprising''; issue; the Resistance has noble motives for rebelling against the Builders, but Lio Convoy’s “[[ShootTheDog no matter the cost]]” attitude quickly leads to them becoming a bunch of ultra-ruthless psychos that are hardly any better than the Builders and drive out all the sane members for [[SarcasmMode the hideous crime]] of not playing jump rope with the MoralEventHorizon. By the end, [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone Lio comes to deeply regret everything about the Resistance]] and [[spoiler:the [[EarnYourHappyEnding happy ending]] only comes about, in part, because most of the radicals die [[HeelRealization or learn their lessons]] in the Vehicon Apocalypse.]]



* In the Franchise/MarvelUniverse, Skrull Kill Krew. That the Krew members are essentially suffering from Mad Skrull-Cow Disease doesn't help.
* ''ComicBook/{{Micronauts|MarvelComics}}'' featured the royal family of Homeworld as good guys, displaced from their home by violent revolutionaries under the leadership of the ObviouslyEvil Baron Karza. Karza's rhetoric seems to involve a lot of class warfare elements, with him promising immortality to the commoners.

to:

* In the Franchise/MarvelUniverse, Skrull Kill Krew. ''ComicBook/SkrullKillKrew'': That the Krew members are essentially suffering from Mad Skrull-Cow Disease doesn't help.
* ''ComicBook/{{Micronauts|MarvelComics}}'' ''ComicBook/{{Micronauts|MarvelComics}}'': The comic featured the royal family of Homeworld as good guys, displaced from their home by violent revolutionaries under the leadership of the ObviouslyEvil Baron Karza. Karza's rhetoric seems to involve a lot of class warfare elements, with him promising immortality to the commoners.



* Quite a few ''Franchise/StarWars'' ExpandedUniverse comics have attempted to extend this to the Rebel Alliance, trying to [[BlackAndGrayMorality soften the line between good guys and bad guys]], as well as explain how the cash-strapped outfit got its money. Sometimes it's just down to the occasional {{jerkass}} pilot, such as Jal Te Gniev (who later makes a HeroicSacrifice after watching a teenager he'd abused [[TakingTheBullet take the blaster bolt]] for him--and shooting with a gun that he'd bought to ''kill'' Gniev). However, it did sometimes come down to situations where in order to keep working, the Alliance and later New Republic would have to kill innocents themselves.\\
\\
In fact, after the Rebels won at Endor, destroying the Death Star, one of the first acts of the New Republic they established was to execute Grand Admiral Osvald Teshik for war crimes after he was captured in this battle. With Palpatine and Vader dead, he was pretty much one of the highest-ranking Imperials captured. Tragic fact that Teshik was one of the few decent Imperials.

to:

* ''Franchise/StarWars'': Quite a few ''Franchise/StarWars'' ExpandedUniverse comics have attempted to extend this to the Rebel Alliance, trying to [[BlackAndGrayMorality soften the line between good guys and bad guys]], as well as explain how the cash-strapped outfit got its money. Sometimes it's just down to the occasional {{jerkass}} pilot, such as Jal Te Gniev (who later makes a HeroicSacrifice after watching a teenager he'd abused [[TakingTheBullet take the blaster bolt]] for him--and shooting with a gun that he'd bought to ''kill'' Gniev). However, it did sometimes come down to situations where in order to keep working, the Alliance and later New Republic would have to kill innocents themselves.\\
\\
themselves.
**
In fact, after the Rebels won at Endor, destroying the Death Star, one of the first acts of the New Republic they established was to execute Grand Admiral Osvald Teshik for war crimes after he was captured in this battle. With Palpatine and Vader dead, he was pretty much one of the highest-ranking Imperials captured. Tragic fact that Teshik was one of the few decent Imperials.



* The [[Characters/XMenBrotherhoodOfMutants Brotherhood of Mutants]] from the ''Franchise/XMen'' comics are an example of a revolutionary group of this type that never seems to get very far with their revolution. The few times they ''have'' seized a measure of control, such as when Magneto took over the nation of San Marco in the 60s or when he (later retconned into an impostor of him) briefly seized control of New York during the "Planet X" story, out came the [[PuttingOnTheReich M-armband wearing stormtroopers]] and guillotines and, in the latter story, even ''crematoriums''.

to:

* ''ComicBook/XMen'': The [[Characters/XMenBrotherhoodOfMutants Brotherhood of Mutants]] from the ''Franchise/XMen'' comics are an example of a revolutionary group of this type that never seems to get very far with their revolution. The few times they ''have'' seized a measure of control, such as when Magneto took over the nation of San Marco in the 60s or when he (later retconned into an impostor of him) briefly seized control of New York during the "Planet X" story, out came the [[PuttingOnTheReich M-armband wearing stormtroopers]] and guillotines and, in the latter story, even ''crematoriums''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* The Free Kingdom group seen in "No Country", a comic strip in "The Phoenix", are portrayed as ruthless and dangerous to civilians, though the Prime Minister is now a dictator.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/BloodDiamond'' doesn't pull any punches in showing how bad things can get when the revolution isn't civilized. From the start characters are describing the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolutionary_United_Front RUF's]] attempt to [[AfricanTerrorists overthrow the government of Sierra Leone]] as a case of "[[FromBadToWorse government bad, rebels worse]]" and there is plenty of evidence that they are right. The populations of entire villages are killed, mutilated, or taken as slave labor to support the violent revolutionaries. Meanwhile the children of those villages are kidnapped and indoctrinated into being ChildSoldiers. The kids are then hooked on drugs (so they can murder without conscience or feeling), given [=AKs=], and set loose to destroy and loot villages that are just like their former homes. Civilians who were partying in a seemingly safe city one day are fleeing for their lives or being murdered indiscriminately the next when the rebels take it by surprise. The fate of those captured cities is nightmarish, complete with desecrated corpses being left in the street or further mutilated for fun while women are raped in nearby buildings. Some of this is left in deleted scenes, but there's more than enough in the final cut to show the trope is in effect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/PosterGirl'' rebels and the following Triumvirate are ALighterShadeOfGrey to the old Delegation, but during the uprising that overthrew the regime they indiscriminately killed people connected to the Delegation, including teenagers and children. Several more were executed afterwards and the survivors locked into a ghetto to rot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/OutOfTheShadows'': {{Defied|Trope}}. Once the riots and revolts started in reaction to the behavior of the royals, the Institute passed enough reforms to pacify the population to a degree, but Ballister notes that more change is still on the horizon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


SubTrope of ChangeVsStatusQuo.

to:

SubTrope %%SubTrope of ChangeVsStatusQuo.
Change Vs Status Quo.

Top