Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / TaxonomicTermConfusion

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


Frankly, it's not surprising that writers are sometimes ignorant or confused. Though this can also turn into a case of FanWank as many of these words also have different less precise meanings in regular English as in family and class are both used to refer to groups of similar things, a class of ships, the t-series family of trucks so a lot of these errors are just people using the words with their regular meanings. But there's really no excuse for such errors when they're committed by scientists who work in zoology and other fields that explicitly require them to be well-versed in how the nomenclature works.

to:

Frankly, it's not surprising that writers are sometimes ignorant or confused. Though this can also turn into a case of FanWank as many of these words also have different less precise meanings in regular English as in family and class are both used to refer to groups of similar things, a things (a class of ships, the t-series family of trucks trucks, and so on), so a lot of these errors are just people using the words with their regular meanings. But there's really no excuse for such errors when they're committed by scientists who work in zoology and other fields that explicitly require them to be well-versed in how the nomenclature works.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In a particularly head-hurting example, [=MUTO=] Prime in the ''Franchise/{{Monsterverse}} comic ''Godzilla: Aftershock'' is described as simultaneously evolving ''from'' the [=MUTO=]s, yet at the same time is the same species which ''created'' the [=MUTO=]s in the first place. Not only is this a complete violation of how evolution and speciation works, but would be impossible to render in modern cladistics, as it implies that the evolution of the [=MUTO=]s and Prime is nothing more than a tightly-closed loop. Somewhere, a taxonomist is probably crying.

to:

* In a particularly head-hurting example, [=MUTO=] Prime in the ''Franchise/{{Monsterverse}} ''Franchise/{{Monsterverse}}'' comic ''Godzilla: Aftershock'' is described as simultaneously evolving ''from'' the [=MUTO=]s, yet at the same time is the same species which ''created'' the [=MUTO=]s in the first place. Not only is this a complete violation of how evolution and speciation works, but would be impossible to render in modern cladistics, as it implies that the evolution of the [=MUTO=]s and Prime is nothing more than a tightly-closed loop. Somewhere, a taxonomist is probably crying.

Added: 561

Removed: 558

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In a particularly head-hurting example, [=MUTO=] Prime in the ''Franchise/{{Monsterverse}} comic ''Godzilla: Aftershock'' is described as simultaneously evolving ''from'' the [=MUTO=]s, yet at the same time is the same species which ''created'' the [=MUTO=]s in the first place. Not only is this a complete violation of how evolution and speciation works, but would be impossible to render in modern cladistics, as it implies that the evolution of the [=MUTO=]s and Prime is nothing more than a tightly-closed loop. Somewhere, a taxonomist is probably crying.



* In a particularly head-hurting example, [=MUTO=] Prime in the ''Franchise/{{Monsterverse}} comic ''Godzilla: Aftershock'', is described as simultaneously evolving ''from'' the [=MUTO=]s, yet at the same time is the same species which ''created'' the MUTOs in the first place. Not only is this a complete violation of how evolution and speciation works, but would be impossible to render in modern cladistics, as it implies that the evolution of the [=MUTO=]s and Prime is nothing more than a tightly-closed loop. Somewhere, a taxonomist is probably crying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In a particularly head-hurting example, [=MUTO=] Prime in the ''Franchise/{{Monsterverse}} comic ''Godzilla: Aftershock'', is described as simultaneously evolving ''from'' the [=MUTO=]s, yet at the same time is the same species which ''created'' the MUTOs in the first place. Not only is this a complete violation of how evolution and speciation works, but would be impossible to render in modern cladistics, as it implies that the evolution of the [=MUTO=]s and Prime is nothing more than a tightly-closed loop. Somewhere, a taxonomist is probably crying.

Added: 411

Changed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/GodzillaKingOfTheMonsters2019'': Titans are all classified under the genus ''Titanus''. Titans represent everything from Godzilla (a reptile) to King Kong (a mammal) to Mothra (an insect). While this is already bad enough, what tips this into making taxonomists everywhere cry themselves to sleep are the following, particularly egregious missteps:

to:

* ''Film/GodzillaKingOfTheMonsters2019'': Titans are all classified under the genus ''Titanus''. Titans represent everything from Godzilla (a reptile) to King Kong (a mammal) to Scylla (a mollusc) to Mothra (an insect). While this is already bad enough, what tips this into making taxonomists everywhere cry themselves to sleep are the following, particularly egregious missteps:


Added DiffLines:

** King Ghidorah is also classed as a titan, even though it's heavily implied in the film that he didn't come from Earth. If this is true, it would be impossible to classify him under the current taxonomic system ''at all'', as by virtue of all life discovered thus far being native to Earth, King Ghidorah's presence would require starting completely from scratch to account for space-faring creatures as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Of course, things are also more complicated than even this. Cladistics, dendrograms, phylogenetics... We'll just leave it at this lest YourHeadAsplode. For entirely imaginary taxanomics PlayedForLaughs, see BinomiumRidiculus.

to:

Of course, things are also more complicated than even this. Cladistics, dendrograms, phylogenetics... We'll just leave it at this lest YourHeadAsplode. For entirely imaginary taxanomics PlayedForLaughs, see BinomiumRidiculus. Compare ImprobableTaxonomySkills, the ability to fully classify an organism with just a cursory examination.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/GodzillaKingOfTheMonsters'': Titans are all classified under the genus ''Titanus''. Titans represent everything from Godzilla (a reptile) to King Kong (a mammal) to Mothra (an insect). While this is already bad enough, what tips this into making taxonomists everywhere cry themselves to sleep are the following, particularly egregious missteps:

to:

* ''Film/GodzillaKingOfTheMonsters'': ''Film/GodzillaKingOfTheMonsters2019'': Titans are all classified under the genus ''Titanus''. Titans represent everything from Godzilla (a reptile) to King Kong (a mammal) to Mothra (an insect). While this is already bad enough, what tips this into making taxonomists everywhere cry themselves to sleep are the following, particularly egregious missteps:

Top