History Main / ShutUpKirk

* In ''Manga/MuhyoAndRoji'', after Page angrily tells Enchu that Yoichi, whom he had looked at dismissively, had gone to great lengths to bring Enchu back, and implies that he himself feels somewhat responsible, Enchu responds by saying "You talk too much, as always."

* ''WesternAnimation/StevenUniverseTheMovie'': Spinel [[spoiler: interrupts Steven's [[NoMoreHoldingBackSpeech No More HoldingBackSong]] by spiking him about a thousand yards back down onto the injector, screaming that he "can't make everything better by singing some stupid song", which, [[RealityEnsues fair point, he can't]]. However, that missed the point of the song: he ''can't'' make her change, she has to actually want to change and take responsibility for herself]].

--->'''Kefka:''' Sickening! You all sound like chapters from a SELF-HELP BOOKLET!

-->'''Kefka:''' Sickening! You all sound like chapters from a SELF-HELP BOOKLET!

* When Jonathan, Zeppelli, and Speedwagon confront the vampire Dio in ''Manga/JoJosBizarreAdventurePhantomBlood'', Zeppeli notices Dio has healed his wounds from his previous fight with Johnathan and asks him how many lives he's "sucked away" to heal his wounds. Dio coolly asks Zeppeli if he remembers [[ButForMeItWasTuesday how many breads he's eaten in a day]]. In ''[[Manga/JoJosBizarreAdventureBattleTendency Battle Tendency]]'', Caesar Zeppelli swears revenge after Whamuu casually kills his friend [[TheAssimilator by walking into him]] while not even noticing him. The Pillarmen start laughing, remarking that this is hardly the first time someone swore revenge against them.

** In ''Manga/PokemonAdventures'', a pissed off Cyrus tells Dia that a stupid kid could never understand the concepts of time and space. Dia responds with a small but heartfelt speech about what time and space mean to him. Cyrus doesn't like Dia's answer (not to mention pissed that Dialga and Palkia seem to like the kid's answer over his), so he smacks the boy across the face with the Red Chain.

'''Mojo:''' (''to Blossom'') I am with Powerpuff Girl Buttercup! It is time for you to put a sock in it, the "it" being your mouth! Now I am not one to talk about not talking because if there is one thing that I like, it is expressing through words how much more intelligent I am than all those around me. But you, Powerpuff Girl Blossom, have taken this self-expression to an annoying and hurtful level.

* In one episode on ''WesternAnimation/OzzyAndDrix'', the villain Stephfinger corners Ozzy in part of the lung with a gun (well, what passes for a gun in this place) Ozzy shouts at him not to fire it, because if he misses, he'll blow a hole in the fall and they'll be sucked outside (and the place they're in the equivalent of the top of a skyscraper). The villain simply says, "Well then... I'd better not miss..." before trying to shoot him anyway. [[IWarnedYou You can probably guess what happens...]]

* ''WesternAnimation/SamuraiJack'': Jack was once shut up by a bounty-hunter who tells him "I got bills to pay, and I already addressed the envelopes." Jack begins to respond with a clever phrase, saying "I hope you haven't yet stamped the parcels which you--" but is cut off as the bounty-hunter punches him out, saying "consider 'em stamped."

* In ''Manga/UselessPrincesses'', some members of Fujishiro's gyaru group badmouth her after she gets suspended. Kurokawa, a plain-looking girl Fujishiro had befriended over the course of the story, overhears them talking and steps in to speak up for Fujishiro, but Miki fires back with a cutting TheReasonYouSuckSpeech saying that Fujishiro will always think of Kurokawa and the others as beneath her.

** In Volume 7, Ruby stands up to Salem, declaring they know everything about her thanks to the Relic of Knowledge and she may be [[spoiler:CompleteImmortality immortal]], but she's still fallible and can be stopped. [[spoiler:Salem calmly responds that Ruby's MissingMom said the exact same thing and was also wrong, leaving Ruby sobbing on the ground in front of her]].

** In Volume 7, Ruby stands up to Salem, declaring they know everything about her thanks to the Relic of Knowledge and she may be [[spoiler: [CompleteImmortality immortal]], but she's still fallible and can be stopped. [[spoiler:Salem calmly responds that Ruby's MissingMom said the exact same thing and was also wrong, leaving Ruby sobbing on the ground in front of her]].

** In Volume 7, Ruby stands up to Salem, declaring they know everything about her thanks to the Relic of Knowledge and she may be [[[spoiler: [CompleteImmortality immortal]]]], but she's still fallible and can be stopped. [[spoiler:Salem calmly responds that Ruby's MissingMom said the exact same thing and was also wrong, leaving Ruby sobbing on the ground in front of her]].

** In Volume 7, Ruby stands up to Salem, declaring they know everything about her thanks to the Relic of Knowledge and she may be [[CompleteImmortality immortal]], but she's still fallible and can be stopped. [[spoiler:Salem calmly responds that Ruby's MissingMom said the exact same thing and was also wrong, leaving Ruby sobbing on the ground in front of her]].

** Kefka, the BigBad of ''VideoGame/FinalFantasyVI'', gives a [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments priceless]] one when faced with the heroes' WorldOfCardboardSpeech before the final battle.

* Almost every time [[TheHero Twilight Sparkle]] of ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' fame gets a chance to, she always delivers a WorldOfCardboardSpeech about ThePowerOfFriendship to the current ArcVillain before or as they're being defeated. [[TheEvilsOfFreeWill Starlight]] [[{{Hypocrite}} Glimmer]], in midst of her VillainousBreakdown, does not indulge her, first by interrupting her with a [[BigShutUp Big "Quiet"]] and then giving a MotiveRant and [[TalkToTheFist magic blast]] when Twi actually finishes.

* ''WesternAnimation/StevenUniverseTheMovie'': Spinel [[spoiler: interrupts Steven's [[WorldOfCardboardSpeech World Of Cardboard Song]] by spiking him about a thousand yards back down onto the injector, screaming that he "can't make everything better by singing some stupid song", which, [[RealityEnsues fair point, he can't]]. However, that missed the point of the song: he ''can't'' make her change, she has to actually want to change and take responsibility for herself]].

The KirkSummation equivalent of ShutUpHannibal, Shut Up, Kirk! is when the villain or antagonist on the receiving end of TheSummation ([[KirkSummation Kirk or otherwise]]), PatrickStewartSpeech, [[WorldOfCardboardSpeech some other goody-goody life affirming lecture]], or even [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech a blistering critique of all their flaws]] rejects what the hero has said and reaffirms his motives and actions. When the hero spells out how his plan to destroy all life on the planet is wrong, the villain usually will respond with this trope with something like "They don't deserve to live!" or "[[SilenceYouFool Silence!]] [[WhoDares How dare you question my judgment?]]" or "[[WhatTheHellHero What gives you the moral authority to condemn me?]] [[NotSoDifferent You're just as evil!]]" or "Fool, [[TheSocialDarwinist only those with strength such as mine are fit to survive!]]", or simply "[[BluntYes Yep]]. I know, [[ForTheEvulz and I don't care]], because [[EvilIsPetty screw you, that's why]]."

The KirkSummation equivalent of ShutUpHannibal, Shut Up, Kirk! is when the villain or antagonist on the receiving end of TheSummation ([[KirkSummation Kirk or otherwise]]), PatrickStewartSpeech, [[WorldOfCardboardSpeech some other goody-goody life affirming lecture]], or even [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech a blistering critique of all their flaws]] rejects what the hero has said and reaffirms his motives and actions. When the hero spells out how his plan to destroy all life on the planet is wrong, the villain usually will respond with this trope with something like "They don't deserve to live!" or "[[SilenceYouFool Silence!]] [[WhoDares How dare you question my judgment?]]" or "[[WhatTheHellHero What gives you the moral authority to condemn me?]] [[NotSoDifferent You're just as evil!]]" or "Fool, [[TheSocialDarwinist only those with strength such as mine are fit to survive!]]", or simply "[[BluntYes Yep]]. I know, [[ForTheEvulz and I don't care]], because screw you, that's why."

The KirkSummation equivalent of ShutUpHannibal, Shut Up, Kirk! is when the villain or antagonist on the receiving end of TheSummation ([[KirkSummation Kirk or otherwise]]), PatrickStewartSpeech, [[WorldOfCardboardSpeech some other goody-goody life affirming lecture]], or even [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech a blistering critique of all their flaws]] rejects what the hero has said and reaffirms his motives and actions. When the hero spells out how his plan to destroy all life on the planet is wrong, the villain usually will respond with this trope with something like "They don't deserve to live!" or "[[SilenceYouFool Silence!]] [[WhoDares How dare you question my judgment?]]" or "[[WhatTheHellHero What gives you the moral authority to condemn me?]] [[NotSoDifferent You're just as evil!]]" or "Fool, [[TheSocialDarwinist only those with strength such as mine are fit to survive!]]", or simply "[[BluntYes Yep]]. I know, [[ForTheEvulz and I don't care]]."

The KirkSummation equivalent of ShutUpHannibal, Shut Up, Kirk! is when the villain or antagonist on the receiving end of TheSummation ([[KirkSummation Kirk or otherwise]]), PatrickStewartSpeech, [[WorldOfCardboardSpeech some other goody-goody life affirming lecture]], or even [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech a blistering critique of all their flaws]] rejects what the hero has said and reaffirms his motives and actions. When the hero spells out how his plan to destroy all life on the planet is wrong, the villain usually will respond with this trope with something like "They don't deserve to live!" or "[[SilenceYouFool Silence!]] [[WhoDares How dare you question my judgment?]]" or "[[WhatTheHellHero What gives you the moral authority to condemn me?]] [[NotSoDifferent You're just as evil!]]" or "Fool, [[TheSocialDarwinist only those with strength such as mine are fit to survive!]]", or simply "[[BluntYes Yep]]. I know, [[ForTheEvilz and I don't care]]."

The KirkSummation equivalent of ShutUpHannibal, Shut Up, Kirk! is when the villain or antagonist on the receiving end of TheSummation ([[KirkSummation Kirk or otherwise]]), PatrickStewartSpeech, [[WorldOfCardboardSpeech some other goody-goody life affirming lecture]], or even [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech a blistering critique of all their flaws]] rejects what the hero has said and reaffirms his motives and actions. When the hero spells out how his plan to destroy all life on the planet is wrong, the villain usually will respond with this trope with something like "They don't deserve to live!" or "[[SilenceYouFool Silence!]] [[WhoDares How dare you question my judgment?]]" or "[[WhatTheHellHero What gives you the moral authority to condemn me?]] [[NotSoDifferent You're just as evil!]]" or "Fool, [[TheSocialDarwinist only those with strength such as mine are fit to survive!]]"

* ''ComicStrip/{{Peanuts}}'': Lampshaded in one strip, when Charlie Brown is being attacked by Lucy, and he begins to explain to her how violence is never the answer to anything. Lucy just slugs him and says "I had to hit him quick-- he was starting to make sense!"
* ComicBook/UltimateMarvel
** A fairly tragic example in ''ComicBook/UltimateSpiderMan,'' mostly because it's taking place in a fight that ends in [[spoiler: Peter's death.]]
-->'''Peter:''' What's the plan, Osborn? I'm dying to know... What next? You kill me, [[AndThenWhat then what next]]? The son you killed won't magically come back to life! Your world as a captain of industry won't magically go back to the way it was! And your hair... Won't magically come... into fashion!
-->'''Goblin:''' But you'll be dead.
** ''ComicBook/UltimateXMen'': Jean gave a speech that they should not kill the soldiers, that it's wrong, even if they're evil. Rogue tried to silence her by touching her, but Iceman freezer her hand.
* In ''Comicbook/TheBlackRing'', when Superman realises that Luthor's hatred for him is going to poison the perfect world Lex has created, he starts out giving him a lecture on the importance of keeping hold of his peace, and then starts ''apologising'' for whatever he's done that Lex hates him for, but to Luthor it all sounds like the KirkSummation, and he screams at Supes to be quiet.

* In ''[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13604633/3/The-Rigged-Game-and-the-Trickster-s-Uprising The Rugged Game and the Trickster's Uprising]]'', Akechi is sent to assassinate Ren Kurusu, Akira's father, for investigating Shido's action to help clear his son's name. Ren tries to convince Akechi to join the fight against Shido, since he has no reason to support the politician. Akechi responds that he wants Shido to become Prime Minister so that TheReveal [[spoiler:that he is Shido's bastard child]] will be all the more damning to his reputation, right before shooting Ren before he could fire back.

* A failed version happened in ''WebVideo/DragonBallZAbridged'' when Goku, now a Super Saiyan, gives a BadassBoast about who he is. Freeza, already cheesed off that he realized that Vegeta was ''right all along'' about a Super Saiyan, blasts Goku in the head with a finger-fired blast. Goku takes it, leans back and finishes his boast.

* In ''Manga/UselessPrincesses'', some members of Fujishiro's gyaru group badmouth her after she gets suspended. Kurokawa, a plain-looking girl Fujishiro had befriended over the course of the story, overhearst them talking and steps in to speak up for Fujishiro, but Miki fires back with a cutting TheReasonYouSuckSpeech saying that Fujishiro will always think of Kurokawa and the others as beneath her.

-->'''Peter:''' What's the plan, Osborn? I'm dying to know... What next? You kill me, then what next? The son you killed won't magically come back to life! Your world as a captain of industry won't magically go back to the way it was! And your hair... Won't magically come... into fashion!

* ''WesternAnimation/StevenUniverseTheMovie'': At the climax of the movie, Steven sings a song to try and convince Spinel it's not too late to make amends for her MisplacedRetribution, and this is her response, right before [[TalkToTheFist literally pounding Steven back to Earth]]:

** Later in Ivy's lair she finally succeeds in seducing Robin and shares a deadly kiss with him. But Robin reveals he saw through her seductions and wore [[CrazyPrepared rubber lips]] to protect himself from her poison. Ivy, realizing Robin tricked her and [[TakeThatKiss stole a kiss from her]], responds by shoving him into her plant infested lily pond to drown him and mocks him further by waving him goodbye as he drowns, [[DatingCatwoman officially ending their "relationship" by "breaking up with him."]]

''(after a moment of silence she and Robin close their eyes and slowly lean in, with Ivy smirking smugly, and share a passionate kiss)''\\

----

-->'''Torres''': Let me tell you a story. Back when I was a gunnery officer: I had to aim at an enemy ship 30 kilometers away in the middle of a storm. The seas were rough that day, and still, I landed one of the two shots.
-->'''David''': Here’s a question: Was your plan elegant? The answer is... yes. At least, until Three Strike ruined it!