Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / SeriesContinuityError

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''The War Machines'' has the computer WOTAN actually say "Doctor Who is required". Even the most casual fans know that he isn't called that. The name is only ever used as a joke ("Who is he? Doctor who?"")
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The actual phrasing was "Obi-Wan, Darth Vader and the man who carried Anakin Skywalker's lightsaber", certainly implying Anakin and Vader were two different people. In one of the deftest {{RetCon}}s in the Expanded Universe, an author was able to use a ''pre-existing'' [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Concordance_of_fealty Jedi ritual]] to justify the man carrying the saber as a third, distinct Jedi who had swapped sabers with Anakin at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
koenig story

Added DiffLines:

**Walter Koenig likes to joke that offscreen they met when Chekov kept Khan waiting at a restroom, then left him with no toilet paper hence Khan remembering him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
addition

Added DiffLines:

* in the Princess Diary Mia's birthday is stated to be after Genovian Independence day In The Princess Diary 2 for some reason Mia's birthday is before Genovian Independence day
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Please, please, please stop it. In that specific episode, the Doctor stated how he ended it, so he probably meant a) it was the Daleks that caused him to do so, or b) figuratively speaking they destroyed Gallifrey before the Doctor turned it to dust.


* From the episode "Dalek", the ninth Doctor tells Rose the following: "I've got to do this. I've got to end it. '''The Daleks destroyed my home, my people.''' I've got nothing left." And in "The End of the World", he tells Rose "There was a war. We lost." Yet, in the final episode with David Tennant, it is explicitly shown that the Doctor ''himself'' destroyed both Daleks and Time Lords alike. This is also the version of events described in "The Sound of Drums", and "The Satan Pit". Either the Doctor was lying, or else the authors revised the back-story between seasons.
** Daleks started the Time War, so they're at least indirectly responsible for all the deaths that took place - not to mention that this supports the Doctor's denial concerning the atrocities that the Time Lords committted towards the end of the War. Likewise, in "Dalek" the Doctor describes the Time War like this: "The end of the Last Great Time War: everybody lost." So yes, the Time Lords lost, the Daleks lost and the Doctor lost in failing to save everybody. As early as in "Dalek" the Doctor also confesses: "I watched it happen! I ''made'' it happen!" There's no continuity errors there, only slightly different perspectives to the Doctor's tale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** From the episode "Dalek", the ninth Doctor tells Rose the following: "I've got to do this. I've got to end it. '''The Daleks destroyed my home, my people.''' I've got nothing left." And in "The End of the World", he tells Rose "There was a war. We lost." Yet, in the final episode with David Tennant, it is explicitly shown that the Doctor ''himself'' destroyed both Daleks and Time Lords alike. This is also the version of events described in "The Sound of Drums", and "The Satan Pit". Either the Doctor was lying, or else the authors revised the back-story between seasons.
*** Daleks started the Time War, so they're at least indirectly responsible for all the deaths that took place - not to mention that this supports the Doctor's denial concerning the atrocities that the Time Lords committted towards the end of the War. Likewise, in "Dalek" the Doctor describes the Time War like this: "The end of the Last Great Time War: everybody lost." So yes, the Time Lords lost, the Daleks lost and the Doctor lost in failing to save everybody. As early as in "Dalek" the Doctor also confesses: "I watched it happen! I ''made'' it happen!" There's no continuity errors there, only slightly different perspectives to the Doctor's tale.

to:

** * From the episode "Dalek", the ninth Doctor tells Rose the following: "I've got to do this. I've got to end it. '''The Daleks destroyed my home, my people.''' I've got nothing left." And in "The End of the World", he tells Rose "There was a war. We lost." Yet, in the final episode with David Tennant, it is explicitly shown that the Doctor ''himself'' destroyed both Daleks and Time Lords alike. This is also the version of events described in "The Sound of Drums", and "The Satan Pit". Either the Doctor was lying, or else the authors revised the back-story between seasons.
*** ** Daleks started the Time War, so they're at least indirectly responsible for all the deaths that took place - not to mention that this supports the Doctor's denial concerning the atrocities that the Time Lords committted towards the end of the War. Likewise, in "Dalek" the Doctor describes the Time War like this: "The end of the Last Great Time War: everybody lost." So yes, the Time Lords lost, the Daleks lost and the Doctor lost in failing to save everybody. As early as in "Dalek" the Doctor also confesses: "I watched it happen! I ''made'' it happen!" There's no continuity errors there, only slightly different perspectives to the Doctor's tale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the DS9 episode "The Alternate", Sisko strongly implies that his father is dead. This contradicts later episodes where his father is very much alive and running a restaurant in New Orleans.


Added DiffLines:

** From the episode "Dalek", the ninth Doctor tells Rose the following: "I've got to do this. I've got to end it. '''The Daleks destroyed my home, my people.''' I've got nothing left." And in "The End of the World", he tells Rose "There was a war. We lost." Yet, in the final episode with David Tennant, it is explicitly shown that the Doctor ''himself'' destroyed both Daleks and Time Lords alike. This is also the version of events described in "The Sound of Drums", and "The Satan Pit". Either the Doctor was lying, or else the authors revised the back-story between seasons.
*** Daleks started the Time War, so they're at least indirectly responsible for all the deaths that took place - not to mention that this supports the Doctor's denial concerning the atrocities that the Time Lords committted towards the end of the War. Likewise, in "Dalek" the Doctor describes the Time War like this: "The end of the Last Great Time War: everybody lost." So yes, the Time Lords lost, the Daleks lost and the Doctor lost in failing to save everybody. As early as in "Dalek" the Doctor also confesses: "I watched it happen! I ''made'' it happen!" There's no continuity errors there, only slightly different perspectives to the Doctor's tale.

Changed: 66

Removed: 1928

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I tried explaining it like that, but they weren\'t listening.


** In the revived ''Doctor Who'', the Doctor continually insists that he is 900 years old, which by ''The End of Time'' became 906. This despite the fact that in the original series, the sixth Doctor also claimed to be 900 years old, and the seventh said once that he was 953 in ''Time and the Rani''. Given that the remainder of the seventh Doctor's life and all of the eighth Doctor's life is lived out after this point, the ninth and tenth Doctors must be far older than 900 years old.
*** Not quite; it is mainly thought this is deliberate, in that the Doctor has forgotten his age or is lying in the new series. Romana seemed to believe that he was a few years off in ''The Ribos Operation'', stating that after the first few centuries things tend to get a bit foggy.
*** It's become something of a standing joke that this is the Doctor's mid-life crisis - comparing time machines with younger men, hanging around with leggy twenty-somethings ([[MyFriendsAndZoidberg and Donna]]), refusing to admit that he's passed the big 'four digits' & regenerating into progressively younger and more attractive forms. He probably just goes from 999 to 900 every century (or there abouts).

to:

** In the revived ''Doctor Who'', the Doctor continually insists that he is 900 years old, which by ''The End of Time'' became 906. This despite the fact that in the original series, the sixth Doctor also claimed to be 900 years old, and the seventh said once that he was 953 in ''Time and the Rani''. Given that the remainder of the seventh Doctor's life and all of the eighth Doctor's life is lived out after this point, the ninth and tenth Doctors must be far older than 900 years old.
*** Not quite; it is mainly thought this is deliberate, in that the Doctor has forgotten his age or is lying in the new series. Romana seemed to believe
old. WordOfGod states that he was a few years off in ''The Ribos Operation'', stating that after the first few centuries things tend to get a bit foggy.
*** It's become something
has no way of a standing joke that this is the Doctor's mid-life crisis - comparing time machines with younger men, hanging around with leggy twenty-somethings ([[MyFriendsAndZoidberg and Donna]]), refusing to admit that he's passed the big 'four digits' & regenerating into progressively younger and more attractive forms. He probably just goes from 999 to 900 every century (or there abouts).remembering his exact age.



** From the episode "Dalek", the ninth Doctor tells Rose the following: "I've got to do this. I've got to end it. '''The Daleks destroyed my home, my people.''' I've got nothing left." And in "The End of the World", he tells Rose "There was a war. We lost." Yet, in the final episode with David Tennant, it is explicitly shown that the Doctor ''himself'' destroyed both Daleks and Time Lords alike. This is also the version of events described in "The Sound of Drums", and "The Satan Pit". Either the Doctor was lying, or else the authors revised the back-story between seasons.
*** Daleks started the Time War, so they're at least indirectly responsible for all the deaths that took place - not to mention that this supports the Doctor's denial concerning the atrocities that the Time Lords committted towards the end of the War. Likewise, in "Dalek" the Doctor describes the Time War like this: "The end of the Last Great Time War: everybody lost." So yes, the Time Lords lost, the Daleks lost and the Doctor lost in failing to save everybody. As early as in "Dalek" the Doctor also confesses: "I watched it happen! I ''made'' it happen!" There's no continuity errors there, only slightly different perspectives to the Doctor's tale.

Added: 606

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In later episodes bender joins Robotology and adherents to that religion aren't allowed to drink alcohol. Instead, he's seen consuming "Mineral Oil", so it would seem that there are acceptable alternatives to alcohol for robots.

to:

** *** In later episodes bender joins Robotology and adherents to that religion aren't allowed to drink alcohol. Instead, he's seen consuming "Mineral Oil", so it would seem that there are acceptable alternatives to alcohol for robots.robots.
** In season 3, the professor specifies that there exist only two parallel universes (the other one seems to be the same as this one except that everyone wears cowboy hats). In season 4, an entire episode revolves around jumping through multiple parallel universes. But perhaps one can argue that the professor's machine had created all of those universes, rather than just a gateway to them.
** Bender has mentioned being able to remember his own "birth". In season 6, it is revealed that [[spoiler: Hermes]] was the inspector who approved him on the assembly line, but Bender does not remember that event.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->''... and yet I also become annoyed whenever the great {{Homer}} nods off.''\\
-'''{{Horace}}''', "Ars Poetica"

to:

-->''...->''... and yet I also become annoyed whenever the great {{Homer}} nods off.''\\
-'''{{Horace}}''',
''
--> -- '''{{Horace}}''',
"Ars Poetica"



-->"''They never said 'Star Trek,' they said 'Start Wreck!'''"

to:

-->"''They never said 'Star Trek,' they said 'Start Wreck!'''"'StartWreck!'''"

Changed: 160

Removed: 327

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removed all instances of "this troper", yadda yadda


*** This troper didn't see a necessary continuity error in those lines. Daleks started the Time War, so they're at least indirectly responsible for all the deaths that took place - not to mention that this supports the Doctor's denial concerning the atrocities that the Time Lords committted towards the end of the War. Likewise, in "Dalek" the Doctor describes the Time War like this: "The end of the Last Great Time War: everybody lost." So yes, the Time Lords lost, the Daleks lost and the Doctor lost in failing to save everybody. As early as in "Dalek" the Doctor also confesses: "I watched it happen! I ''made'' it happen!" There's no continuity errors there, only slightly different perspectives to the Doctor's tale.

to:

*** This troper didn't see a necessary continuity error in those lines. Daleks started the Time War, so they're at least indirectly responsible for all the deaths that took place - not to mention that this supports the Doctor's denial concerning the atrocities that the Time Lords committted towards the end of the War. Likewise, in "Dalek" the Doctor describes the Time War like this: "The end of the Last Great Time War: everybody lost." So yes, the Time Lords lost, the Daleks lost and the Doctor lost in failing to save everybody. As early as in "Dalek" the Doctor also confesses: "I watched it happen! I ''made'' it happen!" There's no continuity errors there, only slightly different perspectives to the Doctor's tale.



* Not that anyone would really expect CareBears to be concerned with continuity, this troper was immensely confused when watching her little sister's movies: the first movie tells of the Care Bears finding the Care Bear Cousins in the Forest of Feelings by accident, while ''Care Bears: A New Generation'', which is essentially an origin story, explicitly shows the Care Bear Cousins being in Care-A-Lot from the very beginning as infants. This troper paid too much attention to those movies...

to:

* Not that anyone would really expect CareBears to be concerned with continuity, this troper it was immensely confused when confusing watching her little sister's the movies: the first movie tells of the Care Bears finding the Care Bear Cousins in the Forest of Feelings by accident, while ''Care Bears: A New Generation'', which is essentially an origin story, explicitly shows the Care Bear Cousins being in Care-A-Lot from the very beginning as infants. This troper paid too much attention to those movies...infants.



** Is it This Troper or did earlier episodes that showed flashbacks of Cotton with functioning (albeit short) legs with knees, but in a later episode, Cotton mentions that when he lost his shins, they attached his knees to his ankles.. Shouldn't that technically mean that he doesn't have knees, thus changing those flashbacks?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The magicians are adopted by magicians, who were adopted by magicians, and so on. The "grandmother" would have to be the master or wife of the master of Underwood's master for it to make any sense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The most famous is Dorothy's children. Dorothy and Stan were married for 38 years, and the show began two years after that. Considering Dorothy had a shotgun wedding, one of her children needs to be at 40 for this to make sense. Although both of her kids were played by multiple actors over the years, none of them appear to be over 30.

to:

* ** The most famous is Dorothy's children. Dorothy and Stan were married for 38 years, and the show began two years after that. Considering Dorothy had a shotgun wedding, one of her children needs to be at 40 for this to make sense. Although both of her kids were played by multiple actors over the years, none of them appear to be over 30.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That was not Warp Road, that was Gate, that summoned all the really powerful warriors.


** There's another error earlier where, after being defeated King decides to use End of Earth to take out Demon Card rather than Gale. He uses Warp Road to move the dark bring from the tower to his DC HQ. There's two flaws here. The first is that Warp Road is just supposed to act as a link between the human and sentinoid world, not to wherever the uses feels like. The second is that ''Plue destroyed Warp Road chapters ago''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[FanNickname Among some fans, these are called "Flints,"]] after Marcus Flint, who was said to be a sixth year student in ''Philosopher's Stone'' but was still at Hogwarts in ''Prisoner of Azkaban''. (Rowling suggested Flint had to repeat a year.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The WholeFlashbackEpisode "And Maggie Makes Three" reveals that Homer had to renounce his dream job at the Bowl-A-Rama and return to his position as security chief in Burns' power plant when Maggie was born. This contradicts Season 1 "Homer's Odissey", where Homer was ascended to security chief (and he already had 3 children, obviously).

to:

** The WholeFlashbackEpisode WholeEpisodeFlashback "And Maggie Makes Three" reveals that Homer had to renounce his dream job at the Bowl-A-Rama and return to his position as security chief in Burns' power plant when Maggie was born. This contradicts Season 1 "Homer's Odissey", where Homer was ascended to security chief (and he already had 3 children, obviously).

Added: 342

Changed: 35

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





** Worth noting said episode depicted college-age Lisa and the rest of the similarly aged Simpson family and supporting cast in the waaaaay distant future of... [[TheFutureAintWhatItUsedToBe 2010]].

to:

** Worth noting said episode depicted college-age Lisa and the rest of the similarly aged Simpson family and supporting cast in the waaaaay distant future of... [[TheFutureAintWhatItUsedToBe [[IWantMyJetPack 2010]].


Added DiffLines:

** The WholeFlashbackEpisode "And Maggie Makes Three" reveals that Homer had to renounce his dream job at the Bowl-A-Rama and return to his position as security chief in Burns' power plant when Maggie was born. This contradicts Season 1 "Homer's Odissey", where Homer was ascended to security chief (and he already had 3 children, obviously).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* And don't forget ''StarTrekFirstContact'', which depicts Zephram Cochrane as the first human to invent warp drive and conduct the first successful warp-flight ''and'' make [[TitleDrop first contact]] with an extraterrestrial species [[spoiler: the Vulcans]]. In the ''StarTrekTOS'' episode "Metamorphosis", where the Cochrane character originated, it was stated that Cochrane only invented the warp drive; he didn't have anything to do with mankind's first contact with extraterrestrials.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* And don't forget ''StarTrekFirstContact'', which depicts Zephram Cochrane as the first human to invent warp drive and conduct the first successful warp-flight ''and'' make [[TitleDrop first contact]] with an extraterrestrial species [[spoiler: the Vulcans]]. In the ''StarTrekTOS'' episode "Metamorphosis", where the Cochrane character originated, it was stated that Cochrane only invented the warp drive; he didn't have anything to do with mankind's first contact with extraterrestrials.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

<<|ThisIndexIsHighlyImprobable|>>
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''TheChroniclesOfNarnia'' Aslan tells people on various occasions that "no one is ever told what 'would have happened'". The wording is unequivocal. Then in ''The Horse and His Boy'' he tells someone "what would have happened". He even uses those very words. Aslan is not supposed to be an inconsistent or untruthful fellow, so that can only mean it was C.S. Lewis who fucked up.

to:

* In ''TheChroniclesOfNarnia'' Aslan tells people on various occasions that "no one is ever told what 'would have happened'". The wording is unequivocal. Then in ''The Horse and His Boy'' ''[[TheMagiciansNephew The Magician's Nephew]]'' he tells someone "what would have happened". He even uses those very words. Aslan is not supposed to be an inconsistent or untruthful fellow, so that can only mean it was C.S. Lewis who fucked up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In a season 13 episode, Cotton in an audio recording, tells Hank to flush his cremated ashes down a bar toilet which General Patton had along with his past war buddies, but in a season 4 episode, he with the help of Peggy fought to be buried in a Texas government cemetery and succeeded.

to:

** In a season 13 episode, Cotton in an audio recording, tells Hank to flush his cremated ashes down a bar toilet which General Patton had along with his past Cotton's dead war buddies, but in a season 4 episode, he with the help of Peggy fought to be buried in a Texas government cemetery and succeeded.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* One of the most famous examples is ''TheGoldenGirls.'' At some point, they hired a new writing team who simply ignored previous continuity in favor of RuleOfFunny. Some famous examples:
** In one episode, Dorothy mentions that Rose is allergic to cats. However, in a flashback of how Rose and Blanche first meet, Rose mentions that she was thrown out of her apartment because her landlord didn't allow her to keep a cat she found, and was holding at the time. (Although, this could be explained with Rose's caring nature, she might put her personal pain aside to help an animal in need.)
* The most famous is Dorothy's children. Dorothy and Stan were married for 38 years, and the show began two years after that. Considering Dorothy had a shotgun wedding, one of her children needs to be at 40 for this to make sense. Although both of her kids were played by multiple actors over the years, none of them appear to be over 30.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:Film]]
* Two big examples from the ''StarWars'' films.
** First is the conflicting ages of the Republic given by Obi-Wan and Palpatine. In ''ANewHope'', Obi-Wan establishes that the Jedi have been protecting the Republic for "a thousand generations" (anywhere from 15,000 to 30,000 years depending on how you count a "generation"). In ''AttackOfTheClones'', Palpatine says that he will not let "this Republic which has stood for a thousand years" fall. Even factoring in that Obi-Wan may have been exaggerating (which, according to the ExpandedUniverse, he wasn't) that's a pretty big difference in ages.
** Another example is Leia remembering her mother as established in ''ReturnOfTheJedi'', only for Padme to die within minutes of Luke and Leia's birth in ''RevengeOfTheSith''. There ''have'' been attempts to explain this, such as the novelization implying Leia was "trying to take in every detail" or some fans' speculating Leia was referring to her foster mother but even Leland Chee, the man responsible for sorting the massive convoluted StarWars continuity, says that he's stumped.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* {{Children Of The Red King}}: When Lysander's mother appears in book three she is called Jessimine. In book five she is called Hortense, which was the name of one of her daughters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Death Eater called Rookwood has the first name Augustus in the first book he's referred to in, ''Goblet of Fire''. In all subsequent books, his first name is Algernon.
** Percy's prefect badge is referred to multiple times as silver, with the word "Prefect" on it (which Fred & George memorably once bewitch so it reads "Pinhead" instead). In ''Order of the Phoenix'', [[spoiler:Ron and Hermione]]'s prefect badges (described as looking exactly like Percy's) are red & gold with the letter "P" on them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----

to:

----*[[TheGrimAdventuresOfBillyAndMandy Grim]] becomes the Grim Reaper on at least three separate occasions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In another episode Muffy was shown in a kindergarten flashback but she moved to Elwood City in the second grade.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FullHouse:

to:

* FullHouse:''FullHouse'':



* ILoveLucy gives Ethel several different middle names, and Ricky two different ''first'' names.
** Pam Beesly of TheOffice has had her name in various incarnations; Pam Beasley, Pam Beesley, Pamela Jean Beesly, the now-canon Pamela ''Morgan'' Beesly...[[spoiler: and finally, Pam Halpert.]]

to:

* ILoveLucy ''ILoveLucy'' gives Ethel several different middle names, and Ricky two different ''first'' names.
** Pam Beesly of TheOffice ''TheOffice'' has had her name in various incarnations; Pam Beasley, Pam Beesley, Pamela Jean Beesly, the now-canon Pamela ''Morgan'' Beesly...[[spoiler: and finally, Pam Halpert.]]



* In an episode of The Suite Life of Zack and Cody, London is shown to be very competent in physical sports. In a recent episode of The Suite Life on Deck, she needs Zack's help. Did she leave her muscles in Boston?

to:

* In an episode of The ''The Suite Life of Zack and Cody, Cody'', London is shown to be very competent in physical sports. In a recent episode of The Suite Life on Deck, she needs Zack's help. Did she leave her muscles in Boston?



* Not that anyone would really expect CareBears to be concerned with continuity, this troper was immensely confused when watching her little sister's movies: the first movie tells of the Care Bears finding the Care Bear Cousins in the Forest of Feelings by accident, while Care Bears: A New Generation, which is essentially an origin story, explicitly shows the Care Bear Cousins being in Care A Lot from the very beginning as infants. This troper paid too much attention to those movies...
** IIRC, in the second movie they first lived in the Kingdom of Caring and then were moved so that the Care Bears lived in Care-a-Lot and the Cousins lived in the Forest of Feelings.

to:

* Not that anyone would really expect CareBears to be concerned with continuity, this troper was immensely confused when watching her little sister's movies: the first movie tells of the Care Bears finding the Care Bear Cousins in the Forest of Feelings by accident, while Care ''Care Bears: A New Generation, Generation'', which is essentially an origin story, explicitly shows the Care Bear Cousins being in Care A Lot Care-A-Lot from the very beginning as infants. This troper paid too much attention to those movies...
** IIRC, in the second movie they first lived in the Kingdom of Caring and then were moved so that the Care Bears lived in Care-a-Lot Care-A-Lot and the Cousins lived in the Forest of Feelings.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Buffy}}'': In Season 7, Spike is "tortured" by the Turok-Han by being drowned, despite the show and its spin-off, ''{{Angel}}'', explicitly and repeatedly stating that Vampires don't breathe. Apparently the First, the Turok-Han and ''Spike himself'' all forgot that little detail.

to:

* ''{{Buffy}}'': In Season 7, Spike is "tortured" by the Turok-Han by being drowned, despite the show and its spin-off, ''{{Angel}}'', explicitly and repeatedly stating that Vampires vampires don't breathe. Apparently the First, the Turok-Han and ''Spike himself'' all forgot that little detail.

Top