Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / SeriesContinuityError

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Dirk Pitt novels by Clive Cussler all take place in the same continuity, with past events often mentioned. At the end of ''Trojan Oddessy'', Dirk marries congresswoman Loren Smith, his love interest for most of the series. In the preperations for the wedding, it states the Loren's parents flew out to attend. The plot of Vixen 03 revolves around the MURDER of Loren's father twenty years previously, and it was stated that he was already a widower when he died.

to:

* The Dirk Pitt novels by Clive Cussler all take place in the same continuity, with past events often mentioned. At the end of ''Trojan Oddessy'', Dirk marries congresswoman Loren Smith, his love interest for most of the series. In the preperations for the wedding, it states the Loren's parents flew out to attend. The plot of Vixen 03 ''Vixen 03'' revolves around the MURDER of Loren's father twenty years previously, and it was stated that he was already a widower when he died.



* In the WizardsOfWaverlyPlace episode "Art Teacher", Mr. Laritate is surprised that his phone gets text messages when a teacher "texted in her resignation." In a later episode, he apparently still doesn't know what a text message is.

to:

* In the WizardsOfWaverlyPlace ''WizardsOfWaverlyPlace'' episode "Art Teacher", Mr. Laritate is surprised that his phone gets text messages when a teacher "texted in her resignation." In a later episode, he apparently still doesn't know what a text message is.



* Let's not forget StarTrekII, where Khan recognizes Chekov despite the latter being introduced in the second season of [[StarTrekTheOriginalSeries the series]]. The episode with Khan was part of the first season.

to:

* Let's not forget StarTrekII, ''StarTrekII'', where Khan recognizes Chekov despite the latter being introduced in the second season of [[StarTrekTheOriginalSeries the series]]. The episode with Khan was part of the first season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DonQuixote: For a book that only has one continuation, there are various examples of those errors. Then again, Cervantes was mocking [[{{FanDumb}}those fans who put too much attention to continuity]]… There are two types:

to:

* DonQuixote: ''DonQuixote'': For a book that only has one continuation, there are various examples of those errors. Then again, Cervantes was mocking [[{{FanDumb}}those fans who put too much attention to continuity]]… There are two types:



* In the first {{Animorphs}} book, Visser Three says [[SmugSnake snidely]] that it's an honor to meet Elfangor right before [[spoiler: eating him.]] This directly contradicts the backstory concocted later on, wherein the two characters have extensive history (even not counting all of the timeline changes that take place).
** Animorphs has quite a few of these in the first book or two, with one of the more obvious being Jake using Thought-speak on Tobias when Tobias is a cat and Jake is still unmorphed. Later books have them discuss the inability to use Though-speak outside of morph.
* The Dirk Pitt novels by Clive Cussler all take place in the same continuity, with past events often mentioned. At the end of Trojan Oddessy, Dirk marries congresswoman Loren Smith, his love interest for most of the series. In the preperations for the wedding, it states the Loren's parents flew out to attend. The plot of Vixen 03 revolves around the MURDER of Loren's father twenty years previously, and it was stated that he was already a widower when he died.
* In TheChroniclesOfNarnia Aslan tells people on various occasions that "no one is ever told what 'would have happened'". The wording is unequivocal. Then in ''The Horse and His Boy'' he tells someone "what would have happened". He even uses those very words. Aslan is not supposed to be an inconsistent or untruthful fellow, so that can only mean it was C.S. Lewis who fucked up.
* In the {{Flashman}} series, Flashman has an uncle Bindley who works at an office responsible for assigning military commissions, and at a couple of points, Flashman is forced to seek his help getting a commission. Consistent in the books is that Bindley dislikes Flashman, but the reason for this depends on the book. In the original novel, Bindley is from the aristocratic side of the family and doesn't like Flashman because he's from the commoner side. Later books reverse this by having Bindley as the commoner and resenting Flashman, who looks down on him. It's possible that this is a deliberate use of UnreliableNarrator, since the novels are [[LiteraryAgentHypothesis supposedly]] extracts from memoirs Flashman wrote as a very old man.

to:

* In the first {{Animorphs}} ''{{Animorphs}}'' book, Visser Three says [[SmugSnake snidely]] that it's an honor to meet Elfangor right before [[spoiler: eating him.]] This directly contradicts the backstory concocted later on, wherein the two characters have extensive history (even not counting all of the timeline changes that take place).
** Animorphs ''Animorph'' has quite a few of these in the first book or two, with one of the more obvious being Jake using Thought-speak on Tobias when Tobias is a cat and Jake is still unmorphed. Later books have them discuss the inability to use Though-speak outside of morph.
* The Dirk Pitt novels by Clive Cussler all take place in the same continuity, with past events often mentioned. At the end of Trojan Oddessy, ''Trojan Oddessy'', Dirk marries congresswoman Loren Smith, his love interest for most of the series. In the preperations for the wedding, it states the Loren's parents flew out to attend. The plot of Vixen 03 revolves around the MURDER of Loren's father twenty years previously, and it was stated that he was already a widower when he died.
* In TheChroniclesOfNarnia ''TheChroniclesOfNarnia'' Aslan tells people on various occasions that "no one is ever told what 'would have happened'". The wording is unequivocal. Then in ''The Horse and His Boy'' he tells someone "what would have happened". He even uses those very words. Aslan is not supposed to be an inconsistent or untruthful fellow, so that can only mean it was C.S. Lewis who fucked up.
* In the {{Flashman}} ''{{Flashman}}'' series, Flashman has an uncle Bindley who works at an office responsible for assigning military commissions, and at a couple of points, Flashman is forced to seek his help getting a commission. Consistent in the books is that Bindley dislikes Flashman, but the reason for this depends on the book. In the original novel, Bindley is from the aristocratic side of the family and doesn't like Flashman because he's from the commoner side. Later books reverse this by having Bindley as the commoner and resenting Flashman, who looks down on him. It's possible that this is a deliberate use of UnreliableNarrator, since the novels are [[LiteraryAgentHypothesis supposedly]] extracts from memoirs Flashman wrote as a very old man.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Malcolm himself jokes about this in "The Lost World", telling people that he was only "mostly dead", and that reports of his death came from inaccurate news stories. That's the given explanation for why he's apparently dead at the end of the first book, but still alive in the second.

to:

** Malcolm himself jokes about this in "The ''The Lost World", World'', telling people that he was only "mostly dead", and that reports of his death came from inaccurate news stories. That's the given explanation for why he's apparently dead at the end of the first book, but still alive in the second.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* At the end of "Jurassic Park" by Michael Crichton it is clearly stated that Chaos Mathematician Ian Malcolm dies. Yet, in the second book, "The Lost World" he is alive. No explanation is ever given.

to:

* At the end of "Jurassic Park" ''Jurassic Park'' by Michael Crichton it is clearly stated that Chaos Mathematician Ian Malcolm dies. Yet, in the second book, "The ''The Lost World" World'' he is alive. No explanation is ever given.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Matt Olsen of the '''{{ComicBooks/WITCH}}'' comic series is one of the worst examples of this. When he first appears, he's a student with a thing for guitars, has a grandfather who owns a pet store and is utterly shocked when his girlfriend, Will Vandom, reveals her secret identity as a Guardian. However, come the second chapter of the New Power storyline and it's revealed that he's actually from Kandrakar, knows magic and already KNEW Will and her friends were Guardians. And there's been nothing to try to fix the previously established backgrounds.

to:

* Matt Olsen of the '''{{ComicBooks/WITCH}}'' ''{{ComicBooks/WITCH}}'' comic series is one of the worst examples of this. When he first appears, he's a student with a thing for guitars, has a grandfather who owns a pet store and is utterly shocked when his girlfriend, Will Vandom, reveals her secret identity as a Guardian. However, come the second chapter of the New Power storyline and it's revealed that he's actually from Kandrakar, knows magic and already KNEW Will and her friends were Guardians. And there's been nothing to try to fix the previously established backgrounds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Matt Olsen of the {{ComicBooks/WITCH}} comic series is one of the worst examples of this. When he first appears, he's a student with a thing for guitars, has a grandfather who owns a pet store and is utterly shocked when his girlfriend, Will Vandom, reveals her secret identity as a Guardian. However, come the second chapter of the New Power storyline and it's revealed that he's actually from Kandrakar, knows magic and already KNEW Will and her friends were Guardians. And there's been nothing to try to fix the previously established backgrounds.
* In one part of {{Watchmen}} Dr. Manhattan is totally unfamiliar with the expression "What's up?" and takes it literally when asked. In another part he asks Janey Slater, "What's up, Janey?" This is a guy who experiences all times as one.

to:

* Matt Olsen of the {{ComicBooks/WITCH}} '''{{ComicBooks/WITCH}}'' comic series is one of the worst examples of this. When he first appears, he's a student with a thing for guitars, has a grandfather who owns a pet store and is utterly shocked when his girlfriend, Will Vandom, reveals her secret identity as a Guardian. However, come the second chapter of the New Power storyline and it's revealed that he's actually from Kandrakar, knows magic and already KNEW Will and her friends were Guardians. And there's been nothing to try to fix the previously established backgrounds.
* In one part of {{Watchmen}} ''{{Watchmen}}'' Dr. Manhattan is totally unfamiliar with the expression "What's up?" and takes it literally when asked. In another part he asks Janey Slater, "What's up, Janey?" This is a guy who experiences all times as one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In chapter 48 of ElfenLied, Nana's sleeve, which was torn off in the previous chapter, reappears.

to:

* In chapter 48 of ElfenLied, ''ElfenLied'', Nana's sleeve, which was torn off in the previous chapter, reappears.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The injury confusion is referenced in the Guy Ritchie film, where Watson limps throughout the film but is also wounded in his shoulder by shrapnel near the end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->''... and yet I also become annoyed whenever the great {{Homer}} nods off.''\\
-'''{{Horace}}''', "Ars Poetica"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** A more plausible explanation is that the ''story of him dying and being left behind in the first place'' was the inaccurate part; he was presumably severely wounded, but survived and was able to escape with the others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In later episodes bender joins Robotology and adherents to that religion aren't allowed to drink alcohol. Instead, he's seen consuming "Mineral Oil", so it would seem that there are acceptable alternatives to alcohol for robots.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*In an episode of The Suite Life of Zack and Cody, London is shown to be very competent in physical sports. In a recent episode of The Suite Life on Deck, she needs Zack's help. Did she leave her muscles in Boston?

Added: 243

Changed: 160

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n* The StarWarsExpandedUniverse seems to have these a'plenty. Some biggies:
** Dac or Mon Calamari? {{Retcon}}ned as Dac being the indigenous name for the planet.
** The Marvels introduced us to "your father, Darth Vader, and Obi-Wan Kenobi". Also, Obi-Wan has black hair.
** Chewie only having one son when WordOfGod says Wookiees have multiple births. And [[FetishFuel six breasts]]. Thanks a lot, George!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "Like Goku" could simply mean a child, and Vegita was 3 when their home world was destroyed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*In the WizardsOfWaverlyPlace episode "Art Teacher", Mr. Laritate is surprised that his phone gets text messages when a teacher "texted in her resignation." In a later episode, he apparently still doesn't know what a text message is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
changing example a bit


* In the {{Flashman}} series, Flashman at times applies for various military commissions with his uncle Bindley who dislikes him. However, the reason for the dislike depends upon the book. In the first novel, Bindley is from the aristocratic side of the family and doesn't like Flashman because he's from the commoner side. Later books reverse this by having Bindley as the commoner and resenting Flashman, who looks down on him. It's possible that this is deliberate- the novels are [[LiteraryAgentHypothesis supposedly]] extracts from memoirs Flashman wrote as a very old man.


to:

* In the {{Flashman}} series, Flashman at times applies for various military commissions with his has an uncle Bindley who works at an office responsible for assigning military commissions, and at a couple of points, Flashman is forced to seek his help getting a commission. Consistent in the books is that Bindley dislikes him. However, Flashman, but the reason for the dislike this depends upon on the book. book. In the first original novel, Bindley is from the aristocratic side of the family and doesn't like Flashman because he's from the commoner side. Later books reverse this by having Bindley as the commoner and resenting Flashman, who looks down on him. It's possible that this is deliberate- a deliberate use of UnreliableNarrator, since the novels are [[LiteraryAgentHypothesis supposedly]] extracts from memoirs Flashman wrote as a very old man.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I "think" this example is this trope rather than say a retcon




to:

\n* In the {{Flashman}} series, Flashman at times applies for various military commissions with his uncle Bindley who dislikes him. However, the reason for the dislike depends upon the book. In the first novel, Bindley is from the aristocratic side of the family and doesn't like Flashman because he's from the commoner side. Later books reverse this by having Bindley as the commoner and resenting Flashman, who looks down on him. It's possible that this is deliberate- the novels are [[LiteraryAgentHypothesis supposedly]] extracts from memoirs Flashman wrote as a very old man.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Apparently WordOfGod has said she's a separate but similar species. Regardless, in the prison in Tools of Destruction they mention "prisoner's of lombax descent", so Angela could also be half-lombax.

to:

** Apparently WordOfGod has said she's a separate but similar species. Regardless, in the prison in Tools of Destruction they mention "prisoner's of lombax Lombax descent", so Angela could also be half-lombax.
half-Lombax.
*** FlipFlopOfGod. As of ''A Crack In Time'' Angela has been confirmed as a Lombax (apparently females don't have tails).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In one part of {{Watchmen}} Dr. Manhattan is totally unfamiliar with the expression "What's up?" and takes it literally when asked. In another part he asks the original Silk Spectre, "What's up, Janey?" This is a guy who experiences all times as one.

to:

* In one part of {{Watchmen}} Dr. Manhattan is totally unfamiliar with the expression "What's up?" and takes it literally when asked. In another part he asks the original Silk Spectre, Janey Slater, "What's up, Janey?" This is a guy who experiences all times as one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
right show, wrong character


* In a newer episode of ''{{Arthur}}'' Muffy is seen in a Kindergarten class photo when in fact she transferred in third grade.

to:

* In a newer episode of ''{{Arthur}}'' Muffy Sue Ellen is seen in a Kindergarten class photo when in fact she transferred in third grade.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In TheChroniclesOfNaria Aslan tells people on various occasions that "no one is ever told what 'would have happened'". The wording is unequivocal. Then in ''The Horse and His Boy'' he tells someone "what would have happened". He even uses those very words. Aslan is not supposed to be an inconsistent or untruthful fellow, so that can only mean it was C.S. Lewis who fucked up.


to:

* In TheChroniclesOfNaria TheChroniclesOfNarnia Aslan tells people on various occasions that "no one is ever told what 'would have happened'". The wording is unequivocal. Then in ''The Horse and His Boy'' he tells someone "what would have happened". He even uses those very words. Aslan is not supposed to be an inconsistent or untruthful fellow, so that can only mean it was C.S. Lewis who fucked up.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n* In TheChroniclesOfNaria Aslan tells people on various occasions that "no one is ever told what 'would have happened'". The wording is unequivocal. Then in ''The Horse and His Boy'' he tells someone "what would have happened". He even uses those very words. Aslan is not supposed to be an inconsistent or untruthful fellow, so that can only mean it was C.S. Lewis who fucked up.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In one part of {{Watchmen}} Dr. Manhattan is totally unfamiliar with the expression "What's up?" and takes it literally when asked. In another part he asks the original Silk Spectre, "What's up, Janey?" This is a guy who experiences all times as one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[OrSoIHeard Apparently]] WordOfGod has said she's a separate but similar species. Regardless, in the prison in Tools of Destruction they mention "prisoner's of lombax descent", so Angela could also be half-lombax.

to:

** [[OrSoIHeard Apparently]] Apparently WordOfGod has said she's a separate but similar species. Regardless, in the prison in Tools of Destruction they mention "prisoner's of lombax descent", so Angela could also be half-lombax.

Changed: 609

Removed: 1112

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removing natter and contradictory statements with a simple and more clarified explanation


** Also, Harry somehow fails to notice the Thestrals pulling the carriages at the end of ''Goblet of Fire'' only to do so the next book.
*** [[WordOfGod JK Rowling herself]] says that this is because she didn't want to add that crap in the end of a book, stuffing it. Her [[JustifiedTrope in-universe explanation]] is that takes some time to "process" a death and come to terms with it; only after then can you see Thestrals.
*** What was the reason for him not being able to see them from the beginning? After, you know, seeing at least his mother die right next to him?
*** Harry was, at most, ''one year old''. Most kids don't understand what death is until they're about six to nine years old. Considering how he believed the Dursleys when they said his parents died in a car accident, he doesn't even ''remember'' seeing her die. Before anyone mentions the dementors, they wouldn't count since 1. he only heard her last words and not her death, and 2. you need to ''see'' someone die. Quirrel doesn't count either since Harry fainted before he died.
**** But he ''didn't'' see his parents die at all, not even his mother. He was lying in the crib and only saw green light fill the room. Both J.K. Rowling herself and the seventh book confirm this.

to:

** Also, Harry somehow fails to notice the Thestrals pulling the carriages at the end of ''Goblet of Fire'' only to do so the next book.
***
book. [[WordOfGod JK Rowling herself]] says that this is because she didn't want to add that crap in the Thestrals at the end of a book, stuffing it. Her [[JustifiedTrope in-universe explanation]] is that takes some time to "process" a death and come to terms with it; only after then can you see Thestrals. \n*** What was the reason for him not being able to see them from the beginning? After, you know, seeing at least his mother die right next to him?\n*** Harry was, at most, ''one year old''. Most kids don't understand what death It is until they're about six to nine years old. Considering how he believed the Dursleys when they said his parents died in a car accident, he doesn't even ''remember'' seeing her die. Before anyone mentions the dementors, they wouldn't count since 1. he only heard her last words and not her death, and 2. you need to ''see'' someone die. Quirrel doesn't count either since Harry fainted before he died.
**** But
also worth noting that he ''didn't'' see his parents die at all, not even his mother. He was lying in the crib and only saw green light fill the room. Both J.K. Rowling herself and the seventh book confirm this. This explains why he was not able to see the Thestrals from the beginning of the first book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In fairness, this might be the point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Methinks this is [[Centipede'sDilemma another Trope entirely]]

to:

** Methinks this is [[Centipede'sDilemma Seems to be an inversion of [[CentipedesDilemma another Trope entirely]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Methinks this is [[Centipede'sDilemma another Trope entirely]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In a season 13 episode, Cotton in an audio recording, tells Hank to flush his cremated ashes down a bar toilet which General Patton once used along with his past war buddies, but in a season 4 episode, he with the help of Peggy fought to be buried in a Texas government cemetery and succeeded.

to:

** In a season 13 episode, Cotton in an audio recording, tells Hank to flush his cremated ashes down a bar toilet which General Patton once used had along with his past war buddies, but in a season 4 episode, he with the help of Peggy fought to be buried in a Texas government cemetery and succeeded.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Is it This Troper or did earlier episodes that showed flashbacks of Cotton with functioning (albeit short) legs with knees, but in a later episode, Cotton mentions that when he lost his shins, they attached his knees to his ankles.. Shouldn't that technically mean that he doesn't have knees, thus changing those flashbacks?

Top