Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ReasonableAuthorityFigure

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* His Honor, Edward Dyer, Mayor of a fictionalized Orlando in the ''GlobalGuardiansPBEMUniverse'' setting. Are you a superior coming to him to report an alien invasion? He'll listen and even take your advice on how to defend the city. Zombies? He'll listen. Supervillains infiltrating the mayor's office. He'll even listen to you if he's your prime suspect. Of course, if you're wrong, he'll read you the riot act for wasting his time.

Added: 699

Removed: 699

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Grand Councilwoman from ''Disney/LiloAndStitch'' is rather reasonable for being the head of the [[TheFederation Galactic Federation]], although like most aliens, she believes Pleakly when he tells her to spare Earth from destructions because mosquitos are endangered.
** She's also willing to give Stitch a chance to speak for himself when he's intially introduced at Jumba's trial, rather than outright condemning him. Then at the end of the film [[spoiler:she expresses regret at having to take Stitch in after he's shown to have calmed down and matured somewhat, and seems rather satisfied when [[LoopholeAbuse Lilo provides a loophole]] as to why the Grand Councilwoman can't take Stitch]].






* The Grand Councilwoman from ''Disney/LiloAndStitch'' is rather reasonable for being the head of the [[TheFederation Galactic Federation]], although like most aliens, she believes Pleakly when he tells her to spare Earth from destructions because mosquitos are endangered.
** She's also willing to give Stitch a chance to speak for himself when he's intially introduced at Jumba's trial, rather than outright condemning him. Then at the end of the film [[spoiler:she expresses regret at having to take Stitch in after he's shown to have calmed down and matured somewhat, and seems rather satisfied when [[LoopholeAbuse Lilo provides a loophole]] as to why the Grand Councilwoman can't take Stitch]].

Added: 652

Changed: 12

Removed: 612

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Film]]

to:

[[folder:Film]][[folder: Film - Animated]]



* The president in the ''TheDayAfterTomorrow'' became convinced of the meteorologists' prediction of impending doom and ordered the evacuation of the southern United States.



* The doctor from ''OneFlewOverTheCuckoosNest'', while bearing in mind that he's dealing with a load of crazy people, is very kind and agreeable with them.



* The general in ''TheIronGiant'' attempts to understand the situation and not assume the worst when confronted with a giant alien robot. Unfortunately, the FBI agent on the scene happens to be a complete bigot, and goes out of his way just to provoke the Iron Giant into retaliation.
[[/folder]]

[[folder:Film - Live Action]]

* The president in the ''TheDayAfterTomorrow'' became convinced of the meteorologists' prediction of impending doom and ordered the evacuation of the southern United States.
* The doctor from ''OneFlewOverTheCuckoosNest'', while bearing in mind that he's dealing with a load of crazy people, is very kind and agreeable with them.



* The general in ''TheIronGiant'' attempts to understand the situation and not assume the worst when confronted with a giant alien robot. Unfortunately, the FBI agent on the scene happens to be a complete bigot, and goes out of his way just to provoke the Iron Giant into retaliation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In that same universe, [[spoiler: Jonathan, as king, is considered a fair and benevolent ruler. He (technically) lifts the ban on female knights. His queen, Thayet, is an ActionGirl that starts her own band of "Riders" to serve the country.]]
** It's the same way with his father.
*** [[spoiler:Basically, Conté's king and queen are generally examples of this trope.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In later seasons, Head Detective Carlton Lassiter also applies. While still outwardly rude and disbelieving of Shawn, he sees that Shawn gets results and lets more and more of his childishness by.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''[[HisFairAssassin The His Fair Assassin trilogy]]'' has Duchess Anne, the young but extraordinarily level-headed royal served by the protagonist leads.

to:

* ''[[HisFairAssassin [[HisFairAssassin The His Fair Assassin trilogy]]'' trilogy]] has Duchess Anne, the young but extraordinarily level-headed royal served by the protagonist leads.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "[[HisFairAssassin The His Fair Assassin trilogy]]" has Duchess Anne, the young but extraordinarily level-headed royal served by the protagonist leads.

to:

* "[[HisFairAssassin ''[[HisFairAssassin The His Fair Assassin trilogy]]" trilogy]]'' has Duchess Anne, the young but extraordinarily level-headed royal served by the protagonist leads.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "[[HisFairAssassin]]" has Duchess Anne, the young but extraordinarily level-headed royal served by the protagonist leads.

to:

* "[[HisFairAssassin]]" "[[HisFairAssassin The His Fair Assassin trilogy]]" has Duchess Anne, the young but extraordinarily level-headed royal served by the protagonist leads.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Carol Saroyan from "{{Bones}}", also DaChief, is very reasonable (albiet exasperated) with her team of squints. While she feels like the OnlySaneWoman, she respects the work her colleagues do and assists them accordingly.

to:

* Carol Saroyan from "{{Bones}}", ''{{Bones}}'', also DaChief, is very reasonable (albiet exasperated) with her team of squints. While she feels like the OnlySaneWoman, she respects the work her colleagues do and assists them accordingly.

Added: 474

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Duke Gareth in ''[[TortallUniverse Song of the Liones]]'' was one, being strict and authoritative but at the same time, understanding and kind. Despite giving Alanna a stern lecture for beating up a boy who had ruthlessly bullied her (even breaking her arm at one point), he had supported her (even telling her privately that Ralon deserved to be thrashed) and was secretly pleased that she managed to do it on her own.

to:

* Duke Gareth in ''[[TortallUniverse Song of the Liones]]'' Lioness]]'' was one, being strict and authoritative but at the same time, understanding and kind. Despite giving Alanna a stern lecture for beating up a boy who had ruthlessly bullied her (even breaking her arm at one point), he had supported her (even telling her privately that Ralon deserved to be thrashed) and was secretly pleased that she managed to do it on her own.own.
* "[[HisFairAssassin]]" has Duchess Anne, the young but extraordinarily level-headed royal served by the protagonist leads.


Added DiffLines:

* Carol Saroyan from "{{Bones}}", also DaChief, is very reasonable (albiet exasperated) with her team of squints. While she feels like the OnlySaneWoman, she respects the work her colleagues do and assists them accordingly.
** From earlier seasons, Dr. Goodman is an example as well. While he was often tired of his team's antics, he treated them well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ComicBook/UsagiYojimbo: Katsuichi is the biggest example, being a respected swordsman and fair, if stern, teacher. Inspector Ishida is a kind and pleasant old policeman, and Usagi's firm friend, never once falling under InspectorJavert. This trope is usually played with in the many towns Usagi visits, often meeting the masgriate or other headman. Sometimes the result is friendly, where one masgriate and the police force sided behind Usagi against a team of bandits. Sometimes they're corrupt, like Masgriate Oda, who taxed people heavily and killed several who oppose him. Sometimes they just don't like the main character, but are otherwise not villainous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In AndreNorton's ''Literature/IceCrown'', Princess Ludorica conceeds that her grandfather is right to use her as a tool for their kingdom's safety.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The Emperor in ''Disney/{{Mulan}}'', who is clearly the wisest and most level headed person in the movie, especially when contrasted with Chi Fu, his obnoxious, opinionated advisor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Jerry usually qualifies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/StarTrekIntoDarkness'':
** Admiral Christopher Pike, who is still around as Kirk's mentor after the events of [[Film/StarTrek the 2009 film]].
** [[PeterWeller Admiral Marcus]], Carol's father and the chief of Starfleet Command. [[spoiler:He's really [[BigBadEnsemble evil]], and attempts to destroy the ''Enterprise'' to cover up Section 31's actions and start a war with the Klingons]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None








[[folder:Live Action TV]

to:

[[folder:Live Action TV]TV]]

Added: 1127

Changed: 605

Removed: 307

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Heroes like the IgnoredExpert have a hard enough time dealing with [[DyingLikeAnimals idiotic peasants]], but their deepest problems invariably come from the antagonistic local authorities, who are dead set on ignoring their warnings and running them out of town because it's politically expedient.

Which makes the existence of the Reasonable Authority Figure all the rarer. Fully aware that MachiavelliWasWrong, he'll listen to those "[[RagtagBunchOfMisfits crazy kids]]" when they say there's a fugitive nearby, and actually logically consider their arguments and not discard them out of hand. However, their openness to the heroes' ideas doesn't mean they'll follow AgentMulder's crazy ideas blindly. Often, they'll ask for [[WeNeedToGetProof proof]] and facts rather than follow baseless accusations, but even then, they'll usually humor the heroes and go check out their theories; whether it pans out or turns into a [[NotSoImaginaryFriend dead end]] depends on how far along the story is.

Usually LawfulGood. Generally the person characters must BringNewsBack to. And the chain of command that goes past the basic CommandRoster. The RebelliousRebel is motivated by loyalty to him.

Noteworthy because, if the hero does manage to convince them, can help FightingForSurvival. But they may have to ShootTheDog as part of their position. Being in a position where you are responsible for millions and do not think that AMillionIsAStatistic can be quite hard.

to:

Heroes like the IgnoredExpert have a hard enough time dealing with [[DyingLikeAnimals idiotic peasants]], but their deepest problems invariably come from the antagonistic local authorities, who are dead set on ignoring their warnings and running them out of town because it's politically expedient.

Which
expedient. This makes the existence of the Reasonable Authority Figure all the rarer. rarer.

Fully aware that MachiavelliWasWrong, he'll listen to those "[[RagtagBunchOfMisfits crazy kids]]" when they say there's a fugitive nearby, and actually logically consider their arguments and not discard instead discarding them out of hand. However, their openness to the heroes' ideas doesn't mean they'll follow AgentMulder's crazy ideas blindly. Often, they'll ask for [[WeNeedToGetProof proof]] and facts rather than follow baseless accusations, but even then, they'll usually humor the heroes and go check out their theories; whether it pans out or turns into a [[NotSoImaginaryFriend dead end]] depends on how far along the story is.

Usually LawfulGood. Generally LawfulGood and the person characters must BringNewsBack to. And They are the chain of command that goes past the basic CommandRoster. The RebelliousRebel is motivated by loyalty to him.

Noteworthy because, if the hero does manage to convince them, they can help FightingForSurvival. But FightingForSurvival but they may have to ShootTheDog as part of their position. Being in a position where you are responsible for millions and do not think that AMillionIsAStatistic can be quite hard.



'''This position means that they can often end the story very quickly unless other obstacles intervene. Which means [[HowToStopTheDeusExMachina they usually do intervene.]]'''
# They're made [[ConservationOfCompetence inaccessible]] by the ObstructiveBureaucrat and EvilChancellor who has it in for the heroes, trying to stop them getting an audience or [[MaliciousSlander outright lying]] to destroy their arguments and [[ClearMyName reputation]]. Barring this, the ReasonableAuthorityFigure might just be plain [[BeleagueredBureaucrat busy, overworked, or under-funded]] and might not have the time or resources to adequately solve the hero's problem as quickly as he or she would like.

to:

'''This position means that they can often end the story very quickly unless other obstacles intervene. Which means [[HowToStopTheDeusExMachina they usually do intervene.]]'''
# They're made [[ConservationOfCompetence inaccessible]] by the ObstructiveBureaucrat and EvilChancellor who has it in for the heroes, trying to stop them getting an audience or [[MaliciousSlander outright lying]] to destroy their arguments and [[ClearMyName reputation]]. Barring this, the ReasonableAuthorityFigure might just be plain [[BeleagueredBureaucrat busy, overworked, or under-funded]] and might not have the time or resources to adequately solve the hero's problem as quickly as he or she would like.



# If he is not the absolute ruler, InterserviceRivalry and DividedWeFall can be a problem even after you persuade him. Indeed, that you speak with this character may induce his rivals to regard you as an enemy, or at least to undercut you in hopes of ensuring that ''their'' favorites succeed in your place.

to:

# If he is not the absolute ruler, InterserviceRivalry and DividedWeFall can be a problem even after you persuade him. Indeed, that you speak with this character may induce his rivals to regard you as an enemy, enemy or at least to undercut you in hopes of ensuring that ''their'' favorites succeed in your place.



* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'''s Lord Vetinari is one deep down, though for his own reasons he hides it well. Vimes also fits the trope; his incorruptibility is so famous that suggestions to bribe him are tkane as jokes.

to:

* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'''s Lord Vetinari is one deep down, though for his own reasons he hides it well. Vimes also fits the trope; his incorruptibility is so famous that suggestions to bribe him are tkane taken as jokes.



* [[EccentricMentor Dumbledore]] of ''HarryPotter'' fame is perhaps too easygoing when it comes to Harry, but considering the trouble he tends to attract, it pays to listen when Harry says basilisks/death eaters/trolls/whatever are mucking about.
** Albus Dumbledore is one of the few authority figures in the ''HarryPotter'' universe who is consistently not evil ''and'' [[TheChessmaster on the ball]] as far as what's going on, and therefore knows well enough to trust the heroes (and occasionally bail them out of school trouble when it's convenient).

to:

* [[EccentricMentor Dumbledore]] of ''HarryPotter'' fame is perhaps too easygoing when it comes to Harry, but considering the trouble he tends to attract, it pays to listen when Harry says basilisks/death eaters/trolls/whatever are mucking about.
** Albus Dumbledore is
about. He's one of the few authority figures in the ''HarryPotter'' universe who is consistently not evil ''and'' [[TheChessmaster on the ball]] as far as what's going on, and therefore knows well enough to trust the heroes (and occasionally bail them out of school trouble when it's convenient).




to:

*''Literature/ExilesViolin'':
**King Shaun II of Kenesta doesn't squash civil unrest with a heavy hand. Instead, he asks them to select [[TheFace a spokesman]] to send to an audience with him the next day so he can address their concerns. In the audience itself it crossses into OnlySaneMan because he is the only one that recognizes the stupidity in declaring war against a country that they just lost against to reclaim land that never wanted to be part of them.
** General Colborough is calm, rational and Jacquie notes that [[spoiler: when he initates his coup]] that he is not doing it out of ego or warmongering but because he believes it is the best course of action. When one of his subordinates claims that Jacquie and Clay are spies from another country simply because of a family squable, he says the idea is ridiculous but still wants them questioned because they shouldn'nt have been in a meeting that was arranged solely for locals.
** Admiral [=LeBlanc=] isn't keen on listing to a strange detective saying treanous and unlikely things, but, given to the strange circumstances and other things that Jacquie points out, she is willing to listen.



[[folder:Live Action TV]]
* Col. Potter on {{Series/Mash}} ''is'' this trope. His decisions are always the right ones, and he's not afraid to yell at the DesignatedHero when he happens to be in the wrong.

to:

[[folder:Live Action TV]]
TV]
* ''{{Series/Mash}}'': Col. Potter on {{Series/Mash}} ''is'' this trope. His Potter's decisions are always the right ones, and he's not afraid to yell at the DesignatedHero when he happens to be in the wrong.

Added: 259

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Kingsley Shacklebolt, head of the Auror department at the Ministry ''and'' the de facto leader of the Order of the Phoenix, is so reasonable he even gets along with the Dursleys. Too bad the less reasonable Ministers (Fudge, later Scrimgeour) outrank him.



** [[TheThrawnTrilogy Grand Admiral Thrawn]] is one of the bad guys (although [[AffablyEvil not strictly evil]]) and [[YouHaveFailedMe executed a tractor beam operator]] for failing to catch Luke's ship, and then lying to Thrawn about not having performed training that could have kept the tractor beam emitter from eating a torpedo, and attempted to shift the blame to another -- but in a later book he promoted a new tractor beam operator who had failed to catch another ship Luke was on because although the guy had failed, he'd tried new method and accepted responsibility when the tactic didn't work. He also treated his second-in-command and occasional CommanderContrarian with respect.

to:

** [[TheThrawnTrilogy Grand Admiral Thrawn]] is one of the bad guys (although [[AffablyEvil not strictly evil]]) and [[YouHaveFailedMe executed a tractor beam operator]] for failing to catch Luke's ship, and then lying to Thrawn about not having performed training that could have kept the tractor beam emitter from eating a torpedo, and attempted to shift the blame to another -- but in a later book he promoted a new tractor beam operator who had failed to catch another ship Luke was on because although the guy had failed, he'd tried a new method and accepted responsibility when the tactic didn't work. He also treated his second-in-command and occasional CommanderContrarian with respect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/ICarly'' features Principal Franklin, the principal of Carly's school. He's not strict at all, once getting Carly and her friends out of detention, and even giving Carly a reprieve when her friend hacked into the school's computer to change her grades. This may be [[HandWave partially explained]] by the fact that the principal is a big fan of Carly's webshow, and she wouldn't be able to do the show if she were spending all her time in detention.

to:

* ''Series/ICarly'' features Ultimately played for laughs (just like everything else) in ''Series/ICarly''. Principal Franklin, the principal of Carly's school. He's school, is not strict at all, once getting Carly and her friends out of detention, and even giving Carly a reprieve when her friend hacked into the school's computer to change her grades. This may be [[HandWave In the end however, this is at least partially[[HandWave partially explained]] by the fact that the principal is a big fan of Carly's webshow, and she wouldn't be able to do the show if she were spending all her time in detention.



* Principal Geraldine Waxelplax from ''TheFairlyOddparents''.

to:

* Principal Geraldine Waxelplax from ''TheFairlyOddparents''. Sometimes played for laughs, [[DependingOnTheWriter sometimes not]]



* ''WesternAnimation/LittlestPetShop2012'' has Mrs. Twombly, the littlest pet shop owner, helping out Blythe Baxter on certain situations.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/LittlestPetShop2012'' has Mrs. Twombly, the littlest pet shop owner, helping out Blythe Baxter on certain situations.situations[[note]]At least, when she's not being a CloudCuckooLander, which is most of the time.[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The BelisariusSeries features Malwa noble Damodara, who starts off reasonable in actually listening to Rana Sanga's concern that they're being played by Belisarius, and then covers up the Rajput king's failure in capturing Belisarius because he accepts that anyone would have fallen for the BatmanGambit which was used.

to:

* The BelisariusSeries Literature/BelisariusSeries features Malwa noble Damodara, who starts off reasonable in actually listening to Rana Sanga's concern that they're being played by Belisarius, and then covers up the Rajput king's failure in capturing Belisarius because he accepts that anyone would have fallen for the BatmanGambit which was used.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Minamo Kurosawa, the P.E. teacher, from AzumangaDaioh.

to:

* Minamo Kurosawa, the P.E. teacher, from AzumangaDaioh.Manga/AzumangaDaioh.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing a completely inapplicable link. Stab the Salad has nothing to do with \"baseless accusations.\"


Which makes the existence of the Reasonable Authority Figure all the rarer. Fully aware that MachiavelliWasWrong, he'll listen to those "[[RagtagBunchOfMisfits crazy kids]]" when they say there's a fugitive nearby, and actually logically consider their arguments and not discard them out of hand. However, their openness to the heroes' ideas doesn't mean they'll follow AgentMulder's crazy ideas blindly. Often, they'll ask for [[WeNeedToGetProof proof]] and facts rather than follow [[StabTheSalad baseless accusations]], but even then, they'll usually humor the heroes and go check out their theories; whether it pans out or turns into a [[NotSoImaginaryFriend dead end]] depends on how far along the story is.

to:

Which makes the existence of the Reasonable Authority Figure all the rarer. Fully aware that MachiavelliWasWrong, he'll listen to those "[[RagtagBunchOfMisfits crazy kids]]" when they say there's a fugitive nearby, and actually logically consider their arguments and not discard them out of hand. However, their openness to the heroes' ideas doesn't mean they'll follow AgentMulder's crazy ideas blindly. Often, they'll ask for [[WeNeedToGetProof proof]] and facts rather than follow [[StabTheSalad baseless accusations]], accusations, but even then, they'll usually humor the heroes and go check out their theories; whether it pans out or turns into a [[NotSoImaginaryFriend dead end]] depends on how far along the story is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* General Hawk from ''Film/GIJoeTheRiseOfCobra''.

to:

* General Hawk from ''Film/GIJoeTheRiseOfCobra''. Also Sergeant Stone who surprisingly seems much more pleasant than most iterations of the Joe's Drill Sergeant.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''RebelWithoutACause'' - the police officer played by Ed Platt. He lets Jim know that he's there to talk to when things are driving him crazy (and things ''are'' driving him crazy).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* General Hawk from ''Film/GIJoeTheRiseOfCobra''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Firestar too after he becomes the leader.
** In fact, plenty of leaders can be this on a good day at least. Several examples include Blackstar, but the ultimate one would have to be Tallstar, who's very friendly to Firestar and his Clan. But after he dies, [[TookALevelInJerkass Onestar]] (who takes over [=WindClan=] averts this trope when he's in a foul mood.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A large part of the reason that Skitter became a VillainProtagonist in ''Literature/{{Worm}}'' was because none of the authority figures she ever encountered were reasonable. That said, Miss Militia, a superhero in [[TheCity Brockton Bay]] promoted to lead the local superhero team after her predecessor's retirement, is unquestionably evenhanded and responsible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Link.


* In ''Cheer!'', Mr. Madison is considered nice and well-liked by his students. He's the one the girls go to for help when they find that the class president was chained up in the Student Council room, and when we see him teaching, he tries to make obscure math formulas interesting before admitting that the students can forget them after the test.

to:

* In ''Cheer!'', ''Webcomic/{{Cheer}}'', Mr. Madison is considered nice and well-liked by his students. He's the one the girls go to for help when they find that the class president was chained up in the Student Council room, and when we see him teaching, he tries to make obscure math formulas interesting before admitting that the students can forget them after the test.

Top