Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / RaceLift

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Often this is done for the same reasons as AdaptationalDiversity; demographics, values, and the social impact of race can shift over time and between settings, changing what a realistic cast looks like and altering the implications of a character's race. It can also result from a remake trying to appeal (successfully or unsuccessfully) to a different demographic than the original work. And in live-action works or theatrical productions, it can result from AbilityOverAppearance, when the character's race is changed because the ideal actor fits the role in everything but their looks.

to:

Often this is done for the same reasons as AdaptationalDiversity; demographics, values, and the social impact of race can shift over time and between settings, changing what a realistic cast looks like and altering the implications of a character's race.racial casting choices. It can also result from a remake trying to appeal (successfully or unsuccessfully) to a different demographic than the original work. And in live-action works or theatrical productions, it can result from AbilityOverAppearance, when the character's race is changed because the ideal actor fits the role in everything but their looks.

Added: 588

Changed: 588

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
paragraph break


A Race Lift is what occurs when a character's race or ethnicity is changed in the creation of a derivative work, also known as [[Film/TheLastAirbender Racebending]], and in the case of non-white characters becoming white, whitewashing. Often this is done for the same reasons as AdaptationalDiversity; demographics, values, and the social impact of race can shift over time and between settings, changing what a realistic cast looks like and altering the implications of a character's race. It can also result from a remake trying to appeal (successfully or unsuccessfully) to a different demographic than the original work. And in live-action works or theatrical productions, it can result from AbilityOverAppearance, when the character's race is changed because the ideal actor fits the role in everything but their looks.

to:

A Race Lift is what occurs when a character's race or ethnicity is changed in the creation of a derivative work, also known as [[Film/TheLastAirbender Racebending]], and in the case of non-white characters becoming white, whitewashing.

Often this is done for the same reasons as AdaptationalDiversity; demographics, values, and the social impact of race can shift over time and between settings, changing what a realistic cast looks like and altering the implications of a character's race. It can also result from a remake trying to appeal (successfully or unsuccessfully) to a different demographic than the original work. And in live-action works or theatrical productions, it can result from AbilityOverAppearance, when the character's race is changed because the ideal actor fits the role in everything but their looks.

Changed: 644

Removed: 481

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
rm. some of the complaining about this trope to focus more on Tropes Are Not Bad / Tropes Are Tools.


A Race Lift is what occurs when a character's race or ethnicity is changed in the creation of a derivative work, also known as [[Film/TheLastAirbender Racebending]], and in the case of non-white characters becoming white, whitewashing. Sometimes this is a method to try and keep things politically correct. [[DoubleStandard People can't argue racism]] if you have a TokenMinority in the cast, but you usually run into [[UnfortunateImplications problems]] when you change a character who is originally a proud minority into a member of the majority group.

It can also potentially create problems since an important part of fiction is for the audience to get emotionally invested in a character; for that character to suddenly look radically different (especially if it's poorly explained) can risk damaging the sense of familiarity needed for that emotional investment.

to:

A Race Lift is what occurs when a character's race or ethnicity is changed in the creation of a derivative work, also known as [[Film/TheLastAirbender Racebending]], and in the case of non-white characters becoming white, whitewashing. Sometimes Often this is a method to try done for the same reasons as AdaptationalDiversity; demographics, values, and keep things politically correct. [[DoubleStandard People can't argue racism]] if you have a TokenMinority in the cast, but you usually run into [[UnfortunateImplications problems]] when you change a character who is originally a proud minority into a member social impact of race can shift over time and between settings, changing what a realistic cast looks like and altering the majority group.

implications of a character's race. It can also potentially create problems since an important part of fiction is for the audience result from a remake trying to get emotionally invested in a character; for that character appeal (successfully or unsuccessfully) to suddenly look radically a different (especially if it's poorly explained) demographic than the original work. And in live-action works or theatrical productions, it can risk damaging result from AbilityOverAppearance, when the sense of familiarity needed for that emotional investment.
character's race is changed because the ideal actor fits the role in everything but their looks.



This has also been known to result from AbilityOverAppearance, when the character's race is changed because the ideal actor fits the role in everything but their looks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->-- [[InCharacterCommentaries In-character commentary]] for ''WesternAnimation/MrIncredibleAndPals'', [[ShowWithinAShow a cartoon show within the world]] of ''WesternAnimation/TheIncredibles'' starring Frozone and Mr. Incredible.

to:

-->-- [[InCharacterCommentaries In-character commentary]] for ''WesternAnimation/MrIncredibleAndPals'', [[ShowWithinAShow a cartoon show within the world]] of ''WesternAnimation/TheIncredibles'' ''Franchise/TheIncredibles'' starring Frozone and Mr. Incredible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Reverting Ban Evader's edits.


A Race Lift is what occurs when a character's race or ethnicity is changed in the creation of a derivative work, also known as [[Film/TheLastAirbender Racebending]], and in the case of non-white characters becoming white, whitewashing. Sometimes this is a method to try and keep things politically correct. [[DoubleStandard People can't argue racism]] if you have a TokenMinority in the cast, but you usually run into [[UnfortunateImplications problems]] when you change a character who is originally a proud minority into a member of the majority group. A more recent and controversial term, of more popular and even sociopolitical usage, ''blackwashing'', is considered instead the practice of changing an established either fictional or really existed/existing non-black character (European/Caucasian, Asian, Latino) to black (few dictionaries, [[https://it.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackwashing most of them of non-English language]], found place for the term and its definition).

to:

A Race Lift is what occurs when a character's race or ethnicity is changed in the creation of a derivative work, also known as [[Film/TheLastAirbender Racebending]], and in the case of non-white characters becoming white, whitewashing. Sometimes this is a method to try and keep things politically correct. [[DoubleStandard People can't argue racism]] if you have a TokenMinority in the cast, but you usually run into [[UnfortunateImplications problems]] when you change a character who is originally a proud minority into a member of the majority group. A more recent and controversial term, of more popular and even sociopolitical usage, ''blackwashing'', is considered instead the practice of changing an established either fictional or really existed/existing non-black character (European/Caucasian, Asian, Latino) to black (few dictionaries, [[https://it.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackwashing most of them of non-English language]], found place for the term and its definition).
group.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A Race Lift is what occurs when a character's race or ethnicity is changed in the creation of a derivative work, also known as [[Film/TheLastAirbender Racebending]], and in the case of non-white characters becoming white, whitewashing. Sometimes this is a method to try and keep things politically correct. [[DoubleStandard People can't argue racism]] if you have a TokenMinority in the cast, but you usually run into [[UnfortunateImplications problems]] when you change a character who is originally a proud minority into a member of the majority group.

to:

A Race Lift is what occurs when a character's race or ethnicity is changed in the creation of a derivative work, also known as [[Film/TheLastAirbender Racebending]], and in the case of non-white characters becoming white, whitewashing. Sometimes this is a method to try and keep things politically correct. [[DoubleStandard People can't argue racism]] if you have a TokenMinority in the cast, but you usually run into [[UnfortunateImplications problems]] when you change a character who is originally a proud minority into a member of the majority group. \n A more recent and controversial term, of more popular and even sociopolitical usage, ''blackwashing'', is considered instead the practice of changing an established either fictional or really existed/existing non-black character (European/Caucasian, Asian, Latino) to black (few dictionaries, [[https://it.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackwashing most of them of non-English language]], found place for the term and its definition).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!!Examples:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also: ColorblindCasting, BlackVikings, FiveTokenBand, TwoferTokenMinority, {{Mukokuseki}}, GenderFlip, AffirmativeActionLegacy, AdaptationalNationality, AdaptationSpeciesChange, and AdaptationalDiversity. Often involves an AdaptationDyeJob. See GenderFlip when an adaptation changes a character's gender instead of race. See DivineRaceLift when gods are portrayed as a race different from their traditional representations. See FakeNationality when a character's ethnicity is meant to stay the same, but the person playing him doesn't have the same background.

to:

See also: ColorblindCasting, BlackVikings, FiveTokenBand, TwoferTokenMinority, {{Mukokuseki}}, GenderFlip, AffirmativeActionLegacy, AdaptationalNationality, AdaptationSpeciesChange, and AdaptationalDiversity. Often involves an AdaptationDyeJob. See GenderFlip when an adaptation changes a character's gender instead of race. See DivineRaceLift when gods are portrayed as a race different from their traditional representations. See FakeNationality when a character's ethnicity is meant to stay the same, but the person playing him doesn't have the same background.
background. See PlaysGreatEthnics when a particular ''actor'' is known for repeatedly playing characters of multiple ethnic groups other than their own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


If a character in a work changes their race within the storyline, it's RacialTransformation.

to:

If a character in a work changes their race within ''within'' the same storyline, it's RacialTransformation.
that's RacialTransformation instead.

Top