Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Speaking of which, SpeedyGonzales was a victim of this, as his cartoons were taken off the air for many years due to the idea that Mexicans would find the stereotyping offensive. The irony of it all is that [[MexicansLoveSpeedyGonzales a whole lot of Mexicans actually]] ''[[MexicansLoveSpeedyGonzales love]]'' [[MexicansLoveSpeedyGonzales Speedy]], and a few years and several petitions later, he's back on the air.

to:

** Speaking of which, SpeedyGonzales was a victim of this, as his cartoons were taken off the air for many years due to the idea that Mexicans would find the stereotyping offensive. The irony of it all is that [[MexicansLoveSpeedyGonzales a whole lot of Mexicans actually]] ''[[MexicansLoveSpeedyGonzales love]]'' [[MexicansLoveSpeedyGonzales actually''love'' Speedy]], and a few years and several petitions later, he's back on the air.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** That whole news story was actually hyperbole and blown out of proportion, the principal never actually called the sandwhich racist, this was just a bunch of hype for the anti-PC crowd http://www.politifact.com/oregon/statements/2012/sep/18/education-action-group/portland-schools-spending-half-million-dollars-dec/

Changed: 177

Removed: 121

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing discussion.


* Subverted: when the Smithsonian "Museum of the American Indian" opened, a petition quickly pulled up to change it to "Native American". It was quashed by request of none other than the Muscogee High Chief. Most of the complaints for Indians aren't made by Indians. Furthermore, the museum is not about "Native ''Americans''" but is about all of the people indigenous to the New World.
** By the way, the New World is North and South America. 'American' does not have to designate a citizen of the USA only.

to:

* Subverted: when the Smithsonian "Museum of the American Indian" opened, a petition quickly pulled up to change it to "Native American". It was quashed by request of none other than the Muscogee High Chief. Most of the complaints for Indians aren't made by Indians. Furthermore, the museum is not about "Native ''Americans''" but is about all of the people indigenous to the New World.\n** By the way, the New World is North and South America. 'American' does not have to designate a citizen of the USA only.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Tropes Are Not Recent. This is an issue in flux and back in the news.


** Relatedly, the NFL has gotten a lot of flack for the Washington Redskins, which has largely died down since a poll found that about 94% of actual Native Americans don't have any problem with the name.
*** Really, the main image problem the Redskins have is the fact that their original owner, George Preston Marshall, who was one of the founders of the modern National Football League, pressured all the other team owners not to draft or sign a single nonwhite player until 1946 (this despite the presence of black players in the original NFL in the 1920s), and also because Marshall himself refused to sign any black players for his team until 1962. Despite these marks on his character, Marshall is still in the Pro Football Hall of Fame (he's too seminal a figure in American football history to be omitted) and the Redskins still have his name proudly displayed on one of the many banners decorating the perimeter of [=FedEx Field=] in Landover, Maryland.

to:

** Relatedly, the The NFL has gotten a lot of flack for the Washington Redskins, which has largely died down since a poll found that about 94% of actual Native Americans don't have any problem with the name.
Redskins.
*** Really, the One main image problem the Redskins have is the fact that their original owner, George Preston Marshall, who was one of the founders of the modern National Football League, pressured all the other team owners not to draft or sign a single nonwhite player until 1946 (this despite the presence of black players in the original NFL in the 1920s), and also because Marshall himself refused to sign any black players for his team until 1962. Despite these marks on his character, Marshall is still in the Pro Football Hall of Fame (he's too seminal a figure in American football history to be omitted) and the Redskins still have his name proudly displayed on one of the many banners decorating the perimeter of [=FedEx Field=] in Landover, Maryland.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The 4Kids release of ''DragonballZKai'' had the removal of halos from dead characters (too religious, presumably). Instead, they were replaced by small glowing orbs. Also, blue Mr. Popo[[note]] What about him? We may never know.[[/note]] . Heck, 4Kids in general could be put here.

to:

* The 4Kids release of ''DragonballZKai'' had the removal of halos from dead characters (too religious, presumably). Instead, they were replaced by small glowing orbs. Also, painting Mr. Popo blue Mr. Popo[[note]] What about him? We may never know.[[/note]] .(due to fear of him being seen as a caricature of black people, ignoring the fact that every single American airing of Dragon Ball left him as is). Heck, 4Kids in general could be put here.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not an example.


* In the John Byrne relaunch of Superman in the mid-1980s, Krypton was portrayed as a sterile society where all Kryptonians were placed in isolated chambers upon birth and interacted only with automation (robots and other devices) so that there was no chance in any of them being offended by ''anything'' another one did or said. When Jor-El removes Kal-El's "birthing matrix" and attaches it to the escape rocket, he seeks out Lara, the female who provided the other half of the genetic material. The meeting of these two Kryptonians was said to be the first in several thousand years. Also, since Kal-El was still "developing" on the trip from Krypton to Earth, he was "born" on Earth, in Kansas, making him a true citizen of Earth and the U.S.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not to mention "Cougars" is probably one of the most ubiquitous sports teams names, falling under a derive of "TheWildCats" (yes, we even have a trope for it).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This may or may not be a TakeThat towards the reaction real-world MoralGuardians had towards the first movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* From the [[http://www.radiolab.org/2010/jun/28/be-careful-what-you-plan-for/ July 7, 2013]] episode of [[Creator/{{NPR}} WNYC's]] Radiolab, crossing over with the ScunthorpeProblem: A right-wing Christian publication replaced every instance of "gay" in an article with "homosexual". Sounds okay, right? Not when the article is about a guy whose last name is "Gay".

to:

* From the [[http://www.radiolab.org/2010/jun/28/be-careful-what-you-plan-for/ July 7, 2013]] episode of [[Creator/{{NPR}} WNYC's]] Radiolab, crossing over with the ScunthorpeProblem: A right-wing Christian publication replaced every instance of "gay" in an article with "homosexual". Sounds okay, right? Not when the article is a sports piece about a guy whose player with the last name is "Gay".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I could not stop laughing when I heard that.

Added DiffLines:

* From the [[http://www.radiolab.org/2010/jun/28/be-careful-what-you-plan-for/ July 7, 2013]] episode of [[Creator/{{NPR}} WNYC's]] Radiolab, crossing over with the ScunthorpeProblem: A right-wing Christian publication replaced every instance of "gay" in an article with "homosexual". Sounds okay, right? Not when the article is about a guy whose last name is "Gay".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In a recent episode of WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons, Ned Flanders is shown watching EVERY TV show and finds something "offensive" or just something to complain about on all he sees, except for two shows. If that's not Political Correctness literally Gone Mad... It doesn't stop there; even his sons tell him, in their own way, that he's gone off the deep end.

to:

* In *In a recent episode of WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons, Ned Flanders is shown watching EVERY TV show and finds something "offensive" or just something to complain about on all he sees, except for two shows. If that's not Political Correctness literally Gone Mad... It doesn't stop there; even his sons tell him, in their own way, that he's gone off the deep end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*In a recent episode of WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons, Ned Flanders is shown watching EVERY TV show and finds something "offensive" or just something to complain about on all he sees, except for two shows. If that's not Political Correctness literally Gone Mad... It doesn't stop there; even his sons tell him, in their own way, that he's gone off the deep end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the remake of the film ''TheLadykillers'', one of the characters (a foul-mouthed, "gangsta" black teen) is fired for hitting on a female customer. When he hears he's fired, he says his boss is doing it because he's black. The entire cleaning staff is black, and the guy doesn't fall for it until they bribe him.

to:

* In the remake of the film ''TheLadykillers'', ''Film/TheLadykillers'', one of the characters (a foul-mouthed, "gangsta" black teen) is fired for hitting on a female customer. When he hears he's fired, he says his boss is doing it because he's black. The entire cleaning staff is black, and the guy doesn't fall for it until they bribe him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''This is not a place to complain about minor changes that don't make sense to you personally. When adding examples of changes in works due to ExecutiveMeddling, please stick only to those that render the work nonsensical, change its meaning completely, or miss the point of the work altogether.'''

to:

'''This %This is not a place to complain about minor changes that don't make sense to you personally. When adding examples of changes in works due to ExecutiveMeddling, please stick only to those that render the work nonsensical, change its meaning completely, or miss the point of the work altogether.'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Season one had an episode called "Sense and Sensitivity" which gleefully parodied this trope. A demon used magic to cause the L.A.P.D. e to become politically correct beyond the point of lunacy, not only in order to control them, but to cause general mayhem. In a day, all the police are "sharing their feelings", that is, babbling incoherently and pathetically about all the injustice and pain in the world, and showing weakness and an aversion to violence in front of hardened criminals. The entire precinct is almost overrun.

to:

** Season one had an episode called "Sense and Sensitivity" which gleefully parodied this trope. A demon used magic to cause the L.A.P.D. e to become politically correct beyond the point of lunacy, not only in order to control them, but to cause general mayhem. In a day, all the police are "sharing their feelings", that is, babbling incoherently and pathetically about all the injustice and pain in the world, and showing weakness and an aversion to violence in front of hardened criminals. The entire precinct is almost overrun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One of the early issues of the HeroesReborn ''[[Comicbook/TheAvengers Avengers]]'' series has a scene where a {{SHIELD}} agent mentions that there are some people who are upset with the lack of racial diversity in the Avengers line-up. NickFury scoffs at this and proceeds to insult anyone who would actually hold such an opinion, even though [[LeaningOnTheFourthWall diversity continues to be a hot button issue in comics to this day]].

to:

* One of the early issues of the HeroesReborn ''[[Comicbook/TheAvengers Avengers]]'' series has a scene where a {{SHIELD}} ComicBook/{{SHIELD}} agent mentions that there are some people who are upset with the lack of racial diversity in the Avengers line-up. NickFury scoffs at this and proceeds to insult anyone who would actually hold such an opinion, even though [[LeaningOnTheFourthWall diversity continues to be a hot button issue in comics to this day]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Changed to something not as... over-the-top angry or one-sided. Hopefully this is more neutral.


** Even crazier political correctness than that, [[MoralGuardians insane social justice warriors]] forced the company [[ExecutiveMeddling to edit away]] a fan ShoutOut silly nonsense name (leaving her nameless in the interim despite still selling merchandise around her) and mangle said pony's voice to Inoffensively Generic level with no uniqueness at all. Meanwhile, the majority-agreed-upon-name they focus on [[CompletelyMissingThePoint IS an actually insulting slur]], and the removal of her tics and visually recognisable cues [[TheMentallyDisturbed implies that not only are people with strabmisus retarded]], [[DisabledMeansHelpless but also that the mentally disabled shouldn't be allowed to be seen at all]] and [[UnfortunateImplications cannot do anything without coddling and handholding 24/7]]. [[StopHelpingMe And how is this supposed to aid anyone in understanding anything, exactly]]? Similarly to the Speedy Gonzales examples, an outpouring of support [[MexicansLoveSpeedyGonzales from the afflicted and groups related to their awareness]] ensued, but unfortunately since the studio had already eaten the cost of the initial PR nightmare, [[TooSoon it seems some time will need to pass]] before her reintroduction and regaining her original form. This also may have the unintended consequence of [[HeWhoMustNotBeHeard making them reluctant to give speaking roles to background characters ever again]], especially since they already have a workaround for whenever they can't find an appropriate voice for a character. (The scene begins just after they would have spoken, such as beginning a scene immediately after a main pony completes a purchase.)

to:

** Even crazier political correctness than that, [[MoralGuardians insane social justice warriors]] forced The change of a scene in which one of the company [[ExecutiveMeddling to edit away]] background ponies spoke caused a fan ShoutOut silly nonsense name (leaving her nameless split in the interim despite fanbase as to whether or not it's this trope. Prior to this, her only character trait was FishEyes. In the scene she was a WalkingDisasterArea with a SimpletonVoice, and was treated like a needless burden. After the change she was still selling merchandise around her) a WalkingDisasterArea, but her eyes were less fish-eyed and mangle said pony's her voice was a more generally girlish. Another character had her lines redubbed to Inoffensively Generic level with no uniqueness remove her name Derpy which, depending on who you ask, is either a rather harsh jab at all. Meanwhile, the majority-agreed-upon-name they focus on [[CompletelyMissingThePoint IS an actually insulting slur]], and the removal of her tics and visually recognisable cues [[TheMentallyDisturbed implies that not disabled, a perfectly fine name, or only are people with strabmisus retarded]], [[DisabledMeansHelpless but also slighty unfornutate (it's often used as a synonym for "mistake"). Complicating matters is that the mentally disabled redubbed character could either be seen as poorly acted, disinteresed, or treating the first character with mittens. Basically? [[InternetBackdraft The only thing people can agree about is that the eyes shouldn't be allowed to be seen at all]] and [[UnfortunateImplications cannot do anything without coddling and handholding 24/7]]. [[StopHelpingMe And how is this supposed to aid anyone in understanding anything, exactly]]? Similarly to the Speedy Gonzales examples, an outpouring of support [[MexicansLoveSpeedyGonzales from the afflicted and groups related to their awareness]] ensued, but unfortunately since the studio had already eaten the cost of the initial PR nightmare, [[TooSoon it seems some time will need to pass]] before her reintroduction and regaining her original form. This also may have the unintended consequence of [[HeWhoMustNotBeHeard making them reluctant to give speaking roles to background characters ever again]], especially since they already have a workaround for whenever they can't find an appropriate voice for a character. (The scene begins just after they would have spoken, such as beginning a scene immediately after a main pony completes a purchase.)been straightened out.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* An unfortunate case in ''{{Malcolm In The Middle}}'', in which Malcolm is reported for using "The R word," the joke being that it's impossible to tell what the word actually is. Trouble is, since the episode aired, "retard" has been designated as an offensive slur.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In one later season ''KingOfTheHill'' episode, a "diversity expert" was brought in to Tom Landry Middle School by the school board to make sure all the different minorities were "cooperating". He singled out Bobby's carnival committee to do a few experiments and eventually just heaped racial guilt on each member for things their respective cultures were responsible for. When Bobby insisted the students get back to work on the carnival, the expert made a comparison to the Nazi holocaust, and given that Bobby's grandpa Cotton is a WWII veteran, it really got to him. Instead of a carnival, the kids decided to just announce their "guilt" of various global atrocities until a riot almost started because they didn't finish the carnival. Hank, Peggy, and the other parents finished putting together the carnival, and the diversity expert weaseled out of any punishment by claiming it was his idea.

to:

* In one later season ''KingOfTheHill'' episode, a "diversity expert" was brought in to Tom Landry Middle School by the school board to make sure all the different minorities were "cooperating". He singled out Bobby's carnival committee to do a few experiments and eventually just heaped racial guilt on each member for things their respective cultures were responsible for. When Bobby insisted the students get back to work on the carnival, the expert made a comparison to the Nazi holocaust, and given that Bobby's grandpa Cotton is a WWII veteran, [[BerserkButton it really got to him.him]]. Instead of a carnival, the kids decided to just announce their "guilt" of various global atrocities until a riot almost started because they didn't finish the carnival. Hank, Peggy, and the other parents finished putting together the carnival, and the diversity expert weaseled out of any punishment by claiming it was his idea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/LooneyTunes'' shorts have been victims of this for a long time. Many older shorts are sprinkled with content no longer considered suitable for children, which means that some scenes get cut and leave the overall effect pretty disjointed. Others are never shown on kids TV at all anymore, only to adults who seek them out and are assumed to be able to understand the context they were written in.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/LooneyTunes'' shorts have been victims of this for a long time. Many older shorts are sprinkled with content no longer considered suitable for children, children (even though children are most likely not even going to understand what they're seeing, and at worst will probably just [[AccidentalNightmareFuel become frightened at the stereotyped characters' grotesque appearances]]), which means that some scenes get cut and leave the overall effect pretty disjointed. Others are never shown on kids TV at all anymore, only to adults who seek them out and are assumed to be able to understand the context they were written in. Even worse, segments that poke fun at ''white'' ethnic groups do not get cut, even though it's acknowledged that they're also insulting. (Probably NWordPrivileges at work.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* There was [[http://newsfeed.time.com/2012/01/20/utah-school-rejects-cougar-mascot-to-avoid-offending-older-women/ one school in Utah]] that was forced to change its name from the Cougars to avoid offending ''middle aged women'' (for whom "cougar" is a term)

to:

* There was [[http://newsfeed.time.com/2012/01/20/utah-school-rejects-cougar-mascot-to-avoid-offending-older-women/ one school in Utah]] that was forced to change its name from the Cougars to avoid offending ''middle aged women'' (for whom "cougar" is a term)term). Unfair and ridiculous, since the zoological definition precedes the offensive sense of the word by ''centuries''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Really, this is yet another example of people not only being too sensitive, but also getting ''race'' and ''ethnicity'' [[YouKeepUsingThatWord confused]] and - ironically - encouraging racist implications in their own right. Race and cultural background do not always correspond to each other exactly (white Southerners and black Southerners are of different races, but they arguably have the same culinary culture since they both eat "soul food"); and to say that implying that everyone should eat PB&J sandwiches is racist is ''itself'' a racist statement, because it suggests that nonwhite kids somehow have different digestive systems than "normal" humans and literally cannot consume peanut butter and jelly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Common problem with "The Nigger of the Narcissus", a novel by nowadays classic JosephConrad... It has it in its title, so it is quite frequent to rise really heated debate in public libraries and schools. No racism intended in the novel, nigger being a completely acceptable term at the time for any black person.

to:

* Common problem with "The Nigger of the Narcissus", a novel by nowadays classic JosephConrad... It has it in its title, so it is quite frequent to rise really heated debate in public libraries and schools. No racism intended in the novel, nigger ''nigger'' being a completely acceptable term at the time for any black person.person.
** It ''was'' a bad word back then, not because it was offensive to black people (there being statistically no blacks in Britain in those days) but because it was a "crude" lower-class word that socially diminished the person using it. In that regard, were it not for the racial connotation, "The Nigger of the Narcissus" might actually be praised for having a "down-to-earth" or "anti-elitist" title.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Dara O'Briain has a routine in one of his stand-up shows in which he describes receiving a letter of complaint from a gay-rights campaign after making a joke about Elton John writing the score for a musical version of ''Film/BillyElliot'' because "he saw a little of himself ''in'' Billy Elliot", which accused him of contributing to "a culture of violence against gay men." It's played with in that O'Briain, while clearly finding their specific accusation a bit ludicrous ("their previous target was Robert Mugabe ... and now ''me''."), initially describes his defensive reaction before conceding that the complaint had a point, he had no real defence for it and as an Irishman he's benefited quite a bit from increased politically correct attitudes so really doesn't have much cause to complain about them. He also goes on to point out that a lot of typical defences of politically incorrect material from stand-up comedians such as "civil rights, comedy's obligation to say the difficult thing and freedom of speech" tend to sound a bit lofty and pretentious for what are, most of the time, basically dick jokes.

Added: 271

Changed: 78

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler: Kankri]] from ''{{Webcomic/Homestuck}}'', as a parody of {{Tumblr}} and the OverlyNarrowSuperlative sect of the LGBT community, overly defines every potential facet of his caste system and tries way too hard to make sure nothing he says offends anyone in the slightest, often asking people for a detailed list of what would offend them before going into [[WallOfText one of his monologues]]. He seems to be [[{{Irony}} blissfully unaware]] that his attitude comes off as incredibly sexist and bigoted to his friends. It gets to his point where he actually [[BitchInSheepsClothing criticizes a mentally-challenged person for wearing a helmet]] on the grounds that [[SlipperySlopeFallacy it implies that all of the mentally-challenged should be forced to wear helmets]]. Another character suggests that [[DeconstructedTrope his political correctness is just a ruse to get away with backhandedly talking about his friends's flaws to their faces.]]

to:

* [[spoiler: Kankri]] Kankri from ''{{Webcomic/Homestuck}}'', as a parody of {{Tumblr}} and the OverlyNarrowSuperlative sect of the LGBT community, overly defines every potential facet of his caste system and tries way too hard to make sure nothing he says offends anyone in the slightest, often asking people for a detailed list of what would offend them before going into [[WallOfText one of his monologues]]. He seems to be [[{{Irony}} blissfully unaware]] that his attitude comes off as incredibly sexist and bigoted to his friends. It gets to his point where he actually [[BitchInSheepsClothing criticizes a mentally-challenged mentally-ill person who falls down a lot and has poor coordination for wearing a helmet]] on the grounds that [[SlipperySlopeFallacy it implies that all of the mentally-challenged mentally-ill should be forced to wear helmets]]. Another character suggests that [[DeconstructedTrope his political correctness is just a ruse to get away with backhandedly talking about his friends's flaws to their faces.]]]]
** He's also completely failed to notice that his entire society now consists of twelve trolls, and most of them really don't give a damn about the subjects of his speeches. Of course, he may just be ignoring this as it would refute his right to talk on and on at length.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[http://apa3.olivesoftware.com/Default/Scripting/ArticleWin.asp?From=Archive&Source=Page&Skin=NewsandObserverA&BaseHref=NAO/2013/05/05&PageLabelPrint=4X&ForceGif=true&EntityId=Ar18200&DataChunk=Ar18204&ViewMode=GIF This]] ''ComicStrip/BabyBlues'' comic. Doubles as an LawyerFriendlyCameo-added homage to the ''WesternAnimation/LooneyTunes''.

Added: 708

Changed: 394

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''Series/{{Seinfeld}}'' episode "The Cigar Store Indian" has Jerry insulting his Native American girlfriend with the eponymous item, and spending the rest of the episode struggling with things like telling her he made a "reservation" at a restaurant. Eventually she dumps him when he offends an Asian mailman by asking where a good Chinese restaurant is (figuring that as a mailman he'd know the neighborhood).

to:

* From ''Series/{{Seinfeld}}''
**
The ''Series/{{Seinfeld}}'' episode whole idea behind the Festivus arch.
** The
"The Cigar Store Indian" episode has Jerry insulting his Native American girlfriend with the eponymous item, and spending the rest of the episode struggling with things like telling her he made a "reservation" at a restaurant. Eventually she dumps him when he offends an Asian mailman by asking where a good Chinese restaurant is (figuring that as a mailman he'd know the neighborhood).neighborhood).
** Episode [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Outing The Outing]]. A reporter overhears Elaine joking about Jerry and George being gay. The spend the rest of the episode vehemently denying being gay, but always interceding with "Not that there's anything wrong with that."

Top