Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / NoInfantileAmnesia

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: So does that mean that her ''creators'' succumbed to an in-character use of this trope, when they gave her those memories?]]

to:

** [[spoiler: So does that mean this means that her ''creators'' ''creator'' succumbed to an in-character use of this trope, when they he gave her those memories?]]memories.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Justified in the DoctorWhoExpandedUniverse novel ''[=EarthWorld=]''. A device is used to read Fitz's mind, causing him to remember his entire life in reverse:

to:

* Justified in the DoctorWhoExpandedUniverse ''DoctorWho'' EighthDoctorAdventures novel ''[=EarthWorld=]''. A device is used to read Fitz's mind, causing him to remember his entire life in reverse:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Stewie from ''FamilyGuy'' also remembers being a sperm, as does his half-brother, Bertram. Then again, they're mutant supergeniuses. Or something.

to:

* Stewie from ''FamilyGuy'' also remembers being a sperm, [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homunculus#Homunculi_in_preformationism homunculus]] within a sperm cell, as does his half-brother, Bertram. Then again, they're mutant supergeniuses. Or something.

Changed: 334

Removed: 175

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''DragonBall Z'': The first Broly movie. The titular villain has a deep, sadistic, personal hatred for Goku, because [[DisproportionateRetribution Goku's crying bothered him when they were newborns]]. For about one day maximum.
** The fact that the exact same day, he ended up nearly executed by Vegeta and having to witness the destruction of Planet Vegeta by Frieza's hand didn't help matters, either.

to:

* ''DragonBall Z'': The first Broly movie. The titular villain has a deep, sadistic, personal hatred for Goku, because [[DisproportionateRetribution Goku's crying bothered him when they were newborns]]. For about one day maximum.
** The fact
maximum. Possibly [[JustifiedTrope justified]] in that the exact same day, this is an [[BizarreAlienBiology alien]] we're talking about, here. The only other time a Saiyan's infant memories are mentioned is when Raditz asks if Goku received any head injuries when he ended up nearly executed by Vegeta and having to witness the destruction of Planet Vegeta by Frieza's hand didn't help matters, either.was young. They way he talked, you'd almost expect that a Saiyan can recall their entire lives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted in ''CalvinAndHobbes''. Calvin is disturbed that he can't remember that 50% of his life.

to:

* Averted in ''CalvinAndHobbes''. Calvin is disturbed that he can't remember that 50% of his life.
life.
-->'''Calvin:''' What kind of sicko would want to brainwash a ''baby?'' And what did I know that they wanted me to forget?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* There's a horror manga (the title of which, sadly, escapes me) about a young woman who has an irrational fear of butterflies--the sight of one sends her into a screaming, sobbing fit. When her father remarries, she is shocked to find herself slamming the door on her step-mother's face, and beats her with a broom after hallucinating her as a giant butterfly. Later, she suddenly remembers that [[spoiler:this same woman had killed her real mother when she was a baby, and she saw her mother tear the other woman's blouse in efforts to fight her off, revealing a giant birthmark shaped liked a butterfly on her chest. The image of both the mark and the woman's face were branded in the girl's memory, causing her phobia of butterflies and her initial terror of the step-mother.]]

Changed: 192

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the first ''{{Blade}}'' movie, a flashback showing his dying mother bleeding from the neck reaching out to him after he was born moves Blade to help the doctor who is in a similar plight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Stop justifying. If you had to fabricate a justification like you did, it\'s a plot hole and you\'re banking on Epileptic Trees. And if she didn\'t think she was adopted, why does she remember a \"real\" mother (and thus, also a false mother) at all?


** {{Fanon}} tries to pass this off as the result of being the daughter of a powerful Jedi, among other theories.
** Actually, seeing as she still thought she was Bail Organa's daughter, this statement could be perfectly valid. Leia would be referring to his wife, who died sometime in her childhood.
*** So she has ''another'' non-"real" mother? This is a case where both options are equally stupid, really.
*** A photograph, a painting, a talking hologram... or a collection of these, there's no reason for Leia not to have any such mementos.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The fact that the exact same day, he ended up nearly executed by Vegeta and having to witness the destruction of Planet Vegeta by Frieza's hand didn't help matters, either.

Added: 246

Removed: 246

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** It all becomes FridgeBrilliance after the seventh book, [[spoiler: when it's revealed that Harry became an inadvertent Horcrux on that night. What he's experiencing when he meets a Dementor isn't his own worst memory, it's ''Voldemort's''.]]



**** It all becomes FridgeBrilliance after the seventh book, [[spoiler: when it's revealed that Harry became an inadvertent Horcrux on that night. What he's experiencing when he meets a Dementor isn't his own worst memory, it's ''Voldemort's''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**In the episode "Q2," Q's son voices how annoyed he was when Janeway cooed over him as a baby. She's surprised he can remember that, but of course, the Q are [[SufficientlyAdvancedAlien Sufficiently Advanced Aliens]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** A photograph, a painting, a talking hologram... or a collection of these, there's no reason for Leia not to have any such mementos.


Added DiffLines:

**** It all becomes FridgeBrilliance after the seventh book, [[spoiler: when it's revealed that Harry became an inadvertent Horcrux on that night. What he's experiencing when he meets a Dementor isn't his own worst memory, it's ''Voldemort's''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
And the \"real\" mother thing? If she didn\'t have a \"fake\" mother she wouldn\'t have thought that of that woman as anything but her mother, not her \'\'real\'\' mother because she\'d never known any other.


*** No, the woman who raised her from infancy and who she believed to be her mother died when she was young. This is most likely the woman she remembers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** No, the woman who raised her from infancy and who she believed to be her mother died when she was young. This is most likely the woman she remembers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Disney's ''{{Tangled}}'' includes a scene in which [[spoiler: Rapunzel has an epiphany and remembers being an infant.]] The opening narration implies [[spoiler: she was one day old at the time.]]



** In the [[Film/HarryPotter third film]], Harry says he remembers his parents looking at him and "just talking", but admits he isn't sure if it's a real memory.

to:

** In the [[Film/HarryPotter third film]], Harry says he remembers his parents looking at him and "just just talking", but admits he isn't sure if it's a real memory.

Changed: 160

Removed: 442

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There was another episode of ''Rugrats'' revolving around Stu and Drew's flashbacks to when they were babies. In reality, no adult would be able to remember that far back.
*** Actually, the flashbacks were those of Grandpa Lou, Stu and Drew's father, who ''would'' be able to remember.
* In an episode of ''TheSimpsons'', it's revealed that Homer's first memory is of himself as little Homer sperm.
** Though this can easily be attributed to Homer's overactive imagination.
*** We even get to see him imitating the sperm.
**** Though someone who listens would realize he was discussing Maggie's existence, not his own.

to:

** There was In another episode of ''Rugrats'' revolving around Stu and Drew's flashbacks to when they were babies. In reality, no adult would be able to remember that far back.
*** Actually,
episode, Chuckie describes a recurring nightmare which the flashbacks were those of Grandpa Lou, Stu and Drew's father, who ''would'' be able to remember.
* In an episode of ''TheSimpsons'', it's revealed that Homer's first memory
viewer will realise is of himself as little Homer sperm.
** Though this can easily be attributed to Homer's overactive imagination.
*** We even get to see him imitating the sperm.
**** Though someone who listens would realize he was discussing Maggie's existence, not
his own.birth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** So she has ''another'' non-"real" mother?

to:

*** So she has ''another'' non-"real" mother?mother? This is a case where both options are equally stupid, really.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** A child psychologist in the episode even stated the aversion, saying that it was "clinically impossible to remember your first four years of life."

Added: 361

Changed: 104

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In RobertEHoward's ConanTheBarbarian story "A Witch Shall Be Born", the witch remembers being exposed.
-->''But the life in me was stronger than the life in common folk, for it partakes of the essence of the forces that seethe in the black gulfs beyond mortal ken. The hours passed, and the sun slashed down like the molten flames of hell, but I did not die—aye, something of that torment I remember, faintly and far away, as one remembers a dim, formless dream.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The main character in ''{{Powder}}'' has at least one pre-birth memory: [[spoiler: how he killed his own mother by summoning a lightning strike on her while still in the womb]]. To be fair, the character is supposed to be that weird, and the people he tells the story are as freaked by it as because of his ability to remember that.

to:

* The main character in ''{{Powder}}'' ''Powder'' has at least one pre-birth memory: [[spoiler: how he killed his own mother by summoning a lightning strike on her while still in the womb]]. To be fair, the character is supposed to be that weird, and the people he tells the story are as freaked by it as because of his ability to remember that.

Added: 176

Changed: 176

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->''"I remember stuff from when I was an infant, now! I know we got a "C" in Psychology, but it's not normal to remember stuff vividly from before the age of four, is it?"''\\

to:


-->''"I remember stuff from when I was an infant, now! I know we got a "C" 'C' in Psychology, but it's not normal to remember stuff vividly from before the age of four, is it?"''\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This is apparently not entirely normal, but as he's a sort of ArtificialHuman and was created as a copy a matter of weeks previously, his old memories are closer to the surface than they should be.

to:

** This is apparently not entirely normal, but as he's a sort of ArtificialHuman and was created as a copy a matter of weeks previously, fairly recently, his old memories are closer to the surface than they should be.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
that has nothing to do with it


** Also the religious concept of being "born again".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** All of the {{Dune}} novels toy with this trope. In the sequels more characters are introduced who, like Alia, are infants but already have adult-level intelligence and memories from past lives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''FinalFantasyVI'', it's kind of difficult to figure out just whose memory it is when we see Maduin and Madonna/Madeline's flashback. The only character around who ''should'' be able to remember is Maduin... who's technically dead. But the scene in question seems to imply that it's ''Terra's'' flashback. Which incudes her parents meeting. Before she was even conceived. What?!

to:

* In ''FinalFantasyVI'', it's kind of difficult to figure out just whose memory it is when we see Maduin and Madonna/Madeline's flashback. The only character around who ''should'' be able to remember is Maduin... who's technically dead. But the scene in question seems to imply that it's ''Terra's'' flashback. Which incudes includes her parents meeting. Before she was even conceived. What?!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Whoops, this isn't troper tales!


* This troper's mother claims that her earliest memory is from the age of six months -- she tried to "fly" out of her mother's arms in an attempt to greet another grown-up she liked and thus discovered gravity. She suspects that the shock of the event is why she still remembers it over half a century later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* This troper's mother claims that her earliest memory is from the age of six months -- she tried to "fly" out of her mother's arms in an attempt to greet another grown-up she liked and thus discovered gravity. She suspects that the shock of the event is why she still remembers it over half a century later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Also the religious concept of being "born again".

Changed: 106

Removed: 419

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RayBradbury claims he can remember the taste of his mother's milk.
** This would depend a bit on how old he was when weaned and whether he had younger siblings (toddlers might nurse on an ad hoc basis to placate them while a younger baby feeds, particularly in the days pre-formula). For Bradbury's age group and background 2.8yrs was the median duration of breastfeeding. It's not impossible.
*** Except Bradbury has also said that he remembers everything since the moment of his birth.

to:

* RayBradbury claims [[http://www.nytimes.com/2005/07/24/books/chapters/0724-1st-weller.html claims]] he can remember the taste of his mother's milk.
** This would depend a bit on how old he was when weaned and whether he had younger siblings (toddlers might nurse on an ad hoc basis to placate them while a younger baby feeds, particularly in the days pre-formula). For Bradbury's age group and background 2.8yrs was the median duration of breastfeeding. It's not impossible.
*** Except Bradbury has also said that he remembers everything since the moment of his birth.
being born.

Added: 113

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There was another episode of ''Rugrats'' revolving around Stu and Drew's flashbacks to when they were babies. In reality, no adult would be able to remember that far back.

to:

** There was another episode of ''Rugrats'' revolving around Stu and Drew's flashbacks to when they were babies. In reality, no adult would be able to remember that far back. back.
*** Actually, the flashbacks were those of Grandpa Lou, Stu and Drew's father, who ''would'' be able to remember.

Top