Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / MostWritersAreAdults

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ditto for just about everyone in ''{{The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya}}'', also released by same company Kyoto Animation. That is, except for Haruhi herself and Kyon's ten-year-old sister.
*** Ironically, [[PuniPlush quite the opposite]] was true with another K.A. work, ''{{Lucky Star}}'', where the "teenage" girls look, talk, and sound like preteens. The cutesy music and pastel-colored artwork only makes this series feel more like elementary school than high school.

to:

** * Ditto for just about everyone in ''{{The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya}}'', also released by same company Kyoto Animation. That is, except for Haruhi herself and Kyon's ten-year-old sister.
*** * Ironically, [[PuniPlush quite the opposite]] was true with another K.A. work, ''{{Lucky Star}}'', where the "teenage" girls look, talk, and sound like preteens. The cutesy music and pastel-colored artwork only makes this series feel more like elementary school than high school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Heavily averted in PaniPoniDash. The whole point is that the main character is eleven years old, has a job as a high school teacher, and yet acts childishly as you'd expect someone her age to (such as shouting at the top of her lungs or calling her students by distinguishing traits rather than their names).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NowAndThenHereAndThere. It's justified though. [[ChildSoldiers And we wish it wasn't.]]

to:

* NowAndThenHereAndThere.''NowAndThenHereAndThere''. It's justified though. [[ChildSoldiers And we wish it wasn't.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NowAndThenHereAndThere. It's justified though. [[ChildSoldiers And we wish it wasn't.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Justified in ''KimPossible'', as Kim's twin brothers are [[ChildProdigy kid geniuses]] from a genius family.

to:

* Justified in ''KimPossible'', as Kim's twin brothers are [[ChildProdigy kid geniuses]] from a genius family. And like real child prodigies, they do kid stuff and get in trouble, just in an extra-smart way--like unscrewing cables in a jet to see what they do. Kim, on the other hand, seems closer to 16 than her stated age of 14.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Please note that there is an inverse function to this trope - most writers are adults, but are so aware they're writing for children that certain activities will be excised from underage characters even if it's realistic for that age. So your sixteen-year-old won't be dying to get laid; they're searching for true love, and [[RelationshipWritingFumble all relationship interactions will be completely romantic rather than sexual]]. And they'll ''never'' smoke, drink, or get high unless it's a VerySpecialEpisode or the character's an antagonist. Also note that children acting in [[TroublingUnchildhoodBehavior ways that they shouldn't be able to, i.e. like adults,]] is also a common [[CreepyChild go-to Horror Trope]].

to:

Please note that there is an inverse function to this trope - most writers are adults, but are so aware they're writing for children that certain activities will be excised from underage characters even if it's realistic for that age. So your sixteen-year-old won't be dying to get laid; they're searching for true love, and [[RelationshipWritingFumble all relationship interactions will be completely romantic rather than sexual]].sexual]] (excepting [[{{Asexuality}} asexual characters]]). And they'll ''never'' smoke, drink, or get high unless it's a VerySpecialEpisode or the character's an antagonist. Also note that children acting in [[TroublingUnchildhoodBehavior ways that they shouldn't be able to, i.e. like adults,]] is also a common [[CreepyChild go-to Horror Trope]].

Added: 857

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TamoraPierce. Most of her protagonists start out at around ten and grow into their late teens or adulthood, and all the way through they think the same, act the same and talk the same. The CircleOfMagic books, for example, feature a FourTemperamentEnsemble who all become accredited mages at the ImprobableAge of fourteen and thereafter mix (aparently exclusively) in adult circles, and any character who ever suggests they might not be as mature, capable or knowledgeable as older people is either a JerkAss to be publicly humiliated, a villain to be defeated, or both.

to:

* TamoraPierce. Most of her protagonists start out at around ten and grow into their late teens or adulthood, and all the way through they think the same, act the same and talk the same. The CircleOfMagic books, for example, feature a FourTemperamentEnsemble who all become accredited mages at the ImprobableAge of fourteen and thereafter mix (aparently (apparently exclusively) in adult circles, and any character who ever suggests they might not be as mature, capable or knowledgeable as older people is either a JerkAss to be publicly humiliated, a villain to be defeated, or both.both.
** In the TortallUniverse, pages start combat training at about ten years old and train for four years to become squires. The two quartets to have much to do with that are told from the POV of a page; the first one, Alanna, acts considerably more childishly than the second one, Keladry. This is probably due to temperament; Alanna is an impulsive hothead, especially in her youth. Still, they tend to be quite mature.


Added DiffLines:

* Scott Ciencin's ''Dinoverse'' features a batch of 13-year-olds who sometimes do act their age. They're remarkably composed about the situation they find themselves in - cast back in time by 64 million years and possessing the bodies of large, charismatic Cretaceous-period animals - but they're each variably impulsive, self-centered, grudgy, and kind of whiny. Cue character development; they act much older at the end of the book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Bad example. The first book was published when he was nineteen, and all the others were written WELL after he reached adulthood. Enduring myth, but still a myth.


Part of the problem with writers writing like a child is that ''their writing sounds childish'' - which is why this is an omnipresent trope. Consider how many people hate the InheritanceCycle - written by a teenager. Also, do not underestimate children; there are pre-adolescents who vaguely understand sexual matters from an intellectual viewpoint, read encyclopedias and other adult literature, and in the past were apprentices in various trades - so they cannot afford to act or speak childishly.

to:

Part of the problem with writers writing like a child is that ''their writing sounds childish'' - which is why this is an omnipresent trope. Consider how many people hate the InheritanceCycle - written by a teenager. Also, do not underestimate children; there are pre-adolescents who vaguely understand sexual matters from an intellectual viewpoint, read encyclopedias and other adult literature, and in the past were apprentices in various trades - so they cannot afford to act or speak childishly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As ''TheNostalgiaCritic'' pointed out, the "kids" in ''Film/TheWizard'' talk more like 1980's businessmen. That's not even getting into the pedophilia implications of one scene.

to:

* As ''TheNostalgiaCritic'' pointed out, the The "kids" in ''Film/TheWizard'' talk more like 1980's businessmen. That's not even getting into the pedophilia implications of one scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Of course, they are arguably more successful at it than the ''actual'' adults in the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Due to FridgeLogic, Lelouch of ''CodeGeass'' is a borderline example, being a 17-year-old capable of leading an army and dealing with politics without any (visible) prior experience. Yes, he's ThePrince and a genius, yet the show [[WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief asks the viewers to accept]] that he's capable of leading LaResistance against the well-trained army of TheEmpire with experienced military commanders ten (Cornelia, Schneizel) to twenty (Tohdoh) years older than him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''[[OjamajoDoremi Doremi]]'' of the anime with the same name falls in love more often in one season than other people in their whole life. And she is 8 at the start of the first season.

to:

* ''[[OjamajoDoremi Doremi]]'' The titular character of the anime with the same name OjamajoDoremi falls in love more often in one season than other people in their whole life. And she is 8 at the start of the first season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Doremi}}'' of the anime with the same name falls in love more often in one season than other people in their whole life. And she is 8 at the start of the first season.

to:

* ''{{Doremi}}'' ''[[OjamajoDoremi Doremi]]'' of the anime with the same name falls in love more often in one season than other people in their whole life. And she is 8 at the start of the first season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''{{Doremi}}'' of the anime with the same name falls in love more often in one season than other people in their whole life. And she is 8 at the start of the first season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is played exclusively for comedy, and the writers know what they're doing, so it's not an example


* Stewie from FamilyGuy. Remember, he's ONE year old. Still.
--> Brian: I mean, you are getting a little old to have a teddy bear.
--> Stewie: Brian, I'm one!
--> Brian: Still?
--> Stewie: What?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted in the works of RobertCormier. His teens swear, masturbate, drink, fight, and just generally flaunt the artificial limits imposed in the majority of American literature.

to:

* Averted in the works of RobertCormier. His teens swear, masturbate, drink, fight, and just generally flaunt flout the artificial limits imposed in the majority of American literature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In AllGrownUp, the kids are 11-13 years old but they all act like they're about 15.

to:

** In AllGrownUp, the kids are 11-13 years old but they all act like they're about 15.16.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**In AllGrownUp, the kids are 11-13 years old but they all act like they're about 15.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As ''ThatGuyWithTheGlasses'' pointed out, the "kids" in ''Film/TheWizard'' talk more like 1980's businessmen. That's not even getting into the pedophilia implications of one scene.

to:

* As ''ThatGuyWithTheGlasses'' ''TheNostalgiaCritic'' pointed out, the "kids" in ''Film/TheWizard'' talk more like 1980's businessmen. That's not even getting into the pedophilia implications of one scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Once she [[TalkingTheMonsterToDeath starts expounding at the villain]], any pretense she's supposed to be a young girl goes flying out the window. Terry Pratchett can't write kids.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Gifted kids love this book and empathize strongly with Ender. May be a case of RealityIsUnrealistic.

Added: 69

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Beautifully averted in Steven King's ''{{It}}''. One of the reasons the book is so compelling is that King really gets the way children think and reason.

to:

* Beautifully averted in Steven King's StephenKing's ''{{It}}''. One of the reasons the book is so compelling is that King really gets the way children think and reason.reason.
** Except for [[{{Squick}} that part in the sewers towards the end]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Averted in the works of RobertCormier. His teens swear, masturbate, drink, fight, and just generally flaunt the artificial limits imposed in the majority of American literature.

Added: 130

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Stewie from FamilyGuy. Remember, he's ONE.... Still.

to:

* Stewie from FamilyGuy. Remember, he's ONE.... Still.ONE year old. Still.
--> Brian: I mean, you are getting a little old to have a teddy bear.
--> Stewie: Brian, I'm one!
--> Brian: Still?
--> Stewie: What?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Stewie from FamilyGuy. Remember, he's ONE.... Still.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Please note that there is an inverse function to this trope - most writers are adults, but are so aware they're writing for children that certain activities will be excised from underage characters even if it's realistic for that age. So your sixteen-year-old won't be dying to get laid; they're searching for true love, and [[RelationshipWritingFumble all relationship interactions will be completely romantic rather than sexual]]. And they'll ''never'' smoke, drink, or get high unless it's a VerySpecialEpisode or the character's an antagonist. Also note that children acting in [[TroublingUnchildhoodBehavior ways that they shouldn't be able to, i.e. like adults,]] is also a common [[CreepyChild go-to Horror Trope]]. SoYeah.

to:

Please note that there is an inverse function to this trope - most writers are adults, but are so aware they're writing for children that certain activities will be excised from underage characters even if it's realistic for that age. So your sixteen-year-old won't be dying to get laid; they're searching for true love, and [[RelationshipWritingFumble all relationship interactions will be completely romantic rather than sexual]]. And they'll ''never'' smoke, drink, or get high unless it's a VerySpecialEpisode or the character's an antagonist. Also note that children acting in [[TroublingUnchildhoodBehavior ways that they shouldn't be able to, i.e. like adults,]] is also a common [[CreepyChild go-to Horror Trope]]. SoYeah.\n
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Runaways}}'' focuses on a group of preteens and teenagers living together without any kind of adult supervision. For every example of the characters acting their age--insisting that adults can't be trusted, not knowing about current events because they've been watching ''{{Friends}}'' reruns instead of the news--there's a dozen examples of them handling situations most adults would find overwhelming. And while most of them go through crushes like any normal teenager, two of their relationships become quite serious: Gert and Chase act more like husband and wife than boyfriend and girlfriend, and Xavin and Karolina are actually engaged. (Granted, it started out as an arranged marriage to end the war between their worlds, but they stayed together long after that arrangement fell through.)

to:

* ''{{Runaways}}'' focuses on a group of preteens and teenagers living together without any kind of adult supervision. For every example of the characters acting their age--insisting that adults can't be trusted, age--making out in public places, not knowing about current events because they've been watching ''{{Friends}}'' reruns instead of the news--there's a dozen examples of them handling situations most adults your average adult would find overwhelming. And while most of them go through crushes like any normal teenager, two of their relationships become quite serious: Gert and Chase act more like husband and wife than boyfriend and girlfriend, and Xavin and Karolina are actually engaged. (Granted, it started out as an arranged marriage to end the war between their worlds, home planets, but they stayed together long after that arrangement fell through.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The ''{{Legion of Super-Heroes}},'' depending on the version, had characters considered legally adult at 14. The reboot had Ultra Boy and Phantom Girl getting married at [[ComicBookTime some vague age not too long after that]], which on top of that happened when ''another'' 14 year old almost got married.

Added: 184

Removed: 233

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Once she [[TalkingTheMonsterToDeath starts expounding at the villain]], any pretense she's supposed to be a young girl goes flying out the window. Terry Pratchett can't write kids.



** This trope is actually averted if anything, since the most of character's idea of romance is either a case of short, innocent crushes that kids normally have, or trying to emulate the romance they think adults have, which some do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Beautifully averted in Steven King's ''{{It}}''. One of the reasons the book is so compelling is that King really gets the way children think and reason.

Top