Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / MadwomanInTheAttic

Go To

OR

Added: 748

Changed: 4

Removed: 809

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Anime & Manga]]
* Quoted above: [[spoiler: Sakurako]] from ''SakuraGari'', who has been locked in an old house for nine years [[spoiler: after becoming TheUnfavorite and the death of her mother.]]
* Hisoka Kurosaki from ''YamiNoMatsuei'' is locked away by his parents because of his [[TheEmpath empathic powers]]. [[spoiler: In the manga, it's also to keep him from being the prey to a demon who raped ''both'' of his parents and forcibly impregnated his mom.]]
* At least two cases from ''DetectiveConan'' have people trapped in attics and becoming unstable.
** One featured a gifted writer, hiding in the attic after committing a murder over a decade ago. He was very sane indeed, just rather confused/fascinated over a cellphone.
[[/folder]]



[[folder:Manga And Anime]]
* Quoted above: [[spoiler: Sakurako]] from ''SakuraGari'', who has been locked in an old house for nine years [[spoiler: after becoming TheUnfavorite and the death of her mother.]]
* Hisoka Kurosaki from ''YamiNoMatsuei'' is locked away by his parents because of his [[TheEmpath empathic powers]]. [[spoiler: In the manga, it's also to keep him from being the prey to a demon who raped ''both'' of his parents and forcibly impregnated his mom.]]
* At least two cases from ''DetectiveConan'' have people trapped in attics and becoming unstable.
** One featured a gifted writer, hiding in the attic after committing a murder over a decade ago. He was very sane indeed, just rather confused/fascinated over a cellphone.
[[/folder]]




----
<<|{{Villains}}|>>
<<|HorrorTropes|>>
<<|MadnessTropes|>>

to:

\n----\n<<|{{Villains}}|>>\n<<|HorrorTropes|>>\n<<|MadnessTropes|>>----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[spoiler: Subverted]] in one episode of {{Sanctuary}}, the one with the young autistic boy who draws monsters, a missing twin brother, their dead father, and the room under the floor, which has shackles welded to one wall. [[spoiler: The team originally assume the twin brother was kept down there by an abusive father. By the end of the episode, it turns out that the father was an Abnormal who developed laser eyes during fits, and he was locking himself down there to protect his family.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The horror novel ''Others'' has a whole wing of a nursing home filled with Freaks in the Attic. Some of them are nice people who just have a physical deformity of varying severity. The titular Others, though, either because of their imprisonment, or what the director of the home has been doing to them, or just madness, are true monsters.

Added: 217

Removed: 217

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved the picture up. If this was intentionally that far down the page I apologize.


[[quoteright:300:[[TheGoonies http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/SlothTheGoonies.jpg]]]]
[[caption-width-right:300: I swear on my life, they've got... an "It", a giant "It". They got it chained to the wall.]]



[[quoteright:300:[[TheGoonies http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/SlothTheGoonies.jpg]]]]
[[caption-width-right:300: I swear on my life, they've got... an "It", a giant "It". They got it chained to the wall.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Supposedly the Lemp Family--founders of the now-defunct Lemp brewery--had a a son who was born deformed. He was known as the Monkey Boy, and kept locked in a cage suspended ten feet off the ground, deep in the caverns under the brewery. The cage is still there.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The mother in TheCurse, loosely based on [[HPLovecraft The Color out of Space]] becomes one of these late in the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Then there's "The Yellow Face," in which the ''suspected'' MadwomanInTheAttic in fact turns out to be [[spoiler:simply the main character's mixed-race daughter from a previous marriage, whom she'd kept hidden from her new husband. The story has a happy ending, but leaves you kind of unsure if this has lots of UnfortunateImplications or is simply a plea for tolerance at a time when having a mixed-race child was that severe a social liability. Or both.]]

to:

** Then there's "The Yellow Face," in which the ''suspected'' MadwomanInTheAttic in fact turns out to be [[spoiler:simply the main character's mixed-race daughter from a previous marriage, whom she'd kept hidden from her new husband. The story has a happy ending, ending - the little girl is somehow quite healthy and happy, and her new stepfather accepts her immediately, but leaves you kind of unsure if this has lots of UnfortunateImplications or is simply a plea for tolerance at a time when having a mixed-race child was that severe a social liability. Or both.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Then there's "The Yellow Face," in which the ''suspected'' MadwomanInTheAttic in fact turns out to be [[spoiler:simply the main character's mixed-race daughter from a previous marriage, whom she'd kept hidden from her new husband. The story has a happy ending, but leaves you kind of unsure if this has lots of UnfortunateImplications or is simply a plea for tolerance at a time when having a mixed-race child was that severe a social liability. Or both.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This trope is named for the landmark work of feminist literary criticism by Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar. Oddly, the analysis indicates that this trope first popularly appeared, in all places, in Victorian women's literature, where depicting some women as crazy people was an easy way to make female villains with whom readers would be unlikely to sympathize. Obviously, this plan was not a [[YourMileageMayVary complete success]].

to:

This trope is named for the landmark work of feminist literary criticism by Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar. Oddly, the Gubar, referring to [[spoiler:Mr. Rochester's wife]] in Charlotte Brontë's ''JaneEyre''. The analysis indicates that this trope first popularly appeared, in all places, in Victorian women's literature, where depicting some women as crazy people was an easy way to make female villains with whom readers would be unlikely to sympathize. Obviously, this plan was not a [[YourMileageMayVary complete success]].

Added: 89

Changed: 58

Removed: 89

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: In a subversion, it's not that he's crazy. He's actually, well, ''dead''.]]



* Parodied in a HalloweenEpisode of ''TheSimpsons'', with Bart's EvilTwin, Hugo, locked up in the attic. The TwistEnding was that ''Bart'' was the Evil Twin, so Hugo was allowed to go free (even though he was clearly insane) and Bart is locked up in his place.
** Then again, you'd be insane too if you'd been locked in the attic for your whole life.

to:

* Parodied in a HalloweenEpisode of ''TheSimpsons'', with Bart's EvilTwin, Hugo, locked up in the attic. The TwistEnding was that ''Bart'' was the Evil Twin, so Hugo was allowed to go free (even though he was clearly insane) insane - then again, you'd be insane too, if in his shoes) and Bart is locked up in his place.
** Then again, you'd be insane too if you'd been locked in the attic for your whole life.
place.



* [[FeralChild Kaspar Hauser]] claimed to be one of these.

to:

* [[FeralChild Kaspar Hauser]] claimed to be have been one of these.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Saul Femm from ''The Old Dark House'' (1932), though not incredibly deformed, is a raging madman with a taste for arson and is thus kept locked in his room by the rest of the family with the help of a mute and deformed butler.

to:

* Saul Femm from ''The Old Dark House'' ''TheOldDarkHouse'' (1932), though not incredibly deformed, is a raging madman with a taste for arson and is thus kept locked in his room by the rest of the family with the help of a mute and deformed butler.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If not the UrExample, then certainly the [[AncientGreece Knossos Example]] would be the Minotaur. This was when the queen fell in love with a ''bull'' that was supposed to be sacrificed to Poseidon and... well, she was the queen, she could do what she wanted. She had a child by the bull that was a giant human with the head of a bull. To hide the monster, the king commissioned Daedalus [Icarus' papa] to build an elaborate labyrinth under the city from which no one could escape, in order to hide the Minotaur.

to:

* If not the UrExample, then certainly the [[AncientGreece Knossos Example]] would be the Minotaur. This was when the When Minos decided to keep a bull he had been sent by Poseidon to sacrifice to him, Poseidon made Minos's queen fell fall in love with a ''bull'' that was supposed to be sacrificed to Poseidon and... well, she was the queen, she could do what she wanted. She had a child by the bull that was and conceive a giant human child with the head of a bull. it. To hide the resulting hybrid monster, the king commissioned Daedalus [Icarus' papa] papa, and the man who helped the queen consumate her unnatural love] to build an elaborate labyrinth under the city from which no one could escape, in order to hide the Minotaur.escape.

Added: 285

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* There's a story that was filmed for the ''TwilightZone'' called ''The Howling Man''. In it, the protagonist visits a European monestary in the early 1930s and hears horrible screams in the middle of the night. He finds the man imprisoned and frees him. [[NiceJobBreakingItHero Turns out]] that was Satan [[SealedEvilInACan imprisoned there]] to prevent him from bringing strife to the world, and well, given the time period, you can [[WorldWarTwo guess what happens next]].

to:

* There's a story that was filmed for the ''TwilightZone'' called ''The Howling Man''. In it, the protagonist visits a European monestary monastery in the early 1930s and hears horrible screams in the middle of the night. He finds the man imprisoned and frees him. [[NiceJobBreakingItHero Turns out]] that was Satan [[SealedEvilInACan imprisoned there]] to prevent him from bringing strife to the world, and well, given the time period, you can [[WorldWarTwo guess what happens next]].



* The novel ''The Cellar'' is about a woman who keeps horriffic rat-men in her old house.

to:

* The novel ''The Cellar'' is about a woman who keeps horriffic horrific rat-men in her old house.



* In the ''TouhouProject'', Flandre Scarlet is an EnfantTerrible kept in the basement of the Scarlet Devil Mansion, kept there thanks to a combination of being very mentally unstable, and hitting the SuperpowerLottery jackpot with being able to disintigrate any physical object from a distance. Since some fans prefer a much more sympathetic version of Flandre, there is an AlternativeCharacterInterpretation of her where she is far more friendly and stable... but they are not willing to break the {{canon}} backstory of her being locked away for 495 years, which only leaves them to make Remilia completely KickTheDog by seeming to lock her little sister away for no good reason, ironically making Remilia less sympathetic as they make Flandre more sympathetic.

to:

* In the ''TouhouProject'', Flandre Scarlet is an EnfantTerrible kept in the basement of the Scarlet Devil Mansion, kept there thanks to a combination of being very mentally unstable, and hitting the SuperpowerLottery jackpot with being able to disintigrate disintegrate any physical object from a distance. Since some fans prefer a much more sympathetic version of Flandre, there is an AlternativeCharacterInterpretation of her where she is far more friendly and stable... but they are not willing to break the {{canon}} backstory of her being locked away for 495 years, which only leaves them to make Remilia completely KickTheDog by seeming to lock her little sister away for no good reason, ironically making Remilia less sympathetic as they make Flandre more sympathetic.


Added DiffLines:

* In the ''SouthPark'' episode "Marjorine", Butters is selected to [[FakingTheDead fake his death]]. When he returns home, his parents chain him up in the basement believing he is a DamagedSoul and kill a woman so he can feed. Due to NegativeContinuity, he is out in the next episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the short story, The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas, a filthy, malnourished little child of indeterminate gender is locked in a windowless room and treated as an animal for the vague good of the community.



<<|MadnessTropes|>>

to:

<<|MadnessTropes|>>
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Done with the half-breed Scorpius in {{Farscape}}. He was raised on a Scarran ship in a single room and only one person ever entered the room or interacted with him in any way.

to:

* Done with the half-breed Scorpius [[MagnificentBastard Scorpius]] in {{Farscape}}. He ''{{Farscape}}.'' The episode "Incubator" reveals that was raised on a Scarran ship in a single room and his only visitor was his "nanny," [[CompleteMonster Tauza]]- until, of course, Scorpius managed to escape. Quite worryingly, it's implied that Scorpius' [[TheWoobie mother]] was imprisoned in the same cell in a pretty similar fashion; according to Tauza, her [[RapeIsASpecialKindOfEvil impregnation]] at the hands of one person ever entered of the room or interacted with him in any way.guards [[BreakTheCutie drove her insane]]- making her a quite literal case of MadwomanInTheAttic.

Added: 210

Removed: 304

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Of course, back then the profession of Special Education didn't exist, and the alternative was to send the child to a Snake Pit. Arguably, being locked up by people who cared for you at least a little was better than being locked up with a bunch of other freaks under the supervision of hired sadists.


Added DiffLines:

* John Langdon Down (of Down Syndrome fame) advised against this in his writings, arguing that institutionalization was more humane, and that isolation and lack of education tended to make mental defects worse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, dubious sources, but I seem to recall an interview in which Flandre indicated to Aya that she was okay with this treatment.

Added: 537

Changed: 107

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the ''DoctorWho'' ExpandedUniverse, one of the Eighth Doctor novels has a woman keeping a whole load of deformed and disabled people away from society. But in a bit of a twist, she's quite nice to them, treating them almost like family, and refers to them affectionately as "mooncalves". The story takes place in a Dystopia where they wouldn't be safe anywhere else.

to:

* In the ''DoctorWho'' ExpandedUniverse, one of the Eighth Doctor novels has EighthDoctorAdventures novel ''Vanishing Point'', this trope is reconstructed with a woman keeping a whole load number of deformed and disabled people away from society. But in a bit of a twist, she's quite nice to them, treating them almost like family, and refers to them affectionately as "mooncalves". The story takes place in a Dystopia where they wouldn't be safe anywhere else.else.
** In ''The Blue Angel'', the LighterAndFluffier variant continues. The AmbiguouslyHuman AlternateReality Doctor's [[MyBelovedSmother Beloved Smother]] is a [[OurMermaidsAreDifferent mermaid]], and he has two hearts, no navel, and several other general idiosyncrasies. He's also [[TheOphelia delusional]], although it's not clear when that developed. At any rate, as his mother considered both him and herself too weird for society, he grew up as a shut-in. It might not have done his mental health any favors, but his mother meant well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Larry Blamire's DarkAndStormyNight has Thessaly [[spoiler: Sinas Cavendar's insane daughter.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Francis Hodgson Bernett's ''The Secret Garden'', Mary's uncle keeps his son and Mary's cousin, a bedridden hunchback and sickly child named Cedric, hidden away in the house for fear that he will not be able to survive in normal society, and shuns him because of the boy's resemblance to his dead mother.

to:

* In Francis Hodgson Bernett's ''The Secret Garden'', Mary's uncle keeps his son and Mary's cousin, a bedridden hunchback and sickly child named Cedric, Colin, hidden away in the house for fear that he will not be able to survive in normal society, and shuns him because of the boy's resemblance to his dead mother.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Done with the half-breed Scorpius in {{Farscape}}. He was raised on a Scarran ship in a single room and only one person ever entered the room or interacted with him in any way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The opening narration for KissTheGirls describes a self-inflicted version of this: Casanova moves into the attic of the house where his "first love" lives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The legend of the [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monster_of_Glamis Monster of Glamis]], which seems to have at least some factual basis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The protagonist in {{Neil Gaiman}}'s short story "Forbidden Brides of the Faceless Slaves in the Nameless House of the Night of Dread Desire" has an Aunt Agatha chained in his attic. This has no bearing on the plot, it's just one of the things that establish that he lives in a world of Gothic/adventure/fantasy/horror fiction clichés. A character in the story he's writing is also mentioned to have (had) a "hopelessly insane" wife whom he claimed to be dead. Well, he ''is'' writing a realistic, slice of life story based on the world he's living in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I think it's been said/a fan theory that Flan was never LOCKED in the basement... She just couldn't go outside of the mansion anyway, and she had everything she needed in the basement. So why leave?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Some fans prefer to think of it as less Flandre being a psycho killer and more her having no concept of death being a permanent thing (probably not helped by the fact that for some residents of Gensokyo, it ''isn't''). Combining that with her ability to instantly kill people with basically no effort (as she describes it herself at one point, "I went 'kyu' and it went 'boom'.") and you've got a situation where it's highly advantageous for her to not meet other people.

Changed: 71

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Somewhat reversed in {{Fallout}} 3 DLC ''point lookout'' where a deformed couple have a normal looking son and hide him in the basement (untill he runs away)

to:

* Somewhat reversed in {{Fallout}} 3 DLC ''point lookout'' with [[http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Kenny_%28Point_Lookout%29 Kenny]] where a deformed couple have a normal looking son and hide him in the basement (untill he runs away)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Somewhat reversed in {{Fallout}} 3 DLC ''point lookout'' where a deformed couple have a normal looking son and hide him in the basement (untill he runs away)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Penguin in BatmanReturns spends his early years as this, before his parents get rid of him by throwing him to the river.

to:

* The Penguin in BatmanReturns ''BatmanReturns'' spends his early years as this, before his parents get rid of him by throwing him to the river.



*Happens twice in Harry Potter- to Harry himself in the first book, and [[spoiler: Dumbledore's little sister Ariana]]. Subverted with Harry, though, as he was locked in a cupboard under a stairway, but was allowed outside unless he showed signs of magic. He was then freed when all the letters came from Hogwarts, but only because his aunt and uncle thought the letters would stop coming if he slept in a different part of the house. And then he got locked in there anyway, and food was passed to him through a cat flap.

to:

*Happens twice in Harry Potter- ''Harry Potter''- to Harry himself in the first book, and [[spoiler: Dumbledore's little sister Ariana]]. Subverted with Harry, though, as he was locked in a cupboard under a stairway, but was allowed outside unless he showed signs of magic. He was then freed when all the letters came from Hogwarts, but only because his aunt and uncle thought the letters would stop coming if he slept in a different part of the house. And then he got locked in there anyway, and food was passed to him through a cat flap.



*The novel "The Cellar" is about a woman who keeps horriffic rat-men in her old house.

to:

*The novel "The Cellar" ''The Cellar'' is about a woman who keeps horriffic rat-men in her old house.



* The Richard Matheson short story "Born Of Man and Woman" is told from the point of such a person, a vaguely described grotesque who is both pitiable and terrifying at once.

to:

* The Richard Matheson short story "Born ''Born Of Man and Woman" Woman'' is told from the point of such a person, a vaguely described grotesque who is both pitiable and terrifying at once.



* {{Supernatural}} has this as the twist in [[spoiler: "Family Remains", when they discover the last owner of the house kept the twins he conceived with his daughter. The daughter committed suicide and the father was killed by the children, then a new family moved in...]]

to:

* {{Supernatural}} ''{{Supernatural}}'' has this as the twist in [[spoiler: "Family Remains", when they discover the last owner of the house kept the twins he conceived with his daughter. The daughter committed suicide and the father was killed by the children, then a new family moved in...]]



* Quoted above: [[spoiler: Sakurako]] from SakuraGari, who has been locked in an old house for nine years [[spoiler: after becoming TheUnfavorite and the death of her mother.]]
* Hisoka Kurosaki from YamiNoMatsuei is locked away by his parents because of his [[TheEmpath empathic powers]]. [[spoiler: In the manga, it's also to keep him from being the prey to a demon who raped ''both'' of his parents and forcibly impregnated his mom.]]
* At least two cases from DetectiveConan have people trapped in attics and becoming unstable.

to:

* Quoted above: [[spoiler: Sakurako]] from SakuraGari, ''SakuraGari'', who has been locked in an old house for nine years [[spoiler: after becoming TheUnfavorite and the death of her mother.]]
* Hisoka Kurosaki from YamiNoMatsuei ''YamiNoMatsuei'' is locked away by his parents because of his [[TheEmpath empathic powers]]. [[spoiler: In the manga, it's also to keep him from being the prey to a demon who raped ''both'' of his parents and forcibly impregnated his mom.]]
* At least two cases from DetectiveConan ''DetectiveConan'' have people trapped in attics and becoming unstable.



* In the third edition {{Ravenloft}} products from Arthaus, the role of half-orcs is instead given to 'calibans': a PC race of Berthas in the Attic, usually born to human mothers who'd been exposed to black magic or curses while pregnant.

to:

* In the third edition {{Ravenloft}} ''{{Ravenloft}}'' products from Arthaus, the role of half-orcs is instead given to 'calibans': a PC race of Berthas in the Attic, usually born to human mothers who'd been exposed to black magic or curses while pregnant.



*Genestealer Hybrids in {{Warhammer40000}}. Most have three arms and greyish skin, so they generally camp out in the Underhive (which, when we get right down to it, is the Hive City answer to "basement) to avoid getting picked up by the cops for execution by torture. Many of them are also Psykers (who are also often sequestered by their families), who are batshit crazy anyways, due to the scrabbling of Daemons at the back of their mind, and the constant nightmares and flashes of precognition this produces.
*Ogre Gorgers from {{Warhammer}}. They don't start out crazy, but ''scrawny''. Constant exposure to [[GreenRocks Warpstone]] drives them insane and mutates them horribly.

to:

*Genestealer Hybrids in {{Warhammer40000}}.''{{Warhammer 40000}}''. Most have three arms and greyish skin, so they generally camp out in the Underhive (which, when we get right down to it, is the Hive City answer to "basement) to avoid getting picked up by the cops for execution by torture. Many of them are also Psykers (who are also often sequestered by their families), who are batshit crazy anyways, due to the scrabbling of Daemons at the back of their mind, and the constant nightmares and flashes of precognition this produces.
*Ogre Gorgers from {{Warhammer}}.''{{Warhammer}}''. They don't start out crazy, but ''scrawny''. Constant exposure to [[GreenRocks Warpstone]] drives them insane and mutates them horribly.



* In [[DarkCornersOfTheEarth Call of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of the Earth]], a woman in the [[spoiler: Waite's home]] is kept in the attic as she falls to TheCorruption. The husband is just trying to keep his family safe, though.

to:

* In [[DarkCornersOfTheEarth ''[[DarkCornersOfTheEarth Call of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of the Earth]], Earth]]'', a woman in the [[spoiler: Waite's home]] is kept in the attic as she falls to TheCorruption. The husband is just trying to keep his family safe, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Top