History Main / LikeYouWouldReallyDoIt

Oh no! The poor IllGirl [[LittlestCancerPatient with cancer]] who runs the orphanage is being menaced by the SerialKiller! [[AnyoneCanDie No one has survived his attacks yet]], and it's going to break her fiancé's heart, and after he finally got up the courage to propose to her!

->'''''{{Franchise/Superman}} #429''': Superman kicks the bucket again. Sure to be a collectors' item with stupid fans who actually think that Creator/DCComics is going to kill off a character worth billions of dollars.''

This is when the audience turn to the writer and say, ''"Like You Would Really Do It"''. Much like YankTheDogsChain in reverse, this is what GenreSavvy viewers retort when their WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief is no longer suspended, and in fact falls flat on its back because the writing staff that was supposed to catch it in the "[[TrustBuildingBlunder trust building exercise]]" [[AttentionDeficitOohShiny have wandered off to look at something shiny]].

What this means is the audience don't buy the suspense or anguish that the character is being menaced with. They ''know'' the SortingAlgorithmOfMortality has this particular character dead last (pun intended) in terms of who's gonna die, and so they just count the seconds before the door is smashed open and TheCavalry charges in, or the bad guy goes "You're NotWorthKilling", or if the character should actually appear dead, for the (failed) FakeKillScare to be revealed. This reaction extends not just to the [[InfantImmortality stunningly innocent]], but to [[OurHeroIsDead any hero]] or character with thick PlotArmour in a setting where things CouldHaveBeenMessy. Even the HeroicSacrifice, capable of felling the mightiest of heroes, falls short of [[NotQuiteDead really killing them.]]

When actually killed, leads to speculation that HesJustHiding. See also {{Narm}}. Often overlaps with a DisneyDeath. If it involves whether a hero will win or lose a battle, it's BoringInvincibleHero. If the story attempts to convince you that the main character is killed off even though they obviously can't be or the story would end, see OurHeroIsDead. If this applies to lesser good characters who might otherwise be killed off, it's BoringImmortalHero. TheGoodGuysAlwaysWin is the most common cause. Contrast EightDeadlyWords: here it is not lack of care for the characters as much as certainty that they will make it out ok.

What this means is the audience don't buy the suspense or anguish that the character is being menaced with. They ''know'' the SortingAlgorithmOfMortality has this particular character dead last (pun intended) in terms of who's gonna die, and so they just count the seconds before the door is smashed open and TheCavalry charges in, or the bad guy goes "You're NotWorthKilling". This reaction extends not just to the [[InfantImmortality stunningly innocent]], but to [[OurHeroIsDead any hero]] or character with thick PlotArmour in a setting where things CouldHaveBeenMessy. Even the HeroicSacrifice, capable of felling the mightiest of heroes, falls short of [[NotQuiteDead really killing them.]]

This is when we turn to the writer and say, ''"Like You Would Really Do It"''. Much like YankTheDogsChain in reverse, this is what GenreSavvy viewers retort when their WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief is no longer suspended, and in fact falls flat on its back because the writing staff that was supposed to catch it in the "[[TrustBuildingBlunder trust building exercise]]" [[AttentionDeficitOohShiny have wandered off to look at something shiny]].

What this means is we don't buy the suspense or anguish that the character is being menaced with, we ''know'' the SortingAlgorithmOfMortality has this particular character dead last (pun intended) in terms of who's gonna die, and so we just count the seconds before the door is smashed open and TheCavalry charges in, or the bad guy goes "You're NotWorthKilling". This reaction extends not just to the [[InfantImmortality stunningly innocent]], but to [[OurHeroIsDead any hero]] or character with thick PlotArmour in a setting where things CouldHaveBeenMessy. Even the HeroicSacrifice, capable of felling the mightiest of heroes, falls short of [[NotQuiteDead really killing them.]]

Mind, some authors really ''will'' call our bluff and kill this character, ''[[KilledOffForReal permanently]]'', and since the vast majority don't, it comes as [[HesJustHiding quite a shock when they do.]] Generally, actually offing a traditionally "safe" character requires a [[CerebusSyndrome shift in tone]] for lighter series, but reinforces the AnyoneCanDie tone of more [[SlidingScaleOfIdealismVersusCynicism cynical works]]. Of course, taking it ''too'' far can create a MoralEventHorizon for the author in the eyes of his fanbase, or it can cause them to [[DarknessInducedAudienceApathy stop caring about any of the characters]] because they'll probably all end up dead anyway.

When actually killed, leads to speculation that HesJustHiding. See also {{Narm}}. Often overlaps with a DisneyDeath. If it involves whether a hero will win or lose a battle, it's BoringInvincibleHero. If the story attempts to convince you that the main character is killed off even though they obviously can't be or the story would end, see OurHeroIsDead. If this applies to lesser good characters who might otherwise be killed off, it's BoringImmortalHero. TheGoodGuysAlwaysWin is the most common cause. Contrast EightDeadlyWords.

This is when we turn to the writer and say, ''"Like You Would Really Do It"''. Much like YankTheDogsChain in reverse, this is what GenreSavvy viewers retort when their WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief is no longer suspended, and in fact falls flat on its back because the writing staff that was supposed to catch it in the "[[TrustBuildingBlunder trust building exercise]]" [[DistractedByTheShiny have wandered off to look at something shiny]].

-->--''Magazine/{{MAD}}''

When actually killed, leads to speculation that HesJustHiding. See also {{Narm}}. Often overlaps with a DisneyDeath. If it involves whether a hero will win or lose a battle, it's BoringInvincibleHero. If the story attempts to convince you that the main character is killed off even though they obviously can't be or the story would end, see OurHeroIsDead. If this applies to lesser good characters who might otherwise be killed off, it's BoringImmortalHero. TheGoodGuysAlwaysWin is the most common cause. Contrast AudienceApathy.

->'''''{{Franchise/Superman}} #429''': Superman kicks the bucket again. [[SarcasmMode Sure to be a collectors' item]] with [[ViewersAreMorons stupid fans]] who actually think that Creator/DCComics is going to kill off a character [[CashCowFranchise worth billions of dollars]].''

->'''''{{Franchise/Superman}} #429''': Superman kicks the bucket again. Sure to be a collectors' item with stupid fans who actually think that Creator/DCComics is going to kill off a character worth billions of dollars.''

When actually killed, leads to speculation that HesJustHiding. See also {{Narm}}. Often overlaps with a DisneyDeath. If it involves whether a hero will win or lose a battle, it's BoringInvincibleHero. If this applies to lesser good characters who might otherwise be killed off, it's BoringImmortalHero. TheGoodGuysAlwaysWin is the most common cause. Contrast AudienceApathy.

This is when we turn to the writer and say, ''"LikeYouWouldReallyDoIt"''. Much like YankTheDogsChain in reverse, this is what GenreSavvy viewers retort when their WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief is no longer suspended, and in fact falls flat on its back because the writing staff that was supposed to catch it in the "[[TrustBuildingBlunder trust building exercise]]" [[DistractedByTheShiny have wandered off to look at something shiny]].

->'''''Superman #429''': Superman kicks the bucket again. Sure to be a collectors' item with stupid fans who actually think that DCComics is going to kill off a character worth billions of dollars.''

Mind, some authors really ''will'' call our bluff and kill this character, ''[[KilledOffForReal permanently]]'', and since the vast majority don't it comes as [[HesJustHiding quite a shock when they do.]] Generally, actually offing a traditionally "safe" character requires a [[CerebusSyndrome shift in tone]] for lighter series, but reinforces the AnyoneCanDie tone of more [[SlidingScaleOfIdealismVersusCynicism cynical works]]. Of course, taking it ''too'' far can create a MoralEventHorizon for the author in the eyes of his fanbase, or it can cause them to [[DarknessInducedAudienceApathy stop caring about any of the characters]] because they'll probably all end up dead anyway.

-->--''MADMagazine''

When actually killed, leads to speculation that HesJustHiding. See also [[{{Narm}} Narm]]. Often overlaps with a DisneyDeath. If it involves whether a hero will win or lose a battle, it's BoringInvincibleHero. If this applies to lesser good characters who might otherwise be killed off, it's BoringImmortalHero. TheGoodGuysAlwaysWin is the most common cause. Contrast AudienceApathy.

When actually killed, leads to speculation that [=~He's Just Hiding~=]. See also [[{{Narm}} Narm]]. Often overlaps with a DisneyDeath. If it involves whether a hero will win or lose a battle, it's BoringInvincibleHero. If this applies to lesser good characters who might otherwise be killed off, it's BoringImmortalHero. TheGoodGuysAlwaysWin is the most common cause. Contrast AudienceApathy.

----
<<|SubjectiveTropes|>>

This is when we turn to the writer and say, ''"LikeYouWouldReallyDoIt"''. Much like YankTheDogsChain in reverse, this is what GenreSavvy viewers retort when their WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief is not suspended, and in fact falls flat on its back as the writing staff that was supposed to catch it in the "[[TrustBuildingBlunder trust building exercise]]" [[DistractedByTheShiny have wandered off to look at something shiny]].

->'''Some Hospital in D.C.'''\\
'''EMT:''' Ma'am? Did someone order an ambulance for The LittlestCancerPatient?\\
'''LUCY:''' OH MY GOD I LOVE YOU.\\
'''HEARTSTRING #79:''' *does not tug* \\
'''SCREENWRITERS:''' What?\\
'''AUDIENCE:''' Oh, whatever. Like you were going to kill off The LittlestCancerPatient.
-->--'''The Day After Tomorrow''' [[http://community.livejournal.com/m15m/2025.html#cutid2 review]] in ''Movies in 15 Minutes,'' by CleolindaJones

Mind, some authors really ''will'' call our bluff and kill this character, ''[[KilledOffForReal permanently]]'', and since the vast majority don't it comes as [[HesJustHiding quite a shock when they do.]] Generally, actually offing a traditionally "safe" character requires a [[CerebusSyndrome shift in tone]] for lighter series, but reinforces the AnyoneCanDie tone of more [[SlidingScaleOfIdealismVersusCynicism cynical works]]. Of course, taking it ''too'' far can create a MoralEventHorizon for the author in the eyes of his fanbase.

When actually killed, leads to speculation that [=~He's Just Hiding~=]. See also [[{{Narm}} Narm]]. Often overlaps with a DisneyDeath. If it involves whether a hero will win or lose a battle, it's BoringInvincibleHero. If this applies to lesser good characters who might otherwise be killed off, it's BoringImmortalHero. TheGoodGuysAlwaysWin is the most common cause.

'''No examples, please.''' [[spoiler: We'd be here all day.]]

When actually killed, leads to speculation that [=~He's Just Hiding~=]. See also [[{{Narm}} Narm]]. Often overlaps with a DisneyDeath. If it involves whether a hero will win or lose a battle, it's BoringInvincibleHero. If this applies to lesser good characters who might otherwise be killed off, it's BoringImmortalHero.

'''No examples, please.'''

----

'''HEARTSTRING #79:''' * does not tug* \\

----
<<|{{Fan-Speak}}|>>
<<|UnexpectedReactionsToThisIndex|>>
<<|DeathTropes|>>
<<|SubjectiveTropes|>>

<<|DeathTropes|>>

'''No examples, please.''' (Why not? Too Subjective? I am sure there is the possibility to get Objective Examples.)