Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / JacobAndEsau

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Edit description (I don\'t think the Daddys Girl / Mommas Boy pattern is the most common at all.)


The most common stereotype is a DaddysGirl and a MommasBoy. A common variation if both siblings are the same gender is for [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the tougher or "manlier" one]] to be [[LikeFatherLikeSon closer to the dad]], and [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the more sensitive or "girlier" one]] to be [[MommasBoy closer to the mom]].

to:

The most common stereotype is a DaddysGirl and a MommasBoy. A common variation if If both siblings are the same gender gender, it is common for [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the tougher or "manlier" one]] to be [[LikeFatherLikeSon closer to the dad]], and [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the more sensitive or "girlier" one]] to be [[MommasBoy closer to the mom]].mom]]. A common variation with opposite-gender siblings is to have a DaddysGirl and a MommasBoy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Add work: Thor - Thor & Loki



to:

* [[{{Film/Thor}} Thor and Loki]]. At least in ''Film/ThorTheDarkWorld'', it's implied that Frigga preferred Loki, while Odin seems to have favoured Thor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even [[WigDressAccent conspire successfully]] to cheat [[WildHair Esau]] out of his inheritance. [[labelnote:*]]Esau's alienation does not last forever. Esau's descendants are the Edomites, and Jacob's descendants are the Israelites (including the Jews). During the Secunda period of Judaea, the Edomites become part of the Jewish people and share their inheritance again.[[/labelnote]]

to:

* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even [[WigDressAccent conspire successfully]] to cheat [[WildHair Esau]] out of his inheritance. [[labelnote:*]]Esau's alienation does not last forever. forever; the two brothers made peace years later. Furthermore, Esau's descendants are the Edomites, and Jacob's descendants are the Israelites (including the Jews). During the Secunda period of Judaea, the Edomites become part of the Jewish people and share their inheritance again.[[/labelnote]]

Added: 235

Changed: 89

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:



to:

* Two of the princes of Númenor are described this way in ''Literature/TheSilmarillion'':
-->No love was there between Ar-Gimilzôr and his queen, or between their sons. Inziladûn, the elder, was like his mother in mind as in body; but Gimilkhâd, the younger, went with his father, unless he were yet prouder and more wilful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Edit description (I thought the previous sentence made the \"especially\" redundant.)


The most common stereotype is a DaddysGirl and a MommasBoy. A common variation, especially if both siblings are the same gender, is for [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the tougher or "manlier" one]] to be [[LikeFatherLikeSon closer to the dad]], and [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the more sensitive or "girlier" one]] to be [[MommasBoy closer to the mom]].

to:

The most common stereotype is a DaddysGirl and a MommasBoy. A common variation, especially variation if both siblings are the same gender, gender is for [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the tougher or "manlier" one]] to be [[LikeFatherLikeSon closer to the dad]], and [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the more sensitive or "girlier" one]] to be [[MommasBoy closer to the mom]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:



to:

* ''Film/ThePhiladelphiaStory'' plays a fairly subtle version of this with Dinah and Tracy, who resemble their mother and father, respectively. Dinah and Margaret both act pretty kooky at times. Meanwhile Tracy's rivalry with Seth clearly stems from the fact that they both have strong personalities, and part of Tracy's [[DefrostingTheIceQueen rehabilitation]] is acknowledging that they are not as different as she'd like to believe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Add work: Holiday

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:Film]]
* In ''{{Film/Holiday}}'', Linda seems to take after her mother, while Julia is more in line with her father.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This causes Catelyn some amount of angst, at least before [[FromBadToWorse other concerns rear their head]]: Jon is the only son who takes after Ned physically, yet he's the illegitimate one. [[spoiler: Or maybe not.]]

to:

** This causes Catelyn some amount of angst, at least before [[FromBadToWorse other concerns rear their head]]: Jon is the only son who takes after Ned physically, yet he's the illegitimate one. [[spoiler: [[FamilyRelationshipSwitcheroo Or maybe not.not]] .]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This causes Catelyn some amount of angst, at least before [[FromBadToWorse other concerns rear their head]]: Jon is the only son who takes after Ned physically, yet he's the illegitimate one.

to:

** This causes Catelyn some amount of angst, at least before [[FromBadToWorse other concerns rear their head]]: Jon is the only son who takes after Ned physically, yet he's the illegitimate one. [[spoiler: Or maybe not.]]

Added: 256

Removed: 245

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:Film]]
* In ''TheLionInWinter'', Henry wants his youngest son, [[YoungestChildWins John]], to succeed him, but his wife is plotting to get [[MommasBoy Richard]] onto the throne. Poor [[MiddleChildSyndrome Geoffrey]] has to make his own luck.


Added DiffLines:

[[AC:Theatre]]
* In ''Theatre/TheLionInWinter'', Henry wants his youngest son, [[YoungestChildWins John]], to succeed him, but his wife is plotting to get [[MommasBoy Richard]] onto the throne. Poor [[MiddleChildSyndrome Geoffrey]] has to make his own luck.

Changed: 326

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''TheSimpsons'' does this with Bart mirroring Homer's lazier, more irresponsible attitude and Lisa closer to Marge's responsible nature (including nigh-identical disapproving sounds). This is often particularly highlighted in episodes where the parents spend time with the "opposite" child (Bart and Marge or Lisa and Homer)

Changed: 688

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed example not an example of this trope


* ''{{Friends}}'' has siblings Ross and Monica on opposite ends of the parental favoritism spectrum. Ross gets all the love and praise from his parents due to him being very intelligent (he has a [=PhD=]) and they figure he can do no wrong. Monica gets nothing but passive aggressive criticism from her mother while her father acts ignorant to the favoritism issue. This is magnified tenfold where Ross gets divorced multiple times (1st time was from a lesbian, 2nd time was from a failed marriage, and the 3rd time was done while drunk) and his parents look the other way while Monica's dating life is constantly scrutinized, especially when she winds up with a man who is twice her age.

to:

* ''{{Friends}}'' has siblings Ross and Monica on opposite ends of the parental favoritism spectrum. Ross gets all the love and praise from his parents due to him being very intelligent (he has a [=PhD=]) and they figure he can do no wrong. Monica gets nothing but passive aggressive criticism from her mother while her father acts ignorant to the favoritism issue. This is magnified tenfold where Ross gets divorced multiple times (1st time was from a lesbian, 2nd time was from a failed marriage, and the 3rd time was done while drunk) and his parents look the other way while Monica's dating life is constantly scrutinized, especially when she winds up with a man who is twice her age.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** This causes Catelyn some amount of angst, at least before [[ItGotWorse other concerns rear their head]]: Jon is the only son who takes after Ned physically, yet he's the illegitimate one.

to:

** This causes Catelyn some amount of angst, at least before [[ItGotWorse [[FromBadToWorse other concerns rear their head]]: Jon is the only son who takes after Ned physically, yet he's the illegitimate one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''{{Friends}}'' has siblings Ross and Monica on opposite ends of the parental favoritism spectrum. Ross gets all the love and praise from his parents due to him being very intelligent (he has a [=PhD=]) and they figure he can do no wrong. Monica gets nothing but passive aggressive criticism from her mother while her father acts ignorant to the favoritism issue. This is magnified tenfold where Ross gets divorced multiple times (1st time was from a lesbian, 2nd time was from a failed marriage, and the 3rd time was done while drunk) and his parents look the other way while Monica's dating life is constantly scrutinized, especially when she winds up with a man who is twice her age.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''AvatarTheLastAirbender'': Ozai preferred Azula, Ursa preferred Zuko. Of course, this is a BigScrewedUpFamily being talked about here, so...

to:

* ''AvatarTheLastAirbender'': ''WesternAnimation/AvatarTheLastAirbender'': Ozai preferred Azula, Ursa preferred Zuko. Of course, this is a BigScrewedUpFamily being talked about here, so...here.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even [[WigDressAccent conspire successfully]] to cheat [[WildHair Esau]] out of his inheritance. [[hottip:*:Esau's alienation does not last forever. Esau's descendants are the Edomites, and Jacob's descendants are the Israelites (including the Jews). During the Secunda period of Judaea, the Edomites become part of the Jewish people and share their inheritance again.]]

to:

* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even [[WigDressAccent conspire successfully]] to cheat [[WildHair Esau]] out of his inheritance. [[hottip:*:Esau's [[labelnote:*]]Esau's alienation does not last forever. Esau's descendants are the Edomites, and Jacob's descendants are the Israelites (including the Jews). During the Secunda period of Judaea, the Edomites become part of the Jewish people and share their inheritance again.]]
[[/labelnote]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking



to:

* Literature/LowlandsOfScotlandSeries: Given that the books are based on the story of Jacob, the presence of this trope is unsurprising. Jamie is the more genteel, thoughtful, and sly brother who is close to and favored by their mother; Evan is the rougher, tougher, blunt hunter who is closer to and favored by their father. They have all the SiblingRivalry of the originals, too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even [[WigBeardAccent conspire successfully]] to cheat [[WildHair Esau]] out of his inheritance. [[hottip:*:Esau's alienation does not last forever. Esau's descendants are the Edomites, and Jacob's descendants are the Israelites (including the Jews). During the Secunda period of Judaea, the Edomites become part of the Jewish people and share their inheritance again.]]

to:

* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even [[WigBeardAccent [[WigDressAccent conspire successfully]] to cheat [[WildHair Esau]] out of his inheritance. [[hottip:*:Esau's alienation does not last forever. Esau's descendants are the Edomites, and Jacob's descendants are the Israelites (including the Jews). During the Secunda period of Judaea, the Edomites become part of the Jewish people and share their inheritance again.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even conspire successfully to cheat Esau out of his inheritance. [[hottip:*:Esau's alienation does not last forever. Esau's descendants are the Edomites, and Jacob's descendants are the Israelites (including the Jews). During the Secunda period of Judaea, the Edomites become part of the Jewish people and share their inheritance again.]]

to:

* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even [[WigBeardAccent conspire successfully successfully]] to cheat Esau [[WildHair Esau]] out of his inheritance. [[hottip:*:Esau's alienation does not last forever. Esau's descendants are the Edomites, and Jacob's descendants are the Israelites (including the Jews). During the Secunda period of Judaea, the Edomites become part of the Jewish people and share their inheritance again.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''AvatarTheLastAirbender'': Ozai preferred Azula, Ursa preferred Zuko. Of course, this is a BigScrewedUpFamily being talked about here, so....

to:

* ''AvatarTheLastAirbender'': Ozai preferred Azula, Ursa preferred Zuko. Of course, this is a BigScrewedUpFamily being talked about here, so....
so...
* ''{{Daria}}'' has a subtle example where [[TheSnarkKnight Daria]] and [[BumblingDad Jake]] seem particularly close while [[ParentsAsPeople Helen]] bonds more easily with [[LovableLibby Quinn]]. However, Helen in particular still manages to help Daria on several occasions (generally more competently than Jake, if not quite as easy-going).



* TruthInTelevision. According to this [[http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2094371-1,00.html article in Time]], research shows that parents do have favorites even if they will never admit that they do.

to:

* TruthInTelevision. According to this [[http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2094371-1,00.html article in Time]], research shows that parents do have favorites even if they will never admit that they do.

Added: 93

Changed: 203

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* On ''{{Roseanne}}'' Dan's favorites are Darlene and DJ, while the title character is closer to Becky.

to:

* On ''{{Roseanne}}'' Dan's favorites are Darlene and DJ, favorite is Darlene, while the title character is closer to Becky.Becky. They spend an episode trying to switch and each form a closer relationship with the other daughter. When everything blows up in their faces, they agree to go back to the way things were.
-->'''Dan''': So which one of us gets to ruin DJ's life?
-->'''Roseanne''': We'll flip a coin.



* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even conspire successfully to cheat Esau out of his inherritance. [[hottip:*:Esau's alienation does not last forever. Esau's descendants are the Edomites, and Jacob's descendants are the Israelites (including the Jews). During the Secunda period of Judaea, the Edomites become part of the Jewish people and share their inheritance again.]]

to:

* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even conspire successfully to cheat Esau out of his inherritance.inheritance. [[hottip:*:Esau's alienation does not last forever. Esau's descendants are the Edomites, and Jacob's descendants are the Israelites (including the Jews). During the Secunda period of Judaea, the Edomites become part of the Jewish people and share their inheritance again.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
which renders it moot. Lion-O resembles both in appearance and we don\'t see enough of the queen to say she resembles Lion-O in personality


* In ''WesternAnimation/ThunderCats2011'', we have Tygra/Claudus and Lion-O/the Queen. It's worse for Lion-O since [[spoiler:his mother died giving birth to him.]]

to:

* In ''WesternAnimation/ThunderCats2011'', we have Tygra/Claudus and Lion-O/the Queen. It's worse for Lion-O since [[spoiler:his mother died giving birth to him.]]

Changed: 164

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''WesternAnimation/ThunderCats2011'', we have Tygra/Claudus and Lion-O/the Queen. It's worse for Lion-O since [[spoiler:his mother died giving birth to him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This causes Catelyn some amount of angst, at least before [[ItGotWorse other concerns rear their head]]: Jon is the only son who takes after Ned physically, yet he's the illegitimate one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A common variation, especially when both siblings are the same gender, is for [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the tougher or "manlier" one]] to be closer to the dad, and [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the more sensitive or "girlier" one]] to be closer to the mom.

to:

The most common stereotype is a DaddysGirl and a MommasBoy. A common variation, especially when if both siblings are the same gender, is for [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the tougher or "manlier" one]] to be [[LikeFatherLikeSon closer to the dad, dad]], and [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the more sensitive or "girlier" one]] to be [[MommasBoy closer to the mom.mom]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even conspire successfully to cheat Esau out of his inherritance.

to:

* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even conspire successfully to cheat Esau out of his inherritance.
inherritance. [[hottip:*:Esau's alienation does not last forever. Esau's descendants are the Edomites, and Jacob's descendants are the Israelites (including the Jews). During the Secunda period of Judaea, the Edomites become part of the Jewish people and share their inheritance again.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''[[That70sShow That 70's Show]]'': Red makes no secret of his preference for Laurie, while Kitty is subtler about her favoritism toward Eric.

to:

* ''[[That70sShow That 70's Show]]'': ''Series/That70sShow'': Red makes no secret of his preference for Laurie, while Kitty is subtler about her favoritism toward Eric.

Added: 421

Changed: 418

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ''{{Series/Heroes}}'': According to Mama Petrelli, Nathan [[LikeFatherLikeSon takes after his father]] but Peter [[MommasBoy was always her favourite]]. Of course, Mama Petrelli's a [[ManipulativeBastard lying bitch]] who [[PersonOfMassDestruction wanted Peter to explode]], and her husband's a [[BigBad complete monster]] who [[OffingTheOffspring tried to have Nathan murdered]]. Clearly favouritism is a relative thing among the Petrellis.

to:

* ''{{Series/Heroes}}'': ''{{Series/Heroes}}'':
**
According to Mama Petrelli, Nathan [[LikeFatherLikeSon takes after his father]] but Peter [[MommasBoy was always her favourite]]. Of course, Mama Petrelli's a [[ManipulativeBastard lying bitch]] who [[PersonOfMassDestruction wanted Peter to explode]], and her husband's a [[BigBad complete monster]] who [[OffingTheOffspring tried to have Nathan murdered]]. Clearly favouritism is a relative thing among the Petrellis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TruthInTelevision. According to this [[http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2094371-1,00.html article in Time]], research shows that parents do have favorites even if they will never admit that they do.

to:

* TruthInTelevision. According to this [[http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2094371-1,00.html article in Time]], research shows that parents do have favorites even if they will never admit that they do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Create page!!!

Added DiffLines:

->''The boys grew up, and Esau became a skillful hunter, a man of the open country, while Jacob was content to stay at home among the tents. Isaac, who had a taste for wild game, loved Esau, but Rebekah loved Jacob.''
->[[Literature/TheBible - Genesis 25:27-28]]

In a family of two or more children, each child has a stronger affinity for a different parent. There are two main ways this can happen:

# Each child resembles a different parent in looks or personality.
# Each parent is closer to or favours a different child.

These tend to go hand-in-hand, but not always. Sometimes, even when parents strive to be impartial, they still find that each child is more like one parent than the other. Conversely, taking after a parent is no guarantee of being that parent's favourite; it may even have the opposite effect.

May lead to accusations of ParentalFavouritism, or to each child feeling like one parent's [[TheUnfavourite Unfavourite]]. Can lead to SiblingRivalry and even CainAndAbel, particularly when the parents are at odds with each other. May contribute to MiddleChildSyndrome if there are more than two children.

On the other hand, a family like this may be perfectly happy if each child is content to be one parent's favourite. And - [[TruthInTelevision as so often happens]] - the children may well be closer to each other than to ''either'' parent.

A common variation, especially when both siblings are the same gender, is for [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the tougher or "manlier" one]] to be closer to the dad, and [[SensitiveGuyAndManlyMan the more sensitive or "girlier" one]] to be closer to the mom.
----
!!Examples:
[[AC:Film]]
* In ''TheLionInWinter'', Henry wants his youngest son, [[YoungestChildWins John]], to succeed him, but his wife is plotting to get [[MommasBoy Richard]] onto the throne. Poor [[MiddleChildSyndrome Geoffrey]] has to make his own luck.

[[AC:Literature]]
* In ''ASongOfIceAndFire'', the Stark children all physically take after one of their parents. Arya takes after Ned, and Robb, Sansa, Bran, and Rickon all take after Catelyn. Personality-wise, only Robb really takes after either of the parents - he takes after Ned. (Jon both looks and acts like Ned, but isn't Cat's son.)
* Glynn and Ember from Isobelle Carmody's 'Legendsong Saga'. Glynn is much closer to her father while Eber takes after her mother in both looks and talents. It is mentioned that their mother didn't really want children at all, and is only able to love Ember because they are so similar. Strongly influences Glynn's personality.
* John Steinbeck's ''EastOfEden'' relies heavily on the Cain/Abel, Jacob/Esau motif throughout its entirety. There are two sets of brothers: Adam and Charles and then Aron and Cal (sons of Adam and a crazy maniacal whore named Cathy). Adam and Aron = Jacob/Abel, Charles and Cal = Esau/Cain. Adam and Aron are good boys who take after their dads. Charles and Cal are more... unstable and tend to flirt with evil, taking after their mothers.

[[AC:Live-Action T.V.]]
* ''{{Series/Heroes}}'': According to Mama Petrelli, Nathan [[LikeFatherLikeSon takes after his father]] but Peter [[MommasBoy was always her favourite]]. Of course, Mama Petrelli's a [[ManipulativeBastard lying bitch]] who [[PersonOfMassDestruction wanted Peter to explode]], and her husband's a [[BigBad complete monster]] who [[OffingTheOffspring tried to have Nathan murdered]]. Clearly favouritism is a relative thing among the Petrellis.
** Hiro and his sister take after their mother and father, respectively. They have a lot of tension when it comes to Hiro's hero-ing vs. running the company.
* ''[[That70sShow That 70's Show]]'': Red makes no secret of his preference for Laurie, while Kitty is subtler about her favoritism toward Eric.
* ''{{Series/Revenge}}'': In the Grayson family, Daniel is clearly Victoria's favorite, while Charlotte seems to be Conrad's.
* On ''{{Roseanne}}'' Dan's favorites are Darlene and DJ, while the title character is closer to Becky.
* In ''ModernFamily'', Mitchell always considered himself closer to his mother, while Claire felt closer to their father.

[[AC:Mythology & Religion]]
* The prototypical example, at least in western culture, is probably Jacob and Esau from {{Literature/The Bible}}. They are twins, but Esau, the elder brother, is favoured by his father, while Jacob is his mother's favourite. The latter two even conspire successfully to cheat Esau out of his inherritance.

[[AC:Western Animation]]
* ''AvatarTheLastAirbender'': Ozai preferred Azula, Ursa preferred Zuko. Of course, this is a BigScrewedUpFamily being talked about here, so....

[[AC:Real Life]]
* TruthInTelevision. According to this [[http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2094371-1,00.html article in Time]], research shows that parents do have favorites even if they will never admit that they do.

Top