Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / FieldPromotion

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The reason this may not make much sense is because the objection was to lack of a suitable ceremony, not the rapid promotion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
misspelling


** And in ''Discworld/GoingPostal'', Devious Collarbone finds himself field promoted from university researcher, to doctor, and then again to professor, in the span of a few minutes. Mainly because a civilian tried to gainsay him in the presence of Unseen University's Archchancellor, Mustrum Ridcully, a firm believer in Retaliation By Promotion.

to:

** And in ''Discworld/GoingPostal'', Devious Collarbone Collabone finds himself field promoted from university researcher, to doctor, and then again to professor, in the span of a few minutes. Mainly because a civilian tried to gainsay him in the presence of Unseen University's Archchancellor, Mustrum Ridcully, a firm believer in Retaliation By Promotion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A variation on this trope is the [[https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Army_of_the_United_States Army of the United States]], the conscript (read: draft) force of the United States. When activated (thus far, it has only happened in WorldWarII, TheKoreanWar, and TheVietnamWar), many of the officers are initially drawn from the regular Army and the Reserves, where they receive promotions to deal with the increased number of men they will be leading. Once the war ends, and the AUS is stood down, the officers go back to their previous jobs... and their previous ranks, since the Army of the United States is a separate organization from the Regular Army and the Army Reserves. [[hottip:*: Of course, depending on how long they were serving in the AUS, they may have received promotions in the Regular Army anyways, though not necessarily to the level where they served in the AUS).

to:

* A variation on this trope is the [[https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Army_of_the_United_States Army of the United States]], the conscript (read: draft) force of the United States. When activated (thus far, it has only happened in WorldWarII, TheKoreanWar, and TheVietnamWar), many of the officers are initially drawn from the regular Army and the Reserves, where they receive promotions to deal with the increased number of men they will be leading. Once the war ends, and the AUS is stood down, the officers go back to their previous jobs... and their previous ranks, since the Army of the United States is a separate organization from the Regular Army and the Army Reserves. [[hottip:*: Of course, depending on how long they were serving in the AUS, they may have received promotions in the Regular Army anyways, though not necessarily to the level where they served in the AUS).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A variation on this trope is the [[https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Army_of_the_United_States Army of the United States]], the conscript (read: draft) force of the United States. When activated (thus far, it has only happened in WorldWarII, TheKoreanWar, and TheVietnamWar), many of the officers are initially drawn from the regular Army and the Reserves, where they receive promotions to deal with the increased number of men they will be leading. Once the war ends, and the AUS is stood down, the officers go back to their previous jobs... and their previous ranks, since the Army of the United States is a separate organization from the Regular Army and the Army Reserves. [[hottip:*: Of course, depending on how long they were serving in the AUS, they may have received promotions in the Regular Army anyways, though not necessarily to the level where they served in the AUS).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AudieMurphy started as an [[ChildSoldiers underaged]] private, and was field promoted to Sergeant and later Lieutenant in a combination of his heroic actions and YouAreInCommandNow.

to:

* AudieMurphy Audie Murphy started as an [[ChildSoldiers underaged]] private, and was field promoted to Sergeant and later Lieutenant in a combination of his heroic actions and YouAreInCommandNow.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the movie "When Trumpets Fade," set in the battle of the Hurtgen Forest in 1944, the main character starts the movie at the rank of PVT (E-2). Due to the extreme attrition (33,000 Americans were lost in the battle), he is involuntarily promoted to Sergeant (E-5) and made a squad leader on the promise that should he survive he will be evacuated for battle fatigue and given a Section-8 discharge. The evacuation and discharge never happens, and then due again to attrition and the mental breakdown of his platoon leader, he is involuntarily promoted to 2Lt (O-1). This is an example of Truth in Television, as the Battle for the Hurtgen Forest in reality lasted 5 months (the longest battle in US military history) and was enormously bloody with greater than 25% casualties suffered by American forces and many smaller units entirely annihilated. Men who entered the Forest in September of 1944 as privates were almost guaranteed to leave at significantly higher rank if they survived until the battles conclusion in February 1945. Two entire US divisions, the 4th and 9th Infantry could not even use battle field promotions to replace all of the lost NCO's and officers, and were forced to withdraw from combat to rebuild.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Tagon's father in ''SchlockMercenary'' complains that "when I was your age, I was already a general." Tagon retorts that there was a war going on back then, and half of high command got nuked from orbit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not true, Richthofen\'s successors as commanders were Captain Wilhelm Reinhard and 1st Lieutenant Hermann Göring


** Also the case in the WWI German armed forces. Manfred von Richthofen (a.k.a. The RedBaron) had a command and duties that would normally have been a lieutenant-colonel's but, due to a regulation stating that a son could never outrank his father while the father was still alive and the fact that daddy von Richthofen was a Major in the army reserve, he never made it past Captain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** In ''Disaster'' Picard is stuck in a failing turbolift with three children, whom he makes officers to prevent them from panicking. They promptly [[NoOneGetsLeftBehind mutiny]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And in the Season 4 opener. Picard is [[spoiler:assimilated by the borg. Riker, who has just refused a third potential command, is field-promoted to Captain in his place.]]

to:

** And in the Season 4 opener. Picard is [[spoiler:assimilated by the borg.Borg. Riker, who has just refused a third potential command, is field-promoted to Captain in his place.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And in the Season 4 opener. Picard is [[spolier:assimilated by the borg. Riker, who has just refused a third potential command, is field-promoted to Captain in his place.]]

to:

** And in the Season 4 opener. Picard is [[spolier:assimilated [[spoiler:assimilated by the borg. Riker, who has just refused a third potential command, is field-promoted to Captain in his place.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** And in the Season 4 opener. Picard is [[spolier:assimilated by the borg. Riker, who has just refused a third potential command, is field-promoted to Captain in his place.]]

Added: 535

Changed: 571

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Happens to both the Americans and the Soviets in TomClancy's ''{{Red Storm Rising}}'': amongst the viewpoint characters, Sergeant Terry Mackall gets promoted twice, after his lieutenant and then his unit XO were killed in action, while FourStarBadass Pavel Alekseyev--the main Soviet POV character--receives a series of promotions from senior aide of CINC-Southwest to essentially commander of Soviet forces in Europe (as the situation grew more and more desperate, the Politburo began taking a progressively [[YouHaveFailedMe Vaderesque approach]] to its commanders).
** Also {{deconstructed}} somewhat, when discussing the state of the Soviet Army. Since NATO doctrine was to go for the unit commanders first, by mid-war many of the leading Soviet formations were led by junior officers who were field-promoted out of necessity--thus, captains leading battalions, majors leading regiments, and colonels leading entire divisions were not uncommon. The attrition rate on the officer corps had a very serious effect on the Soviet war effort, since the junior officers were almost always inexperienced men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In David Feintuch's 1994 science fiction novel novel ''Midshipman's Hope,'' as the last surviving ship's officer after an attack, the title mIdshipman is promoted to command.

to:

* In David Feintuch's 1994 science fiction novel novel ''Midshipman's Hope,'' as the last surviving ship's officer after an attack, dies of melanoma, the title mIdshipman titular midshipman is promoted to command.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* During NeverwinterNights2 the player is promoted from squire to knight in quick succession. When one of the other knight objects he is reminded that he was knighted in the mud surrounded by an army or orcs.

to:

* During NeverwinterNights2 the player is promoted from squire to knight in quick succession. When one of the other knight objects he is reminded that he was knighted in the mud surrounded by an army or of orcs.

Changed: 208

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* During NeverwinterNights2 the player is promoted from squire to knight in quick succession. When one of the other knight objects he is reminded that he was knighted in the mud surrounded by an army or orcs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** And it was not because of Piett's planning, plus he wasn't a jerk about it. Ozzel wasn't so smart when he decided that [[TooDumbToLive being arrogant to Vader was a smart idea]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*In [[StarWars Star Wars: Empire: To the Last Man]] an Imperial Army column gets surrounded by native warriors and faces destruction. As the casualties mount, General Ziering promotes Lieutenant Janek Sunber to Captain and eventually Commander. When Lt. Sunber manages to get back to headquarters the only other surviving officer refuses to verify his promotion and he gets bumped back down to Lieutenant.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Bujold was never in the Army. (Or a civilian employee of the Army.)


** In real life, Lois Mc Master Bujold served for many years as a logistics officer in the U.S. Army. ''This Troper'' believes that anything Bujold writes in a military context would be very realistic and possibly based on actual experience. If Bujold were to get something wrong in a military story, the error would be more embarrassing for her than for a civilian author.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A commanding officer -- who may be [[YouAreInCommandNow in comand now]] or may hold the correct rank for his position -- sorely lacks in senior officers. Perhaps they're TrappedBehindEnemyLines. Or communications are shot to hell. Or he's piecing together something resembling a unit out of the shattered remains of an army. Any suitable disaster to remove them will do.

to:

A commanding officer -- who may be [[YouAreInCommandNow in comand command now]] or may hold the correct rank for his position -- sorely lacks in senior officers. Perhaps they're TrappedBehindEnemyLines. Or communications are shot to hell. Or he's piecing together something resembling a unit out of the shattered remains of an army. Any suitable disaster to remove them will do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:{{ComicBooks}}]]
* The titular ''[[{{Comicbook/SgtRock}} Sgt. Rock]]'', of course, started out as a buck private, and while many of his actions were considered worthy of promotion, Easy Company's TO was apparently full. Until a certain battle, whereupon as fatalities accumulated, he was promoted to PFC, Corporal, and finally Sergeant in short order. Not how he would have preferred to earn his stripes, to say the least.

to:

[[AC:{{ComicBooks}}]]
[[AC:ComicBooks]]
* The titular ''[[{{Comicbook/SgtRock}} ''[[Comicbook/SgtRock Sgt. Rock]]'', of course, started out as a buck private, and while many of his actions were considered worthy of promotion, Easy Company's TO was apparently full. Until a certain battle, whereupon as fatalities accumulated, he was promoted to PFC, Corporal, and finally Sergeant in short order. Not how he would have preferred to earn his stripes, to say the least.



* One of Darth Vader's trademarks in ''[[StarWars The Empire Strikes Back]]''. In one scene, he chokes the idiotic Admiral Ozzel, and immediately addresses Captain Piett as Admiral Piett, [[YouAreInCommandNow putting him in command right then and there]]. And with the previous Admiral ''still choking in the background'', there's a very tacit reminder of the consequences of messing up.

to:

* One of Darth Vader's trademarks in ''[[StarWars The Empire Strikes Back]]''. ''TheEmpireStrikesBack''. In one scene, [[YouHaveFailedMe he chokes the idiotic Admiral Ozzel, Ozzel]], and immediately addresses Captain Piett as Admiral Piett, [[YouAreInCommandNow putting him in command right then and there]]. And with the previous Admiral ''still choking in the background'', there's a very tacit reminder of the consequences of messing up.



* Variation in ''KingdomOfHeaven'': Balian actually knights every single soldier in Jerusalem right before the final battle. [[spoiler:Which they lose, so it probably didn't help...]]

to:

* Variation in ''KingdomOfHeaven'': ''{{Kingdom of Heaven}}'': Balian actually knights every single soldier in Jerusalem right before the final battle. [[spoiler:Which they lose, so it probably didn't help...]] ]]



* In World War 2, [[BandOfBrothers Dick Winters]] started as a 2nd lieutenant. By the end of the war, he was ''Major'' Dick Winters. At least one of his promotions was a FieldPromotion (1st Lieutenant to Captain).

to:

* In World War 2, [[BandOfBrothers WorldWarII, [[Series/BandOfBrothers Dick Winters]] started as a 2nd lieutenant. By the end of the war, he was ''Major'' Dick Winters. At least one of his promotions was a FieldPromotion (1st Lieutenant to Captain).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In LoisMcMasterBujold's ''The Warrior's Apprenctice'', Miles Vorkosigan accidentally finds himself Admiral of a fleet, during which he puts all his original companions in high positions whether they can handle it or not. In ''The Vor Game'', he assigns his personal bodyguard to the emperor; when the man says he hasn't been trained for it, Miles can only say that it's a common problem in the situation.

to:

* In LoisMcMasterBujold's ''The {{Lois McMaster Bujold}}'s ''[[VorkosiganSaga The Warrior's Apprenctice'', Apprenctice]]'', Miles Vorkosigan accidentally finds himself Admiral of a fleet, during which he puts all his original companions in high positions whether they can handle it or not. In ''The Vor Game'', he assigns his personal bodyguard to the emperor; when the man says he hasn't been trained for it, Miles can only say that it's a common problem in the situation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The titular {{Sergeant Rock}}, of course, started out as a buck private, and while many of his actions were considered worthy of promotion, Easy Company's TO was apparently full. Until a certain battle, whereupon as fatalities accumulated, he was promoted to PFC, Corporal, and finally Sergeant in short order. Not how he would have preferred to earn his stripes, to say the least.

to:

* The titular {{Sergeant Rock}}, ''[[{{Comicbook/SgtRock}} Sgt. Rock]]'', of course, started out as a buck private, and while many of his actions were considered worthy of promotion, Easy Company's TO was apparently full. Until a certain battle, whereupon as fatalities accumulated, he was promoted to PFC, Corporal, and finally Sergeant in short order. Not how he would have preferred to earn his stripes, to say the least.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* [[PlayerCharacter The Force Commander]] in ''DawnOfWar II'' is a rather young SpaceMarine who has never met the Chapter Master, yet he has his rank because the Blood Ravens had their manpower seriously depleted because of the Kaurava Campaign (which Cyrus doesn't want to speak of). Thaddeus is also on the young side for a Sergeant and it shows, he's naive about many things and his fellow sergeants point it all out for him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Expanded Rivers of War example

Added DiffLines:

** The funny thing is that the person who recommended them for that field promotion was the commander of the British forces - being defeated by a Colonel is far less embarrassing for a Major General than being defeated by a brevet Captain who was only there by chance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** B'Elanna Torres is made Starfleet lieutenants on Captain Janeway's authority (despite being a member of a rebel group known as the Maquis) as her skills in engineering means she needs to be chief engineer.

to:

** B'Elanna Torres is made Starfleet lieutenants lieutenant on Captain Janeway's authority (despite being a member of a rebel group known as the Maquis) as her skills in engineering means mean she needs to be made chief engineer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''GirlGenius'', a Lampshade Hanging, when Gil [[spoiler:destroys the attacking Clank Army with a lightning rod,]] the [[http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20071207 following exchange takes places:]]

to:

* In ''GirlGenius'', a Lampshade Hanging, when Gil [[spoiler:destroys the attacking Clank Army with a lightning rod,]] the [[http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20071207 following exchange takes places:]]place:]]



'''THOK'''
'''Dimo:''' Hoy! [[spoiler:So, who else vants to be promoted?]]

to:

'''THOK'''
'''Dimo:''' Hoy! [[spoiler:So,
'''THOK'''\\
'''[[spoiler:Dimo]]:''' [[spoiler:Hoy! So,
who else vants to be promoted?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* GearsOfWar has this happen to protagonist Marcus Fenix via radio after Kim gets [[FamilyUnfriendlyDeath run through]] [[MadeOfIron by RAAM.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In World War 2, [[BandOfBrothers Dick Winters]] started as a 2nd lieutenant. By the end of the war, he was ''Major'' Dick Winters. At least one of his promotions was a FieldPromotion (1st Lieutenant to Captain).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*In David Feintuch's 1994 science fiction novel novel ''Midshipman's Hope,'' as the last surviving ship's officer after an attack, the title mIdshipman is promoted to command.

Top