Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / FandomHeresy

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Of course, "some" isn't the same as "many", and you probably wouldn't find any critic who wants to be your friend. Except Armond White, but [[{{Troll}} he's not a very well-respected critic]].

Added: 521

Removed: 312

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** That's not even getting into Ahsoka Tano. In some circles, if you even insinuate that she's slowly being RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap (starting in Season 2), hope your Force powers can repel InternetBackdraft. On top of that, if you even ''suggest'' that Cad Bane is slightly more interesting than Boba Fett? Make your jump to hyperspace and never look back.



*** That's not even getting into Ahsoka Tano. In some circles, if you even insinuate that she's slowly being RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap (starting in Season 2), hope your Force powers can repel InternetBackdraft. And if you even suggest that Cad Bane is slightly more interesting than Boba Fett? ''Start running''.


Added DiffLines:

* You can criticize any character in MassEffect, but speak ill of Tali'Zorah, Liara T'Soni (pre-ME2) or Garrus Vakarian? Hope your shields/barriers are optimized.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** That's not even getting into Ahsoka Tano. In some circles, if you even insinuate that she's slowly being RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap (starting in Season 2), hope your Force powers can repel InternetBackdraft. And if you even suggest that Cad Bane is slightly more interesting than Boba Fett? ''Start running''.

Added: 178

Changed: 101

Removed: 204

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alot of the fans seem quite okay with people liking Colin Baker nowadays. Hell, his fans practically praise how great he is on their signatures.


** For another way to piss off ''Doctor Who'' fans, mention that TomBaker sucks, or that Colin Baker was the best Doctor ever, or badmouth DavidTennant.
*** You might be able to get two of those past [[ItsPopularNowItSucks a select group of purists]] ''provided'' that you praise William Hartnell extensively. Nothing can save you if you like Colin Baker, though.
*** ''...[[ZigZaggingTrope Unless]]'' you're speaking with a fan of the BigFinish audio dramas, in which Colin Baker is consistently known to be brilliant. SoYeah. Just...be careful in general, basically.

to:

** For another way to piss off ''Doctor Who'' fans, mention that TomBaker sucks, or that Colin Baker was the best Doctor ever, sucks or badmouth DavidTennant.
*** You might be able to get two of those past [[ItsPopularNowItSucks a select group of purists]] ''provided'' that you praise William Hartnell extensively. Nothing can save you if you like Colin Baker, though.\n*** ''...[[ZigZaggingTrope Unless]]'' you're speaking with a fan of the BigFinish audio dramas, in which Colin Baker is consistently known to be brilliant. SoYeah. Just...be careful in general, basically.


Added DiffLines:

** Try to tell the fans that you liked the new redesigns for the Daleks/Cybermen/Practically any Classic villain brought back or you liked the Slitheens. May the heaven help you.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''SilentHill'' fan? Not if you don't like ''SilentHill2''! As every "true" fan knows, ''2'' had the best story, the best atmosphere, and set the rules for how the town itself "punishes siinners". This despite the entire rest of the series not lining up with ''2'', or the fact that the man who invented the series left after making the first game. Nope, you're apparently not a true ''SilentHill'' fan, if you like other games in the series but dislike the second.
** How? the Entire Story can be summed up as " James is a sex obsessed Freak and horrible Person!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Say good things about any third-party material for any series that isn't one of Hitoshi Ariga's works or the tepid OVA. Oh drat, you were just swarmed by furious purists.

to:

** Say good things about any third-party material for any series that isn't one of Hitoshi Ariga's works or the tepid OVA. Oh drat, you were just swarmed maimed by furious purists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Say good things about any third-party material for any series that isn't one of Hitoshi Ariga's works or the tepid OVA. Oh drat, you were just swarmed by furious purists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Among ''BuffyTheVampireSlayer'' fans, any disapproval of homosexuality will result in your being marked for death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No, it would be the feminist equivalent of Fan Dumb. Or, well, one of them.


RealWomenNeverWearDresses would be the feminist equivalent to FandomHeresy. See also GannonBanned and InternetBackdraft for another way to hit the BerserkButton of certain fandoms.

to:

RealWomenNeverWearDresses would be the feminist equivalent to FandomHeresy. See also GannonBanned and InternetBackdraft for another way to hit the BerserkButton of certain fandoms.

Added: 249

Changed: 26

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There is no anime. And although some communities can be ambivalent about most of the above things, [=SSiB=] is almost universally reviled.

to:

** There is no anime. And although some communities can be ambivalent about most of the above things, things (people hate [=KirbyM=]?), [=SSiB=] is almost universally reviled.reviled.
** The canonicity of the PC-98 games, although this is more under BrokenBase as you'll get people who embrace them and [[EpilepticTrees and try to have them fit Windows canon]] and [[FanDumb those who try to deny their existence]] despite WordOfGod.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This overlaps with GannonBanned
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, saying that you dislike ''[[MegaManLegends Legends]]'' in some communities '''will''' get you lynched.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
wanted to contribute


* Don't dare be a Róisín Murphy and then say you also like LadyGaga. The results are not pretty.

to:

* Don't dare be a Róisín Murphy fan and then say you also like LadyGaga. [[FanDumb The results are not pretty.
pretty]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
wanted to contribute



to:

* Don't dare be a Róisín Murphy and then say you also like LadyGaga. The results are not pretty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Of course, the opposite is also true. Only liking or even only recognizing a SignatureSong is irrefutable proof that you're not a true fan. ''Especially'' if the band themselves denounced it. Go on, tell a TheCure fan you like ''Friday I'm in Love.'' I'll wait.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Prior to his [=Retirement/Un-Retirement=] revolving door, NFL fans were not allowed to say a single disparaging word about Brett Farve (Pointing out that he's the career leader in interceptions, for instance, would be dismissed as "being a hater".) Saying you think he was overrated will still get you yelled at by the vast majority.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tell any font enthusiast that you like Comic Sans. Go on, say it.

to:

* Tell any font enthusiast that you like Comic Sans. Go on, say it. The results will not be pretty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Just try and say that Lyra ''is'' in a new design, that Leaf exists in the games, or that Barry's game name is Damion or Pearl.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* If you are a Nightwish fan, mentioning that you like Annette Olzon is one of the fastest known means of committing suicide. Even though the majority of the fandom agree that firing Tarja was a [[ShootTheDog necessary decision]], you're not allowed to think that Nightwish is Nightwish without Tarja's opera-singer voice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Say you like Comic Sans. Go on, say it.

to:

* Say Tell any font enthusiast that you like Comic Sans. Go on, say it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** There's a bit of tension between preferring scanlations and official translations released as well. Saying that you prefer the official translation (especially if there are [[DubNameChange name changes]] or {{Bowdlerise edits}}[[BleachedUnderwear to the artwork]] can be heretic on a fan forum, especially if said forum is strongly connected to scanlation groups.

to:

*** There's a bit of tension between preferring scanlations and official translations released as well. Saying that you prefer the official translation (especially if there are [[DubNameChange name changes]] or minor/massive {{Bowdlerise edits}}[[BleachedUnderwear to the artwork]] edits}}) can be heretic on a fan forum, especially if said forum is strongly connected to scanlation groups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** There's a bit of tension between preferring scanlations and official translations released as well. Saying that you prefer the official translation (especially if there are [[DubNameChange name changes]] or [[Bowdlerise edits]] can be heretic on a fan forum, especially if said forum is strongly connected to scanlation groups.

to:

*** There's a bit of tension between preferring scanlations and official translations released as well. Saying that you prefer the official translation (especially if there are [[DubNameChange name changes]] or [[Bowdlerise edits]] {{Bowdlerise edits}}[[BleachedUnderwear to the artwork]] can be heretic on a fan forum, especially if said forum is strongly connected to scanlation groups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** There's a bit of tension between preferring scanlations and official translations released as well. Saying that you prefer the official translation (especially if there are [[DubNameChange name changes]] or {{Bowdlerise edits to the artwork}}) can be heretic on a fan forum, especially if said forum is strongly connected to scanlation groups.

to:

*** There's a bit of tension between preferring scanlations and official translations released as well. Saying that you prefer the official translation (especially if there are [[DubNameChange name changes]] or {{Bowdlerise edits to the artwork}}) [[Bowdlerise edits]] can be heretic on a fan forum, especially if said forum is strongly connected to scanlation groups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** There's a bit of tension between preferring scanlations and official translations released as well. Saying that you prefer the official translation (especially if there are [[DubNameChange name changes]] or [[Bowdlerise edits to the artwork]]) can be heretic on a fan forum, especially if said forum is strongly connected to scanlation groups.

to:

*** There's a bit of tension between preferring scanlations and official translations released as well. Saying that you prefer the official translation (especially if there are [[DubNameChange name changes]] or [[Bowdlerise {{Bowdlerise edits to the artwork]]) artwork}}) can be heretic on a fan forum, especially if said forum is strongly connected to scanlation groups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** There's a bit of tension between preferring scanlations and official translations released as well. Saying that you prefer the official translation (especially if there are [[DubNameChange name changes]] or [[Bowdlerise edits, whether they are major or minor]]) can be heretic on a fan forum, especially if said forum is strongly connected to scanlation groups.

to:

*** There's a bit of tension between preferring scanlations and official translations released as well. Saying that you prefer the official translation (especially if there are [[DubNameChange name changes]] or [[Bowdlerise edits, whether they are major or minor]]) edits to the artwork]]) can be heretic on a fan forum, especially if said forum is strongly connected to scanlation groups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** For MassiveDamage, if the series in question [[DubNameChange had the characters' names changed in the dub]], try to say that you prefer the changed names to the original ones.


Added DiffLines:

*** There's a bit of tension between preferring scanlations and official translations released as well. Saying that you prefer the official translation (especially if there are [[DubNameChange name changes]] or [[Bowdlerise edits, whether they are major or minor]]) can be heretic on a fan forum, especially if said forum is strongly connected to scanlation groups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Actually, it depends on where this is said. This leans more towards BrokenBase.


Added DiffLines:

* Rejecting Capcom of America's {{Bowdlerization}} of ''MegaManBattleNetwork'' is only a step in the right direction. To be a true fan, ensure that you refer to every character only by their original Japanese names. No, don't even use the proper romanizations of the obvious name-puns; it's Meiru, not Mayl. For that matter, the series is called ''[=Rockman.EXE=]'', and don't you forget it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding an example



to:

* Say you like Comic Sans. Go on, say it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, you're not supposed to have one particular favourite song. It you can name one song that you like best with little to no difficulty, then you apparently aren't a 'real' music fan.

Added: 225

Changed: 317

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Go to any ''QuantumLeap''-centric forum. Say you accept [[ExecutiveMeddling the fact that]] [[DownerEnding Sam never made it home.]] You'll get the cold shoulder, at best.

to:

* Go ** Though there will always be a fiercely loyal contingent of {{Rolling Stones}} ready to any ''QuantumLeap''-centric forum. Say back you accept [[ExecutiveMeddling up. But then again a nice chunk of each fandom will just say 'hey, they loved each other, can't we just tolerate them?'
** The war between
the fact that]] [[DownerEnding Sam Dylan the Protester fans and the Dylan the Poet bases will never made it home.]] You'll get debate. They may as well have their own Inquisitions to catch the cold shoulder, at best.heretics. And the fans of his new works. They apparently have no worth.

Top