Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / DoomedByCanon

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* We know in the Golden Age saga of ''Manga/{{Berserk}}'' that Guts, who starts off as a loyal mercenary soldier under Griffith, will eventually be betrayed by Griffith and gain the Mark of Sacrifice, leading him to become the merciless Black Swordsman. What that means, unfortunately, is that pretty much everyone else in the Band of the Hawk aside from Guts and Griffith is doomed to a bad fate. But what we ''don't'' know is that [[spoiler:while nearly all of the Hawks are branded like Guts and indeed die horribly when the Eclipse goes down and the demons come out of the woodwork for the feast, there are two other Hawks who ultimately survive -- Rickert, due to not being with the rest of the Hawks when the Eclipse went down; and Casca, who, despite being branded like the rest and being put through pure hell by Griffith himself upon him becoming a demon god, was rescued along with Guts by the Skull Knight, but who went insane from her ordeal and was left behind with Rickert and the blacksmith Godot, and ultimately becomes the reason for Guts to lay aside his vendetta against Griffith for her sake]].

to:

* We know in the Golden Age saga of ''Manga/{{Berserk}}'' that Guts, who starts off as a loyal mercenary soldier under Griffith, will eventually be betrayed by Griffith and gain the Mark of Sacrifice, leading him to become the merciless Black Swordsman. What that means, unfortunately, is that pretty much everyone else in the Band of the Hawk aside from Guts and Griffith is doomed to a bad fate. But what we ''don't'' know is that [[spoiler:while nearly all of the Hawks are branded like Guts and indeed die horribly when the Eclipse goes down and the demons come out of the woodwork for the feast, there are two other Hawks who ultimately survive -- Rickert, due to who was not being with the rest of the Hawks when the Eclipse went down; and Casca, who, despite being branded like the rest and being [[RapeAsDrama put through pure hell by Griffith himself himself]] upon him becoming a demon god, was rescued along with Guts by the Skull Knight, but who went insane from her ordeal and was left behind with Rickert and the blacksmith Godot, and ultimately becomes the reason for Guts to lay aside his vendetta against Griffith for her sake]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the Order 66 arc, the audience knows Fives won't be able to reveal the truth behind Order 66, because it remains unknown in ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith''. Most of the tension comes from the fact that even though he can't succeed in his quest, there's still hope he'll at least ''survive''.

to:

** In the Order 66 arc, the audience knows Fives won't be able to reveal the truth behind Order 66, because it remains unknown in ''Film/RevengeOfTheSith''. Most of the tension comes from the fact that even though he can't succeed in his quest, there's still hope he'll at least ''survive''.''survive'', though ultimately, he doesn't.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''ComicBook/StarWarsKanan'': Depa Billaba is known to have been killed by her clone battalion when Order 66 was issued, so not only are the friendships developed between them and Kanan doomed their betrayl and murder of their general is shown in the second issue before they are developed further.

to:

* ''ComicBook/StarWarsKanan'': Depa Billaba is known to have been killed by her clone battalion when Order 66 was issued, so not only are the friendships developed between them and Kanan doomed doomed, their betrayl betrayal and murder of their general is shown in the second issue before they are developed further.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It's also mentioned that George and Mary's marriage was in such turmoil before this that George had an affair. Their marriage on the show is no where near as bad as ''The Big Bang Theory'' claims. [[spoiler:George and Mary begin fighting a lot more often as the series progresses, and after a particularly nasty fight in the season 4 finale, George runs into recently-divorced neighbor Brenda Sparks at a bar, implying that she is the other woman.]]

to:

*** It's also mentioned that George and Mary's marriage was in such turmoil before this that George had an affair. Their marriage on the show is no where near as bad as ''The Big Bang Theory'' claims. [[spoiler:George and Mary begin fighting a lot more often as the series progresses, and after a particularly nasty fight in the season 4 finale, George runs into recently-divorced neighbor Brenda Sparks at a bar, implying that she is the other woman.]]]] [[note]] Actually, the final season [[SubvertedTrope subverted]] this; not only does George never have an affair with Brenda, he never had one to begin with- Mary came home from a trip to Germany with Sheldon and they had sex which involving her dressing up and talking like a German woman. Sheldon walked on in them, didn't recognize his mom, and assumed his dad was having an affair, since, as narrator Sheldon says, he never discussed the incident with him. [[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Uncle Ben is the poster boy of "DeathByOriginStory". His death, an unexpected consequence of Peter being selfish and using his powers for personal gain, made him learn that "WithGreatPowerComesGreatResponsibility". That means that any adaptation of Spider-Man where Ben appears from the start (such as ''ComicBook/UltimateSpiderMan'' or [[Film/SpiderMan1 the first Sam Raimi's film]]) will have him die very soon.

to:

** Uncle Ben is the poster boy of "DeathByOriginStory". His death, an unexpected consequence of Peter being selfish and using his powers for personal gain, made him learn that "WithGreatPowerComesGreatResponsibility". That means that any adaptation of Spider-Man where Ben appears from the start (such as ''ComicBook/UltimateSpiderMan'' or [[Film/SpiderMan1 the first Sam Raimi's film]]) will have him die very soon. [[spoiler:Except in the ComicBook/UltimateMarvel2024 universe, where Aunt May is killed off and Peter didn't get his powers until adulthood]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Manga/RainsHead'': Rain, as it turns out, is inflicted with a terminal illness that gives her three years to live. [[ForegoneConclusion It's no spoiler already to anyone who reads just the manga's first chapter when Claroa makes it very clear to her that she will not survive from it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Manga/RainsHead'': Rain, as it turns out, is inflicted with a terminal illness that gives her three years to live. [[ForegoneConclusion It's no spoiler already to anyone who reads just the manga's first chapter when Claroa makes it very clear to her that she will not survive from it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''WesternAnimation/TheLittleMermaid1992'' and ''WesternAnimation/TheLittleMermaidIIIArielsBeginning'', Ariel has to be unaware of Eric's existence. Conversely, ''Ariel's Beginning'' is the earliest-set installment of the franchise - and the only one to feature Ariel's mother. Mom's totally doomed, isn't she? [[MissingMom Yes, she is.]] Also, Marina's goal in ''Ariel's Beginning'' is to steal Sebastian's job as King Triton's advisor. Sebastian is seen holding the job in the other installments.

to:

* In ''WesternAnimation/TheLittleMermaid1992'' and ''WesternAnimation/TheLittleMermaidIIIArielsBeginning'', ''WesternAnimation/TheLittleMermaidArielsBeginning'', Ariel has to be unaware of Eric's existence. Conversely, ''Ariel's Beginning'' is the earliest-set installment of the franchise - and the only one to feature Ariel's mother. Mom's totally doomed, isn't she? [[MissingMom Yes, she is.]] Also, Marina's goal in ''Ariel's Beginning'' is to steal Sebastian's job as King Triton's advisor. Sebastian is seen holding the job in the other installments.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Roleplay/InkCity'' saw an unusual case of this when Thrasher became aware of his status as a character from the show ''WesternAnimation/{{Robotomy}}''. Specifically, he learned that it got ScrewedByTheNetwork, and due to this, his universe was completely destroyed when the creators disposed of all their show-related materials. [[GoMadFromTheRevelation He took that about as well as you'd expect]].

to:

* ''Roleplay/InkCity'' saw sees an unusual case of this when Thrasher became becomes aware of his status as a character from the show ''WesternAnimation/{{Robotomy}}''. Specifically, he learned learns that it got ScrewedByTheNetwork, and and, due to this, his universe was completely destroyed when the creators disposed of all their show-related materials. [[GoMadFromTheRevelation He took takes that about as well as you'd expect]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Fanfic/AgeOfCalamity'' is a direct prequel to ''Fanfic/BreathOfTheWild'' in ''Fanfic/TheMythOfLinkAndZeldaSurvivorsofTheCalamity'', taking place during the buildup to the awakening of Calamity Ganon. Naturally, this means Ganon wins, the Champions die, and Link is placed into Stasis while Zelda ends up in a duel with Ganon.

to:

* ''Fanfic/AgeOfCalamity'' ''Fanfic/TheMythOfLinkAndZeldaAgeOfCalamity'' is a direct prequel to ''Fanfic/BreathOfTheWild'' ''Fanfic/TheMythOfLinkAndZeldaBreathOfTheWild'' in ''Fanfic/TheMythOfLinkAndZeldaSurvivorsofTheCalamity'', taking place during the buildup to the awakening of Calamity Ganon. Naturally, this means Ganon wins, the Champions die, and Link is placed into Stasis while Zelda ends up in a duel with Ganon.

Added: 793

Removed: 765

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It's been decided that Manhua and Manhwa examples shall be placed into their own folders. Moving example to the correct section.


* A saying in the Hong Kong comic ''The Manhua/RavagesOfTime'' goes, "Those who are fated to die, will die. Those who are fated to live, will live." That is to say, every character is going to die at the time that they did in [[Literature/RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms the source material]], even if the circumstances vary quite widely, while at least two original characters were created/centered around specific story arcs and thus were doomed to go when that arc was up[[note]]Yuan Fang would not survive the Battle of Guandu, since he was created to make it more cooler/complex than the version in ''Romance of the Three Kingdoms'', while Xiao Meng--who debuted as the real identity of the fictional Diaochan--would not survive the final downfall of Lu Bu[[/note]].


Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Manhua]]
* A saying in the Hong Kong comic ''The Manhua/RavagesOfTime'' goes, "Those who are fated to die, will die. Those who are fated to live, will live." That is to say, every character is going to die at the time that they did in [[Literature/RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms the source material]], even if the circumstances vary quite widely, while at least two original characters were created/centered around specific story arcs and thus were doomed to go when that arc was up[[note]]Yuan Fang would not survive the Battle of Guandu, since he was created to make it more cooler/complex than the version in ''Romance of the Three Kingdoms'', while Xiao Meng--who debuted as the real identity of the fictional Diaochan--would not survive the final downfall of Lu Bu[[/note]].
[[/folder]]

Added: 1911

Changed: 456

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Anime/Danganronpa3TheEndOfHopesPeakHighSchool'': As the Despair Arc is a prequel to the rest of the series, we already know who's going to die and who's going to [[spoiler:become Remnants of Despair]]. It just serves to fill us in on all the details. Exaggerated with the fate of [[spoiler:Yukizome]], who was just killed off at the end of the first episode of the Future Arc and whom posthumously comments on their doomed status in the intro to the Despair Arc.

to:

* ''Anime/Danganronpa3TheEndOfHopesPeakHighSchool'': As the The Despair Arc is a prequel to both the rest games and the Future Arc, so the fates of a lot of characters are set in stone, though the anime does insert twists where it can:
** Class 77-B, given that they're the progatonists
of the series, we already know second game (except for Ryota Mitarai, who's going also a confirmed survivor as he's a main character in ''Future''), must all survive [[spoiler:-with the exception of Chiaki (whose fate is set up to die be bad because her game self is an AI, so something must've happened to the human Chiaki)- and who's going to [[spoiler:become Remnants of become Ultimate Despair]]. It just serves to fill us in on all Side: Hope does at least set up the details. Exaggerated with twist that [[spoiler: characters doomed because they died in ''Goodbye Despair'' were saved; the fate of [[spoiler:Yukizome]], who was just killed off at game ends ambiguous about whether the end of the first episode survivors would ever be able to wake them up, but ''Hope'' confirms they were by having them appear.]]
** All characters shown as members
of the Future Foundation will survive, but Chisa will die first in the last killing game (which is shown before the Despair Arc and whom starts). She even gets to posthumously comments on their doomed status complain about how she's doomed. [[spoiler:The twist is that she, much like her students, was brainwashed into Ultimate Despair... and Makoto didn't save her.]]
** Natsumi Kuzuryu and Sato's story is the second 'motive' of ''Goodbye Despair'', so the audience knows that the latter will kill the former and be killed by Fuyuhiko in revenge. Some ''details'' are different (most notably, Monokuma's motive game implied that Mahiru destroyed evidence that incriminated Sato, but the anime shows that she didn't and was in fact horrified by the whole affair), but the core narrative is the same.
** Hajime Hinata, being ''Goodbye Despair'''s protagonist, must [[spoiler:suffer a DeathOfPersonality and become Izuru Kamukura, although the finale of ''Goodbye Despair'' and ''Side: Hope'' reveal that he got better.]]
** Jin Kirigiri must live through the anime in order to die
in the intro to prologue of ''Trigger Happy Havoc''.
** All of
the Despair Arc.members of Class 77 shown must survive the anime, but only the ones who appear in ''Side:Future'' will survive ''Trigger Happy Havoc''.



* ''Manga/OnePiece'': An extended flashback showing how Wano became the hellhole it is now and Kozuki Oden's story has the villainous Orochi being assisted by two Devil Fruit users. An old woman with the Clone-Clone Fruit and an old man with the Barrier-Barrier Fruit. Since only one person may have a Devil Fruit power at any time, and we've seen that in the present day different people have those specific powers, it's immediately clear they're both dead by now. Indeed, the old woman is killed offscreen by Kaido for interfering with his battle with Oden (although she probably saved Kaido's life, the one thing he hates the most is for the chance to have an evenly matched fight with a WorthyOpponent snatched from him, since he's so strong, few can stand up against him in battle).

to:

* ''Manga/OnePiece'': An extended flashback showing how Wano became the hellhole it is now and Kozuki Oden's story has the villainous Orochi being assisted by two Devil Fruit users. An old woman with the Clone-Clone Fruit and an old man with the Barrier-Barrier Fruit. Since only one person may have a Devil Fruit power at any time, and we've seen that in the present day present-day different people have those specific powers, powers (Bon Clay and Bartholomew), it's immediately clear they're both dead by now. Indeed, the old woman is killed offscreen by Kaido for interfering with his battle with Oden (although she probably saved Kaido's life, the one thing he hates the most is for the chance to have an evenly matched fight with a WorthyOpponent snatched from him, since he's so strong, few can stand up against him in battle).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
tyop


* ''Fanfic/TheNutdealerExpandedUniverse'' (''VideoGame/{{Deltarune}}'' & ''VideoGame/Undertale}}''): "Nut Leader" opens with a council of sapient nuts plotting Nathan's downfall. Since "[=TunaElder=]" had already shown his arrest for public exposure ruining his reputation, it was only a matter of how.

to:

* ''Fanfic/TheNutdealerExpandedUniverse'' (''VideoGame/{{Deltarune}}'' & ''VideoGame/Undertale}}''): ''VideoGame/{{Undertale}}''): "Nut Leader" opens with a council of sapient nuts plotting Nathan's downfall. Since "[=TunaElder=]" had already shown his arrest for public exposure ruining his reputation, it was only a matter of how.

Added: 422

Removed: 422

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Webcomic/ALittleHintOfBlue'' shows Skara dating Fled ([[NamedByTheAdaptation the boy who asked her out to Grom]]) during the timeline of [[WesternAnimation/TheOwlHouse the original show]], but [[Webcomic/MoringMarkTOHComics other comics by the author]] that came out beforehand establish that she eventually goes on to marry Viney instead, so no matter what her and Fled aren't going to stay together in the long term.



* ''Webcomic/ALittleHintOfBlue'' shows Skara dating Fled ([[NamedByTheAdaptation the boy who asked her out to Grom]]) during the timeline of [[WesternAnimation/TheOwlHouse the original show]], but [[Webcomic/MoringMarkTOHComics other comics by the author]] that came out beforehand establish that she eventually goes on to marry Viney instead, so no matter what her and Fled aren't going to stay together in the long term.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Webcomic/ALittleHintOfBlue'' shows Skara dating Fled ([[NamedByTheAdaption the boy who asked her out to Grom]]) during the timeline of [[WesternAnimation/TheOwlHouse the original show]], but [[Webcomic/MoringMarkTOHComics other comics by the author]] that came out beforehand establish that she eventually goes on to marry Viney instead, so no matter what her and Fled aren't going to stay together in the long term.

to:

* ''Webcomic/ALittleHintOfBlue'' shows Skara dating Fled ([[NamedByTheAdaption ([[NamedByTheAdaptation the boy who asked her out to Grom]]) during the timeline of [[WesternAnimation/TheOwlHouse the original show]], but [[Webcomic/MoringMarkTOHComics other comics by the author]] that came out beforehand establish that she eventually goes on to marry Viney instead, so no matter what her and Fled aren't going to stay together in the long term.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The "A Little Hint of Blue" storyline of ''Webcomic/MoringMarkTOHComics'' shows Skara dating Fled ([[NamedByTheAdaption the boy who asked her out to Grom]]) during the timeline of [[WesternAnimation/TheOwlHouse the original show]], but comics that came out beforehand establish that she eventually goes on to marry Viney instead, so no matter what her and Fled aren't going to stay together in the long term.

to:

* The "A Little Hint of Blue" storyline of ''Webcomic/MoringMarkTOHComics'' ''Webcomic/ALittleHintOfBlue'' shows Skara dating Fled ([[NamedByTheAdaption the boy who asked her out to Grom]]) during the timeline of [[WesternAnimation/TheOwlHouse the original show]], but [[Webcomic/MoringMarkTOHComics other comics by the author]] that came out beforehand establish that she eventually goes on to marry Viney instead, so no matter what her and Fled aren't going to stay together in the long term.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:''VideoGame/FateGrandOrder'']]
* ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/37424887/chapters/93397411 San Peftastéri]]'' follows the Servants from Proper Human History in their fight against the Atlantis Lostbelt, with particular focus on Achilles, Medea, Mordred, and [[SailorEarth Sir Kay]]. As the story takes place before Chaldea arrives to the Lostbelt where only a handful of Servants await them, the Heroic Spirits' fate range from confirmed dead by Canon[[note]]Medea, PHH Odysseus, and Mordred[[/note]], expected to die as they did not appear in the present[[note]]Sir Kay, Gilgamesh, and Patroclus[[/note]], or will die in the game proper[[note]]Achilles, Jason, Bartholomew Roberts, and Caligula[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The "A Little Hint of Blue" storyline of ''Webcomic/MoringMarkTOHComics'' shows Skara dating Fled ([[NamedByTheAdaption the boy who asked her out to Grom]]) during the timeline of [[WesternAnimation/TheOwlHouse the original show]], but comics that came out beforehand establish that she eventually goes on to marry Viney instead, so no matter what her and Fled aren't going to stay together in the long term.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The same applies to [[spoiler:Spock and Chapel's relationship. It was doomed from the start because there's no hint of it in TOS, plus Chapel is supposed to be engaged to Roger Korby. This actually ends up happening because [[WesterAnimation/StarTrekLowerDecks Boimler]] tells Chapel that there's nothing in the records about Spock exploring his emotional side, which she takes to mean that nothing will come of their romance]].

Top