Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / BuryYourDisabled

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* '''[[DrivenToSuicide Suicide]]:''' May carry the {{Unfortunate Implication|s}} that one is better off dead than disabled. Or, worst-case scenario, the writer who uses this trope [[TheSocialDarwinist really does believe that one is better dead than disabled]].

to:

* '''[[DrivenToSuicide Suicide]]:''' May carry the {{Unfortunate Implication|s}} unfortunate implications that one is better off dead than disabled. Or, worst-case scenario, the writer who uses this trope [[TheSocialDarwinist really does believe that one is better dead than disabled]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* '''Murder:''' The disabled person is killed off in a violent manner. This can be because they (the disabled character) were considered, by the writer and audience, an easier victim because of their disability. Tends to carry the {{Unfortunate Implication|s}} that someone who is disabled can't protect themselves.[[note]]This ''can'' be TruthInTelevision, but that depends on the specific disability -- and even the crippling ones can be compensated for these days. Before the 20th century... not so much.[[/note]]

to:

* '''Murder:''' The disabled person is killed off in a violent manner. This can be because they (the disabled character) were considered, by the writer and audience, an easier victim because of their disability. Tends to carry the {{Unfortunate Implication|s}} unfortunate implications that someone who is disabled can't protect themselves.[[note]]This ''can'' be TruthInTelevision, but that depends on the specific disability -- and even the crippling ones can be compensated for these days. Before the 20th century... not so much.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* '''MercyKill:''' Someone close to the disabled kills -- or even murders -- the disabled, either by their request or thinking that life as a disabled person would be too hard to bear. This may overlap with suicide, mercy killing, euthanasia, and even murder, and may carry the same UnfortunateImplications as suicide.

to:

* '''MercyKill:''' Someone close to the disabled kills -- or even murders -- the disabled, either by their request or thinking that life as a disabled person would be too hard to bear. This may overlap with suicide, mercy killing, euthanasia, and even murder, and may carry the same UnfortunateImplications unfortunate implications as suicide.



* The book and subsequent movie ''Film/MeBeforeYou'' has its male lead Will (who has quadriplegia) commit suicide, with all the UnfortunateImplications that entails. It then goes further and has him leave the female lead a ton of money so that she can [[BrokenAesop "live boldly."]]

to:

* The book and subsequent movie ''Film/MeBeforeYou'' has its male lead Will (who has quadriplegia) commit suicide, with all the UnfortunateImplications unfortunate implications that entails. It then goes further and has him leave the female lead a ton of money so that she can [[BrokenAesop "live boldly."]]



* Part of the backlash against vaccines is fueled by one fraudulent study that purported to link vaccines and autism (the fraudster hoped to supplant the usual measles vaccine with one of his own). As both scientists and autistic people have pointed out, this leads to some UnfortunateImplications: better to die in agony than be autistic.

to:

* Part of the backlash against vaccines is fueled by one fraudulent study that purported to link vaccines and autism (the fraudster hoped to supplant the usual measles vaccine with one of his own). As both scientists and autistic people have pointed out, this leads to some UnfortunateImplications: unfortunate implications: better to die in agony than be autistic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The [[ProudWarriorRaceGuy Tanakth]] in ''VideoGame/HorizonZeroDawn'' have this as part of their culture. They believe that anyone who can't fight is worthless so anyone who suffers a disabling injury is forced to fight a machine to prove that they are still able to fight which almost always results in their death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


** Ancient Egypt and Israel defied this trope, outlawing infanticide in their societies and severely punishing those who committed it. The former group would even rescue children "exposed" by foreigners living in Egypt. And the latter group's influence on Christianity and Islam led to the rise of orphanages as unwanted children were left at the doors of mosques and churches instead of being left in the woods to die.[[note]]Unfortunately in the countryside most children born with birth defects were either killed at birth or, by necessity, left to die.[[/note]] Orphanages often had [[OrphanageOfFear poor conditions]] though. Newborn infants also had a high mortality rate regardless in those days.

to:

** Ancient Egypt and Israel defied this trope, outlawing infanticide in their societies and severely punishing those who committed it. The former group would even rescue children "exposed" by foreigners living in Egypt. And Egypt, and people with dwarfism were especially honored, some even rising to very high positions (possibly the only society on record with such attitudes). The latter group's influence on Christianity and Islam led to the rise of orphanages as unwanted children were left at the doors of mosques and churches instead of being left in the woods to die.[[note]]Unfortunately in the countryside most children born with birth defects were either killed at birth or, by necessity, left to die.[[/note]] Orphanages often had [[OrphanageOfFear poor conditions]] though. Newborn infants also had a high mortality rate regardless in those days.



* Even before the Nazis, some eugenicists and euthanasia advocates (especially if they were both) advocated this idea. Because of the history, this remains one reason it's controversial, with a lot of disabled people and disability rights activists suspicious of euthanasia as a result.
* In modern times, a majority of fetuses with Down Syndrome are aborted, according to The Other Wiki: [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Down_syndrome up to 92% in Europe and about 67% in the U.S.]]

to:

* Even before the Nazis, some eugenicists and euthanasia advocates (especially if they were both) advocated this idea. Because of the history, this remains one reason it's for euthanasia being very controversial, with a lot of disabled people and disability rights activists suspicious of euthanasia it as a result.
* In modern times, a majority of fetuses with Down Syndrome are aborted, according to The Other Wiki: [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Down_syndrome up to 92% in Europe and about 67% in the U.S.]]]], often with explicitly eugenicist motives. Worth noting is that the vast majority of people Down Syndrome report that they're happy.



* Curiously enough, averted by [[https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/06/17/878896381/ancient-bones-offer-clues-to-how-long-ago-humans-cared-for-the-vulnerable multiple stone age communities]] according to recent analyses of various groups of remains and artifacts. There are examples of both individuals born with severe genetic disorders as well as those who had sustained severe injuries whose remains show evidence of care, and who would've died young due to aspects of their conditions that their caregivers would not have been able to identify and treat.

to:

* Curiously enough, averted by [[https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/06/17/878896381/ancient-bones-offer-clues-to-how-long-ago-humans-cared-for-the-vulnerable multiple stone age communities]] according to recent analyses of various groups of remains and artifacts. There are examples of both individuals born with severe genetic disorders as well as those who had sustained severe injuries whose remains show evidence of care, and who would've died young due to aspects of their conditions that their caregivers would not have been able to identify and treat. This disproves an old Social Darwinist argument that the opposite was the case.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/TheTwilightZone1959'': {{Discussed}} in "[[Recap/TheTwilightZone1959S2E29TheObsoleteMan The Obsolete Man]]" as the Chancellor openly speaks of how anyone too disabled to do useful work is eliminated by the State (either by physical impairment, sickness or just age). He claims Adolf Hitler as one precursor of the State (whose own regime had murdered thousands of disabled people), but also that Hitler's killings ''didn't go far enough''.

Added: 329

Changed: 495

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


* In ''Series/{{Glee}}'': [[spoiler: Jean Sylvester, Sue's older sister, had Down's Syndrome and died of pneumonia. Subverted with Becky, who attempts suicide, but is stopped by Sue.]] Averted with the InspirationallyDisabled Sean from Season 1--he attempted suicide by driving into the pool but was found before he could succeed.

to:

* ''Series/Echo2024'': In "[[Recap/EchoEpisode1Chafa Chafa]]" Maya's mother, who it turns out was a deaf woman like her, dies in the flashback. She's the only relative aside from Maya's father who dies, and the very first chronologically. {{Downplayed}} however as Maya herself of course survived.
* In ''Series/{{Glee}}'': [[spoiler: Jean [[spoiler:Jean Sylvester, Sue's older sister, had Down's Syndrome and died of pneumonia. Subverted with Becky, who attempts suicide, but is stopped by Sue.]] Averted with the InspirationallyDisabled Sean from Season 1--he attempted suicide by driving into the pool but was found before he could succeed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Partnership'', ''The Ship Who Searched'', and ''The City Who Fought'', published a good thirty years later, try to soften this by portraying non-shelled disabled adults who are happy, reframing shells as life support, and explaining to a NaiveNewcomer that shells are the end point of assistive technology made to allow the disadvantaged to live as normal a life as possible.
** However, several {{Politically Incorrect Villain}}s do still despise shellpeople. The Kolnari in ''The City Who Fought'', in particular, are such [[TheSocialDarwinist Social Darwinists]] that they readily kill any of their own children they regard as weak.

to:

** ''Partnership'', ''The Ship Who Searched'', and ''The City Who Fought'', The other books in the series, published a good thirty years later, try to soften this by portraying non-shelled disabled adults who are happy, reframing shells as life support, and explaining to a NaiveNewcomer that shells are the end point of assistive technology made to allow the disadvantaged to live as normal a life as possible.
possible. It's still the case that the sheer expense of becoming a shellperson leaves them as [[IndenturedServitude indentured workers]] for often decades or longer.
** However, several {{Politically Incorrect Villain}}s do still despise shellpeople. It's noted in one book that this is a society where people with money can change their appearances quite readily, and the very concept of shellpeople discomforts and disgusts some. Polyon gets into a snit realizing that he's being transported on a [[SapientShip brainship]], sneering that it's absurd that something like [[ItIsDehumanizing "it"]] has not just been allowed to live but given a job that someone like ''him'' could have filled instead. The Kolnari in ''The City Who Fought'', in particular, Fought'' are such [[TheSocialDarwinist Social Darwinists]] that they readily their standard response to "disabling illness", any disease that can't just be shrugged off, is for the afflicted to either kill any of themselves or be killed as weak. Injured warriors who won't pull through with nothing worse than scars face the same choice, and Kolnari even kill their own children they regard as weak.for perceived flaws.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rename


* Narrowly {{Averted}} in ''VideoGame/PuellaMagiMadokaMagicaPortable''--in this version, [[DisabledLoveInterest Kyosuke]]'s angst about his CareerEndingInjury is upped so that [[ActionGirl Sayaka]] actually [[InterruptedSuicide walks in on him trying to kill himself]], prompting her [[DealWithTheDevil contract]] to heal him.

to:

* Narrowly {{Averted}} in ''VideoGame/PuellaMagiMadokaMagicaPortable''--in this version, [[DisabledLoveInterest [[TragicallyDisabledLoveInterest Kyosuke]]'s angst about his CareerEndingInjury is upped so that [[ActionGirl Sayaka]] actually [[InterruptedSuicide walks in on him trying to kill himself]], prompting her [[DealWithTheDevil contract]] to heal him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I think it's important to know that even though the more recent cultures were into the whole exposure thing, humans didn't start out that way.

Added DiffLines:

* Curiously enough, averted by [[https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/06/17/878896381/ancient-bones-offer-clues-to-how-long-ago-humans-cared-for-the-vulnerable multiple stone age communities]] according to recent analyses of various groups of remains and artifacts. There are examples of both individuals born with severe genetic disorders as well as those who had sustained severe injuries whose remains show evidence of care, and who would've died young due to aspects of their conditions that their caregivers would not have been able to identify and treat.

Added: 259

Changed: 90

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/TheShipWho Sang'' starts with the assertion that Helva's birth defects (deformed limbs and dim senses) meant she was born a "thing" and "as such would be condemned" if she didn't pass the encephalograph test required of all newborns. Because she was found to be intelligent, her grieving parents were presented with the choice of euthanizing her or surrendering her to be [[ManInTheMachine converted into a "shellperson"]] who would one day be the "brain" of a LivingShip. By implication, most disabled babies in this setting are killed.
** ''Partnership'', ''The Ship Who Searched'', and ''The City Who Fought'', published a good thirty years later, try to soften this by portraying non-shelled disabled adults who are happy, reframing the decision to put babies into "shells" as starting them on life support, and explaining to a NaiveNewcomer that shells are the end point of technological advances made to allow the disadvantaged to live as normal a life as possible.

to:

* ''Literature/TheShipWho Sang'' starts with the assertion that Helva's birth defects (deformed limbs and dim senses) meant she was born a "thing" and "as such would be condemned" if she didn't pass the encephalograph test required of all newborns. Because she was found to be intelligent, her grieving parents were presented with the choice of euthanizing her or surrendering her to be [[ManInTheMachine converted into a "shellperson"]] who would one day be the "brain" [[WetwareCPU "brain"]] of a LivingShip. By implication, most disabled babies in this setting are killed.
** ''Partnership'', ''The Ship Who Searched'', and ''The City Who Fought'', published a good thirty years later, try to soften this by portraying non-shelled disabled adults who are happy, reframing the decision to put babies into "shells" shells as starting them on life support, and explaining to a NaiveNewcomer that shells are the end point of technological advances assistive technology made to allow the disadvantaged to live as normal a life as possible.possible.
** However, several {{Politically Incorrect Villain}}s do still despise shellpeople. The Kolnari in ''The City Who Fought'', in particular, are such [[TheSocialDarwinist Social Darwinists]] that they readily kill any of their own children they regard as weak.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/StarTrekStrangeNewWorlds'': After introducing to great fanfare a blind main character, Hemmer, played by the franchise's [[DisabledCharacterDisabledActor first blind actor]], the series kills him off [[BlackDudeDiesFirst after he appears in just six of the first nine episodes]] - fewer than any other main character in the franchise. However, this is a downplayed example -- his race, the Aenar, are naturally blind and are compensated by other; his death isn't because of his disability but [[spoiler:he's been infected with Gorn eggs and he decides to perform a HeroicSuicide to prevent the creatures from continuing trying to kill his crewmates]]; and his main goal in the series is to be a SacrificalLion: [[spoiler:as he's DoomedByCanon, his storyarc is for him to bond with an uncertain Cadet Nyota Uhura and guide her on the path to becoming the iconic member of the ''Enterprise'' and his LastWords are to tell her to take that risk and make more bonds rather than drift to try and not get hurt again]].

to:

* ''Series/StarTrekStrangeNewWorlds'': After introducing to great fanfare a blind main character, Hemmer, played by the franchise's [[DisabledCharacterDisabledActor first blind actor]], the series kills him off [[BlackDudeDiesFirst after he appears in just six of the first nine episodes]] - fewer than any other main character in the franchise. However, this is a downplayed example -- his race, the Aenar, are naturally blind and are compensated by other; his death isn't because of his disability but [[spoiler:he's been infected with Gorn eggs and he decides to perform a HeroicSuicide to prevent the creatures from continuing trying to kill his crewmates]]; and his main goal in the series is to be a SacrificalLion: SacrificialLion: [[spoiler:as he's DoomedByCanon, his storyarc is for him to bond with an uncertain Cadet Nyota Uhura and guide her on the path to becoming the iconic member of the ''Enterprise'' and his LastWords are to tell her to take that risk and make more bonds rather than drift to try and not get hurt again]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/WorldOnFire'': [[JustifiedTrope Justified]]. The introduction of Aktion T4 leads to the mass murder of people with disabilities in Nazi Germany. [[spoiler:The Rosslers' daughter Hilda has epilepsy and her mother kills her and then herself in a MurderSuicide that could be seen as a MercyKill.]]

Top