Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / AllohistoricalAllusion

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Played with in GunsOfTheSouth, also by Turtledove, after losing the Civil War, Lincoln contemplates writing a book about what would have happened if "it hadn't been for Bobbie Lee"

to:

* Played with in GunsOfTheSouth, ''TheGunsOfTheSouth'', also by Turtledove, Turtledove; after losing the Civil War, Lincoln contemplates writing a book about what would have happened if "it hadn't been for Bobbie Lee"Lee".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Lampshaded by the fact that the first mention is a newspaper headline that refers to the candidate by the initials "RR".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Watchmen}}'', RobertRedford running against the incumbent Richard Nixon for the Presidency is met with derision, "This is still America! People don't want a cowboy actor for president!" In 1985 when it was written, the President was RonaldReagan, who previously had a career as a cowboy actor.

to:

* In ''{{Watchmen}}'', RobertRedford running against the incumbent Richard Nixon for the Presidency is met with derision, "This is still America! People don't want [[ButchCassidyAndTheSundanceKid a cowboy actor actor]] for president!" In 1985 when it was written, the President was RonaldReagan, who previously had a career as a cowboy actor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:VideoGames]]
* In the first ''[[CommandAndConquer Red Alert]]'' game, the Allies are suffering heavy losses and are being pushed farther West by the advancing Soviet forces. Then a new tactic is introduced by a German general that helps slow the Soviet advance and, eventually, pushes them back. The news report calls this new tactic "Lightning War" (''Blitzkrieg'' in German).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the movie, the Redford joke is updated to "People don't want a cowboy as president," referring to then-current President George W. Bush.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** And the Star Wars defense system is real thanks to the "Defense Czar" Walter Bishop.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** And a hit musical ''[[{{Cats}} Dogs]]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Played with in GunsOfTheSouth, also by Turtledove, after losing the Civil War, Lincoln contemplates writing a book about what would have happened if "it hadn't been for Bobbie Lee"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Penn Station is now "Springsteen Station", suggesting that The Boss was just as popular over there, but had probably died.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In an episode of ''StrikeWitches'' (which is set in an alternate 1944 in which aliens invaded and conquered most of continental Europe in 1939), Minna comments how if the aliens hadn't invaded, their superiors (Europe's political and military leaders) would likely be [[WorldWarTwo fighting among themselves]].

to:

* In an episode from the first season of ''StrikeWitches'' (which is set in an alternate 1944 in which aliens invaded and conquered most of continental Europe in 1939), Minna comments how if the aliens hadn't invaded, their superiors (Europe's political and military leaders) would likely be [[WorldWarTwo fighting among themselves]].
themselves]]. An episode from the second season (set in 1945) has the aircraft carrier Amagi supporting the Strike Witches in battle (in real life, the Amagi was a partially completed battle cruiser canceled under the conditions of the Washington Naval Treaty and was intended to be converted into a carrier, but was badly damaged in an earthquake and scrapped.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:Anime and Manga]]
* In an episode of ''StrikeWitches'' (which is set in an alternate 1944 in which aliens invaded and conquered most of continental Europe in 1939), Minna comments how if the aliens hadn't invaded, their superiors (Europe's political and military leaders) would likely be [[WorldWarTwo fighting among themselves]].

Added: 66

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And Fidel Castro being pitching coach for the Brooklyn Dodgers.



* There are several in KimNewman and Eugene Byrne's BackInTheUSSA series of short stories. Including one where a character comments that something was as strange as finding London Bridge in the Arizona desert.

to:

* There are several in KimNewman and Eugene Byrne's BackInTheUSSA ''BackInTheUSSA'' series of short stories. Including one where a character comments that something was as strange as finding London Bridge in the Arizona desert.



* Robert Silverberg's "A Hero of the Empire" has the Roman main character speculating what the world would be like if he doesn't [[spoiler:assassinate Mohammed before Islam takes off.]] He does.

to:

* Robert Silverberg's RobertSilverberg's "A Hero of the Empire" has the Roman main character speculating what the world would be like if he doesn't [[spoiler:assassinate Mohammed before Islam takes off.]] He does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Robert Silverberg's "A Hero of the Empire" has the Roman main character speculating what the world would be like if he doesn't [[spoiler:assassinate Mohammed before Islam takes off.]] He does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
missing the allusion


* Philip Roth wrote an alternate history version of America where Charles Lindberg is elected president after FDR. The novel takes place in WWII and is a speculation of what would have happened if an Anti-Semite was in charge of the country during Hitler's rise to power.

to:

* Philip Roth wrote an alternate history version of America where Charles Lindberg is elected president after FDR. The novel takes place in WWII and is a speculation of what would have happened if an Anti-Semite was in charge of the country during Hitler's rise to power.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The {{Reds}}! TL plays with this trope extensively.

Added: 119

Changed: 23

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:Comic Books]]
* In {{Watchmen}} Robert Redford running against the incumbent Richard Nixon for the Presidency is met with derision, "This is still America! People don't want a cowboy actor for president!" In 1985 when it was written, the President was Ronald Reagan, who previously had a career as a cowboy actor.

to:

[[AC:Comic Books]]
[[AC:ComicBooks]]
* In {{Watchmen}} Robert Redford ''{{Watchmen}}'', RobertRedford running against the incumbent Richard Nixon for the Presidency is met with derision, "This is still America! People don't want a cowboy actor for president!" In 1985 when it was written, the President was Ronald Reagan, RonaldReagan, who previously had a career as a cowboy actor.



[[AC:Fan Fic]]

to:

[[AC:Fan Fic]][[AC:FanFic]]



[[AC:Literature]]

to:

[[AC:Literature]][[AC:{{Literature}}]]



* One WildCards novel had a throwaway reference of TheBeatles either suspected of or having mind powers.

to:

* One WildCards ''WildCards'' novel had a throwaway reference of TheBeatles either suspected of or having mind powers.



* The difference between the 'verse of the book {{Fatherland}} and that of TheFilmOfTheBook can be marked by a pair of references. The book includes a conversation that suggests that the Mersey Beat never left Merseyside. The movie has a Beatles poster up in Nazi Berlin.

to:

* The difference between the 'verse of the book {{Fatherland}} ''{{Fatherland}}'' and that of TheFilmOfTheBook can be marked by a pair of references. The book includes a conversation that suggests that the Mersey Beat never left Merseyside. The movie has a Beatles poster up in Nazi Berlin.



[[AC: Live Action TV]]

to:

[[AC: Live Action TV]]LiveActionTV]]



** Aruba war vets.

to:

** Aruba war vets.vets.

[[AC:WebOriginal]]
* Also very favorite in timelines from AlternateHistoryDotCom, like the ChaosTimeline and others.
----

Changed: 270

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*Philip Roth wrote an alternate history version of America where Charles Lindberg is elected president after FDR. The novel takes place in WWII and is a speculation of what would have happened if an Anti-Semite was in charge of the country during Hitler's rise to power.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** How about those [[AllThePresidentsMen two Washington Post reporters]] [[StuffedInAFridge found dead in a parking garage]]?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And, in the moment that [[WhamEpisode ended the first season,]] [[TheWarOnTerror the White House has just finished reconstruction from the 9-11 attacks, and the World Trade Center still stands.]]

to:

** And, in the moment that [[WhamEpisode ended the first season,]] [[TheWarOnTerror the White House has just finished reconstruction from the 9-11 attacks, and the World Trade Center still stands.]]]]
** Aruba war vets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Turtledove loves this. In one of the "Tosev Timeline" stories (WorldWar) he has a alien invasion craft's nuclear reactor get blown up and contaminate the surrounding area.... that area being Chernobyl. And then, later, a captured member of The Race is being interrogated by the Japanese and wishes that a nuke would fall on him. He is being interrogated in Hiroshima.

to:

* Turtledove loves this. In one of the "Tosev Timeline" stories (WorldWar) he has a alien invasion craft's nuclear reactor get blown up and contaminate the surrounding area.... that area being Chernobyl. And then, later, a captured member of The Race is being interrogated by the Japanese and wishes that a nuke would fall on him. He is being interrogated in Hiroshima.Nagasaki.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In one Italian Disney comic, MickeyMouse ends up in a parallell world where the Roman Empire never fell, though a lot of other things look like the late 20th century. Including their being a science fiction genre, and Mickey sets himself up as an author by repeating basic real world history as AlternateHistory. His first story of Columbus discovering America is severely edited, because "that's too unrealistic! It could never have happened that way!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** A more light-hearted example would be when Vice President Ford stumbles a little bit, when walking down some stairs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A reference to the Lindbergh baby draws a blank stare.

to:

** A reference to the Lindbergh baby draws a blank stare.stare (as, on the Other Side, the appropriate parallel is Peter).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**The story "His Powder'd Wig, His Crown Of Thorns" by Marc Laidlaw takes it a step further; the alternate history depicted is ''wrong'', and {{Magical Native American}}s know how the universe ''should'' be (i.e. ours).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In {{Watchmen}} Robert Redford running against the incumbent Richard Nixon for the Presidency is meant with derision, "This is still America! People don't want a cowboy actor for president!" In 1985 when it was written, the President was Ronald Reagan, who previously had a career as a cowboy actor.

to:

* In {{Watchmen}} Robert Redford running against the incumbent Richard Nixon for the Presidency is meant met with derision, "This is still America! People don't want a cowboy actor for president!" In 1985 when it was written, the President was Ronald Reagan, who previously had a career as a cowboy actor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One of the earlier AlternateHistory works, WinstonChurchill's "If Lee Had Not Won The Battle of Gettysburg" in J.C. Squire's AlternateHistory collection ''If It Had Happened Otherwise'' (1929), used this as a framing device: a historian musing what would've happened had the Union won. (Among the results of Lee's victory, [[BenjaminDisraeli Disraeli]] and [[WilliamGladstone Gladstone]] end up in the opposite parties, slavery is abolished by Robert E. Lee, and WorldWarI is prevented.)

to:

* One of the earlier AlternateHistory works, WinstonChurchill's "If Lee Had Not Won The Battle of Gettysburg" in J.C. Squire's AlternateHistory collection ''If It Had Happened Otherwise'' (1929), used this as a framing device: a historian musing what would've happened had the Union won. (Among device. Among the results of Lee's victory, if the Union had won, [[BenjaminDisraeli Disraeli]] might have become a Conservative and [[WilliamGladstone Gladstone]] end up in the opposite parties, slavery is a Liberal, Robert E. Lee might not have abolished by Robert E. Lee, slavery but [[ValuesDissonance prevented Negro enfranchisement]], and WorldWarI is prevented.)a [[WorldWarI world war involving all the great powers]] might not have been averted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One of the earlier AlternateHistory works, WinstonChurchill's "If Lee Had Not Won The Battle of Gettysburg" in J.C. Squire's AlternateHistory collection ''If It Had Happened Otherwise...'', used this as a framing device: Confederate historians musing what would've happened had the Union won.

to:

* One of the earlier AlternateHistory works, WinstonChurchill's "If Lee Had Not Won The Battle of Gettysburg" in J.C. Squire's AlternateHistory collection ''If It Had Happened Otherwise...'', Otherwise'' (1929), used this as a framing device: Confederate historians a historian musing what would've happened had the Union won.won. (Among the results of Lee's victory, [[BenjaminDisraeli Disraeli]] and [[WilliamGladstone Gladstone]] end up in the opposite parties, slavery is abolished by Robert E. Lee, and WorldWarI is prevented.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One of the earlier AlternateHistory works used this as a framing device: Confederate historians musing what would've happened had the Union won.

to:

* One of the earlier AlternateHistory works works, WinstonChurchill's "If Lee Had Not Won The Battle of Gettysburg" in J.C. Squire's AlternateHistory collection ''If It Had Happened Otherwise...'', used this as a framing device: Confederate historians musing what would've happened had the Union won.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*Used in several of the stories in the ''The Mammoth Book of Alternate Histories'': for instance Frederick Pohl's "Waiting For The Olympians" in which a science-romance author in a world where [[AncientRome Rome]] never fell imagines what the world would be like if Tiberius had been Emperor; and Paul [=McAuley=]'s "A Very British History", in which a review of a book about the Britain-dominated space program criticises the historian for wasting a chapter speculating on what would have happened if the UK hadn't got all the [[HerrDoktor German rocket scientists]] after WorldWarII.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Turtledove loves this. In one of the "Tosev Timeline" stories (WorldWar) he has a alien invasion craft's nuclear reactor get blown up and contaminate the surrounding area.... that area being Chernobyl. And then, later, a captured member of The Race is being interrogated by the Japanese and wishes that a nuke would fall on him. He is being interrogated in Hiroshima.

Top