Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / AllJewsAreCheapskates

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Brazilian comedy show ''Escolinha do Professor Raimundo'' had Samuel Blaustein, highlighted by his {{Catch Phrase}}s "Up for any business!" and, after his answer to the teacher's question (usually highlighting his penny-pinching ways) was wrong, "well, better a zero in my grades than a loss in my account!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Angel:'''' Why, cost? The Ten commandments don't cost anything!\\
'''Jews:'''' What, they're free? Sure, we'll take all of them!

to:

'''Angel:'''' '''Angel:''' Why, cost? The Ten commandments don't cost anything!\\
'''Jews:'''' '''Jews:''' What, they're free? Sure, we'll take all of them!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Q: Why are Jewish men circumcised? A: Because Jewish women won't buy anything that isn't at least 20% off!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Tidying


* The Literature/{{Discworld}} of Creator/AAPessimal has [[BadassIsraeli Rivka ben-Divorah]], who while[[Fanfic/GapYearAdventures touring abroad]], demonstrates she can do complex currency conversions in her head even before the other person has stopped speaking. As a klatchian friend remarks
-->You really don't do anything to dispel all the stereotypes people have got about Cenotians, do you?

to:

* The Literature/{{Discworld}} of Creator/AAPessimal has [[BadassIsraeli Rivka ben-Divorah]], who while[[Fanfic/GapYearAdventures touring abroad]], is happy for her friend to do most of the spending for both of them[[note]]To be fair, Rivka's parents have blocked her from accessing her own cash, forcing Mariella to budget for both of them[[/note]], and demonstrates she can do complex currency conversions in her head even before the other person has stopped speaking. As a klatchian Klatchian friend remarks
-->You really don't do anything much to dispel all the cultural stereotypes people have got about Cenotians, do you? you?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The Literature/{{Discworld}} of Creator/AAPessimal has [[BadassIsraeli Rivka ben-Divorah]], who while[[Fanfic/GapYearAdventures touring abroad]], demonstrates she can do complex currency conversions in her head even before the other person has stopped speaking. As a klatchian friend remarks
-->You really don't do anything to dispel all the stereotypes people have got about Cenotians, do you?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:Page picture? What are you, crazy? Do you know how much bandwidth costs?]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:Page picture? What are you, crazy? Do you know have ''any'' idea how much bandwidth costs?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Welsh people point at ''Cardis'' - people from West Wales.[[note]]Cardiganshire[[/note]]

to:

Welsh people point at ''Cardis'' - ''Cardis''--[[Music/CardiB no, not her]], people from West Wales.[[note]]Cardiganshire[[/note]]
Cardiganshire in western Wales.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A Christian church is offering a cash reward to new members. One Jew decides to try joining. When a friend, also Jewish, asks whether he actually got the money, the convert chides, "Is that all you people think about?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''VideoGame/AtomRPG'', equipping a ''kippah'' gives the user a bonus to the Barter skill.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/StrikeCommander'' plays this trope straight with Virgil Beetlebaum, [[TheSquad]]'s accountant, who [[JewishComplaining complains constantly]] about every single financial decision, and literally [[GameplayAndStorySegregation cannot be pleased no matter how much money you make]]. {{Subverted}} in that Virgil is ultimately a sympathetic character who has an incredibly difficult job keeping the Wildcats afloat with all of the overhead.

to:

* ''VideoGame/StrikeCommander'' plays this trope straight with Virgil Beetlebaum, [[TheSquad]]'s TheSquad's accountant, who [[JewishComplaining complains constantly]] about every single financial decision, and literally [[GameplayAndStorySegregation cannot be pleased no matter how much money you make]]. {{Subverted}} in that Virgil is ultimately a sympathetic character who has an incredibly difficult job keeping the Wildcats afloat with all of the overhead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/StrikeCommander'' plays this trope straight with Virgil Beetlebaum, [[TheSquad]]'s accountant, who [[JewishComplaining complains constantly]] about every single financial decision, and literally [[GameplayAndStorySegregation cannot be pleased no matter how much money you make]]. {{Subverted}} in that Virgil is ultimately a sympathetic character who has an incredibly difficult job keeping the Wildcats afloat with all of the overhead.
Tabs MOD

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[DescribeTopicHere Describe All Jews Are Cheapskates Here. It's free, after all.]]

to:

[[DescribeTopicHere [[JustforFun/DescribeTopicHere Describe All Jews Are Cheapskates Here. It's free, after all.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
You Have To Have Jews is no longer a trope


In Great Britain, this trope is less common, since Jews are a much smaller and less [[YouHaveToHaveJews culturally-represented]] minority, and their economical niche is [[ThriftyScot filled by Scotsmen]], a never-failing source of British ethnic jokes. Yorkshiremen also have this reputation, especially among [[OopNorth other Northerners]].

to:

In Great Britain, this trope is less common, since Jews are a much smaller and less [[YouHaveToHaveJews culturally-represented]] culturally-represented minority, and their economical niche is [[ThriftyScot filled by Scotsmen]], a never-failing source of British ethnic jokes. Yorkshiremen also have this reputation, especially among [[OopNorth other Northerners]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing red link


[[folder:Podcasts]]
* When ''Podcast/ChapoTrapHouse'' reviewed [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hillary%27s_America:_The_Secret_History_of_the_Democratic_Party a documentary by Dinesh D'Souza]], they observed that the film's demonization of Saul Alinsky (known for writing the book ''Rules For Radicals'') seemed to rely on this stereotype rather than the usual right-wing methods of smearing him as a nefarious lefty demagogue.

Changed: 46

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** They even go UpToEleven and pull this on Jesus, where he delivers an Aesop on religion. Peter asks Jesus to prove he's Jewish by calculating an appropriate tip on a $180 bill.

to:

** They even go UpToEleven {{exaggerate|dTrope}} it and pull this on Jesus, where he delivers an Aesop on religion. Peter asks Jesus to prove he's Jewish by calculating an appropriate tip on a $180 bill.



* In a ''WesternAnimation/RobotChicken'' skit where [=Seth McFarlane=] has the power to setup {{Cutaway Gag}}s, he brings up the idea of ''Scooby Jew''. Cut to a stereotypically-dressed Scooby haggling over Scooby snacks in exchange for going into a haunted house.

to:

* In a ''WesternAnimation/RobotChicken'' skit where [=Seth McFarlane=] Creator/SethMacFarlane has the power to setup set up {{Cutaway Gag}}s, he brings up the idea of ''Scooby Jew''. Cut to a stereotypically-dressed Scooby haggling over Scooby snacks in exchange for going into a haunted house.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One character on ''Series/TheYoungOnes'' (played by [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arnold_Brown_%28comedian%29 Arnold Brown]]) plays with this trope by describing himself as being "Scottish and Jewish -- two racial stereotypes for the price of one!" Works on multiple levels because in the UK the Scots are also commonly stereotyped as being cheapskates, and two of anything for the price of one would therefore appeal to them, too.

to:

* One character on ''Series/TheYoungOnes'' (played by [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arnold_Brown_%28comedian%29 Arnold Brown]]) plays with this trope by describing himself as being "Scottish and Jewish -- two racial stereotypes for the price of one!" Works on multiple levels because in the UK the Scots are also [[ThriftyScot commonly stereotyped as being cheapskates, cheapskates]], and two of anything for the price of one would therefore appeal to them, too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Features in ''A Field Guide to the Jewish People'', i.e. [[Literature/BookOfEsther Esther]] maintains her Gentile disguise by "going so far as to pay retail on three distinct occasions."

Added: 949

Changed: 198

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In modern times, thriftiness is often a trait associated with East Asians, especially the Chinese. Though [[AluminiumChristmasTrees there are literal Asian Jews, such as the Chinese Kaifeng Jews]], this stereotype is rarely used except as a joke.[[note]]Curiously, those Chinese who have heard of Jews at all will often hold this opinion about them, but also consider it a ''positive'' trait![[/note]] Also, the Cold War-era generation of people from the former Eastern Bloc, no matter what ethnicity, is stereotyped this way by the younger, more Westernized generation, [[InsultBackfire to which they agree with pride]] [[JustifiedTrope as this lifestyle enabled them to survive in the times of mass poverty and low living standards]], and chastise younger people for their consumerism.
In Israel, where [[CaptainObvious most people are jews]], the stereotype is applied to Persian and Yemeni Jews.

to:

In modern times, thriftiness is often a trait associated with East Asians, especially the Chinese. Though [[AluminiumChristmasTrees there are literal Asian Jews, such as the Chinese Kaifeng Jews]], this stereotype is rarely used except as a joke.[[note]]Curiously, those Chinese who have heard of Jews at all will often hold this opinion about them, but also consider it a ''positive'' trait![[/note]] trait! This positive view is also held in Japan and to some extent Korea, and some Japanese officials advocated admitting Jewish refugees because they believed it would make Japan economically powerful.[[/note]] Also, the Cold War-era generation of people from the former Eastern Bloc, no matter what ethnicity, is stereotyped this way by the younger, more Westernized generation, [[InsultBackfire to which they agree with pride]] [[JustifiedTrope as this lifestyle enabled them to survive in the times of mass poverty and low living standards]], and chastise younger people for their consumerism.
In Israel, where [[CaptainObvious most people are jews]], Jews]], the stereotype is applied to Persian and Yemeni Jews.


Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'': Deconstructed and partially justified in the case of Grunkle Stan. When first introduced, Stan appears to be a greedy miser who uses his own family to make an extra buck. By the time the Author is introduced, we learn that he's so preoccupied with money because he was homeless for much of his life and had to turn to crime to survive, and now that he owns the Mystery Shack, he has to pay the mortgage on it to [[spoiler:have a chance of seeing his brother again]]. Notably, we don't get any hints that he's Jewish until "A Tale of Two Stans", when a mezuzah is seen on his childhood home. By this point he's become a sympathetic character. Contrast his actions in the finale with the archetypal GreedyJew, [[Theatre/TheMerchantOfVenice Shylock]], who cares more for money than his own daughter. [[spoiler:Stan responds to Bill's offer of money and power with a MegatonPunch, proving he puts his family first.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jack Benny is kind of an unusual example of this, as while his persona is a perfect example of this trope, that persona wasn't explicitly Jewish and was more of a WASP if anything. Thus, his being a Jewish stereotype/being played by a Jewish actor is sort of {{subtext}}. Also, in real life, Benny was a massive subversion of the trope, being generous to a fault.

to:

** Jack Benny is kind of an unusual example of this, as while his persona is a perfect example of this trope, that persona wasn't explicitly Jewish and was more of a WASP if anything. Thus, his being a Jewish stereotype/being played by a Jewish actor is sort of {{subtext}}. Also, in real life, Benny was a massive subversion of the trope, being generous to a fault.extremely generous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jack Benny is kind of an unusual example of this, as while his persona is a perfect example of this trope, that persona wasn't explicitly Jewish and was more of a WASP if anything. Thus, his being a Jewish stereotype/being played by a Jewish actor is sort of {{subtext}}.

to:

** Jack Benny is kind of an unusual example of this, as while his persona is a perfect example of this trope, that persona wasn't explicitly Jewish and was more of a WASP if anything. Thus, his being a Jewish stereotype/being played by a Jewish actor is sort of {{subtext}}. Also, in real life, Benny was a massive subversion of the trope, being generous to a fault.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A variant on this joke has the angel give a single commandment to each people (a different one each time, and just the one the people in front of him won't accept). When the Jews find out that the commandment doesn't cost anything, they reply "We'll take ten of them!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->'''Cartman:''' ''[reaches for the bag of gold, bur it turns out to be in vain]'' No! '''NO!!!'''

to:

--->'''Cartman:''' ''[reaches for the bag of gold, bur but it turns out to be in vain]'' No! '''NO!!!'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->'''Cartman:''' ''[reaches for the bag of gold in vain]'' No! ''NO!!!''

to:

--->'''Cartman:''' ''[reaches for the bag of gold gold, bur it turns out to be in vain]'' No! ''NO!!!'''''NO!!!'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->'''Cartman:''' ''[reaches for the bag of gold in vain]]'' No! ''NO!!!''

to:

--->'''Cartman:''' ''[reaches for the bag of gold in vain]]'' vain]'' No! ''NO!!!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "Two Days Before the Day after Tomorrow", Cartman at one point demands the small sack of gold from Kyle that he states all Jews carry. Kyle actually does carry gold on him. Not only that, but he carries a bag of fake gold just in case someone tries to take the gold. When Cartman calls him out on this, Kyle looks like he's about to surrender the real gold... only for him to toss it away, making sure Cartman can never have it.
--->'''Cartman:''' No! NO!!!

to:

** In "Two Days Before the Day after Tomorrow", when the boys are about to be rescued by the government from a burning oil factory, Cartman at one point demands the small sack little bag of gold from Kyle that he states all Jews carry. carry around their necks. As it turns out, Kyle actually does ''does'' carry gold on him. Not only that, but he carries a bag of fake gold to keep the real bag of gold safe, just in case someone tries to take the gold.like all Jews do, apparently. When Cartman calls him out on this, Kyle looks like he's about to surrender the real gold... only for him to toss it away, away into the fire, making sure Cartman can never have it.
--->'''Cartman:''' ''[reaches for the bag of gold in vain]]'' No! NO!!!''NO!!!''

Added: 28

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "Two Days Before the Day after Tomorrow", Cartman at one point demands the small sack of gold from Kyle that he states all Jews carry. Kyle actually does carry gold on him. Not only that, but he carries a bag of fake gold just in case someone tries to take the gold. When Cartman calls him out on this, Kyle looks like he's abbout to surrender the real gold... Only for him to toss it away, making sure Cartman can never have it.

to:

** In "Two Days Before the Day after Tomorrow", Cartman at one point demands the small sack of gold from Kyle that he states all Jews carry. Kyle actually does carry gold on him. Not only that, but he carries a bag of fake gold just in case someone tries to take the gold. When Cartman calls him out on this, Kyle looks like he's abbout about to surrender the real gold... Only only for him to toss it away, making sure Cartman can never have it.it.
--->'''Cartman:''' No! NO!!!

Changed: 569

Removed: 541

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In modern times, thriftiness is often a trait associated with East Asians, especially the Chinese. Though there are literal Asian Jews, such as the Chinese Kaifeng Jews, this stereotype is rarely used except as a joke.

[[note]]Curiously, those Chinese who have heard of Jews at all will often hold this opinion about them, but also consider it a ''positive'' trait![[/note]] Also, the Cold War-era generation of people from the former Eastern Bloc, no matter what ethnicity, is stereotyped this way by the younger, more Westernized generation, [[InsultBackfire to which they agree with pride]] [[JustifiedTrope as this lifestyle enabled them to survive in the times of mass poverty and low living standards]], and chastise younger people for their consumerism.

to:

In modern times, thriftiness is often a trait associated with East Asians, especially the Chinese. Though [[AluminiumChristmasTrees there are literal Asian Jews, such as the Chinese Kaifeng Jews, Jews]], this stereotype is rarely used except as a joke.

joke.[[note]]Curiously, those Chinese who have heard of Jews at all will often hold this opinion about them, but also consider it a ''positive'' trait![[/note]] Also, the Cold War-era generation of people from the former Eastern Bloc, no matter what ethnicity, is stereotyped this way by the younger, more Westernized generation, [[InsultBackfire to which they agree with pride]] [[JustifiedTrope as this lifestyle enabled them to survive in the times of mass poverty and low living standards]], and chastise younger people for their consumerism.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In modern times, thriftiness is often a trait associated with East Asians especially the Chinese. Though there are literal Asian Jews such as the Chinese Kaifeng Jews, this stereotype is rarely used except as a joke.

to:

In modern times, thriftiness is often a trait associated with East Asians Asians, especially the Chinese. Though there are literal Asian Jews Jews, such as the Chinese Kaifeng Jews, this stereotype is rarely used except as a joke.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ross Geller from ''Series/{{Friends}}'' frequently. Rarely includes his sister, Monica, such as in "The One Where Rosita Dies" where Phoebe Buffay refers to the Geller siblings as "the worst tippers in the world" after having them as massage clients.

to:

* Ross Geller from ''Series/{{Friends}}'' frequently. Rarely includes ''Series/{{Friends}}''. At times also his sister, Monica, such as in "The One Where Rosita Dies" where Phoebe Buffay refers to the Geller siblings as "the worst tippers in the world" after having them as massage clients.

Top