Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / AliensNeverInventedDemocracy

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Link to episode


** One episode, "The Cloud Minders" showed that Federation membership doesn't require a democratic government at the planetary level. However, another maintains that the Federation won't accept any planet which practices "[[FantasticCasteSystem caste-based discrimination]]".

to:

** One episode, "The "[[Recap/StarTrekS3E21TheCloudMinders The Cloud Minders" Minders]]" showed that Federation membership doesn't require a democratic government at the planetary level. However, another maintains that the Federation won't accept any planet which practices "[[FantasticCasteSystem caste-based discrimination]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TabletopGame/{{Warhammer40000}}'': {{Downplayed}}. On the global scale, none of the major Xenos races are democratic: the Tyranids are a HiveMind, the Orks and the Drukhari lack a centralised government altogether and are ruled by [[MightMakesRight the strongest]], the Necron Dynasties are a [[FeudalFuture feudal monarchy]], and the Aeldari Craftworlds and the T'au Empire are oligarchies (the former ruled by the [[TheMagocracy psychic]] Seer Council, and the latter by the [[ThePhilosopherKing philosophizing]] Ethereal Caste). On the other hand, minor Xenos civilisations mentioned in the fluff ''are'' stated to be "republics", as are some members of the larger ones (such as the communist-themed Gretchin Revolutionary Committee). And, of course, 40k being [[CrapsackWorld what it is]], humans in the setting are [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters no paragons of liberty and democracy either]]. The Imperium of Man (not to mention the horrific Chaos-worshipping human societies) is often even ''more'' oppressive than most Xenos governments, with background fluff mentioning that even ''theorizing'' about democracy can get your planet subject to [[PlanetShatteringKaboom Exterminatus]].

to:

* ''TabletopGame/{{Warhammer40000}}'': {{Downplayed}}. On the global scale, none of the major Xenos races are democratic: the Tyranids are a HiveMind, the Orks and the Drukhari lack a centralised government altogether and are ruled by [[MightMakesRight the strongest]], the Necron Dynasties are a [[FeudalFuture feudal monarchy]], and the Aeldari Craftworlds and the T'au Empire are oligarchies (the former ruled by the [[TheMagocracy psychic]] Seer Council, and the latter by the [[ThePhilosopherKing philosophizing]] Ethereal Caste). On the other hand, minor Xenos civilisations mentioned in the fluff ''are'' stated to be "republics", as are some members of the larger ones (such as the communist-themed Gretchin Revolutionary Committee). And, of course, 40k being [[CrapsackWorld what it is]], humans in the setting are [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters no paragons of liberty and democracy either]]. The Imperium of Man (not to mention the horrific Chaos-worshipping human societies) is often even ''more'' oppressive than most Xenos governments, with background fluff mentioning that even ''theorizing'' about democracy can get your planet subject to [[PlanetShatteringKaboom [[OrbitalBombardment Exterminatus]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/Stellaris'': Averted, as any species is able to be one of seven government types: Democracy, Oligarchy, Dictatorship, Empire, Mega Corp, Hive Mind or Machine Intelligence (if they're robots). Depending on their Ethic and Civics, their government can be more specific, such as having the Materialist Ethic can turn a Representative Democracy into a Direct Democracy, or having the Citizen Service Civic makes them a Citizen's Republic.

to:

* ''VideoGame/Stellaris'': ''VideoGame/{{Stellaris}}'': Averted, as any species is able to be one of seven government types: Democracy, Oligarchy, Dictatorship, Empire, Mega Corp, Hive Mind or Machine Intelligence (if they're robots). Depending on their Ethic and Civics, their government can be more specific, such as having the Materialist Ethic can turn a Representative Democracy into a Direct Democracy, or having the Citizen Service Civic makes them a Citizen's Republic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/Stellaris'': Averted, as any species is able to be one of seven government types: Democracy, Oligarchy, Dictatorship, Empire, Mega Corp, Hive Mind or Machine Intelligence (if they're robots). Depending on their Ethic and Civics, their government can be more specific, such as having the Materialist Ethic can turn a Representative Democracy into a Direct Democracy, or having the Citizen Service Civic makes them a Citizen's Republic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''TabletopGame/{{Warhammer40000}}'': {{Downplayed}}. On the global scale, none of the major Xenos races are democratic: the Tyranids are a HiveMind, the Orks and the Drukhari lack a centralised government altogether and are ruled by [[MightMakesRight the strongest]], the Necron Dynasties are a [[FeudalFuture feudal monarchy]], and the Aeldari Craftworlds and the T'au Empire are oligarchies (the former ruled by the [[TheMagocracy psychic]] Seer Council, and the latter by the [[ThePhilosopherKing philosophizing]] Ethereal Caste). On the other hand, minor Xenos civilisations mentioned in the fluff ''are'' stated to be "republics", as are some members of the larger ones (such as the communist-themed Gretchin Revolutionary Committee). And, of course, 40k being [[CrapsackWorld what it is]], humans in the setting are [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters no paragons of liberty and democracy either]]. The Imperium of Man (not to mention the horrific Chaos-worshipping human societies) is often even ''more'' oppressive than most Xenos governments, with background fluff mentioning that even ''theorizing'' about democracy can get your planet subject to [[PlanetShatteringKaboom Exterminatus]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The atevi of Creator/CJCherryh's ''Literature/{{Foreigner}}'' series cannot conceive of any other form of governance than monarchy.

to:

* The atevi of Creator/CJCherryh's ''Literature/{{Foreigner}}'' ''Literature/Foreigner1994'' series cannot conceive of any other form of governance than monarchy.

Added: 908

Changed: 7

Removed: 908

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Tabletop Games]]
* ''TabletopGame/{{Pathfinder}}'': There are relatively few nonhuman-ruled nations on Golarion, and none are democracies. Elven Kyonin and the dwarven city-states in the Five Kings Mountains and elsewhere are monarchies (with the dwarf kings forming a larger alliance), while the orc lands of the Hold of Belkzen are an amorphous association of tribes that run on AsskickingEqualsAuthority. To be fair, however, there aren't many human democracies either, the only notable ones being Andoren (a staunchly anti-slavery parliamentary republic based on [[{{Eagleland}} an idealized vision of the United States]]), Galt ([[DemocracyIsFlawed effective mob rule]], inspired by [[UsefulNotes/TheFrenchRevolution France at the height of the Terror]]), and Nirmathas (loose confederation of woodland settlements). The Kellid barbarians also elect their clan leaders by acclamation.
[[/folder]]



* ''Franchise/TheTransformers'': Played straight in pretty much every incarnation of the franchise. Autobot leaders are chosen by the Matrix of Leadership, Decepticon leaders by AsskickingEqualsAuthority and KlingonPromotion. The one major exception to this is ''ComicBook/TransformersIDW2005'': when Optimus Prime decides that he can't be leader of the Autobots anymore, they hold an election for his replacement and choose Bumblebee. Later, after the Cybertronian Civil War ends and the Autobots, Decepticons, and unaligned Cybertrons reunite on Cybertron, an election is held for a new planetary leader. Thanks to the unaligned not knowing any better, they elected [[TheStarscream Starsceam]].

to:

* ''Franchise/TheTransformers'': Played straight in pretty much every incarnation of the franchise. Autobot leaders are chosen by the Matrix of Leadership, Decepticon leaders by AsskickingEqualsAuthority and KlingonPromotion. The one major exception to this is ''ComicBook/TransformersIDW2005'': ''ComicBook/TheTransformersIDW'': when Optimus Prime decides that he can't be leader of the Autobots anymore, they hold an election for his replacement and choose Bumblebee. Later, after the Cybertronian Civil War ends and the Autobots, Decepticons, and unaligned Cybertrons reunite on Cybertron, an election is held for a new planetary leader. Thanks to the unaligned not knowing any better, they elected [[TheStarscream Starsceam]].



[[folder:Tabletop Games]]
* ''TabletopGame/{{Pathfinder}}'': There are relatively few nonhuman-ruled nations on Golarion, and none are democracies. Elven Kyonin and the dwarven city-states in the Five Kings Mountains and elsewhere are monarchies (with the dwarf kings forming a larger alliance), while the orc lands of the Hold of Belkzen are an amorphous association of tribes that run on AsskickingEqualsAuthority. To be fair, however, there aren't many human democracies either, the only notable ones being Andoren (a staunchly anti-slavery parliamentary republic based on [[{{Eagleland}} an idealized vision of the United States]]), Galt ([[DemocracyIsFlawed effective mob rule]], inspired by [[UsefulNotes/TheFrenchRevolution France at the height of the Terror]]), and Nirmathas (loose confederation of woodland settlements). The Kellid barbarians also elect their clan leaders by acclamation.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Toys]]
* ''Franchise/TheTransformers'': Played straight in pretty much every incarnation of the franchise. Autobot leaders are chosen by the Matrix of Leadership, Decepticon leaders by AsskickingEqualsAuthority and KlingonPromotion. The one major exception to this is ''ComicBook/TransformersIDW2005'': when Optimus Prime decides that he can't be leader of the Autobots anymore, they hold an election for his replacement and choose Bumblebee. Later, after the Cybertronian Civil War ends and the Autobots, Decepticons, and unaligned Cybertrons reunite on Cybertron, an election is held for a new planetary leader. Thanks to the unaligned not knowing any better, they elected [[TheStarscream Starsceam]].
[[/folder]]

Added: 805

Changed: 1167

Removed: 420

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A recurring character of ''WebComic/TheInexplicableAdventuresOfBob'' is Princess Voluptua, the butterfly-like heir to an empire centering around the neighboring brown dwarf of Nemesis and viceroy of our solar system ([[AlienNonInterferenceClause Earth is a nature preserve]]). They do apparently have a parliament, though. And the dragons (one of their subject races) have a legislature called the [[UsefulNotes/{{Iceland}} Althing.]]

to:

* ''WebComic/TheInexplicableAdventuresOfBob'': A recurring character of ''WebComic/TheInexplicableAdventuresOfBob'' is Princess Voluptua, the butterfly-like heir to an empire centering around the neighboring brown dwarf of Nemesis and viceroy of our solar system ([[AlienNonInterferenceClause Earth is a nature preserve]]). They do apparently have a parliament, though. And the dragons (one of their subject races) have a legislature called the [[UsefulNotes/{{Iceland}} Althing.]]



* In ''WesternAnimation/{{Futurama}}'', whilst the Earth government is essentially a carbon copy of the US presidential system, the rest of the species have:

to:

* In ''WesternAnimation/{{Futurama}}'', whilst ''WesternAnimation/{{Futurama}}'': Whilst the Earth government is essentially a carbon copy of the US presidential system, the rest of the species have:



* On ''WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons'' [[Recap/TheSimpsonsS8E1TreehouseOfHorrorVII Treehouse of Horror VII]] segment, "Citizen Kang", aliens kidnap Homer and ask him to TakeMeToYourLeader. Homer quickly agrees, but then he changes his mind because he just remembered they are about to have an election between then-President UsefulNotes/BillClinton and Senator Bob Dole, so Homer doesn't know what to tell them. The aliens Kang and Kodos are apparently familiar with the concept of an election, having monitored human activity for years, but when they kidnap Clinton and Dole and impersonate them, their campaign styles make it clear that they have no direct experience with elections. Once Kang is elected, he enslaves the human population and converts the United States into a dictatorial monarchy.

to:

* On ''WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons'' [[Recap/TheSimpsonsS8E1TreehouseOfHorrorVII ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'': Not alien by standard definition, but the magical land of Equestria is ruled by two millennia-old, immortal monarchs with enough magic strength to move celestial bodies. All other species are likewise ruled by traditional monarchs. The only edge cases are the griffins, who had kings in the past but are now a failed state without an active government, and the dragons, whose absolute monarch is chosen through a competition in which any dragon can take part.
* ''WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons'': In the "[[Recap/TheSimpsonsS8E1TreehouseOfHorrorVII
Treehouse of Horror VII]] segment, VII]]" segment "Citizen Kang", aliens kidnap Homer and ask him to TakeMeToYourLeader. Homer quickly agrees, but then he changes his mind because he just remembered they are about to have an election between then-President UsefulNotes/BillClinton and Senator Bob Dole, so Homer doesn't know what to tell them. The aliens Kang and Kodos are apparently familiar with the concept of an election, having monitored human activity for years, but when they kidnap Clinton and Dole and impersonate them, their campaign styles make it clear that they have no direct experience with elections. Once Kang is elected, he enslaves the human population and converts the United States into a dictatorial monarchy.



* Not alien by standard definition, but [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic the magical land of Equestria]] is ruled by two millennia-old, immortal monarchs with enough magic strength to move celestial bodies. Thankfully, they're generally considered competent and benevolent. Fanfics sometimes poke fun at this, with the ponies confused, distrustful or even hostile of democracy and other political models.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Sometimes this is done because the writer wants to make the aliens truly alien in culture, thus having weird, even sometimes incomprehensible, political systems is a way. However, if the aliens' government system is just another non-democratic human system like absolute monarchy or dictatorship, then this is not the reason. In some works it could be a way to present humanity's [[GoodRepublicEvilEmpire nice democratic system vs the aliens' evil Empire]], which is very common when TheFederation faces TheEmpire. (This is especially common in works made during the UsefulNotes/ColdWar for [[ScaryDogmaticAliens obvious reasons]].) Sometimes is just a matter of PlanetOfHats: some writers just can't think that a ProudWarriorRace can be democratic (despite the fact that we have many examples in our own world) because, well [[ArmiesAreEvil warriors are not democrats]], also in scenarios of AlienInvasion, having the invaders enjoying a democracy would feel kind of contradictory (despite, again, many examples in our history where democratic republics held vast, cruel empires and subjugated other peoples without considering this a contradiction).

to:

Sometimes this is done because the writer wants to make the aliens truly alien in culture, thus having weird, even sometimes incomprehensible, political systems is a way. However, if the aliens' government system is just another non-democratic human system like Due to Hollywood and WeAllLiveInAmerica, an absolute monarchy or dictatorship, then this dictatorship is foreign to most western pop culture, while not the reason.having to come up with truly non-human systems since MostWritersAreHuman. In some works it could be a way to present humanity's [[GoodRepublicEvilEmpire nice democratic system vs the aliens' evil Empire]], which is very common when TheFederation faces TheEmpire. (This is especially common in works made during the UsefulNotes/ColdWar for [[ScaryDogmaticAliens obvious reasons]].) Sometimes is just a matter of PlanetOfHats: some writers just can't think that a ProudWarriorRace can be democratic (despite the fact that we have many examples in our own world) because, well [[ArmiesAreEvil warriors are not democrats]], also in scenarios of AlienInvasion, having the invaders enjoying a democracy would feel kind of contradictory (despite, again, many examples in our history where democratic republics held vast, cruel empires and subjugated other peoples without considering this a contradiction).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/{{X}}'': The Argon (a LostColony of humans) are the only explicitly representative government among the major factions, giving a senator to every inhabited planet, moon, or space station in their territory. The rest are the Boron (TheKingdom), the Split (TheEmpire), the Paranids (TheTheocracy), and the Teladi ({{Corporatocracy}}). It's unclear what form the Terran government takes.

to:

* ''VideoGame/{{X}}'': The Argon (a LostColony of humans) are the only explicitly representative government among the major factions, giving a senator to every inhabited planet, moon, or space station in their territory. The rest are the Boron (TheKingdom), (TheGoodKingdom), the Split (TheEmpire), the Paranids (TheTheocracy), and the Teladi ({{Corporatocracy}}). It's unclear what form the Terran government takes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''ComicBook/WonderWoman1942'': During the Golden Age Diana encountered dozens of extraterrestrial civilizations, all of which were ruled by kings, queens or emperors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The [[MechanicalAbomination individual members]] of the [[[[Characters/NewMutants Technarchy]] are not social and seem to barely tolerate each other enough to share a "crecheworld" for reproduction.

to:

** The [[MechanicalAbomination individual members]] of the [[[[Characters/NewMutants [[Characters/NewMutants Technarchy]] are not social and seem to barely tolerate each other enough to share a "crecheworld" for reproduction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlayedWith in the "Majority Rule" episode of ''Series/TheOrville'' in which the Sarguns have a form of direct democracy. Unfortunately, it's based on snap-voting in which uninformed opinions are more important than any consideration of the facts.

to:

* PlayedWith in the "Majority Rule" episode of ''Series/TheOrville'' in which the Sarguns have a form of direct democracy. Unfortunately, it's based on snap-voting in which uninformed opinions are more important than any consideration of the facts.facts, in an obvious parody of excesses on social media.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PlayedWith in the "Majority Rule" episode of ''Series/TheOrville'' in which the Sarguns have a form of direct democracy. Unfortunately, it's based on snap-voting in which uninformed opinions are more important than any consideration of the facts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{Coneheads}}'' based on a series of ''Series/SaturdayNightLive'' skits, the eponymous aliens' homeworld is ruled by an absolute dictator.

to:

* ''Film/{{Coneheads}}'' In, ''Film/{{Coneheads}}'', based on a series of ''Series/SaturdayNightLive'' skits, the eponymous aliens' homeworld is ruled by an absolute dictator.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The [[MechanicalAbomination individual members]] of the [[Comicbook/{{Warlock}} Technarchy]] are not social and seem to barely tolerate each other enough to share a "crecheworld" for reproduction.

to:

** The [[MechanicalAbomination individual members]] of the [[Comicbook/{{Warlock}} [[[[Characters/NewMutants Technarchy]] are not social and seem to barely tolerate each other enough to share a "crecheworld" for reproduction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[TheReptilians The Race]] in Creator/HarryTurtledove's ''Literature/{{Worldwar}}'' are ruled by an emperor, and have no concept that any other political system is viable or even possible. They initially believe that humanity works the same way, and think that the leaders of the various nations they encounter are each a hereditary emperor. Once they figure out that FDR, Stalin, and Hitler are not "emperors" despite being in charge, the only way they can think to describe them are as "not-emperors" who rule a "not-empire". Democracy is the most confusing to the Race, since at least Hitler and Stalin have the authority of an emperor, while the concept of working under the authority of the populace is even more alien. The name for democracy in their language is "snout-counting". Interestingly enough, The Race ''does'' have a procedure for removing someone from a position of power that's remarkably similar to an impeachment vote; one of them lampshades its resemblance to the "snout-counting" that they hold in contempt. They seem to justify it to themselves that they are counting the snouts of those who have the proper authority, not just the general public at random.

to:

* [[TheReptilians [[LizardFolk The Race]] in Creator/HarryTurtledove's ''Literature/{{Worldwar}}'' are ruled by an emperor, and have no concept that any other political system is viable or even possible. They initially believe that humanity works the same way, and think that the leaders of the various nations they encounter are each a hereditary emperor. Once they figure out that FDR, Stalin, and Hitler are not "emperors" despite being in charge, the only way they can think to describe them are as "not-emperors" who rule a "not-empire". Democracy is the most confusing to the Race, since at least Hitler and Stalin have the authority of an emperor, while the concept of working under the authority of the populace is even more alien. The name for democracy in their language is "snout-counting". Interestingly enough, The Race ''does'' have a procedure for removing someone from a position of power that's remarkably similar to an impeachment vote; one of them lampshades its resemblance to the "snout-counting" that they hold in contempt. They seem to justify it to themselves that they are counting the snouts of those who have the proper authority, not just the general public at random.

Changed: 510

Removed: 238

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Narn Regime: a Military Junta lead by the leaders of LaResistance against the Centauri. Background material goes into more detail and explain that the Narn government's name is the Kha'ri and it is made of several concentric circles of power from nobility and high priests to artisans and peasents. G'Kar is from the third circle of profesionals and intellectuals.

to:

** The Narn Regime: a Military Junta lead led by the leaders of LaResistance against the Centauri. Background material goes into more detail and explain that the Narn government's name is the Kha'ri and it is made of several concentric circles of power from nobility and high priests to artisans and peasents. G'Kar is from the third circle of profesionals professionals and intellectuals.



** The Hyach Grand Council of Elders: A gerontocracy.
** The Brakiri Syndicracy: A case of {{Corporatocracy}}.
** The pak'ma'ra: A communitarian society with no State (the dream of the anarchists).

to:

** The Hyach Grand Council of Elders: A a gerontocracy.
** The Brakiri Syndicracy: A a case of {{Corporatocracy}}.
** The pak'ma'ra: A a communitarian society with no State state (the dream of the anarchists).



** The Klingon Empire: A feudal oligarchy with the heads of the noble houses comprising the High Council and choosing a Chancellor, an emperor in all but name. They use to have fully empowered Emperors who were successors of Kahless ([[CrystalDragonJesus their culture's Jesus]]) but the figure was abandoned some 200 years before the first series starts. A clone of Kahless was later named Emperor but with only decorative and religious functions. They ''are'' democratic in a way, in that any Klingon is technically able to become Chancellor, but unless one is the designated or arbitrated successor this generally requires [[KlingonPromotion killing one's predecessor in a duel after making him look dishonorable]].
*** An episode of ''Series/DeepSpaceNine'' references they ''did'', briefly, practice democracy after a coup ousted the current emperor. It didn't last long, and Klingon history refers to it as "the Dark Time." Make of that what you will.

to:

** The Klingon Empire: A a feudal oligarchy with the heads of the noble houses comprising the High Council and choosing a Chancellor, an emperor in all but name. They use to have fully empowered Emperors who were successors of Kahless ([[CrystalDragonJesus their culture's Jesus]]) but the figure was abandoned some 200 years before the first series starts. A clone of Kahless was later named Emperor but with only decorative and religious functions. They ''are'' democratic in a way, in that any Klingon is technically able to become Chancellor, but unless one is the designated or arbitrated successor this generally requires [[KlingonPromotion killing one's predecessor in a duel after making him look dishonorable]].
***
dishonorable]]. An episode of ''Series/DeepSpaceNine'' references they ''did'', briefly, practice democracy after a coup ousted the current emperor. It didn't last long, and Klingon history refers to it as "the Dark Time." Make of that what you will.



** The Tzenkethi Coalition: Its leader is named the Autarch, you make the math.

to:

** The Tzenkethi Coalition: Its its leader is named the Autarch, you make do the math.



** The Ferengi Alliance: A plutocratic autocracy led by the Grand Nagus (generally the richest and most politically influential of all Ferengi, or most able to make other Ferengi think he is). All the rest of the administration is basically {{Corporatocracy}}. Near the end of the series, they transition to a constitutional system with the establishment of a "Congress of Economic Advisors".

to:

** The Ferengi Alliance: A a plutocratic autocracy led by the Grand Nagus (generally the richest and most politically influential of all Ferengi, or most able to make other Ferengi think he is). All the rest of the administration is basically {{Corporatocracy}}. Near the end of the series, they transition to a constitutional parliamentary system with the establishment of by establishing a "Congress of Economic Advisors".Advisors" to pass laws, with the Grand Nagus now more like a president or prime minister.



*** One episode, "The Cloud Minders" showed that Federation membership doesn't require a democratic government at the planetary level.

to:

*** ** One episode, "The Cloud Minders" showed that Federation membership doesn't require a democratic government at the planetary level. However, another maintains that the Federation won't accept any planet which practices "[[FantasticCasteSystem caste-based discrimination]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Takisians in ''Literature/WildCards'' practice [[DeadlyDecadentCourt especially skullduggerous]] medieval feudalism, with the noble families being selectively bred for superior psychic ability, scientific acumen, and physical beauty. Dr. Tachyon still doesn't get democracy after living among us for decades, not entirely seeing why elections are preferable to assassinations.

to:

* The Takisians in ''Literature/WildCards'' practice [[DeadlyDecadentCourt [[DecadentCourt especially skullduggerous]] medieval feudalism, with the noble families being selectively bred for superior psychic ability, scientific acumen, and physical beauty. Dr. Tachyon still doesn't get democracy after living among us for decades, not entirely seeing why elections are preferable to assassinations.

Added: 5406

Changed: 569

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/JohnCarter'': The Red Martian city-states of Zodanga and Helium are monarchies, while the Green Martians a.k.a. Tharks are a tribal clan structure whose choice of leaders are determined by AsskickingEqualsAuthority.
* ''Film/FlashGordon1980'': As in the classic serials, Mongo is an absolute monarchy run by the mad emperor Ming the Merciless. The nations under his rule seem similarly monarchical, with the Arboreans and the Hawkmen both being governed by a "prince" who is in turn answerable to Ming.
* ''Film/IndependenceDay'' doesn't offer much detail about the society of the invading aliens. ''Film/IndependenceDayResurgence'' goes further, establishing that the aliens are organized into hive minds ruled by queens.



* ''Literature/EndersGame'' gives us the Buggers, insectoid and telepathic aliens organized into hive minds each ruled by a queen. The story clarifies, however, that from the Buggers' point of view, this isn't a system of government because the hive is viewed as a single being, not a group of people whose society needs to be organized: the queen is effectively the "brain" of this being, while the other individuals are analogized to fingers or toes. Note that once the queen dies, so does everybody in the hive - they have no minds of their own telling them to eat or drink or save themselves.



* In ''Literature/PlanetOfTheApes'', the world seems to be a FantasticCasteSystem, with the gorillas, the orangutans, and the chimpanzees being roughly analogous to the aristocracy, the clergy, and the intellectuals, respectively. Subverted in that we're told that there is no law enforcing this, and any ape can go into any field he chooses: in practice, however, very few of them ever buck the trend.



* Often the case in ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'':
** Almost none of the alien races from outside of the known galaxy (i.e. extragalactic and Unknown Regions, what the setting would consider truly alien) practice democracy. Ssi-ruuk and Yuuzhan Vong societies both run on a very strict FantasticCasteSystem, leading up to a [[EvilOverlord supreme leader]], and legitimized by an official state religion. The Killiks are run by a hive mind. The Chosen are dominated by the warlord-conqueror Nuso Esva, with racial and religious allusions suggesting that any beings of other species are considered inferior (though the groups he pressures or tricks into his alliance aren't initially aware of this). The closest thing to a free society outside of the "known galaxy" may be the Chiss Ascendancy, but even their government is dominated by Ruling Families suggesting an aristocratic rather than democratic arrangement.
** Within the known galaxy, nonhuman species outside of Republic influence don't tend to go for democracy either. The most prominent are the Hutts, a half-plutocratic half-criminal society; they're ruled by a supreme council that houses one representative for each of the major Hutt clans (which are effectively crime syndicates). In complete fairness, the ''human'' societies outside of the Republic don't tend to be democratic either: the Hapes Consortium is an absolute monarchy, the Senex and Juvex sectors are slave societies ruled by aristocratic houses, and the Corporate Sector is OneNationUnderCopyright. In general, societies outside the Republic are likely to be run this way regardless of species, since they're usually ruled by autocrats who want to be free of Republic laws and Jedi enforcers.
** The Republic itself is an interesting example. It has the trappings of a democracy, it's referred to as one in-universe, and its chief executive is selected by a simple majority vote among the senators, who can also remove him any time they so choose. However, these senators are chosen by their planetary governments, and the requirements on how those governments should be run are... unclear, but fairly expansive: many of the Republic's alien members have monarchies, hive minds, [[FantasticCasteSystem Fantastic Caste Systems]], and other thoroughly nondemocratic systems of government. It's downplayed in that, again, some of the human worlds are nondemocratic as well.



* ''Series/StargateSG1'': Between the collapse of the Goa'uld Empire and the Ori invasion, the Free Jaffa attempt to establish a nation of their own. Early on, there's a conflict between Teal'c, one of the main cast members and pro-democracy, and Gerak, who favors [[AsskickingEqualsAuthority representation based on military strength]]. [[spoiler:Gerak later has to make a HeroicSacrifice to end the Ori plague on Earth, and Teal'c and Bra'tac push the Free Jaffa Nation back to traditional representative democracy.]]

to:

* ''Series/StargateSG1'': ''Series/StargateSG1'':
**
Between the collapse of the Goa'uld Empire and the Ori invasion, the Free Jaffa attempt to establish a nation of their own. Early on, there's a conflict between Teal'c, one of the main cast members and pro-democracy, and Gerak, who favors [[AsskickingEqualsAuthority representation based on military strength]]. [[spoiler:Gerak later has to make a HeroicSacrifice to end the Ori plague on Earth, and Teal'c and Bra'tac push the Free Jaffa Nation back to traditional representative democracy.]]]]
** The Goa'uld themselves are a blend of monarchy, feudalism, and theocracy. Their supreme authorities are System Lords who rule over individual domains: their human, Unas, and Jaffa slaves worship them as gods, while their other Goa'uld underlings obey them as kings.
** Earth's offworld allies the Tok'ra, the Tollan, and the Asgard are somewhat unclear. They're all ruled by some form of a high council and do generally seem to have laws they follow, in contrast to the System Lords' my-word-is-law attitude. However, there's no word on how the leaders of these councils are selected.
* ''Series/StargateAtlantis'':
** Similar to the Goa'uld, the Wraith run on feudalism, though a slightly more insectoid version. Their society is divided into hives, each one ruled by a queen.



** The Romulan Star Empire is technically a parliamentary republic, with the praetor seemingly equivalent to a prime minister. However, it's also very much a PoliceState where the major state security agency, the [[StateSec Tal Shiar]], wields significant political power: they station [[ThePoliticalOfficer political officers]] on naval vessels, and at two separate points in ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'', the vice-chair and chairman of the Tal Shiar also sit in the Senate.
** The Cardassian Union is a military dictatorship with a merely symbolic civil government. It has similarities with both Fascist and Soviet regimes. [[spoiler:In the ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'' episode "[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS04E01E02TheWayOfTheWarrior The Way of the Warrior]]", a popular uprising overthrows the military government and restores power to the Detapa Council. Later the Dominion invades Cardassia and overthrows this government to install Gul Dukat as their puppet dictator. Democratic rule is restored after the Dominion defeat in the ensuing war.]]

to:

** The Romulan Star Empire is technically a parliamentary republic, with the praetor seemingly equivalent to a prime minister. However, it's also very much a PoliceState where the major state security agency, the [[StateSec Tal Shiar]], wields significant political power: they station [[ThePoliticalOfficer political officers]] on naval vessels, and at two separate points in ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'', the vice-chair and chairman of the Tal Shiar also sit in the Senate.
Senate. It's also unclear how the members of the parliament are selected.
** The Cardassian Union is a military dictatorship with a merely symbolic civil government. It has similarities with both Fascist and Soviet Communist regimes. [[spoiler:In the ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'' episode "[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS04E01E02TheWayOfTheWarrior The Way of the Warrior]]", a popular uprising overthrows the military government and restores power to the Detapa Council. Later the Dominion invades Cardassia and overthrows this government to install Gul Dukat as their puppet dictator. Democratic rule is restored after the Dominion defeat in the ensuing war.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer'' and ''Series/{{Angel}}'' most demon cultures shown are autocratic or monarchic in nature. Vampire have generally packs ruled by masters (who are generally not only the strongest, but also the smartest -sometimes by far- and meanest of all). Also most other dimensions shown also seem to have absolute monarchies like Pylea and Oden-Tal.

to:

* In ''Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer'' and ''Series/{{Angel}}'' most demon cultures shown are autocratic or monarchic in nature. Vampire Vampires have generally packs ruled by masters (who are generally not only the strongest, but also the smartest -sometimes by far- and meanest of all). Also most other dimensions shown also seem to have absolute monarchies like Pylea and Oden-Tal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer'' and ''Series/{{Angel}}'' most demon cultures shown are autocratic or monarchic in nature. Vampire have generally packs ruled by masters (who are generally not only the strongest, but also the smartest -sometimes by far- and meanest of all). Also most other dimensions shown also seem to have absolute monarchies like Pylea and Oden-Tal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* On ''WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons'' [[Recap/TheSimpsonsS8E1TreehouseOfHorrorVII Treehouse of Horror VII]] segment, "Citizen Kang", aliens kidnap Homer and ask him to TakeMeToYourLeader. Homer hesitates, because they are about to have an election between President UsefulNotes/BillClinton and Senator Bob Dole, so Homer doesn't know what to tell them. The aliens Kang and Kodos are apparently familiar with the concept of an election, having monitored human activity for years, but when they kidnap Clinton and Dole and impersonate them, their campaign styles make it clear that they have no direct experience with elections. Once Kang is elected, he enslaves the human population and converts the United States into a dictatorial monarchy.

to:

* On ''WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons'' [[Recap/TheSimpsonsS8E1TreehouseOfHorrorVII Treehouse of Horror VII]] segment, "Citizen Kang", aliens kidnap Homer and ask him to TakeMeToYourLeader. Homer hesitates, quickly agrees, but then he changes his mind because he just remembered they are about to have an election between President then-President UsefulNotes/BillClinton and Senator Bob Dole, so Homer doesn't know what to tell them. The aliens Kang and Kodos are apparently familiar with the concept of an election, having monitored human activity for years, but when they kidnap Clinton and Dole and impersonate them, their campaign styles make it clear that they have no direct experience with elections. Once Kang is elected, he enslaves the human population and converts the United States into a dictatorial monarchy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A recurring character of ''WebComic/TheInexplicableAdventuresOfBob'' is Princess Voluptua, the butterfly-like heir to an empire centering around the neighboring brown dwarf of Nemesis and viceroy of our solar system ([[AlienNonInterferenceClause Earth is a nature preserve]]). They do apparently have a parliament, though.

to:

* A recurring character of ''WebComic/TheInexplicableAdventuresOfBob'' is Princess Voluptua, the butterfly-like heir to an empire centering around the neighboring brown dwarf of Nemesis and viceroy of our solar system ([[AlienNonInterferenceClause Earth is a nature preserve]]). They do apparently have a parliament, though. And the dragons (one of their subject races) have a legislature called the [[UsefulNotes/{{Iceland}} Althing.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A recurring character of ''WebComic/TheInexplicableAdventuresOfBob'' is Princess Voluptua, the butterfly-like heir to an empire centering around the neighboring brown dwarf of Nemesis and viceroy of our solar system ([[AlienNonInterferenceClause Earth is a nature preserve]]).

to:

* A recurring character of ''WebComic/TheInexplicableAdventuresOfBob'' is Princess Voluptua, the butterfly-like heir to an empire centering around the neighboring brown dwarf of Nemesis and viceroy of our solar system ([[AlienNonInterferenceClause Earth is a nature preserve]]). They do apparently have a parliament, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:350:[[Recap/TheSimpsonsS8E1TreehouseOfHorrorVII https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/president_kang.jpg]]]]

to:

[[quoteright:350:[[Recap/TheSimpsonsS8E1TreehouseOfHorrorVII [[quoteright:350:[[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/president_kang.jpg]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The robot homeworld is run (incompetently) by a NotSoOmniscientCouncilOfBickering.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TabletopGame/{{Pathfinder}}'': There are relatively few nonhuman-ruled nations on Golarion, and none are democracies. Elven Kyonin and the dwarven city-states in the Five Kings Mountains and elsewhere are monarchies (with the dwarf kings forming a larger alliance), while the orc lands of the Hold of Belkzen are an amorphous association of tribes that run on AsskickingEqualsAuthority. To be fair, however, there aren't many human democracies either, the only notable ones being Andoren (a staunchly anti-slavery parliamentary republic based on [[{{Eagleland}} an idealized vision of the United States]]), Galt ([[DemocracyIsFlawed effective mob rule]], inspired by [[UsefulNotes/TheFrenchRevolution France at the height of the Terror]]), and Nirmathas (loose confederation of woodland settlements).

to:

* ''TabletopGame/{{Pathfinder}}'': There are relatively few nonhuman-ruled nations on Golarion, and none are democracies. Elven Kyonin and the dwarven city-states in the Five Kings Mountains and elsewhere are monarchies (with the dwarf kings forming a larger alliance), while the orc lands of the Hold of Belkzen are an amorphous association of tribes that run on AsskickingEqualsAuthority. To be fair, however, there aren't many human democracies either, the only notable ones being Andoren (a staunchly anti-slavery parliamentary republic based on [[{{Eagleland}} an idealized vision of the United States]]), Galt ([[DemocracyIsFlawed effective mob rule]], inspired by [[UsefulNotes/TheFrenchRevolution France at the height of the Terror]]), and Nirmathas (loose confederation of woodland settlements). The Kellid barbarians also elect their clan leaders by acclamation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Tabletop Games]]
* ''TabletopGame/{{Pathfinder}}'': There are relatively few nonhuman-ruled nations on Golarion, and none are democracies. Elven Kyonin and the dwarven city-states in the Five Kings Mountains and elsewhere are monarchies (with the dwarf kings forming a larger alliance), while the orc lands of the Hold of Belkzen are an amorphous association of tribes that run on AsskickingEqualsAuthority. To be fair, however, there aren't many human democracies either, the only notable ones being Andoren (a staunchly anti-slavery parliamentary republic based on [[{{Eagleland}} an idealized vision of the United States]]), Galt ([[DemocracyIsFlawed effective mob rule]], inspired by [[UsefulNotes/TheFrenchRevolution France at the height of the Terror]]), and Nirmathas (loose confederation of woodland settlements).
[[/folder]]

Top