Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / AdaptationalIntelligence

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding an example

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:FanFiction]]
* Asami in ''TheSagaOfAvatarKorra'' portrays her as being more intelligent than in canon. While she is far from stupid in canon and is considered TheSmartGuy, her skills in science and business are much more pronounced in this story. She is a skilled inventor (in this continuity she is the inventor of the shock glove and not just its user) and she also holds a leading position in her father's company by the time she and Korra reunite.

Changed: 126

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The fourth season of ''Series/StarTrekEnterprise'' has the Orion women turn out to be the brains behind the Orion Syndicate.

to:

* The fourth season of ''Series/StarTrekEnterprise'' has the Orion women turn out to be the brains behind the Orion Syndicate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GirlsNeedRoleModels. Perhaps the original material only has one female character and she is firmly in TheChick category and might even come across as TheLoad or a BrainlessBeauty to modern audiences. As alternative to {{Xenafication}} she might be turned into the brains of the group instead (or she might go through both this trope and that one.)

to:

* GirlsNeedRoleModels. Perhaps the original material only has one female character and she is firmly in TheChick category and might even come across as TheLoad or a BrainlessBeauty to modern audiences. As alternative to {{Xenafication}} she might be turned into the brains of the group instead (or she might go through both this trope and that one.)one).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


When adapting an existing character for a new work the character is often altered in transition from the source material. They might become [[AdaptationalHeroism nicer]], [[AdaptationalVillainy nastier]], [[AdaptationalBadass more badass]] or [[AdaptationalWimp a lot less badbass]].

to:

When adapting an existing character for a new work the character is often altered in transition from the source material. They might become [[AdaptationalHeroism nicer]], [[AdaptationalVillainy nastier]], [[AdaptationalBadass more badass]] or [[AdaptationalWimp a lot less badbass]].
badass]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Dinobots from the ''Transformers Generation 1'' comics typically are portrayed as smarter and more cunning than their animated counterparts.

to:

* The Dinobots from the ''Transformers Generation 1'' ''TFranchise/TransformersGeneration1'' comics typically are portrayed as smarter and more cunning than their [[WesternAnimation/TheTransformers animated counterparts.counterparts]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:Anime & Manga]]
* Subverted with Misa Amane from ''Manga/DeathNote''. While she wasn't [[OvershadowedByAwesome the most intelligent person]] in the original manga, she did have a good head on her shoulders and was serious about her actions, knew simple, slightly dangerous yet effective plans on how to get what was needed, like in the Yotsuba Arc where [[spoiler: she goes off on her own to investigate Higuchi from the Yotsuba group and records his admission that he is the current Kira]] which played a big role in finishing up that arc. The anime altered her intelligence to the point of downplaying any big moments she had in the manga and even [[AdaptationPersonalityChange changed her personality]] to be more airheaded and up-played her {{Yandere}} traits towards Light, making her a typical TheDitz character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the 2000 ''Literature/{{Dune}}'' mini-series, Irulan is far more clever than she is in the books (in which she's still fairly intelligent - she becomes a respected historian, after all - but otherwise just a typical princess.) In the mini-series, she quickly figures out that her father aided House Harkonnen in its violent overthrow of House Atreides, and actively works to spy on the Harkonnens by sending one of her servants to seduce Feyd.

to:

* In the 2000 ''Literature/{{Dune}}'' ''Series/{{Dune}}'' mini-series, Irulan is far more clever than she is in the books (in which she's still fairly intelligent - she becomes a respected historian, after all - but otherwise just a typical princess.) In the mini-series, she quickly figures out that her father aided House Harkonnen in its violent overthrow of House Atreides, and actively works to spy on the Harkonnens by sending one of her servants to seduce Feyd.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even before that, ''StarTrekEnterprise'' showed them as the real power behind the Orion Syndicate, using the LivingAphrodisiac effect they have on male Orions to keep them in a ''permanent'' state of DistractedByTheSexy and doing what the woman want while nominally in charge. And even before ''that,'' the ''two'' Orion females we met in the ''original series'' were, in order, an ''illusion'' used to tempt Christopher Pike, and a criminally insane mental patient. Basing our idea of what Orion females are like purely on ''those'' two is probably not the best way to get a feel for Orion society.

to:

** Even before that, ''StarTrekEnterprise'' ''Series/StarTrekEnterprise'' showed them as the real power behind the Orion Syndicate, using the LivingAphrodisiac effect they have on male Orions to keep them in a ''permanent'' state of DistractedByTheSexy and doing what the woman want while nominally in charge. And even before ''that,'' the ''two'' Orion females we met in the ''original series'' were, in order, an ''illusion'' used to tempt Christopher Pike, and a criminally insane mental patient. Basing our idea of what Orion females are like purely on ''those'' two is probably not the best way to get a feel for Orion society.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The reboot movies also did a favor for Uhura. In ''Film/StarTrekVITheUndiscoveredCountry'', Uhura's attempt to speak Klingon came across as YouNoTakeCandle (which Nichelle Nichols was ''not'' pleased with). On the other hand, in ''Film/StarTrekIntoDarkness'', Uhura describes her Klingon as "rusty, but good," and then proceeds to speak fluent Klingon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the original ''Literature/WinnieThePooh'' books Kanga is just as stupid as the other residents of Hundred Acre Wood, but Disney's adaptations tend to make her smarter, acting as the TeamMom of the cast.

Added: 2156

Changed: 167

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/FantasticFour'' and its sequel Ben Grimm (also known as The Thing) is a lot smarter than his comic book counterpart (though even in the comic book [[DependingOnTheWriter some writers]] have explained that Ben employs ObfuscatingStupidity..) For example in ''Rise of the Silver Surfer'' he instantly deduces that a picture taken of ComicBook/SilverSurfer arriving in Earth's atmosphere isn't a comet because "the trail is wrong". This is quite apt considering that Ben, like the rest of the Four, is a trained astronaut.

to:

* In ''Film/FantasticFour'' and its sequel Ben Grimm (also known as The Thing) is a lot smarter than his comic book counterpart (though even in the comic book [[DependingOnTheWriter some writers]] have explained that Ben employs ObfuscatingStupidity..ObfuscatingStupidity.) For example in ''Rise of the Silver Surfer'' he instantly deduces that a picture taken of ComicBook/SilverSurfer arriving in Earth's atmosphere isn't a comet because "the trail is wrong". This is quite apt considering that Ben, like the rest of the Four, is a trained astronaut.astronaut.
**Basically, with Ben, it's this: it's established from the beginning that he's had a long, distinguished military career involving jobs and authority ''no'' idiot would have, ''was the one Reed got to pilot the ship during the space flight, which is why he was there,'' and also has multiple advanced degrees. However, he's got an appearance and accent that says DumbMuscle, and as TheSnarkKnight, if anyone's going to poke fun at Reed's SesquipedalianLoquaciousness, it's him, meaning he's the one repeatedly depicted as not understanding something. So those who know nothing of the character beyond "It's clobberin' time!" - a population that has sadly included a writer or two over the many years of the franchise - do not realize that he's actually a brilliant mind, occasionally resulting in adaptational/DependingOnTheWriter ''unintelligence,'' and a few surprised fans on the days we see how smart he is. He's just no Reed Richards (but who is?) even if it's shown that he ''actually'' understands most of Reed's TechnoBabble ''just fine,'' and if a supervillain shows up and starts smashing things and you happen to be ''ridiculously strong,'' well, what is the most logical course of action? IT'S CLOBBERIN' TIME!



**Even before that, ''StarTrekEnterprise'' showed them as the real power behind the Orion Syndicate, using the LivingAphrodisiac effect they have on male Orions to keep them in a ''permanent'' state of DistractedByTheSexy and doing what the woman want while nominally in charge. And even before ''that,'' the ''two'' Orion females we met in the ''original series'' were, in order, an ''illusion'' used to tempt Christopher Pike, and a criminally insane mental patient. Basing our idea of what Orion females are like purely on ''those'' two is probably not the best way to get a feel for Orion society.



* Inverted big time with Bane in ''Film/BatmanAndRobin''. Whereas the comics Bane was smart enough to come up with a plan to beat Batman, the movie Bane was barely speak, only engaging in HulkSpeak and saying one or two words at most when he does.

to:

* Inverted big time with Bane in ''Film/BatmanAndRobin''. Whereas the comics Bane was smart enough to come up with a plan to beat Batman, the movie Bane was barely speak, only engaging in HulkSpeak and saying one or two words at most when he does.
does. Turning the GeniusBruiser into barely sentient DumbMuscle is one of the many, many reasons why fans would rather [[DisContinuity pretend that movie never happened]].


Added DiffLines:

**By at least the third season, she's definitely graduated to Sherlock's apprentice, no longer just tagging along. Holmes even once sent her to get his dry cleaning, never even hinting that something was amiss at the place he sent her to, knowing she'd be able to work out what was really going on there. With ''no'' help, she did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Susan Storm, who in the comics got to fly into space via being Reed's girlfriend, is a scientist in this version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Inverted big time with Bane in ''Film/BatmanAndRobin''. Whereas the comics Bane was smart enough to come up with a plan to beat Batman, the movie Bane was barely speak, only engaging in HulkSpeak and saying one or two words at most when he does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Joan Watson in ''Series/{{Elementary}}''. Watson in the Doyle stories was competent enough, but as a normal person working with Literature/SherlockHolmes, he frequently found himself OvershadowedByAwesome. In ''Elementary'' Joan shows above-average observational skills from the start, and she becomes a competent detective in her own right over the course of the series.

to:

* Joan Watson in ''Series/{{Elementary}}''. Watson in the Doyle stories was competent enough, but as a normal person working with Literature/SherlockHolmes, he frequently found himself OvershadowedByAwesome. In ''Elementary'' Joan shows above-average observational skills from the start, and she becomes a competent detective in her own right over the course of the series. Probably to the point where she doesn't need Sherlock's help.

Changed: 187

Removed: 165

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This also occurred in the fourth season of the prequel series StarTrekEnterprise, in which the Orion women turned out to be the brains behind the Orion Syndicate.



* The [[Series/TheWalkingDead TV adaptation]] of ''ComicBook/TheWalkingDead'' made The Governor a DangerouslyGenreSavvy ManipulativeBastard who knows how to [[AffablyEvil charm his way through people]]. It helps that he also underwent AdaptationalAttractiveness.

to:

* The [[Series/TheWalkingDead TV adaptation]] of ''ComicBook/TheWalkingDead'' made The ''Series/TheWalkingDead'', the Governor is a DangerouslyGenreSavvy ManipulativeBastard who knows how to [[AffablyEvil charm his way through people]]. It helps that he also underwent AdaptationalAttractiveness.
* The fourth season of ''Series/StarTrekEnterprise'' has the Orion women turn out to be the brains behind the Orion Syndicate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Joan Watson in ''Series/{{Elementary}}''. Watson in the Doyle stories was competent enough, but as a normal person working with Literature/SherlockHolmes, he frequently found himself OvershadowedByAwesome. In ''Elementary'' Joan shows above-average observational skills from the start, and she becomes a competent detective in her own right over the course of the series. Which doesn't make any sense, in a way, since they're supposed to be partners.

to:

* Joan Watson in ''Series/{{Elementary}}''. Watson in the Doyle stories was competent enough, but as a normal person working with Literature/SherlockHolmes, he frequently found himself OvershadowedByAwesome. In ''Elementary'' Joan shows above-average observational skills from the start, and she becomes a competent detective in her own right over the course of the series. Which doesn't make any sense, in a way, since they're supposed to be partners.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Joan Watson in ''Series/{{Elementary}}''. Watson in the Doyle stories was competent enough, but as a normal person working with Literature/SherlockHolmes, he frequently found himself OvershadowedByAwesome. In ''Elementary'' Joan shows above-average observational skills from the start, and she becomes a competent detective in her own right over the course of the series.

to:

* Joan Watson in ''Series/{{Elementary}}''. Watson in the Doyle stories was competent enough, but as a normal person working with Literature/SherlockHolmes, he frequently found himself OvershadowedByAwesome. In ''Elementary'' Joan shows above-average observational skills from the start, and she becomes a competent detective in her own right over the course of the series. Which doesn't make any sense, in a way, since they're supposed to be partners.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Joan Watson in ''Series/{{Elementary}}''. Watson in the Doyle stories was competent enough, but as a normal person working with SherlockHolmes, he frequently found himself OvershadowedByAwesome. In ''Elementary'' Joan shows above-average observational skills from the start, and she becomes a competent detective in her own right over the course of the series.

to:

* Joan Watson in ''Series/{{Elementary}}''. Watson in the Doyle stories was competent enough, but as a normal person working with SherlockHolmes, Literature/SherlockHolmes, he frequently found himself OvershadowedByAwesome. In ''Elementary'' Joan shows above-average observational skills from the start, and she becomes a competent detective in her own right over the course of the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''WesternAnimation/SpiderManTheAnimatedSeries'', Debra Whitman went from a ShrinkingViolet in the comics to an intellectual rival to Peter Parker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[ComicBook/{{Deathstroke}} Slade]] from ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans'' is by no mean stupid in the comics, but he is more of a HiredGun and mercenary more comfortable on the field, and while he can be good at manipulation, there are plenty villains more competent than him. In the Teen Titans cartoon, he is portrayed as a criminal mastermind and the show's biggest MagnificentBastard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:Comic Book]]
* The Dinobots from the ''Transformers Generation 1'' comics typically are portrayed as smarter and more cunning than their animated counterparts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the original ''Disney/SleepingBeauty'', it took [[EvilSorceress Maleficent]] sixteen years to find Aurora, because she was relying on her grunts. In [[Film/{{Maleficent}} her own movie]], it takes her about a day, because she sends out [[TheDragon Diaval]] instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ValuesDissonance. The character was originally an EthnicScrappy ComicRelief and their stupidity wouldn't fly for modern audiences.

to:

* ValuesDissonance. The character was originally an EthnicScrappy ComicRelief PluckyComicRelief and their stupidity wouldn't fly for modern audiences.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* in ''Film/CaptainAmerica'', ComicBook/RedSkull is upgraded to the head of the Nazi science division; the comics version is no fool, but he's certainly not a brilliant scientist on his own.

to:

* in ''Film/CaptainAmerica'', ''Film/CaptainAmericaTheFirstAvenger'', ComicBook/RedSkull is upgraded to the head of the Nazi science division; the comics version is no fool, but he's certainly not a brilliant scientist on his own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This also occurred in the fourth season of the prequel series StarTrekEnterprise, in which the Orion women turned out to be the brains behind the Orion Syndicate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The [[Series/TheWalkingDead TV adaptation]] of ''ComicBook/TheWalkingDead'' made The Governor a DangerouslyGenreSavvy ManipulativeBastard who knows how to [[AffablyEvil charm his way through people]]. It helps that he also underwent AdaptationalAttractiveness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That\'s really more Depending On The Writer.


[[AC: ComicBooks]]
* Wolverine: sometimes he's a crafty combatant, sometimes he's a dumb berserker badass.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC: ComicBooks]]
* Wolverine: sometimes he's a crafty combatant, sometimes he's a dumb berserker badass.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

When adapting an existing character for a new work the character is often altered in transition from the source material. They might become [[AdaptationalHeroism nicer]], [[AdaptationalVillainy nastier]], [[AdaptationalBadass more badass]] or [[AdaptationalWimp a lot less badbass]].

Or they might become smarter. This trope is about taking a character who wasn't ''particularly'' smart in the source material and might even have been TheDitz and turning them into TheSmartGuy.

There are several reasons why a character might gain IQ points in an adaptation. Some reasons include:

* The adapted character is actually a CompositeCharacter - Bob might have been BookDumb in the original novel but he was given traits from InsufferableGenius Steve for the movie.
* A more serious take might turn an IneffectualSympatheticVillain into a serious threat.
* ValuesDissonance. The character was originally an EthnicScrappy ComicRelief and their stupidity wouldn't fly for modern audiences.
* GirlsNeedRoleModels. Perhaps the original material only has one female character and she is firmly in TheChick category and might even come across as TheLoad or a BrainlessBeauty to modern audiences. As alternative to {{Xenafication}} she might be turned into the brains of the group instead (or she might go through both this trope and that one.)
* Rarely, a comedy might turn a character previously portrayed as TheDitz into a genius for the sake of a joke.

See also AdaptationPersonalityChange, AdaptationalComicRelief, AdaptationalHeroism, AdaptationalVillainy , AdaptationalBadass, AdaptationalWimp and {{Xenafication}}.

Compare and contrast DumbassNoMore where a character increases their intellect inside the particular work.

----

!!Examples

[[AC:AnimatedFilm]]
* The Disney version of ''Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame'' makes Esmerelda smarter than she is in the book. In the book, she's very naive and in the film, she's more savvy.

[[AC:LiveActionFilm]]
* Most modern adaptations of Creator/RoaldDahl's ''Literature/CharlieAndTheChocolateFactory'' turn Mike Teavee into an InsufferableGenius. He did have a few JerkassHasAPoint moments in the book but was mostly just an excitable TV obsessed little kid. In both the 2005 film and the West End musical adaptation he has been depicted as a jaded computer hacker.
* ''Film/GetSmart''
** In the TV series ''Series/GetSmart'' Max was a general purpose bungling idiot who only succeeds by [[TheFool luck]] and Agent 99's competence. In the film he's genuinely a clever guy and a ''great'' analyst, just a klutz who isn't well suited to field work. This was apparently done to make a romantic relationship with 99 more believable as modern audience would not accept someone as buffoonish as the original Max being attractive to a woman as capable as 99.
** Larrabee in the original series is even more of a dunce than Max (he has been referred to as "Max's Max"), whereas in the film he's a jerkass but competent agent.
* In ''Film/FantasticFour'' and its sequel Ben Grimm (also known as The Thing) is a lot smarter than his comic book counterpart (though even in the comic book [[DependingOnTheWriter some writers]] have explained that Ben employs ObfuscatingStupidity..) For example in ''Rise of the Silver Surfer'' he instantly deduces that a picture taken of ComicBook/SilverSurfer arriving in Earth's atmosphere isn't a comet because "the trail is wrong". This is quite apt considering that Ben, like the rest of the Four, is a trained astronaut.
* In ''Film/JurassicPark'' Lex is made older than she was in the book and given knowledge of computer systems. Contrasting, her brother Tim was made younger and loses the computer systems scene, but maintains his knowledge of dinosaurs.
* The Creator/SteveMartin reboot of ''Film/ThePinkPanther'' is predicated on the idea that [[spoiler: Clouseau is to some degree employing ObfuscatingStupidity]], quite unlike the book character or previous versions in film.
* in ''Film/CaptainAmerica'', ComicBook/RedSkull is upgraded to the head of the Nazi science division; the comics version is no fool, but he's certainly not a brilliant scientist on his own.
* In their brief appearance in ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries'' [[GreenskinnedSpaceBabe Orion women]] are presented as mindless nymphomaniacs. Dialogue from the [[Recap/StarTrekS1E0TheCage original pilot]] even explicitly compares them to ''animals'', suggesting they might not even be fully sapient. The [[Film/StarTrek 2009 reboot film]] gave us a sympathetic and obviously fully intelligent Orion woman as a supporting character whom writer and producer Roberto Orci theorised had escaped to the the Federation via an underground railroad.
* While Gwen Stacy has always been smart in the comics ''Film/TheAmazingSpiderMan2'' raises her to being an outright brilliant, as smart or perhaps even smarter than TeenGenius Peter Parker himself.
* In the ''Film/XMen'' movie series, Jean Grey was turned into a doctor. Originally, they were going to include Beast as the resident smart guy of the team but when he was removed from the final film, they gave the job to Jean Grey.

[[AC:LiveActionTelevision]]
* In the original film version of ''Film/BuffyTheVampireSlayer'' Buffy started as a BrainlessBeauty who turned out to have HiddenDepths and went through some serious CharacterDevelopment, leaving her pretty smart by the end of the movie. Not nearly as smart as she was in the First Season of the [[Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer television show]] however. TV Buffy, especially in the first few episodes was whip smart, extremely perceptive, a better researcher than Giles and explicitly singled out as having a first class mind by one of her teachers. In fact her brilliance was subtly downplayed in the Second Season to make Giles look less useless.
* In ''{{Series/Arrow}}'', Malcolm Merlyn is a clever schemer with shades of CorruptCorporateExecutive; in the comics, Merlyn is merely a ProfessionalKiller with archery skills that rival those of Character/GreenArrow.
** Similarly, Solomon Grundy goes from the HulkSpeak zombie of the comics to a much more articulate PsychoForHire with regenerative powers thanks to PragmaticAdaptation.
** The Clock King goes from the doofy version of the comics to a skilled hacker and computer expert.
* In the 2000 ''Literature/{{Dune}}'' mini-series, Irulan is far more clever than she is in the books (in which she's still fairly intelligent - she becomes a respected historian, after all - but otherwise just a typical princess.) In the mini-series, she quickly figures out that her father aided House Harkonnen in its violent overthrow of House Atreides, and actively works to spy on the Harkonnens by sending one of her servants to seduce Feyd.
* The 2013 ''Series/{{Dracula}}'' television series upgraded Mina Harker from a reasonably smart school teacher to a brilliant, ahead of time medical student.
* Joan Watson in ''Series/{{Elementary}}''. Watson in the Doyle stories was competent enough, but as a normal person working with SherlockHolmes, he frequently found himself OvershadowedByAwesome. In ''Elementary'' Joan shows above-average observational skills from the start, and she becomes a competent detective in her own right over the course of the series.

[[AC:WesternAnimation]]
* In ''WesternAnimation/BatmanTheAnimatedSeries'', several villains receive intelligence upgrades:
** The Riddler is reinvented as a technological genius, capable of creating advanced virtual reality devices and inventing best-selling, sophisticated toys. He even manages to accomplish all of his goals in his first appearance and get away scott free!
** The aforementioned Clock King becomes [[ClockKing a true example of the trope that bears his name]], and, like the Riddler, is one of the few villains to escape Batman in their first encounter.
** Inverted with the show's take on Hugo Strange, however, who is far less clever as a manipulator or as an inventor than his PsychoPsychologist and MadScientist comics counterpart.

Top