Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TwoMinuteMysteries

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "The Case of the Death at Sunrise" treats Nick the Nose's eyewitness testimony that a murder had taken place as false because his window shade was down when the police came -- ignoring the fact that, ''having witnessed a murder'', Nick would probably have drawn the shade in the heat of the moment, either out of disgust or fear at being spotted by the killer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* SuspiciouslyPrescientPlanning: A violin teacher has planned to have one of his prize students debut at a concert but doesn't decide which until shortly before the start. Soon thereafter, the chosen student turns up dead. Haledjian deduces that the other student was the killer because he had rosined his bow. [[ConvictionByCounterfactualClue Readers have noted that this doesn't actually work as an explanation]]--since both students had an equal chance of being selected, they'd naturally ''have'' to be ready to go on at a moment's notice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A downplayed example in "The Case of the Poisoned Mice": Haledjian realizes that a mouse breeder's assistant is accidentally killing the prize mice by feeding them cheese, which "overheats their blood". Bizarre euphemism for dehydration / illness aside, cheese also isn't healthy for mice as a meal or treat because it's mostly empty calories to them; Freddie's mice would've been getting extremely overweight and unfit for mouse shows or stud breeding, and Reeves' incompetence would've been easily spotted before Haledjian investigated.

to:

** A downplayed example in "The Case of the Poisoned Mice": Mice". Haledjian realizes that a mouse breeder's assistant is accidentally killing the prize mice by feeding them cheese, which "overheats their blood". Bizarre blood"; bizarre euphemism for dehydration / illness aside, cheese also isn't healthy for mice as a meal or treat because it's mostly empty calories to them; them and can't be properly digested. Even if Freddie's mice hadn't exhibited diarrhea, nausea, and erratic behavior, they would've been getting extremely overweight and unfit for mouse shows or stud breeding, and Reeves' incompetence would've been easily spotted before Haledjian investigated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I know all three books pretty well, and AFAIK this case doesn't exist. If you can confirm its existence, feel free to put it back.


** In one of the Two-Minute Mysteries, the suspect was caught after Haledjian said the (diamond?) was hidden in the cupola because the murderer was the only one who ran up towards the attic instead of to the kitchen. Because only a murderer could know that a cupola (usually "KOOP-ul'uh", but the pronunciation varies by person enough that "kupp-ola" wouldn't be suspicious) was a term for the little domed thing on top of the house and not just an annoying term for a cappuccino maker, that only someone who had killed the house's occupant would assume that the stairs going up lead to the roof level, and that it's impossible to see a cupola from outside the house.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GrandeDame: Mrs. Sydney is variously described as the wealthiest woman in New York, reputed to own over 8% of the city and "more of Manhattan Island than anyone save the Indians", and a dowager at the top of society circles who throws lavish and illustrious parties. Her motivations for presenting false mysteries aren't just mischief and intellectual curiosity, but also because tricking the great Dr. Haledjian is something money can't buy, and she can't resist matching wits with him.[[note]]While her age is never brought up, her status, her behavior, and the scenario she lays out in "The Case of the False Brother" -- having a 'childhood playmate' who died some time ago at 65 -- all suggest she's pretty old.[[/note]]

to:

* GrandeDame: Mrs. Sydney is variously described as the wealthiest woman in New York, reputed to own over 8% of the city and "more of Manhattan Island than anyone save the Indians", and a dowager at the top of society circles who throws lavish and illustrious parties. Her motivations for presenting false mysteries aren't just mischief and intellectual curiosity, but also because tricking the great Dr. Haledjian is something money can't buy, and she can't resist matching wits with him.[[note]]While her age is never brought up, her status, her behavior, and the scenario she lays out in "The Case of the False Unknown Brother" -- having a 'childhood playmate' who died some time ago at 65 -- all suggest she's pretty old.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A downplayed example in "The Case of the Poisoned Mice": Haledjian realizes that a mouse breeder's assistant is accidentally killing the prize mice by feeding them cheese, which "overheats their blood". Bizarre euphemism for dehydration / illness aside, cheese also isn't healthy for mice as a meal or treat because it's mostly empty calories to them; Freddie's mice would've been getting extremely overweight and unfit for mouse shows or stud breeding, and Reeves' incompetence would've been easily spotted before Haledjian investigated.


Added DiffLines:

* NeverSuicide: If a body is ever discovered in circumstances that so much as suggest the person killed themselves, you can bet that they didn't. Even "The Case of the Suicide Room", about a mysterious bottomless room in a Welsh castle that has developed a legend about a curse that makes young men jump to their deaths there, doesn't feature a genuine suicide.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GrandeDame: Mrs. Sydney is variously described as the wealthiest woman in New York, reputed to own over 8% of the city and "more of Manhattan Island than anyone save the Indians", and a dowager at the top of society circles who throws lavish and illustrious parties. Her motivations for presenting false mysteries aren't just mischief and intellectual curiosity, but also because tricking the great Dr. Haledjian is something money can't buy, and she can't resist matching wits with him.[[note]]While her age is never brought up, her status, her behavior, and the scenario she lays out in "The Case of the False Brother" -- having a 'childhood playmate' who died some time ago at 65 -- all suggest she's pretty old.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SnakeOilSalesman: "The Case of the Indian Trader" has a tour guide recount the story of Doc Henry, who sold his wares "only to them Injuns", supposedly confessed on his deathbed that his elixir was nothing but sugar water, and bartered his wares in exchange for a young woman's life after she was kidnapped by a drunk war party. Based on how Doc's bottles didn't break after "five days of sub-freezin' weather", Haledjian notes that he was probably selling them hard alcohol and [[TheNativesAreRestlessTonight was the reason they were getting drunk in the first place]].

to:

* SnakeOilSalesman: "The Case of the Indian Trader" has a tour guide recount the story of Doc Henry, who sold his wares "only to them Injuns", supposedly confessed on his deathbed that his elixir was nothing but sugar water, and bartered his wares in exchange for a young woman's life after she was kidnapped by a drunk war party. Based on how Doc's bottles didn't break after "five days of sub-freezin' weather", Haledjian notes that he was probably selling them hard alcohol and [[TheNativesAreRestlessTonight [[TheNativesAreRestless was the reason they were getting drunk in the first place]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LaboriousLaziness: Bertie Tilford is almost always mentioned as hating work and avoiding it at every opportunity, but the lengths he seems to go to just to pursue promises of easy money shows that he's certainly not opposed to ''effort''.


Added DiffLines:

* SnakeOilSalesman: "The Case of the Indian Trader" has a tour guide recount the story of Doc Henry, who sold his wares "only to them Injuns", supposedly confessed on his deathbed that his elixir was nothing but sugar water, and bartered his wares in exchange for a young woman's life after she was kidnapped by a drunk war party. Based on how Doc's bottles didn't break after "five days of sub-freezin' weather", Haledjian notes that he was probably selling them hard alcohol and [[TheNativesAreRestlessTonight was the reason they were getting drunk in the first place]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* YouNoTakeCandle: The hermit in "The Case of the Footprint" grunts "no kill man" while being held on suspicion of murder. Bizarrely, he is confirmed to have periodic human contact in spite of talking like this, as he not only earns a subsistence hunting and fishing, but recently bought a new pair of shoes.

Top