Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / Timeline191

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS cleanup


* StuffedIntoTheFridge: Sylvia Enos does ''not'' have a happy ending, to put it mildly. Anne Colleton's ending is even more [[BodyHorror gruesome]] but also marks decisively the end of her KarmaHoudini status.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlackAndGreyMorality: The Confederates may be an analog for Nazi Germany, but calling the United States the "heroes" in this series would greatly stretch the definition. To cite just two examples, the revelation of the Confederate concentration camps is largely met with indifference because the Union doesn't care too much for blacks themselves, and after the war thousands of Floridian civilians are rounded up and executed in retaliation for an attack on a Naval vessel.

to:

* BlackAndGreyMorality: The Confederates may be As in real life, the Confederacy forms in order to keep slavery alive. Even after giving up slavery they maintain an oppressive apartheid system, and ultimately become an analog for Nazi Germany, but calling Germany. But the United States is similarly militaristic and brutal, and only marginally less racist (several black characters in the "heroes" in this series would greatly stretch the definition. To cite just two examples, the revelation of the Confederate concentration camps is largely met with indifference because the Union doesn't care too CSA muse that they wouldn't be much for blacks themselves, better off in the USA). They also embrace horrifying tactics during the wars (including arresting and after the war thousands of Floridian executing random civilians are rounded up and executed in retaliation for an attack on a Naval vessel.response to guerilla attacks).
Tabs MOD

Changed: 21

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The CSA has the "[[UnfortunateNames Mule]]" dive bomber (a.k.a. "[[AwesomeMcCoolName The Asskicker]]"), a [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuka Ju-87 Stuka]] with the serial numbers filed off.

to:

** The CSA has the "[[UnfortunateNames Mule]]" "Mule" dive bomber (a.k.a. "[[AwesomeMcCoolName The Asskicker]]"), a [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuka Ju-87 Stuka]] with the serial numbers filed off.

Changed: 262

Removed: 513

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* NotSoDifferent:
** Stonewall Jackson invites Frederick Douglass to eat with him in his tent after Douglass is taken prisoner by Confederate soldiers. They both expect the other to be the personification of evil, but are surprised to find that they have some things in common.
** Also from ''How Few Remain'', General Custer's constant mockery of the Mormons' polygamy while occupying Salt Lake City looks more hypocritical when he conducts an affair with a local woman that is nipped in the bud when his wife arrives unexpectedly.

to:

* NotSoDifferent:
**
NotSoDifferentRemark: Stonewall Jackson invites Frederick Douglass to eat with him in his tent after Douglass is taken prisoner by Confederate soldiers. They both expect the other to be the personification of evil, but are surprised to find that they have some things in common.
** Also from ''How Few Remain'', General Custer's constant mockery of the Mormons' polygamy while occupying Salt Lake City looks more hypocritical when he conducts an affair with a local woman that is nipped in the bud when his wife arrives unexpectedly.
common.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WashingtonDCInvasion: The proximity of how close D.C. is to the Confederate border sees the city get rather quickly overrun by the Confederate offensive at the start of the Great War. It's not 1917 when the Confederacy is on the retreat that the U.S. reclaims it.
** It's actually because of fear of this trope that D.C. since the 1880s has only been the de facto capital of the U.S. (largely only used for Presidential inaugurations). The U.S. Federal government has setup shop in Philadelphia for the most part.

to:

* WashingtonDCInvasion: The proximity of how close D.C. is to the Confederate border sees the city get rather quickly overrun by the Confederate offensive at the start of the Great War. It's not until 1917 when the Confederacy is on the retreat that the U.S. reclaims it.
** It's actually because of fear of this trope that D.C. since the 1880s has only been the de facto ''de jure'' capital of the U.S. (largely only used for Presidential inaugurations). The U.S. Federal government has setup shop in Philadelphia for since then with the most part. President living out of the Powell House.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpiritualAntithesis: To Turtledove's ''TheGunsOfTheSouth''. Both series share the basic premise of a Confederate victory in the American Civil War but ''Guns of the South'' it was on account of time-travelers trying to MakeWrongWhatOnceWentRight while the series here has a far more mundane point of divergence with the Union never intercepting Lee's lost Special Order 191 dispatch. In addition, ''The Guns Of The South'' ends on a more hopeful note with the implication the United States and Confederacy will work more closely with one another along with better racial relations for blacks. While the whole series is a kickstart to an 80 year cycle of bitter war between the United States and Confederacy.
* SpiritualSuccessor: To ''Literature/TheGunsOfTheSouth''.

to:

* SpiritualAntithesis: To Turtledove's ''TheGunsOfTheSouth''. ''Literature/TheGunsOfTheSouth''. Both series share the basic premise of a Confederate victory in the American Civil War but ''Guns in ''The Guns of the South'' it was on account of time-travelers trying to MakeWrongWhatOnceWentRight while the series here has a far more mundane point of divergence with the Union never intercepting Lee's lost Special Order 191 dispatch. In addition, ''The Guns Of The South'' ends on a more hopeful note with the implication the United States and Confederacy will work more closely with one another along with better racial relations for blacks. While the whole series Tl-191 is a kickstart to an 80 year cycle of bitter and destructive war between the United States and Confederacy.
* SpiritualSuccessor: To [[Creator/HarryTurtledove Turtledove's]] own ''Literature/TheGunsOfTheSouth''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DarkestHour: ''Return Engagement'' and most of ''Drive to the East'' would be this for the U.S. during the Second Great War. Al Smith is killed in an air bombing by the Confederacy, the U.S. has been cut in two with the Confederacy overrunning Ohio, Irving Morrell has nearly been killed by an assassination attempt, and U.S. counter-offensives in Virgina against the Confederacy have completely failed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WashingtonDCInvasion: The proximity of how close D.C. is to the Confederate border sees the city get rather quickly overrun by the Confederate offensive at the start of the Great War. It's not 1917 when the Confederacy is on the retreat that the U.S. reclaims it.
** It's actually because of fear of this trope that D.C. since the 1880s has only been the de facto capital of the U.S. (largely only used for Presidential inaugurations). The U.S. Federal government has setup shop in Philadelphia for the most part.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmericaSavesTheDay: Downplayed example during the Second Great War portion of the series. The American and European Theaters are fairly separate from one another so when it comes to the North American theater it's "America Saves the Day" but in Europe it's "Germany saves the day".


Added DiffLines:

* FictionalPoliticalParty: Several notable ones in the both the Union and Confederacy:
** Overseeing the U.S.'s defeat in both the War of Secession and Second Mexican War causes the Republicans to be supplanted by the newly formed Socialist Party as the other big two party in U.S. politics. The Sodalists being a big tent mix of genuine radicals like Eugene Debs but also more standard progressive reformers like Al Smith.
** The main parties of the Confederacy are the Whigs and Radical Liberals. The Whigs are the dominant party (every C.S. President before Featherston was a Whig) and are composed of the aristocratic landholding elite of the Confederacy. Radical Liberalsm meanwhile are mainly a party based out of the Confederacy's western and Mexican territories and composed of reformers.
*** Then there's obviously Jake Featherston's Freedom Party.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmashTheSymbol: One of the two cities the U.S. drops it's first superbombs on is Charleston, South Carolina. Charleston being the capital of the first state to secede during the Civil War, as well as the state where the first shots were fired at Fort Sumter. Signaling the U.S.'s intention to end the Confederacy for good.

to:

* SmashTheSymbol: One of the two cities the U.S. drops it's first superbombs on is Charleston, South Carolina. Charleston being the capital symbolic birthplace of the Confederacy due it being located in South Carolina (the first state to secede during the Civil War, as well as the state secede) and where the first shots of the War of Secession were fired at Fort Sumter. Signaling Signalling the U.S.'s intention to end finally end the Confederacy for good. Confederacy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SmashTheSymbol: One of the two cities the U.S. drops it's first superbombs on is Charleston, South Carolina. Charleston being the capital of the first state to secede during the Civil War, as well as the state where the first shots were fired at Fort Sumter. Signaling the U.S.'s intention to end the Confederacy for good.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoKillLikeOverkill: [[spoiler: In response to Featherston having Clarence Potter dentate a superbomb in Philadelphia, the U.S. drops it's first superbomb on Newport News believing Jake Featherston was located there. Wiping out an entire city just to try and kill one person]].

to:

* NoKillLikeOverkill: [[spoiler: In response to Featherston having Clarence Potter dentate a superbomb in Philadelphia, the U.S. drops it's its first superbomb on Newport News believing Jake Featherston was located there. Wiping out an entire city just to try and kill one person]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoKillLikeOverkill: [[spoiler: In response to Featherston having Clarence Potter dentate a superbomb in Philadelphia, the U.S. drops it's first superbomb on Newport News believing Jake Featherston was located there. Wiping out an entire city just to try and kill one person]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnAesop:
** As obvious as the parallels between the Confederate Population Reduction and our world's Holocaust are, it does enable Turtledove to make some important points about how such atrocities happen, about the bureaucracy involved and how most real-world Nazis and war criminals were not {{Card Carrying Villain}}s that are easier and more palatable to digest in fictional form.
** Also: racism is bad. Period. And the South winning the Civil War would have been a bad thing, despite the cries of many Confederate diehards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SpiritualAntithesis: To Turtledove's ''TheGunsOfTheSouth''. Both series share the basic premise of a Confederate victory in the American Civil War but ''Guns of the South'' it was on account of time-travelers trying to MakeWrongWhatOnceWentRight while the series here has a far more mundane point of divergence with the Union never intercepting Lee's lost Special Order 191 dispatch. In addition, ''The Guns Of The South'' ends on a more hopeful note with the implication the United States and Confederacy will work more closely with one another along with better racial relations for blacks. While the whole series is a kickstart to an 80 year cycle of bitter war between the United States and Confederacy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TrojanAmbulance: CSA President [[PresidentEvil Jake Featherston]] travels in a vehicle marked with the Red Cross to avoid being shot at by USA forces.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:WW1's latest change.]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:WW1's latest change.[[caption-width-right:350:World War I is different.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/southern_victory.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:WW1's latest change.]]

Added: 196

Changed: 366

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IndustrializedEvil: The Confederacy under Featherston is industrial evil on the scale of Nazi Germany, using the most modern and efficient practises to exterminate the African-American populace.

to:

* IllegalReligion: The US government faces rebellions from the Mormons of Utah during every war they fight with the CSA, with the Union Army crushing the rebels each time. This mirrors the real-life conflicts of the Mormons with the USA, and UsefulNotes/TheTroubles. It's sparked by the federal government cracking down on their polygamy in 1881.
* IndustrializedEvil: The Confederacy under Featherston is industrial evil on the scale of Nazi Germany, using the most modern and efficient practises practices to exterminate the African-American populace.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SomebodySetUpUsTheBomb: [[spoiler:Clarence Potter]] uses stolen US military uniforms and vehicles to smuggle [[spoiler:the Confederacy's first (and only) nuclear bomb]] into Philadelphia (which is serving as the US capital). He sets ''two'' timers, just to be sure it goes off, and ends up [[spoiler:[[NukeEm destroying half the city]]]].

Added: 1129

Changed: 313

Removed: 452

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkassHasAPoint: At Jefferson Pinkard's trial, he offers no defence - not even "I was only Following Orders" - but points out that while his actions were horrific [[spoiler: instituting their version of the "Final Solution"]], the victorious North only cares about what the Confederates were doing ''because it was the Confederates who were doing it''. Given other comments from Northerners elsewhere, he clearly has a point (not that it saves him).



** Clarence Potter.

to:

** Clarence Potter. He [[spoiler:ran the Confederate intelligence agency through WWII, knew about the genocide and did nothing, and set off a nuclear bomb in Philadelphia]], and yet is allowed to peacefully retire at the end of the series.



** Don Partridge fills the same role as [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_D%C3%B6nitz Karl Donitz]], who signed Nazi Germany's unconditional surrender. His name, though, is a reference to UsefulNotes/DanQuayle, and he's just about as bland.



*** He's joined by two soldiers named Carl and Bob (obvious references to Carl Bernstein and Bob Woodward, who broke the Watergate scandal. However, the real Woodward and Bernstein were born in the 40s, so this is just for the sake of a joke.



** Union soldier Boris Lavochkin of ''In At The Death'' is a psycho. And there's always [[TheFundamentalist Gordon]] [[KillItWithFire McSweeney]].

to:

** Union soldier Boris Lavochkin of ''In At The Death'' is a psycho. And there's always [[TheFundamentalist Gordon]] [[KillItWithFire McSweeney]].McSweeney]], to the point that some fans anticipated him becoming the Hitler-analogue if the US lost WWI.


Added DiffLines:

* SomeoneToRememberHimBy: When Yossel Reisen dies in World War I, his fiancee Sophie names her unborn son after him. Yossel II grows up just in time to serve in World War II, though he survives.


Added DiffLines:

* VillainHasAPoint: At Jefferson Pinkard's trial, he offers no defence - not even "I was JustFollowingOrders" - but points out that while his actions were horrific [[spoiler: instituting their version of the "Final Solution"]], the victorious North only cares about what the Confederates were doing ''because it was the Confederates who were doing it''. Given other comments from Northerners elsewhere, he clearly has a point (not that it saves him).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
You mean to tell me that the book is 60% just that? No way, man. 10% is far more realistic.


** Sam Carsten has extremely fair skin, and burns easily - a bad trait for a sailor. As a result, he can often be seen slathering sunblock onto his skin, but it does little good - he still gets badly burnt. Forgotten all that? Don't worry, Sam will helpfully mention this ''every single time he makes an appearance''. Multiply this by [[LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters fifty other characters]], and soon enough a 200 page book becomes a 500 page book.

to:

** Sam Carsten has extremely fair skin, and burns easily - a bad trait for a sailor. As a result, he can often be seen slathering sunblock onto his skin, but it does little good - he still gets badly burnt. Forgotten all that? Don't worry, Sam will helpfully mention this ''every single time he makes an appearance''. Multiply this by [[LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters fifty other characters]], and soon enough a 200 450 page book becomes a 500 page book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed own incorrect entry


** Surfing pioneer [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duke_Kahanamoku Duke Kahanamoku]] puts in an appearance in US-occupied Hawaii during the First Great War and even shows off some of his moves [[spoiler: before he is arrested and executed as a British informant by the occupation government]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NamedAfterSomebodyFamous: Most African-Americans in the Confederacy are named either for Biblical figures or for historic [[AncientRome Romans]]. When friends from the U.S. ask Cincinnatus Driver why Confederate blacks have such fancy names, he theorizes that, being forbidden surnames, they want to pack as much meaning into their given names as they can.
** Several white characters were also named after famous figures, notably Jefferson Davis Pinkard, Armstrong Grimes, and Laura Secord.

Added: 476

Changed: 962

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlackAndGreyMorality: The USA isn't always a nice place to live, but the CSA is a Nazi hellhole by the end.

to:

* BittersweetEnding: As observed by reviewer Lionel Ward, the ending can only be considered happy in the sense that the Freedom Party was defeated. The United States is a much darker, less egalitarian, and less globally regarded nation than it was after the real World War II, and on top of that they're trying to control no less than three groups of former enemies (the Confederates, the Mormons, and the Canadians) while treating them with utter contempt, meaning the next rebellion is more a matter of "when" than "if". There's no United Nations in this universe, just a vague form of nuclear regulatory committee overseen by the US and Germany lording over the other nations, and there are plenty of international powers with the means and motives to start trouble in the future -- assuming the US doesn't do it themselves, such as trying to forcibly re-assimilate Texas (itself an independent nation at the end of the story) along with Chihuahua and Sonora (which Mexico more than likely wants back).
* BlackAndGreyMorality: The USA isn't always a nice place to live, but the CSA is a Confederates may be an analog for Nazi hellhole by Germany, but calling the end.United States the "heroes" in this series would greatly stretch the definition. To cite just two examples, the revelation of the Confederate concentration camps is largely met with indifference because the Union doesn't care too much for blacks themselves, and after the war thousands of Floridian civilians are rounded up and executed in retaliation for an attack on a Naval vessel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
'Gypsy' is now considered an ethnic slur; replaced with the proper name for the group


* SettingUpdate: ''Timeline-191'' is basically European history of the 19th and 20th century [-MOVED TO AMERICA !-] Featherston is Hitler, West Texas/Kentucky/Sequoyah suffers a fate identical to Austria/Sudetenland, [[SignificantAnagram Irwing Morrell]] is an American CaptainErsatz of Erwin Rommel and the Battle of Pittsburgh becomes the equivalent of our Battle of Stalingrad. Blacks, Mormons and Indians become the equivalent of Jews, Slavs, Gypsies and other nationalities that died in our world's Holocaust. It may not be particularly inspired, but it works well both as a story and as a HistoricalInJoke. The only real outliers are the fate of Canada, which is occupied by the United States at the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarI, and American politics, which are far too soft and democratic (albeit increasingly left-wing after UsefulNotes/WorldWarI) to make a meaningful parallel to the Soviet Union. Still, the Confederate invasion of the United States in 1941 strongly parallels, militarily, the German invasion of the Soviet Union, though the geography is ''tremendously'' compressed (Ohio and eastern Pennsylvania compared to the whole of Europe east of Warsaw) and the United States is somewhat more prepared.

to:

* SettingUpdate: ''Timeline-191'' is basically European history of the 19th and 20th century [-MOVED TO AMERICA !-] Featherston is Hitler, West Texas/Kentucky/Sequoyah suffers a fate identical to Austria/Sudetenland, [[SignificantAnagram Irwing Morrell]] is an American CaptainErsatz of Erwin Rommel and the Battle of Pittsburgh becomes the equivalent of our Battle of Stalingrad. Blacks, Mormons and Indians become the equivalent of Jews, Slavs, Gypsies Roma and other nationalities that died in our world's Holocaust. It may not be particularly inspired, but it works well both as a story and as a HistoricalInJoke. The only real outliers are the fate of Canada, which is occupied by the United States at the end of UsefulNotes/WorldWarI, and American politics, which are far too soft and democratic (albeit increasingly left-wing after UsefulNotes/WorldWarI) to make a meaningful parallel to the Soviet Union. Still, the Confederate invasion of the United States in 1941 strongly parallels, militarily, the German invasion of the Soviet Union, though the geography is ''tremendously'' compressed (Ohio and eastern Pennsylvania compared to the whole of Europe east of Warsaw) and the United States is somewhat more prepared.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Surfing pioneer [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duke_Kahanamoku Duke Kahanamoku]] puts in an appearance in US-occupied Hawaii during the First Great war and even shows off some of his moves [[spoiler: before he is arrested and executed as a British informant by the occupation government]].

to:

** Surfing pioneer [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duke_Kahanamoku Duke Kahanamoku]] puts in an appearance in US-occupied Hawaii during the First Great war War and even shows off some of his moves [[spoiler: before he is arrested and executed as a British informant by the occupation government]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Surfing pioneer [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duke_Kahanamoku Duke Kahanamoku]] puts in an appearance in US-occupied Hawaii during the First Great war and even shows off some of his moves [[spoiler: before he is arrested and executed as a British informant by the occupation government]].

Changed: 20

Removed: 875

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* BadassGrandpa:
** General Custer is a pretty poor general, to the point where some of his underlings consider him a PointyHairedBoss, but a scene where he foils an assassination attempt (on himself) by '''throwing a bomb back''' at the would-be assassin before it explodes shows why he managed to rise so high in the military hierarchy in the first place.
** Anyone who manages to survive the entire series from beginning to end certainly counts!
** Many are old enough, few are literal grandparents. Cincinnatus Driver literally is. Clarence Potter, Abner Dowling, and Sam Carsten are old enough and badass enough, but never had kids. Jonathan Moss is one of the most badass, but [[spoiler:his wife and daughter were killed by Mary Pomeroy's bomb]]. Irving Morrell and Flora Hamburger/[[spoiler:Blackford]] aren't yet but likely will be shortly after the end of the series.



* DoubleReverseQuadrupleAgent: Cincinnatus Driver, a lowly black truck driver in Kentucky, starts as an ActionSurvivor and ends up as a go-between for all sides (the USA, Confederates, and black Marxists) in the conflict during the First Great War, taking [[TookALevelInBadass several levels in badass]] in the process. He eventually becomes a US auxiliary ([[BadassGrandpa despite being in his fifties]]) during the Second Great War. The man even had ''Teddy Roosevelt order the head of the Kentucky State (read: secret) Police to release him and pay him $100 (in 1920) out of his own pocket'' at one point!

to:

* DoubleReverseQuadrupleAgent: Cincinnatus Driver, a lowly black truck driver in Kentucky, starts as an ActionSurvivor and ends up as a go-between for all sides (the USA, Confederates, and black Marxists) in the conflict during the First Great War, taking [[TookALevelInBadass several levels in badass]] in the process. He eventually becomes a US auxiliary ([[BadassGrandpa despite being in his fifties]]) fifties during the Second Great War. The man even had ''Teddy Roosevelt order the head of the Kentucky State (read: secret) Police to release him and pay him $100 (in 1920) out of his own pocket'' at one point!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Both versions of Calvin Coolidge died on the same date.


** UsefulNotes/CalvinCoolidge ran for President in 1928 and 1932, winning in the latter. He died before he could be inaugurated, and his running mate UsefulNotes/HerbertHoover became President.

to:

** UsefulNotes/CalvinCoolidge ran for President in 1928 and 1932, winning in the latter. He died before he could be inaugurated, inaugurated,[[note]]Both the TL-191 and OTL versions of Coolidge died on January 5, 1933.[[/note]] and his running mate UsefulNotes/HerbertHoover became President.

Top