Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheScienceOfDiscworld

Go To

OR

Added: 157

Changed: 3346

Removed: 164

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguouslyRelated: In the second and third books, the men who (badly) fill the historical roles of, respectively, Creator/WilliamShakespeare and UsefulNotes/CharlesDarwin (until the wizards fix things) are named Arthur J. Nightingale[[labelnote:*]] who still exists in the final timeline, but as an illiterate ploughman[[/labelnote]] and ''Preserved'' J. Nightingale[[labelnote:*]] short for Preserved-By-God; he was the sole survivor of a shipwreck as an infant and his adoptive parents were extremely religious[[/labelnote]]. It's not outright stated that they are members of the same Nightingale family (keep in mind that they would have lived about 300 years apart), but given the similar roles they play in the story, the implication is there.

to:

* AmbiguouslyRelated: In the second and third books, the men who (badly) fill the historical roles of, respectively, Creator/WilliamShakespeare and UsefulNotes/CharlesDarwin (until the wizards fix things) are named Arthur J. Nightingale[[labelnote:*]] Nightingale[[note]] who still exists in the final timeline, but as an illiterate ploughman[[/labelnote]] ploughman[[/note]] and ''Preserved'' J. Nightingale[[labelnote:*]] Nightingale[[note]] short for Preserved-By-God; he was the sole survivor of a shipwreck as an infant and his adoptive parents were extremely religious[[/labelnote]].religious[[/note]]. It's not outright stated that they are members of the same Nightingale family (keep in mind that they would have lived about 300 years apart), but given the similar roles they play in the story, the implication is there.



-->'''Elf Queen:''' Do you not think I could give you something better than a potato?
-->'''Rincewind:''' [[ComicallyMissingThePoint Are we talking about sour cream topping with chives?]]

to:

-->'''Elf --->'''Elf Queen:''' Do you not think I could give you something better than a potato?
-->'''Rincewind:'''
potato?\\
'''Rincewind:'''
[[ComicallyMissingThePoint Are we talking about sour cream topping with chives?]]



* DifferentWorldDifferentMovies: When they write that intelligence appears to be useful enough that it would probably still have arisen is some form if we hadn't appeared (the fiction parts show a number of civilisations getting a foothold on Roundworld in much earlier epochs, only to be wiped out by cataclysmic disasters) they speculate that if sentient crabs had evolved on the Earth in humans' place, three of them might be writing ''The Science of Dishworld'', about a bowl-shaped world that's carried on the backs of gigantic marine invertebrates.
** In-universe, the third book is about the wizards' attempts to ensure that Charles Darwin writes ''On The Origin Of Species'', not ''Theology Of Species''.

to:

* DifferentWorldDifferentMovies: DifferentWorldDifferentMovies:
**
When they write that intelligence appears to be useful enough that it would probably still have arisen is some form if we hadn't appeared (the fiction parts show a number of civilisations getting a foothold on Roundworld in much earlier epochs, only to be wiped out by cataclysmic disasters) they speculate that if sentient crabs had evolved on the Earth in humans' place, three of them might be writing ''The Science of Dishworld'', about a bowl-shaped world that's carried on the backs of gigantic marine invertebrates.
** In-universe, the third book is about the wizards' attempts to ensure that Charles Darwin writes ''On The the Origin Of of Species'', not ''Theology Of of Species''.



* {{Expy}}: Ratonasticthenes for Eratosthenes, and Antigonus for Archimedes.
* TheFairFolk: In volume 2.

to:

* %%* {{Expy}}: Ratonasticthenes for Eratosthenes, and Antigonus for Archimedes.
*
Archimedes.%%How?
%%*
TheFairFolk: In volume 2.



* ItWillNeverCatchOn: The wizards do this a lot, first claiming that planets are no place for life, that the sea is only place for a intelligent creature, that the primates will never amount to anything, and so on.
** Also, that the "terribly dull lizards" would never catch anyone's interest, such that any accounts of Roundworld prehistory will most likely skip over their era.

to:

* ItWillNeverCatchOn: The wizards do this a lot, first claiming that planets are no place for life, that the sea is only place for a an intelligent creature, that the primates will never amount to anything, and so on.
** Also,
that the "terribly dull lizards" would never catch anyone's interest, such that interest and any accounts of Roundworld prehistory will most likely skip over their era.era, and so on.



* {{Retcon}}: The first book uses 'splitting the thaum' as a magical equivalent of 'splitting the atom'. In previous books, thaums were just an arbitrary measurement of magic (and with the competing Prime system) rather than the smallest possible unit of magic. (This definition of the thaum first appeared in ''Literature/LordsAndLadies'', but buried in a footnote to an essay on the nature of magic. This is the first time it's actually been explored. Thaums also continue to be used as a measurement when one is needed. It's not even clear if it's the same thaum; it would be very UU to use the same word for two distinct concepts and just trust that everyone will know which one you mean.)
** This sub-series seems to suggest that not just the Discworld itself but the entire universe in which it resides runs on magical principles rather than the laws of physics, with stars described as tiny points of light and so on, whereas earlier books implied that normal stars and planets also existed alongside Great A'Tuin and a few other oddities like planets made from the corpses of giant dragons, with things like the TheoryOfNarrativeCausality and (barely) FunctionalMagic only existing inside the Disc's self-contained BackgroundMagicField.
*** Which seemingly gets retconned again in Book IV, which mentions they have indeed observed normal planets and stars passing by the Discworld. Blame quantum.

to:

* {{Retcon}}: {{Retcon}}:
**
The first book uses 'splitting the thaum' as a magical equivalent of 'splitting the atom'. In previous books, thaums were just an arbitrary measurement of magic (and with the competing Prime system) rather than the smallest possible unit of magic. (This definition of the thaum first appeared in ''Literature/LordsAndLadies'', but buried in a footnote to an essay on the nature of magic. This is the first time it's actually been explored. Thaums also continue to be used as a measurement when one is needed. It's not even clear if it's the same thaum; it would be very UU to use the same word for two distinct concepts and just trust that everyone will know which one you mean.)
** This sub-series The series seems to suggest that not just the Discworld itself but the entire universe in which it resides runs on magical principles rather than the laws of physics, with stars described as tiny points of light and so on, whereas earlier books implied imply that normal stars and planets also existed alongside Great A'Tuin and a few other oddities like planets made from the corpses of giant dragons, with things like the TheoryOfNarrativeCausality and (barely) FunctionalMagic only existing inside the Disc's self-contained BackgroundMagicField.
***
BackgroundMagicField. Which seemingly gets retconned again in Book IV, which mentions they have indeed observed normal planets and stars passing by the Discworld. Blame quantum.



* WelcomeToTheRealWorld

to:

* %%* WelcomeToTheRealWorld



* WretchedHive: Rincewind's opinion of 16th century London - like Ankh-Morpork, but ''worse''.

to:

* WretchedHive: Rincewind's opinion of 16th century London - -- like Ankh-Morpork, but ''worse''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* CowTools: It is mentioned that every University has a Very Big Thing, whose primary purpose is to be bigger and more impressive than the Very Big Thing owned by the school's rival University. UU's VBT is apparently a distinct item from Hex and the Roundworld, and only gets brought up in a budget meeting where the senior wizards are discussing if they need to make it even bigger to outdo Brazeneck University's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LiteraryWorkOfMagic:
** ''II: The Globe'': The wizards of Unseen University visit the "Roundworld" to fight off the elves as they disrupt ''Theatre/AMidsummerNightsDream''.
** ''SOD III: Darwin's Watch'': The wizards try to make sure that UsefulNotes/CharlesDarwin completes ''The Origin of Species''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AuthorityInNameOnly: Rincewind's promotion to Professor of Cruel and Unusual Geography is very much an excuse so the other wizards can dump him into Roundworld. The end of the book states that he's not allowed to teach or even get paid, but he can show up at meals, provided he eats very quietly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

->''"With magic you can turn a frog into a prince. With science you can turn a frog into a PHD and still have the frog you started with."''

Added: 1111

Removed: 217

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BewareTheNiceOnes: At one point in Book 2, all the wizards get duplicated due to time travel. Fixing this requires merging them, essentially killing at least one of the duplicates. Initially it seems like everyone is okay with this, only at the last second for them to turn on one another and try to punch themselves out (except the Rincewinds). The normally non-active Ponder is included in this.



* CreativeSterility: What mankind is like without the elves interfering. No drive, no ambition, no imagination. No ''humanity''.



* EverythingsBetterWithDinosaurs: The first book originally skipped over the thunder lizards when showing the development of life on Earth. A later edition went back and added a chapter because... well, ''dinosaurs''.


Added DiffLines:

* PlanetOfSteves: The "edge people" created by the wizards interfering are all called Ugg. Or at least, this is the closest they can be bothered to get to naming themselves.


Added DiffLines:

* RuleOfCool: The first book originally skipped over the thunder lizards when showing the development of life on Earth. A later edition went back and added a chapter because... well, ''dinosaurs''.


Added DiffLines:

* SeriesContinuityError: Book 2's brief appearance of Granny Weatherwax portrays her as innumerate, when prior appearances have had it that Granny is a ''demon'' with numbers. It's literacy she's got no truck with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Updated Try To Fit That On A Business Card entry with info from third book


* TryToFitThatOnABusinessCard: By the beginning of book 2, Rincewind has accumulated seven different titles (on the provision that he in no way act like this grants him any authority within the university whatsoever).

to:

* TryToFitThatOnABusinessCard: By the beginning of book 2, Rincewind has accumulated seven different titles (on the provision that he in no way act like this grants him any authority within the university whatsoever). By the beginning of book 3, this has grown to nineteen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* NotImportantToThisEpisodeCamp: The Bursar is absent in book 2, being off with his aunt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Which seemingly gets retconned again in Book IV, which mentions they have indeed observed normal planets and stars passing by the Discworld. Blame quantum.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The narration in chapter 2 of book 4 mentions the unlikelihood of someone [[VideoGame/CommanderKeen building a spaceship out of old bean tins]].

Changed: 129

Removed: 197

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MeasuringTheMarigolds: Averted in the science parts of the books.



-->This is why we can get the words of songs completely wrong and not realise it. The ''Guardian'' newspaper ran an amusing section on this habit, with examples such as 'kit-kat angel' for 'kick-ass angel' -- bit of a generation gap there, which underlines how our perceptions are biased by our expectations. Ian recalls an Annie Lennox song that really went 'a garden overgrown with trees', but always sounded like 'I'm getting overgrown with fleas'.
** Amusingly enough, ''[[SelfDemonstratingArticle he's still wrong]]''. The actual lyric is 'I'm thrown and overblown with bliss'.

to:

-->This is why we can get the words of songs completely wrong and not realise it. The ''Guardian'' newspaper ran an amusing section on this habit, with examples such as 'kit-kat angel' "kit-kat angel" for 'kick-ass angel' "kick-ass angel" -- bit of a generation gap there, which underlines how our perceptions are biased by our expectations. Ian recalls an Annie Lennox song that really went 'a "a garden overgrown with trees', trees", but always sounded like 'I'm "I'm getting overgrown with fleas'.
** Amusingly
fleas".[[note]]Amusingly enough, ''[[SelfDemonstratingArticle he's ''he's still wrong]]''. wrong''. The actual lyric is 'I'm "I'm thrown and overblown with bliss'.bliss".[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Mondegreen is no longer a trope; dewicking


* {{Mondegreen}}: Discussed in one of the science sections in the second book, when they bring up how our brains fill in the blanks in our sensory data by putting what we have seen and heard in a context.

to:

* {{Mondegreen}}: MondegreenGag: Discussed in one of the science sections in the second book, when they bring up how our brains fill in the blanks in our sensory data by putting what we have seen and heard in a context.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[caption-width-right:350:''An Experiment on a Parallel Universe with the Windbags.'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/81zqcl8ir_l.jpg]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In Book 4, Ridcully pulls the exact same gag on Vetinari that Ponder Stibbons did to him, having the Patrician ceremonially "activate" UU's latest MagiTek device despite the fact that they'd already turned it on earlier to make sure it would actually work.

to:

** In Book 4, Ridcully pulls the exact same gag on Vetinari that Ponder Stibbons did to him, him in the very first volume, having the Patrician ceremonially "activate" UU's latest MagiTek device despite the fact that they'd already turned it on earlier to make sure it would actually work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In Book 4, Ridcully pulls the exact same gag on Vetinari that Ponder Stibbons did to him, having the Patrician ceremonially "activate" UU's latest MagiTek device despite the fact that they'd already turned it on earlier to make sure it would actually work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HumansAreTheRealMonsters: On being defeated at the end of Book 3, the Auditors warn Charles Darwin and the Wizards that all they have done is created a timeline in which humanity will spread war and destruction across the entire galaxy. Darwin is a little disconcerted by this, but Ridcully's reaction, rather predictably, is essentially to shrug his shoulders and say "so what?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This sub-series seems to suggest that not just the Discworld itself but the entire universe in which it resides runs on magical principles rather than the laws of of physics, with stars described as tiny points of light and so on, whereas earlier books implied that normal stars and planets also existed alongside Great A'Tuin and a few other oddities like planets made from the corpses of giant dragons, with things like the TheoryOfNarrativeCausality and (barely) FunctionalMagic only existing inside the Disc's self-contained BackgroundMagicField.

to:

** This sub-series seems to suggest that not just the Discworld itself but the entire universe in which it resides runs on magical principles rather than the laws of of physics, with stars described as tiny points of light and so on, whereas earlier books implied that normal stars and planets also existed alongside Great A'Tuin and a few other oddities like planets made from the corpses of giant dragons, with things like the TheoryOfNarrativeCausality and (barely) FunctionalMagic only existing inside the Disc's self-contained BackgroundMagicField.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This sub-series seems to suggest that not just the Discworld itself but the entire universe in which it resides runs on magical principles rather than the laws of of physics, with stars described as tiny points of light and so on, whereas earlier books implied that normal stars and planets also existed alongside Great A'Tuin and a few other oddities like planets made from the corpses of giant dragons, with things like the TheoryOfNarrativeCausality and (barely) FunctionalMagic only existing inside the Disc's self-contained BackgroundMagicField.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShamuFu: In one timeline, Shakespeare is killed with a pike during a riot shortly after staging his first play. That is to say he was beaten to death by a fishmonger using his own wares, not impaled with a long medieval spear.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Rincewind's discussion about all the things you can make from [[TrademarkFavoriteFood potatoes]] with the Elf Queen in book 2 apes Bubba's similar discourse on shrimp with Film/ForestGump.

to:

** Rincewind's discussion about all the things you can make from [[TrademarkFavoriteFood potatoes]] with the Elf Queen in book 2 apes Bubba's similar discourse on shrimp with Film/ForestGump.Film/ForrestGump.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Rincewind's discussion about all the things you can make from [[TrademarkFavoriteFood potatoes]] with the Elf Queen in book 2 apes Bubba's similar discourse on shrimp with Film/ForestGump.

Added: 407

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The enchanted VR suit Rincewind uses to explore prehistoric Earth, described as a bulky thing that looks like it was made out of some kind of bones, is not at all dissimilar to the "Space Jockey"'s pilot suit from ''Film/{{Alien}}''. Funnily enough, the book was written over a decade before ''Film/{{Prometheus}}'', which reveals those creatures also visited early Earth and influenced its development.



** In book 3, the Dean re-enacts that scene from ''Film/DirtyHarry''. The Auditor he's against is smugly sure he's got no chocolate left... then Dead fills it full of nougat (and admits, actually, he ''wasn't'' sure he had any left).

to:

** In book 3, the Dean re-enacts that scene from ''Film/DirtyHarry''. The Auditor he's against is smugly sure he's got no chocolate left... then Dead Dean fills it full of nougat (and admits, actually, he ''wasn't'' sure he had any left).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OneIPreparedEarlier: In the first book, Ponder explains his planet-making methods using Roundworld rules, before presenting another planet he made earlier. This one turns out to be Earth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrickJoke: In Book 3, Ponder, when the topic of evolution rears its head, lives in dread of Ridicully trying to ask about the eye. Eventually, Ridicully does mention the eye, and Ponder yelps in alarm. Fortunately, he's not asking about it. He figures eyes are easy. Now, the ''wasp'', on the other hand.


Added DiffLines:

* INeedToGoIronMyDog: When Ridicully tries discussing the evolution of the wasp, Ponder declares he can hear the lunch bell going off, and he'd better go check it right now.

Added: 507

Changed: 523

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut: In book 3, the Dean re-enacts that scene from ''Film/DirtyHarry''. The Auditor he's against is smugly sure he's got no chocolate left... then Dead fills it full of nougat (and admits, actually, he ''wasn't'' sure he had any left).
** The Dean's proposed mile-high limpet, as the only life form on Earth to get anything like immortality, is identical to Leviathan - the oldest living creature on Earth in the ''Literature/{{Illuminatus}}'' trilogy, with a point-for-point correspondence in the description.

to:

* ShoutOut: ShoutOut:
** One of the rules Ponder deduces for how things work on Roundworld is "[[Literature/TheSecondComing Things fall apart, but centres hold]]."
** The Dean's proposed mile-high limpet, as the only life form on Earth to get anything like immortality, is identical to Leviathan - the oldest living creature on Earth in the ''Literature/{{Illuminatus}}'' trilogy, with a point-for-point correspondence in the description.
**
In book 3, the Dean re-enacts that scene from ''Film/DirtyHarry''. The Auditor he's against is smugly sure he's got no chocolate left... then Dead fills it full of nougat (and admits, actually, he ''wasn't'' sure he had any left).
** The Dean's proposed mile-high limpet, as the only life form on Earth to get anything like immortality, is identical to Leviathan - the oldest living creature on Earth in the ''Literature/{{Illuminatus}}'' trilogy, with a point-for-point correspondence in the description.
left).

Added: 1475

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One of first non-fiction chapters paraphrases Death's speech to Susan from the end of ''Hogfather'', noting you could grind the universe down to its component parts, and still not find a single atom of Science.



* EverythingsBetterWithDinosaurs: The first book originally skipped over the thunder lizards when showing the development of life on Earth. A later edition went back and added a chapter because... well, ''dinosaurs''.



* FamousFamousFictional: The beginning of the first book has a series of epigraphs, including Arthur C. Clarke, Mark Twain, and finally... Ponder Stibbons.



* NiceJobFixingItVillain: The Wizards nearly foil their plan in "The Globe" by teaching Shakespear "The Hedgehog Song". But the Queen of Elves, under the assumption that the Wizards are ''trying'' to stop Shakespear from writing ''Theatre/AMidsummerNightsDream'', using her powers to strip the song from William's mind.

to:

* NiceJobFixingItVillain: The Wizards nearly foil their plan in "The Globe" by teaching Shakespear Shakespeare "The Hedgehog Song". But the Queen of Elves, under the assumption that the Wizards are ''trying'' to stop Shakespear Shakespeare from writing ''Theatre/AMidsummerNightsDream'', using her powers to strip the song from William's mind.


Added DiffLines:

* RefugeInAudacity: In order to save Darwin, Rincewind has to be seen. In doing so, he dresses up in the most ridiculously over-the-top fashion, reasoning that Darwin won't tell anyone what he's seen, and that no-one will believe him if he does. Since history has never recorded of Darwin being saved by a wizzard dressed as a clown, it seems to work.


Added DiffLines:

* SkewedPriorities: Ridicully tells the Dean to stop playing on the squash court not because doing so (wizard squash being decidedly different from Roundworld squash, due to magic) is endangering everyone's life, but just because he feels wizards running around getting sweaty is unhygenic.


Added DiffLines:

* SophisticatedAsHell: The chapter in the first book explaining the premise of the non-fiction segments explains that it could have been like ''The Physics of X-Files'', trying to explain the logic of the setting, but that this would've been "dumb".

Top