Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheNakedSun

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NakedFirstImpression: Gladia receives Elijah's first viewing in the shower, causing him to do an abrupt about-face when she steps into full view.

to:

* NakedFirstImpression: Gladia receives Elijah's first viewing in the shower, causing him to do an abrupt about-face when she steps into full view. She's initially unphased because after all, it was just ''viewing''.



* NoodleIncident: Elijah mentions one case he was on where a murderer was caught only because he couldn't bring himself to break the custom of absolute silence in the communal restrooms.

to:

* NoodleIncident: When discussing whether or not a killer would be willing to violate Solaria's personal presence taboo in order to kill the victim, Elijah mentions one a case he was back on Earth where a murderer killer was caught only because he couldn't bring himself due to break his unwillingness to violate the custom of absolute silence in the communal community restrooms.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IntimateArtistry: When Gladia creates an abstract 'portrait' of Elijah Baley, she encloses it in a grey cube symbolic of the enclosing walls of Earth's Cities. Seeing himself so imprisoned, even metaphorically, gives Elijah extra impetus to face his agoraphobia and go outside with Gladia for a walk. [[spoiler:[[DeconstructedTrope Since Elijah really isn't ready to face the outside on even footing, he overexposes himself in the attempt to prove himself and winds up suffering a complete collapse.]] Since it was Gladia's art that motivated him, this is taken as compelling evidence that she is the murderer and tried to manipulate him into dying here.]]

Added: 2065

Changed: 1681

Removed: 642

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbsurdlyHugePopulation: Inverted, Daniel tells Baley that Solaria's population is only 20,000. This gets to the point that he initially believes that Daniel mispronounced, and what he really meant was 20 million.

to:

* AbsenceOfEvidence:
** The entire murder mystery revolves around the lack of a murder weapon found at the scene. Everybody agrees that only Gladia Delmarre could possibly have gotten close enough to kill the victim, but there was no murder weapon discovered with her and she had no time to remove it from the area or destroy it. This conundrum is what spurs Solaria to ask for outside help. [[spoiler:The murder weapon was the arm of the robot that was found at the scene, which was detachable and could be used as a club. Since everybody took for granted that the robot would not have been involved in the murder, nobody thought to inspect it for physical evidence on its body.]]
** Baley finds it frustrating that the nature of the robotic society on Solaria prevents the retention of any evidence. The robots are constantly performing routine cleaning, maintenance, and upkeep of the environment so all evidence is destroyed in the course of their normal duties. Despite the numerous attempted murders after Baley begins his investigation, he only manages to retain any evidence of the one he was personally the target of.
* AbsurdlyHugePopulation: Inverted, Daniel Daneel tells Baley that Solaria's population is only 20,000. This gets to the point is so minuscule that he Baley initially believes that Daniel Daneel mispronounced, and what he really meant was 20 million.million. When Daneel clarifies that he does mean 20,000 people, Baley realizes that Solaria is an outlier even among the other Spacer worlds.



* BeleagueredAssistant: Klorissa Cantoro to the victim. It wasn't so much that he was a MeanBoss (by Solarian standards, anyway) as it was that the job he selected her for involves some in-person contact with children which, like all Solarians, she hates.



* BureaucraticallyArrangedMarriage: Spouses on Solaria are assigned based on genetic compatibility, and the number of children they produce is mandated according to the planet's PopulationControl. It makes sense, considering it's only for reproduction, and most Solarians are so averse to physical contact that emotional compatibility wouldn't make much of a difference ([[spoiler: Gladia and Rikaine being a notable exception]]).

to:

* BureaucraticallyArrangedMarriage: Spouses on Solaria are assigned based on genetic compatibility, and the number of children they produce is mandated according to the planet's PopulationControl. It makes sense, considering it's only Marriages are solely intended for reproduction, and most Solarians are so averse to physical contact that emotional compatibility wouldn't make much of a difference ([[spoiler: Gladia and Rikaine being a notable exception]]).difference.



* CrapsaccharineWorld: Solaria is an approximately Earth-sized planet with a total population of 20 thousand spread out evenly and a robot-to-human ratio of ''10 thousand'' robots to each human. Every individual owns a huge estate, nearly any task they don't wish to do themselves is done by robots, and there are no real physical needs that are unfulfilled. The problem? The people are so isolated from each other, that two people being in the same room is considered {{Squick}}. It is further reinforced in the sequel, ''Literature/TheRobotsOfDawn'', where [[spoiler: Gladia says that she first experienced happiness when she arrived on Aurora, which itself is a more subtle kind of CrapsaccharineWorld.]] One Spacer in the sequel (admittedly, one who only has second-hand knowledge about Solaria) even states that he would rather live on Earth (which, for the pampered Spacers, is rather close to an outright CrapsackWorld).
* CultureClash: The culture of Solaria is so different from Earth that Baley is frequently flummoxed over the most simple of things. He reflects several times that he doesn't have the context to understand what people mean, and things that are commonplace to him are exotic or even ''repulsive'' to the Solarians.
* CyanidePill: After the SummationGathering, [[spoiler: Jothan Leebig]] is about to be arrested. [[spoiler: He]] is so afraid of "seeing" another human being that [[spoiler: he kills himself]] rather than meeting another human being face to face. The irony is that it was R. Daneel, a robot, who was going to make the arrest, only nobody on Solaria had realized that Daneel was not human.

to:

* CrapsaccharineWorld: Solaria is an approximately Earth-sized planet with a total population of 20 thousand spread out evenly and a robot-to-human ratio of ''10 thousand'' robots to each human. Every individual owns a huge estate, nearly any task they don't wish to do themselves is done by robots, and there are no real physical needs that are unfulfilled. The problem? The people are so isolated from each other, that two people being in the same room is considered {{Squick}}. It is further reinforced in the sequel, ''Literature/TheRobotsOfDawn'', where [[spoiler: Gladia says that she first experienced happiness when she arrived on Aurora, which itself is a more subtle kind of CrapsaccharineWorld.]] One Spacer in the sequel (admittedly, one who only Society has second-hand knowledge about Solaria) even states that he would rather live on Earth (which, stagnated, and Baley observes there is no longer any way for the pampered Spacers, is rather close Solarians to an outright CrapsackWorld).
save themselves from the gilded cage they created.
* CultureClash: CultureClash:
**
The culture of Solaria is so different from Earth that Baley is frequently flummoxed over the most simple of things. He reflects several times that he doesn't have the context to understand what people mean, and things that are commonplace to him are exotic or even ''repulsive'' to the Solarians.
** In a deliberate attempt to understand more about Solarian culture, Baley tries to read several Solarian novels. He gives up partway through, because he cannot even understand the fictional motivations and it all seems nonsense to him.
* CyanidePill: After the SummationGathering, SummationGathering where Baley [[BluffingTheMurderer lays out his accusations]], [[spoiler: Jothan Leebig]] is about to be arrested. [[spoiler: He]] is so afraid of "seeing" another human being that [[spoiler: he Leebig kills himself]] himself rather than meeting another human being face to face. experience the personal presence of seeing somebody face-to-face. The irony is that it was R. Daneel, a robot, who was going to make the arrest, only nobody on Solaria had realized that Daneel was not human.]]



* GoodGirlsAvoidAbortion: It is at one point revealed that the artificial gestation facility on Solaria is manually operated because robots would keep all the fetuses and embryos alive (including the imperfect ones). This, combined with the First Law Of Robotics (robots must never harm human beings) means that in the story embryos and fetuses are considered human beings by the robots.

Added: 1236

Removed: 548

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAllegedExpert: Solaria's sole sociologist, Dr. Quemont, is self-taught and can't bring himself to be in the same room as another human being (although, to be fair, the same is true of most Solarians). And if that's not bad enough, he's never even studied basic and valuable sociology principles developed on other planets. Considering the conditions on Solaria, this is not surprising, as there would be few social problems to exert pressure on Quemont, or anyone else, to develop sociology into anything an Earthman would recognize as robust.


Added DiffLines:

* TheAllegedExpert: Solaria's sole sociologist, Dr. Quemot, is self-taught and can't bring himself to be in the same room as another human being (although, to be fair, the same is true of most Solarians). And if that's not bad enough, he's never even studied basic and valuable sociology principles developed on other planets. Considering the conditions on Solaria, this is not surprising, as there would be few social problems to exert pressure on Quemot, or anyone else, to develop sociology into anything an Earthman would recognize as robust.
* AndThenWhat: Dr. Anselmo Quemot predicts that the Solarian societal model will eventually be adopted by every other planet, and decrees that once it happens human history will come to an end. There will no longer be any need for conflict between people, and everybody's cares will be taken care of. What people will '''do''' after this happens never seems to occur to him.


Added DiffLines:

* CultureClash: The culture of Solaria is so different from Earth that Baley is frequently flummoxed over the most simple of things. He reflects several times that he doesn't have the context to understand what people mean, and things that are commonplace to him are exotic or even ''repulsive'' to the Solarians.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SeparatedByACommonLanguage: One of the very first stumbling blocks that Baley runs into on Solaria is the different use of language that has emerged from their unique society. There is a critical distinction between the words "seeing" and "viewing", and some common words like "children" are considered vulgar and obscene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FoundTheKillerLostTheMurderer: Inverted. [[spoiler: Lije catches the murderer but deliberately lets the killer go free.]]

to:

* FoundTheKillerLostTheMurderer: Inverted. [[spoiler: [[DiscussedTrope Discussed]] when Gruer is first telling Baley about his suspicions for a conspiracy on Solaria. He is convinced like everybody else that Gladia must be the one who physically struck her husband to kill him, but he also recognizes that it is the unknown conspirators working through her who actually ''matter''. That's why he brought in an outside detective instead of just letting Gladia's obvious guilt be taken for granted. [[spoiler:It is ultimately [[InvertedTrope inverted]], as Lije catches the murderer but deliberately lets the killer go free.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NakedFirstImpression: Elijah's first "meeting" with Gladia.

to:

* NakedFirstImpression: Gladia receives Elijah's first "meeting" with Gladia.viewing in the shower, causing him to do an abrupt about-face when she steps into full view.

Added: 369

Changed: 37

Removed: 453

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ambiguous Disorder has been replaced by the YMMV trope Diagnosed By The Audience. Removing example because it doesn't


* AmbiguousDisorder: Johan Leebig is extremely anti-social, and voluntarily stopped all human contact when he was a small child. Of course, [[ValuesDissonance in Solaria]], that was considered a good thing and [[LamarckWasRight proof humans were evolving past gregariousness]]. [[spoiler: He dislikes human presence so strongly that he was ready to ''conquer the galaxy'' just so that Solaria and its taboo on personal presence would remain untouched.]]



* LonersAreFreaks: [[spoiler:Johan Leebig has been extremely antisocial since early childhood, even by Solarian standards. Ordinarily this would make him [[DeliberateValuesDissonance a model Solarian]], but he dislikes human company so strongly that he's ready to ''conquer the galaxy'' just so that Solaria and its taboo on personal presence would remain untouched.]]



* RaisedByRobots: It goes without saying that given their aversion to human contact the Solarians simply cannot bear to be around children and robots perform most child-rearing tasks. There still has to be at least one human chaperone to keep them in line, since robots aren't so great at providing discipline.

to:

* RaisedByRobots: It goes without saying that given Given their aversion to human contact contact, the Solarians simply cannot bear to be around children and children, so robots perform most child-rearing tasks. There still has to be at least one human chaperone to keep them in line, since robots aren't so great at providing discipline.

Added: 887

Changed: 694

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ThreeLawsCompliant: Naturally. There are no misprogrammed robots in this book. [[spoiler: However, there ''is'' an unspoken assumption built into the laws of robotics that becomes highly significant. Law One -- "A robot may not '''knowingly''' injure a human being or, through inaction, '''knowingly''' allow a human being to come to harm." Basically, a robot can be ordered to perform an innocuous task, individually harmless, which taken along with a number of other equally harmless tasks performed by other robots or people would result in serious harm or death to a human being. The murderer carries out all of his attacks through a set of careful orders to robots that get around the first law in this way.]]

to:

* ThreeLawsCompliant: ThreeLawsCompliant:
**
Naturally. There are no misprogrammed robots in this book. [[spoiler: However, there ''is'' an unspoken assumption built into the laws of robotics that becomes highly significant. Law One -- "A robot may not '''knowingly''' injure a human being or, through inaction, '''knowingly''' allow a human being to come to harm." Basically, a robot can be ordered to perform an innocuous task, individually harmless, which taken along with a number of other equally harmless tasks performed by other robots or people would result in serious harm or death to a human being. The murderer carries out all of his attacks through a set of careful orders to robots that get around the first law in this way.]]
** It also foreshadows later twists the First Law can take, including [[spoiler: getting a robot to think of a human being as inhuman less than human, and therefore outside its protection.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The circumvention of the First Law in ''Literature/RobotsAndEmpire'' by [[spoiler:changing a robot's definition of human]] is hinted at in this book during the scene at the farm, when one of the robots [[spoiler:describes Earthmen as "inferior" humans, which apparently is part of its default programming]]. And though the robot denies it, Baley suspects this may have caused it to hesitate when the child it was guarding suddenly fired an arrow at him.

to:

** The circumvention of the First Law in ''Literature/RobotsAndEmpire'' [[spoiler: and the Solarians eventually getting robots to slaughter anyone who comes to their planet by telling them that only those who speak with the Solarian accent are human]] by [[spoiler:changing a robot's definition of human]] is hinted at in this book during the scene at the farm, when one of the robots [[spoiler:describes Earthmen as "inferior" humans, which apparently is part of its default programming]]. And though the robot denies it, Baley suspects this may have caused it to hesitate when the child it was guarding suddenly fired an arrow at him.

Added: 824

Changed: 1

Removed: 620

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rewording and moving to more accurate trope


* FalseReassurance: Unintentionally invoked by Daneel after Baley and Attlebish get into a pissing match about the murder investigation. Caught between them, he tries to be as diplomatic as possible while still supporting Baley. His reassurance is quite genuine, but Baley sees it from another perspective.
--> "To one who knew Daneel was a robot, it was all an attempt to do a job without giving offense to any human, not to Baley and not to Attlebish. To one who thought Daneel was an Auroran, a native of the oldest and most powerful military of the Outer Worlds, it sounded like a series of subtly courteous threats."



-->'''Baley''': You poisoners on Solaria don't know dosages. Lack of experience.

to:

-->'''Baley''': You Your poisoners on Solaria don't know dosages. Lack of experience.


Added DiffLines:

* ShameIfSomethingHappened: Unintentionally invoked by Daneel after Baley and Attlebish get into a pissing match about the murder investigation. Caught between them, he tries to be as diplomatic as possible while still supporting Baley, with lots of mollifying statements about how it would be "inadvisable" to hinder their investigation and how much he would "regret" it if their presence continues to be "unpleasant". His deliberate politeness is entirely genuine, but Baley sees it from another perspective.
--> "To one who knew Daneel was a robot, it was all an attempt to do a job without giving offense to any human, not to Baley and not to Attlebish. To one who thought Daneel was an Auroran, a native of the oldest and most powerful military of the Outer Worlds, it sounded like a series of subtly courteous threats."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAllegedExpert: Solaria's sole sociologist, Dr. Quemont, is self-taught and can't bring himself to be in the same room as another human being (although, to be fair, the same is true of most Solarians). And if that's not bad enough, he's never even studied basic and valuable sociology principles developed on other planets.

to:

* TheAllegedExpert: Solaria's sole sociologist, Dr. Quemont, is self-taught and can't bring himself to be in the same room as another human being (although, to be fair, the same is true of most Solarians). And if that's not bad enough, he's never even studied basic and valuable sociology principles developed on other planets. Considering the conditions on Solaria, this is not surprising, as there would be few social problems to exert pressure on Quemont, or anyone else, to develop sociology into anything an Earthman would recognize as robust.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RichReclusesRealm: Solaria's tiny population, PostScarcityEconomy, and solitary culture have made it an entire planet of these. Each Solarian lives alone in palatial luxury with hundreds or thousands of square miles of land, legions of robots attending their every whim, and a crippling fear of personal contact.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DramaPanes: Baley comes to a window and, despite Daneel's protests rips off its curtains before staring at the night outside, to show his defiance of the characteristic Earthman agoraphobia. He also gets his EurekaMoment then.
Tabs MOD

Removed: 64

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
misuse


* ItIsPronouncedTroPAY: Gladia's name is pronounced glah-DIE-ah.

Added: 327

Removed: 299

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAllegedExpert: Solaria's sole sociologist, Dr. Quemont, is self-taught and can't bring himself to be in the same room as another human being (although, to be fair, the same is true of most Solarians). And if that's not bad enough, he's never even studied basic and valuable sociology principles developed on other planets.



* KnowNothingKnowItAll: Sociologist Anselmo Quemont. He has a decent understanding of Solarian society but has the same preconceptions as everyone else. He has never even heard of sociomathamatics and other such methods and studies from Earth even though they could still be used in his own society.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->Baley wanted to cry: "You fool, it isn’t a human that’s approaching; only one of the robots you love."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

--->'''Robot:''' I would not have allowed harm to come to a human, even an Earthman. He moved too quickly and I was not fast enough.\\
'''Baley:''' Perhaps you thought I was just an Earthman, not completely a human, and hesitated a bit.\\
'''Robot:''' No, master.\\
It was said with quiet calm, but Baley's lips quirked grimly. The robot might deny it in all faith, but Baley felt that was exactly the factor involved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FuturisticJetInjector: A "high-pressure needle jet" is mentioned as an alternative to hypodermic needles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AbsurdlyHugePopulation: Inverted, Daniel tells Baley that Solaria's population is only 20,000. This gets to the point that he initially believes that Daniel mispronounced, and what he really meant was 20 million.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DramaticSitDown: Daneel is so shaken by witnessing an attempted murder (even though there was nothing he could do, so he wasn't breaking the First Law) that he sits down "as though there were a weakness in his knees."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As part of his work on the farm, Delmarre wanted to create robots that were sophisticated enough to understand that disciplining children for misbehaving is better for their development in the long term. As it turns out later, [[spoiler: Daneel and Giskard were already on their way to understanding this concept at a much higher level than anyone could have expected.]]

to:

** As part of his work on the farm, Delmarre wanted to create robots that were sophisticated enough to understand that disciplining children for misbehaving is better for their development in the long term.term, and therefore consistent with the spirit of the First Law. As it turns out later, [[spoiler: Daneel and Giskard were already on their way to understanding this concept at a much higher level than anyone could have expected.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Quemot comparing Solaria to ancient Sparta. The main reason for Sparta's fall was that its social structure was incapable of replenishing its citizen body. Two centuries later, and Solaria's population is five thousand and falling.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BatmanGambit: Elijah tricks Daneel (who is trying to keep him from investigating further out of concern for his safety) into showing his robot circuits by claiming to think he's really a human impersonating Daneel, then calls in the house robots so that they'll see Daneel is also robot. This permits the robots to restrain Daneel, at Baley's order, while he continues the investigation unimpeded.

to:

* BatmanGambit: Elijah tricks Daneel (who is trying to keep him from investigating further out of concern for his safety) into showing his robot circuits by claiming to think he's really a human impersonating Daneel, then calls in the house robots so that they'll see Daneel is also a robot. This permits the robots to restrain Daneel, at Baley's order, while he continues the investigation unimpeded.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NobleBigotWithABadge: In a science fiction sense. Security Chief Hannis Gruer is civil and professional to Elijah and is the one to realize that an Earthman mindset, with its much greater context, will stand a better chance of figuring out the murder. He also seems firmly convinced that the murder was planned by a conspiracy of people who (by modern standards) are progressive opponents of Solaria's stagnated society. [[spoiler:Ironically, the exact opposite s true, with the killer wanting to spread Solarian values across the galaxy and elevate any possible threat to being seen.]]

to:

* NobleBigotWithABadge: In a science fiction sense. Security Chief Hannis Gruer is civil and professional to Elijah and is the one to realize that an Earthman mindset, with its much greater context, will stand a better chance of figuring out the murder. He also seems firmly convinced that the murder was planned by a conspiracy of people who (by modern standards) are progressive opponents of Solaria's stagnated society. [[spoiler:Ironically, the exact opposite s is true, with the killer wanting to spread Solarian values across the galaxy and elevate eliminate any possible threat to being seen.]]

Top