Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheLegendOfRahAndTheMuggles

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrapsaccharineWorld: Aura prior and after the war. The former was a peaceful civilisation kept through humanitarian charters, while the latter is a cutesy Teletubbies-like land. In between, humanity's greed and corruption festered on the inside of the former and lead to a nuclear holocaust, the ensuing radiation and mutations leading to the current adorable life forms.*

to:

* CrapsaccharineWorld: Aura prior and after the war. The former was a peaceful civilisation kept through humanitarian charters, while the latter is a cutesy Teletubbies-like land. In between, humanity's greed and corruption festered on the inside of the former and lead to a nuclear holocaust, the ensuing radiation and mutations leading to the current adorable life forms.*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MeaningfulName: The Muggles are named in a ceremony because of a particular sign or a behavior that shows in its infancy. However, some of the names don't have clear origins (Rah and Zyn, Yur and Golda, Peter...), some inexplicably match for lovers or spouses (Pitter and Patter, Pick and Pluck), and some imply that the Muggle is doomed to a flawed life, such as Boggs, who is implied to [[ThePigPen smell bad and be covered in mud]] ''since birth''.

to:

* MeaningfulName: The Muggles are named in a ceremony because of a particular sign or a behavior that shows in its infancy. However, some of the names don't have clear origins (Rah and Zyn, (like Peter or Yur and Golda, Peter...), Golda), some inexplicably match for lovers or spouses (Pitter and Patter, Pick and Pluck), and some imply that the Muggle is doomed to a flawed life, such as Boggs, who is implied to [[ThePigPen smell bad and be covered in mud]] ''since birth''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DescriptionPorn: Stouffer puts very elaborate descriptions of details that aren't vital to the story. To wit, the elements that ''are'' relevant are mostly glossed over or barely mentioned.

to:

* DescriptionPorn: Stouffer puts very elaborate descriptions of details that aren't vital to the story. To wit, On the other hand, the elements that ''are'' relevant are mostly glossed over or barely mentioned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlotHole: The Muggles use elaborate flower arrangements in their naming ceremony, which is described as "traditional". By "traditional", it's implied it was that way before Rah and Zyn's arrival, when there was no plant life alive at that point.

to:

* PlotHole: The Muggles use elaborate flower arrangements in their naming ceremony, which is described as "traditional". By "traditional", it's implied it was that way before Rah and Zyn's arrival, when there was no plant life alive at that point. And this is one of the tamer plot holes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving from the soon-to-be-cut subpage.


* PlotHole: So many that the "plot" resembles a block of Swiss cheese. [[PlotHole/TheLegendOfRahAndTheMuggles Most of them are listed in this page]].

to:

* PlotHole: So many The Muggles use elaborate flower arrangements in their naming ceremony, which is described as "traditional". By "traditional", it's implied it was that the "plot" resembles a block of Swiss cheese. [[PlotHole/TheLegendOfRahAndTheMuggles Most of them are listed in this page]].way before Rah and Zyn's arrival, when there was no plant life alive at that point.

Added: 532

Removed: 838

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed per TRS. Removed natter.


* ImprobableInfantSurvival: Taken to the logical extreme. Place two infants (toddlers?) on a raft and shove them out to sea, let them stay on the raft for ''one full week'' before having the happy sea creatures come to their aid, and then consider how they avoid being horribly sunburnt, half-drowned or maybe ''all'' drowned, salt-burnt, and/or dehydrated and probably dead from that alone. They're ''certainly'' not going to be shiny, happy babies by that point, and that's even leaving in such an important detail as NobodyPoops.



* InfantImmortality: Taken to the logical extreme. Place two infants (toddlers?) on a raft and shove them out to sea, let them stay on the raft for ''one full week'' before having the happy sea creatures come to their aid, and then consider how they avoid being horribly sunburnt, half-drowned or maybe ''all'' drowned, salt-burnt, and/or dehydrated and probably dead from that alone. They're ''certainly'' not going to be shiny, happy babies by that point, and that's even leaving in such an important detail as NobodyPoops.
** The lack of sunburn could possibly be {{Handwave}}d with the fact that Lady Catherine apparently covered them with a blanket before sending them off. It's still really a weak explaination, because that doesn't excuse their heads, and there is no more mention of the blanket, nor does it appear in the pictures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse


* YouKeepUsingThatWord: Stouffer doesn't seem to know the difference between radiation and fallout, as she talks of purple clouds of radiation. ''Fallout'' could conceivably be purple, as mentioned above, but radiation itself is invisible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* FriendToAllLivingThings: Rah.

to:

%%* * FriendToAllLivingThings: Even birds, bunnies and other sorts of small animals like Rah.



%%* MoodWhiplash: From ParanoiaFuel to TastesLikeDiabetes back to NightmareFuel in record time.

to:

%%* * MoodWhiplash: From ParanoiaFuel the looming threat of nuclear war to TastesLikeDiabetes back cutesypoo talking sea animals, for just one example - this story was written for small children and the author seemed to NightmareFuel in record time.have no clear idea as to what might be age-inappropriate.



%%* TheResenter: Zyn

to:

%%* * TheResenter: ZynZyn comes to resent Rah for being so great at everything and getting all the adulation of the muggles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Clarified a sentence


* DepartmentOfRedundancyDepartment: The writing style is a style of writing with many unnecessary repetitions that she repeats unnecessarily many times. Stouffer would be hopeless on ''Radio/JustAMinute''. Also see the quote under FunetikAksent below.

to:

* DepartmentOfRedundancyDepartment: The writing style is a style of writing with many unnecessary repetitions that she the author repeats unnecessarily many times. Stouffer would be hopeless on ''Radio/JustAMinute''. Also see the quote under FunetikAksent below.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling


* BeautyEqualsGoodness: Zyn, the supposed bad guy, becomes more and more ugly and thin as he descends in depression, especially after residing in the Manchineet Tree. The Nevils get the same tretament, growing long claws and hair.

to:

* BeautyEqualsGoodness: Zyn, the supposed bad guy, becomes more and more ugly and thin as he descends in depression, especially after residing in the Manchineet Tree. The Nevils get the same tretament, treatment, growing long claws and hair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Capitalization


* AerithAndBob: The Nevils' names are Teeter, Jitters, Fraidy, Boggs, Stubby, Patch and...Peter ([[SubvertedTrope altough he prefers to be called "chops"]]).

to:

* AerithAndBob: The Nevils' names are Teeter, Jitters, Fraidy, Boggs, Stubby, Patch and...Peter ([[SubvertedTrope altough he prefers to be called "chops"]])."Chops"]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* FamilyUnfriendlyAesop: The story impies that helping someone out of depression is useless, because they're inherently evil. It also implies that a person is only good if he sticks to the norm and stays idle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Stupid Evil is for when someone is evil despite it not benefitting them, or even being actively harmful to them. This is just an example of the Nevils being idiots in general.


* StupidEvil: It takes the Nevils several days of living in a radioactive tree to decide that it was a bad idea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FamilyUnfriendlyAesop: The story impies that helping someone out of depression is useless, because they're inherently evil. It also implies that a person is only good if he sticks to the norm and stays idle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OcularGushers: Someone cries so much that ''they cause a flash flood''.

to:

* OcularGushers: Someone Rah cries so much that ''they cause a flash flood''.flood that sinks Zyn's boat''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigShadowLittleCreature: The "Shadow Monsters" on Dezra are nothing but Zyn and the Nevils' heavily distorted shadows.

to:

* BigShadowLittleCreature: The "Shadow Monsters" on Dezra are nothing but Zyn and the Nevils' heavily distorted shadows. And somehow they're afraid of them.

Changed: 1228

Removed: 612

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cleaning up some subjectivity


* AlternativeCalendar: And clearly not that helpful, since "The Year of the Purple Haze" does little to distinguish a year from any of the 500 other years in which the world was blanketed with a [[TechnicolorScience purple]] cloud of fallout.
** IdiosyncraticEpisodeNaming: Every year seems to be named after a particular parable from ''The Ancient Book of Tales''. For example, "The Year of the Gilded Cage" refers to an incident in which pirates stole a number of animals taken to be sold and released them on Aura, keeping only the gold cages.

to:

* AlternativeCalendar: And clearly not that helpful, since "The Year of the Purple Haze" does little to distinguish a year from any of the 500 other years in which the world was blanketed with a [[TechnicolorScience purple]] cloud of fallout.
** IdiosyncraticEpisodeNaming:
fallout. Every year seems to be named after a particular parable from ''The Ancient Book of Tales''. For example, "The Year of the Gilded Cage" refers to an incident in which pirates stole a number of animals taken to be sold and released them on Aura, keeping only the gold cages.



* BigShadowLittleCreature: The "Shadow Monsters" on Dezra are nothing but Zyn and the Nevils' heavily distorted shadows. [[WhatAnIdiot And somehow they're afraid of them.]]

to:

* BigShadowLittleCreature: The "Shadow Monsters" on Dezra are nothing but Zyn and the Nevils' heavily distorted shadows. [[WhatAnIdiot And somehow they're afraid of them.]]



* FreudianExcuse: Zyn's StartOfDarkness comes from his [[CainAndAbel resentment]] of his brother, and is handled with [[{{Anvilicious}} all the subtlety you'd expect]].
* FriendToAllLivingThings: Rah.

to:

* FreudianExcuse: Zyn's StartOfDarkness comes from his [[CainAndAbel resentment]] of his brother, and is handled with [[{{Anvilicious}} all the subtlety you'd expect]].
*
brother.
%%*
FriendToAllLivingThings: Rah.



* MeaningfulName: This book has a very bad example of this trope: the Muggles are supposed to be named in a ceremony because of a particular sign or a behavior that shows in its infancy. However, some of the names don't have clear origins (Rah and Zyn, Yur and Golda, Peter...), some inexplicably match for lovers or spouses (Pitter and Patter, Pick and Pluck), and some lead to UnfortunateImplications, such as Boggs, who is implied to [[ThePigPen smell bad and be covered in mud]] ''since birth''.
* MoodWhiplash: From ParanoiaFuel to TastesLikeDiabetes back to NightmareFuel in record time.

to:

* MeaningfulName: This book has a very bad example of this trope: the The Muggles are supposed to be named in a ceremony because of a particular sign or a behavior that shows in its infancy. However, some of the names don't have clear origins (Rah and Zyn, Yur and Golda, Peter...), some inexplicably match for lovers or spouses (Pitter and Patter, Pick and Pluck), and some lead imply that the Muggle is doomed to UnfortunateImplications, a flawed life, such as Boggs, who is implied to [[ThePigPen smell bad and be covered in mud]] ''since birth''.
* %%* MoodWhiplash: From ParanoiaFuel to TastesLikeDiabetes back to NightmareFuel in record time.



* NeverSayDie: Despite gleefully recounting the annihilation of all life that doesn't fall into the TastesLikeDiabetes category earlier on, the book describes the BigBad's plan as making Rah "sleep forever".

to:

* NeverSayDie: Despite gleefully recounting the annihilation of all most life that doesn't fall into the TastesLikeDiabetes category on Earth earlier on, the book describes the BigBad's plan as making Rah "sleep forever".



* OcularGushers: If you want to {{Narm}}ify a touching goodbye scene, you can't do better than have someone cry so much that ''they cause a flash flood''. Evidently the [[ElementalBaggage vast volume of water involved]] was stored in one of the massive {{plot hole}}s.

to:

* OcularGushers: If you want to {{Narm}}ify a touching goodbye scene, you can't do better than have someone cry Someone cries so much that ''they cause a flash flood''. Evidently the [[ElementalBaggage vast volume of water involved]] was stored in one of the massive {{plot hole}}s.flood''.



* ShowDontTell: One of the book's main problems. Qualities of characters are stated, but never actually shown.
** In a particular example, it is stated that Zyn has become jealous and is losing all of his self-esteem, and that he and Rah were very close until now. Stouffer doesn't actually describe how and why it happens, and what part of his personality is losing. This also cements Zyn's status as DesignatedVillain.

to:

* ShowDontTell: One of the book's main problems. Qualities of characters are stated, but never actually shown.
**
shown. In a particular example, it is stated that Zyn has become jealous and is losing all of his self-esteem, and that he and Rah were very close until now. Stouffer doesn't actually describe how and why it happens, and what part of his personality is losing. This also cements Zyn's status as DesignatedVillain.



* TalkingAnimal: A few with cute alliterative names show up, without much consequence; that [[BigApplesauce some of them have New York accents]] would be a major source of FridgeLogic in any other book, but here it barely registers.

to:

* TalkingAnimal: A few with cute alliterative names show up, without much consequence; that consequence. [[BigApplesauce some Some of them inexplicably have New York accents]] would be a major source of FridgeLogic in any other book, but here it barely registers.accents]].



* [[WantonCrueltyToTheCommonComma Wanton Cruelty To The Common Apostrophe]]: Very frequently, including on Stouffer's own website.

to:

* [[WantonCrueltyToTheCommonComma Wanton Cruelty To The Common Apostrophe]]: %%* WantonCrueltyToTheCommonComma: Very frequently, including on Stouffer's own website.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrapsaccharineWorld: The world prior and after the war. The former was a peaceful civilisation kept through humanitarian charters, while the latter is a cutesy Teletubbies-like land. In between, humanity's greed and corruption festered on the inside of the former and lead to a nuclear holocaust, the ensuing radiation and mutations leading to the current adorable life forms.*

to:

* CrapsaccharineWorld: The world Aura prior and after the war. The former was a peaceful civilisation kept through humanitarian charters, while the latter is a cutesy Teletubbies-like land. In between, humanity's greed and corruption festered on the inside of the former and lead to a nuclear holocaust, the ensuing radiation and mutations leading to the current adorable life forms.*

Added: 236

Removed: 220

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Early in the story, the main characters (who are babies) survive for ''eight days'' on a raft in the ocean without food and water (for the record, your average adult can barely survive half that time with no water, let alone a baby).



** Early in the book the main characters (who are babies) survive for ''eight days'' on a raft without food or water (for the record, your average adult can barely survive half that time with no water, let alone a baby.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: The humans living on Aura evolved into Muggles in 500 years. For comparison, the human species (homo sapiens) has existed for 100,000 at the most conservative estimate, and we are just greenhorns compared to even most mammals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Early in the book the main characters (who are babies) survive for ''eight days'' on a raft without food or water (for the record, your average adult can barely survive half that time with no water, let alone a baby.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* YouKeepUsingThatWord: Stouffer doesn't seem to know the difference between radiation and fallout, as she talks of purple clouds of radiation. ''Fallout'' could conceivably be purple, as mentioned above, but radiation itself is invisible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
As far as I know this part wasn't medically accurate either


** How allergies are treated in this book. One can't simply pass out after having an allergy: in most cases, there would be cutaneous eructions, rashes and severe irritations. The worst that could happen are asthma or respiratory problems that could lead to lacks of oxygen and therefore fainting. This means that, even if Zyn didn't intend to kill Rah, provoking an allergy on him so that he has no air and faints, would mean giving him a slow and painful death.

to:

** How allergies are treated in this book. One can't simply pass out after having an allergy: in most cases, there would be cutaneous eructions, rashes and severe irritations. The Fainting is the sign of the anaphylactic shock which is the worst that could happen are asthma or respiratory problems that could possible consequence of allergy and which, among such "fun" things like coagulopathy and acute kidney injury, can quickly lead to lacks loss of oxygen consciousness followed by coma and therefore fainting. This means that, even death, if Zyn didn't intend to kill Rah, provoking an allergy on him so that he has no air and faints, would mean giving him a slow and painful death.it isn't treated immediately.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RandomEventsPlot

to:

* RandomEventsPlot RandomEventsPlot: Between the 2nd and 9th chapter, the plot stops to a screeching halt and turns into a mish-mash of random anecdotes involving Rah and Zyn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RandomEventsPlot
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* SignificantGreenEyedRedhead: Zyn

to:

%%* * SignificantGreenEyedRedhead: ZynZyn is the story's main antagonist, and he has green eyes and red hair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OrwellianRetcon: According to Stouffer, the book was always titled "The Legend of Rah and the Muggles". However, there is no evidence prior to 2000 to back up this claim, as it was only titled "The Legend of Rah", and the "Muggle" term was copyrighted much after.

to:

* OrwellianRetcon: According to Stouffer, the book was always titled "The Legend of Rah and the Muggles". However, there is no evidence prior to 2000 to back up this claim, as it was only titled "The Legend of Rah", and the "Muggle" term "and the Muggles" part was copyrighted much after.added after the attempted lawsuit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OrwellianRetcon: According to Stouffer, the book was always titled "The Legend of Rah and the Muggles". However, there is no evidence prior to 2000 to back up this claim, as it was only titled "The Legend of Rah", and the "Muggle" term was copyrighted much after.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheLegendOfX

Added: 260

Removed: 168

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Mutants}}: The muggles are descendants of humans who got mutated by radioactive fallout.



** WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds: What he really comes off as. He's not even scary, just angry-more like. In another story, would come off as a well-written redeemable bully.


Added DiffLines:

* WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds: What Zyn really comes off as. He's not even scary, just angry-more like. In another story, would come off as a well-written redeemable bully.

Top