Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheIronDream

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* DropTheHammer: The Steel Commander, aka the Great Truncheon of Held, is as light as a feather ([[OnlyTheChosenMayWield to its rightful bearer]]) but strikes with the mass of a mountain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
this seems to just be about real-world Hitler and not his portrayal as the author of this book.


** It is surprisingly obscure knowledge, but Hitler was for a short time a member of a secret police unit and was tasked with infiltration of political movements. He attended his first German Workers' Party (later renamed the National Socialist German Workers' Party, or Nazi Party) meeting as a police spy, liked what he heard, and joined up for real). He quickly concluded that brute force only causes the dissenters to hide, and the covert intelligence operations are much more likely to yield good results. Likewise he was against police brutality and would not allow German police to carry guns or truncheons, which he considered demeaning to the public.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
IUEO now


* AwesomeMcCoolname: Feric Jaggar! See also MeaningfulName, below.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* TakeThat: The book suggests that in the real world, the works of certain specific sf and fantasy writers, their {{Fandom}}, and the science fiction and fantasy genres as a whole at large have UnfortunateImplications. [[invoked]]

to:

* TakeThat: The book suggests that in the real world, the works of certain specific sf and fantasy writers, their {{Fandom}}, and the science fiction and fantasy genres as a whole at large have UnfortunateImplications. [[invoked]]are problematic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The higher-ups in Jaggar's party also have names similar to those of their real-life Nazi counterparts: Joseph Goebbels becomes Seph Bogel, Rudolf Hess becomes Ludolf Best,and so on.

to:

** The higher-ups in Jaggar's party also have names similar to those of their real-life Nazi counterparts: Joseph Goebbels becomes Seph Bogel, Rudolf Hess becomes Ludolf Best,and so on.on (which interestingly makes this alternate Hitler sort of a medium - for some reason he models Feric Jaggar's paladins after the guys who were the inner circle of the historica Hitler).

Changed: 932

Removed: 362

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FantasyCounterpartCulture: Quite a few
** Heldon = Germany
** Zind = the Soviet Union
** Bora = Moscow
** Universalists = Communists
** Dominators = Jews
** Wolack = Poland
** Borgravia = Austria
** Vetonia = France
** Husak (capital Kolchak) = the Netherlands
** Cressia, Arbona, Karmath = unclear, perhaps Iberia or Italy
** Feder = Belgium
** Knights of the Swastika = SA
** Sons of the Swastika = SS
** Gormond = Linz
** Heldhime = Berlin
** High Republic = Weimar Republic
** Classification Camps = concentration camps (Konzentrationslager)

to:

* FantasyCounterpartCulture: Quite a few
few:
** Heldon = Germany
(Germany), with its capital Heldheim (Berlin) and the second most important city, Walder (Munich).
** Zind = the (the Soviet Union
**
Union, but also 'Zion') with its capital Bora = Moscow
** Universalists = Communists
** Dominators = Jews
** Wolack = Poland
(Moscow).
** Borgravia = Austria
** Vetonia = France
** Husak (capital Kolchak) =
is based on Austria-Hungary. However, the Netherlands
fact that this nation is overwhelmingly populated by mutants with Truemen only being a tiny minority is a deviation from that model.
** Wolack is Poland.
** The other countries surrounding Heldon (Husak, Feder, Vetonia,
Cressia, Arbona, Karmath = unclear, perhaps Iberia or Italy
Karmak) are less clear - they seem to be more worldbuilding than anything else.
** Feder = Belgium
**
And then there are various groups and institutions that are knockoffs of their real life counterparts: Universalists are Communists, Dominators are Jews, the Knights of the Swastika = SA
**
is the SA and the Sons of the Swastika = SS
** Gormond = Linz
** Heldhime = Berlin
** High Republic = Weimar Republic
**
is the SS; and Classification Camps = are reminiscent of concentration camps (Konzentrationslager)camps, though initially they're more for separating the wheat from the chaff - the whole genocide aspect happens later in the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Feric Jaggar is horrified by the prospect of using nuclear weapons against Zind (because the fallout would taint the gene pool of the true humans). TruthInTelevision in that Hitler was known to be very negative toward the idea of nuclear weapons. He was forced to conduct research into nuclear weaponry only because the Germans knew that the other Powers would do so. Surprising? Likewise he was against police brutality and would not allow German police to carry guns or truncheons, which he considered demeaning to the public.
** It is surprisingly obscure knowledge, but Hitler was for a short time a member of a secret police unit and was tasked with infiltration of political movements. He attended his first German Workers' Party (later renamed the National Socialist German Workers' Party, or Nazi Party) meeting as a police spy, liked what he heard, and joined up for real). He quickly concluded that brute force only causes the dissenters to hide, and the covert intelligence operations are much more likely to yield good results. And his aversion to [=WMDs=] might have been caused by being wounded in a gas attack during Great War.

to:

** Feric Jaggar is horrified by the prospect of using nuclear weapons against Zind (because the fallout would taint the gene pool of the true humans). TruthInTelevision in that Hitler was known to be very negative toward the idea of nuclear weapons. He was forced to conduct [=WMDs=] - he had witnessed the horrific impact of gas as a weapon of war during his time in the trenches of the Great War; and he wasn't too keen on atomic bombs and conducted research into nuclear weaponry only because the Germans knew that the other Powers would do so. Surprising? Likewise he was against police brutality and would not allow German police to carry guns or truncheons, which he considered demeaning to the public.
so.
** It is surprisingly obscure knowledge, but Hitler was for a short time a member of a secret police unit and was tasked with infiltration of political movements. He attended his first German Workers' Party (later renamed the National Socialist German Workers' Party, or Nazi Party) meeting as a police spy, liked what he heard, and joined up for real). He quickly concluded that brute force only causes the dissenters to hide, and the covert intelligence operations are much more likely to yield good results. And his aversion Likewise he was against police brutality and would not allow German police to [=WMDs=] might have been caused by being wounded in a gas attack during Great War.carry guns or truncheons, which he considered demeaning to the public.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ContemptibleCover
** Just try explaining to a horrified busgoer why the book you're reading features a blond Nazi triumphantly raising a truncheon above his head.
** Later editions [[TrailersAlwaysSpoil openly put Hitler on the cover]] (see [[http://www.librarything.com/work/49259/covers/ here]] for examples)-- and then there's [[http://www.fantasticfiction.co.uk/s/norman-spinrad/iron-dream.htm the edition]] that shies away from Nazi imagery (barring one swastika).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Schizo Tech: Justified Trope


* SchizoTech: The book starts in a post-apocalyptic world where steam-powered buses are common transportation, but swiftly moves through World War II-level weaponry before ending with cloning and interstellar spaceships.

to:

* SchizoTech: The book starts in a post-apocalyptic world where steam-powered buses are common transportation, but swiftly moves through World War II-level weaponry before ending with cloning and interstellar spaceships. [[JustifiedTrope Justified]] in that it is explicitly stated that these technologies used to exist but were lost after a previous nuclear war and are being rediscovered rather than being invented for the first time, so a lot of the work is actually finding old equipment and textbooks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Only The Chosen May Wield: subverted trope


* OnlyTheChosenMayWield: Only Jaggar can wield the Truncheon of Held.

to:

* OnlyTheChosenMayWield: Only Jaggar can wield the Truncheon of Held. Also [[SubvertedTrope subverted]] in that it is stated that the bloodline assumed to be required to wield the truncheon has become widely disseminated by this point, so if the truncheon hadn't been hidden many other individuals could have stepped up and wielded it as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Mind Control: Jaggar may be a Dominator; also a Take That!


* MindControl: How the Dominators dominate. Jaggar is the only one able to resist them.

to:

* MindControl: How the Dominators dominate. Jaggar is the only one able to resist them. [[spoiler:This and the constant references to Jaggar's psychic communion with his troops and the way they recklessly plunge into battle just like the Dominators' forces suggests more than a little that Jaggar, too, is a Dominator, which could easily be seen as a further TakeThat considering Hitler himself didn't exactly match the image of the Aryan {{ubermensch}}, either.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Author Appeal: Clarification: Repetition


* AuthorAppeal: The massive amount of PhallicWeapon and HomoeroticSubtext on display suit many theories about Hitler having had some issues with sexuality. There's also a scene involving mutant warriors [[PottyFailure crapping themselves]] that is described in unusual detail--in real life, one of the more persistent claims about Hitler is that he may have had a scat fetish.

to:

* AuthorAppeal: The massive amount of PhallicWeapon and HomoeroticSubtext on display suit many theories about Hitler having had some issues with sexuality. There's also a scene involving mutant warriors [[PottyFailure crapping themselves]] that is described in unusual detail--in detail (as well as endless repetition)--in real life, one of the more persistent claims about Hitler is that he may have had a scat fetish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AuthorAppeal: The massive amount of PhallicWeapon and HomoeroticSubtext on display suit many theories about Hitler having had some issues with sexuality. There's also a scene involving mutant warriors [[PottyFailure crapping themselves]] that is described in unusual detail--in real life, one of the more persistent claims about Hitler is that he may have had a scat fetish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HerCodeNameWasMarySue: Feric Jaggar is clearly meant to be the analogue to Hitler himself, so naturally, he's tall, blonde, attractive, muscular, a chosen hero, highly intelligent, and always in the right.

Added: 230

Changed: 799

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Deconstruction}}: Of the HeroicFantasy and ScienceFiction genres, intended to show the creepy fascist aspects at their core.
* DeliberateValuesDissonance

to:

* {{Deconstruction}}: Of the HeroicFantasy and ScienceFiction genres, intended to show the creepy fascist aspects at their core.
core. A straight-jawed, hypermasculine chosen hero leading an uprising against an AlwaysChaoticEvil race is a very standard sci-fi plot, but when you add in the idea that it was written by Hitler, suddenly all those elements become very questionable.
* DeliberateValuesDissonanceDeliberateValuesDissonance: It's a book written by Hitler; what kind of values do you think it'll be espousing?



* TakeThat: The book suggests that in the real world, the works of certain specific sf and fantasy writers, their {{Fandom}}, and the science fiction and fantasy genres as a whole at large have UnfortunateImplications - see the [[YMMV/TheIronDream YMMV page.]] [[invoked]]

to:

** Additionally, much of the story comes across as a ClicheStorm, which is part of the point; the fact that a very standard story setup is also one that invokes a mess of Nazi imagery is meant as critique for pulp HeroicFantasy.
* TakeThat: The book suggests that in the real world, the works of certain specific sf and fantasy writers, their {{Fandom}}, and the science fiction and fantasy genres as a whole at large have UnfortunateImplications - see the [[YMMV/TheIronDream YMMV page.]] UnfortunateImplications. [[invoked]]



%% * FantasticRacism: A bit of that, yes.

to:

%% * FantasticRacism: A bit of that, yes.Unsurprisingly, the Dominators are held in very low regard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
where are the unfortunate implications?


* UnfortunateImplications: Apparently, if the Nazis hadn't taken over Germany, the communists would have instead, resulting in a Greater Soviet Union that dominates most of the world, with only an American-Japanese alliance holding out. [[invoked]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* :AstralFinale: [[spoiler:When the Dominators pollute Earth with radiation all over again, Feric responds by colonizing the stars]].

to:

* :AstralFinale: AstralFinale: [[spoiler:When the Dominators pollute Earth with radiation all over again, Feric responds by colonizing the stars]].

Added: 512

Changed: 11

Removed: 513

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:AstralFinale]]: [[spoiler:When the Dominators pollute Earth with radiation all over again, Feric responds by colonizing the stars]].

to:

* [[spoiler:AstralFinale]]: :AstralFinale: [[spoiler:When the Dominators pollute Earth with radiation all over again, Feric responds by colonizing the stars]].



* DieselPunk: As Feric Jaggar ascends to power, the Held air force uses giant aircraft with ten gasoline engines each and just as big steam tanks. [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dornier_Do_X Both]] [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_tank existed]] in RealLife in the period between UsefulNotes/WorldWarI and 1933 [[RealLifeWritesThePlot and performed poorly]], just as Jaggar himself admits. It's the reason for which our hero pushes the Helden industry to develop smaller, faster and more practical designs.



** DieselPunk: as Feric Jaggar ascends to power, the Held air force uses giant aircraft with ten gasoline engines each and just as big steam tanks. [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dornier_Do_X Both]] [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_tank existed]] in RealLife in the period between UsefulNotes/WorldWarI and 1933 [[RealLifeWritesThePlot and performed poorly]], just as Jaggar himself admits. It's the reason for which our hero pushes the Helden industry to develop smaller, faster and more practical designs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalSelfDefense: The war Ferric wages against the Dominators hits most of the beats of World War II, except that the Soviet analogue invades Poland first.

Changed: 1392

Removed: 819

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhoWouldBeStupidEnough: The author analyzing Hitler's story notes that while some fans may yearn for such a decisive and iron-willed leader to save them from Soviet domination, he concludes that no rational person would ever stand such a clearly delusional, bloodthirsty tyrant, and that they certainly wouldn't be swayed by [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Bundesarchiv_Bild_102-04062A,_Nürnberg,_Reichsparteitag,_SA-_und_SS-Appell.jpg snappy uniforms, precision marching, and gigantic displays of stirring imagery]].
** He also rejects the idea that Doms are an anti-semitic metaphor, as given the Soviet Union's persecution of their own Jewish population, no-one would seriously believe that Communism was a Jewish conspiracy.

to:

* WhoWouldBeStupidEnough: The author analyzing Hitler's story notes that while some fans may yearn for such a decisive and iron-willed leader to save them from Soviet domination, he concludes that no rational person would ever stand such a clearly delusional, bloodthirsty tyrant, and that they certainly wouldn't be swayed by [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Bundesarchiv_Bild_102-04062A,_Nürnberg,_Reichsparteitag,_SA-_und_SS-Appell.jpg snappy uniforms, precision marching, and gigantic displays of stirring imagery]].
**
imagery]]. He also rejects the idea that Doms are an anti-semitic metaphor, as given the Soviet Union's persecution of their own Jewish population, no-one would seriously believe that Communism was a Jewish conspiracy.



** Feric Jaggar is horrified by the prospect of using nuclear weapons against Zind (because the fallout would taint the gene pool of the true humans).
** TruthInTelevision in that Hitler was known to be very negative toward the idea of nuclear weapons. He was forced to conduct research into nuclear weaponry only because the Germans knew that the other Powers would do so. (Surprising? Likewise he was against police brutality and would not allow German police to carry guns or truncheons, which he considered demeaning to the public.)
** It is surprisingly obscure knowledge, but Hitler was for a short time a member of a secret police and was tasked with infiltration of political movements. (He attended his first German Workers' Party (later renamed the National Socialist German Workers' Party, or Nazi Party) meeting as a police spy, liked what he heard, and joined up for real.) He quickly concluded that brute force only causes the dissenters to hide, and the covert intelligence operations are much more likely to yield good results. And his aversion to [=WMDs=] might have been caused by being wounded in a gas attack during Great War.

to:

** Feric Jaggar is horrified by the prospect of using nuclear weapons against Zind (because the fallout would taint the gene pool of the true humans).
**
humans). TruthInTelevision in that Hitler was known to be very negative toward the idea of nuclear weapons. He was forced to conduct research into nuclear weaponry only because the Germans knew that the other Powers would do so. (Surprising? Surprising? Likewise he was against police brutality and would not allow German police to carry guns or truncheons, which he considered demeaning to the public.)
public.
** It is surprisingly obscure knowledge, but Hitler was for a short time a member of a secret police unit and was tasked with infiltration of political movements. (He He attended his first German Workers' Party (later renamed the National Socialist German Workers' Party, or Nazi Party) meeting as a police spy, liked what he heard, and joined up for real.) real). He quickly concluded that brute force only causes the dissenters to hide, and the covert intelligence operations are much more likely to yield good results. And his aversion to [=WMDs=] might have been caused by being wounded in a gas attack during Great War.



** Feric (or "ferric," for iron) Jaggar (or ''Jaeger'', German for "hunter"). Other characters, usually ones loyal to Feric, have vaguely Germanic names. Ernst Rohm becomes Stag Stopa

to:

** Feric (or "ferric," for iron) Jaggar (or ''Jaeger'', German for "hunter"). Other characters, usually ones loyal to Feric, have vaguely Germanic names. Ernst Rohm becomes Stag Stopa Stopa.



* RuleOfCool: it's not clear why truncheons and motorcycles play such a big role in modern warfare, except that Hitler thinks that truncheons and motorcycles are cool.

to:

* RuleOfCool: it's It's not clear why truncheons and motorcycles play such a big role in modern warfare, except that Hitler thinks that truncheons and motorcycles are cool.



** DieselPunk: as Feric Jaggar ascends to power, the Held air force uses giant aircraft with ten gasoline engines each and just as big steam tanks. [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dornier_Do_X Both]] [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_tank existed]] in RealLife in the period between UsefulNotes/WorldWarI and 1933 [[RealLifeWritesThePlot and performed poorly]], just as Jaggar himself admits. Reason for which our hero pushes the Helden industry to develop smaller, faster and more practical designs.

to:

** DieselPunk: as Feric Jaggar ascends to power, the Held air force uses giant aircraft with ten gasoline engines each and just as big steam tanks. [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dornier_Do_X Both]] [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam_tank existed]] in RealLife in the period between UsefulNotes/WorldWarI and 1933 [[RealLifeWritesThePlot and performed poorly]], just as Jaggar himself admits. Reason It's the reason for which our hero pushes the Helden industry to develop smaller, faster and more practical designs.



** A while after the last example, it is reported to Jaggar that nearly forty thousand pure human females have been found suitable for breeding with the SS. (Meanwhile, [[FridgeHorror seventy thousand suitable SS recruits have been found]].) [[invoked]]
** All of this is, of course, intentional, reflecting as it does both Hitler's general lack of interest in women and Nazism's simultaneous encouragement of traditional female roles and tendencies towards postering overbearing masculinity. It also reflects a general tendency within many works of HeroicFantasy to basically reduce women to scenery.

to:

** A while after the last example, it is reported to Jaggar that nearly forty thousand pure human females have been found suitable for breeding with the SS. (Meanwhile, SS (meanwhile, [[FridgeHorror seventy thousand suitable SS recruits have been found]].) found]]). [[invoked]]
** All of this is, of course, intentional, reflecting as it does both Hitler's general lack of interest in women and Nazism's simultaneous encouragement of traditional female roles and tendencies towards postering posturing, overbearing masculinity. It also reflects a general tendency within many works of HeroicFantasy to basically reduce women to scenery.

Top