Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* GirlInABox: Chava, before she is activated.
Changed line(s) 31 (click to see context) from:
* SealedBadassInACan: Both of the titles characters are arguably this, tho Chava only was for a couple of weeks (in a mere wooden crate), while Ahmed hews more closely to the trope, as he was imprisoned for 1,000 years (in a literal metal vessel as well).
to:
* SealedBadassInACan: Both of the titles characters are arguably this, tho Chava only was for a couple of weeks (in a mere wooden crate), while Ahmed hews more closely to the trope, as he was imprisoned for 1,000 years (in a literal metal vessel as well).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 30 (click to see context) from:
* OurMonstersAreDifferent/OurGeniesAreDifferent: Chava the golem isn't an automaton, but a conscious being with her own mores & personality. Ahmed the jinni is, contrary to many contemporary depictions, a being of fire, and not air, and is unable to grant wishes even after being released from his imprisonment.
to:
* OurMonstersAreDifferent/OurGeniesAreDifferent: OurMonstersAreDifferent (and/or OurGeniesAreDifferent): Chava the golem isn't an automaton, but a conscious being with her own mores & personality. Ahmed the jinni is, contrary to many contemporary depictions, a being of fire, and not air, and is unable to grant wishes even after being released from his imprisonment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 30 (click to see context) from:
* OurMonstersAreDifferent: Chava the golem isn't an automaton, but a conscious being with her own mores & personality. Ahmed the jinni is, contrary to many contemporary depictions, a being of fire, and not air, and is unable to grant wishes even after being released from his imprisonment.
to:
* OurMonstersAreDifferent: OurMonstersAreDifferent/OurGeniesAreDifferent: Chava the golem isn't an automaton, but a conscious being with her own mores & personality. Ahmed the jinni is, contrary to many contemporary depictions, a being of fire, and not air, and is unable to grant wishes even after being released from his imprisonment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Our Monsters Are Different / Sealed Badass in a Can
Added DiffLines:
* OurMonstersAreDifferent: Chava the golem isn't an automaton, but a conscious being with her own mores & personality. Ahmed the jinni is, contrary to many contemporary depictions, a being of fire, and not air, and is unable to grant wishes even after being released from his imprisonment.
* SealedBadassInACan: Both of the titles characters are arguably this, tho Chava only was for a couple of weeks (in a mere wooden crate), while Ahmed hews more closely to the trope, as he was imprisoned for 1,000 years (in a literal metal vessel as well).
* SealedBadassInACan: Both of the titles characters are arguably this, tho Chava only was for a couple of weeks (in a mere wooden crate), while Ahmed hews more closely to the trope, as he was imprisoned for 1,000 years (in a literal metal vessel as well).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hoist by his own petard
Added DiffLines:
* HoistByHisOwnPetard: [[spoiler: Schaalman gets imprisoned in the same flask he sealed the jinni in 1,000 years earlier]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* {{Golem}}: Chava, obviously. And part of the reason Rabbi Meyer understands her so well is that, as a child, he once created a much-less-complex mini-golem under the supervision of a (slightly eccentric) tutor.
Deleted line(s) 26 (click to see context) :
* KabbalicGolem: Chava, obviously. And part of the reason Rabbi Meyer understands her so well is that, as a child, he once created a much-less-complex mini-golem under the supervision of a (slightly eccentric) tutor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 25 (click to see context) :
* {{Golem}}: Chava, obviously. And part of the reason Rabbi Meyer understands her so well is that, as a child, he once created a much-less-complex mini-golem under the supervision of a (slightly eccentric) tutor.
Added DiffLines:
* KabbalicGolem: Chava, obviously. And part of the reason Rabbi Meyer understands her so well is that, as a child, he once created a much-less-complex mini-golem under the supervision of a (slightly eccentric) tutor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* ImmortalitySeeker: Schaalman's goal is to find the secret to eternal life. [[spoiler: Ironically he already has it because his existence has been bound to Ahmad's ever since he sealed him in the bottle. Every time he dies he reincarnates, and this cycle will continue as long as Ahmad lives.]]
Deleted line(s) 27 (click to see context) :
* ImmortalitySeeker: Schaalman's goal is to find the secret to eternal life. [[spoiler: Ironically he already has it because his existence has been bound to Ahmad's ever since he sealed him in the bottle. Every time he dies he reincarnates, and this cycle will continue as long as Ahmad lives.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* ImmortalitySeeker: Schaalman's goal is to find the secret to eternal life. [[spoiler: Ironically he already has it because his existence has been bound to Ahmad's ever since he sealed him in the bottle. Every time he dies he reincarnates, and this cycle will continue as long as Ahmad lives.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 24 (click to see context) from:
* GodIsGood: The book is ''very'' subtle about it, but there is a heavy implication that there is a higher power watching over us whilst not portraying the books' Atheist characters as being bad people because of their lack of faith.
to:
* GodIsGood: The book is ''very'' subtle about it, but there is a heavy implication that there is a higher power watching over us whilst not portraying the books' Atheist characters as being bad people because of their lack of faith. Most of them are all around good people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 16 (click to see context) from:
* AllMythsAndLegendsAreTrue: When we see Schaalman's [[spoiler: past lives]] we see that [[spoiler: in every reincarnation, he became the equivalent of a priest of the dominant religion of the land he was born in, discovered the mystic arts associated with it, found that they were real, and wound up dead because of his lust for power.]]
to:
* AllMythsAndLegendsAreTrue: AllMythsAreTrue: When we see Schaalman's [[spoiler: past lives]] we see that [[spoiler: in every reincarnation, he became the equivalent of a priest of the dominant religion of the land he was born in, discovered the mystic arts associated with it, found that they were real, and wound up dead because of his lust for power.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* AllMythsAndLegendsAreTrue: When we see Schaalman's [[spoiler: past lives]] we see that [[spoiler: in every reincarnation, he became the equivalent of a priest of the dominant religion of the land he was born in, discovered the mystic arts associated with it, found that they were real, and wound up dead because of his lust for power.]]
Added DiffLines:
* GodIsGood: The book is ''very'' subtle about it, but there is a heavy implication that there is a higher power watching over us whilst not portraying the books' Atheist characters as being bad people because of their lack of faith.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added line(s) 4 (click to see context) :
[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/golem_and_the_djinni.png]]
Changed line(s) 4 (click to see context) from:
[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/golem_and_the_djinni.png]]
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added image.
Changed line(s) 4,6 (click to see context) from:
to:
Deleted line(s) 15 (click to see context) :
----
Deleted line(s) 17 (click to see context) :
Changed line(s) 35 (click to see context) from:
* TrueSight: Chava and Ahmad can see through each other's human disguises to the elemental beings underneath.
to:
* TrueSight: Chava and Ahmad can see through each other's human disguises to the elemental beings underneath.underneath.
----
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* EarnYourHappyEnding: The ending is a little [[BittersweetEnding bittersweet,]] as good people do die [[spoiler: (mainly, Michael is killed by Yehudah and Saleh [[HeroicSacrifice gives his life to trap Yehudah in the flask]])]], but otherwise, most of the characters get varying degrees of happy endings. [[spoiler: Anna's is the most bittersweet, as she doesn't know how long she'll be able to provide for her son, but she is intent on being the best mother possible and Chava is supporting her as her new, lifelong friend. Ahmad takes Matthew to live with his grandmother and is able to see him off, and he and Arbeely make up and continue their partnership. Sophia gets to see her dream of traveling the world. And of course, Chava and Ahmad are friends once again... [[MaybeEverAfter with hints they may become something more.]]]]
Added DiffLines:
* MaybeEverAfter: [[spoiler: At the end of the book, it's hinted that Chava and Ahmad may attempt to pursue a romantic relationship, even if, given their circumstances, it would be a very strange one to most New Yorkers. [[ShipperOnDeck Anna certainly wants it to happen.]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 23,24 (click to see context) from:
* EthicalSlut: Jinns are this by nature, male or female. This attitude is basically an extension of their flame-like bodies, which makes them passionate and somewhat fickle.
** Despite this, Ahmad recoils at the idea of buying a prostitute for the evening, since he considers sex with only physical pleasure to be rather pointless.
** Despite this, Ahmad recoils at the idea of buying a prostitute for the evening, since he considers sex with only physical pleasure to be rather pointless.
to:
* EthicalSlut: Jinns Jinn are this by nature, male or female. This attitude is basically an extension of Their society doesn't bother with exclusive or permanent relationship and their flame-like bodies, which makes bodies make them passionate and somewhat fickle.
** Despite this,fickle, but Ahmad recoils at the idea of buying a prostitute for the evening, since he considers sex with only physical pleasure to be rather pointless.
** Despite this,
* TheSleepless: Ahmad and Chava don't need rest and are incapable of sleep. They both find nights frustratingly dull at times.
Changed line(s) 31 (click to see context) from:
* SuperStrength: Both Chava and Ahmad -- so that when Chava loses control, Ahmad is the only one physically able to stop her.
to:
* SuperStrength: Both Chava and Ahmad -- so that when Chava loses control, Ahmad is the only one physically able to stop her.her.
* ThenLetMeBeEvil: Schaalman's StartOfDarkness begins when his brief dream of an edenic garden is cut off by a voice telling him "You do not belong here." [[MaybeMagicMaybeMundane Whether or not]] it's actually supernatural, he interprets it as God rejecting him and takes up self-serving villainy with barely a backwards glance.
* TrueSight: Chava and Ahmad can see through each other's human disguises to the elemental beings underneath.
* ThenLetMeBeEvil: Schaalman's StartOfDarkness begins when his brief dream of an edenic garden is cut off by a voice telling him "You do not belong here." [[MaybeMagicMaybeMundane Whether or not]] it's actually supernatural, he interprets it as God rejecting him and takes up self-serving villainy with barely a backwards glance.
* TrueSight: Chava and Ahmad can see through each other's human disguises to the elemental beings underneath.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 26 (click to see context) from:
* Golem: Chava, obviously. And part of the reason Rabbi Meyer understands her so well is that, as a child, he once created a much-less-complex mini-golem under the supervision of a (slightly eccentric) tutor.
to:
* Golem: {{Golem}}: Chava, obviously. And part of the reason Rabbi Meyer understands her so well is that, as a child, he once created a much-less-complex mini-golem under the supervision of a (slightly eccentric) tutor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* AIIsACrapshoot: All golems supposedly go berserk or become dangerous at some point. Chava is perpetually worried about it happening to her. [[spoiler:And indeed, a couple of times she gets so angry in defense of a person she cares about that she experiences what in a human would probably be called a dissociative episode -- her body attacks them while her mind observes, as if from a distance, without being in control.]]
Changed line(s) 20 (click to see context) from:
* TheEmpath: Chava.
to:
* ElementalEmbodiment: Chava is made of earth; Ahmad is made of fire.
* TheEmpath:Chava.Chava feels the fears and desires of the people around her. To keep from being identified by her, [[spoiler:Schaalman uses a spell to suppress them]].
* TheEmpath:
* Golem: Chava, obviously. And part of the reason Rabbi Meyer understands her so well is that, as a child, he once created a much-less-complex mini-golem under the supervision of a (slightly eccentric) tutor.
* SealedEvilInACan: [[spoiler:Schaalman at the end, in the flask he was going to use on the jinni.]]
Changed line(s) 26 (click to see context) from:
* SlutShaming: Affects most of the female characters. Anna has to hide her premarital pregnancy. Sophia has to hide her fling with the jinni, and [[spoiler:her engagement is eventually broken because of the rumors]]. Chava marries a human who doesn't know what she is, and when they engage in "marital duties", it's all good for him...but the one time it starts stimulating her in a pleasurable way and she moves to pursue that, he thinks it's "immodest" and unbecoming of a wife. Because [[TheEmpath she can sense his desires]], she shuts the feeling down.
to:
* SlutShaming: Affects most of the female characters. Anna has to hide her premarital pregnancy. Sophia has to hide her fling with the jinni, and [[spoiler:her engagement is eventually broken because of the rumors]]. Chava marries a human who doesn't know what she is, and when they engage in "marital duties", it's all good for him...but the one time it starts stimulating her in a pleasurable way and she moves to pursue that, he thinks it's "immodest" and unbecoming of a wife. Because [[TheEmpath she can sense his desires]], she shuts the feeling down.down.
* SuperStrength: Both Chava and Ahmad -- so that when Chava loses control, Ahmad is the only one physically able to stop her.
* SuperStrength: Both Chava and Ahmad -- so that when Chava loses control, Ahmad is the only one physically able to stop her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 18 (click to see context) :
* {{Asexuality}}: It can be argued that Chava has this, although this is purely because Schaalman created her to be like "a gentleman's wife". She has a moment of sexual excitement [[spoiler: while in bed with Michael]], but her attempts to encourage that feeling die quickly after [[spoiler:she hears Michael feeling shocked at how "immodest" she is being]].
* BornAgainImmortality: [[spoiler:Yehudah Schaalman turns out to be the latest incarnation of the wizard who trapped Ahmad.]] Gains access to PastLifeMemories late in the book.
* TheEmpath: Chava.
* TheEmpath: Chava.
* GenieInABottle: Poor Ahmad. At least he doesn't have to grant wishes.
Changed line(s) 23 (click to see context) from:
* SecretKeeper: Arbeely is this for Ahmad, Rabbi Meyer for Chava.
to:
* SecretKeeper: Arbeely is this for Ahmad, Rabbi Meyer for Chava.Chava.
* SlutShaming: Affects most of the female characters. Anna has to hide her premarital pregnancy. Sophia has to hide her fling with the jinni, and [[spoiler:her engagement is eventually broken because of the rumors]]. Chava marries a human who doesn't know what she is, and when they engage in "marital duties", it's all good for him...but the one time it starts stimulating her in a pleasurable way and she moves to pursue that, he thinks it's "immodest" and unbecoming of a wife. Because [[TheEmpath she can sense his desires]], she shuts the feeling down.
* SlutShaming: Affects most of the female characters. Anna has to hide her premarital pregnancy. Sophia has to hide her fling with the jinni, and [[spoiler:her engagement is eventually broken because of the rumors]]. Chava marries a human who doesn't know what she is, and when they engage in "marital duties", it's all good for him...but the one time it starts stimulating her in a pleasurable way and she moves to pursue that, he thinks it's "immodest" and unbecoming of a wife. Because [[TheEmpath she can sense his desires]], she shuts the feeling down.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 9,10 (click to see context) from:
In 1899, the Golem wakes up in the cargo of a ship bound for NewYorkCity. Despite being inhumanly strong and made of clay, her newborn status makes her fearful and confused about the humans surrounding her. She is taken in and named Chava by a kindly old rabbi, who warns her to never let others around her learn of her true nature, lest they destroy her.
to:
In 1899, the Golem wakes up in the cargo of a ship bound for NewYorkCity.UsefulNotes/NewYorkCity. Despite being inhumanly strong and made of clay, her newborn status makes her fearful and confused about the humans surrounding her. She is taken in and named Chava by a kindly old rabbi, who warns her to never let others around her learn of her true nature, lest they destroy her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 20 (click to see context) from:
* EthicalSlut: Jinniyeh are this by nature, male or female. This attitude is basically an extension of their flame-like bodies, which makes them passionate and somewhat fickle.
to:
* EthicalSlut: Jinniyeh Jinns are this by nature, male or female. This attitude is basically an extension of their flame-like bodies, which makes them passionate and somewhat fickle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* {{Asexuality}}: It can be argued that Chava has this, although this is purely because Schaalman created her to be like "a gentleman's wife". She has a moment of sexual excitement [[spoiler: while in bed with Michael]], but her attempts to encourage that feeling die quickly after [[spoiler:she hears Michael feeling shocked at how "immodest" she is being]].
Changed line(s) 19 (click to see context) from:
** Despite this, Ahmad recoils at the idea of buying a prostitute for the evening, since he considers purely sex with only physical pleasure to be rather pointless.
to:
** Despite this, Ahmad recoils at the idea of buying a prostitute for the evening, since he considers purely sex with only physical pleasure to be rather pointless.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 15 (click to see context) from:
!!Tropes in this novel include:
to:
!!Tropes in this novel include:include:
*AMindIsATerribleThingToRead: Chava is usually overwhelmed with the volume of thoughts that she can hear. The ones of a sexual nature are especially annoying for her considering her modesty (programmed in by Schaalman).
*EthicalSlut: Jinniyeh are this by nature, male or female. This attitude is basically an extension of their flame-like bodies, which makes them passionate and somewhat fickle.
**Despite this, Ahmad recoils at the idea of buying a prostitute for the evening, since he considers purely sex with only physical pleasure to be rather pointless.
*MuggleBestFriend: You'd ''think'' that Arbeely would be this, considering that he's the only human that knows Ahmad's secret, but Ahmad is too prickly about his lack of independence (especially compared to his previous life) to open up properly.
*SecretKeeper: Arbeely is this for Ahmad, Rabbi Meyer for Chava.
*AMindIsATerribleThingToRead: Chava is usually overwhelmed with the volume of thoughts that she can hear. The ones of a sexual nature are especially annoying for her considering her modesty (programmed in by Schaalman).
*EthicalSlut: Jinniyeh are this by nature, male or female. This attitude is basically an extension of their flame-like bodies, which makes them passionate and somewhat fickle.
**Despite this, Ahmad recoils at the idea of buying a prostitute for the evening, since he considers purely sex with only physical pleasure to be rather pointless.
*MuggleBestFriend: You'd ''think'' that Arbeely would be this, considering that he's the only human that knows Ahmad's secret, but Ahmad is too prickly about his lack of independence (especially compared to his previous life) to open up properly.
*SecretKeeper: Arbeely is this for Ahmad, Rabbi Meyer for Chava.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 8,9 (click to see context) from:
In 1899, the Golem wakes up in the cargo of a ship bound for New York City. Despite being inhumanly strong and made of clay, her newborn status makes her fearful and confused about the humans surrounding her. She is taken in and named Chava by a kindly old rabbi, who warns her to never let others around her learn of her true nature, lest they destroy her.
to:
In 1899, the Golem wakes up in the cargo of a ship bound for New York City.NewYorkCity. Despite being inhumanly strong and made of clay, her newborn status makes her fearful and confused about the humans surrounding her. She is taken in and named Chava by a kindly old rabbi, who warns her to never let others around her learn of her true nature, lest they destroy her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 11 (click to see context) from:
After months of living amongst the humans, the two meet late at night, instantly recognizing each other as different from the others around them. A friendship is struck, and slowly the threads of their lives and the peoples' around them become more and more intertwined.
to:
After months of living amongst the humans, the two meet late at night, instantly recognizing each other as different from the others around them. A friendship is struck, and slowly the threads of their lives and the peoples' around them become more and more intertwined.intertwined.
----
!!Tropes in this novel include:
----
!!Tropes in this novel include:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5,6 (click to see context) from:
'The Golem and the Jinni'(2013) is a HistoricalFantasy novel written by Helene Wecker.
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3 (click to see context) from:
'''Chava:''' True. But I look at it, and I feel a certain way. Maybe that’s its purpose.\\
to:
'''Chava:''' True. But I look at it, and I feel a certain way. Maybe that’s its purpose.\\purpose.
'The Golem and the Jinni'(2013) is a HistoricalFantasy novel written by Helene Wecker.
In 1899, the Golem wakes up in the cargo of a ship bound for New York City. Despite being inhumanly strong and made of clay, her newborn status makes her fearful and confused about the humans surrounding her. She is taken in and named Chava by a kindly old rabbi, who warns her to never let others around her learn of her true nature, lest they destroy her.
Across town in Little Syria, the Jinni springs from a copper flask being repaired by the local tinsmith. After hundreds of years of imprisonment, the Jinni still has an iron manacle attached to his wrist, confining him to human form instead of his usual form of a spirit made of flame. Choosing the name Ahmad, he begins to work in the tinsmith's shop as an assistant to keep his cover.
After months of living amongst the humans, the two meet late at night, instantly recognizing each other as different from the others around them. A friendship is struck, and slowly the threads of their lives and the peoples' around them become more and more intertwined.
'The Golem and the Jinni'(2013) is a HistoricalFantasy novel written by Helene Wecker.
In 1899, the Golem wakes up in the cargo of a ship bound for New York City. Despite being inhumanly strong and made of clay, her newborn status makes her fearful and confused about the humans surrounding her. She is taken in and named Chava by a kindly old rabbi, who warns her to never let others around her learn of her true nature, lest they destroy her.
Across town in Little Syria, the Jinni springs from a copper flask being repaired by the local tinsmith. After hundreds of years of imprisonment, the Jinni still has an iron manacle attached to his wrist, confining him to human form instead of his usual form of a spirit made of flame. Choosing the name Ahmad, he begins to work in the tinsmith's shop as an assistant to keep his cover.
After months of living amongst the humans, the two meet late at night, instantly recognizing each other as different from the others around them. A friendship is struck, and slowly the threads of their lives and the peoples' around them become more and more intertwined.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 2,3 (click to see context) from:
'''Ahmad:''' “Yes, but it doesn’t grant wishes. It doesn’t do anything.”
'''Chava:''' “True. But I look at it, and I feel a certain way. Maybe that’s its purpose.
'''Chava:''' “True. But I look at it, and I feel a certain way. Maybe that’s its purpose.
to:
'''Ahmad:''' “Yes, Yes, but it doesn’t grant wishes. It doesn’t do anything.”
\\
'''Chava:'''“True.True. But I look at it, and I feel a certain way. Maybe that’s its purpose.\\
'''Chava:'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,3 (click to see context) from:
->''"So, it’s just stories now. And perhaps the humans did create their God. But does that make him less real? Take this arch. They created it. Now it exists.”
Ahmad: “Yes, but it doesn’t grant wishes. It doesn’t do anything.”
Chava: “True. But I look at it, and I feel a certain way. Maybe that’s its purpose."''
Ahmad: “Yes, but it doesn’t grant wishes. It doesn’t do anything.”
Chava: “True. But I look at it, and I feel a certain way. Maybe that’s its purpose."''
to:
Ahmad:
'''Ahmad:''' “Yes, but it doesn’t grant wishes. It doesn’t do anything.”
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
->''"So, it’s just stories now. And perhaps the humans did create their God. But does that make him less real? Take this arch. They created it. Now it exists.”
Ahmad: “Yes, but it doesn’t grant wishes. It doesn’t do anything.”
Chava: “True. But I look at it, and I feel a certain way. Maybe that’s its purpose."''
Ahmad: “Yes, but it doesn’t grant wishes. It doesn’t do anything.”
Chava: “True. But I look at it, and I feel a certain way. Maybe that’s its purpose."''