Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheFireNeverDies

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As of October 13, 2022, part 1 of the story, ''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/the-fire-never-dies-labors-star-ascendant.525137/ Labor's Star Ascendant]]'' has been completed.

to:

As of October 13, 2022, part 1 of the story, ''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/the-fire-never-dies-labors-star-ascendant.525137/ Labor's Star Ascendant]]'' has been completed. The timeline would continue in a new thread under the title ''"The Fire Never Dies II: The Red Colossus"''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FictionalPoliticalParty: The Post-SACW American political system has political parties which either only exists because of the revolution, or had existed before as in RealLife but had been radically altered by the revolution. Chief among them include:

to:

* FictionalPoliticalParty: The Post-SACW American political system has political parties which either only exists because of the revolution, or had existed before as in RealLife but had been radically altered by the revolution. Chief among them include:include (as of the 1920 Elections):



** The Revolutionary Socialist Party (RSP), headed by the likes of Leon Bronstein, Vincent St. John and Emma Goldman, is much less unified but much more revolutionary/radical than the SLP, calling for an openly confrontational foreign policy, the complete restructuring of American government, and a more extensive series of postwar trials.

to:

** The Revolutionary Socialist Party (RSP), headed by the likes of Leon Bronstein, Vincent St. John and Emma Goldman, is much less unified but much more revolutionary/radical than the SLP, calling for an openly confrontational foreign policy, the complete restructuring of American government, and a more extensive series of postwar trials.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AwesomeMomentOfCrowning: Technically it's a premiership inauguration, but the Inauguration of Premier Eugene V. Debs on 1st May 1920 marked the official beginning of the American Socialist Union as a firmly established socialist state.


Added DiffLines:

* FictionalPoliticalParty: The Post-SACW American political system has political parties which either only exists because of the revolution, or had existed before as in RealLife but had been radically altered by the revolution. Chief among them include:
** The Socialist Labour Party (SLP) is the leading party of the revolution and the nation, and at the start included leading Socialists such as Eugene Debs, Billy Haywood, Mother Jones and William Trautmann. They have a more moderate and pragmatic platform for socialist America among the mainstream socialist parties.
** The Revolutionary Socialist Party (RSP), headed by the likes of Leon Bronstein, Vincent St. John and Emma Goldman, is much less unified but much more revolutionary/radical than the SLP, calling for an openly confrontational foreign policy, the complete restructuring of American government, and a more extensive series of postwar trials.
** The Progressive Party is headed by the likes of Hiram Johnson and Sam Rayburn, consisting of politicians who are not originally socialist or still refrained from socialism, but had made their peace with the new socialist america they had found themselves in. They represents small cooperatives against big unions and favours the continued existence of a free market with within a market socialist economic framework.
** The Federalist Party, consisting of non-socialist figures from pre-revolution who remained like Clarence Edward McCartney and Calvin Coolidge, is the most openly reactionary and hostile to the socialist revolution (though not to the point of sedition), condemning the 'excesses' of the revolution and calling for restoration of old flag, capital and traditions of old America.

Added: 264

Changed: 29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As of October 13, 2022, ''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/the-fire-never-dies-labors-star-ascendant.525137/ Part 1: Labor's Star Ascendant]]'' has been completed.

to:

As of October 13, 2022, part 1 of the story, ''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/the-fire-never-dies-labors-star-ascendant.525137/ Part 1: Labor's Star Ascendant]]'' has been completed.


Added DiffLines:

* MyCountryRightOrWrong: This is the attitude of the Texas Red Guard, largely formed out of the former Army of the Plains. They may not like what America has become, but they'll still defend it against a foreign incursion (in this case a raid by the Mexican army).

Added: 1298

Changed: 256

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/the-fire-never-dies-labors-star-ascendant.525137/ The Fire Never Dies]]''''' is an AlternateHistory timeline on Website/AlternateHistoryDotCom by Tropers/{{Meshakhad}}, depicting an America that eventually experiences a successful socialist revolution, as several of the schisms that the American socialist movement suffered are averted or mended.

to:

'''''[[https://www.'''''The Fire Never Dies''''' is an AlternateHistory timeline on Website/AlternateHistoryDotCom by Tropers/{{Meshakhad}}, depicting an America that eventually experiences a successful socialist revolution, as several of the schisms that the American socialist movement suffered are averted or mended. The absence of the United States (and American war materiel) from World War I leads to a negotiated settlement rather than either side claiming victory.

As of October 13, 2022, ''[[https://www.
alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/the-fire-never-dies-labors-star-ascendant.525137/ The Fire Never Dies]]''''' is an AlternateHistory timeline on Website/AlternateHistoryDotCom by Tropers/{{Meshakhad}}, depicting an America that eventually experiences a successful socialist revolution, as several of the schisms that the American socialist movement suffered are averted or mended.
Part 1: Labor's Star Ascendant]]'' has been completed.



** After the war in America is over, the GDC follows through on their promise to Pancho Villa, sending two expeditionary forces to Mexico to overthrow the government there. The Mexican Constitutional Army is completely overpowered by the Red Army.



* MonumentalBattle:
** During the Battle of Washington, firefights break out in the Smithsonian and the Capitol.
* MonumentalDamage:
** The White House is destroyed by artillery fire during the final assault on Washington (as is the War Department).



* RushmoreRefacement:
** After the [[spoiler:Simmons coup]], the KKK turns the incomplete Lincoln Memorial into the ''Nathan Bedford Forrest Memorial''. Fortunately, the actual statue of Lincoln was still in the Bronx at the time. After the war, the Lincoln Memorial is built... in Central Park, where it serves as the backdrop to Debs' inauguration as Premier.



* TokenFemaleTeammate: Activist Mary Harris Jones, better known as Mother Jones, is the sole woman to command an army during the Second American Revolution, leading the Army of Knoxville in the Appalachians. After the war, she becomes the ASU's first Deputy Premier.



* WarIsHell: The Second American Civil War had many brutal moments and war crimes to rival the horrors of the Great War in Europe. Notable mention include the brutal fighting and devastating famine in Calicornia which earned the state the nickname as "The Golden Abbatoir" [[note]]Abbatoir means 'Slaughterhouse'[[/note]], the use of chemical weapons and city-flattening artillery barrages by the Reds, atrocities by the KKK and the Whites such as the Huffington Massacres, the American Flu...

to:

* WarIsHell: The Second American Civil War had many brutal moments and war crimes to rival the horrors of the Great War in Europe. Notable mention include the brutal fighting and devastating famine in Calicornia California which earned the state the nickname as "The Golden Abbatoir" [[note]]Abbatoir means 'Slaughterhouse'[[/note]], the use of chemical weapons and city-flattening artillery barrages by the Reds, atrocities by the KKK and the Whites such as the Huffington Massacres, the American Flu...

Added: 652

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Subverted with the Reds in comparison, who while no saints ultimately come off as the better of the two forces, and in fact responded furiously to atrocities committed by the Whites. Their [[ThisIsUnforgivable response]] to the Huffington Massacre was to [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge systematically]] [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill annihilate]] the Army of the Ohio with everything they got.

to:

** Subverted with the Reds in comparison, who while no saints ultimately come off as the better of the two forces, and in fact responded furiously to atrocities committed by the Whites. Their [[ThisIsUnforgivable response]] to the Huffington Massacre Massacres was to [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge systematically]] [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill annihilate]] the Army of the Ohio with everything they got.


Added DiffLines:

* SaltTheEarth: As the CivilWar turns against the Whites, they began to implement scorch earth policies to either slow down the Reds or simply to spite them.


Added DiffLines:

* WarIsHell: The Second American Civil War had many brutal moments and war crimes to rival the horrors of the Great War in Europe. Notable mention include the brutal fighting and devastating famine in Calicornia which earned the state the nickname as "The Golden Abbatoir" [[note]]Abbatoir means 'Slaughterhouse'[[/note]], the use of chemical weapons and city-flattening artillery barrages by the Reds, atrocities by the KKK and the Whites such as the Huffington Massacres, the American Flu...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A FlashForward in Update 100 revealed this happened to ''[[spoiler:Britain]]'' of all places years after the Second American Revolution, falling under a [[spoiler:Falangist regime headed by the likes of [[spoiler:Baron Garvagh, General Fuller, William Joyce]] and others.

to:

** A FlashForward in Update 100 revealed this happened to ''[[spoiler:Britain]]'' of all places years after the Second American Revolution, falling under a [[spoiler:Falangist regime headed by the likes of [[spoiler:Baron Baron Garvagh, General Fuller, William Joyce]] and others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A FlashFoward in Update 100 revealed this happened to ''[[spoiler:Britain]]'' of all places years after the Second American Revolution, falling under a [[spoiler:Falangist regime headed by the likes of [[spoiler:Baron Garvagh, General Fuller, William Joyce]] and others.

to:

** A FlashFoward FlashForward in Update 100 revealed this happened to ''[[spoiler:Britain]]'' of all places years after the Second American Revolution, falling under a [[spoiler:Falangist regime headed by the likes of [[spoiler:Baron Garvagh, General Fuller, William Joyce]] and others.

Added: 1090

Changed: 515

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ANaziByAnyOtherName: Falangism, which became the TFND-verse's analogue of Fascism, became prominent following the Great War and the Second American Revolution in part due to the RedScare. [[spoiler:A FlashForward revealed Britain to be among the nations which fell under a Falangist dictatorship]].



* TyrantTakesTheHelm: After President Wilson suffered a stroke and the remainder of the US government considered surrendering to the Reds, General William J. Simmons, Imperial Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan, took control of the White forces in a military coup, destroying not only any chance of a negotiated surrender but also any remaining legitimacy of the US government. Simmons fully intended to remake America in the KKK's white supremacist image if given the chance, but the Reds' imminent victory ensured it would never come to pass.

to:

* TyrantTakesTheHelm: TyrantTakesTheHelm:
**
After President Wilson suffered a stroke and the remainder of the US government considered surrendering to the Reds, General William J. Simmons, Imperial Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan, took control of the White forces in a military coup, destroying not only any chance of a negotiated surrender but also any remaining legitimacy of the US government. Simmons fully intended to remake America in the KKK's white supremacist image if given the chance, but the Reds' imminent victory ensured it would never come to pass.
** A FlashFoward in Update 100 revealed this happened to ''[[spoiler:Britain]]'' of all places years after the Second American Revolution, falling under a [[spoiler:Falangist regime headed by the likes of [[spoiler:Baron Garvagh, General Fuller, William Joyce]] and others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ItsPersonal: Vice Admiral Ernest King was not a hardcore socialist and was more or less swept up to the Reds' side by the Great Mutiny which saw the US Atlantic Fleet defecting to the socialists, but he had a very personal beef with his former high command, having railed for years against the conservative Navy establishment and holding his superiors in utter disdain for refusing to implement radical reforms he believes to be crucial to modernise and strengthen the navy. Add to the loss of the ''Texas'' and ''New York'' at the Battle of Chesapeake Bay, Ernest King was left ''very'' eager and wanting to destroy the White navy as an effective fighting force to make up for years of frustration and earlier setbacks. He would get his chance to do so at the Battle of Miami Beach.

Added: 981

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArmiesAreEvil: The White forces increasingly became this as the KKK which Wilson aligned with become increasingly influential within it, on top of growing desperation and fanaticism as the Red forces gain the upper hand in the Second American Civil War. The Army of the Ohio exemplifies this after it comes under the command of KKK member General Huffington, who made a standing order to treat ''every'' African-American as an enemy combatant following the Memphis Uprising, resulting in the Huffington Massacres where White forces murdered thousands of innocent African-American civilians.
** Subverted with the Reds in comparison, who while no saints ultimately come off as the better of the two forces, and in fact responded furiously to atrocities committed by the Whites. Their [[ThisIsUnforgivable response]] to the Huffington Massacre was to [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge systematically]] [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill annihilate]] the Army of the Ohio with everything they got.



** General Pershing, who would had commanded US forces in WWI in RealLife, was killed during [[spoiler:TheCoup launched by General William J. Simmons and the KKK to prevent the US government from surrendering to the Reds towards the end of the SACW]].
** [[spoiler:Both President Woodrow Wilson and General William J. Simmons were killed by an artillery barrage from the Reds midway through the Battle of Washington]]

to:

** General Pershing, who would had commanded US forces in WWI in RealLife, was killed murdered during [[spoiler:TheCoup launched by General William J. Simmons and the KKK to prevent the US government from surrendering to the Reds towards the end of the SACW]].
** [[spoiler:Both President Woodrow Wilson and General William J. Simmons were killed by an artillery barrage from the Reds midway through the Battle of Washington]]Washington]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** General Pershing, who would had commanded US forces in WWI in RealLife, was killed during [[spoiler:TheCoup launched by General William J. Simmons and the KKK to prevent the US government from surrendering to the Reds towards the end of the SACW]].

Added: 2691

Changed: 502

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CurbStompBattle: The Battle of Miami is extremely one-sided, with the White fleet (including most of the US Navy's remaining combat strength) being almost completely wiped out for few enemy casualties. The Battle of Chesapeake Bay also qualifies, except the Whites knew that their chances were negligible, and they prioritized [[TakingYouWithMe taking as many Red ships with them as they could]].

to:

* CurbStompBattle: CurbStompBattle:
**
The Battle of Miami is extremely one-sided, with the White fleet (including most of the US Navy's remaining combat strength) being almost completely wiped out for few enemy casualties. The Battle of Chesapeake Bay also qualifies, except the Whites knew that their chances were negligible, and they prioritized [[TakingYouWithMe taking as many Red ships with them as they could]].could]].
** The Army of the Ohio was systematically obliterated by the Red forces with everything they have - up to and including chemical weapons - within three weeks after the Reds received reports of General Huffington's orders to treat ''every'' African-American as an enemy combatant and the subsequent massacres of thousands of Black civilians.



* EveryoneHasStandards:
** Leon Bronstein was absolutely enraged when he heard reports of the Huffington Massacres, and responded to the Army of the Ohio's massacre of thousands of innocent African-American civilians with orders to Red forces to destroy the Army of the Ohio with everything they got. [[CurbstompBattle Said White army would be wiped out within three weeks]].
** As much as Winston Churchill oppose the Socialists of America as a matter of principle, he opposes Falangism just as if not much more, and greatly regretted [[spoiler:not noticing and do more to stop its rise in Britain until it was too late due to being too distracted by the RedScare]].



* FlashForward: Update 100 is an extract from decades after the revolution which highlights foreign reactions to the victory of the Reds in America and the failure of exiled American political figures to form a legitimate government in exile. What made it a WhamEpisode is not that it revealed in response to the communist threat many nations would go Falangist, the timeline's equivalent of Fascism, as that was already alluded to much earlier, but rather the reveal that [[spoiler:''Britain'' was among the nations which had gone Falangist, with Churchill the author of the extract lamenting that he and others were too distracted by the RedScare to notice or stop it until it was too late]].



** The KKK and Southern Whites, aligned with the Wilson Administration, had made Blacks' already misrable lives in the South even worse over the CivilWar out of paranoia of Red sympathies, racism and sheer frustration at the economic deprivations they are enduring due to the conflict. This only served to galvanise the African-Americans into supporting the revolution, and with support and supplies provided to them by the IWW, they would launch the Memphis Uprising which set the entire 'Black Belt' aflame, which would eventually lead to the collapse of the White forces in the Southern United States.



* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: After the Memphis uprising and the death of General Carleton at the hands of a black partisan, the Klansman-turned-general Joe Huffington takes command of the Army of the Ohio in Kentucky and Tennessee. He issues an order that all African-Americans are to be treated as enemy combatants, resulting in the slaughter of thousands of black civilians. In response, the Red Army shifts its strategy from "slowly strangle the Army of the Ohio" to "wipe them out by any means necessary". This includes the use of [[DeadlyGas chemical weapons]] by the Army of Cleveland.

to:

* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: After the Memphis uprising and the death of General Carleton at the hands of a black partisan, the Klansman-turned-general Joe Huffington takes command of the Army of the Ohio in Kentucky and Tennessee. He issues an order that all African-Americans are to be treated as enemy combatants, resulting in the slaughter of thousands of black civilians. In response, the Red Army shifts its strategy from "slowly strangle the Army of the Ohio" to "wipe them out by any means necessary". This includes the use of [[DeadlyGas chemical weapons]] by the Army of Cleveland. [[CurbstompBattle Within three weeks]], the Army of the Ohio was [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill systematically annihilated]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ThePlague: The Spanish Flu appears in this timeline as well, only it is called the ''American'' Flu, owing to its appearance in Kansas[[note:While the precise origin of the 1918 flu pandemic remains disputed, the first confirmed case was diagnosed at an Army camp in Kansas]]. Leon Bronstein almost became a victim of it, but recovered just in time to coordinate the Delmarva Offensive. It was noted that while it indiscriminately infected and decimated both the Reds and Whites, it ultimately hurted the Whites more as the Reds have better access to medical care, while the Whites failed to do proper preparations due to both lacking the industries to produce them (most of them fell to the Reds' control) and mistakes by the Whites leadership which caused delays and problems to combat the disease.

to:

* ThePlague: The Spanish Flu appears in this timeline as well, only it is called the ''American'' Flu, owing to its appearance in Kansas[[note:While Kansas[[note]]While the precise origin of the 1918 flu pandemic remains disputed, the first confirmed case was diagnosed at an Army camp in Kansas]].Kansas[[/note]]. Leon Bronstein almost became a victim of it, but recovered just in time to coordinate the Delmarva Offensive. It was noted that while it indiscriminately infected and decimated both the Reds and Whites, it ultimately hurted the Whites more as the Reds have better access to medical care, while the Whites failed to do proper preparations due to both lacking the industries to produce them (most of them fell to the Reds' control) and mistakes by the Whites leadership which caused delays and problems to combat the disease.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: After the Memphis uprising and the death of General Carleton at the hands of a black partisan, the Klansman-turned-general Joe Huffington takes command of the Army of the Ohio in Kentucky and Tennessee. He issues an order that all African-Americans are to be treated as enemy combatants, resulting in the slaughter of thousands of black civilians. In response, the Red Army shifts its strategy from "slowly strangle the Army of the Ohio" to "wipe them out by any means necessary". This includes the use of [[DeadlyGas chemical weapons]] by the Army of Cleveland.

Added: 1108

Changed: 814

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KnowWhenToFoldThem: When Bill Haywood and Governor Hiram Johnson negotiated the latter's submission to the Revolutionary government in Chicago in the Spring of 1918 that meant Haywood's Army of the Cascades, the California National Guard, and the Army of San Francisco under Mayor Jackson Wilson of Berkeley were more or less pointed at the same target. By the end of July it was clear to Admiral Caperton, U. S. Pacific Fleet Commander and functional ruler of White-held California, that trying to hold the Los Angeles-to-San Diego coastal strip would be futile so he announced his intent to evacuate to Panama, released whatever forces willing to take their chances surrendering to the Reds (he had never bothered to implement Wilson's order to discharge all Colored servicemen), and loaded on those civilians who preferred not to.

to:

* KnowWhenToFoldThem: KnowWhenToFoldThem:
**
When Bill Haywood and Governor Hiram Johnson negotiated the latter's submission to the Revolutionary government in Chicago in the Spring of 1918 that meant Haywood's Army of the Cascades, the California National Guard, and the Army of San Francisco under Mayor Jackson Wilson of Berkeley were more or less pointed at the same target. By the end of July it was clear to Admiral Caperton, U. S. Pacific Fleet Commander and functional ruler of White-held California, that trying to hold the Los Angeles-to-San Diego coastal strip would be futile so he announced his intent to evacuate to Panama, released whatever forces willing to take their chances surrendering to the Reds (he had never bothered to implement Wilson's order to discharge all Colored servicemen), and loaded on those civilians who preferred not to.to.
** After series of disasters for the Whites (including the fall of Salt Lake City, the withdrawal from Southern California, the Memphis Uprising, and the capture of the Lower Mississippi), Governor William P. Hobby of Texas and General Liggett of the Army of the Plains surrender to the Reds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheReveal: See WhamLine for more details.


Added DiffLines:

* WhamLine: At first, [[spoiler:update 100]] seems fairly normal, mainly covering the European reactions to [[spoiler:the GDC officially winning the Second American Revolution]], but ends with a major reveal: [[spoiler:''Britain'', and not Germany, ends up falling to [[ANaziByAnyOtherName Falangism]].]]
-->[[spoiler:…Our mistake, in retrospect, was in assuming that a simple act of Parliament would settle the matter. It did not. Those who had opposed recognition were hardened anti-socialists. Many of their names – Baron Garvagh, General Fuller, William Joyce – would go on to infamy. We – and I surely include myself in this – became so fixated on the threat from across the Atlantic that we ignored the threat at home…]]\\
[[spoiler:- From The Enemy Was In Our House: How We Surrendered Britain To Falangism by [[{{UsefulNotes/WinstonChurchill}} Winston Churchill]]]]
** [[spoiler:For those who don't recognize those names, all of the people Churchill listed were [[TruthInTelevision real life British Fascists]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DecapitationStrike: At the Battle of Washington DC, the Reds managed one against the White forces in the city when they directed a massive artillery barrage downtown, taking the White forces by surprise. When the dust settled, [[spoiler:both President Woodrow Wilson and General Simmons]] were killed along with General Hiram W. Evans and most of the Army of the Chesapeake’s leadership.

to:

* DecapitationStrike: At the Battle of Washington DC, Washington, the Reds managed one against the White forces in the capital city when they directed a massive artillery barrage downtown, taking the White forces by surprise. When the dust settled, [[spoiler:both President Woodrow Wilson and General Simmons]] were killed along with General Hiram W. Evans and most of the Army of the Chesapeake’s leadership.



* FinalBattle: The Battle of Washington DC would be one for the Second American Civil War, with the Reds storming the city across the frozen Potomac river after encircling it and bombarding the city's defences as well as other critical locations with artillery bombardment. It took a month and levelled much of the city before the White defenders and what's left of the US government finally surrendered. While the civil war would continue a little longer with the Reds cleaning up the fragmented White forces across the country, the fall of Washington DC marks the effective end of the United States of America.

to:

* FinalBattle: The Battle of Washington DC would be one for the Second American Civil War, culminating with the Reds storming the city across the frozen Potomac river after encircling it and bombarding the city's defences as well as other critical locations with artillery bombardment. It took a month overall and levelled much of the city before the White defenders and what's left of the US government finally surrendered. While the civil war would continue a little longer with the Reds cleaning up the fragmented White forces across the country, the fall of Washington DC marks the effective end of the Whites as a unified military force and with it the end of the United States of America.

Added: 311

Changed: 79

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CapitalOffensive: The capture of Washington DC became a main objective of the Red forces towards the end of the Second American Civil War, especially after General William J. Simmons (Leader of the KKK) launched a military coup and took over the White forces, which ended any chance of a negotiated surrender.



* DecapitationStrike: At the Battle of Washington DC, the Reds managed one against the White forces in the city when they directed a massive artillery barrage downtown, taking the White forces by surprise. When the dust settled, [[spoiler:both the already stroke-incapacitated President Woodrow Wilson and General Simmons were killed]] along with General Evans and most of the Army of the Chesapeake’s leadership.

to:

* DecapitationStrike: At the Battle of Washington DC, the Reds managed one against the White forces in the city when they directed a massive artillery barrage downtown, taking the White forces by surprise. When the dust settled, [[spoiler:both the already stroke-incapacitated President Woodrow Wilson and General Simmons Simmons]] were killed]] killed along with General Hiram W. Evans and most of the Army of the Chesapeake’s leadership.



** [[spoiler:Both President Woodrow Wilson and General Simmons were killed by an artillery barrage from the Reds in the early stage of the Battle of Washington DC]]

to:

** [[spoiler:Both President Woodrow Wilson and General William J. Simmons were killed by an artillery barrage from the Reds in the early stage of midway through the Battle of Washington DC]]Washington]]

Added: 597

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Late in the CivilWar, President Wilson had suffered a stroke, the Whites had failed to secure foreign aid, and the Reds had by then captured most of the country. At this juncture the US government had finally decided to stop delaying the inevitable and sent overtures to the Reds' leadership for a negotiated surrender. Then General William J. Simmons, leader of the Ku Klux Klan, launched a military coup and took over the leadership of the White forces in opposition to it, destroying not only any chance for a peaceful end of the war but also any remaining legitimacy of the US government.



* IncurableCoughOfDoom: US Secretary of State Robert Lansing starts coughing in the middle of a speech at the Basel Conference. He dies a few days later from the American Flu.

to:

* IncurableCoughOfDoom: IncurableCoughOfDeath: US Secretary of State Robert Lansing starts coughing in the middle of a speech at the Basel Conference. He dies a few days later from the American Flu.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DecapitationAttack: At the Battle of Washington DC, the Reds managed one against the White forces in the city when they directed a massive artillery barrage downtown, taking the White forces by surprise. When the dust settled, [[spoiler:both the already stroke-incapacitated President Woodrow Wilson and General Simmons were killed]] along with General Evans and most of the Army of the Chesapeake’s leadership.

to:

* DecapitationAttack: DecapitationStrike: At the Battle of Washington DC, the Reds managed one against the White forces in the city when they directed a massive artillery barrage downtown, taking the White forces by surprise. When the dust settled, [[spoiler:both the already stroke-incapacitated President Woodrow Wilson and General Simmons were killed]] along with General Evans and most of the Army of the Chesapeake’s leadership.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DecapitationAttack: At the Battle of Washington DC, the Reds managed one against the White forces in the city when they directed a massive artillery barrage downtown, taking the White forces by surprise. When the dust settled, [[spoiler:both the already stroke-incapacitated President Woodrow Wilson and General Simmons were killed]] along with General Evans and most of the Army of the Chesapeake’s leadership.


Added DiffLines:

* MonumentalDamage: The Battle of Washington DC resulted in considerable damage to the capital of the US and many of its famous landmarks during the month of battle overall and ten days worth of urban warfare, most notably the flattening of the White House and the State, War, and Navy Building (Currently called the Eisenhower Executive Office Building) by artillery fire.


Added DiffLines:

* TyrantTakesTheHelm: After President Wilson suffered a stroke and the remainder of the US government considered surrendering to the Reds, General William J. Simmons, Imperial Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan, took control of the White forces in a military coup, destroying not only any chance of a negotiated surrender but also any remaining legitimacy of the US government. Simmons fully intended to remake America in the KKK's white supremacist image if given the chance, but the Reds' imminent victory ensured it would never come to pass.


Added DiffLines:

* WashingtonDCInvasion: The climax of the Second American Civil War was the Battle of Washington, which culminated in the invasion of Washington DC itself. With the Reds' crushing numerical superiority, the White forces would surrender after ten days of urban warfare.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler:Both President Woodrow Wilson and General Simmons were killed by an artillery barrage from the Reds in the early stage of the Battle of Washington DC]]


Added DiffLines:

* FinalBattle: The Battle of Washington DC would be one for the Second American Civil War, with the Reds storming the city across the frozen Potomac river after encircling it and bombarding the city's defences as well as other critical locations with artillery bombardment. It took a month and levelled much of the city before the White defenders and what's left of the US government finally surrendered. While the civil war would continue a little longer with the Reds cleaning up the fragmented White forces across the country, the fall of Washington DC marks the effective end of the United States of America.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IncurableCoughOfDoom: US Secretary of State Robert Lansing starts coughing in the middle of a speech at the Basel Conference. He dies a few days later from the American Flu.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Commissariats (basically the Red cabinet) operate on a similar principle. Without a cadre of career civil servants to draw upon, the first Commissars are generally people without experience in government administration (although they do usually have expertise in their specific field).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Many notable labor activists, such as Bill "Big Bill" Haywood, Vincent St. John, and William Trautmann, successfully run for political office. Others (also including Haywood) become military commanders in the Second American Revolution.

to:

** Many notable labor activists, such as Bill "Big Bill" Haywood, Vincent St. John, and William Trautmann, successfully run for political office. Others (also including Haywood) Haywood, St. John, and Trautmann) become military commanders in the Second American Revolution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** General Guy Carleton, commanding the Army of the Ohio in Kentucky and Tennessee, orders that all blacks - regardless of age or gender - be considered enemy combatants.

Added: 739

Changed: 894

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Woodrow Wilson, who responds to the civil unrest with increasingly harsh measures.
* HoistByHisOwnPetard:

to:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: HistoricalVillainUpgrade:
**
Woodrow Wilson, who responds to the civil unrest with increasingly harsh measures.
** General Guy Carleton, commanding the Army of the Ohio in Kentucky and Tennessee, orders that all blacks - regardless of age or gender - be considered enemy combatants.
* HoistByHisOwnPetard: HoistByHisOwnPetard:



* KnowWhenToFoldThem: When Bill Haywood and Governor Hiram Johnson negotiated the latter's submission to the Revolutionary government in Chicago in the Spring of 1918 that meant Haywood's Army of the Cascades, the California National Guard, and the Army of San Francisco under Mayor Jackson Wilson of Berkeley were more or less pointed at the same target. By the end of July it was clear to Admiral Caperton, U. S. Pacific Fleet Commander and functional ruler of White-held California, that trying to hold the Los Angeles-to-San Diego costal strip would be futile so he announced his intent to evacuate, released whatever forces willing to take thier chances surrendering to the Reds (he had never bothered to implement Wilson's order to discharge all Colored servicemen), and loaded on those civilians who preferred not to.

to:

* KnowWhenToFoldThem: When Bill Haywood and Governor Hiram Johnson negotiated the latter's submission to the Revolutionary government in Chicago in the Spring of 1918 that meant Haywood's Army of the Cascades, the California National Guard, and the Army of San Francisco under Mayor Jackson Wilson of Berkeley were more or less pointed at the same target. By the end of July it was clear to Admiral Caperton, U. S. Pacific Fleet Commander and functional ruler of White-held California, that trying to hold the Los Angeles-to-San Diego costal coastal strip would be futile so he announced his intent to evacuate, evacuate to Panama, released whatever forces willing to take thier their chances surrendering to the Reds (he had never bothered to implement Wilson's order to discharge all Colored servicemen), and loaded on those civilians who preferred not to.



* SparedByTheAdaptation: Daniel DeLeon, a highly influential American socialist thinker, survives the illness that killed him IOTL thanks to his newspaper, the ''Daily Worker'', being more successful, which in turn improves his living situation and access to medical care.
* StrikeEpisode: Several. So far, they're largely OTL strikes, but with generally better outcomes. The Great Longshoremen's Strike, on the other hand, leads to the outbreak of the Second American Revolution.

to:

* SparedByTheAdaptation: SparedByTheAdaptation:
**
Daniel DeLeon, [=DeLeon=], a highly influential American socialist thinker, survives the illness that killed him IOTL thanks to his newspaper, the ''Daily Worker'', being more successful, which in turn improves his living situation and access to medical care.
care. His illness does force him to temporarily withdraw from politics for a time.
** The Mexican revolutionary Pancho Villa never begins his raids on the United States that led to him being killed as he receives support from American socialists. When the Second American Revolution breaks out, he brings his army across the border, offering his assistance to the Reds in exchange for their help in winning the Mexican Revolution.
* StrikeEpisode: Several. So far, they're Some are largely OTL strikes, but with generally better outcomes. The Great Longshoremen's Strike, on the other hand, leads to the outbreak of the Second American Revolution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The three-way war in California's Central Valley, complete with forcible requisitions of crops by all sides, ''did'' cause one there.


Added DiffLines:

* KnowWhenToFoldThem: When Bill Haywood and Governor Hiram Johnson negotiated the latter's submission to the Revolutionary government in Chicago in the Spring of 1918 that meant Haywood's Army of the Cascades, the California National Guard, and the Army of San Francisco under Mayor Jackson Wilson of Berkeley were more or less pointed at the same target. By the end of July it was clear to Admiral Caperton, U. S. Pacific Fleet Commander and functional ruler of White-held California, that trying to hold the Los Angeles-to-San Diego costal strip would be futile so he announced his intent to evacuate, released whatever forces willing to take thier chances surrendering to the Reds (he had never bothered to implement Wilson's order to discharge all Colored servicemen), and loaded on those civilians who preferred not to.


Added DiffLines:

* NeutralityBacklash: Governor Johnson of California alone tried to hold his state aloof from the Wilson administration and the Revolutionaries. Unforunately that put him at odds with the IWW-aligned Army of San Francisco dominating the Bay Area and the U. S. Navy's Pacific Fleet which took over Los Angeles. The MeleeATrois between the Reds, Whites, and California National Guard (AKA the Blues) reduced the Central Valley to famine and earned the state in general the nickname [[WarIsHell "The Golden Abbatoir"]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ClosestThingWeGot: The Reds began the war with virtually no veteran officers, so it fell to the IWW's union organizers (many of whom were also elected politicians) to organize and command the Red Army. For the most part, it worked.
* CurbStompBattle: The Battle of Miami is extremely one-sided, with the White fleet (including most of the US Navy's remaining combat strength) being almost completely wiped out for few enemy casualties. The Battle of Chesapeake Bay also qualifies, except the Whites knew that their chances were negligible, and they prioritized [[TakingYouWithMe taking as many Red ships with them as they could]].


Added DiffLines:

* GeneralRipper: General Vincent St. John. He's competent, but utterly ruthless (and fairly egotistical). When Salt Lake City refused to surrender, he razed the city with artillery (although that might also be a case of prioritizing his men's lives).


Added DiffLines:

** Huey Long describes the ruthless tactics used by partisans in the South, such as breaking into a Klansman's home and murdering him in his bed.


Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalBadassUpgrade: Pretty much every single Red Army general, as almost none of them had any military experience before the Revolution, mostly being veteran organizers. For the most part, they rise to the challenge. The only ones who don't fit this are Bronstein (who also did it in our history) and the few actual soldiers like Charles Whittlesley and Omar Bradley.


Added DiffLines:

* MoreDakka: The default strategy of a Red general when faced with serious opposition is to hammer it flat with a massive artillery barrage.


Added DiffLines:

* WeHaveReserves: Averted. Despite the Red Army having a significant numerical advantage, they avoid getting their soldiers killed unnecessarily, mostly striking where the enemy is overstretched.

Top