Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheBoxcarChildren

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptedOut: Many characters from the original books, including Mrs. McGregor's husband, Aunt Jane's farmhands, Benny's friend Mike Wood, and the grandfather's pilot/former spy friend John Carter completely disappear in the post-Warner books.

to:

* AdaptedOut: Many characters from the original books, including Mrs. McGregor's [=McGregor=]'s husband, Aunt Jane's farmhands, Benny's friend Mike Wood, and the grandfather's pilot/former spy friend John Carter completely disappear in the post-Warner books.



** Mr. McGregor, who the kids reunite with Mrs. McGregor in the third book, disappears after the original books.

to:

** Mr. McGregor, who the kids reunite with Mrs. McGregor [=McGregor=] in the third book, disappears after the original books.



* WealthyEverAfter: The first book ends this way, with the children moving in with their grandfather, who is described as being very rich and living in a huge house with many servants. The rest of the books by Warner downplay his wealth, with the maids being replaced by a single housekeeper, Mrs. [=McGregor=]. In the post-Warner series, the Aldens are an upper middle class family (with a housekeeper and enough room to put a boxcar in their back yard).

to:

* WealthyEverAfter: The first book ends this way, with the children moving in with their grandfather, who is described as being very rich and living in a huge house with many servants. The rest of the books by Warner downplay his wealth, with the maids being replaced by a single housekeeper, Mrs. [=McGregor=]. In the post-Warner series, the Aldens are an upper middle class family (with a housekeeper and housekeeper), albeit one with enough room to put a boxcar in their back yard).yard for a boxcar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IllGirl: Near the end of the first book, Violet becomes sick with a fever. The other children eventually have no choice but to take her to a hospital, even though they know that giving their names means the likelihood that their grandfather will find them. He does, but it turns out for the better.

to:

* IllGirl: Near the end of the first book, Violet becomes sick with a fever. The other children eventually have no choice but to take her to a hospital, friend who's a doctor, even though they know that giving their names means the likelihood that their grandfather will find them. He does, but it turns out for the better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdultFear: Violet's fever and illness in the first book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ComicBookTime: Initially set in the depression era, more recent books have included passenger jets, tropical cruises, and the internet. They have a different summer adventure in every book, and they're all still young somehow...

to:

* ComicBookTime: Initially set in the depression era, more recent books have included passenger jets, tropical cruises, and the internet.internet (yet the boxcar remains a wood-sided boxcar that would have been retired by the 1950s). They have a different summer adventure in every book, and they're all still young somehow...



* WealthyEverAfter: The first book ends this way, with the children moving in with their grandfather, who is described as being very rich and living in a huge house with many servants. The rest of the books by Warner downplay his wealth, with the maids being replaced by a single housekeeper, Mrs. [=McGregor=]. In the post-Warner series, the Aldens are an upper middle class family (with a housekeeper).

to:

* WealthyEverAfter: The first book ends this way, with the children moving in with their grandfather, who is described as being very rich and living in a huge house with many servants. The rest of the books by Warner downplay his wealth, with the maids being replaced by a single housekeeper, Mrs. [=McGregor=]. In the post-Warner series, the Aldens are an upper middle class family (with a housekeeper).housekeeper and enough room to put a boxcar in their back yard).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DecemberDecemberRomance: Aunt Jane and Andy Bean, who marry in their 70s after decades apart. Also a case of TheOneThatGotAway, as Andy had proposed to her unsuccessfully in their youth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DefeatMeansFriendship: If the culprit of whatever mystery they're solving has any decency in him/her at all, he'll be reconciled to the Aldens right away.

to:

* DefeatMeansFriendship: If the culprit of whatever mystery they're solving has any decency in him/her at all, he'll be reconciled to the Aldens right away. Averted in books where the culprit is arrested.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GreenAesop: The 18th book, where the grandfather educates a paint factory owner on ways to cut down on water and air pollution and helps reconcile him with his environmentalist sons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptedOut: Many characters from the original books, including Mrs. McGregor's husband, Aunt Jane's farmhands, Benny's friend Mike Wood, and the grandfather's pilot/former spy friend John Carter completely disappear in the post-Warner books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ILoveNuclearPower: In book 4, it's discovered that the black and yellow rocks in the fireplace at Aunt Jane's ranch are uranium. By the next visit to Aunt Jane, the sleepy ranch town is now home to a massive uranium mine.


Added DiffLines:

* Retcon: Plenty in the post-Warner books
** One book features them going on a train for the first time, ignoring two train trips they took in the Warner books
** Mr. McGregor, who the kids reunite with Mrs. McGregor in the third book, disappears after the original books.
** The kids' grown cousin Joe and his wife Alice are later retconned to be their aunt and uncle ([[AdaptationInducedPlotHole inadvertently raising the question of why the kids don't live with them]]).
** Even within the post-Warner books, the family goes from living in Massachusetts to Connecticut.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngstWhatAngst: The first book doesn't show any of the Alden kids grieving the loss of their parents or stressed about how they're going to survive. Mostly averted in the movie when Benny asks if they're going to live in the boxcar forever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngstWhatAngst: The first book doesn't show any of the Alden kids grieving the loss of their parents or stressed about how they're going to survive. Mostly averted in the movie when Benny asks if they're going to live in the boxcar forever.



* StrongFamilyResemblance: In the movie, Henry specifically looks a lot like his dad based on an old photograph. It's also easy to tell that the Boxcar are related when all four of them are in a group.

to:

* StrongFamilyResemblance: In the movie, Henry specifically looks a lot like his dad based on an old photograph. It's also easy to tell that the Boxcar kids are related when all four of them are in a group.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StrongFamilyResemblance: In the movie, Henry specifically looks a lot like his dad based on an old photograph. It's also easy to tell that the Boxcar are related when all four of them are in a group.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: Several plot points are left unaddressed in the first book and the movie based on it:
** It's never explained how Mr. and Mrs. Alden died, leaving their kids orphaned. There's also no mention of whether the Boxcar kids stuck around long enough for the funeral and there aren't many details on the kind of lives they led prior to their parents death.
** We never learn why James Henry Walden had no contact with his son and the Boxcar kids. Henry explains early that he and their mother didn't get along, but this isn't elaborated on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: Several plot points are left unaddressed in the first book and the movie based on it:
** It's never explained how Mr. and Mrs. Alden died, leaving their kids orphaned. There's also no mention of whether the Boxcar kids stuck around long enough for the funeral and there aren't many details on the kind of lives they led prior to their parents death.
** We never learn why James Henry Walden had no contact with his son and the Boxcar kids. Henry explains early that he and their mother didn't get along, but this isn't elaborated on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalDyeJob: Jessie is shown as being brunette like her siblings in the books cover art, but in the animated movie she's a redhead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnimatedAdaptation: One was released in 2014, and is a straight up adaptation of the first book. It was reasonably well received, currently having a user-rating of 7.5 on [=IMDB=].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MythologyGag: In the animated movie, the bakery they visit is called "Chandler's".

Changed: 186

Removed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
took out zero content example, expanded example, reworded example


* ParentalAbandonment
* RaisedByGrandparents

to:

* ParentalAbandonment
* RaisedByGrandparents
RaisedByGrandparents: They move out of the boxcar to live with their grandfather. At first they were afraid he wouldn't like them, but he's not so bad after all.



* TwoferTokenMinority: The Boxcar Kids get a female Korean adopted cousin.

to:

* TwoferTokenMinority: The Boxcar Kids get a female Korean Kids' new cousin is an adopted cousin. Korean girl.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NamesTheSame: Henry James Alden is named after his grandfather, and in the first book uses his first two names as a pseudonym -- it doesn't help them hide from the grandfather.



* OutlivedItsCreator: ''The Boxcar Children'' series had only 19 books by its original creator, Gertrude Chandler Warner. Then, over a decade after her death, Albert Whitman of ''Albert Whitman & Company'' resurrected the series, producing over '''''100''''' more books due to reinterest (including a kid-friendly cookbook). Unsurprisingly, after Warner stopped writing them, [[CanonDiscontinuity continuity went right out the window.]] Notably, a couple pets introduced in her later books suddenly disappear, and sadly the storytelling quality does, too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WealthyEverAfter: The first book ends this way, with the children moving in with their grandfather, who is described as being very rich and living in a huge house with many servants. The rest of the books by Warner downplay his wealth, with the maids being replaced by a single housekeeper, Mrs. [=McGregor=]. In the post-Warner series, the Aldens are pretty much normal middle-class people (though still with a housekeeper).

to:

* WealthyEverAfter: The first book ends this way, with the children moving in with their grandfather, who is described as being very rich and living in a huge house with many servants. The rest of the books by Warner downplay his wealth, with the maids being replaced by a single housekeeper, Mrs. [=McGregor=]. In the post-Warner series, the Aldens are pretty much normal middle-class people (though still with an upper middle class family (with a housekeeper).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WealthyEverAfter: The first book ends this way, with the children moving in with their grandfather, who is described as being very rich and living in a huge house with many servants. The rest of the books by Warner downplay his wealth, with the maids being replaced by a single housekeeper, Mrs. McGregor. In the post-Warner series, the Aldens are pretty much normal middle-class people (though still with a housekeeper).

to:

* WealthyEverAfter: The first book ends this way, with the children moving in with their grandfather, who is described as being very rich and living in a huge house with many servants. The rest of the books by Warner downplay his wealth, with the maids being replaced by a single housekeeper, Mrs. McGregor.[=McGregor=]. In the post-Warner series, the Aldens are pretty much normal middle-class people (though still with a housekeeper).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added Freerange Children example.

Added DiffLines:

* FreerangeChildren: The first book they live quite alone in the woods. Though they go to live with their grandfather in later books, they continue to move around extremely independently, if to a slightly lesser extent.

Added: 138

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: The first book had nothing to do with mysteries, and focused on how the children lived in the titular boxcar.



* IllGirl: Near the end of the book, Violet becomes sick with a fever. The other children eventually have no choice but to take her to a hospital, even though they know that giving their names means the likelihood that their grandfather will find them. He does, but it turns out for the better.

to:

* IllGirl: Near the end of the first book, Violet becomes sick with a fever. The other children eventually have no choice but to take her to a hospital, even though they know that giving their names means the likelihood that their grandfather will find them. He does, but it turns out for the better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WealthyEverAfter: The first book ends this way, with the children moving in with their grandfather, who is described as being very rich and living in a huge house with many servants. The rest of the books by Warner downplay his wealth, with the maids being replaced by a single housekeeper, Mrs. McGregor. In the post-Warner series, the Aldens are pretty much normal middle-class people (though still with a housekeeper).

Changed: 57

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtifactTitle: The Boxcar Kids live in the box car in only one book yet the title sticks throughout the series.

to:

* ArtifactTitle: The Boxcar Kids live in the box car in only one book yet the title sticks throughout the series. They do hang on to the boxcar, and use it as a clubhouse.

Added: 294

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FourTemperamentEnsemble: Benny is Sanguine, Violet is Phlegmatic, Jessie is Melancholic, and Henry is Choleric.

to:

* FourTemperamentEnsemble: Benny is Sanguine, Violet is Phlegmatic, Jessie is Melancholic, and Henry is Choleric. Choleric.
* IllGirl: Near the end of the book, Violet becomes sick with a fever. The other children eventually have no choice but to take her to a hospital, even though they know that giving their names means the likelihood that their grandfather will find them. He does, but it turns out for the better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtifactTitle: The Boxcar Kids live in the box car in only one book yet the title sticks throughout the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FourTemperamentEnsemble: Benny is Sanguine, Violet is Melancholic, Jessie is Phlegmatic, and Henry, is Choleric.

to:

* FourTemperamentEnsemble: Benny is Sanguine, Violet is Phlegmatic, Jessie is Melancholic, Jessie is Phlegmatic, and Henry, Henry is Choleric.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FourTemperamentEnsemble: Benny is Sanguine, Violet is Melancholy, Jessie is Phlegmatic, and Henry, is Choleric.

to:

* FourTemperamentEnsemble: Benny is Sanguine, Violet is Melancholy, Melancholic, Jessie is Phlegmatic, and Henry, is Choleric.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:300:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/boxcar_children_4055.jpg]]
''The Boxcar Children'' was initially written in 1924, but the version that everyone now knows was published in 1942, and was specifically aimed at young readers.

The book chronicles the adventures of a family of runaway orphans, Henry, Jessie, Violet, and Benny Alden, fleeing their grandfather, who they believe to be a cruel man. They eventually find shelter in an abandoned boxcar and make it their home for several months, having various adventures, before eventually being found out and returned to their grandfather's custody. He turns out to be very nice, as well as filthy rich.

After many requests, Warner followed up the book with eighteen sequels, mostly mysteries, over which the characters gradually aged. Benny, 5 in the initial book, was 11 and working as a stock boy in a department store in book #19.

Then in 1991, the ''Albert Whitman & Co.'' publishing company decided to cash in on their continuing popularity. There are now over 100 books in the series, and counting. And a cookbook, that somehow takes recipes mentioned in passing in the books and... turns them over to children.
-----
!!Contains examples of the following:

* AndKnowingIsHalfTheBattle: Every mystery book contained some minor science lesson, such as about plankton, or Captain Cook's voyages, or similar. A noteworthy one: Henry's sage observation that "Mashed potatoes don't smell." (The Lighthouse Mystery.)
* BigEater: Benny, whose catchphrase was practically "I'm hungry!"
* ComicBookTime: Initially set in the depression era, more recent books have included passenger jets, tropical cruises, and the internet. They have a different summer adventure in every book, and they're all still young somehow...
* DefeatMeansFriendship: If the culprit of whatever mystery they're solving has any decency in him/her at all, he'll be reconciled to the Aldens right away.
* FourTemperamentEnsemble: Benny is Sanguine, Violet is Melancholy, Jessie is Phlegmatic, and Henry, is Choleric.
* NamesTheSame: Henry James Alden is named after his grandfather, and in the first book uses his first two names as a pseudonym -- it doesn't help them hide from the grandfather.
* OrphansOrdeal: The whole plot of the first book.
* OutlivedItsCreator: ''The Boxcar Children'' series had only 19 books by its original creator, Gertrude Chandler Warner. Then, over a decade after her death, Albert Whitman of ''Albert Whitman & Company'' resurrected the series, producing over '''''100''''' more books due to reinterest (including a kid-friendly cookbook). Unsurprisingly, after Warner stopped writing them, [[CanonDiscontinuity continuity went right out the window.]] Notably, a couple pets introduced in her later books suddenly disappear, and sadly the storytelling quality does, too.
* ParentalAbandonment
* RaisedByGrandparents
* ShrinkingViolet: Violet. [[MeaningfulName Hey...]]
* SnapBack: Between the last book written by Warner, and the first by the publishing company, the Alden children's ages were reset to 14, 12, 10, and 6.
* StatusQuoIsGod: Have you picked up what the most memorable feature of this series is yet? You can read any book past #19 in any order you like.
* TeamPet: Watch the dog, who technically belongs to Jessie.
* TwoferTokenMinority: The Boxcar Kids get a female Korean adopted cousin.
----

Top