Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / Persuasion

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Made into a Granada miniseries in 1971, a [[Film/{{Persuasion|1995}} movie]] starring Amanda Root and [[Creator/CiaranHinds Ciarán Hinds]] in 1995, and a made-for-tv movie (this time starring Sally Hawkins and Rupert Penry-Jones) in 2007. Creator/{{Netflix}} released a [[Film/Persuasion2022 "modern" retelling]] starring Creator/DakotaJohnson in 2022.

to:

Made into a Granada miniseries in 1971, a [[Film/{{Persuasion|1995}} movie]] starring Amanda Root and [[Creator/CiaranHinds Ciarán Hinds]] in 1995, and [[Film/Persuasion2007 a made-for-tv movie movie]] (this time starring Sally Hawkins Creator/SallyHawkins and Rupert Penry-Jones) Creator/RupertPenryJones) in 2007. Creator/{{Netflix}} released a [[Film/Persuasion2022 "modern" retelling]] starring Creator/DakotaJohnson in 2022.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hardsplitting Film.Persuasion 2007


* AdaptationalAttractiveness: Averted: both adaptations thus far make sure Anne has her having-lost-her-bloom look, exactly as she's described in the novel, despite Amanda Root and Sally Hawkins being very attractive actresses in reality.
* AdaptationalDumbass:
** Mary Musgrove of the book is a self-absorbed, whiny woman constantly seeking attention, mostly by playing sick. She's certainly not the sharpest tool in the box, but nothing in the book suggests that her intelligence is below average. In the 2007 version, she's absolutely, utterly idiotic and honestly behaves like a mentally deranged person, always twitching and jerking about, speaking with a nasal voice and laughing and whining all the time and manages to embarrass herself at every opportunity.
** Charles Musgrove is a fairly intelligent and friendly chap in the book. In the 2007 version, he's a stupid, ditzy guy who doesn't seem to realize how embarrassing his wife is and behaves like a dimwit. For instance, unlike in the book, he doesn't seem to realize that his wife only pretends to be ill.
* AdaptedOut: Richard Musgrove, Charles' deceased younger brother, is never mentioned in the 2007 adaptation.
* AlliterativeName: Captain Harville, whose first name [[NamedByTheAdaptation in the 2007 adaptation]] is '''H'''arry '''H'''arville.
* RaceForYourLove: The climax of the 2007 adaptation has Anne running all around Bath looking for Captain Wentworth. She first goes to the Crofts' lodgings, where she meets Captain Harville, who gives her a note from Wentworth bearing his declaration of love, that for her alone he thinks and plans. She starts running towards the springs at Bath where Harville told her the Crofts and Wentworth went. Then Anne encounters the Crofts, who tell her that Wentworth had [[MissedHimByThatMuch just been there]] and gone to call on her at Camden Place (the Elliots' townhouse). So Anne is sent off running again, whereupon she bumps into Wentworth and Charles.

Added: 655

Changed: 25

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlliterativeName: Captain Harville, whose first name in the 2007 adaptation is '''H'''arry '''H'''arville.

to:

* AlliterativeName: Captain Harville, whose first name [[NamedByTheAdaptation in the 2007 adaptation adaptation]] is '''H'''arry '''H'''arville.'''H'''arville.
* RaceForYourLove: The climax of the 2007 adaptation has Anne running all around Bath looking for Captain Wentworth. She first goes to the Crofts' lodgings, where she meets Captain Harville, who gives her a note from Wentworth bearing his declaration of love, that for her alone he thinks and plans. She starts running towards the springs at Bath where Harville told her the Crofts and Wentworth went. Then Anne encounters the Crofts, who tell her that Wentworth had [[MissedHimByThatMuch just been there]] and gone to call on her at Camden Place (the Elliots' townhouse). So Anne is sent off running again, whereupon she bumps into Wentworth and Charles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WomenAreWiser: The late Lady Eliot is mentioned to have had a lot more fiscal sense than Sir Walter, and his irresponsible spending habits increased after her death.


Added DiffLines:

* AdaptedOut: Richard Musgrove, Charles' deceased younger brother, is never mentioned in the 2007 adaptation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* MutualPining: Anne is convinced that Wentworth has moved on from her and would never even remotely consider starting up a relationship with her again, all while Wentworth loudly acts like he's moved on but really hasn't at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Foregone Conclusion is when "authors choose to go a different route. They will make known to the audience how their story ends before they even begin telling it."


* ForegoneConclusion: This is an Austen novel... Readers can guess Anne ends up being happily settled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ill Girl has been cut per TRS decision. Examples are moved to Delicate And Sickly when appropriate.


* [[IllGirl Ill Woman]]: Anne's best friend Mrs. Smith is afflicted with rheumatism which makes her unable to walk. Her poverty means that she can only afford one nurse who attends numerous other patients, which doesn't help.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Made into a Granada miniseries in 1971, a [[Film/{{Persuasion}} movie]] starring Amanda Root and [[Creator/CiaranHinds Ciarán Hinds]] in 1995, and a made-for-tv movie (this time starring Sally Hawkins and Rupert Penry-Jones) in 2007. Creator/{{Netflix}} released a "modern" retelling starring Creator/DakotaJohnson in 2022.

to:

Made into a Granada miniseries in 1971, a [[Film/{{Persuasion}} [[Film/{{Persuasion|1995}} movie]] starring Amanda Root and [[Creator/CiaranHinds Ciarán Hinds]] in 1995, and a made-for-tv movie (this time starring Sally Hawkins and Rupert Penry-Jones) in 2007. Creator/{{Netflix}} released a [[Film/Persuasion2022 "modern" retelling retelling]] starring Creator/DakotaJohnson in 2022.

Added: 444

Removed: 545

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
this is an index, not a trope


* HeroicBSOD: After Louisa falls from the Cobb, Mary and Henrietta immediately fall into a shrieking panic and her brother Charles is hardly any better. Wentworth, though an experienced captain, is struck with horror because he'd encouraged her to be impetuous and stubborn, which led her to attempt the unsafe jump, and Captain Benwick is similarly shocked into immobility. Anne is the one who keeps her head and takes charge of the situation.



* PlotInducedStupidity: When Louisa falls, everyone but Anne goes into a total panic. Not surprising for the Musgroves, but the two naval captains in the party have certainly seen injuries before. Wentworth's later remarks on the vent imply that he was horror-struck because he thought he had encouraged her impetuousness--it's one thing for a naval officer to see a sailor being injured in combat, because war is war; it's another to see a girl you've encouraged to be spirited be ''so'' spirited that she behaves foolishly and injures herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Hypocrite}}: Sir Walter complains about the Navy bringing "persons of obscure birth into undue distinction" and Mary, when speculating that Wentworth might be made a baronet, says that she doesn't think much of new creations. The Elliots are not only on the lowest rung of the ladder of peerage, their baronetcy would have been only a hundred years old when Sir Walter was born[[note]]it was granted by Charles II, who took the throne in 1660; Sir Walter was born in 1760[[/note]] and was itself granted for loyal service as a borough's high sheriff.


Added DiffLines:

* NotQuiteTheRightThing: Lady Russell's advice and Anne's yielding to it eight years ago. On the face of it, Lady Russell had good reason to fear the result of Anne marrying Wentworth--he was a man in a dangerous profession, was enthusiastic rather than cautious, had already been spendthrift with prize money, and Sir Walter would have cut Anne off without a penny had they gone through with it. This gave Lady Russell a very real fear that Anne would be widowed young and left with no support from her own family. Anne didn't mind defying her foolish and arrogant father, but she couldn't bear the thought of disappointing [[ParentalSubstitute the woman who had become her second mother]]. But in the seven years since, Anne has formed the view that she may have been poor but ''happier''.


Added DiffLines:

* WartimeWedding: Mentioned by Admiral Croft when he and Sophy wonder why Wentworth is waiting so long to marry one of the Musgrove sisters. The Admiral says that Wentworth's hesitation comes of the peace; if it was still wartime, it would have been settled already. He also mentions his and Sophy's FourthDateMarriage.

Changed: 88

Removed: 306

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
RIP Snook/Fry Persuasion :(


Made into a Granada miniseries in 1971, a [[Film/{{Persuasion}} movie]] starring Amanda Root and [[Creator/CiaranHinds Ciarán Hinds]] in 1995, and a made-for-tv movie (this time starring Sally Hawkins and Rupert Penry-Jones) in 2007.

A new feature film adaptation was announced in September 2020, to be filmed in 2021 and released by [[Creator/SearchlightPictures Searchlight Pictures]], starring Sarah Snook and Joel Fry. Coincidentally, Creator/{{Netflix}} has also announced plans for a "modern" retelling starring Creator/DakotaJohnson.

to:

Made into a Granada miniseries in 1971, a [[Film/{{Persuasion}} movie]] starring Amanda Root and [[Creator/CiaranHinds Ciarán Hinds]] in 1995, and a made-for-tv movie (this time starring Sally Hawkins and Rupert Penry-Jones) in 2007.

A new feature film adaptation was announced in September 2020, to be filmed in 2021 and released by [[Creator/SearchlightPictures Searchlight Pictures]], starring Sarah Snook and Joel Fry. Coincidentally,
2007. Creator/{{Netflix}} has also announced plans for released a "modern" retelling starring Creator/DakotaJohnson.Creator/DakotaJohnson in 2022.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlliterativeName: Captain Harville, whose first name in the 2007 adaptation is '''H'''arry '''H'''arville.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WoodenShipsAndIronMen: These elements are peripheral, but they're definitely mentioned. Austen had two brothers in the Navy, and so the discussions of the service are well-informed. (One imagines that the Admiral's fault-finding with a painting of a boat was something Miss Austen heard herself at some point.) One major element brought out is how the Navy's actions during the Napoleonic Wars brought about some social upheaval, as reflected in Sir Walter's complaints about persons of low birth achieving "undue distinction" and the Musgrove girls gushing over the dashing Wentworth. The system of prize money allowed middle-class men to become landed gentry, not always to the approval of their neighbors, while news of their courage and victories in battles against the French inspired widespread admiration. Notably, all of the naval officers in this book are portrayed in a positive light.

to:

* WoodenShipsAndIronMen: These elements are peripheral, but they're definitely mentioned. Austen had two brothers in the Navy, and so the discussions of the service are well-informed. (One imagines that the Admiral's fault-finding with a painting of a boat was something Miss Austen heard herself at some point.) One major element brought out is how the Navy's actions during the Napoleonic Wars brought about some social upheaval, as reflected in Sir Walter's complaints about persons of low birth achieving "undue distinction" and the Musgrove girls gushing over the dashing Wentworth.Wentworth, with Henrietta forgetting about her respectable clergyman beau. The system of prize money allowed middle-class men to become landed gentry, not always to the approval of their neighbors, while news of their courage and victories in battles against the French inspired widespread admiration. Notably, all of the naval officers in this book are portrayed in a positive light.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->--'''Anne Elliot'''

to:

-->--'''Anne -->-- '''Anne Elliot'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''All the privilege I claim for my own sex (it is not a very enviable one: you need not covet it), is that of loving longest, when existence or when hope is gone.''
-->--'''Anne Elliot''', ''Persuasion''

to:

->''All ->''"All the privilege I claim for my own sex (it is not a very enviable one: you need not covet it), is that of loving longest, when existence or when hope is gone.''
"''
-->--'''Anne Elliot''', ''Persuasion''
Elliot'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HaveAGayOldTime: Apparently, [[PosthumousCharacter Richard Musgrove]] has not deserved another name than "Dick"...

to:

* HaveAGayOldTime: Apparently, [[PosthumousCharacter Richard Musgrove]] has not deserved another name than "Dick"..."[[ADickInName Dick]]"...

Top