Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / Oathbringer

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When discussing Amaram, Adolin says that he used to see him as a model soldier who didn't care for petty politics, and Shallan wonders why soldiers who don't care what they're fighting for would be a good thing. It turns out that Dalinar was just like that in his youth, and was worse than Shallan could imagine before becoming TheAtoner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Dalinar:''' You cannot have my pain. [[PunctuatedForEmphasis You. Cannot. Have. My. Pain.]] [[spoiler:I killed those children. I burned the people of Rathalas.]] [...] ''[[SuddenlyShouting YOU CANNOT HAVE MY PAIN!]]'' [[spoiler:I ''did'' kill the people of Rathalas. You might have been there, but ''I'' made the choice. I decided! I killed her. It hurt so much, but I did it. I accept that. You cannot have her. You ''cannot'' take her from me again.]] If I pretend... If I pretend I ''didn't'' do those things, it means I can't have grown to become someone else. [...] [[ArcWords Journey before destination.]] It cannot be a journey if it ''doesn't have a beginning''.

Changed: 714

Removed: 716

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Parshmen, after they've regained their minds, are rightfully angry about how mankind has treated them, and Kaladin, a former slave himself, has more than a little sympathy for them.
** Perhaps because of this, the humans enslaved by the parsh are treated surprisingly well. They are given shelter and clothing, freedom to roam when they're not working, and can choose what type of work they want to do--they can even choose not to work at all, though they don't get food in that case. They are also careful not to work their slaves to exhaustion and excuse slaves who are simply too weak to do the job (though they keep an eye out for slaves just ''pretending'' to be too weak to do the job) and keep them well-equipped as necessary. It's a stark contrast to the way humans treat their slaves. There's an argument to be made that technically the humans aren't slaves at all, just ordinary laborers.

to:

** The Parshmen, after they've regained their minds, are rightfully angry about how mankind has treated them, and Kaladin, a former slave himself, has more than a little sympathy for them.
**
them. Perhaps because of this, the humans enslaved by the parsh are treated surprisingly well. They are given shelter and clothing, freedom to roam when they're not working, and can choose what type of work they want to do--they can even choose not to work at all, though they don't get food in that case. They are also careful not to work their slaves to exhaustion and excuse slaves who are simply too weak to do the job (though they keep an eye out for slaves just ''pretending'' to be too weak to do the job) and keep them well-equipped as necessary. It's a stark contrast to the way humans treat their slaves. There's an argument to be made that technically the humans aren't slaves at all, just ordinary laborers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Alethi culture as a whole is getting its gender norms about women not being allowed to fight overturned in an awful hurry. As multiple characters point out, it doesn't matter if the Alethi care about such things -- the ''spren'' don't, and refusing to take advantage of 50% of your Radiants is madness. Plus, Jasnah and Shallan are already out there setting the precedents, so it's too late in any case.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MythologyGag: At one point, Shallan needs to undo one of her illusionary disguises without revealing that it was an illusion. She does this by borrowing an towel and rubbing the face, pretending that the illusion was just makeup. Raoden used a similar trick in ''Literature/{{Elantris}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NeverLiveItDown: InUniverse. Syl is understandably still a little miffed about Kaladin killing her in ''Words of Radiance'', and insists he apologize every time the subject comes up. Which she does often.


Added DiffLines:

* OnceDoneNeverForgotten: Syl is understandably still a little miffed about Kaladin killing her in ''Words of Radiance'', and insists he apologize every time the subject comes up. Which she does often.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OffscreenMomentOfAwesome:
** Whatever the remainder of the team sent to Kholinar did to [[spoiler: escape a conquered city overrunning with fused and singers, while rescuing Gavinor from Aesudan's clutches in the process.]]
** The last we see of the Honor spren and Azure [[spoiler: has them preparing to fight the fused, with Azure preparing ''something'' involving a lot of Awakening, if her instructing the Spren to prepare a lot of specifically cut scraps of cloth are any indication]].

Added: 619

Changed: 660

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EasilyForgiven: [[spoiler:Adolin stresses about what his father might think about his murder of Sadeas, but to his surprise Dalinar takes it pretty well when the truth comes out. Szeth is also accepted as one of Dalinar's Radiants -- his personal bodyguard, even -- with only some grumbling and mistrust, mostly because at the point where he joined then, Dalinar ''really'' needed his assistance and they still need as many Radiants as possible.]]
** [[spoiler: Taln forgives the other Heralds for leaving him in Damnation for four and a half thousand years, since it prevented the Desolations from coming and gave humanity a chance to thrive]].

to:

* EasilyForgiven: [[spoiler:Adolin stresses EasilyForgiven:
** Adolin [[spoiler:stresses
about what his father might think about his murder of Sadeas, but to his surprise Dalinar takes it pretty well when the truth comes out. out.]]
**
Szeth is [[spoiler:is also accepted as one of Dalinar's Radiants -- his personal bodyguard, even -- with only some grumbling basically no resistance despite being perhaps the most famous and mistrust, mostly prolific assassin in the world. Mostly because at the point where he joined then, Dalinar ''really'' needed his assistance and they still need as many Radiants as possible.REALLY needed help at the time and were in no position to demand and explanation or turn down his help.]]
** Taln, [[spoiler: Taln to Ash's surprise, not only forgives the other Heralds for leaving him in Damnation for four and a half thousand years, but ''is excited to find out how long he was abandoned'' since it prevented the Desolations from coming and gave humanity a chance to thrive]].

Added: 706

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Meta-wise and in-universe, the explicit mention there's only one Perpendicularity in Roshar despite there being 2 Shards, and that it belongs to Cultivation. [[spoiler:Honor's Perpendicularity is part of the climax, and has many imlicaitons both in and out of universe.]]

to:

** Meta-wise and in-universe, the explicit mention there's only one Perpendicularity in Roshar despite there being 2 Shards, and that it belongs to Cultivation. [[spoiler:Honor's Perpendicularity is part of the climax, and has many imlicaitons implicaitons both in and out of universe.]]


Added DiffLines:

** As everyone prepares for the climactic battle, Dalinar goes out to survey the fortifications of Thaylen City. Meridas Amaram has been personally been preparing them, and when Dalinar speaks to him about them, Amaram remarks that he admires Dalinar for their plan to know the enemy's defenses. Dalinar reprimands Amaram for this, believing Amaram to be one of the people who believe Dalinar is trying to conquer the world for Alethkar. [[spoiler:It's actually because Amaram is now on Odium's payroll and has been informed that Dalinar is to become Odium's champion, so he believes Dalinar is organizing the defense specifically to take advantage of intentional weaknesses when Odium's army attacks.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Dalinar's memories, interspersed with present-day chapters. [[spoiler: A flashback chapter ends with Dalinar making a tentative plan for peace with Rathalas and leading a force of Elites to investigate the supposed traitorous caravan. The name of the next chapter? Rockfall - the lighteyes manor house that Veil and her team robs in the present day.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added Kaladin as an example of a meaningful name

Added DiffLines:

* MeaningfulName: From what we learn of how Alethi names work in Dalinar's backstory, Kaladin's name is comprised of a base word, "kalad", and a suffix, "-in". The exerpt on the Calligraphers' Guild reveals that "kalad" is the name of the Alethi glyph for "eternal" or "eternity", also used in "Kalazeras", Alethi for "Everstorm". It is also revealed in Dalinar's backstory that the suffix "-in" means "born unto". Kaladin became a full Radiant in the previous book during the very first Everstorm.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Averted with just about every other character though. Most humans, and virtually all lighteyes, see nothing inherently wrong with slavery, although many do disapprove of masters mistreating their slaves. At least a few of the main characters [[DeliberateValuesDissonance technically own slaves themselves]], although it's fairly easy for the reader not to notice this.

to:

** Averted with just about every other character though. Most humans, and virtually all lighteyes, see nothing inherently wrong with slavery, although many do disapprove of masters mistreating their slaves, and the Vorin religion proscribes penalties for mistreating slaves. At least a few of the main characters [[DeliberateValuesDissonance technically own slaves themselves]], although it's fairly easy for the reader not to notice this. The fact that Vorin priests are also slaves owned by their highprinces goes a long way to explain why this is considered socially acceptable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Averted with just about every other character though. Most humans, and virtually all lighteyes, see nothing inherently wrong with slavery, although many do disapprove of masters mistreating their slaves. At least a few of the main characters [[DeliberateValuesDissonance technically own slaves themselves]], although it's fairly easy for the reader not to notice this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As a side effect of having his soul be caught and prevented from ascending in death, Szeth is now constantly followed by a ghostly afterimage. He can also more acutely hear the voices of the dead, and being around Stormlight quells these voices.

to:

** As a side effect of having his soul be caught and prevented from ascending in death, Szeth is now constantly followed by a ghostly afterimage. He can also more acutely hear the voices of the dead, and being around Stormlight quells these voices.

Added: 687

Changed: 436

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CameBackWrong: [[spoiler: The Fused are the spirits of ancient parshmen transformed into spren by Odium, growing more insane each time they take over the body of another parshman, killing them in the process, with many so focused on revenge on humanity that they're willing to destroy Roshar to get it. Some of them don't even seem aware of what's going on anymore, and some souls are so twisted Venli can barely recognize them as Listeners anymore]].

to:

* CameBackWrong: CameBackWrong:
**
[[spoiler: The Fused are the spirits of ancient parshmen transformed into spren by Odium, growing more insane each time they take over the body of another parshman, killing them in the process, with many so focused on revenge on humanity that they're willing to destroy Roshar to get it. Some of them don't even seem aware of what's going on anymore, and some souls are so twisted Venli can barely recognize them as Listeners anymore]].anymore]].
** As a side effect of having his soul be caught and prevented from ascending in death, Szeth is now constantly followed by a ghostly afterimage. He can also more acutely hear the voices of the dead, and being around Stormlight quells these voices.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PrivateProfitPrison: One of the Skybreaker tests has the new recruits investigating a small private prison where the prisoners escaped and killed the guard on the way out. Note that this is considered "bleeding heart progressive" by the world's standards; they're still mostly at the stage where all criminals are executed as a matter of course. The recruits are told to hunt down the prisoners and bring them back dead or alive; the test proctors already have received writs of execution for all of them. Szeth realizes that the reason the prisoners were able to escape was because the prison was of shoddy construction with only one guard--the warden had been spending the absolute minimum amount of money and pocketing the rest. Szeth asks if he's allowed to execute the warden. [[HiddenPurposeTest The proctors tell him his writ of execution was the first one they received]].

to:

* PrivateProfitPrison: One of the Skybreaker tests has the new recruits investigating a small private prison where the prisoners escaped and killed the guard on the way out. Note that this is considered "bleeding heart progressive" by the world's standards; they're still mostly at the stage where all criminals are executed or enslaved as a matter of course. The recruits are told to hunt down the prisoners and bring them back dead or alive; the test proctors already have received writs of execution for all of them. Szeth realizes that the reason the prisoners were able to escape was because the prison was of shoddy construction with only one guard--the warden had been spending the absolute minimum amount of money and pocketing the rest. Szeth asks if he's allowed to execute the warden. [[HiddenPurposeTest The proctors tell him his writ of execution was the first one they received]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NotTheIntendedUse: The Stormfather's visions were intended to serve as a warning by Honor for the recipient, to pass on lessons and bits of the past to worthy subjects. They weren't intended to serve as historical records, but Honor had infused them with so many valuable details from the past and enough interactivity to tease out some lost secrets of history that Dalinar and later Navani and Jasnah use them to learn a great deal about the ancient and mythological past.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WeHaveReserves: According to the Stormfather, this was why the Fused were so unstoppable, even before they gained Surgebinding abilities. While the singers lost the same number of bodies either way, (since the fusion process essentially kills the host singer), the ability to trade common "civilian" singers for their most skilled and experienced warriors gave them a huge advantage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I don't recall EVERYONE being sure it would fall on Dalinar's camp, and they actually did look into it.


* WhoMurderedTheAsshole: on finding Sadeas' body, there's a large confrontation between Sadeas' men and Bridge 4 that draws a large crowd, and no one can really figure out who did it. Everyone is sure blame will fall on Dalinar's camp, but the list of potential suspects is oo large, so everyone just agrees to continue on, not looking into it.

to:

* WhoMurderedTheAsshole: on On finding Sadeas' body, there's a large confrontation between Sadeas' men and Bridge 4 that draws a large crowd, and no one can really figure out who did it. Everyone is sure blame will fall on Dalinar's camp, but the The list of potential suspects is oo large, so everyone just agrees to continue on, not looking into it.thousands long.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhoKilledTheAsshole: on finding Sadeas' body, there's a large confrontation between Sadeas' men and Bridge 4 that draws a large crowd, and no one can really figure out who did it. Everyone is sure blame will fall on Dalinar's camp, but the list of potential suspects is oo large, so everyone just agrees to continue on, not looking into it.

to:

* WhoKilledTheAsshole: WhoMurderedTheAsshole: on finding Sadeas' body, there's a large confrontation between Sadeas' men and Bridge 4 that draws a large crowd, and no one can really figure out who did it. Everyone is sure blame will fall on Dalinar's camp, but the list of potential suspects is oo large, so everyone just agrees to continue on, not looking into it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhoKilledTheAsshole: on finding Sadeas' body, there's a large confrontation between Sadeas' men and Bridge 4 that draws a large crowd, and no one can really figure out who did it. Everyone is sure blame will fall on Dalinar's camp, but the list of potential suspects is oo large, so everyone just agrees to continue on, not looking into it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DisneyDeath: Played with. Eshonai fell into a chasm at the end of ''The Words of Radiance,'' but was wearing Shardplate (which we know is able to cancel some amount of fall damage) and was in Stormform (whose exact specifications are unknown). Dalinar sees a vision of the Voidbringer champion, and they are clad in shardplate painted black, just like Eshonai's. After the end of Part One, one of the interludes details her sister on and a strange new Spren searching for her. They discover that she survived the fall, used her Shardblade to anchor herself to the wall while the storms met, [[spoiler: and drowned as the storms' rain filled the chasm she fell into]].

to:

* DisneyDeath: Played with. Eshonai fell into a chasm at the end of ''The Words of Radiance,'' but was wearing Shardplate (which we know is able to cancel some amount of fall damage) and was in Stormform (whose exact specifications are unknown). unknown). Dalinar sees a vision of the Voidbringer champion, and they are clad in shardplate painted black, just like Eshonai's. Eshonai's. After the end of Part One, one of the interludes details her sister on and a strange new Spren searching for her. her. They discover that she survived the fall, used her Shardblade to anchor herself to the wall while the storms met, [[spoiler: and drowned as the storms' rain filled the chasm she fell into]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DisneyDeath: Played with. Eshonai fell into a chasm at the end of ''The Words of Radiance,'' but was wearing Shardplate (which we know is able to cancel some amount of fall damage) and was in Stormform (whose exact specifications are unknown). Dalinar sees a vision of the Voidbringer champion, and they are clad in shardplate painted black, just like Eshonai's. After the end of Part One, one of the interludes details her sister on and a strange new Spren searching for her. They discover that she survived the fall, used her Shardblade to anchor herself to the wall while the storms met, [[spoiler: and drowned as the storms' rain filled the chasm she fell into]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArmorPiercingQuestion: Amaram (see IDidWhatIHadToDo below) is close to snapping for good, insisting that he has no blame because he acted how it was right in those circumstances. [[spoiler: Kaladin then asks why, if that's true, he's so vehemently trying to justify himself. This ends up cementing Amaram's VillainousBreakdown.]]

to:

* ArmorPiercingQuestion: Amaram (see IDidWhatIHadToDo below) is close to snapping for good, insisting that he has no blame because he acted how it was right in those circumstances. [[spoiler: Kaladin then asks why, if that's true, he's so vehemently trying to justify himself. Specifically, if he’s trying to achieve personal peace and claiming to feel no guilt, "why do you still hurt?" This ends up cementing Amaram's VillainousBreakdown.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DarkSecret: The secret that broke the old Knights Radiant is brought up again. The Stormfather knows it, but refuses to share it. [[spoiler:The truth is that humans were the first Voidbringers. They arrived on Roshar as refugees after their homeworld (implied to be Yolen, or possibly Ashyn, the first planet in the Rosharan system) was destroyed and rendered uninhabitable by Surgebinding to coexist beside the parshmen, but they grew greedy and tried to take everything for themselves. At first, whenever the Knights discovered this, Honor was able to calm them down and convince them to keep fighting. But by the time of the Recreance, he was dying and half-mad, so talking to him only made things worse]].

to:

* DarkSecret: The secret that broke the old Knights Radiant is brought up again. The Stormfather knows it, but refuses to share it. [[spoiler:The truth is that humans were the first Voidbringers. They arrived on Roshar as refugees after their homeworld (implied (confirmed by [[WordOfGod the author]] to be Yolen, or possibly Ashyn, the first planet in the Rosharan system) was destroyed and rendered uninhabitable by Surgebinding to coexist beside the parshmen, but they grew greedy and tried to take everything for themselves. At first, whenever the Knights discovered this, Honor was able to calm them down and convince them to keep fighting. But by the time of the Recreance, he was dying and half-mad, so talking to him only made things worse]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PrivateProfitPrison: One of the Skybreaker tests has the new recruits investigating a small private prison where the prisoners escaped and killed the guard on the way out. Note that this is considered "bleeding heart progressive" by the world's standards; they're still mostly at the stage where all criminals are executed as a matter of course. The recruits are told to hunt down the prisoners and bring them back dead or alive; the test proctors already have received writs of execution for all of them. Szeth realizes that the reason the prisoners were able to escape was because the prison was of shoddy construction with only one guard--the warden had been spending the absolute minimum amount of money and pocketing the rest. Szeth asks if he's allowed to execute the warden. [[HiddenPurposeTest The proctors tell him his writ of execution was the first one they received]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He also gives Dalinar the encouragement he needs [[spoiler:to fight off being chosen as Odium's own champion]].
-->'''Odium''': Be strong, Dalinar. I have faith in you, even when you don't have it in yourself. Though it will hurt for a time, there is an end. Peace is in your future. Push ''through'' the agony. Then you will be victorious, my son.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheBrute: As seen in the flashbacks, this is basically the role Dalinar filled for Gavilar when they were young. In the present, Dalinar's reputation as [[FourStarBadass The Blackthorn]] makes it difficult to convince the other nations to cooperate with Alethkar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GenocideDilemma: {{Discussed}}. Jasnah points out that without the Oathpact to force the Fused back to Braize, the only way to stop them is to kill off ''every living singer'' to deprive them of their hosts.

Added: 216

Removed: 223

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not transforming.


* TalkingIsAFreeAction: {{Averted}} in one of the book's worst TearJerkers. [[spoiler:Elokhar gets within ''a single word'' of speaking the First Ideal...only for Moash to stab him in the back before he can finish]].



* TransformationIsAFreeAction: {{Averted}} in one of the book's worst TearJerkers. [[spoiler:Elokhar gets within ''a single word'' of speaking the First Ideal...only for Moash to stab him in the back before he can finish]].

Top