Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / NancyDrew

Go To

OR

Added: 217

Removed: 453

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved the main text to a more appropriate trope. Also, Georgia is not uncommon enough (today) to count as an Outdated Name, and Mortimer is not unusual enough to preserve as an example of Aerith And Bob.


* AerithAndBob: Mostly chalked up to time, since quite a few names have fallen out of favor since the books were written; as it is, names like "Nancy," "Bess," and "Ned" currently sound a little old-fashioned and not the kind of names you'd expect teenagers to have, and the same goes for "Georgia", while her nickname, "George", is a GenderBlenderName that's common for men. But a name like Mortimer Bartesque couldn't have been very common, even then.


Added DiffLines:

* OutdatedName: A few names have fallen out of favor since the books were written; names like "Nancy," "Bess," and "Ned" currently sound a little old-fashioned and not the kind of names you'd expect teenagers to have.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FourPhilosophyEnsemble: Nancy and her three most trusted sleuthing companions. She's the grounded, sensible Realist; upbeat Bess, who is quick to believe the best of others, is the Optimist; sarcastic, often-distrustful George is the Cynic; and Ned, who's not around as often and not as active as his ActionGirlfriend Nancy, is the Apathetic, although he sometimes switches to the Conflicted in books where Nancy's cases cause tension between them and make him doubt their relationship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Recurring Character}}s: Nancy's main cast includes her father, Carson Drew; KindlyHousekeeper and ParentalSubstitute Hannah Gruen; [[LoveInterest boyfriend]] Ned Nickerson; and [[HeterosexualLifePartners best friends]] Bess Marvin and George Fayne. While they appear in every book of the original series, and most books of most of the others, Ned, Carson, and Hannah are relegated to this status in the ''Files'' books. Additionally, some of the various series have their own examples:

to:

* {{Recurring Character}}s: Nancy's main cast includes her father, ace defense attorney Carson Drew; KindlyHousekeeper and ParentalSubstitute Hannah Gruen; [[LoveInterest boyfriend]] Ned Nickerson; and [[HeterosexualLifePartners best friends]] Bess Marvin and George Fayne. While they appear in every book of the original series, and most books of most of the others, Ned, Carson, and Hannah are relegated to this status in the ''Files'' books. Additionally, some of the various series have their own examples:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The ''Files'' have Brenda Carlton, a journalist and self-styled rival to Nancy, who usually is there to cause additional hindrances to Nancy, but occasionally works with her and helps her out.

to:

** The ''Files'' have Brenda Carlton, a journalist and self-styled rival to Nancy, who usually is there to cause additional hindrances to Nancy, her and her friends, but occasionally works with her them and helps her them out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ned spends much of the first few books of the ''Files'' series bitching about always being second best to Nancy's detective work and being upset that she prioritizes her career over him, to the point where he finally breaks up with her at the end of "Two Points to Murder". By "False Moves", the very next book after this, he himself needs those same detective skills to help his new girlfriend. His hypocrisy aside, this is also horrifically insensitive of him. And then there's the fact that said girlfriend is ''far more'' self-centered and career-oriented than Nancy ever was. He's also visibly jealous upon meeting her new boyfriend, even though ''he'' broke up with ''her'' and is dating someone else.

to:

** Ned spends much of the first few books of the ''Files'' series bitching about always being second best to Nancy's detective work and being upset that she prioritizes her career over him, to the point where he finally breaks up with her at the end of "Two Points to Murder". By "False Moves", the very next book after this, he himself needs those same detective skills to help his new girlfriend. His hypocrisy aside, this is also horrifically insensitive of him. And then there's him, not to mention the fact that said girlfriend is ''far more'' self-centered and career-oriented than Nancy ever was. He's also visibly jealous upon meeting her new boyfriend, even though ''he'' broke up with ''her'' and is dating someone else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SensualSlavs: In ''Files'', the “Summer of Love” trilogy has handsome Russian dancer Sasha Petrov as Nancy’s TemporaryLoveInterest. He’s a NiceGuy, pretty clever, and does pretty well for himself in some action sequences, but obviously he’s no substitute for Ned in the end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This is averted with Charlie Adams, who has a thing for Nancy; he's very polite, sweet, and gentlemanly to her, and respects that she's dating someone else, never acting pushy or trying to assert his feelings. Nancy, in turn, while not interested in him romantically, very much appreciates what a NiceGuy he is and is always kind to him.

to:

** This is averted with Charlie Adams, who has a thing for Nancy; he's very polite, sweet, and gentlemanly to her, and respects that she's dating someone else, never acting pushy or trying to assert his feelings. Nancy, in turn, while not interested in him romantically, very much appreciates what a NiceGuy he is is, considers him her friend, and is always kind to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


For what's basically the equivalent with dudes, see ''Literature/TheHardyBoys''.

to:

For what's basically the equivalent with dudes, see ''Literature/TheHardyBoys''.
''Literature/TheHardyBoys''. Like that series, it's very prominent for the abundance of {{Tom Swiftie}}s in the narrative.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ExtrudedBookProduct: Alongside sister series ''The Hardy Boys'' it is among the worst offenders of this trope ever recorded. A rough outline of how bad it got follows below:

to:

* ExtrudedBookProduct: Alongside sister series ''The Hardy Boys'' it is among one of the worst offenders most extreme examples of this trope ever recorded. this. A rough outline of how bad it got follows below:outline:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In Sweden, she was renamed ''Kitty'' Drew for reasons that has never been fully explained. The most common theory being that the publishing company thought that ''Nancy'' sounded like an old lady's name, while ''Kitty'' would be more more hip and appealing to Swedish teenagers in the 1950s.

to:

** In Sweden, she was renamed ''Kitty'' Drew for reasons that has never been fully explained. unspecified reasons. The most common theory being is that the publishing company thought that ''Nancy'' sounded like an old lady's name, while ''Kitty'' would be more more hip and appealing to Swedish teenagers in the 1950s.



* LongRunningBookSeries

to:

* LongRunningBookSeriesLongRunningBookSeries: The original "Mystery Stories" series ran from 1930 to 2004, comprising 175 books plus spin-offs. A canonical reboot, "Nancy Drew: Girl Detective", began immediately after and continues to the present.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AbhorrentAdmirer: In the ''Girl Detective'' series, Nancy and Ned have a steady relationship, but each have another RecurringCharacter with one-sided feelings for them, who contrast with each other neatly:
** This is averted with Charlie Adams, who has a thing for Nancy; he's very polite, sweet, and gentlemanly to her, and respects that she's dating someone else, never acting pushy or trying to assert his feelings. Nancy, in turn, while not interested in him romantically, very much appreciates what a NiceGuy he is and is always kind to him.
** Meanwhile, Deirdre Shannon, who has a massive crush on Ned, plays this straight; it should be noted that this has nothing to do with her appearance (as she's quite beautiful) and is entirely thanks to her behavior and personality. Deirdre's ''very'' pushy and constantly acts flirtatious with Ned, and no matter how many times he politely turns down her offers to spend time together and makes it clear he has eyes for no one but Nancy, she refuses to take no for an answer. In books where Nancy and Ned are having an argument or there's some other issue between them, Deirdre can usually be counted on to try to worm her way into Ned's company, and while Nancy's usually not seriously worried about losing him to her, it will act as a way to create more tension between them before they inevitably work things out.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Recurring Character}}s: Nancy's main cast includes her father, Carson Drew; KindlyHousekeeper and ParentalSubstitute Hannah Gruen; [[LoveInterest boyfriend]] Ned Nickerson; and [[HeterosexualLifePartners best friends]] Bess Marvin and George Fayne. While they appear in every book of the original series, and most books of most of the others, Ned, Carson, and Hannah are relegated to this status in the ''Files'' books. Additionally, some of the various series have their own examples:
** Across every series, [[DaChief Police Chief McGinnis]] makes regular appearances, especially in cases that take place in River Heights, but certainly not in every book.
** The ''Files'' have Brenda Carlton, a journalist and self-styled rival to Nancy, who usually is there to cause additional hindrances to Nancy, but occasionally works with her and helps her out.
** ''Girl Detective'' has Deirdre Shannon replace Brenda as TheRival to Nancy; she's not really an investigator, and is instead more interested in trying to cause trouble in Nancy's relationship with Ned, but otherwise plays a similar role to Brenda, including the rivalry being mostly one-sided. Another example is Charlie Adams, a NiceGuy mechanic who frequently helps Nancy with her car and has a major crush on her, though she just likes him as a friend.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TomboyAndGirlyGirl: George and Bess, respectively. George is the most athletic of the three girls and often acts as "muscle" when there aren't any guys around, being an ActionGirl like Nancy; wears her dark hair in a BoyishShortHair style and chooses a [[TomboyishName tomboyish nickname]] for a feminine full name that she dislikes; and, while she occasionally gets love interests, she mostly prefers to focus on her own pursuits. Bess, by contrast, dresses extremely fashionably and loves clothes, makeup, and shopping; has a very feminine appearance and chose an arguably even ''more'' feminine nickname than her real name; and is by far the most boy-crazy of the three girls, frequently gaining new love interests and sometimes even falling in LoveAtFirstSight, and acts flirtatious around men in general to the point that she will often distract or get information from a relevant male character by batting her eyes at him and speaking sweetly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* EagleEyeDetection
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 511

Changed: 256

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HardHead

to:

* HardHeadHardHead: Nancy and other characters are frequently knocked out by being hit upside the head from behind. At worst, they just wake up later with a splitting headache, but no further damage. This trope is shared with her SpearCounterpart series, ''The Hardy Boys''.
* HeterosexualLifePartners: Nancy, George, and Bess are a trio version of this. The latter two are cousins, but all three are as close as sisters and spend most of their free time together. Bess and George are Nancy's most frequent and (along with Ned) most trusted partners in her investigations, and are very protective of each other. Whatever disagreements and temporary rifts may form between them during a case, by the climax of the book, they'll always patch things up and be as strong as ever by the end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AerithAndBob: Mostly chalked up to time, since quite a few names have fallen out of favor since the books were written (as it is, names like "Nancy," "Bess," and "Ned" currently sound a little old-fashioned and not the kind of names you'd expect teenagers to have), but a name like Mortimer Bartesque couldn't have been very common, even then.

to:

* AerithAndBob: Mostly chalked up to time, since quite a few names have fallen out of favor since the books were written (as written; as it is, names like "Nancy," "Bess," and "Ned" currently sound a little old-fashioned and not the kind of names you'd expect teenagers to have), but have, and the same goes for "Georgia", while her nickname, "George", is a GenderBlenderName that's common for men. But a name like Mortimer Bartesque couldn't have been very common, even then.

Added: 98

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** 2016-present: ''Diaries'' is reduced to bi-annually.

to:

** 2016-present: 2016-2021: ''Diaries'' is reduced to bi-annually.bi-annually.
** 2022-Present: ''Diaries'' is cut to only one book per year, bringing the franchise full circle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Likewise, Don Cameron was Nancy's boyfriend for the first few books before he was replaced with by Ned Nickerson for future installments. Unlike Helen, there was no mention of what happened with Don.

to:

** Likewise, Don Cameron was Nancy's boyfriend for the first few books before he was replaced with by Ned Nickerson for future installments. Unlike Helen, there was no mention of what happened with Don.Don, though he does [[TheBusCameBack reappear again]] in a ''Files'' book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Overlaps with TheUnfairSex: in the ''Files'' series and their crossovers with the Hardy Boys, Nancy has, and occasionally even acts on, some serious feelings for men other than Ned, most notably Frank Hardy and Mick Devlin (both of whom she straight-up kisses multiple times); though these flings don't ever end up lasting long-term, they're still usually portrayed positively or at least as being tragically star-crossed, even though she's essentially cheating on Ned with other guys. At least with Frank, he and Nancy mutually conclude whenever this happens that they want to stick with their respective partners, but with Mick, he outright asks Nancy to marry him, and she actually considers it. And yet, when there are books that involve another girl being attracted to Ned, Nancy gets very jealous, even though Ned never displays behavior that comes across as "cheating" as blatantly as Nancy does in the same situations.

to:

** Overlaps with TheUnfairSex: in In the ''Files'' series and their crossovers with the Hardy Boys, Nancy has, and occasionally even acts on, some serious feelings for men other than Ned, most notably Frank Hardy and Mick Devlin (both of whom she straight-up kisses multiple times); though these flings don't ever end up lasting long-term, they're still usually portrayed positively or at least as being tragically star-crossed, even though she's essentially cheating on Ned with other guys. At least with Frank, he and Nancy mutually conclude whenever this happens that they want to stick with their respective partners, but with Mick, he outright asks Nancy to marry him, and she actually considers it. And yet, when there are books that involve another girl being attracted to Ned, Nancy gets very jealous, even though Ned never displays behavior that comes across as "cheating" as blatantly as Nancy does in the same situations.[[note]]This is probably a case of ProtagonistCenteredMorality, as the same thing sometimes happens in ''The Hardy Boys Casefiles'' as well.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is a defunct trope


* CostumePorn: Much like FoodPorn as described on the ''Literature/HardyBoys'' page, the books devoted a decent amount of space to descriptions of the outfits the girls wore. However, unlike the FoodPorn of the Hardys, the clothing descriptions remained, and when there are books like "A Model Crime" and "Designs in Crime", which focus on modeling and the fashion industry, the descriptions sometimes went UpToEleven.

to:

* CostumePorn: Much like FoodPorn as described on the ''Literature/HardyBoys'' page, the books devoted a decent amount of space to descriptions of the outfits the girls wore. However, unlike the FoodPorn of the Hardys, the clothing descriptions remained, and when there are books like "A Model Crime" and "Designs in Crime", which focus on modeling and the fashion industry, the descriptions sometimes went UpToEleven.up to eleven.



** Turned UpToEleven in the French translation [[http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Roy#La_traduction_française as you can see on the other wiki]]: the only major character whose name is unchanged is Ned Nickerson (even River Heights is called River City). Nancy Drew herself is known as ''Alice Roy'' to make her name more euphonic (the ''Dr-'' sound is much harsher and more guttural in French) while still sounding quintessentially American. Even Carolyn Keene becomes ''Caroline Quine'' (which is pronounced the same).

to:

** Turned UpToEleven up to eleven in the French translation [[http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Roy#La_traduction_française as you can see on the other wiki]]: the only major character whose name is unchanged is Ned Nickerson (even River Heights is called River City). Nancy Drew herself is known as ''Alice Roy'' to make her name more euphonic (the ''Dr-'' sound is much harsher and more guttural in French) while still sounding quintessentially American. Even Carolyn Keene becomes ''Caroline Quine'' (which is pronounced the same).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Turned UpToEleven in the French translation [[http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Roy#Traduction_des_noms_originaux as you can see on the other wiki]], Nancy Drew is known as ''Alice Roy'' to make her name more appealing to French ears while still sounding American enough. Even Carolyn Keene becomes ''Caroline Quine''.

to:

** Turned UpToEleven in the French translation [[http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Roy#Traduction_des_noms_originaux org/wiki/Alice_Roy#La_traduction_française as you can see on the other wiki]], wiki]]: the only major character whose name is unchanged is Ned Nickerson (even River Heights is called River City). Nancy Drew herself is known as ''Alice Roy'' to make her name more appealing to French ears euphonic (the ''Dr-'' sound is much harsher and more guttural in French) while still sounding American enough. quintessentially American. Even Carolyn Keene becomes ''Caroline Quine''.Quine'' (which is pronounced the same).



* EagleEyeDetection

to:

* %%* EagleEyeDetection
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* [[WhereTheHellIsSpringfield Where The Hell Is River Heights?]]: The location of River Heights has always been pretty sketchy. The original ghostwriter, Mildred Wirt Benson, put it in her home state of Iowa, but it seemed to keep drifting farther and farther east, going as far as New Jersey when Harriet Adams did her rewrites in the 60s. As early as the ''Files'' series, however, it seems to have settled down and tends to stay within driving distance of Chicago (and despite that leaving four states as possibilities due to Chicago's location, it's often implied that it's in Illinois, also.)

to:

* [[WhereTheHellIsSpringfield Where The Hell Is River Heights?]]: WhereTheHellIsSpringfield: The location of River Heights has always been pretty sketchy. The original ghostwriter, Mildred Wirt Benson, put it in her home state of Iowa, but it seemed to keep drifting farther and farther east, going as far as New Jersey when Harriet Adams did her rewrites in the 60s. As early as the ''Files'' series, however, it seems to have settled down and tends to stay within driving distance of Chicago (and despite that leaving four states as possibilities due to Chicago's location, it's often implied that it's in Illinois, also.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Averted with George in the original books, where this is her real GenderBlenderName, it's played straight in the reprints and all subsequent books, where her full name is Georgia Fayne, but she's near-exclusively called "George". In the most recent series--''Girl Detective'' and ''Diaries''--she actually ''hates'' being called by her full name.

to:

** Averted with George in the original books, where this is her real GenderBlenderName, but it's played straight in the reprints and all subsequent books, where her full name is Georgia Fayne, but she's near-exclusively called "George". In the most recent series--''Girl Detective'' and ''Diaries''--she actually ''hates'' being called by her full name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Averted with George in the original books, where this is her real GenderBlender name, it's played straight in the reprints and all subsequent books, where her full name is Georgia Fayne, but she's near-exclusively called "George". In the most recent series--''Girl Detective'' and ''Diaries''--she actually ''hates'' being called by her full name.

to:

** Averted with George in the original books, where this is her real GenderBlender name, GenderBlenderName, it's played straight in the reprints and all subsequent books, where her full name is Georgia Fayne, but she's near-exclusively called "George". In the most recent series--''Girl Detective'' and ''Diaries''--she actually ''hates'' being called by her full name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the earliest books in the series, Nancy's entourage who helps her with her sleuthing consists of one main "gal pal", Helen Corning, and her boyfriend, Don Cameron. They both only last for a few books before being phased out in favor of the classic characters everyone knows: Don is replaced by Ned Nickerson as Nancy's boyfriend, while Helen is PutOnABus and Nancy gets two "chums" instead of one--Bess Marvin and George Fayne--to form a trio of best friends.

to:

** In the earliest books in the series, Nancy's entourage who helps her with her sleuthing consists of her boyfriend, Don Cameron, and one main "gal pal", Helen Corning, and her boyfriend, Don Cameron.Corning. They both only last for a few books before being phased out in favor of the classic characters everyone knows: Don is replaced by Ned Nickerson as Nancy's boyfriend, while Helen is PutOnABus and Nancy gets two "chums" instead of one--Bess Marvin and George Fayne--to form a trio of best friends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AffectionateNickname:
** In the Digests and ''Files'' and their crossovers, Nancy's family and close friends will often call her "Nan" (which is also a bit of a MythologyGag, since one of the original ideas for what to name the character was "Nan Drew" before it was eventually lengthened to "Nancy").
** In ''Girl Detective'' and ''Diaries'', these same people will call her "Nance".


Added DiffLines:

* OnlyKnownByTheirNickname:
** Elizabeth Marvin and Edward Nickerson are almost never called by these names, going by "Bess" and "Ned" respectively.
** Averted with George in the original books, where this is her real GenderBlender name, it's played straight in the reprints and all subsequent books, where her full name is Georgia Fayne, but she's near-exclusively called "George". In the most recent series--''Girl Detective'' and ''Diaries''--she actually ''hates'' being called by her full name.

Top