Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / LonesomeDove

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: The plot of the original novel is a close analogue to the story of the Goodnight-Loving Trail, the westernmost cattle trail blazed by Texas cattlemen Charles Goodnight and Oliver Loving in the 1860s. Call and [=McCrae=] are larger-than-life stand-ins for Goodnight and Loving. Several historical events are replicated in the book, including Goodnight/Call burying [[spoiler: his respected African-American scout]] beneath a wooden marker and later honoring his partner's wishes by [[spoiler: taking [=Loving/McCrae's=] body back to Texas after he was killed in a fight with Native Americans]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DefiantToTheEnd: Gus is very unimpressed with Dan Suggs' recalcitrance in the face of his execution for several murders:

to:

* DefiantToTheEnd: Gus is very unimpressed with Dan Suggs' recalcitrance in the face of his execution for several murders:murders, to the point that he and his impromptu posse leave the man's corpse swaying in the breeze while his cohorts ([[spoiler:and Jake]]) were given the dignity of a proper burial:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DefiantToTheEnd: Gus is very unimpressed with Dan Suggs' recalcitrance in the face of his execution for several murders:
-->"''I'll say this to you, Suggs: You're the kind of man that's a pleasure to hang. If all you can talk is guff, go talk it to The Devil.''"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AnnoyingArrows: Heavily averted; several people are killed by them and bow-wielding natives are considered a serious threat. In [[spoiler: Gus's]] case, he sustains a "mere" hit to the leg with an arrow [[RealityEnsues and subsequently dies a few days later after the wound becomes gangrenous]].

to:

* AnnoyingArrows: Heavily averted; several people are killed by them and bow-wielding natives are considered a serious threat. In [[spoiler: Gus's]] case, he sustains a "mere" hit to the leg with an arrow [[RealityEnsues and subsequently dies a few days later after the wound becomes gangrenous]].gangrenous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, don't call Lori a whore in front of Dish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This is somewhat justified, in that towns are few and far between on the frontier, and not all of them even have lawmen, so it's not necessarily practical for Gus and Woodrow to try to bring them in for trial. If anything, it shows what a CrapsackWorld the frontier could be, as taking the law into your ow

to:

** This is somewhat justified, in that towns are few and far between on the frontier, and not all of them even have lawmen, so it's not necessarily practical for Gus and Woodrow to try to bring them in for trial. If anything, it shows what a CrapsackWorld the frontier could be, as taking the law into your owown hands is often the only option.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EmotionsVsStoicism: A central part of the story is the contrast between the laid-back, talkative and generally pleasant Gus and the grumpy, uptight, unemotional Call.'

to:

* EmotionsVsStoicism: A central part of the story is the contrast between the laid-back, talkative and generally pleasant Gus and the grumpy, uptight, unemotional Call.'
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BetterToDieThanBeKilled: When facing hanging, both [[spoiler:Jake and Blue Duck]] decide to preempt their execution. [[spoiler:Jake, who was being hanged from a tree branch, spurred his horse out from under himself before Gus could do it. Blue Duck, when about to be led from his fourth-story cell to the gallows, broke away from his guards and jumped out a window.]]

to:

* BetterToDieThanBeKilled: When facing hanging, both [[spoiler:Jake and Blue Duck]] decide to preempt their execution. [[spoiler:Jake, who was being hanged from a tree branch, spurred his horse out from under himself before Gus could do it.it (though it's as much about sparing Gus from having to do it). Blue Duck, when about to be led from his fourth-story cell to the gallows, broke away from his guards and jumped out a window.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActionGirl: Janey, whose rough life has taught her to live off the land. She helps capture two outlaws be throwing rocks at them and when Blu Duck attacks their camp is the only one with the reflexes to fight back well. [[spoiler: unfortunately due to the {{Deconstruction}} nature of the story she ends up being TooCoolTooLive]].

to:

* ActionGirl: Janey, whose rough life has taught her to live off the land. She helps capture two outlaws be by throwing rocks at them and when Blu Blue Duck attacks their camp is the only one with the reflexes to fight back well. [[spoiler: unfortunately Unfortunately due to the {{Deconstruction}} nature of the story she ends up being TooCoolTooLive]].

Added: 1385

Changed: 88

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenBird: Poor Lori. First she falls for Jake Spoon and his empty promises of living the high life. Then she’s kidnapped by Blue Duck, spending weeks in captivity [[spoiler: being gang-raped multiple times per day by his crew, while Jake quickly abandons any notion of rescuing her and soon forgets she even exists. Gus eventually manages to rescue her, but by then she's been horribly brutalized]].



* DefiledForever: Discussed. Lori feels this way about herself after [[spoiler: being kidnapped by Blue Duck and gang-raped by his followers, then subsequently rescued by Gus]]. [[BrokenBird She's convinced that between that and her time as a prostitute, she's unfit for any kind of decent society]], and when Gus tells her of his plan to set her up with a new life on Clara's ranch, she argues that "She'll know what I am!" Gus, NiceGuy that he is, is having none of it and declares, "You're absolutely right. She'll recognize right right away that you're ''a fine human being!"''



* JudgeJuryAndExecutioner: Call, Gus, and associates will summarily execute bandits, horse thieves and other scofflaws they run across. Overlaps some with VigilanteMan since they continue to do so after they've retired from the Texas Rangers and have no official legal standing to dispense justice. At one point Gus is bemused by an outlaw who believes Gus is simply going to arrest him.

to:

* JudgeJuryAndExecutioner: Call, Gus, and associates will summarily execute bandits, horse thieves and other scofflaws they run across. Overlaps some with VigilanteMan since they continue to do so after they've retired from the Texas Rangers and have no official legal standing to dispense justice.
** This is somewhat justified, in that towns are few and far between on the frontier, and not all of them even have lawmen, so it's not necessarily practical for Gus and Woodrow to try to bring them in for trial. If anything, it shows what a CrapsackWorld the frontier could be, as taking the law into your ow
**
At one point Gus is bemused by an outlaw who believes Gus is simply going to arrest him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ActionGirl: Janey, whose rough life has taught her to live off the land. She helps capture two outlaws be throwing rocks at them and when Blu Duck attacks their camp is the only one with the reflexes to fight back well. [[spoiler: unfortunately due to the {{Deconstruction}} nature of the story she ends up being TooCoolTooLive]].

Added: 125

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EmotionsVsStoicism: A central part of the story is the contrast between the laid-back, talkative and generally pleasant Gus and the grumpy, uptight, unemotional Call.

to:

* EmotionsVsStoicism: A central part of the story is the contrast between the laid-back, talkative and generally pleasant Gus and the grumpy, uptight, unemotional Call.'
* FaceDeathWithDignity: Jake spurs his own horse during his hanging, sparing Gus from the actual act of executing his friend.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IdiotBall: Gus passes up a chance to simply shoot Blue Duck in the back and bring his violent career to a an early and very much deserved end. Gus himself regrets this almost immediately, and indeed, numerous innocent people are killed (along with Blue Duck's entire gang) as a direct result of that decision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenreDeconstruction: [=McMurtry=] [[http://www.motherjones.com/media/2014/05/larry-mcmurtry-brokeback-mountain-last-kind-words intended]] the series to be one for the Western genre, but feels that a lot of people missed out on this. It could have a lot to do with the miniseries' bright cinematography and adventurous score setting a tone more suited to a classic, idealistic western film, rather than the kind of gritty, desaturated style that would normally go with a story as unafraid to reflect the actual harshness of life in the Old West as ''Lonesome Dove'' is.

to:

* GenreDeconstruction: [=McMurtry=] [[http://www.motherjones.com/media/2014/05/larry-mcmurtry-brokeback-mountain-last-kind-words intended]] the series to be one for the Western genre, but feels that a lot of people missed out on this. It could have a lot to do with the miniseries' bright cinematography and adventurous score setting a tone more suited to a classic, idealistic western film, rather than the kind of gritty, desaturated style that would normally go with a story as unafraid to reflect that reflects the actual harshness of life in the Old West as ''Lonesome Dove'' is.West.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateContinuity: The sequel miniseries ''Return to Lonesome Dove'' portrays a completely different set of events than those depicted in the McMurtry-penned followup ''Streets of Laredo''.

to:

* AlternateContinuity: The sequel miniseries ''Return to Lonesome Dove'' portrays a completely different set of events than those depicted in the McMurtry-penned [=McMurtry=]-penned followup ''Streets of Laredo''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlternateContinuity: The sequel miniseries ''Return to Lonesome Dove'' portrays a completely different set of events than those depicted in the McMurtry-penned followup ''Streets of Laredo''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WorstAid: Gus solution for [[spoiler:an arrow in his leg is to try and ''push it out the rest of the way'', which might not have directly caused an infection, but most certainly didn't help his situation]].

to:

* WorstAid: Gus Gus' solution for [[spoiler:an arrow in his leg is to try and ''push it out the rest of the way'', which might not have directly caused an infection, the infection that ends up killing him, but most certainly didn't help his situation]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DecoyProtagonist: Gus is such a focal character throughout the story that it comes as a major shock when [[spoiler:he dies and Woodrow makes it his mission to bring Gus' body home to Lonesome Dove for burial. He later becomes the main protagonist in ''Streets of Laredo'']].

to:

* DecoyProtagonist: Gus is such a focal character throughout the story that it comes as a major shock when [[spoiler:he dies and Woodrow makes it his mission to bring Gus' body home to Lonesome Dove for burial. He Woodrow later becomes the main protagonist in ''Streets of Laredo'']].



--> '''Capt. Woodrow F. Call:''' [to onlookers] I can't abide rude behavior in a man...I ''won't'' tolerate it!

to:

--> '''Capt. Woodrow F. Call:''' [to onlookers] I can't abide hate rude behavior in a man...man... I ''won't'' won't tolerate it!

Added: 276

Changed: 209

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DecoyProtagonist: Gus is such a focal character throughout the story that it comes as a major shock when [[spoiler:he dies and Woodrow makes it his mission to bring Gus' body home to Lonesome Dove for burial. He later becomes the main protagonist in ''Streets of Laredo'']].



* GenericEthnicCrimeGang: Blue Duck's gang primarly has Kiowa Indian members, but others are white and Blue Duck is Mexican and Comanche.

to:

* GenericEthnicCrimeGang: Blue Duck's gang primarly primarily has Kiowa Indian members, but others are white and Blue Duck is Mexican and Comanche.




to:

* WorstAid: Gus solution for [[spoiler:an arrow in his leg is to try and ''push it out the rest of the way'', which might not have directly caused an infection, but most certainly didn't help his situation]].

Added: 189

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DrivenToSuicide [[spoiler:Xavier, out of loneliness, and Jake Spoon]]

to:

* DrivenToSuicide [[spoiler:Xavier, out of loneliness, and Jake Spoon]]Spoon]].
* DroppedABridgeOnHim: By the time ''Streets of Laredo'' begins, two of the most sympathetic characters still alive by the end of ''Lonesome Dove'' are both dead: [[spoiler:Newt and July]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* ShootTheShaggyDog

to:

%%* ShootTheShaggyDog* ShootTheShaggyDog: Elmira's story arc ends with her [[spoiler:finding Dee just as he's scheduled to hang, abandoning both July ''and'' her newborn child, then setting out for St. Louis and dying in a Sioux attack]]. The only thing she accomplished was getting a few horny buffalo hunters killed in the process.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

The miniseries boasted an AllStarCast headed by Creator/RobertDuvall and Creator/TommyLeeJones as Gus and Woodrow, with Creator/DianeLane as Lorena, Creator/AnjelicaHuston as Clara, and Creator/DannyGlover as Joshua Deets. Also features a pre-stardom Creator/SteveBuscemi as Luke.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


%% ZeroContextExample entries are not allowed on wiki pages. All such entries have been commented out.

to:

%% ZeroContextExample Administrivia/ZeroContextExample entries are not allowed on wiki pages. All such entries have been commented out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut to ''Film/{Bandolero}'' with a Sheriff named July Johnson who has a deputy named Roscoe who embarks on a quest to catch a fugitive. July is also in love with someone who doesn't love him and would rather be with an outlaw named Dee.

to:

* ShoutOut to ''Film/{Bandolero}'' ''Film/{{Bandolero}}'' with a Sheriff named July Johnson who has a deputy named Roscoe who embarks on a quest to catch a fugitive. July is also in love with someone who doesn't love him and would rather be with an outlaw named Dee.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShoutOut to ''Film/{Bandolero}'' with a Sheriff named July Johnson who has a deputy named Roscoe who embarks on a quest to catch a fugitive. July is also in love with someone who doesn't love him and would rather be with an outlaw named Dee.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JudgeJuryAndExecutioner: Call, Gus, and associates will summarily execute bandits, horse thieves and other scofflaws they run across. Overlaps some with VigilanteMan since they continue to do so after they've retired from the Texas Rangers and have no real legal authority to do so. At one point Gus is bemused by an outlaw who believes Gus is simply going to arrest him.

to:

* JudgeJuryAndExecutioner: Call, Gus, and associates will summarily execute bandits, horse thieves and other scofflaws they run across. Overlaps some with VigilanteMan since they continue to do so after they've retired from the Texas Rangers and have no real official legal authority standing to do so.dispense justice. At one point Gus is bemused by an outlaw who believes Gus is simply going to arrest him.

Added: 475

Changed: 87

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jake Spoon ''thinks'' he's this, but [[TheSlacker he's not]].

to:

** Jake Spoon ''thinks'' he's this, but [[TheSlacker he's not]]. However, he is charismatic enough that people often don't figure that out right away.


Added DiffLines:

* JudgeJuryAndExecutioner: Call, Gus, and associates will summarily execute bandits, horse thieves and other scofflaws they run across. Overlaps some with VigilanteMan since they continue to do so after they've retired from the Texas Rangers and have no real legal authority to do so. At one point Gus is bemused by an outlaw who believes Gus is simply going to arrest him.
--> '''Gus:''' [to Dan Suggs] I don't know what makes you think we'd tote you all the way to a jail.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PretentiousLatinMotto: Gus insists on putting one on the Hat Creek sign because he thinks it looks classy - although he can’t read it. Call doesn’t think it makes any sense to have such a motto in the first place and says it might invite robbers for all Gus knows.
Willbyr MOD

Added: 290

Changed: 504

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Lonesome Dove'' is the name of a highly-regarded [[TheWestern Western]] novel by Larry [=McMurtry=] published in 1985. It was also adapted into a 1989 Emmy-winning four-episode television miniseries. The novel was the first of a tetralogy of novels, followed up by a sequel novel, ''The Streets of Laredo'', and two prequel novels, ''Dead Man's Walk'' and ''Literature/ComancheMoon''. All were made into miniseries. It is also considered the first part of an informal trilogy of Westerns staring Robert Duval, with the second being ''Film/OpenRange'' and the third being ''Film/BrokenTrail.''

In 1876, former Texas Rangers Captains Augustus [=McCrea=] and Woodrow Call run a livery in the small border town of Lonesome Dove. When their old colleague Jake Spoon arrives with tales of the unsettled territory in Montana, Call is inspired to drive of cattle there to start a ranch.

to:

''Lonesome Dove'' is the name of a highly-regarded [[TheWestern Western]] novel by Larry [=McMurtry=] published in 1985. It was also adapted into a 1989 Emmy-winning four-episode television miniseries. The novel was the first of a tetralogy of novels, followed up by a sequel novel, ''The Streets of Laredo'', and two prequel novels, ''Dead Man's Walk'' and ''Literature/ComancheMoon''. All were made into miniseries. It is also considered the first part of an informal trilogy of Westerns staring Robert Duval, Duvall, with the second being ''Film/OpenRange'' and the third being ''Film/BrokenTrail.''

In 1876, former Texas Rangers Captains Augustus [=McCrea=] [=McCrae=] and Woodrow Call run a livery in the small border town of Lonesome Dove. When their old colleague Jake Spoon arrives with tales of the unsettled territory in Montana, Call is inspired to drive of cattle there to start a ranch.



* BetterToDieThanBeKilled: When facing hanging, both [[spoiler: Jake and Blue Duck]] decide to preempt their execution. [[spoiler: Jake, who was being hanged from a tree branch, spurred his horse out from under himself before Gus could do it. Blue Duck, when about to be led from his fourth-story cell to the gallows, broke away from his guards and jumped out a window.]]

to:

* BetterToDieThanBeKilled: When facing hanging, both [[spoiler: Jake [[spoiler:Jake and Blue Duck]] decide to preempt their execution. [[spoiler: Jake, [[spoiler:Jake, who was being hanged from a tree branch, spurred his horse out from under himself before Gus could do it. Blue Duck, when about to be led from his fourth-story cell to the gallows, broke away from his guards and jumped out a window.]]



* BrilliantButLazy: Gus is a competent tracker, skilled in a gunfight, and generally an all-around impressive individual - when he can be bothered. Left to his own devices, he'll just drink on the porch with an occasional trip to a whorehouse. Jake Spoon ''thinks'' he's this, but [[TheSlacker he's not.]]

to:

* BrilliantButLazy: BrilliantButLazy:
**
Gus is a competent tracker, skilled in a gunfight, and generally an all-around impressive individual - when he can be bothered. Left to his own devices, he'll just drink on the porch with an occasional trip to a whorehouse.
**
Jake Spoon ''thinks'' he's this, but [[TheSlacker he's not.]]not]].



* BuryMeNotOnTheLonePrairie: Woodrow Call brings [[spoiler: Gus [=MacCrae=]'s]] body across the country so he can be buried in his favorite orchard.

to:

* BuryMeNotOnTheLonePrairie: Woodrow Call brings [[spoiler: Gus [[spoiler:Gus [=MacCrae=]'s]] body across the country so he can be buried in his favorite orchard.



%%* EmotionsVsStoicism

to:

%%* EmotionsVsStoicism* EmotionsVsStoicism: A central part of the story is the contrast between the laid-back, talkative and generally pleasant Gus and the grumpy, uptight, unemotional Call.



* HookerWithAHeartOfGold: Lorena

to:

* HookerWithAHeartOfGold: LorenaLorena is friendly, kind, and quite close to Gus.



* TakingYouWithMe: When [[spoiler: Blue Duck]] pulls his high-dive, he drags a lawman with him.

to:

* TakingYouWithMe: When [[spoiler: Blue [[spoiler:Blue Duck]] pulls his high-dive, he drags a lawman with him.



* StuffedIntoTheFridge: In Streets of Laredo, the author discontinuously revisits [[spoiler: Lorena Wood's]] kidnapping from the Lonesome Dove, in flashback in order to add in a characteristically gruesome scene where a child is kidnapped and burned to death, [[ForTheEvulz just so we hate the main villain more.]]

to:

* StuffedIntoTheFridge: In Streets ''Streets of Laredo, Laredo'', the author discontinuously revisits [[spoiler: Lorena [[spoiler:Lorena Wood's]] kidnapping from the Lonesome Dove, ''Lonesome Dove'', in flashback in order to add in a characteristically gruesome scene where a child is kidnapped and burned to death, [[ForTheEvulz just so we hate the main villain more.]]more]].


Added DiffLines:

Willbyr MOD

Added: 297

Changed: 351

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnnoyingArrows: Heavily averted; several people are killed by them and bow-wielding natives are considered a serious threat. In [[spoiler: Gus's]] case, he sustains a "mere" hit to the leg with an arrow [[RealityEnsues and subsequently dies a few days later after the wound becomes gangrenous.]]

to:

* AnArmAndALeg: [[spoiler:Gus]] has a leg amputated against his will after it becomes gangrenous due to an arrow wound. Unfortunately, by that time the blood poisoning is too widespread and he dies a few days later.
* AnnoyingArrows: Heavily averted; several people are killed by them and bow-wielding natives are considered a serious threat. In [[spoiler: Gus's]] case, he sustains a "mere" hit to the leg with an arrow [[RealityEnsues and subsequently dies a few days later after the wound becomes gangrenous.]]gangrenous]].

Top