Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / AndThenThereWereNone

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** In the Russian version, Vera also gets a scene in her black underwear, [[spoiler:which is followed by a [[ToplessnessFromTheBack bare back shot minutes later with Lombard...]] [[FanDisservice as he begins to rape her. Er, yeah...]]]]

to:

** In the Russian version, Vera also gets a scene in her black underwear, [[spoiler:which is followed by a [[ToplessnessFromTheBack bare back shot minutes later with Lombard...]] Lombard]]... [[FanDisservice as he begins to rape her. Er, yeah...]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There's a degree of this trope in how U.N. Owen hunts down their victims, although it's [[DownplayedTrope downplayed]] in that Owen is said to be actively seeking out people who committed crimes and got away with them. Owen also prepares a pat speech about the nature of injustice and how some people escape the truth, which encourages people to provide examples. That said, even Owen themself admits that finding out about [[spoiler: Vera killing Cyril on purpose was a ridiculous coincidence: they just so happened to run into a drunken Hugo on a boat and, without expecting much success, began reciting their KarmaHoudini monologue--only for Hugo to spill the whole story about Vera without any further prompting.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


But whatever its title, every serious mystery fan knows the novel's plot by heart: [[TenLittleMurderVictims ten people, strangers to one another (except one husband-and-wife pair), receive invitations to an island hideaway]], where a mysterious recording played for the group accuses each person of having caused another person's death. Sometime after the record is played, members of the group start dying off one by one, each in a manner similar to one from the well-known nursery rhyme ("Ten Little Niggers" in the original British edition, "Ten Little Indians" in many later editions, "Ten Little Soldiers" in current editions). Those still alive have no choice but to come to the only possible conclusion: one of them is murdering the others. Paranoia and suspicion run high, as each remaining person in the group tries to outwit the killer; who can be trusted, after all, when everyone around them is dying? And how long will it be before the next one dies?

to:

But whatever its title, every serious mystery fan knows the novel's plot by heart: [[TenLittleMurderVictims ten people, strangers to one another (except (save for one husband-and-wife pair), receive invitations to an island hideaway]], where a mysterious recording played for the group accuses each person of having caused another person's death. Sometime after the record is played, members of the group start dying off one by one, each in a manner similar to one from the well-known nursery rhyme ("Ten Little Niggers" in the original British edition, "Ten Little Indians" in many later editions, "Ten Little Soldiers" in current editions). Those still alive have no choice but to come to the only possible conclusion: one of them is murdering the others. Paranoia and suspicion run high, as each remaining person in the group tries to outwit the killer; who can be trusted, after all, when everyone around them is dying? And how long will it be before the next one dies?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The novel has been published under several different titles, as a direct result of ValuesDissonance. It was originally published in the UK as ''Ten Little Niggers'', which was not shocking in 1930s Britain. In the United States, [[DidNotDoTheBloodyResearch more sensitive publishers changed the title]] to ''And Then There Were None'',[[note]] keeping in line with its allusion to the minstrel song [[/note]] while several earlier foreign translations kept the original title, such as ''Dix petits nègres'' (in French) or ''Zehn kleine Negerlein'' (in German). The novel was also published in English as ''Ten Little Indians'' on both sides of the Atlantic until people eventually came to see that title as racist as well. In consequence, ''And Then There Were None'' has, more or less, become the official standardized title.

to:

The novel has been published under several different titles, as a direct result of ValuesDissonance. It was originally published in the UK as ''Ten Little Niggers'', which was not wasn't shocking in 1930s Britain. In the United States, [[DidNotDoTheBloodyResearch more sensitive publishers changed the title]] to ''And Then There Were None'',[[note]] keeping in line with its allusion to the minstrel song [[/note]] while several earlier foreign translations kept the original title, such as ''Dix petits nègres'' (in French) or ''Zehn kleine Negerlein'' (in German). The novel was also published in English as ''Ten Little Indians'' on both sides of the Atlantic until people eventually came to see that title as racist as well. In consequence, ''And Then There Were None'' has, more or less, become the official standardized title.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking

Added DiffLines:

* AdvanceNoticeCrime: When the "guests" have all arrived at the mansion on the island, a record is played in which "U.N. Owen" (a play on "unknown") announces his intention to kill everyone in attendance as retribution for crimes which they escaped justice, either because the law could not touch them, or because they had concealed their crimes too well. There is even a rhyme that spells out how each of the victims is to die. [[spoiler:The narrative makes plain before the story is out that each of them was guilty of the crime they were accused of, making all of them {{Asshole Victim}}s]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The 2015 version also has a lesbian subtext with Emily and Beatrice Taylor. [[spoiler: When Beatrice accidentally pokes her finger with a knitting needle and draws blood, Emily pulls her hand to her mouth and sucks on the finger while staring at her. Um...Squick. Also falls under AdaptationalVillainy, as it seemingly adds another facet to why Emily callosly throws Beatrice out after finding out she's pregnant.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The 1974 version ups the ante by having the taped voice be none other than Creator/OrsonWelles. The end credits also promote Welles' involvement heavily.]]

to:

** The 1974 version ups the ante by having the taped voice be none other than Creator/OrsonWelles. The end credits also promote Welles' involvement heavily.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The 2015 version also has a lesbian subtext with Emily and Beatrice Taylor. [[spoile: When Beatrice accidentally pokes her finger with a knitting needle and draws blood, Emily pulls her hand to her mouth and sucks on the finger while staring at her. Um...Squick. Also falls under AdaptationalVillainy, as it seemingly adds another facet to why Emily callosly throws Beatrice out after finding out she's pregnant.]]

to:

** The 2015 version also has a lesbian subtext with Emily and Beatrice Taylor. [[spoile: [[spoiler: When Beatrice accidentally pokes her finger with a knitting needle and draws blood, Emily pulls her hand to her mouth and sucks on the finger while staring at her. Um...Squick. Also falls under AdaptationalVillainy, as it seemingly adds another facet to why Emily callosly throws Beatrice out after finding out she's pregnant.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The 2015 version also has a lesbian subtext with Emily and Beatrice Taylor. [[when Beatrice accidentally pokes her figer with a knitting needle and draws blood, Emily pulls her hand to her mouth and sucks on the finger while staring at her. Um...Squick. Also falls under AdaptationalVillany, as it seemingly adds another facet to why Emily callosly throws Beatrice out after finding out she's pregnant.]]

to:

** The 2015 version also has a lesbian subtext with Emily and Beatrice Taylor. [[when [[spoile: When Beatrice accidentally pokes her figer finger with a knitting needle and draws blood, Emily pulls her hand to her mouth and sucks on the finger while staring at her. Um...Squick. Also falls under AdaptationalVillany, AdaptationalVillainy, as it seemingly adds another facet to why Emily callosly throws Beatrice out after finding out she's pregnant.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The novel has been published under several different titles, as a direct result of ValuesDissonance. It was originally published in the UK as ''Ten Little Niggers'', which was not shocking in 1930s Britain. In the United States, [[DidNotDoTheBloodyResearch more sensitive publishers changed the title]] to ''And Then There Were None''[[note]]keeping in line with its allusion to the minstrel song[[/note]], while many earlier foreign translations kept the original title, such as ''Dix petits nègres'' in French or ''Zehn kleine Negerlein'' in German. The book was also published in English as ''Ten Little Indians'' on both sides of the Atlantic until people eventually came to see that title as racist as well. ''And Then There Were None'' has, more or less, become the official standardized title.

But whatever its title, every serious mystery fan knows the novel's plot by heart: [[TenLittleMurderVictims ten people, strangers to one another (except one pair of husband and wife), receive invitations to an island hideaway.]] A mysterious recording played for the group accuses each person of having caused another person's death. Sometime after the record is played, members of the group start dying one by one, each in ways similar to those in the rhyme ("Ten Little Niggers" in the original British edition, "Ten Little Indians" in many later editions, "Ten Little Soldiers" in current editions). Those still alive soon come to the only possible conclusion: one of them is killing the others. Paranoia and suspicion run high, as each person tries to outwit the killer; who can be trusted when everyone around them is dying? And how long will it be before the next one dies?

to:

The novel has been published under several different titles, as a direct result of ValuesDissonance. It was originally published in the UK as ''Ten Little Niggers'', which was not shocking in 1930s Britain. In the United States, [[DidNotDoTheBloodyResearch more sensitive publishers changed the title]] to ''And Then There Were None''[[note]]keeping None'',[[note]] keeping in line with its allusion to the minstrel song[[/note]], song [[/note]] while many several earlier foreign translations kept the original title, such as ''Dix petits nègres'' in French (in French) or ''Zehn kleine Negerlein'' in German. (in German). The book novel was also published in English as ''Ten Little Indians'' on both sides of the Atlantic until people eventually came to see that title as racist as well. In consequence, ''And Then There Were None'' has, more or less, become the official standardized title.

But whatever its title, every serious mystery fan knows the novel's plot by heart: [[TenLittleMurderVictims ten people, strangers to one another (except one pair of husband and wife), husband-and-wife pair), receive invitations to an island hideaway.]] A hideaway]], where a mysterious recording played for the group accuses each person of having caused another person's death. Sometime after the record is played, members of the group start dying off one by one, each in ways a manner similar to those in one from the well-known nursery rhyme ("Ten Little Niggers" in the original British edition, "Ten Little Indians" in many later editions, "Ten Little Soldiers" in current editions). Those still alive soon have no choice but to come to the only possible conclusion: one of them is killing murdering the others. Paranoia and suspicion run high, as each remaining person in the group tries to outwit the killer; who can be trusted trusted, after all, when everyone around them is dying? And how long will it be before the next one dies?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InheritanceMurder: An indirect one: Vera engineered the death of a child under her care so that her lover could inherit the child's fortune. She didn't count on Hugo being utterly horrified when he realizes that she'd killed his nephew and rejecting her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeathFromAbove: [[spoiler:Blore is killed by a falling marble clock landing on his head.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheButlerDidIt: [[spoiler:Averted; Rogers is one of the early characters to be killed off. He and his wife did commit the crime they were accused of, but the murders on the island weren't him.]]

to:

* TheButlerDidIt: [[spoiler:Averted; Rogers is one of the early characters to be killed off. He and his wife did commit the crime they were accused of, but the murders on the island weren't him.his doing.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhyDidItHaveToBeSnakes: Or wasps and bees, in Miss Brent's case. She gets so freaked out by seeing bees that [[GetAHoldOfYourselfMan someone else has to slap Miss Brent in the face to bring her back down to earth]]. Even then, it's still a sore subject.

to:

* WhyDidItHaveToBeSnakes: Or wasps and bees, in Miss Brent's Vera's case. She gets so freaked out by seeing bees that [[GetAHoldOfYourselfMan someone else Armstrong has to slap Miss Brent Vera in the face to bring her back down to earth]]. Even then, it's still a sore subject.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
spelling


** In the eplilogue, AC Legge and Inspector Maine are meticulous in analysing the case and trying to work out who the killer was. Maine refuses to use any shortcuts and probes every possible explanation for the deaths, even when this means accepting none of their theories. However, they cannot crack the case either.

to:

** In the eplilogue, epilogue, AC Legge and Inspector Maine are meticulous in analysing the case and trying to work out who the killer was. Maine refuses to use any shortcuts and probes every possible explanation for the deaths, even when this means accepting none of their theories. However, they cannot crack the case either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
spelling


* WhenItAllBegan: In the epliogue, the killer states that they were first inspired following a discussion with the GP (family doctor) of the employer of Mr & Mrs Rodgers. The GP stated that he was certain that the Rodgerses had deliberately killed their employer by witholding medication, but knew that there was no way of proving this, and wondered to the killer about how many other similar cases existed, where people had committed murders in ways that could never be proven.

to:

* WhenItAllBegan: In the epliogue, epilogue, the killer states that they were first inspired following a discussion with the GP (family doctor) of the employer of Mr & Mrs Rodgers. The GP stated that he was certain that the Rodgerses had deliberately killed their employer by witholding medication, but knew that there was no way of proving this, and wondered to the killer about how many other similar cases existed, where people had committed murders in ways that could never be proven.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added happy ending

Added DiffLines:

* HappyEnding: The book's grim ending - by which everyone on the island is killed, and everyone on the island is guilty of their crimes - is missing from every screen adaptation other than the 1987 Russian adaptation and the 2015 BBC adaptation. All of the other versions include somewhat happy endings, with at least one survivor, and at least one person actually being innocent of the crime that they are accused of.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhenItAllBegan: In the epliogue, the killer states that they were first inspired following a discussion with the GP (family doctor) of the employer of Mr & Mrs Rodgers. The GP stated that he was certain that the Rodgerses had deliberately killed their employer by witholding medication, but knew that there was no way of proving this, and wondered to the killer about how many other similar cases existed, where people had committed murders in ways that could never be proven.

Added: 518

Changed: 301

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguousSituation / AmbiguouslyEvil: Every character eventually cops to the murder they're accused of (sometimes to try to justify or rationalize it), either openly to the group, privately to another character, or in their own internal monologue. Every character, that is, except the Rogerses, whose account of their employer's death is never explicitly contradicted by the text. There's evidence for (if it was an InheritanceMurder, it certainly wasn't a very successful one given that it didn't seem improve their station much) and against (Mrs. Rogers' reaction to the gramophone recording is not that of an innocent person) this conclusion, but they're the only characters who just ''might'' be innocent.

to:

* AmbiguousSituation / AmbiguouslyEvil: Every character eventually cops to the murder they're accused of (sometimes to try to justify or rationalize it), either openly to the group, privately to another character, or in their own internal monologue. Every character, that is, except the Rogerses, whose account of their employer's death is never explicitly contradicted by the text. There's evidence for (if it was an InheritanceMurder, it certainly wasn't a very successful one given that it didn't seem improve their station much) and against (Mrs. Rogers' reaction to the gramophone recording is not that of an innocent person) this conclusion, but they're the only characters who just ''might'' be innocent. In the epilogue written by the killer, they reveal that they chose the couple following a discussion with the dead employer's doctor: in the doctor's opinion, he was "convinced" that the patient's death was due to the Rodgers' witholding of medication, but knew that there was no way of proving this.


Added DiffLines:

* PoliceAreUseless: Played with.
** Blore shows some intelligence at the beginning of the novel, when trying to find clues from the various letters written by U N Owen, but is no match for the killer.
** In the eplilogue, AC Legge and Inspector Maine are meticulous in analysing the case and trying to work out who the killer was. Maine refuses to use any shortcuts and probes every possible explanation for the deaths, even when this means accepting none of their theories. However, they cannot crack the case either.

Added: 626

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NiceJobBreakingItHero: In the 1945, 1965, and 1974 versions, [[spoiler: Power is cut to the house, resort, and hotel, respectively, by Blore attempting to fix the generator and screwing it up.]]

to:

* NiceJobBreakingItHero: In the 1945, 1965, and 1974 versions, [[spoiler: Power power is cut to the house, resort, and hotel, respectively, by Blore attempting to fix the generator and screwing it up.]]
* [[spoiler: The doctor's (Armstrong/Werner) trust in Wargrave gets him and Blore killed in the 1945, 1965, 1974, and 1989 versions. In the 1987 Russian adaptation, and the 2015 BBC version, it results in the deaths of Vera and Lombard as well, as his bloated corpse leads Vera to believe Lombard is the only other person alive and thus has to be the killer, and she shoots him dead before hanging herself. The main reason Wargrave pulls off his gambit in the movies mostly, or completely, successfully is due to Armstrong's gullibility. Wargrave even lampshades the gullibility in the end after he's revealed as the killer.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HalfTheManHeUsedToBe: The video game adaptation takes the "one chopped himself in halves" line more literally than most versions of Rogers' death. Whereas in the book, he's killed by an axe wound to the back of the head, the game sees him fully chopped in two, with his head and torso sticking out from behind one end of the firewood pile, and his legs at the other.
--> '''Blore''': Rogers! Blimey, either he's a good five feet taller or-
--> '''Patrick''': Cut clean in half.
--> '''Blore''': Dead, of course?
--> '''Patrick''': Yes, we don't need Dr. Armstrong to tell us that.

Added: 897

Changed: 2043

Removed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnyoneCanDie: [[spoiler:And they all do.]]

to:

* AnyoneCanDie: [[spoiler:And they all do.do, by the end of the book. Even Wargrave, the one who's committing all the killings, doesn't make it out alive.]]



* AssholeVictim: ''None'' of the victims is exactly an innocent, though Claythorne, Lombard, and Marston stand out for either the nature of their crimes, their lack of remorse, or both.

to:

* AssholeVictim: AssholeVictim:
**
''None'' of the victims is exactly an innocent, though innocent -- the reason they were all invited to the island in the first place is because they were responsible for someone else's death, either directly or indirectly. Claythorne, Lombard, and Marston stand out for either the nature of their crimes, their lack of remorse, or both.



%%* AxCrazy: Vera and, to a lesser extent, [[spoiler:Wargrave.]]

to:

%%* * AxCrazy: Vera and, The killer, U.N. Owen, was a closet sadist and also motivated by a desire to a lesser extent, [[spoiler:Wargrave.]]punish the guilty. [[PayEvilUntoEvil Ten people who had caused other people to die]] was too much for them to resist.



* TheBadGuyWins: Well it ain't called ''[[MeaningfulName And Then There Were None]]'' for nothin'. The killer pulls the plan off so well that the police can't figure out what happened, closing the investigation well before the confession letter is discovered -- although your mileage may vary on whether this person really qualifies as the "bad guy" of the story, considering the victims' own crimes.

to:

* TheBadGuyWins: Well it It ain't called ''[[MeaningfulName And Then There Were None]]'' for nothin'. The killer pulls the plan off so well that the police can't figure out what happened, closing the investigation well before the confession letter is discovered -- although your mileage may vary on whether this person really qualifies as discovered. [[spoiler:That being said, the "bad guy" killer also dies by the end of the story, considering the victims' own crimes.so he didn't get off scot-free either.]]



* BigBad: U.N. Owen, really [[spoiler:[[HangingJudge Justice]] Lawrence Wargrave]], is the killer who traps everyone in the mansion to [[TenLittleMurderVictims off them one-by-one]] as punishment for them getting away with their crimes.

to:

* BigBad: U.N. Owen, really [[spoiler:[[HangingJudge Justice]] Lawrence Wargrave]], Owen is the killer who traps everyone in the mansion to [[TenLittleMurderVictims off them one-by-one]] as punishment for them getting away with their crimes.



* TheButlerDidIt: Averted; [[spoiler: Rogers is one of the early characters to be killed off. He and his wife did commit the crime they were accused of, but this is no surprise. ]]

to:

* TheButlerDidIt: Averted; [[spoiler: [[spoiler:Averted; Rogers is one of the early characters to be killed off. He and his wife did commit the crime they were accused of, but this is no surprise. the murders on the island weren't him.]]



* ClosedCircle: The group of ten are trapped on an island.
* ContrivedCoincidence: The storm prevents anybody from leaving the island throughout the course of the story. It's {{downplayed|Trope}}, as it was common knowledge that the island is often isolated by the storm for a week or more, at least one experienced man is able to predict its coming in advance, and, finally, the island is situated rather far from the coast anyway. Essentially, as that same man says, "you can't never tell at sea".

to:

* ClosedCircle: The group of ten are trapped on an island.
island, and can't just leave it, even after U.N. Owen starts offing them because of a really bad storm.
* ContrivedCoincidence: ContrivedCoincidence:
**
The storm prevents anybody from leaving the island throughout the course of the story. It's {{downplayed|Trope}}, as it was common knowledge that the island is often isolated by the storm for a week or more, at least one experienced man is able to predict its coming in advance, and, finally, the island is situated rather far from the coast anyway. Essentially, as that same man says, "you can't never tell at sea".



* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Lombard doesn't seem to think that abandoning twenty-one men to starve was all that bad because "they were only natives".
** Lombard also sees Isaac Morris as fulfilling the GreedyJew stereotypes.

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Lombard doesn't seem to think that abandoning twenty-one men to starve was all that bad because "they were only natives".
**
natives". Lombard also sees Isaac Morris as fulfilling the GreedyJew stereotypes.



* EverybodysDeadDave: The only named character to survive the story is [[spoiler:Fred Narracott]], unless you count the policemen who only appear in the epilogue.
* EverybodyDiesEnding: When the authorities arrive, they find ten bodies. ''And then there were none.''

to:

* EverybodysDeadDave: The only named character to survive the story is [[spoiler:Fred Narracott]], Narracott, unless you count the policemen who only appear in the epilogue.
epilogue]].
* EverybodyDiesEnding: When [[spoiler:When the authorities arrive, they find ten bodies. ''And then there were none.'' '']]



%%* GambitRoulette

to:

%%* GambitRoulette* GambitRoulette: As soon as the bodies start piling up and it becomes clear that survival isn't a guarantee, everyone starts making their own plans to outsmart the others and kill the others, or at the very least defend themselves long enough to escape. [[spoiler:But it ultimately doesn't matter, as none of them make it out alive.]]



* HaveAGayOldTime: General Macarthur's thoughts on Captain Philip Lombard: "That fellow Lombard now, he was a queer chap. Not straight. He'd swear the man wasn't straight."

to:

* HaveAGayOldTime: HaveAGayOldTime:
**
General Macarthur's thoughts on Captain Philip Lombard: "That fellow Lombard now, he was a queer chap. Not straight. He'd swear the man wasn't straight."



%%* WhyDidItHaveToBeSnakes: Or wasps and bees, in Miss Brent's case.

to:

%%* * WhyDidItHaveToBeSnakes: Or wasps and bees, in Miss Brent's case.case. She gets so freaked out by seeing bees that [[GetAHoldOfYourselfMan someone else has to slap Miss Brent in the face to bring her back down to earth]]. Even then, it's still a sore subject.

Added: 430

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AsYouKnow: In the video game, Wargrave provides some background information on the court of Chancery that is more to explain to modern readers and players why the poem's line "one got into Chancery" would be connected to death (it dealt with equity disputes before it was merged with the common law courts in 1873, and cases could often drag out for the lifetimes of those involved) than for the benefit of the other characters.



** The video game also invokes this with Gabrielle Turl, the Hollywood actress mentioned among the rumours of the true identity of Indian/Soldier Island's owner in the book's opening. Renamed as Gabrielle Steel, [[spoiler: it's revealed in the game that she not only owns the island, she's been impersonating Miss Brent after murdering her two weeks prior, having masterminded the entire plot as revenge against Wargrave for killing Edward Seton, to whom she was romantically attached.]]

to:

** The video game also invokes this with Gabrielle Turl, the Hollywood actress mentioned among the rumours of the true identity of Indian/Soldier Island's owner in the book's opening. Renamed as Gabrielle Steel, Steele, [[spoiler: it's revealed in the game that she not only owns the island, she's been impersonating Miss Brent after murdering her two weeks prior, having masterminded the entire plot as revenge against Wargrave for killing Edward Seton, to whom she was romantically attached.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NobleProfession: This is probably why Dr. Armstrong dies third, just before multiple-murderer Lombard and child-killer Vera, even though the death of his patient was arguably an accident; the killer felt he should know better.

to:

* NobleProfession: This is probably why Dr. Armstrong dies third, just before multiple-murderer Lombard and child-killer Vera, even though the death of his patient was arguably an accident; the killer felt he should know better. [[spoiler: And arguably, Wargrave exploits ''his'' profession's respectability to lure Armstrong into a false sense of safety.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NobleProfession: This is probably why Dr. Armstrong dies third, just before multiple-murderer Lombard and child-killer Vera, even though the death of his patient was arguably an accident; the killer felt he should know better.

Changed: 198

Removed: 151

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
These points belong on the page for the 2015 adaptation.


* AlasPoorVillain: General Macarthur did send his wife's lover to his death but, by the time the story begins, he has become a somber man, living a rather unhappy life. Because of his act of jealousy, he's (unknowingly) condemned himself to live his retirement alone, when the rumors start to catch up with him. Also, his wife, whom he truly loved, never truly recovered after the death of her lover and died a few years after because of [[UsefulNotes/TheSpanishFlu the 1918-1920 Spanish flu pandemic]], ultimately making his action [[AllForNothing pointless]]. When he has to face the fact that he will never leave the island alive, [[FaceDeathWithDignity he calmly accepts his fate]]. The 2015 BBC adaptation goes one step further by showing that he ended up regretting not letting Leslie and her lover be together.
--> '''Macarthur''': "[[MyGreatestFailure I should have just stepped aside like a gentleman...]] [[IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy Just let them be happy...]]"

to:

* AlasPoorVillain: General Macarthur did send his wife's lover to his death but, by the time the story begins, he has become a somber man, living a rather unhappy life. Because of his act of jealousy, he's (unknowingly) condemned himself to live his retirement alone, when the rumors start to catch up with him. Also, his wife, whom he truly loved, never truly recovered after the death of her lover and died a few years after because of [[UsefulNotes/TheSpanishFlu the 1918-1920 Spanish flu pandemic]], double pneumonia, ultimately making his action [[AllForNothing pointless]]. When he has to face the fact that he will never leave the island alive, [[FaceDeathWithDignity he calmly accepts his fate]]. The 2015 BBC adaptation goes one step further by showing that he ended up regretting not letting Leslie and her lover be together.
--> '''Macarthur''': "[[MyGreatestFailure I should have just stepped aside like a gentleman...]] [[IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy Just let them be happy...]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The island itself is renamed Shipwreck Island in the game adaptation, attributed by player character Patrick Narracott to its resemblance to a beached schooner and to the many shipwrecks that have been caused by the submerged rocks surrounding it. Related to this, the central poem is renamed "Ten Little Sailors".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The video game also invokes this with Gabrielle Turl, the Hollywood actress mentioned among the rumours of the true identity of Indian/Soldier Island's owner in the book's opening. Renamed as Gabrielle Steel, [[spoiler: it's revealed in the game that she not only owns the island, she's been impersonating Miss Brent after murdering her two weeks prior, having masterminded the entire plot as revenge against Wargrave for killing Edward Seton, to whom she was romantically attached.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheAlcoholic: The video game adaptation plays up this aspect of Dr. Armstrong's character. Whereas in the book, he'd been sober since the incident with Mary Clees, his game counterpart is constantly slipping away to his room to "freshen up", as he puts it. Becomes a plot point when [[spoiler: the killer goads him into getting so drunk that he won't notice their pulse after they've faked their death.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OneDialogueTwoConversations: How Lombard meets his end. He failed to recognize that there was actually no double meaning in Vera's words and responded to her questions as if he needed to let her understand that she still wouldn't come on top. Which only made her certain that Lombard is the killer and has to be liquidated. Another proof that PoorCommunicationKills.

to:

* OneDialogueTwoConversations: How Lombard meets his end. He failed to recognize that there was actually no double meaning in Vera's words and responded to her questions as if he needed to let her understand that she might be the killer but she still wouldn't come on top. Which only made her certain that Lombard ''he'' is the killer and has to be liquidated. Another proof that PoorCommunicationKills.

Top