Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Horrible / Music

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I personally found it SoBadItsGood, so YMMV.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-> ''"(screams and cries in horror and pain) These [[PrecisionFStrike fucking]] songs are '''HORRIBLE!''' It's like Alan Menken's [[RefugeInVulgarity puke]] [[CrossesTheLineTwice somehow mutated]] [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking and started writing music!"]]''

to:

-> ''"(screams and cries in horror and pain) These ''"These [[PrecisionFStrike fucking]] songs are '''HORRIBLE!''' It's like Alan Menken's [[RefugeInVulgarity puke]] [[CrossesTheLineTwice somehow mutated]] [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking and started writing music!"]]''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-> ''"(screams and cries in horror and pain) These [[PrecisionFStrike fucking]] songs are '''HORRIBLE!''' It's like Alan Menken's [[RefugeInVulgarity puke]] [[CrossesTheLineTwice somehow mutated]] [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking and started writing music!"]]''
-->--The NostalgiaCritic during his review of TomAndJerryTheMovie.

Added: 99

Changed: 260

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Their "best ever" lists took a hit back in the '80s, though, when it was revealed that Wenner put "Uptown Girl" in the lower rungs of a "best singles of the past 20 years" list just to kiss Billy Joel's butt. He could have at least gone with "Piano Man"...
** To be fair, critics in general think Springsteen and U2 can do no wrong, not just Rolling Stone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It looks like they had very intelligent writers and dumbass writers working for the magazine. This can be seen because some of the entries on the list actually make sense (i.e. ecstasy having a negative influence on the music scene).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** It's actually Rolling Stone's album reviews that have been going downhill. They still have credibility. Their "best ever" lists are totally done fairly (due to them having credible people in the music industry list their favorite in whatever category it's in, and then based off of their lists develop a point system). What's wrong with Rolling Stone is it takes their reviewers awhile to see greatness or potential in something that AllMusic sees months in advance. They're not horrible, but they aren't as credible as they used to be.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ex-Cheetah Girl Kiely Willams tries to reinvent herself as DarkerAndEdgier (and falls flat on her face) with [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cc030yp6-bg "Spectacular"]], a touching tribute to binge drinking, unprotected sex with strangers, and date rape. Features catchy lyrics such as: "Last I remember I was face down, ass up, clothes off". Brings a lump to your throat, doesn't it?

to:

* Ex-Cheetah Girl Kiely Willams tries to reinvent herself as DarkerAndEdgier (and falls flat on her face) with [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cc030yp6-bg com/watch?v=unDB3y1jW1U "Spectacular"]], a touching tribute to binge drinking, unprotected sex with strangers, and date rape. Features catchy lyrics such as: "Last I remember I was face down, ass up, clothes off". Brings a lump to your throat, doesn't it?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Arguably, ''Rolling Stone'' magazine could fit this trope well, particularly from the mid 1970s onward when its "ex-hippie baby boomers first" ethos started becoming irrelevant in the face of punk, disco, and new wave. Its lips are permanently attached to a select group of acts (Bruce Springsteen, U2, etc.), its covers perpetuate an outdated sexist view of women, and Jann Wenner is generally acknowledged as being the person who is single-handedly ruining the prestige and value of the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame since he became its administrator.

to:

* Arguably, ''Rolling Stone'' magazine could fit this trope well, particularly from the mid 1970s onward when its "ex-hippie baby boomers first" ethos started becoming irrelevant in the face of punk, disco, and new wave. Its lips are permanently attached to the backsides of a select group of acts (Bruce Springsteen, U2, Pearl Jam, etc.), its covers perpetuate an outdated sexist view of women, and Jann Wenner is generally acknowledged as being the person who is single-handedly ruining the prestige and value of the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame since he became its administrator.

Added: 551

Changed: 372

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OMG, nuh-uh, no WAY did they put Japan and Howard Jones on that list of "worst artists of all time"! Do they know what the hell they're even talking about there? Do they solely enjoy listening to shallow dreck that doesn't require any thought at all? This means war.

to:

* ** OMG, nuh-uh, no WAY did they put Japan and Howard Jones on that list of "worst artists of all time"! Do they know what the hell they're even talking about there? Do they solely enjoy listening to shallow dreck that doesn't require any thought at all? This means war.




to:

* ''Paste'' magazine, while not as egregious an offender as ''Blender'', is generally regarded as a shallow "style" magazine that only highlights the artists that are safely considered hip by a certain coffee-drinking, aspirationally urban segment of the population. Its articles lack substance and it's highly unusual for them to cover any "challenging" musical genres.
* Arguably, ''Rolling Stone'' magazine could fit this trope well, particularly from the mid 1970s onward when its "ex-hippie baby boomers first" ethos started becoming irrelevant in the face of punk, disco, and new wave. Its lips are permanently attached to a select group of acts (Bruce Springsteen, U2, etc.), its covers perpetuate an outdated sexist view of women, and Jann Wenner is generally acknowledged as being the person who is single-handedly ruining the prestige and value of the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame since he became its administrator.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OMG, nuh-uh, no WAY did they put Japan and Howard Jones on that list of "worst artists of all time"! Do they know what the hell they're even talking about there? Do they solely enjoy listening to shallow dreck that doesn't require any thought at all? This means war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It'd be awfully rich for new wave fans to hate disco considering how much the genre influenced new wave music, particularly in Britain with post-punk's influence on new wave (post-punk being a combination of punk and disco). And it might be argued that only certain punks disliked disco; Scottish punk bands by and large enjoyed disco and the Scars's punk classic "[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Er9l5R37a58 Adult ery]]" was inspired after the band watched the film ''{{Saturday Night Fever}}''.


Added DiffLines:

* While ''Thank You'' has some redeeming values to it, Duran Duran's ''Red Carpet Massacre'' was a real musical massacre. Making things worse was that Timbaland and Justin Timberlake (believe it or not) were co-producers of the album and made it sound overproduced and lightweight. Nearly every single song on the album is forgettable and there is nothing that redeems the album.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Though Lou Reed loved the band's cover of "Perfect Day", the "White Lines" cover became a fan favorite, and some covers (e.g. "Crystal Ship") are arguably well done. It's just the weird selections and listener dissonance (e.g. the aforementioned "911 Is A Joke" cover) that rendered the covers album a poor one overall. Had they stuck with their actual influences (e.g. Bowie, Cockney Rebel, The Doors), that might've made for a better album.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is an example of artists being trolls. They cover the song, knowing full well it's WAAAY out of their style just for laughs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A woman named Emma Amelia Pearl Czikai is reportedly suing Simon Cowell for insulting her after [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPLWhmH5bDc this performance]] on BritainsGotTalent. What makes it worse is the way she introduces herself in the little montage prior to her singing. She claims that her music has brought people to tears. Now we can all see why that is true.

to:

* A woman named Emma Amelia Pearl Czikai is reportedly suing Simon Cowell for insulting her after [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPLWhmH5bDc this performance]] on BritainsGotTalent. What makes it worse is the way she introduces herself in the little montage prior to her singing. She claims that her music has brought people to tears. Now I think we can all see why that is that's true.

Added: 120

Changed: 457

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"'Nuff said" isn't much of an explaination.


* Celine Dion covered AC/DC's "You Shook Me All Night Long." 'Nuff said.

to:

* If there ever was a fast way to take a classic hard rock song and [[RuinedForever ruin it forever]], letting an elderly diva famous for her soothing ballads perform a cover version of it would be one of the most efficient methods to do so. Case in point, Celine Dion covered AC/DC's "You [[{{ACDC}} AC/DC]]'s "[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULmC8JTTVy0 You Shook Me All Night Long." 'Nuff said. ]]" With Anastasia, to boot. Just the sight of Celine trying to act like she's in any way credible as a rock singer should already be shameful enough.
** And once you've seen that, wash it down with the [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zHtuGMHWAf0 Shania Twain]] version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Don't expect this album to be removed from this list anytime soon, as the album is still considered a commercial failure, despite the fact that it eventually became a gold record. Lil Wayne's previous album, ''Tha Carter 3'', went triple platinum, and has a good chance at becoming a Diamond Album one day. ''Rebirth'' has sold one sixth of what ''Tha Carter 3'' sold, a significant drop in sales, and it is highly unlikely that it will ever sell any more units. Not to mention the millions of unsold copies sitting in retail stores due to an overestimate of sales.

to:

** Don't expect this the album to be removed from this list anytime soon, as the album is still considered a commercial failure, despite the fact that it eventually became a gold record. Lil Wayne's previous album, ''Tha Carter 3'', went triple platinum, and has a good chance at becoming a Diamond Album one day. ''Rebirth'' has sold one sixth of what ''Tha Carter 3'' sold, a significant drop in sales, and it is highly unlikely that it will ever sell any more units. Not to mention the millions of unsold copies sitting in retail stores due to an overestimate of sales.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Don't expect this album to be removed from this list anytime soon, as the album is still considered a commercial failure, despite the fact that it eventually became a gold record, Lil Wayne's previous album, ''Tha Carter 3'', went triple platinum, and has a good chance at becoming a Diamond Album one day. ''Rebirth'' has sold one sixth of what ''Tha Carter 3'' sold, a significant drop in sales, and it is highly unlikely that it will ever sell any more units. Not to mention the millions of unsold copies sitting in retail stores due to an overestimate of sales.

to:

** Don't expect this album to be removed from this list anytime soon, as the album is still considered a commercial failure, despite the fact that it eventually became a gold record, record. Lil Wayne's previous album, ''Tha Carter 3'', went triple platinum, and has a good chance at becoming a Diamond Album one day. ''Rebirth'' has sold one sixth of what ''Tha Carter 3'' sold, a significant drop in sales, and it is highly unlikely that it will ever sell any more units. Not to mention the millions of unsold copies sitting in retail stores due to an overestimate of sales.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While the album did become a gold record, its still considered a commercial failure. Lil Wayne's previous album, ''Tha Carter 3'', went triple platinum, and has a good chance at becoming a Diamond Album one day. ''Rebirth'' has sold one sixth of what ''Tha Carter 3'' sold, a significant drop in sales, and it is highly unlikely that it will ever sell any more units. Not to mention the millions of unsold copies sitting in retail stores due to an overestimate of sales.

to:

** While Don't expect this album to be removed from this list anytime soon, as the album did become a gold record, its is still considered a commercial failure. failure, despite the fact that it eventually became a gold record, Lil Wayne's previous album, ''Tha Carter 3'', went triple platinum, and has a good chance at becoming a Diamond Album one day. ''Rebirth'' has sold one sixth of what ''Tha Carter 3'' sold, a significant drop in sales, and it is highly unlikely that it will ever sell any more units. Not to mention the millions of unsold copies sitting in retail stores due to an overestimate of sales.



** ''Thank You'' is a collection of {{cover song}}s originally done by the band's influences. All the covers are poorly done. Probably the worst is [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_k_BgzSDQNk their cover of Public Enemy's "911 Is A Joke".]] Also, the album led to a lot of critical backlash; the band had trouble recovering from it. Critics would reject later DuranDuran albums sound unheard because of this. Oh, and the worst part? You know how some albums get better with each listen? This one gets worse with each listen, and it's insulting on the first listen.

to:

** ''Thank You'' is a collection of {{cover song}}s cover songs originally done by the band's influences. All the covers are poorly done. Probably the worst is [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_k_BgzSDQNk their cover of Public Enemy's "911 Is A Joke".]] Also, the album led to a lot of critical backlash; the band had trouble recovering from it. Critics would reject later DuranDuran albums sound unheard because of this. Oh, and the worst part? You know how some albums get better with each listen? This one gets worse with each listen, and it's insulting on the first listen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The CreatorBacklash has already started on this one. Take a look at that link and read the comments. The last 2 which were both negative comments were removed and all the other comments are positive. This isn't gonna end well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The track "I Can Transform Ya" is regarded as the worst single of 2009. The song lacks a tune and has obnoxious lyrics. Even though Lil Wayne is on this track, [[BeyondtheImpossible it's generally regarded as the lowest point in Lil Wayne's entire musical career, including the album ''Rebirth,'' which is]] ''also'' extremely dubious. Fortunately, [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G5IuRsmS4ho the hatred "I Can Transform Ya" received from reviewers can make interesting reading.]]

to:

*** The track "I Can Transform Ya" is regarded as the worst single of 2009. The song lacks a tune and has obnoxious lyrics. Even though Lil Wayne is on this track, [[BeyondtheImpossible it's generally regarded as the lowest point in Lil Wayne's entire musical career, including the album aforementioned ''Rebirth,'' which is]] ''also'' extremely dubious. Fortunately, [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G5IuRsmS4ho the hatred "I Can Transform Ya" received from reviewers can make interesting reading.]]



* Sheryl Crowe's cover of "[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZFU9qBEvEVw Sweet Child O' Mine]]" will make your ears bleed.

to:

* Sheryl Crowe's Crow's cover of "[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZFU9qBEvEVw Sweet Child O' Mine]]" will make your ears bleed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A woman named Amelia Pearl Czikai is reportedly suing Simon Cowell for insulting her after [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPLWhmH5bDc this performance]] on BritainsGotTalent. What makes it worse is the way she introduces herself in the little montage prior to her singing. She claims that her music has brought people to tears. Now we can all see why that is true.

to:

* A woman named Emma Amelia Pearl Czikai is reportedly suing Simon Cowell for insulting her after [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPLWhmH5bDc this performance]] on BritainsGotTalent. What makes it worse is the way she introduces herself in the little montage prior to her singing. She claims that her music has brought people to tears. Now we can all see why that is true.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A woman named Amelia Pearl Czikai is reportedly suing Simon Cowell for insulting her after [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPLWhmH5bDc this performance]] on BritainsGotTalent. What makes it worse is the way she introduces herself in the little montage prior to her singing. She claims that her music has brought people to tears. Now we can all see why that is true.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Don't forget Kanye West's performance of Love Lockdown on SaturdayNightLive sans Auto Tune. As much flak as people get for lip-synching, he probably should have done so here.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Warning: It's also an EarWorm. You'll hate it, but it sticks in your mind and you just ''CAN'T'' get it out of your head!!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** YourMileageMayVary on some of these, as more reputable critics share some of these opinions. Even one edition of the Rolling Stone Record Guide dubbed TheDoors "the most overrated band in rock history," while Dave Marsh's ''The Book of Rock Lists'' includes "We Didn't Start The Fire" on its list of worst #1 hits.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Kyle Dennis, better known as [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ow9FiLESA0 Fuck, The Retarded Girl]]. That's pretty much what all his music sounds like right there. He is known only for [[TrueArtIsOffensive shock value]], both on his artwork and in his recordings, (for example, the song "Two Zoophiles" which sampled commentary on a couple having sex with a horse) and, all-in-all, shows little-to-no effort beyond merely evincing discomfort.

to:

* Noise musician Kyle Dennis, better known as [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ow9FiLESA0 Fuck, The Retarded Girl]]. That's pretty much what all his music sounds like right there. He is known only for [[TrueArtIsOffensive shock value]], both on his artwork and in his recordings, (for example, the song "Two Zoophiles" which sampled commentary on a couple having sex with a horse) and, all-in-all, shows little-to-no effort beyond merely evincing discomfort.

Added: 721

Removed: 277

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Self-Portrait'' by BobDylan. It's been said that "nobody sings Dylan like Dylan," and his voice is effective on his own material. But who thought that a double album of Dylan covering other people's stuff would be a good idea? Ever wanted to hear Dylan sing "Let It Be Me"?



* ''Self-Portrait'' by BobDylan. It's been said that "nobody sings Dylan like Dylan," and his voice is effective on his own material. But who thought that a double album of Dylan covering other people's stuff would be a good idea? Ever wanted to hear Dylan sing "Let It Be Me"?


Added DiffLines:

* Kyle Dennis, better known as [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ow9FiLESA0 Fuck, The Retarded Girl]]. That's pretty much what all his music sounds like right there. He is known only for [[TrueArtIsOffensive shock value]], both on his artwork and in his recordings, (for example, the song "Two Zoophiles" which sampled commentary on a couple having sex with a horse) and, all-in-all, shows little-to-no effort beyond merely evincing discomfort.

Changed: 1

Removed: 500

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dZ94vnmvPrw Jan Terri]]. Her music will make you want to run screaming into traffic.
* Ladies and gentlemen, I introduce you to [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ow9FiLESA0 Fuck, The Retarded Girl]]. If you think Lou Reed's metal machine music was unlistenable, you'll be crying for that hour long recording of guitar feedback back when you listen to this. Pure, utter noise in it's most uncomfortable form. This is the way all of their music sounds, and one of their tracks is notorious for including commentary on a couple having sex with a miniature stallion. Sweet dreams, kiddies.

to:

* [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dZ94vnmvPrw Jan Terri]]. Her music will make you want to run screaming into traffic.
* Ladies and gentlemen, I introduce you to [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ow9FiLESA0 Fuck, The Retarded Girl]]. If you think Lou Reed's metal machine music was unlistenable, you'll be crying for that hour long recording of guitar feedback back when you listen to this. Pure, utter noise in it's most uncomfortable form. This is the way all of their music sounds, and one of their tracks is notorious for including commentary on a couple having sex with a miniature stallion. Sweet dreams, kiddies.
traffic.

Added: 297

Changed: 280

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Some minor cleanup


'''''Important Note''''': When judging sales, keep certain facts in mind. Even a gold record can be considered a commercial failure if the previous record by the artist sold triple platinum. Which is why ''Rebirth'' and ''Results May Vary'' are considered commercial failures. '''''Important Note''''': When considering music for this list, do some research and see if the album/band has had an important role in the development of something else. For example, Metal Machine Music, despite being critically panned, helped form NoiseRock and {{Shoegazing}}.

to:

'''''Important *'''''Important Note''''': When judging sales, keep certain facts in mind. Even a gold record can be considered a commercial failure if the previous record by the artist sold triple platinum. Which is why ''Rebirth'' and ''Results May Vary'' are considered commercial failures. '''''Important Note''''':
**'''''[[RuleOfThree Important Note]]''''':
When considering music for this list, do some research and see if the album/band has had an important role in the development of something else. For example, Metal Machine Music, despite being critically panned, helped form NoiseRock and {{Shoegazing}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''''Important Note''''': When judging sales, keep certain facts in mind. Even a gold record can be considered a commercial failure if the previous record by the artist sold triple platinum. Which is why ''Rebirth'' and ''Results May Vary'' are considered commercial failures.

to:

'''''Important Note''''': When judging sales, keep certain facts in mind. Even a gold record can be considered a commercial failure if the previous record by the artist sold triple platinum. Which is why ''Rebirth'' and ''Results May Vary'' are considered commercial failures. '''''Important Note''''': When considering music for this list, do some research and see if the album/band has had an important role in the development of something else. For example, Metal Machine Music, despite being critically panned, helped form NoiseRock and {{Shoegazing}}.

Top