Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Heartwarming / Mulan

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* No one questions "Ping's" manhood when Mulan holds the murdered little girl's doll to her chest. Shang looks completely understanding about it, showing that despite his macho personality, he knows that it's approproate to show sadness or grief.


Added DiffLines:

** Oddly enough, Shan Yu reacting to Mulan revealing herself as the "soldier from the mountains". There's no mockery, no disbelief, just Shan Yu recognizing Mulan as his true WorthyOpponent, and putting all of his effort into getting payback. After going through much of the story being disrespected or humiliated because of her gender, this could he seen as the first time Mulan has ''ever'' been treated as an equal to a man. Even though he's trying to kill her, Shan Yu really only sees Mulan as a soldier, [[PoliticallyCorrectVillain her being a woman is irrelevant to him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When Mulan sneaks into her parents' bedchamber and steals the commission, Mulan briefly looks at her asleep father with regret and uncertainty before her expression changes to one of resolved endearment -- a subtle showing that no matter what consequences she might incur, be it dishonor to her family or execution by law, Mulan is truly doing this out of love.

Added: 780

Changed: 104

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As funny as the bathing scene is, there's something to be said for how Yao, Ling, and Chien Po almost immediately show up running and laughing to swim in the lake right after Mulan gets in, and aren't surprised to see her. Yao immediately and invitingly calls out "Hey, Ping!" once they're close to her, and Ling acknowledges that the trio were rude to her before and asks to start over, the gang properly introducing themselves right before automatically trying to include her in playing with them. It's possible they were also thinking of bathing that night, noticed their awkward-but-smart newfound training buddy Ping heading off to take a dip, and thought that joining "him" would be a great opportunity to make amends and memories, inviting "him" into their friend circle!



** When the Emperor is captured by Shan Yu, we see Shang, Yao, Ling, and Chien-Po trying to break into the palace to rescue him. Mulan runs over and tells them she has a {{plan}}. Shang looks understandably hesitant to follow her, but Yao, Ling, and Chien-Po ''immediately'' drop what they're doing and run over to help her. It clearly doesn't bother them a bit that she's a woman or that she had to lie to get into the army. That, my friends, is the very definition of TrueCompanions.

to:

** When the Emperor is captured by Shan Yu, we see Shang, Yao, Ling, and Chien-Po trying to break into the palace to rescue him. Mulan runs over and tells them she has a {{plan}}. Shang looks understandably hesitant to follow her, but Yao, Ling, and Chien-Po ''immediately'' drop what they're doing and run over to help her. It clearly doesn't bother them a bit that she's a woman or that she had to lie to get into the army. army - all they know is that their friend, who has been a great problem-solver in the past, has a new idea! That, my friends, is the very definition of TrueCompanions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Fa Zhou''': ''(throws them aside and hugs her)'' The greatest gift and honor is having you for a daughter. I missed you so.

to:

'''Fa Zhou''': ''(throws them aside and hugs her)'' [[SoProudOfYou The greatest gift and honor is having you for a daughter. daughter.]] I missed you so.

Added: 306

Changed: 27

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> She's just trying to help her father --

to:

--> She's ''"She's just trying to help her father ----"''



* The moment when General Li promotes Shang to Captain. You can tell how much the General is proud of his son with just his few sentences. Shang's [[{{Adorkable}} joy and borderline fawning]] before gaining back his composure just seal the deal.

to:

* The moment when General Li promotes Shang to Captain. You can tell how much the General is proud of his son with just his few sentences. Shang's [[{{Adorkable}} [[EndearinglyDorky joy and borderline fawning]] before gaining back his composure just seal the deal.deal.
** While more of a {{Tearjerker}} given that this would be the last time Shang and his father would see each other, the fact that this was the last thing the General would say to his son at the very least will let Shang carry on his memory knowing he wasn't a WellDoneSonGuy and have no PartingWordsRegret.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:[[SoProudOfYou The greatest gift and honor is having you for a daughter.]]]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:[[SoProudOfYou The "The greatest gift and honor is having you for a daughter.]]]]
"]]]]

Added: 823

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Brief but sweet moment: During the song "Honor to Us All", a boy steals a little girl's doll and tries to run away with it only for Mulan to take the doll and give it back to the girl.

to:

* Brief but a sweet moment: During the song "Honor to Us All", a boy steals a little girl's doll and tries to run away with it only for Mulan to take the doll and give it back to the girl.



* It's subtle, but "A Girl Worth Fighting For" has a lot of friendly moments between the soldiers. At the beginning, they're worn-out from the long march and morale is low, but Ling cheers them up by suggesting that instead, they think about what (or rather, who) would make the journey worthwhile, and by the end, everyone [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments except Mulan]] is in high spirits, singing, smiling, joking, [[VitriolicBestBuds shoving each other around]], throwing snowballs and making snowmen. [[MoodWhiplash That is, until they see the burned-out remains of the village.]]

to:

* It's subtle, but "A Girl Worth Fighting For" has a lot of friendly moments between the soldiers. At In the beginning, they're worn-out from the long march and morale is low, but Ling cheers them up by suggesting that instead, they think about what (or rather, who) would make the journey worthwhile, and by the end, everyone [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments except Mulan]] is in high spirits, singing, smiling, joking, [[VitriolicBestBuds shoving each other around]], throwing snowballs and making snowmen. [[MoodWhiplash That is, until they see the burned-out remains of the village.]]


Added DiffLines:

** Technically, no one is allowed to touch the Emperor, the representative of heaven. The Emperor lets it slide when Chien-Po apologizes before picking him up and evacuating him to safety as Shang holds off Shan Yu. After all, the man saved his life and with it, China's independence from the Huns.
** Shan Yu manages to knock out Shang just as Mulan is about to evacuate on the ImprovisedZipline. Yao sees her hesitating about leaving her commander and orders her to hurry up! Mulan makes another decision: cut the line so that Shan Yu can't follow.
** While they're running from Shan Yu, Mulan admits she doesn't have a plan to Mushu. Then they stop and see the fireworks tower from the window. When Mulan says "Mushu," he goes, "Way ahead of you, sister" and takes Crick-Ee to commandeer the fireworks. It's perfect sync.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

--> She's just trying to help her father --
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another example is when one of the ancestors showing more care about Mulan than the others by defending her actions when she reminds them Mulan is only trying to help her father.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Update a link to fix dead URL


** [[http://theflyingredpig.tumblr.com/post/91894843215/leaper182-this-is-one-of-my-most-favorite This commentary]] just cements how beautiful this scene really is.

to:

** [[http://theflyingredpig.[[https://leaper182.tumblr.com/post/91894843215/leaper182-this-is-one-of-my-most-favorite com/post/91881173381/this-is-one-of-my-most-favorite-endings-to-a This commentary]] just cements how beautiful this scene really is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Brief but sweet moment: during the song "Honor to Us All", a boy steals a little girl's doll and tries to run away with it only for Mulan to take the doll and give it back to the girl.

to:

* Brief but sweet moment: during During the song "Honor to Us All", a boy steals a little girl's doll and tries to run away with it only for Mulan to take the doll and give it back to the girl.



-->'''Fa Zhou:''' My, my. What beautiful blossoms we have this year. But look! This one's late. But I'll bet that when it blooms, it will be the most beautiful of all.
:: : It later receives a beautiful echo from the Emperor of China himself.

to:

-->'''Fa Zhou:''' My, my. What beautiful blossoms we have this year. ''(notices a flower that hasn't opened yet)'' But look! This one's late. But I'll bet that when it blooms, it will be the most beautiful of all.
:: : It later receives a beautiful echo MeaningfulEcho from the Emperor of China Emperor, himself.



* There's a quick one when Mulan's father is getting his drafting orders. One of the other families is called and an older man is about to step forward. His son stops him and states that he'll go in his father's place.

to:

* There's a quick one when Mulan's father is getting his Chi Fu announces the drafting orders. One of When the other families Yi family is called and an older man is about to step forward. His called, the patriarch's son stops him from stepping forward and states that he'll go in his father's place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* General Li summarizes his plan to Chi Fu and Shang: Shan Yu has been wiping out every village that crosses his path. The last one before the path to the capital is in the Tung Shao Pass, so the general decides to set up his men there to ambush Shan Yu before he can cause more devastation. Part of General Li's strategy is to defeat Shan Yu, but the other part is to protect innocents.


Added DiffLines:

* Fa Li and Grandmother Fa then see that Mulan has returned and reconciled with Fa Zhou. While Fa Li gives a relieved smile that her daughter is safe, Grandmother Fa snarks she should have brought home a man. Fa Li gives her a smirk, knowing Grandmother Fa cares.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** To reiterate, Shang has spent most of the movie dealing with Chi Fu's taunts and unhelpful criticisms, never even threatening him. But the ''moment'' the arrogant Chi Fu threatens and insults Mulan, Shang doesn't hesitate to angrily grab him with the heavy implication he would've gotten more violent had the Emperor not stepped. Mulan really does have a soft place in Shang's heart.

to:

*** To reiterate, Shang has spent most of the movie dealing with Chi Fu's taunts and unhelpful criticisms, never even threatening him. But the ''moment'' the arrogant Chi Fu threatens and insults Mulan, Shang doesn't hesitate to angrily grab him with the heavy implication he would've gotten more violent had the Emperor not stepped.stepped in. Mulan really does have a soft place in Shang's heart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The characters also reveal something else heartwarming. No matter what happened, later on, naming your kid "bully" is a pretty darn mean name to give a baby. Thankfully, Chi Fu's parents weren't ''those'' parents: The characters used are another meaning for Chi Fu that translates roughly to "Joyous Fortune" maybe Chi Fu didn't bring 'joyous fortune' to the other characters, but it's nice to know that at the very least it wasn't because he was messed up from having the type of folks who would give "to bully" to an ''infant'' as their actual, official name.

to:

** The characters also reveal something else heartwarming. No matter what happened, later on, naming your kid "bully" is a pretty darn mean name to give a baby. Thankfully, Chi Fu's parents weren't ''those'' parents: The characters used are another meaning for Chi Fu that translates roughly to "Joyous Fortune" Fortune". Now, maybe Chi Fu didn't bring 'joyous fortune' to the other characters, but it's nice to know that at the very least it wasn't because he was messed up from having the type of folks who would give a name like "to bully" to an ''infant'' as their actual, official name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A minor detail and also a TearJerker, but when Mulan's parents discover her departure, Fa Li's only thought when urging her husband to go after her is "She could be killed," while Fa Zhou's only response is "If I reveal her, she will be." The subsequent scene with the ancestors reveals that if Mulan's identity is revealed, her family will be forever shamed and lose their property too, but her parents don't give a thought to this; their only fear is for their daughter's life. Despite the [[WellDoneSonGuy pressure Mulan has felt]] to bring honor to her family, this moment reveals that she truly means more to them than honor does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Likewise, Shang steps forward, preparing to defend Mulan's actions to the Emperor. Technically she's more in the wrong since she deceived him and employed multiple LeeroyJenkins moments that were chaotic and dangerous. That doesn't matter to Shang; he's all about TakingTheHeat so that the woman who saved his life isn't executed. Then we get another heartwarming moment from the Emperor; he refuses to punish or remonstrate Shang for what Mulan did, knowing that the Captain was only doing his best with limited information.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** To reiterate, Shang has spent most of the movie dealing with Chi Fu's taunts and unhelpful criticisms, never even threatening him. But the ''moment'' the arrogant Chi Fu threatens and insults Mulan, Shang doesn't hesitate to angrily grab him with the heavy implication he would've gotten more violent had the Emperor not stepped. Mulan really does have a soft place in Shang's heart.

Added: 1432

Changed: 423

Removed: 914

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Kind of a minor thing, but notice how during the bathing scene, Mushu makes a point of covering his eyes (with his ears) so that way he doesn't see Mulan totally naked--and though it is mostly a funny moment, Mushu goes in to save Mulan from being discovered to be a woman by biting Ling (on his butt) and distracting the others.
* Mulan (as Ping) overhears Chi Fu chew Shang out as being an "unfit" captain, not to mention that his soldiers aren't ready for war. Mulan initially tries to cheer up Shang with a playful suggestion that they beat up Chi Fu, before she gives him this meaningful line:
-->'''Mulan:''' For what it's worth, [[YouAreBetterThanYouThinkYouAre I think you're a great captain]].
* The picture of Chi Fu with the emperor is clearly intended to be a funny moment, but the characters translated reveal that it was a gift from his younger brother.
** The characters also reveal something else heartwarming. No matter what happened, later on, naming your kid "bully" is a pretty darn mean name to give a baby. Thankfully, Chi Fu's parents weren't ''those'' parents: The characters used are another meaning for Chi Fu that translates roughly to "Joyous Fortune" maybe Chi Fu didn't bring 'joyous fortune' to the other characters, but it's nice to know that at the very least it wasn't because he was messed up from having the type of folks who would give "to bully" to an ''infant'' as their actual, official name.



* Kind of a minor thing, but notice how during the bathing scene, Mushu makes a point of covering his eyes (with his ears) so that way he doesn't see Mulan totally naked--and though it is mostly a funny moment, Mushu goes in to save Mulan from being discovered to be a woman by biting Ling (on his butt) and distracting the others.
* The picture of Chi Fu with the emperor is clearly intended to be a funny moment, but the characters translated reveal that it was a gift from his younger brother.
** The characters also reveal something else heartwarming. No matter what happened, later on, naming your kid "bully" is a pretty darn mean name to give a baby. Thankfully, Chi Fu's parents weren't ''those'' parents: The characters used are another meaning for Chi Fu that translates roughly to "Joyous Fortune" maybe Chi Fu didn't bring 'joyous fortune' to the other characters, but it's nice to know that at the very least it wasn't because he was messed up from having the type of folks who would give "to bully" to an ''infant'' as their actual, official name.
* Brief but sweet moment: during the song "Honor to Us All", a boy steals a little girl's doll and tries to run away with it only for Mulan to take the doll and give it back to the girl.

to:

* Kind of a minor thing, but notice how during the bathing scene, Mushu makes a point of covering his eyes (with his ears) so that way he doesn't see ** This time around, Shang and Mulan totally naked--and though it is mostly can start over fresh, not as a funny moment, Mushu goes in to save Mulan from being discovered to be false soldier under the command of a woman by biting Ling (on his butt) strict captain, but as equals and distracting the others.
* The picture of Chi Fu with the emperor is clearly intended to be
a funny moment, but the characters translated reveal that it was a gift from his younger brother.
** The characters also reveal something else heartwarming. No matter what happened, later on, naming your kid "bully" is a pretty darn mean name to give a baby. Thankfully, Chi Fu's parents weren't ''those'' parents: The characters used are another meaning for Chi Fu that translates roughly to "Joyous Fortune" maybe Chi Fu didn't bring 'joyous fortune' to the other characters, but it's nice to know that at the very least it wasn't because he was messed up from having the type of folks who would give "to bully" to an ''infant'' as their actual, official name.
* Brief but sweet moment: during the song "Honor to Us All", a boy steals a little girl's doll and tries to run away with it only for Mulan to take the doll and give it back to the girl.
potential couple.

Added: 397

Changed: 18

Removed: 191

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Doubles as a Moment of Awesome, but when General Li says he will place troops protecting the palace, [[AFatherToHisMen the Emperor]] at once tells him that he should go and protect the people of China instead.
* Brief but sweet moment: during the song "Honor to Us All", a boy steals a little girl's doll and tries to run away with it only for Mulan to take the doll and give it back to the girl.



* Doubles as a Moment of Awesome, but when General Li says he will place troops protecting the palace, the Emperor at once tells him that he should go and protect the people of China instead.



* The moment when General Li promotes Shang to Captain. You can tell how much the General is proud of his son with just his few sentences. Shang's joy and borderline fawning before gaining back his composure just seal the deal.

to:

* The moment when General Li promotes Shang to Captain. You can tell how much the General is proud of his son with just his few sentences. Shang's [[{{Adorkable}} joy and borderline fawning fawning]] before gaining back his composure just seal the deal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
A Call Back is a Continuity Nod being used as a plot point.


** It receives a beautiful CallBack from the Emperor of China himself.

to:

** :: : It later receives a beautiful CallBack echo from the Emperor of China himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There is a moment that Mulan finds ActuallyPrettyFunny. When Chi Fu starts singing about a girl he has, Yao whispers to "Ping," "Yeah the only girl who'll love him is his mother." Mulan can't help but smile.


Added DiffLines:

** Also if you recall, Mulan's helmet fell off her when the weapons wagon exploded. Then it got buried in the snow. Shang somehow dug through and found the helmet, and he did it as thanks for "Ping" saving his life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The characters also reveal something else heartwarming. No matter what happened, later on, naming your kid "bully" is a pretty darn mean name to give a baby. Thankfully, Chi Fu's parents weren't ''those'' parents: The characters used are another meaning for Chi Fu that translates roughly to "Joyous Fortune" maybe Chi Fu didn't bring 'joyous fortune' to the other characters, but it's nice to know that at the very least it wasn't because he was messed up from having the type of folks who would give "to bully" to a ''newborn baby'' as their actual, official name.

to:

** The characters also reveal something else heartwarming. No matter what happened, later on, naming your kid "bully" is a pretty darn mean name to give a baby. Thankfully, Chi Fu's parents weren't ''those'' parents: The characters used are another meaning for Chi Fu that translates roughly to "Joyous Fortune" maybe Chi Fu didn't bring 'joyous fortune' to the other characters, but it's nice to know that at the very least it wasn't because he was messed up from having the type of folks who would give "to bully" to a ''newborn baby'' an ''infant'' as their actual, official name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The characters also reveal something else heartwarming. No matter what happened, later on, naming your kid "bully" is a pretty darn mean name to give a baby. Thankfully, Chi Fu's parents weren't ''those'' parents: The characters used are another meaning for Chi Fu that translates roughly to "Joyous Fortune" maybe Chi Fu didn't bring 'joyous fortune' to the other characters, but it's nice to know that at the very least it wasn't because he was messed up from having the type of folks who would give "to bully" to a ''newborn baby'' as their actual, official name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Clarified in this [[http://the-ice-castle.tumblr.com/post/104728131377/you-know-one-thing-i-like-about-mulan-is-how-yao commentary]].

to:

*** Clarified in this [[http://the-ice-castle.[[https://thethiefandtheairbender.tumblr.com/post/104728131377/you-know-one-thing-i-like-about-mulan-is-how-yao com/post/173071774159/the-ice-castle-you-know-one-thing-i-like-about#notes commentary]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Brief but sweet moment: during the song "Honor to Us All", a boy steals a little girl's doll and tries to run away with it only for Mulan to take the doll and give it back to the girl.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Doubles as a Moment of Awesome, but when General Li says he will place troops protecting the palace, the Emperor at once tells him that he should go and protect the people of China instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The picture of Chi Fu with the emperor is clearly intended to be a funny moment, but the characters translated reveal that it was a gift from his younger brother.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Extra extra heartwarming in that in Mulan II, it's shown that he has three daughters, at least one of whom (Mei, the middle daughter) seems close to Mulan's age. He probably wasn't bothered by her hugging him because his daughters have done so many times.

Added: 131

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
just putting this here for future editors


'''As a Moments subpage, all spoilers are unmarked [[Administrivia/SpoilersOff as per policy.]] Administrivia/YouHaveBeenWarned.'''



-->'''Fa Zhou''': My, my. What beautiful blossoms we have this year. But look! This one's late. But I'll bet that when it blooms, it will be the most beautiful of all.

to:

-->'''Fa Zhou''': Zhou:''' My, my. What beautiful blossoms we have this year. But look! This one's late. But I'll bet that when it blooms, it will be the most beautiful of all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Near the end of "I'll Make a Man Out of You", where Yao catches Mulan/Ping's staff in the air, but quickly hands it off to her with a smile, showing she have earned his respect. It makes for a great contrast with the beginning of the song, where, in a nearly identical situation, Yao caught the staff, then used it to knock Mulan/Ping off her feet.

to:

* Near the end of "I'll Make a Man Out of You", where Yao catches Mulan/Ping's staff in the air, but quickly hands it off to her with a smile, showing she have has earned his respect. It makes for a great contrast with the beginning of the song, where, in a nearly identical situation, Yao caught the staff, then used it to knock Mulan/Ping off her feet.

Top