Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / WynonnaEarp

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How did Wynonna's [[spoiler:disappearance]] affect WayHaught? And why was Waverly [[spoiler:engaged to Perry, and not Champ?]]

to:

* How did Wynonna's [[spoiler:disappearance]] affect WayHaught? Waverly and Nicole's relationship? And why was Waverly [[spoiler:engaged to Perry, and not Champ?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because by making August testify, Wyatt had practically sealed his fate. It was never specified that these kills had to be direct.

to:

** Because by making August testify, Wyatt had practically sealed his fate. It was never specified that these kills had to be direct.direct.

* How did Wynonna's [[spoiler:disappearance]] affect WayHaught? And why was Waverly [[spoiler:engaged to Perry, and not Champ?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because in forcing August to testify, Wyatt had practically sealed his fate. It was never specified that these kills had to be direct.

to:

** Because in forcing by making August to testify, Wyatt had practically sealed his fate. It was never specified that these kills had to be direct.

Added: 137

Changed: 77

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** No, because [[spoiler: it was revealed that Waverly is not an Earp.]]



* If the curse effects the seventy-seven killed by Wyatt, how does it effect August Hamilton who was killed by Doc?

to:

* If the curse effects affects the seventy-seven killed by Wyatt, how does it effect affect August Hamilton who was killed by Doc?Doc?
** Because in forcing August to testify, Wyatt had practically sealed his fate. It was never specified that these kills had to be direct.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Season 2 when [[spoiler: Waverly's hand is cut off, and the Mictian grows it back]] wouldn't it be fairly easy for Wynonna to go back and [[spoiler: retrieve the hand and prove it was cut off?]]

to:

* In Season 2 when [[spoiler: Waverly's hand is cut off, and the Mictian grows it back]] wouldn't it be fairly easy for Wynonna to go back and [[spoiler: retrieve the hand and prove it was cut off?]]off?]]

* If the curse effects the seventy-seven killed by Wyatt, how does it effect August Hamilton who was killed by Doc?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In S2E4 when [[spoiler: Waverly's hand is cut off, and the Mictian grows it back]] wouldn't it be fairly easy for Wynonna to go back and [[spoiler: retrieve the hand and prove it was cut off?]]

to:

* In S2E4 Season 2 when [[spoiler: Waverly's hand is cut off, and the Mictian grows it back]] wouldn't it be fairly easy for Wynonna to go back and [[spoiler: retrieve the hand and prove it was cut off?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Does this mean that if Wynonna hadn't returned to Purgatory in the first episode that Waverly would have been the next Earp to inherit the gun? Or does it mean the revenants would have come back on Wynonna's 27th birthday, leaving Waverly as the only Earp in town and the next Earp heir, but with no way to use Peacemaker?

to:

** Does this mean that if Wynonna hadn't returned to Purgatory in the first episode that Waverly would have been the next Earp to inherit the gun? Or does it mean the revenants would have come back on Wynonna's 27th birthday, leaving Waverly as the only Earp in town and the next Earp heir, but with no way to use Peacemaker?Peacemaker?

* In S2E4 when [[spoiler: Waverly's hand is cut off, and the Mictian grows it back]] wouldn't it be fairly easy for Wynonna to go back and [[spoiler: retrieve the hand and prove it was cut off?]]

Added: 738

Changed: 1952

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If the revenants outnumber Wynonna 77 to 1 and know where she lives, why don't they converge on her together outside the boundaries of her land instead of waiting for her to pick them off individually?

** According to the Earp curse, "if the Heir dies before they are able to break the curse, all of the revenants the previous Heir killed will resurrect when they next one comes of age." If the revenants come back every generation and don't change in appearance, wouldn't it be fairly easy to keep track of all of them in such a small town? And even the ones that survive without being killed would be essentially ageless, which ought to raise suspicions.

** Also, if the next family member to turn 27 inherits the gun if the current Heir dies, what's to stop all the revenants in the triangle from killing all the current Earps in town? It's shown when [[spoiler: Willa comes back, and Wynonna can't use Peacemaker anymore]] that if an Heir is not available, the next Earp to turn 27 will inherit the ability to wield Peacemaker. What determines an Heir's availability?
*** Does this mean that if Wynonna hadn't returned to Purgatory in the first episode that Waverly would have been the next Earp to inherit the gun? Or does it mean the revenants would have come back on Wynonna's 27th birthday, leaving Waverly as the only Earp in town and the next Earp heir, but with no way to use Peacemaker?

to:

** * If the revenants outnumber Wynonna 77 to 1 and know where she lives, why don't they converge on her together outside the boundaries of her land instead of waiting for her to pick them off individually?

individually?
** There may be some secondary rule of the curse that prevents the revenants from simply ganging up on the Earps all at once, particularly since Wyatt would have put them all down individually himself.

*
According to the Earp curse, "if the Heir dies before they are able to break the curse, all of the revenants the previous Heir killed will resurrect when they next one comes of age." If the revenants come back every generation and don't change in appearance, wouldn't it be fairly easy to keep track of all of them in such a small town? And even the ones that survive without being killed would be essentially ageless, which ought to raise suspicions.

suspicions.
** Depends on various factors; the quality of photographs in the past may make it harder to identify longer-living Revenants, and they may choose to remain relatively low-key until they have a chance to oppose the Earps.

*
Also, if the next family member to turn 27 inherits the gun if the current Heir dies, what's to stop all the revenants in the triangle from killing all the current Earps in town? It's shown when [[spoiler: Willa comes back, and Wynonna can't use Peacemaker anymore]] that if an Heir is not available, the next Earp to turn 27 will inherit the ability to wield Peacemaker. What determines an Heir's availability?
*** ** Does this mean that if Wynonna hadn't returned to Purgatory in the first episode that Waverly would have been the next Earp to inherit the gun? Or does it mean the revenants would have come back on Wynonna's 27th birthday, leaving Waverly as the only Earp in town and the next Earp heir, but with no way to use Peacemaker?

Added: 326

Changed: 233

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, if the next family member to turn 27 inherits the gun if the current Heir dies, what's to stop all the revenants in the triangle from killing all the current Earps in town.

to:

** Also, if the next family member to turn 27 inherits the gun if the current Heir dies, what's to stop all the revenants in the triangle from killing all the current Earps in town.town? It's shown when [[spoiler: Willa comes back, and Wynonna can't use Peacemaker anymore]] that if an Heir is not available, the next Earp to turn 27 will inherit the ability to wield Peacemaker. What determines an Heir's availability?
*** Does this mean that if Wynonna hadn't returned to Purgatory in the first episode that Waverly would have been the next Earp to inherit the gun? Or does it mean the revenants would have come back on Wynonna's 27th birthday, leaving Waverly as the only Earp in town and the next Earp heir, but with no way to use Peacemaker?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If the revenants outnumber Wynonna 77 to 1 and know where she lives, why don't they converge on her together outside the boundaries of her land instead of waiting for her to pick them off individually?

** According to the Earp curse, "if the Heir dies before they are able to break the curse, all of the revenants the previous Heir killed will resurrect when they next one comes of age." If the revenants come back every generation and don't change in appearance, wouldn't it be fairly easy to keep track of all of them in such a small town? And even the ones that survive without being killed would be essentially ageless, which ought to raise suspicions.

** Also, if the next family member to turn 27 inherits the gun if the current Heir dies, what's to stop all the revenants in the triangle from killing all the current Earps in town.

Top