Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / KenganAshura

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ^^ Well duh, I'd say that indeed, the act of spinning a sword by the large cloth tassel gets in the way of wielding it normally because you're obviously not wielding the thing by the handle while you do so. And yes, while the characters do have superhuman skills in some cases and the spinning can add to the slash a much bigger force than it'd normally have, it is still far from optimal, since unlike a flail, a sword need to hit with the edge ''and'' from the right angle to slash through. Furthermore, the blade may either get stuck in an obstacle (opponent's flesh or surroundings) or worse bounce off, which leaves the wielder wide open as he needs to spin again the sword to rebuild the centrifugal force. In short, while it's cool and may work, it's an awfully impractical choice in a universe where the slightest mistake can leave you dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a response in the head scratchers

Added DiffLines:

** Purgatory is an underground organization like the Kengan matches, hence illegal, so it’s definitely a secret of some level. That said, purgatory still has a lot of funds to cover any slip-ups that might arise and stay underground.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** They could potentially use it as a standard sword as well, and can also fool opponents who initially think it is only a sword.

to:

** They could potentially use it as a standard sword as well, and can also fool opponents who initially think it is only a sword.sword.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It doesnt get in the way of wielding it normally and while spinning a sword as fast as they do is fairly unfeasible, with someone as huge as Howard doing it, it could probably do some real damage. While spinning that huge cleaver Howard uses is probably impossible, [[https://youtu.be/WozbZMljRiM?t=128 Scorpion Dart]] demos give a pretty decent look at what these old-school trick weapons can do

to:

** It doesnt get in the way of wielding it normally and while spinning a sword as fast as they do is fairly unfeasible, with someone as huge as Howard doing it, it could probably do some real damage. While spinning that huge cleaver Howard uses is probably impossible, [[https://youtu.be/WozbZMljRiM?t=128 Scorpion Dart]] demos give how tough people are in the series I imagine it's to make them actually lethal. It's basically having the option to use your sword like a pretty decent look at what these old-school trick weapons can dosling, and slings are scary. In DavidVersusGoliath, David wasn't the underdog, he literally brought a gun to a sword fight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It doesnt get in the way of wielding it normally and while spinning a sword as fast as they do is fairly unfeasible, with someone as huge as Howard doing it, it could probably do some real damage. While spinning that huge cleaver Howard uses is probably impossible, [[https://youtu.be/WozbZMljRiM?t=128 Scorpion Dart]] demos give a pretty decent look at what these old-school trick weapons can do
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* About the spinning sword technique of Long Min, Howard Wu and Xing Wu: how much sense does it make? What's the point of using a completely normal sword as a flail rather than use a proper blade on a rope?

to:

* About the spinning sword technique of Long Min, Howard Wu and Xing Wu: how much sense does it make? What's the point of using a completely normal sword as a flail rather than use a proper blade on a rope?rope?
** They could potentially use it as a standard sword as well, and can also fool opponents who initially think it is only a sword.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Haruo is still shown to be a pretty good fighter, and was likely more than enough to handle run-of-the-mill disputes that Nentendo had to deal with. He just wasn't good enough the Tournament, which many characters noted to be unusually stacked with talent. Also, as it's Nentendo, video games are their forte.

to:

** Haruo is still shown to be a pretty good fighter, and was likely more than enough to handle run-of-the-mill disputes that Nentendo had to deal with. He just wasn't good enough the Tournament, which many characters noted to be unusually stacked with talent. Also, as it's Nentendo, video games are their forte.forte.
* About the spinning sword technique of Long Min, Howard Wu and Xing Wu: how much sense does it make? What's the point of using a completely normal sword as a flail rather than use a proper blade on a rope?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why did the Nentendo president allow Haruo to eat and play video games until be become morbidly obese? Wouldn't it be in his best interest to keep him in as good fighting shape as possible?

to:

* Why did the Nentendo president allow Haruo to eat and play video games until be become morbidly obese? Wouldn't it be in his best interest to keep him in as good fighting shape as possible?possible?
** Haruo is still shown to be a pretty good fighter, and was likely more than enough to handle run-of-the-mill disputes that Nentendo had to deal with. He just wasn't good enough the Tournament, which many characters noted to be unusually stacked with talent. Also, as it's Nentendo, video games are their forte.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Did they ever come out and say it was secret? The rules are pretty mainstream when you look at them and are even safer than the Kengan matches. Pretty much the only thing separating Purgatory and real life MMA is the gloves. There doesn't seem to be a reason for it to be secret.

to:

** Did they ever come out and say it was secret? The rules are pretty mainstream when you look at them and are even safer than the Kengan matches. Pretty much the only thing separating Purgatory and real life MMA is the gloves. There doesn't seem to be a reason for it to be secret.secret.
* Why did the Nentendo president allow Haruo to eat and play video games until be become morbidly obese? Wouldn't it be in his best interest to keep him in as good fighting shape as possible?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Kengan Assocation limits attendance to just members and important government and foreign dignitaries with the latter only showing up during Annihilation Tournaments, thus keeping it's existence secret somewhere in the realm of the plausible if distantly. However Purgatory that has a much greater attendance rate with huge stadiums just for regular matches somehow has kept it's existenc secret as well?

to:

* The Kengan Assocation limits attendance to just members and important government and foreign dignitaries with the latter only showing up during Annihilation Tournaments, thus keeping it's existence secret somewhere in the realm of the plausible if distantly. However Purgatory that has a much greater attendance rate with huge stadiums just for regular matches somehow has kept it's existenc existence secret as well?

Removed: 1062

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Already got my answers elsewhere.


** Did they ever come out and say it was secret? The rules are pretty mainstream when you look at them and are even safer than the Kengan matches. Pretty much the only thing separating Purgatory and real life MMA is the gloves. There doesn't seem to be a reason for it to be secret.
* Why is the Kengan Association and The Purgatory in conflict with each other? They're both underground fighting rings, but otherwise they exist for completely different purposes: the Kengan Association is an arena where merchants/businessmen settle trade disputes, and the fighting matches are just the mean to achieve that end. The Purgatory, on the other hand, is more of a straightforward fighting ring--not unlike a regular MMA competition. Any relationship between Kengan and Purgatory would be LESS like two rivaling sports team vying over a limited pool of talented fighters, but more akin to two independent film productions that just happen to feature fighting. Other than scheduling conflicts and health/safety issues, there should be no reason why a fighter can't work for both sides--especially since a lot of the associated fighters are also actively involved in public sports competitions, so it's not like there's a strict regulation that forbids a fighter from "two-timing", so to speak. I'm not clear on how a merger would benefit either party.

to:

** Did they ever come out and say it was secret? The rules are pretty mainstream when you look at them and are even safer than the Kengan matches. Pretty much the only thing separating Purgatory and real life MMA is the gloves. There doesn't seem to be a reason for it to be secret.
* Why is the Kengan Association and The Purgatory in conflict with each other? They're both underground fighting rings, but otherwise they exist for completely different purposes: the Kengan Association is an arena where merchants/businessmen settle trade disputes, and the fighting matches are just the mean to achieve that end. The Purgatory, on the other hand, is more of a straightforward fighting ring--not unlike a regular MMA competition. Any relationship between Kengan and Purgatory would be LESS like two rivaling sports team vying over a limited pool of talented fighters, but more akin to two independent film productions that just happen to feature fighting. Other than scheduling conflicts and health/safety issues, there should be no reason why a fighter can't work for both sides--especially since a lot of the associated fighters are also actively involved in public sports competitions, so it's not like there's a strict regulation that forbids a fighter from "two-timing", so to speak. I'm not clear on how a merger would benefit either party.
secret.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is the Kengan Association and The Purgatory in conflict with each other? They're both underground fighting rings, but otherwise they exist for completely different purposes: the Kengan Association is an arena where merchants/businessmen settle trade disputes, and the fighting matches are just the mean to achieve that end. The Purgatory, on the other hand, is more of a straightforward fighting ring, where the fight itself is both the means and the ends. Any relationship between Kengan and Purgatory would be LESS like two rivaling sports team vying over a limited pool of talented fighters, but more akin to two independent film productions that just happen to feature fighting. Other than scheduling conflicts and health/safety issues, there should be no reason why a fighter can't work for both sides--especially since a lot of the associated fighters are also actively involved in public sports competitions, so it's not like there's a regulation against a fighter "two-timing" so to speak. I'm not clear on how a merger would benefit either party.

to:

* Why is the Kengan Association and The Purgatory in conflict with each other? They're both underground fighting rings, but otherwise they exist for completely different purposes: the Kengan Association is an arena where merchants/businessmen settle trade disputes, and the fighting matches are just the mean to achieve that end. The Purgatory, on the other hand, is more of a straightforward fighting ring, where the fight itself is both the means and the ends.ring--not unlike a regular MMA competition. Any relationship between Kengan and Purgatory would be LESS like two rivaling sports team vying over a limited pool of talented fighters, but more akin to two independent film productions that just happen to feature fighting. Other than scheduling conflicts and health/safety issues, there should be no reason why a fighter can't work for both sides--especially since a lot of the associated fighters are also actively involved in public sports competitions, so it's not like there's a strict regulation against that forbids a fighter "two-timing" from "two-timing", so to speak. I'm not clear on how a merger would benefit either party.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Did they ever come out and say it was secret? The rules are pretty mainstream when you look at them and are even safer than the Kengan matches. Pretty much the only thing separating Purgatory and real life MMA is the gloves. There doesn't seem to be a reason for it to be secret.

to:

** Did they ever come out and say it was secret? The rules are pretty mainstream when you look at them and are even safer than the Kengan matches. Pretty much the only thing separating Purgatory and real life MMA is the gloves. There doesn't seem to be a reason for it to be secret.secret.
* Why is the Kengan Association and The Purgatory in conflict with each other? They're both underground fighting rings, but otherwise they exist for completely different purposes: the Kengan Association is an arena where merchants/businessmen settle trade disputes, and the fighting matches are just the mean to achieve that end. The Purgatory, on the other hand, is more of a straightforward fighting ring, where the fight itself is both the means and the ends. Any relationship between Kengan and Purgatory would be LESS like two rivaling sports team vying over a limited pool of talented fighters, but more akin to two independent film productions that just happen to feature fighting. Other than scheduling conflicts and health/safety issues, there should be no reason why a fighter can't work for both sides--especially since a lot of the associated fighters are also actively involved in public sports competitions, so it's not like there's a regulation against a fighter "two-timing" so to speak. I'm not clear on how a merger would benefit either party.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Kengan Assocation limits attendance to just members and important government and foreign dignitaries with the latter only showing up during Annihilation Tournaments, thus keeping it's existence secret somewhere in the realm of the plausible if distantly. However Purgatory that has a much greater attendance rate with huge stadiums just for regular matches somehow has kept it's existenc secret as well?

to:

* The Kengan Assocation limits attendance to just members and important government and foreign dignitaries with the latter only showing up during Annihilation Tournaments, thus keeping it's existence secret somewhere in the realm of the plausible if distantly. However Purgatory that has a much greater attendance rate with huge stadiums just for regular matches somehow has kept it's existenc secret as well?well?
** Did they ever come out and say it was secret? The rules are pretty mainstream when you look at them and are even safer than the Kengan matches. Pretty much the only thing separating Purgatory and real life MMA is the gloves. There doesn't seem to be a reason for it to be secret.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Nogi called for the tournament to oust Metsudo. Metsudo was defending his position though as above had stated, he did invite some heavy hitters to spice things up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He was not looking for a new head of the Kengan Association, he was bored of no one challenging his position, and wanted to have his fighter pushed to the limit like he did when he fought to be the head of the Association. He invited veterans of the Association and respected fighters outside to watch exciting matches, but expressly stated that did not expect his fighter to lose.

to:

** He was not looking for a new head of the Kengan Association, he was bored of no one challenging his position, and wanted to have his fighter pushed to the limit like he did when he fought to be the head of the Association. He invited veterans of the Association and respected fighters outside to watch exciting matches, but expressly stated that did not expect his fighter to lose.lose.
* The Kengan Assocation limits attendance to just members and important government and foreign dignitaries with the latter only showing up during Annihilation Tournaments, thus keeping it's existence secret somewhere in the realm of the plausible if distantly. However Purgatory that has a much greater attendance rate with huge stadiums just for regular matches somehow has kept it's existenc secret as well?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So if Metsudo is looking for a new head of the Kengan Association to replace him why is he then participating in the tournament?

to:

* So if Metsudo is looking for a new head of the Kengan Association to replace him why is he then participating in the tournament?tournament?
** He was not looking for a new head of the Kengan Association, he was bored of no one challenging his position, and wanted to have his fighter pushed to the limit like he did when he fought to be the head of the Association. He invited veterans of the Association and respected fighters outside to watch exciting matches, but expressly stated that did not expect his fighter to lose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*So if Metsudo is looking for a new head of the Kengan Association to replace him why is he then participating in the tournament?

Top