Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / StarTrekVoyager

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling


* Speaking of the afterlife, "Coda" offers up not only some NightmareFuel, but the dreadful and (we know from seeing certain other ''Star Trek'' series' episodes about the afterlife) entirely credible possibility that Hell and its demons are real and on the prowl for prey in the ''Star Trek'' universe. We're not just talking about SufficientlyAdvancedAliens like the Q Continuum and possibly the Prophets and their Pah-Wraith counterparts in ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'', but spiritual predators in an actual afterlife. This is actually acknowledged somewhat near the end of the episode when Janeway tells Chakotay she sure ''hopes'' the imposter posing as her deceased father was just another local alien from the Delta Quadrant, but she can't really be sure in view of the near death experiences some have reported back home in the Alpha Quadrant.

to:

* Speaking of the afterlife, "Coda" offers up not only some NightmareFuel, but the dreadful and (we know from seeing certain other ''Star Trek'' series' episodes about the afterlife) entirely credible possibility that Hell and its demons are real and on the prowl for prey in the ''Star Trek'' universe. We're not just talking about SufficientlyAdvancedAliens like the Q Continuum and possibly the Prophets and their Pah-Wraith Pah-wraith counterparts in ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'', but spiritual predators in an actual afterlife. This is actually acknowledged somewhat near the end of the episode when Janeway tells Chakotay she sure ''hopes'' the imposter posing as her deceased father was just another local alien from the Delta Quadrant, but she can't really be sure in view of the near death experiences some have reported back home in the Alpha Quadrant.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Remember when Tom and Harry discussed how thin the walls are, because ''Voyager'' really wasn't designed for long-term missions? If Harry's clarinet practice makes his neighbour knock on the wall, imagine what Tom and B'Elanna's poor neighbours go through.
** The subsequent trip to Sickbay with broken bones probably gives the game away as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Assuming Chakotay is from Dorvan V, the planet colonized by Native Americans in "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E19JourneysEnd Journey's End]]," the very episode that introduced the Cardassian conflict that gave rise to the Maquis (he is never ''explicitly'' said to be from there, but it's a very reasonable assumption), it actually makes perfect sense that he would have been raised in an amalgam of the beliefs of the various colonists and their descendents, probably with a lot of newer philosophies thrown into the mix, and that he would be of mixed ancestry, so he would not identify with any single tribe specifically.

to:

** Assuming Chakotay is from Dorvan V, the planet colonized by Native Americans in "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E19JourneysEnd Journey's End]]," the very episode that introduced the Cardassian conflict that gave rise to the Maquis (he is never ''explicitly'' said to be from there, but it's a very reasonable assumption), it actually makes perfect sense that he would be of mixed ancestry, and that he would have been raised in an amalgam of the beliefs of the various colonists and their descendents, probably with a lot of newer philosophies thrown into the mix, and that he would be of mixed ancestry, so he would not identify with any single tribe specifically.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Assuming Chakotay is from Dorvan V, the planet colonized by Native Americans in "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E19JourneysEnd Journey's End]]," the very episode that introduced the Cardassian conflict that gave rise to the Maquis (he is never ''explicitly'' said to be from there, but it's a very reasonable assumption), it actually makes perfect sense that he would have been raised in an amalgam of the beliefs of the various colonists and their descendents, probably with a lot of newer philosophies thrown into the mix, and that he would not identify with any single tribe specifically.

to:

** Assuming Chakotay is from Dorvan V, the planet colonized by Native Americans in "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E19JourneysEnd Journey's End]]," the very episode that introduced the Cardassian conflict that gave rise to the Maquis (he is never ''explicitly'' said to be from there, but it's a very reasonable assumption), it actually makes perfect sense that he would have been raised in an amalgam of the beliefs of the various colonists and their descendents, probably with a lot of newer philosophies thrown into the mix, and that he would be of mixed ancestry, so he would not identify with any single tribe specifically.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Assuming Chakotay is from Dorvan V, the planet colonized by Native Americans in "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E19JourneysEnd Journey's End]]," the very episode that introduced the Maquis (he is never ''explicitly'' said to be from there, but it's a very reasonable assumption), it actually makes perfect sense that he would have been raised in an amalgam of the beliefs of the various colonists and their descendents, probably with a lot of newer philosophies thrown into the mix, and that he would not identify with any single tribe specifically.

to:

** Assuming Chakotay is from Dorvan V, the planet colonized by Native Americans in "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E19JourneysEnd Journey's End]]," the very episode that introduced the Cardassian conflict that gave rise to the Maquis (he is never ''explicitly'' said to be from there, but it's a very reasonable assumption), it actually makes perfect sense that he would have been raised in an amalgam of the beliefs of the various colonists and their descendents, probably with a lot of newer philosophies thrown into the mix, and that he would not identify with any single tribe specifically.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Assuming Chakotay is from Dorvan V, the planet colonized by Native Americans in ''[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E19JourneysEnd Journey's End]],'' the very episode that introduced the Maquis (he is never ''explicitly'' said to be from there, but it's a very reasonable assumption), it actually makes perfect sense that he would have been raised in an amalgam of the beliefs of the various colonists and their descendents, probably with a lot of newer philosophies thrown into the mix, and that he would not identify with any single tribe specifically.

to:

** Assuming Chakotay is from Dorvan V, the planet colonized by Native Americans in ''[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E19JourneysEnd "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E19JourneysEnd Journey's End]],'' End]]," the very episode that introduced the Maquis (he is never ''explicitly'' said to be from there, but it's a very reasonable assumption), it actually makes perfect sense that he would have been raised in an amalgam of the beliefs of the various colonists and their descendents, probably with a lot of newer philosophies thrown into the mix, and that he would not identify with any single tribe specifically.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, a holographic crew member can go places where flesh-and-blood crew members can't go. Need to defuse a bomb that is radiating deadly energy? Need a decoy to draw off some alien intruders? Etc etc. There are literally hundreds of reasons why having the ability to create holographic crew members and objects would be useful.

to:

** Also, a holographic crew member can go places where flesh-and-blood crew members can't go. Need to defuse a bomb that is radiating deadly energy? Need a decoy to draw off some alien intruders? Etc etc. There are literally hundreds of reasons why having the ability to create holographic crew members and objects (and objects) would be useful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, a holographic crew member can go places where flesh-and-blood crew members can't go. Need to defuse a bomb that is radiating deadly energy? Need a decoy to draw off some alien intruders? Etc etc. There are literally hundreds of reasons why having the ability to create holographic crew members would be useful.

to:

** Also, a holographic crew member can go places where flesh-and-blood crew members can't go. Need to defuse a bomb that is radiating deadly energy? Need a decoy to draw off some alien intruders? Etc etc. There are literally hundreds of reasons why having the ability to create holographic crew members and objects would be useful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Assuming Chakotay is from Dorvan V, the planet colonized by Native Americans in ''[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E19JourneysEnd Journey's End]],'' the very episode that introduced the Maquis (he is never ''explicitly'' said to be from there, but it's a very reasonable assumption), it actually makes perfect sense that he would have been raised in an amalgam of the beliefs of the various colonists and their descendents, probably with a lot of newer philosophies thrown into the mix, and that he would not identify with any single tribe specifically.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Another possibility that people fail to take into account is that Harry may have a good reason to go after other women while he has a girl back home. Though everyone on board Voyager is hopeful to get home within their lifetime, there is a good chance that they may not. Think about it: they deal with external threats on a regular basis. The crew compliment of Voyager started with 153 (and that's when she launched from DS9, before she was pulled to the other side of the galaxy). There were a lot of situations where a lot of lives were lost due to one situation or another, and the likelihood that each day could literally be your last. And even on good days, the thought of never getting home would constantly be on your mind. Harry may have been in love with Libby, but the fact is that he more than likely knew that there was a chance he wasn't ever going to make it back home alive. And then we have the opposite side of the story, those who are back home. Voyager was reported as lost with all hands aboard. People who were in relationships may have grieved and then moved on. A great example of this was Janeway's boyfriend, Mark Johnson. Originally, he held out hope that Janeway was still alive for a while before he finally came to accept she was dead and moved on, starting another relationship with a woman he knew (Janeway herself stated it was the logical thing because of the fact that even though now the Federation knows they're alive, there's a good chance that they'd still be killed or die of old age long before even reaching the Alpha Quadrant). What are the chances that Libby would be holding out in the same regard and waiting for Harry? Harry himself may have had in his mind that she probably thought he was dead and may have moved on even before they finally got in contact with the Federation (and even after that, there was still no guarantee they'd make it back alive). Basically, the entire crew aren't just trying to get home, but they're trying to enjoy what life they have left while being in the Delta Quadrant.

to:

** Another possibility that people fail to take into account is that Harry may have a good reason to go after other women while he has a girl back home. Though everyone on board Voyager is hopeful to get home within their lifetime, there is a good chance that they may not. Think about it: they deal with external threats on a regular basis. The crew compliment of Voyager started with 153 (and that's when she launched from DS9, [=DS9=], before she was pulled to the other side of the galaxy). There were a lot of situations where a lot of lives were lost due to one situation or another, and the likelihood that each day could literally be your last. And even on good days, the thought of never getting home would constantly be on your mind. Harry may have been in love with Libby, but the fact is that he more than likely knew that there was a chance he wasn't ever going to make it back home alive. And then we have the opposite side of the story, those who are back home. Voyager was reported as lost with all hands aboard. People who were in relationships may have grieved and then moved on. A great example of this was Janeway's boyfriend, Mark Johnson. Originally, he held out hope that Janeway was still alive for a while before he finally came to accept she was dead and moved on, starting another relationship with a woman he knew (Janeway herself stated it was the logical thing because of the fact that even though now the Federation knows they're alive, there's a good chance that they'd still be killed or die of old age long before even reaching the Alpha Quadrant). What are the chances that Libby would be holding out in the same regard and waiting for Harry? Harry himself may have had in his mind that she probably thought he was dead and may have moved on even before they finally got in contact with the Federation (and even after that, there was still no guarantee they'd make it back alive). Basically, the entire crew aren't just trying to get home, but they're trying to enjoy what life they have left while being in the Delta Quadrant.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In "Unity," Chakotay's injuries ''just happen'' to be of a type that can only be treated in a way that leaves him vulnerable to full-on possession later. There's also no possibility of waiting until Voyager arrives with other options; it has to be done NOW! As soon as he comes around from the procedure, Riley is right there to... distract him from any critical thinking and get him on her side using the most tried-and-tested method in existence. In short: Chakotay was being manipulated from the moment he opened his eyes. His injuries were never as bad as he was informed, his symptoms might even have been drug-induced. Riley asking for Janeway's help with the "second collective" plan was just a smokescreen to get the crew to drop their guard. The plan was always to force Chakotay to do what they wanted.

Added: 686

Removed: 670

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Wrong section


* A disproportionate number of Maquis seem to work in Engineering. (B'Elanna, Seska, Bendera, Hogan, Jonas, Tabor, Jor...) One might expect them to dominate Security, as soldiers. But before forming the Maquis, most of these people were colonists, literally ''building'' their societies from the ground up. If anything, it's ironic that the Val Jean's two best Engineers, B'Elanna and Seska, weren't from those colonies. (Though starship engineering is a bit different than land-stations.)
** Many if not most of the Maquis were also farmers, making for a good crew to mind Airponics even after Kes leaves. (It's a bit odd that none of them thought of an onboard garden before Kes did.)



* A disproportionate number of Maquis seem to work in Engineering. (B'Elanna, Hogan, Jonas, Tabor, Jor...) One might expect them to dominate Security, as soldiers. But before forming the Maquis, most of these people were colonists, literally ''building'' their societies from the ground up. If anything, it's ironic that the Val Jean's two best Engineers, B'Elanna and Seska, weren't from those colonies. (Though starship engineering is a bit different than land-stations.)
** Many if not most of the Maquis were also farmers, making for a good crew to mind Airponics even after Kes leaves. (It's a bit odd that none of them thought of an onboard garden before Kes did.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** EU and official material after suggests that this did happen -- the final episode more or less says this was the case given that Tom, B'Elanna and others had Starfleet careers after their initial return. Considering how popular Voyager was after it was discovered they were still alive, and the fact Starleet even forwarded on messages to the Maquis, it may have been a bad PR move to jail any of them even with their earlier return. Plus the fact they dealt a very crippling blow to the Borg upon their return, AND the fact this was after the Dominion War -- no doubt there was a lot of "hindsight is 20-20" regarding the Maquis after that. Especially since some of those EU sources say that the surviving Maquis in the Alpha Quadrant joined the war against the Dominion in exchange for a full pardon, and when ''Voyager'' returned home, that same pardon was extended to Chakotay and the other Maquis aboard.

to:

** EU and official material after suggests that this did happen -- the final episode more or less says this was the case given that Tom, B'Elanna and others had Starfleet careers after their initial return. Considering how popular Voyager was after it was discovered they were still alive, and the fact Starleet even forwarded on messages to the Maquis, it may have been a bad PR move to jail any of them even with their earlier return. Plus the fact they dealt a very crippling blow to the Borg upon their return, AND the fact this was after the Dominion War -- no doubt there was a lot of "hindsight is 20-20" regarding the Maquis after that. Especially since some of those EU sources say that the surviving Maquis in the Alpha Quadrant joined the war against the Dominion in exchange for a full pardon, and when ''Voyager'' returned home, that same pardon was extended to Chakotay and the other Maquis aboard. This gets confirmed in [=NuTrek=] canon: Captain Chakotay is given command of USS ''Protostar'', B'Elanna helps Vice-Admiral Janeway design a Starfleet version of USS ''Dauntless'' (Arturis' fake Starfleet ship), and Tom Paris goes on a celebrity tour that includes USS ''Cerritos''.



** Thankfully, the Picard series answers this question a few decades later, but its so grim that it might as well have not mattered.

to:

** Thankfully, the Picard series season 3 of ''Series/StarTrekPicard'' answers this question a few decades later, but its it turns out to be so grim that it might as well have not mattered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added detail to Ro's blurb

Added DiffLines:

** Thankfully, the Picard series answers this question a few decades later, but its so grim that it might as well have not mattered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another "Equinox" one -- some viewers have called it a plot hole or assumed Janeway was lying when she claimed not to have violated the Prime Directive, considering it had been violated in "Thirty Days". However, it was not she who violated it then, it was Paris, and he was disobeying Janeway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In "Once Upon a Time", Neelix's reason he gives for not telling Naomi that Samantha is in danger (besides the fact that he doesn't want her to experience what he did) is that she's "sensitive". Yet in the episode, Naomi doesn't seem sensitive at all, and if anything, ''Neelix'' is the one acting sensitive. This could just be PsychologicalProjection, but it might also be because back in "Mortal Coil", Naomi really ''did'' seem sensitive -- she was an insomniac and worried about [[ThingsThatGoBumpInTheNight monsters in her room]]. Perhaps Neelix simply didn't realise that Naomi had outgrown her sensitive phase.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And to keep it going beyond the named cast members, the whole galaxy would end up being overrun by Species 8472.

to:

** And to keep it going beyond the named cast members, the whole galaxy would end up being overrun by Species 8472. Well, assuming literally nobody else in the galaxy has the resources of a holographic doctor and one ship to create the super-nanoprobes....
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Consider for a moment that Deanna Troi is an empath with a range than covered the entire ''Enterprise.'' Every single time someone got aroused by her on that ship, ''she knew.'' And given Reg Barclay's history of making out with duplicates of her on the holodeck, one has to wonder exactly what creepy empathic vibes she was still getting off him if her first instinct in ''Inside Man'' when he walked up to her on the beach was to immediately cover up. The only other time on-screen we ever see her do anything remotely similar was when a Ferengi kidnapped her and literally beamed the clothes off her back. Yes, she does have a point about professionalism, but this is also a woman who went to work wearing a tight catsuit for six years and comes from a planet of matriarchal telepaths who hold nude weddings so she is hardly screamish about revealing her body in public either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[foldercontrol]]

to:

[[foldercontrol]]
[[/folder]]

Added: 45

Changed: 46

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:FridgeBrilliance]]

to:

[[AC:FridgeBrilliance]][[foldercontrol]]

[[folder: FridgeBrilliance]]





[[AC:FridgeHorror]]

to:

\n\n[[AC:FridgeHorror]][[/folder]]

[[folder: FridgeHorror]]


Added DiffLines:

[[foldercontrol]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the season 7 episode, "Critical Care". The head surgeon claims that Tebbis died when his medicine his previously healing infection rather suddenly "relapsed", and he was denied more medication. However, it seems oddly suspicious considering just the day before that Tebbis was recovering rather nicely. Which may indicate the boy as actually killed instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A disproportionate number of Maquis seem to work in Engineering. (B'Elanna, Hogan, Jonas, Tabor, Jor...) One might expect them to dominate Security, as soldiers. But before forming the Maquis, most of these people were colonists, literally ''building'' their societies from the ground up. If anything, it's ironic that the Val Jean's two best Engineers, B'Elanna and Seska, weren't from those colonies. (Though starship engineering is a bit different than land-stations.)
** Many if not most of the Maquis were also farmers, making for a good crew to mind Airponics even after Kes leaves. (It's a bit odd that none of them thought of an onboard garden before Kes did.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n* In "Threshold", the first time Paris makes his transwarp flight, passsing through every point in the universe simultaneously, his shuttle appears back where it started from; the second time, after he starts turning into a salamander and abducts Janeway, it shows up at a nearby uninhabited planet (it takes three days of searching to find them). This actually makes more sense if you assume that, rather than just appearing at some random location, the shuttle was actually guided to a specific point by Paris' own will. After all, TNG's "Where No One Has Gone Before" previously established that people's thoughts start to affect reality at transwarp speeds. The first time, Paris came straight back to ''Voyager'' because he wanted to come straight back and report to the crew. The second time, his instincts wanted to travel to a planet where his and Janeway's tadpoles would be safe, but at the same time, the part of him that was still Tom Paris wanted to end up close enough for the crew to find them. So, naturally, he went straight to the nearest planet that was suitable for them.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling


** Caveat-- It might not be the same class ship. After all, Starfleet is notorious for reusing perfectly good ship-names as class-names, and also for having multiple ships of the same name. For example: The Consititution-class USS "Defiant" (NCC-1764) in ENT's "In a Mirror, Darkly" (Season 4 Episode 19). And later the "Defiant-class" USS "Defiant" (NX-74205), and Defiant-class USS Defiant (formerly the USS Sao-Paulo) (NCC-75633). And let's not even get into how many ships of the name "Enterprise" or "Endeavour" there are.. However, the timing lines up. The competition was mentioned in the seventh season of TNG, and Voyager's mission began less than a year later.

to:

** Caveat-- It might not be the same class ship. After all, Starfleet is notorious for reusing perfectly good ship-names as class-names, and also for having multiple ships of the same name. For example: The Consititution-class Constitution-class USS "Defiant" (NCC-1764) in ENT's "In a Mirror, Darkly" (Season 4 Episode 19). And later the "Defiant-class" USS "Defiant" (NX-74205), and Defiant-class USS Defiant (formerly the USS Sao-Paulo) (NCC-75633). And let's not even get into how many ships of the name "Enterprise" or "Endeavour" there are.. However, the timing lines up. The competition was mentioned in the seventh season of TNG, and Voyager's mission began less than a year later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In "Author, Author", there are no analogues to Neelix, Naomi, or Icheb in the ''Photons be Free'' holonovel. Perhaps this is because he feels like they'd be unfit for such a dark story, since Neelix is so cheerful (true, he could just rewrite Neelix's personality but then he'd have to essentially make him a personality from whole cloth) and Naomi and Icheb are minors.

to:

* In "Author, Author", there are no analogues to Neelix, Naomi, or Icheb in the ''Photons be Free'' holonovel. Perhaps this is because he feels like they'd be unfit for such a dark story, since Neelix is so cheerful (true, he could just rewrite Neelix's personality but then he'd have to essentially make him a personality from whole cloth) and Naomi and Icheb are minors. That would also explain why Neelix was the only one who didn't get angry over the program -- he didn't have to face his evil counterpart.

Top