Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / Revolution

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Dan and the dwellers trashed the elevators' controls as well as making sure the elevators could not reach level 12, even if repaired from above. If there were stairs top to bottom, the dwellers could have sealed them off after trashing the elevator controls as they barricaded themselves in the lower levels. Randall had not been back to The Tower since he left to ally with Monroe and left Grace in charge of repairing the elevators; he only left a mook there to supervise her. It's likely that Randall knew about the stairs the whole time, but there was no way to go lower than the entry level without a functional elevator which was still not working the last time he was there. He is banking on Grace having fixed the elevators by the time he and Monroe get there since that is the only way he can keep Monroe from killing him. He seems genuinely surprised that the elevator stops at 11 (due to it being sabotaged by the dwellers). The dwellers seem to be situated between levels 7 and 11 and dispatch anyone attempting to reach level 12. Plot hole closed?

to:

*** Dan and the dwellers trashed the elevators' controls as well as making sure the elevators could not reach level 12, even if repaired from above. If there were stairs top to bottom, the dwellers could have sealed them off after trashing the elevator controls as they barricaded themselves in the lower levels. Randall had not been back to The Tower since he left to ally with Monroe and left Grace in charge of repairing the elevators; he only left a mook there to supervise her. It's likely that Randall knew about the stairs the whole time, but there was no way to go lower than the entry level without a functional elevator which was still not working the last time he was there. He is was banking on Grace having fixed the elevators by the time he and Monroe get got there since that is was the only way he can could keep Monroe from killing him. He seems seemed genuinely surprised that the elevator stops stopped at 11 (due to it being sabotaged by the dwellers). The dwellers seem to be situated between levels 7 and 11 and dispatch anyone attempting to reach level 12. Plot hole closed?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Dan and the dwellers trashed the elevators' controls as well as making sure the elevators could not reach level 12, even if repaired from above. Randall had not been back to The Tower since he left to ally with Monroe and left Grace in charge of repairing the elevators; he only left a mook there to supervise her. It's likely that Randall knew about the stairs from level 11 to 12 the whole time, but there was no way to go lower than the entry level without a functional elevator which was still not working the last time he was there. Or, if there were stairs from top to bottom, the dwellers could have sealed them off after trashing the elevator controls before barricading themselves in the lower levels. He is banking on Grace having fixed the elevators by the time he and Monroe get there since that is the only way he can keep Monroe from killing him. He seems genuinely surprised that the elevator only goes down to 11 (due to it being sabotaged by the dwellers). The dwellers seem to be situated between levels 7 and 11 and dispatch anyone attempting to reach level 12. Plot hole closed?

to:

*** Dan ***Dan and the dwellers trashed the elevators' controls as well as making sure the elevators could not reach level 12, even if repaired from above.above. If there were stairs top to bottom, the dwellers could have sealed them off after trashing the elevator controls as they barricaded themselves in the lower levels. Randall had not been back to The Tower since he left to ally with Monroe and left Grace in charge of repairing the elevators; he only left a mook there to supervise her. It's likely that Randall knew about the stairs from level 11 to 12 the whole time, but there was no way to go lower than the entry level without a functional elevator which was still not working the last time he was there. Or, if there were stairs from top to bottom, the dwellers could have sealed them off after trashing the elevator controls before barricading themselves in the lower levels.there. He is banking on Grace having fixed the elevators by the time he and Monroe get there since that is the only way he can keep Monroe from killing him. He seems genuinely surprised that the elevator only goes down to stops at 11 (due to it being sabotaged by the dwellers). The dwellers seem to be situated between levels 7 and 11 and dispatch anyone attempting to reach level 12. Plot hole closed?

Changed: 1102

Removed: 886

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



*** Dan and the dwellers trashed the elevators' controls as well as making sure the elevators could not reach level 12, even if repaired from above. Randall had not been back to The Tower since he left to ally with Monroe and left Grace in charge of repairing the elevators; he only left a mook there to supervise her. It's likely that Randall knew about the stairs from level 11 to level 12, but there was no way to go lower than the entry level without a functional elevator which was still not working the last time he was there. He is banking on Grace having fixed it by the time he and Monroe get there since that is the only way he can keep Monroe from killing him. He seems genuinely surprised that it only goes down to 11 (due to the elevator being sabotaged by the dwellers). The dwellers are situated on level 11 and dispatch anyone trying to reach level 12. Plot hole closed?

to:

\n*** Dan and the dwellers trashed the elevators' controls as well as making sure the elevators could not reach level 12, even if repaired from above. Randall had not been back to The Tower since he left to ally with Monroe and left Grace in charge of repairing the elevators; he only left a mook there to supervise her. It's likely that Randall knew about the stairs from level 11 to level 12, 12 the whole time, but there was no way to go lower than the entry level without a functional elevator which was still not working the last time he was there. Or, if there were stairs from top to bottom, the dwellers could have sealed them off after trashing the elevator controls before barricading themselves in the lower levels. He is banking on Grace having fixed it the elevators by the time he and Monroe get there since that is the only way he can keep Monroe from killing him. He seems genuinely surprised that it the elevator only goes down to 11 (due to the elevator it being sabotaged by the dwellers). The dwellers are seem to be situated on level between levels 7 and 11 and dispatch anyone trying attempting to reach level 12. Plot hole closed? closed?

Added: 886

Changed: 552

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Dan and the dwellers trashed the elevators' controls, and Randall had not been back to The Tower since he left Grace in charge of repairing the elevator. He left a mook there to supervise her. It's very likely that Randall knew about the stairs from level 11 to level 12, but there was no way to go lower than the entry level without a functional elevator. In the episode where he and Monroe get to the Tower, he comments that Grace was able to get it working after all and seems genuinely surprised that it only goes down to 11. Plot hole closed?

to:


*** Dan and the dwellers trashed the elevators' controls, and controls as well as making sure the elevators could not reach level 12, even if repaired from above. Randall had not been back to The Tower since he left to ally with Monroe and left Grace in charge of repairing the elevator. He elevators; he only left a mook there to supervise her. It's very likely that Randall knew about the stairs from level 11 to level 12, but there was no way to go lower than the entry level without a functional elevator. In elevator which was still not working the episode where last time he was there. He is banking on Grace having fixed it by the time he and Monroe get to the Tower, he comments there since that Grace was able to get it working after all and is the only way he can keep Monroe from killing him. He seems genuinely surprised that it only goes down to 11.11 (due to the elevator being sabotaged by the dwellers). The dwellers are situated on level 11 and dispatch anyone trying to reach level 12. Plot hole closed?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***Dan and the dwellers trashed the elevators' controls, and Randall had not been back to The Tower since he left Grace in charge of repairing the elevator. He left a mook there to supervise her. It's very likely that Randall knew about the stairs from level 11 to level 12, but there was no way to go lower than the entry level without a functional elevator. In the episode where he and Monroe get to the Tower, he comments that Grace was able to get it working after all and seems genuinely surprised that it only goes down to 11. Plot hole closed?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***** [[spoiler: another possibility is that Miles ''himself'' was Foster's lover or husband, and betrayed her (not to mention ''his own brother'') by hooking up with Rachel prior to the blackout.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Corollary: And even those who were smart about it probably gave off radiofrequency emissions Randall's satellites could detect, because any source of radio waves in the post-Blackout world needs must consume electricity to do so. Computers are fantastic RF transmitters and receivers, especially those old-fashioned CRT monitors Grace ''et al'' were using.

to:

** Corollary: And even those who were smart about it probably gave off radiofrequency emissions Randall's satellites could detect, because any source of coherent[[note]]This is distinct from blackbody radiation, which would be broad-spectrum and clearly not of artificial origin[[/note]] radio waves in the post-Blackout world needs must consume electricity to do so. Computers are fantastic RF transmitters and receivers, especially those old-fashioned CRT monitors Grace ''et al'' were using.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Corollary: And even those who were smart about it probably gave off radiofrequency emissions Randall's satellites could detect, because any source of radio waves in the post-Blackout world needs must consume electricity to do so. Computers are fantastic RF transmitters and receivers, especially those old-fashioned CRT monitors Grace ''et al'' were using.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And the fact that lightning strikes rapidly happen with greater frequency [[spoiler:when the nanites are stopped]] would seem to back this up regarding their ability to partially, but not perfectly, suppress static electricity phenomena like lightning.

to:

** And the fact that lightning strikes rapidly happen with greater frequency [[spoiler:when the nanites are stopped]] would seem to back this up regarding their ability to partially, but not perfectly, suppress static electricity transient phenomena like lightning.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: Season 2 shows Rachel treat an Atlanta survivor. The guy was on the very fringe of the danger zone and had some of his clothing melt into his skin, causing nasty burn wounds. The guy considers himself to be one of the lucky ones. Let's not forget the massive increase in cancer rates for decades to come.]]

Changed: 253

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:Philadelphia and Atlanta were nuked by ICBMs, with the power going back off shortly afterward. Consider the plight of any survivors who are faced with the results of a nuclear explosion without the benefit of modern medicine or infrastructure. The survivors of Hiroshima and Nagasaki were hit with much smaller weapons and at least had 1940's medical care (when it finally arrived) available. The survivors of Philadelphia and Atlanta won't even have it ''that'' good...]]

to:

* [[spoiler:Philadelphia and Atlanta were nuked by ICBMs, [=ICBMs=], with the power going back off shortly afterward. Consider the plight of any survivors who are faced with the results of a nuclear explosion without the benefit of modern medicine or infrastructure. The survivors of Hiroshima and Nagasaki were hit with much smaller weapons and at least had 1940's medical care (when it finally arrived) available. The available for the survivors. Given the damage to infrastructure that took place during the blackout and afterward, the loss of medical personnel in the intervening years, and the inability to move what resources there are to the blast area, the survivors of Philadelphia and Atlanta won't even have it ''that'' good...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[spoiler:Philadelphia and Atlanta were nuked by ICBMs, with the power going back off shortly afterward. Consider the plight of any survivors who are faced with the results of a nuclear explosion without the benefit of modern medicine or infrastructure. The survivors of Hiroshima and Nagasaki were hit with much smaller weapons and at least had 1940's medical care (when it finally arrived) available. The survivors of Philadelphia and Atlanta won't even have it ''that'' good...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
By now it\'s really kind of not a spoiler.


* Charlie [[spoiler:having been forcibly branded with the Monroe militia insignia]] could be an excellent spy. One wonders if the writers will somehow use this in future episodes.

to:

* Charlie [[spoiler:having having been forcibly branded with the Monroe militia insignia]] insignia could be an excellent spy. One wonders if the writers will somehow use this in future episodes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "Born in the USA" shows that at least for some people, it gives her a point of connection to them, such as the bartender she sleeps with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The Monroe militia are at first only seen using muzzle loaded muskets, which really doesn't make any sense. Sure musket balls and muskets are easy to mass produce. However, repeating rifles such as the [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spencer_repeating_rifle Spencer repeating rifle]] were mass produced during the civil war and we even see a couple of riles that look like those in the second half of season one. Even breach loading and rifling are easily included upgrades over muzzle loading muskets. However, when we learn that the militia are made up of mostly conscripts the brilliance begins. Since they are conscripts they can't be trusted to not turn on the government that made them. So arming them with weapons just effective enough to do the job of policing the internal affairs of the republic makes more sense then arming them with high end weaponry. Also, in a real war if they are called to the front they are most likely just cannon fodder compared to the soldiers trained before the blackout anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Well, this troper doesn't know how the US military builds secure installations, but it would make sense to have limited access points inside. Also, what is to say that the different between level one and level two is not fifty or so stories? Then the rest of the 11 floors could be spaced normally, including the stairs. This makes more sense then having the Tower be only 12 stories underground. It is supposed to be more secure then NORAD after all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** [[spoiler: Actually although nuking Atalanta and Philadelphia WAS mass murder, it is quite possible that doing so saves many more lives in the long run. Think about the real world American Civil war, only with fighter jets and cruise missiles in a at least five way fight. Now change out Lincoln and Davis for Hitler and Osama Bin Laden. That war would make World War II look like little more than bar brawl.]]

to:

*** [[spoiler: Actually although nuking Atalanta and Philadelphia WAS mass murder, it is quite possible that doing so saves many more lives in the long run. Think about the real world American Civil war, only with fighter jets and cruise missiles in a at least five way fight. Now change out Lincoln and Davis for Hitler and Osama Bin Laden. That war would make World War II look like little more than a bar brawl.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler: Actually although nuking Atalanta and Philadelphia WAS mass murder, it is quite possible that doing so saves many more lives in the long run. Think about the real world American Civil war, only with fighter jets and cruise missiles in a at least five way fight. Now change out Lincoln and Davis for Hitler and Osama Bin Laden. That war would make World War II look like little more than bar brawl.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***** [[spoiler: far more likely was that the previous President of Georgia was Foster's husband, whom Miles may have either personally assassinated or ordered assassinated.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Also, it should be considered that Nora's tattoo has a much smaller number of stars than the normal US Flag, but just about as many as you would expect to see representing the States that used to exist within the area now covered by the Monroe Republic. Maybe the rebels had no illusions about restoring all 50 states, at least not right away, so they only include the States they would bring back by dethroning Monroe. Also the difference would allow them to tell the difference between tattoos from before the blackout to ones marking their comrades.

to:

**** Also, it should be considered that Nora's tattoo has a much smaller number of stars than the normal US Flag, but just about as many as you would expect to see representing the States that used to exist within the area now covered by the Monroe Republic. Maybe the rebels had no illusions about restoring all 50 states, at least not right away, so they only include included the States they would bring back by dethroning Monroe. Also the difference would allow them to tell the difference between tattoos from before the blackout to ones marking their comrades.Monroe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Also, it should be considered that Nora's tattoo has a much smaller number of stars than the normal US Flag, but just about as many as you would expect to see representing the States that used to exist within the area now covered by the Monroe Republic. Maybe the rebels had no illusions about restoring all 50 states, at least not right away, so they only include the States they would bring back by dethroning Monroe. Also the difference would allow them to tell the difference between tattoos from before the blackout to ones marking their comrades.

Added: 231

Changed: 3

Removed: 231

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moved a Horror to a Brilliance since more appropriate.


* Charlie [[spoiler:having been forcibly branded with the Monroe militia insignia]] could be an excellent spy. One wonders if the writers will somehow use this in future episodes.
** "The Stand" shows her first use of this disguise.



* One would assume the residents of Atlanta would be impressed more than they were but a gas-powered car coming into Atlanta - however they do have steam-powered vehicles - they must have thought it was some new engineering.

to:

* One would assume the residents of Atlanta would be impressed more than they were but by a gas-powered car coming into Atlanta - however they do have steam-powered vehicles - they must have thought it was some new engineering.



* Charlie [[spoiler:having been forcibly branded with the Monroe militia insignia]] could be an excellent spy. One wonders if the writers will somehow use this in future episodes.
** "The Stand" shows her first use of this disguise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Wouldn't anyone have noticed the characteristic smell of the exhaust of a gasoline-powered internal combustion engine? Even assuming the GF uses methane/propane/kerosene-fuelled steam engines, the odor of the fuel-burning process would be different than that from gasoline. But then FridgeBrilliance suggests that Atlanta has rediscovered the problem that bedevilled 19th/early 20th century large cities: excess pollution from "dirty" fuel sources. People may be so used to the smell of unburnt coal and kerosene they don't notice the smell of car exhaust. That said, smell is a ''very'' potent memory aid. (e.g. Some people smell, say, the odor of a chemistry lab and it's like they never left.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* One would assume the residents of Atlanta would be impressed more than they were but a gas-powered car coming into Atlanta - however they do have steam-powered vehicles - they must have thought it was some new engineering.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The mere fact that (at least in some parts) people almost immediate caught on to [[spoiler:the lights coming back on]] may initially seem like a plot hole...until the realization hits that since there's been no power for over 15 years, it wouldn't make any difference if everything was switched on or not.

to:

* The mere fact that (at least in some parts) people almost immediate immediately caught on to [[spoiler:the lights coming back on]] may initially seem like a plot hole...until the realization hits that since there's been no power for over 15 years, it wouldn't make any difference if everything was switched on or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling


* Randall mentions he has access to spy satellites of all kinds. This means that how he deduced the existence of the pendants was to look for suspicious sites of night lighting. One very fundamnetal human tendency is to devise sources of light which last outside of sunlight hours. Non-electrical lighting could only be based on fossil fuels or wood, which, being flame-based, would have a characteristic flicker that electrical lighting cannot mimic very well, especially forms of electrical lighting that purposely create very diffuse, uniform sources of light in a room. In short, the people who had pendants who were insufficiently cautious about using them betrayed themselves to eyes beyond the atmosphere.

to:

* Randall mentions he has access to spy satellites of all kinds. This means that how he deduced the existence of the pendants was to look for suspicious sites of night lighting. One very fundamnetal fundamental human tendency is to devise sources of light which last outside of sunlight hours. Non-electrical lighting could only be based on fossil fuels or wood, which, being flame-based, would have a characteristic flicker that electrical lighting cannot mimic very well, especially forms of electrical lighting that purposely create very diffuse, uniform sources of light in a room. In short, the people who had pendants who were insufficiently cautious about using them betrayed themselves to eyes beyond the atmosphere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Randall mentions he has access to spy satellites of all kinds. This means that how he deduced the existence of the pendants was to look for suspicious sites of night lighting. One very fundamnetal human tendency is to devise sources of light which last outside of sunlight hours. Non-electrical lighting could only be based on fossil fuels or wood, which, being flame-based, would have a characteristic flicker that electrical lighting cannot mimic very well, especially forms of electrical lighting that purposely create very diffuse, uniform sources of light in a room. In short, the people who had pendants who were insufficiently cautious about using them betrayed themselves to eyes beyond the atmosphere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The mere fact that (at least in some parts) people almost immediate caught on to [[spoiler:the lights coming back on]] may initially seem like a plot hole...until the realization hits that since there's been no power for over 15 years, it wouldn't make any difference if everything was switched on or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: The original plan as Randall outlined it makes sense: use Monroe, who is almost universally despised, to break Georgia and extend his dictatorship, then have the remnant United States come in to remove the madman Monroe and re-establish the country everyone knew and loved 15 years earlier. Now there's a major PR mess to overcome (to say the least!) unless the restored US government manages to blame Philadelphia and Atlanta on malfunctioning nukes from Russia or China. One of the launches took place from Texas which may prove significant later on in undoing the new government.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** So the FridgeBrilliance of this is that Randall may have been such a WellIntentionedExtremist the [[spoiler:President will probably have an OhCrap moment as he realizes Randall just made him a mass murderer.]]

Top